E moderation social_media_and_customer_service-may-2013
1. Social media
and customer
service
A massive 80% of companies plan to use social media for
customer service. This white paper examines how customer
service is evolving, and gives practical advice on how to use
social channels to deliver great service to consumers.
Authored by eModeration CEO Tamara Littleton May 2013
www.emoderation.com
2. Social media and customer service
Table of contents
Customers are social............................................................................................................................ 3
Social media customer service: the landscape.................................................................................. 4
Why brands should get to grips with social media customer service............................................. 6
What you can expect from customer queries on social media......................................................... 8
Best practice advice: things to do to deliver great social media customer service..................... 10
Twitter and Facebook rule the customer service airwaves, but for how long?............................ 13
Social customer service is now a differentiator for brands............................................................ 15
About eModeration............................................................................................................................. 16
2
3. Customers are social
Social media is blurring the lines between social media marketing and customer service. Customers
are asking product or service-related questions on social channels that are primarily run by marketing
departments. Social media managers of branded social pages are having to respond to customer
queries which have the potential to reach a global audience.
A global survey by Oracle in Q4 2011 (cited by McInsey Company in its Social Care â Social
Media Meets Customer Care report in December 2012) found that customers expected a response
within 30 minutes on Twitter, and, as a minimum, the same day on Facebook.
That timeframe has reduced significantly in our experience: our best practice recommendation is
that brands have 15 minutes to acknowledge an issue on Twitter, and an hour on Facebook. But
the upside is huge: 71% of customers recommend a brand that gives them a âquick and effectiveâ
response on social media, according to NM Inciteâs 2012 social care study. The result of good
customer service is brand advocacy, the holy grail of social media to marketers.
In this white paper, we have collated some of the best thinking on customer service, and combined it
with our own experience to give you practical advice on how to deliver excellent customer service on
social media.
We look at the impact that social media is having on customer expectations, and what to expect
from customers on social channels. We also recommend which channels to use (and which not to
â or at least, not yet), and give tips on best practice. And there are lots of examples throughout of
companies who are doing it well, plus a few where there is room for improvement.
Great customer service on social media is achievable for every company. It just needs the right
approach and resources to deliver it.
Social media and customer service
3
4. Social media customer service: the landscape
According to a report on Mashable, 80% of companies plan to use social media for customer
service. Research in March 2013 from Simply Measured shows that 30% of the Interbrand top
100 brands already have a dedicated customer service feed on Twitter (99% of these brands
have some sort of presence on Twitter).
This is driven by consumer demand. A Forbes interview with Genesysâ Head of Sales, Tom
Eggemeier, reveals that consumer demand is growing significantly quicker than companiesâ
implementation of social customer care strategies. In the interview, Eggemeier says:
âConsumer behavior is changing much faster than companies are adaptingâŠ
Companies are still seeing social media through the lens of marketing, not as
part of an overall brand execution strategy.â
But there are reports of businesses unable to cope with resourcing social customer service. US
cable firm Charter shut it social media customer care (âUmatter2Charterâ) on Twitter and Facebook
in December, reportedly to focus on traditional channels, saying social media was just too time-
consuming. According to Aberdeen Group, 59% of companies donât yet integrate customer care to
their social media delivery.
There is a serious resource issue here. NM Inciteâs 2012 social care study finds that:
â47% of all social media users have used social care, with usage as high as
59% among 18-24 year olds; usage spans all ages and genders.â
Is Twitter the first or last resort?
There are suggestions in some sectors that Twitter is the only way for consumers to get good
customer service. Research by StellaService analysts tested Twitter against traditional call centres for
flower retailers on Valentineâs Day this year, and found that interactions on Twitter beat phone calls to
customer care teams hands down. Forbesâ Managing Editor of Business News, Dan Bigman, went
so far as to say:
âIf youâre like me and you didnât get the flowers you ordered for your wife on
Valentineâs Day, and then you felt like a complete idiot for wasting a hunk of your
day or so on the phone with no result, thatâs because you are an idiot. If you
want customer service these days, use Twitter. Period.â
Social media and customer service
4
5. LA Fitness, BT and Halifax are all cited in a Guardian article
as examples of firms that use Twitter effectively for customer
service but in all cases Twitter has been used as a last resort
when traditional channels have failed.
Is it the threat of bad publicity that makes Twitter such
an effective way to get a company to take notice? Or is it
that the team on social media channels naturally have the
mindset to respond quickly? Either way, Twitterâs reputation as an effective issues resolution
channel will only increase its use.
