International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications (IJERA) is a team of researchers not publication services or private publications running the journals for monetary benefits, we are association of scientists and academia who focus only on supporting authors who want to publish their work. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online, all the articles will be archived for real time access.
Our journal system primarily aims to bring out the research talent and the works done by sciaentists, academia, engineers, practitioners, scholars, post graduate students of engineering and science. This journal aims to cover the scientific research in a broader sense and not publishing a niche area of research facilitating researchers from various verticals to publish their papers. It is also aimed to provide a platform for the researchers to publish in a shorter of time, enabling them to continue further All articles published are freely available to scientific researchers in the Government agencies,educators and the general public. We are taking serious efforts to promote our journal across the globe in various ways, we are sure that our journal will act as a scientific platform for all researchers to publish their works online.
1. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
RESEARCH ARTICLE
www.ijera.com
OPEN ACCESS
An Empirical Study on Modified ML Estimator and ML Estimator of
Weibull Distribution by Using Type II Censored Sample
Farrukh Jamal, Muhammad Arsalan Nasir
Ph. D (Statistics) Scholar in the Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan
Ph. D (Statistics) Scholar in the Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan
Abstract
In this paper MML estimator and ML estimator of Weibull distribution by using doubly type II censored
sample have been derived and compared in term of asymptotic variances and mean square error. The purpose of
conducting the empirical study is to see the closeness of MML estimators to ML estimator, and relative
efficiency of censored sample to complete sample.
Keyword--- Type II censored sample, Modified Maximum Likelihood Estimator (MMLE), Maximum
Likelihood Estimator (MLE) , Asymptotic Variances, Bias, Mean Square Error, Weibull distribution, Order
Statistics.
I.
on the right .The likelihood function is given as
Introduction
When there are censoring present in the
sample the Maximum Likelihood Estimator (MLE)
can’t be found in closed form in general because of
intractable term. Dayyeh and Sawi (1996) replace the
intractable term of likelihood equations with its
expectation, to get the estimators of location
parameter by considering the scale parameter
equal to 1 of logistic distribution in right Type ll
censored sample. Kambo (1978) derived the explicit
solution for ML estimator of two parameter
exponential distribution in the case of type ll
censored sample.
The two-parameter Weibull distribution
with scale and shape parameter is given as
f y; ,
1
y
y exp( ) , , y >0
Where is the shape and
.with distribution function
y
F Y exp
(1.1)
is the scale parameter
ns
n!
F Yr 1 r 1 F Yn s s f yi (2.1)
r! s!
i r 1
Where r nq1 1 and s nq 2 1 , q 1 is the
proportion of left censored sample and q 2 is the
L
proportion of right censored sample .By using
(1.1)&(1.2) in (2.1) we get
y
n1
L
exp r 1
r! s!
r
y ns
1 exp
s
ns
i r 1
The first derivative of the log-likelihood
function with respect to is given by:
y ns
exp
ln L y r 1 sy n s
nsr 1
r 2 2
2
y
1 exp n s
(2.2)
(1.2)
Put
zn s
yn s
and
by
using
Related distribution,
Here is the shape parameter. At = 1,
it reduces to the Exponential distribution, where as
at = 2 , it reduces to the Rayleigh distribution.
1
n
for intractable
E
1 exp z n s 1
ns
II.
term in (2.2) see Walid Abu-Dayyeh and Esam Al
Sawi (2006 ). Solving (2.2) the modified maximum
likelihood estimator of is given as
The Modified Maximum Likelihood
Estimator (MMLE) Of The Scale
Parameter
Of
The
Weibull
Distribution
For the doubly type ll censored sample with r
samples censored on the left and s samples censored
www.ijera.com
^
ns
nsy n s
y i
n s 1 i r 1
nsr
y
y 1 exp i
ry r 1 sy n s
(2.3)
73 | P a g e
ns
y
i r 1
i
set
0
2. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
^
from (2.3) is Modified Maximum Likelihood
estimator of the scale parameter from Weibull
distribution of type-ll censored sample.(Also called
Jamal & Nasir estimator).
