Digital Power Factor Correction - Handling the corner cases
1. Digital Power Factor Correction
Handling the corner cases
Superior THD over entire operating range
www.controltrix.com
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
2. Power Factor primer
Inductive - Lagging
we
r cosΦ = Real Power
Po
re n t Apparent Power
pa
Ap
Reactive Power
= Power Factor
Φ
Real Power
Capacitive - Leading
Applies for ideal sinusoidal
waveforms for both voltage
and current
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
3. Calculating Power Factor
Power factor = Real power / Apparent power
= (Vrms * I1rms * CosΦ) / (Vrms * Irms)
= cosΦ * ( I1rms / Irms)
Power factor = KΦ * Kd
Kd = distortion factor (THD) KΦ = displacement factor (D.F)
Vrms = AC input rms voltage
Irms = AC input rms current
I1rms = Fundamental component of Irms
cos Φ = Phase angle between input AC voltage
and the fundamental current
Irms = Sqrt (I12 + I22 + I32+ ………….+In2)
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
4. PF Degradation
Voltage
Resulting
Current
Sinusoidal Current with phase
shift
Voltage
Resulting
Current
Current with harmonic
content
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
5. Power factor correction
• Reduce energy loss in transmission lines
• Improve power quality
• Cost
• Regulatory needs
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
6. Useful Power
Useful Power Negative Power
Applied Voltage
Region Region
Resulting Current
Without PFC
Φ Φ
Applied Voltage
Resulting Current
With Active PFC
copyright 2011 controltrix corp Useful Power www. controltrix.com
7. Digital PFC system
Boost
AC Supply Rectifier Load
PFC
Vac Iac PWM Vdc
DSP/DSC
Basic Components of the PFC Converter
Switch Capacitor
Inductor Diode
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
8. Boost Topology
Average Inductor Current
IL IL
PFC Boost Converter
L D
tON +
IL ID
IS IS
+
vIN S C
-
ID -
VOUT > VIN
Average Current Mode Control
The average current through the inductor is made to follow the input voltage
Ref: AN1274 Interleaved PFC app note from microchip
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
9. Challenges
Ideally ……
• Low THD & high PF over entire 90 -265 Vac input
• Low THD & high PF over entire 10 -100 % load range
Low line and high load meeting specifications is EASY !!!!
Low load ( < 50%) & Hi Line (> 220 V) spec is HARD !!!!
Cause : Change of system dynamics
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
10. Typical specs
Load(%) THD(%) • (Typical Desired) State of the art
spec.
10 <15
• 2.4 KW bridgeless PFC spec. for
20 <10
power supplies for server
30 <6 farms
50 <5 • Digital (DSP) control
70 <3 • Fixed switching frequency
operation
80 <3
100 <3
Gets harder @ Hi line
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
11. State of the art review
Approach 1
• Determine Discontinuous/continuous conduction mode
operation
• Change the control laws
Challenge
• Computation
• If-else ladder
• Parameter sensitivity
• Non linearity of discontinuous mode of operation is hard
• Fixed point implementation is challenging
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
12. State of the art review
Approach 2
• Harmonic injection
Challenge
• Trial and error
• Not plug and play / System specific
• If-else ladder (discontinuities in code execution and dynamics)
• Limited Code size Memory/MIPS
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
13. State of the art summary
• Computationally complex (MIPS, code size)
• Fixed point implementation hard !!
• Physical models sensitive to parameter estimates (e.g. inductor
saturation )
• Poor convergence
• Strange artefacts
• Jumps/spikes/kinks/oscillations due to if-else ladder
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
14. Proposed solution features
• Good THD at all operating conditions
• Plug and play
• Just enter parameter dependent coefficients
• Low parameter and feedback sensitivity
• Fast convergence
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
15. Proposed solution features .
• No if-else ladder
• Small extra code size
• Low MIPS requirement ~ 12-14 MIPS (25% of 40 MIPS) @ 50 KHz
interrupt frequency
(Compares favorably with traditional methods)
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
16. Proposed solution features ..
• System independent /scalable to any rating
• Relevant for Interleaved PFC and bridgeless PFC topologies
• Guaranteed convergence/no large scale oscillations
• No if -else ladder
• Patent pending technology
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
17. Switched mode Simulation Results
• Fixed frequency operation ~100 KHz
• Vac = 220V rms ac, Vdc = 400 V
( High line is hardest to handle !!! )
• 330 W boost PFC system
• 700 uH inductance
• 300 uF output capacitance
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
18. Simulation Results:
• Left plot:
Average inductor current
• Right plot:
Switched mode inductor current
(continuous and discontinuous conduction mode)
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
22. Comparison of Specifications
IPFC reference design from microchip 2.4 KW server power supply from delta
Switching frequency : 100 KHz Switching Frequency : 65Khz
One side max load : 180 W Inductance : 200uH
Inductance : 700 uH(much
smaller value than
equivalent server
supply for that
rating)
• A system for similar specification as server supply for 700 uH,
100 KHz the power rating would be,
2400 * 200 / 700 * 65 / 100 = 445 W
• Thus 87 W is effectively 19.5 % load
• The results are thus very convincing
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
23. Experimental results
(IPFC board 89 W only single phase enabled)
Voltage 90 110 160 220 Remarks
Method
Classical PI controller (over damped) modeled 5.98 7.2 17.0 18.4 PF and THD rapidly degrades
on linear dynamics of continuous conduction at low loads
mode system
Classical PI controller modeled on linear 3.5 6.5 13.5 15.5 Easily ends up becoming
(critically damped) unstable / sub harmonic
oscillations due to parameter
changes
Classical P I controller with voltage feedforward 3.35 5.35 7.65 17.75 Works great in CCM. But
rapidly degrades in DCM /low
load conditions
Proposed method 2.9 5.2 6.21 8.5 Works equally well in all
regions of operation
89W load when corrected for inductance values and switching frequency is equivalent to
19.5 % load for comparable 2.4 KW system used in server power supply.
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
24. Scope shots (87 W load , 400 Vdc output)
110 V
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
25. Scope shots (87 W load , 400 Vdc output)
220 V
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
26. Classical PI control w/o FF
110 V
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
27. Classical PI control w/o FF
220 V
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
28. Results with AN1278 from microchip
Input voltage: 220 V, Load: 180 W (50%) dual phase
180 W for IPFC is equivalent to 90 W with only one phase of IPFC operational.
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com
29. Thank You
consulting@controltrix.com
copyright 2011 controltrix corp www. controltrix.com