Already, social media customer service is becoming âthe new normal.â In the words of Carousel30âs
Greg Kihlström and Kaitlin Carpenter:
âThe new normal is that consumers want to access content, buy products and
receive customer service wherever they are with whatever theyâre holding.â
Social media and customer service
5
6. Why brands should get to grips with social media customer service
Customer service has long been multichannel (or âomnichannelâ for buzzword fans). But those
multiple channels are only now including social media as standard.
Customer service isnât, in our view, an âeither/orâ option. Customers will choose where and how
they talk about you (if youâre not listening on the channels they choose, you have no option to
hear them and resolve issues) and they should be able to choose where and how they talk to
you.
There are some real advantages for brands in tackling this head on:
Talk to customers on their terms. Customers will talk about you on social channels whether you
choose to get involved or not. Brands really have two choices: ignore customers on the channels
theyâre using; or use social channels to monitor and resolve issues quickly. Like it or not, this is the
age of the âempowered buyerâ. Melanie May, writing for B2BMarketing.net, says:
âGiving customers what they want may not be the quickest way to make
money, but this, in the age of the empowered buyer, is increasingly becoming
key to long-term business survival. Yet while customer centricity has become a
popular buzzword, few businesses are currently accomplishing it.â
Improve the customer experience. A report in CRM Buyer talks about the need to ensure that the
customer has the same experience of customer service no matter what channel they use to interact
with you. The âomnichannelâ view of customer service requires real integration of social data with
CRM systems, to improve the customer experience: customers expect to be recognised across
different channels (as far as data privacy allows). And as weâve seen from the examples above,
thereâs still a lot of work to be done to make customer service equally good over any channel.
Improve customer trust. Analysis by Avaya (and a great infographic) states that 43% of consumers
prefer to connect with businesses over the Internet, and 51% of consumers trust a companyâs online
forums more than its website. Unsurprising, perhaps â but it does show the need for a brand to make
sure any issues on those forums or communities are dealt with quickly and effectively.
A customerâs experience is rarely a private experience. We know that customers will use social
channels to shout about both good and bad experiences with a brand. If your review sites, Facebook
pages, Twitter feeds and forums are full of unresolved issues, thatâs not going to help win you new
customers or followers. There are even specialist issues resolution services springing up (Resolver is
an interesting one to watch in this space; it handles customer complaints for free, and sells analysis
to brands on how to improve customer service).
Social media helps reach younger audiences. The number of people interacting with a brand on
social media increases dramatically in 18-25 year olds (Avaya).
Self-service communities can reduce pressure on customer care teams. While weâre focusing
on public social media channels in this paper, it would be remiss not to mention self-service or
Social media and customer service
6
7. dedicated social care communities. ASOS, which has an
amazing reputation for customer service on social media, uses
Get Satisfaction for a (partly) self-service community for ASOS
Marketplace.
The advantage of this approach is to take conversations off
public channels, and group questions by subject, so that one
customer service representative can answer common questions
in one place.
Dellâs community pages include tech support where users
can help each other, and groups for customers to share ideas.
To make communities like this work, you need a well-defined
strategy to encourage people to use them, and a process
for taking discussions off public channels into the dedicated
community. Itâs good practice to direct people to the right
threads within a community, to keep conversations appropriate and on-topic; and to feed any issues
back to the brand. (This is a huge topic in itself; if youâre looking for more information on self-serve
communities, the Get Satisfaction blog is a good place to start.)
Social media and customer service
7
8. What you can expect from customer queries on social media
We are often asked questions such as: âWhat should I expect from social customer service?â âWhat
will customers ask me on Facebook?â âWhat resources should I put behind a customer care team on
social media?â âHow quickly should I respond to a query on Twitter?â Here, we hope to answer some
of those questions.
Volume: Research from Simply Measured indicates that of the top brands using Twitter for customer
service, 15% respond to 10 or more tweets a day; 7% to 50 or more tweets a day; and just 3% to
100 or more tweets a day. Start small, but be prepared to increase volumes as you build awareness
of your social channels.
Dealing with negativity: Just over half (52%) of customer feedback on social media is
negative, according to a study of 40 top brands by Brandwatch. The majority of this negative
feedback relates to dissatisfaction with customer service. According to the study:
âSocial media users were more likely to take to the web to voice general
discontent of a brandâs customer service than for any other reason,
corresponding to the negative perception of the survey as a whole. This was
particularly prevalent in the utilities sector.â
In the main, negative feedback isnât determined by the channel through which itâs reported, but by the
service provided by the brand (YouTube may be an exception to this rule, where comments tend to
be more abusive than on other channels).