III.
Asymptotical variance and Bias of
scale parameter
By using Glivenko-Cantelli lemma given by
john and Chen (2003)
We have
p1 G 1 q1 and p 2 G 1 1 q 2
So as n
z r 1 G 1 q1 and z n s G 1 1 q 2
z r 1 can be evaluated by using following
www.ijera.com
2nsyn s
2ryr 1 2syn s
ln L
nsr 2
3
3
2
3
3
n s 1
2
ns
y
i r 1
ns
1 zi
2q2 zn s
n
2 2q1 zr 1 2q2 zn s
1 q1 q2 2 i r
1
n
1 q2
n
Where
q1
i
r
s
q2
n
n
Applying expectation and multiplying by
negative sign on both sides we get For large n i.e
n , substituting the values (3.1) , (3.2) and
(3.3) in above equation
ln L n 2q2 ln q2
E
2
2
1 q 1 q1 q 2 2 ln 1 q1
2
relation
G z r 1 q1
So Asymptotic variance is given as
z r 1
f z dz q
1
0
z r 1 ln 1 q1
(3.1)
^
var
2q ln q 2
n1 q1 q 2 2 ln 1 q1 2
1 q2
and
2
G z n s 1 q 2
f z dz q
(3.4)
2
zn s
From
z n s ln q 2
(3.2)
and
1 ns
lim E z i
n i r 1
we
observe
as
n
,
var 0
y r 1
zn s
For Bias put z r 1
z r 1
z r 1
(3.3)
for intractable term in equation
(2.2) and replace intractable term with its expectation
nsyn n
ln L ryr 1 syn s
nsr
1
2 2 2
2
n s 1
Again differentiate with respect to
ns
y
i r 1
i
, z ns
y ns
, zi
y i
in (2.3) and applying expectation
zf z dz z exp z dz
1 q1 1 ln 1 q1 q 2 1 ln q 2
yn s
(3.4)
^
zn s
n
Put zn s
1
^
var
E ln L
2
q2
1 ns
q1 z r 1 q 2 z n s
z ns E zi
1
n i r 1
1 q1
n
^
E
1 q1 q 2
For large sample size substituting the (3.1) , (3.2)
and (3.3) in above equation we get,
q2 ln q2
1 q ln 1 q1
2
Bias E
1 q1 q2
^
^
(3.5)
www.ijera.com
74 | P a g e
3. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
From
(3.5)
we
0
Bias
IV.
observe
as
n
,
^
Estimation of the Mean Square Error
of ^ for ordered random variable
The probability density function of z r:n is given by
f r:n z
n!
1 exp z r 1 exp n r 1z
r 1!n r !
0 x
By definition E z r :n is given as
0
n!
1 exp z r 1 exp n r 1dz
r 1!n r !
Solving the integral and simplifying we get
(See Akhter (2006))
r
E z r:n
1
= r
i 1 n j 1
r
1
Similarly vz r:n
r
2
i 1 n j 1
Now we find mean and variance of z r
E zr
E y r r
1
E yr
(4.3)
Now by applying variance on equation (2.3)
and by using (4.2) we get
q2
2
2
2
q1 r 1 q2
1
1 q2
^
n
v
2
1 q1 q2
2
ns 2
n
(4.4)
Where
ns
i r 1
yr
i
ns
i r 1
i
By using (4.3) and (4.4) , we have
MSE ^
(4.1)
r
1
j 1 n j 1
1
var zr 2 var yr
var y r 2 r
r
1
Where r
2
j 1 n j 1
Where r
q2
q1 r 1
q2 n s 1 q1 q2
1
n
1 q2
n
^
Bais
1 q1 q2
2
E z r:n zf r:n z dz
z
ns
ns j
r 1 1
1
ns ns 1
1
r
s
1 n i 1 jr1 i1 n i 1
n i 1
i 1
i 1 n i 1 n s 1 i
^
E
nrs
2
r 1
ns
ns
ns j
1
1
s
1
1
2
r2
s
n i 12 n i 12 1 s 1 n i 12 n i 12
i 1
i 1
i 1
j 1 i 1
n n
^
v
2
n r s
www.ijera.com
2
1 q1 q2
2
2
q2
q1 r 1
q2 n s 1 q1 q2
n
1 q2 1
n
2
q2
2
2
ns 2
q1 r 1 q2
n
1 q2 1
n
(4.5)
V.
