Speaker: Alyse Killeen
Event: Blockchain Training Conference by CryptoCurrency Certification Consortium (C4)
Location: Toronto, Canada
Venture Capital and Blockchain Sector Startups: Very little information has existed to support the development of a mature angel or venture investing community within this complex and growing ecosystem. In this presentation the basic concepts of investing in startups within the bitcoin ecosystem are covered, and specific consideration is given to the diligence and thoughtfulness that should be uniquely applied to blockchain and cryptocurrency startup investing as it differs from other investments.
Investing in Blockchain Startups (Seminar) C4 MaRS Discovery District Toronto 6 2016
1. STILLMARK
This document is proprietary and confidential.
Investing in Blockchain-based Startups
@AlyseKilleen
June 2016
2. ‣ Very little information exists to
support the development of a
mature angel and venture
investing community.
‣ Traditional VCs have yet publicly
expressed their strategies for
evaluating blockchain companies.
2#VentureCash: Blockchain-based StartupsJune 2016 | StillMark Co.
• $1Billion+ Invested
• 200 Firms Investing
By the end of 2015
But still …
3. Forbes Entrepreneur 6.16.2016
3#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
Article based on opinions shared by Alyse Killeen, Tim Draper, and Pamir Gelenbe, a
Partner at Hummingbird Ventures.
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
5. INVESTING
The distinction between investing vs.
gambling is unclear, and the result is many
companies over-capitalized (creating
unhealthy incentives for teams) while other
companies lack the support needed to thrive.
CURRENT CHALLENGE
TODAY’S PRESENTATION
5#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Venture!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
RISK
SPECULATION GAMBLING We’ll cover a few of the basics necessary for
an investment mindset and practice, with
specific consideration given to the diligence
and thoughtfulness that should be specially
applied to blockchain and cryptocurrency
startup investing as it differs from other
investments.
ABILITY TO
MITIGATE RISK
6. INVESTING
The distinction between investing vs.
gambling is unclear, and the result is many
companies over-capitalized (creating
unhealthy incentives for teams) while other
companies lack the support needed to thrive.
CURRENT CHALLENGE
TODAY’S PRESENTATION
6#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Venture!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
RISK
SPECULATION GAMBLING We’ll cover a few of the basics necessary for
an investment mindset and practice, with
specific consideration given to the diligence
and thoughtfulness that should be specially
applied to blockchain and cryptocurrency
startup investing as it differs from other
investments.
ABILITY TO
MITIGATE RISK
7. Investing and accepting venture capital:
A. An expectation and commitment for the Company to create value and monetize that value, with a focus on
opportunities for scale in both value creation and monetization (e.g. decreasing incremental costs of service,
network effects – the increasing value of the Company product as the user group grows, etc.).
B. Can the Company and Team create value that will be recognized by consumers or enterprise users, and can the
Company and Team capture adequate compensation (via data, payment/fees, etc.) from the value they create?
C. Evaluate these two components separately.
7#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Venture!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
Creating Value vs. Capturing Value
8. General Principles of Review
Considerations and Diligence
• Pain Point (i.e. the problem, and audience’s awareness)
• Proposed Solution
• Market
• Competition
• Critical Timelines
• Product/Solution Development
• Capital Needs
• Team
8#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Venture!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
• Growth Projections (Users or Enterprise Sales Pipeline)
• Technical Barriers to Competition
• Time period the protection in expected to last
• Defining Key Metrics (KPIs)
• Current KPIs and the match to investment stage
• KPIs needed to raise the next financing round
9. Investing in blockchain companies requires special and
additional considerations, beyond the generalist basics
9#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
10. Infrastructure def.: Infrastructure provides a platform for
applications. Technology infrastructure generally does not
include the operating systems or software above the
hardware level except where WANs or cloud are used. Here
such transport mechanisms, along with platform or software
as a service may be considered infrastructure.
• The Problem: Blockchain core and associated
infrastructure is in early development and not
comprehensive to serve the needs of existing and
future applications; the necessary infrastructure to
serve current and future needs is not fully understood.
Infrastructure immaturity is delaying app development
and scalability.
Application
• The Problem: Many opportunities to address consumer and
enterprise problems and pain points. The Company’s problem
statement should be tested and evaluated in advance.
• Solutions: Efficiencies vs. New Value
• Efficiencies: Cost savings and opportunities to
serve larger markets (and the masses).
• New Value: What can now be done just because
blockchain technology exists?
10#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Venture!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
Venture Dynamics: Application vs. Infrastructure
11. What is the reliance and dependencies on the core blockchain infrastructure?
A. What is the state and expected progress of bitcoin core, and how does this impact the pace of progress for the
Company?
B. What is the ability of the Company to achieve scale with and without development of the core infrastructure?
C. Do the Company’s timelines (product, growth, team, capital needs) match with a realistic timeline for core
infrastructure development? Have other scenarios for the pace of core infrastructure development been
considered and planed for?
D. What is the risk of the pace of core infrastructure development? What is the cost of this risk?
11#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!Risks!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
Questions unique to blockchain and cryptocurrency: RISK
12. 12#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!Risks!
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
How does regulation and the regulatory environments affect the Company’s business?
A. What are the Company’s risks as a result of foreseeable or possible regulatory changes (or lack of change in
contentious regulatory environments)?
B. What will the cost of regulatory compliance be for the Company?
C. What is the risk of the pace of core infrastructure development? What is the cost of this risk?
Questions unique to blockchain and cryptocurrency: RISK
15. 15#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Ecosystem!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
‣ Is the Company’s product/service and goals (i.e. the Company’s value
proposition) consistent with the Satoshi value proposition?
‣ How will this impact the Company’s ability to form key partnerships and
business development? Scalability? Sustainability?
16. 16#VentureCash: Blockchain-based Startups
!!!!!!Ecosystem!
June 2016 | StillMark Co.
!!!!!!!
!!!
!!!!!!!
Venture Dynamics: A connected ecosystem
Investing in a target Company given the intertwined nature of the ecosystem:
A. In traditional angel and venture investing, an investment in one target Company precludes you from investing in
that Company’s competitors, and this is a critical component of the investment practice.
B. Given this condition, how do traditional investors select a target Company to invest in from a competitive set of
companies?