Brandwatch found that the three UK companies noted for being the best at delivering great customer
service â John Lewis, Waitrose and BQ â all had a much higher than average report of positive
feedback. The lesson here is not to get off social media, but to get your customer service strategy
right across the business in order to reduce negative feedback.
Nokia USâs social media manager, Sean Valderas, was quoted in an interview by Ron Miller on
Citeworld on the companyâs goal to create trust and dispel negativity by creating content that
addresses the communityâs common questions. Miller quotes Valderas as saying:
âBeing that our role is as customer support, our content creation is centered
on product and application tips which proactively address the most frequent
types of questions that our followers have.â
Customers want a quick response: Jeff Zabin, writing for CRM Buyer, says too many companies
are transferring their offline practices online; response times which might be acceptable for an email
are not sufficient on social channels. He cites research from Gleanster that found many companies
take 24 hours to respond over social media, and in his view thatâs 23 hours too long for most
customers.
Social media agency Ignite analysed the response times of brands to posts and customer
comments on Facebook (using Expion data). The results make interesting reading.
Social media and customer service
8
9. KLM, lauded as a leader in social media customer service since it used social media to help stranded
passengers after Icelandic volcano Eyjafjallajökull erupted in 2010, averaged 26 minutes to first
respond to a post on Facebook. Wal-Mart is shortly behind, at 28 minutes, followed by retailer Next
Online at 36 minutes and Xbox at 38 minutes. Seven of the top 10 companies respond within an hour.
In the same study, KLM tops the list of companies measured by the amount of Facebook page posts
by customers to which the company responded: it has an impressive 92% response rate to customer
posts.
Customers want a direct answer to a direct question: one of the biggest challenges facing
brands is how to find direct requests or responses among the background noise of Twitter and
Facebook. A survey by Software Advice (reported on Teletech.com) put brands to the test by
sending out a series of tweets over 26 days to some of the biggest brands in the world.
Some were âurgentâ, some were requests for help, others were negative feedback or praise. Pepsi
and Bank of America were top of the respondents list (Pepsi responded in 19 seconds; Bank of
America had the highest response rate). But the names that failed to respond at all to any of the
26 tweets might surprise you: Apple, Starbucks, Wal-Mart (which as weâve seen above, scores
highly on Facebook) and Visa. There shouldnât be a discrepancy between quality of service on
different channels. Your customers wonât care that you couldnât get hold of the right person in your
organisation quickly enough to answer their question.
Social media and customer service
9
10. Best practice advice: things to do to deliver great social media
customer service
Here are our tips for best practice in social media customer service:
Establish your objectives at the outset.
Agree what you want social media customer service to achieve. Is it reduced cost? Increased
resolution time? Better user experience? This will define how you measure its success, and how you
allocate resource.
Monitor and track conversations.
This is, really, the very basis of any good customer service. If you donât know whatâs being said about
your brand, you canât respond. There are any number of social media monitoring tools out there,
which leads us toâŠ
âŠTriage posts.
If youâre dealing with hundreds or even thousands of queries a day, youâll need a combination of
technology (such as Radian6 or Sysymos) and human analysis to help you identify those posts which
need a response. Tools such as Augify can help you determine intent (such as intent to buy) and
emotion, rather than just relying on the more traditional âpositive, negative, neutralâ sentiment, which
is extremely useful when you triage social content. Add a layer of human insight to this to understand
which posts are the most important.
Use good management tools.
Social CRM is a whole topic in its own right, but worth a mention here is Comufy, which can help
companies integrate social data in to CRM systems. This goes a long way to getting a single view
of a customer across different channels â really helpful to your customer service team. Moderation
and management tools (such as Adobe Social or Conversocial) will let you manage and track
customer conversations, as well as your responses, so you have a record for both marketing and
legal purposes.
Donât silo social media from customer service.
Customer service should be an integrated part of your social media approach (and vice versa). The
user experience should be equally good whatever the channel.
Get your social media team right from the outset.
Include customer service specialists, marketing and legal representatives who are on hand to answer
urgent questions. Thereâs a really interesting discussion on Saleforceâs Marketing Cloud blog (written
by Jeffrey L Cohen) that recaps a debate between Ford, GM and Chrysler on the importance of social
customer service, including having the right people in place. Cohen summarises the point as follows:
âThe same people who respond by phone and email are not necessarily
the right people for social media customer care. You can establish rules,
policies and terms of engagement for social media, but in the end your agents
need to respond as people. This may not be easy for those who have been
Social media and customer service
10
11. following phone scripts for years. This means have a bit of fun and personality.