(4.2)
The Maximum Likelihood Estimator
(MLE)Of The Scale Parameter Of The
Weibull Distribution By Using Type II
Censored Sample
Kambo (1978) derived the explicit solution for ML
estimator of two parameter exponential distribution
in the case of doubly type ll censored sample. In this
section ML estimator are given for two parameters
Weibull distribution in the case of doubly type ll
censored sample.
Now by applying expectation on (2.3) and by using
(4.1) we get
www.ijera.com
75 | P a g e
4. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
By putting zn s
yn s
and using (3.2) in (2.2) see
Kambo(1978) then the
estimator of is given as
maximum
(5.6)
Corollary: For large sample size estimator from (2.3)
and (5.1) become same.
(5.1)
Proof: From (2.3) we have
^
from (5.1) is Maximum Likelihood estimator of
the scale parameter from Weibull distribution of
type-ll censored sample.
For bias put z r 1
y r 1
y ns
, z ns
(5.2)
we
0
Bias
observe
n
as
^ put zn s
yn s
^
var
2q ln q 2
n1 q1 q 2 2 ln 1 q1 2
1 q2
VI.
Comparison of Censored Sample To
Complete Sample.
2
(5.3)
n , var ^ 0
For estimation of the mean square error by order
random variable by using (4.1) and (4.2) in (5.1)
after applying expectation and variance we get,
Bias ^ E ^
q2
q1 r 1 2 n s 1 q1 q2
1 q2
n
1 q1 q2
(5.4)
and
var ^
2
q 22
2
1 q2
n
2 q12 r 1 n s
1 q1 q2
2
(5.5)
From the equation (5.4) and (5.5) we obtain MSE as
www.ijera.com
ns
yi
i r 1
For large n estimator from (2.3) and (5.1)
are exactly same that why asymptotic variances,
MSEs (for large sample size) are same, this
establishes the Corollary.
and (3.2) for intractable term in equation (2.2) we
have
From (5.3) we observe as
,
^
For asymptotic Variance of
^
(5.2)
n ns
ryr 1 sy n s 1
yi
^
n s 1 i r 1
nsr
1
q2 n
ryr 1 sy n s
1
1 q2
^
n
nsr
q 2 2 ln q2
q 2 ln q2 ln 1 q1
1 q2
Bias E
1 q1 q2
From
^
ns
nsy n s
y i
n s 1 i r 1
nsr
ry r 1 sy n s
y i
, zi
in (5.1) and applying expectation and for large
sample size substituting the (3.1) , (3.2) and (3.3) in
(5.1) we have
^
2
2
2
2
q1 r 1 q 2 ns 1 q1 q2 q12 r 1 q 2 ns 2
2
n
n
1 q1 q2
1 q2
1 q2
2
likelihood
q ns
ryr 1 sy n s 2 yi
^
1 q2 i r 1
nsr
MSE ( )
www.ijera.com
In this section we compare the reduction in
efficiency of censored sample to the complete sample
for the scale parameter of Weibull distribution
keeping the shape parameter fixed. Now we find
estimator of complete sample using method of
maximum likelihood from the equation (1.1) we get.
n
^
y
i 1
i
(6.1)
n
^
from (6.1) is the estimator of compete sample.
For estimation of the mean square error by
order random variable by using (4.1) and (4.2) in
(6.1) after applying expectation and variance we get,
^
Bias
1
n
(6.2)
and
2
^
var 2
n
(6.3)
76 | P a g e
5. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
From (6.2) and (6.3) we obtained MSE as,
2
^ 2
MSE 1 2
n
n
(6.4)
It is the MSE of complete sample
Reduction in efficiency =(MSE of censored sample
/MSE of complete sample )-1
Which can be obtain from (4.5) and (6.4)
(6.5)
VII.
Discussion and Conclusion.
1)
In this paper a simple approximation has
been proposed for intractable term (See Walid AbuDayyeh and Esam Al Sawi 2006 ) , to estimate scale
parameter keeping shape parameter fixed of two
parameter Weibull distribution from doubly type ll
censored sample.
minimum as compare to ML estimator for small
sample size . So for small sample size MML
estimator is better than ML estimator. For large
sample size of n (n>100) MSE,s of both MML
estimator and ML estimator are same.
6)
From Table (3) we observe that for q1=q2=0
as the sample size increases the reduction in
efficiency decreases. And for rest of values the
sample size increases the reduction in efficiency also
increases with the same proportion of left and right
censored sample. As the total proportion of censored
sample increases , the reduction in efficiency also
increases.
REFERENCES
[1]
2)
The table(1) of asymptotic variance for n =
10 ,20 ,30 ,50 &100 and table(2) of MSE by using
theory of order statistics for n = 10 , 20 , 30, 50 &100
are given for the MML estimator and ML estimator
with maximum 0.6 total proportion of censored
sample i.e q1+q2=0.6 , where q1 is the proportion
of left censored sample and q2 is the proportion of
right censored sample. For any sample size there are
three conditions for q1 and q2. (i) q1 > q2 (ii) q1< q2
(iii) q1= q2 .
[2]
3)
From Table (1), as the sample size increases
the asymptotic variances are decreased with the same
proportion of left and right censored sample.
Asymptotic variances depend on total proportion of
censored sample, as total proportion increases. the
variances also increases. Asymptotic variances of
MML estimator exactly same as variances of ML
estimators.
[4]
4)
From Table (2) for q1=q2=0. no censoring
scheme is involved in other words there is no missing
element in the sample then the MSE,s of MML
estimator and ML estimator tends to decreases for
any sample of size n. As the sample size increases
the Mean square errors of MML estimator tends to
decreases but Mean square errors of ML estimators
increases.
5)
The purpose of conducting empirical study
is to see the closeness of MML estimators to ML
estimator of Weibull distribution for type II censored
sample .Since it has been seen that the asymptotic
variances of Modify Maximum Likelihood (MML)
estimator are exactly same to Maximum Likelihood
(ML) estimator. MSE,s of MML estimator is
www.ijera.com
www.ijera.com
[3]
[5]
[6]
[7]
Aleem M. and Jamal F. (2009),”Modified
Inference about the scale parameter of the
Inverse Weibull Distribution by using type ll
censored sample Sindh. Univ.Res. Jour .
(Sci.Ser) Vol.41(1) 87-94.
Aleem M.et al (2009) Modified Inference
about the scale parameter of the Weibull
Distribution by using type ll censored
sample.Proc.5th International Statistical
Conference January 23-25. 2009, Vol 17,
203-210.
Akhter . S (2006) a study on parameter
estimation of exponential distribution for
type-ll censored sample M.Phil thesis
department of statistics G.C.U Lahore
Pakistan
John , T.T and Chen, P (2003). Selection of
the Best using Censored Data from
(log-)
location - Scale
Populations.
Preprint submitted to journal of Statistical
Planning and Inference 24 October 2003.
Walid Abu-Dayyeh and Esam Al Sawi
(1996) modified inference about the location
parameter of the logistic distribution using
type II censored samples pak. J. Statist. 2006
vol. 22 (2) pp 157-169
Kambo, N, S ,.(1978). Maximum likelihood
estimators of the location and scale
parameters of the exponential distribution
from a censored sample, comm.. Statist.