Be unscripted, but understand where the lines are and you will make better
connections. If your customers have an emotional attachment to your products,
make sure your social media agents have that same passion. Even in 140
characters, it shows.â
Train your social customer service team properly and give them the authority to act.
Zappos reportedly trains all employees on Twitter as part of a new hire training programme. And
anyone interacting with customers over any channel should have the appropriate authority to resolve
issues. Ron Miller on Citeworld quotes Nokiaâs Valderas, saying:
âSocial is breaking down the communication barrier between the consumers
that are experiencing issues in the field and our key internal experts that can
create and communicate solutions.â
Without being able to access experts, the trust between the brand and the consumer breaks down,
and the channel becomes useless.
Choose your channel(s).
Donât spread your resources too thin. While itâs important to monitor every social channel over
which your customers are talking about you, itâs better to focus on delivering service well over a few
channels, than trying to be all things to all people. For consumer brands, Facebook and Twitter still
rule the roost (but see our analysis of the up and coming channels, below).
Resource it properly.
The example of Charter, mentioned previously, is a salutary lesson. You donât want to be in a position
of having to close down a Twitter handle called âwecareâ if you (presumably) donât care enough to
resource it properly. Plan additional staff for busy times, and have a team on standby in the event of a
crisis. Consider outsourcing all or part of your social media management to a company that can scale
up or down as you need it. Good monitoring tools and escalation processes can really help identify
when you need additional resource.
Respond quickly.
Our recommendation to clients is that for a really serious breaking issue, you have around 15 minutes
to acknowledge the issue on Twitter, and slightly longer â an hour â on Facebook. For less serious
customer issues, these times can be a little longer.
Donât feel you have to get involved in every discussion.
Responding to customer posts is important in most cases, but there are times when itâs best to
walk away. You should never have to deal with aggressive behaviour, or extremism, or bullying; and
sometimes no amount of intervention can pacify someone who just wants to vent anger. Set your
guidelines for your customer service team from the start, so they know when to walk away.
Set the rules for your customer community, and moderate content.
Never leave abusive or inappropriate content, swearing or spam on your customer community. Set
the rules clearly, and enforce them. Nothing says âwe donât careâ like a Facebook page full of spam.
Social media and customer service
11
12. Social media and customer service
12
Group answers to commonly asked questions if youâre short of time. In busy times, it may not
be possible to respond to every single post by every single customer. If there are recurring questions
from customers, answer them in a âgroupâ post, such as âTo all our customers whoâre asking about
the service outage today, we can confirm thatâŠâ
Consider splitting your customer service feeds from your
main social media feeds.
ASOS Here To Help and BTCare are both great examples of
brands that have split their customer service streams in order
to encourage a more private conversation, away from the public
channels. Itâs more manageable for the brand, and stops your
main feed being cluttered with customer queries.
Accept criticism, and act to right wrongs.
It is possible to turn an angry customer into a loyal advocate
with the right customer service. Spot an issue quickly, and
put it right, fast. Itâs not always about financial compensation,
either: sometimes a customer wants suggestions, feedback or
quick help; Salesforce has a great Prezi showing how the right
handling can resolve a customer issue quickly.
What you donât want to do is what home delivery firm Yodel
did: threaten to sue Twitter if critical tweets werenât deleted. (Itâs
not clear whether Twitter acted on these threats â according
to Gordon McMillan, writing for The Wall blog, Twitter doesnât
discuss individual cases â but even if it did, Yodel has landed
itself a lot of negative publicity on the back of the case.)
Take complex discussions offline where possible.
If a customer query is going to extend beyond a couple of posts,
itâs better to take it to email, online chat, a dedicated community
or even a phone call. The risk of keeping long, complicated conversations on Twitter or Facebook
is that you risk broadcasting the problem to a wider audience. This problem has been made slightly
easier by Facebookâs introduction of threaded comments on brand pages (caveat here: at the time
of writing, Conversocial is the only management tool to let you manage threaded comments on
Facebook, but that is likely to change over the coming weeks).
Respond with an appropriate tone of voice and personalisation.
O2 in the UK responded to an incredibly difficult and prolonged service outage issue with a personal
touch, and humour where it was appropriate. Show that youâre a human being, not a robot. Itâs also a
good example of how personalisation can help the brand counter negativity.