Theory methods A 12, 1129-1132.
Mehrotra , K.G and Nanda, P . (1974) .
Unbiased estimator of parameter by order
statistics in the case of censored samples.
Biometrika 61, 601-606.
77 | P a g e
6. Farrukh Jamal et al Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Applications
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 1( Version 1), January 2014, pp.73-80
www.ijera.com
2
Table 1 : The asymptotic variance of MML& ML estimates from doubly censored sample in term of for n=10, 20,
30, 50 and100 from the equation (3.4) and (5.3)
n=10
n=20
n=30
q1
q2
var 1 2
var 1 2
var 1 2
var 2 2
var 2 2
var 2 2
0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.1
0.2
0.2575
0.2004
0.9434
0.1576
0.414
0.1247
0.2447
1.2289
0.099
0.1621
0.2575
0.2004
0.9434
0.1576
0.414
0.1247
0.2447
1.2289
0.099
0.1621
0.1288
0.1002
0.4717
0.0788
0.207
0.0624
0.1224
0.6145
0.0495
0.081
0.1288
0.1002
0.4717
0.0788
0.207
0.0624
0.1224
0.6145
0.0495
0.081
0.0858
0.0668
0.3145
0.0525
0.138
0.0416
0.0816
0.4096
0.033
0.054
0.0858
0.0668
0.3145
0.0525
0.138
0.0416
0.0816
0.4096
0.033
0.054
n=50
n=100
q1
q2
var 1 2
var 2 2
var 1 2
var 2 2
0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.1
0.2
0.0515
0.0401
0.1887
0.0315
0.0828
0.0249
0.0489
0.2458
0.0198
0.0324
0.0515
0.0401
0.1887
0.0315
0.0828
0.0249
0.0489
0.2458
0.0198
0.0324
0.0258
0.02
0.0943
0.0158
0.0414
0.0125
0.0245
0.1229
0.0099
0.0162
0.0258
0.02
0.0943
0.0158
0.0414
0.0125
0.0245
0.1229
0.0099
0.0162
2
Where var 1 is the variance of MML estimator from (3.4)
and
var 2 2
is the variance of ML estimator from (5.3)
Table 2 :The MSE of MML estimates from doubly censored sample in term of for n=10, 20, 30, 50 and 100 from
the equation (4.5) and (5.6)
n=10
n=20
n=30
MSE 2 2 MSE 1 2 MSE 2 2 MSE 1 2 MSE 2 2
q1
q2
2
MSE 1
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.0293
0.0792
0.2244
0.4778
0.9125
1.6975
3.2551
0.0516
0.0453
0.1565
0.3951
0.8628
1.8336
0.1347
0.0406
0.0884
0.2772
0.7451
www.ijera.com
0.0448
0.1024
0.2968
0.6618
1.3403
2.7035
5.8783
0.0707
0.0653
0.228
0.5972
1.3786
3.1812
0.159
0.0531
0.1503
0.4901
1.375
0.009
0.0749
0.2341
0.5059
0.9691
1.8027
3.4522
0.0256
0.0343
0.1626
0.4256
0.9349
1.9858
0.0972
0.0141
0.0813
0.3013
0.8303
0.013
0.0849
0.2695
0.5951
1.1708
2.2576
4.5644
0.0306
0.0424
0.1977
0.5243
1.1792
2.5961
0.1035
0.0178
0.1121
0.4067
1.1312
0.0044
0.0757
0.2394
0.5173
0.9904
1.8408
3.5224
0.0197
0.0333
0.1671
0.4385
0.9623
2.0413
0.0883
0.0084
0.0822
0.3132
0.864
0.0062
0.0822
0.263
0.5765
1.1228
2.1358
4.2307
0.0219
0.0385
0.1907
0.5041
1.123
2.4374
0.0911
0.0106
0.1031
0.3838
1.0627
78 | P a g e