13. Social media and customer service
13
Twitter and Facebook rule the customer service airwaves, but for
how long?
Twitter and Facebook are certainly the most commonly used channels for customer service. But
others are raising their heads. Here is our take on the ones to watch:
Instagram
While itâs early days to advise brands to proactively run
customer service programmes on Facebook-owned Instagram,
this channel is one to watch. Itâs growing, fast, and according to
Simply Measured, 59% of the Interbrand Top 100 companies
already have a presence on Instagram. (Itâs worth noting that it
doesnât support Twitter any more.) Most notable in our view is
Topshop (this description of Topshopâs Instagram is taken from
the retailerâs âInsight Outâ blog):
âWant to see what weâre up to at Topshop HQ? Well now you can with our
Instagram! Giving you a sneak peek of anything and everything that says eye-
candy to the style hungry, expect to see all sorts from what the girls in the
office are wearing to pieces we spy on the buying floor! Find us on Instagram
@Topshop and be sure to tag any Topshop pieces in your own snaps with
#topshop.â
Brands are using Instagram as a marketing channel, and (broadly speaking) where thereâs marketing,
thereâs customer service. Consumers are sharing brand images (encouraging them to hashtag images
is a great way of keeping track of whatâs being shared thatâs relevant to your brand), and some of
those images might need a response.
As Ryan Northover says on his blog post for Social Media Today: âDonât be afraid to engage users
who are sharing negative images about your brand.â
Google+
Google+ is increasingly being used as a marketing tool for
brands, and there are some major features that mean customer
service on Google+ is set to grow over the next year, assuming
consumers demand it. Most notable are:
nn hangouts, where you can talk direct to customers, and
showcase new products, services or ideas;
nn communities, which you can use to collect ideas, feedback
or questions from customers;
nn circles, which is still the simple way to segment customers
on any social channel;
nn Google Ripples, which lets you see the viral impact of your posts (useful in identifying influencers
or potential brand ambassadors, as well as prioritising responses to negative posts).
14. Social media and customer service
14
In truth, there are few brands which need to use Google+ for
customer service yet, as Facebook still seems to be the channel
where customers will post complaints and requests (take a
look at ASOS on Google+; the brand posts regularly, but the
comments are mostly things like âI love thisâ and âhow coolâ, and
a few +1s, rather than anything that needs a direct response).
But thereâs no doubt that as consumers increase interaction with
brands on Google+, it will become more important.
Pinterest
While brands are using Pinterest for marketing purposes
(mostly with links back to their main website, or other âownedâ
community), thereâs little customer interaction, at the time of
writing, on Pinterest. While people can comment on photos,
most consumer activity is simply re-pinning to existing boards, rather than interacting with brands.
YouTube
YouTube is a great vehicle for displaying âhow toâ videos
to customers. Have a look at Appleâs YouTube channel
for examples â although note that comments are disabled
under each video (possibly a sensible move given the kind of
comments that YouTube historically seems to attract). Brands
should certainly monitor YouTube, but its real value for customer
service interaction within the posts remains to be seen.
Other sites: notable mentions
If youâre looking for the next big channel in customer service, itâs always worth watching where
Zappos is heading. Currently, it focuses most of its effort on Facebook, Twitter, Google+ and
Instagram, but is, according to Kelly Clay on Forbes:
ââŠdeveloping strategies to connect with customers [on] other platforms in
2013 such as Tout, Pose, Tumblr, Polyvore, Reddit, Medium, and SocialCam.â
These are all channels to keep an eye on over the next year, but itâs still important to monitor all
channels for customer issues, particularly those such as Reddit where passions can run high.
15. Social media and customer service
15
Social customer service is now a differentiator for brands
Forrester, in its 2013 report The Future of Customer Service, claims that customer service is moving
from being a cost centre to a differentiator. Author Kate Leggett says in her blog on the subject:
âCustomer Service Is Moving From Cost Center To Differentiator:
Customer service organizations are typically managed as a cost center. Key
success metrics focus on productivity, efficiency, and regulatory compliance
instead of customer satisfaction. However, we are seeing that customer
service organizations are gradually adopting a balanced scorecard of metrics
that include not only cost and compliance, but also customer satisfaction,
and which are more suited to drive the right agent behavior and deliver better
outcomes.â
If customer service is a differentiator, and customers are turning to social media for the provision of
at least part of that service, we all have to be ready. Itâs an exciting â and challenging â time for social
customer service.