3. www.greenchemistry.net
Adhesives
Solvent is the major
ingredient (the ‘wet’ bit if
you were wondering)
Solvent is needed in
manufacturing &
processing
Solvent used
for washing
Market: 20 Million
Tonnes /year
ESIG data, 1997
4. www.greenchemistry.net
• Solvent use in adhesives has declined since the 1980’s.
• 6% of solvent use in 1990’s Europe attributed to the adhesives sector.
• Solvent-based adhesives made up 14% of European production in 1995
(25% in Asia).
• Many industries which use solvent-based adhesives have moved to regions
with less restrictions. For example:
• Shoe making in Brazil, China, and India (e.g. polyurethane adhesives);
• rubber bonding;
• PVC pipe bonding;
• contact polychloroprene adhesives.
• Typical solvents for the adhesives sector are hydrocarbon (both aliphatic
and aromatic) and ketone solvents (acetone and MEK).
Handbook of Solvents, Ed. Wypych, 1st edition (2001), page 848; Handbook of Adhesives and Sealants (Basic Concepts in High Tech Bonding,
vol. 1), Ed. Cognard, 2005, page 93.
10. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 1. Problem: Solvent substitution necessary
Safer, renewable hydrocarbon solvents from food waste
p-CymeneLimonene
11. www.greenchemistry.net
>
>
Case study 1. Problem: Solvent substitution necessary
Safer, renewable hydrocarbon solvents
G. Paggiola, A. J. Hunt, C. R. McElroy, J. Sherwood and J. H. Clark, Green Chem., 2014, 16, 2107.
12. www.greenchemistry.netJ. H. Clark D. J. Macquarrie and J. Sherwood, Chem. Eur. J., 2013, 19, 5174.
Ln[product selectivity]
Solvent induced
tautomerisation
Case study 1. Problem: Solvent substitution necessary
Safer, renewable hydrocarbon solvents
13. www.greenchemistry.net
Solvent Safety Health Environment Conclusion
Limonene 4 2 7 Problematic
n-Hexane 8 7 7 Hazardous
p-Cymene 4 5 5 Problematic
Toluene 5 6 3 Problematic
D. Prat et al., Green Chem., 2016, 18, 288.
CHEM21 selection guide of classical- and less classical-solvents
14. www.greenchemistry.net
Renewable Citrus Products Association LCA* (cradle-to-gate)
http://www.renewablecitrus.org/sites/renewablecitrus.org/files/LCA%201-6-13.pdf
Global warming potential (left):
Less good in ‘habitat alteration’
and ‘eutrophication’ indicators
due to direct land use change
and fertiliser/agrochemicals
Tapwater
Limonene
Orangeoil
Naphtha
Kerosene
Xylenes
Benzene
Toluene
Ethylbenzene
Acetone
DCM
Perc
(steam distillation)
(vacuum distillation)
15. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 2. Opportunity: New alternative solvents
A bio-based alternative for dipolar aprotic solvents
Image credit:
Andrew Hunt
16. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 2. Opportunity: New alternative solvents
A bio-based alternative for dipolar aprotic solvents
Polarity plot
credit: Laurianne Moity
17. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 2. Opportunity: New alternative solvents
A bio-based alternative for dipolar aprotic solvents
Three dimensional structure
Combination of functionality
18. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 2. Opportunity: New alternative solvents
A bio-based alternative for dipolar aprotic solvents
Can replace dipolar aprotic
solvents
19. www.greenchemistry.net
Case study 2. Opportunity: New alternative solvents
A bio-based alternative for dipolar aprotic solvents
Applications in materials science
20. www.greenchemistry.net
Open-bio is developing test methods and
recommendations for European standards describing
bio-based content, biodegradation, recycling strategies,
as well as labelling and procurement tools, and
• Our goal is to assist the growth of
the European bio-based product
market.
• Started in November 2014 as a 3
year EC-funded FP7 project.
Bio-based product standardisation
22. www.greenchemistry.net
Performance Bio-based content
HSE Sustainability
Bio-based solvents
CEN/TS 16766
At least 25% bio-based carbon
• Class A: ≥95%
• Class B: ≥50%
• Class C: ≥25%
Provide data but no threshold
values:
• Polarity
• Volatility
• Colour
• Density
• Viscosity
No harsher than REACH and
GHS/CLP
No extra barriers for bio-based
solvents
Sustainable biomass must be
used, and optionally the
production phase assessed
Bio-based product standardisation
23. www.greenchemistry.net
How to unify these ‘green’ EU economic
strategies?
Circular economy (general legislated targets)
ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/index_en.htm
Reduce food
waste and
marine litter
Increase recycling
and re-use of
municipal waste to
65%
Maximum
landfilling rate
of 10%
Bio-based economy (standardised product descriptions)
www.biobasedeconomy.eu
Biomas
s
Product
s
Some end-of-life
requirements for
certain products
Bio-based product standardisation
25. www.greenchemistry.net
Recirculated:
Returned to use within a certain timeframe by an
anthropogenic process and/or a natural process.
Open-Bio D3.4 Definitions for renewable
elements and renewable molecules
Renewable:
Comes from
renewable
resources and is
returned to use
within a certain
timeframe by a
natural process.
Returned to
use within a
certain
timeframe by
an
anthropogenic
process.
Recyclable:Reusable:
Returned to use
within a certain
timeframe without
modification to the
parent article or
loss of
performance.
Report available online at http://www.biobasedeconomy.eu/research/open-
bio/publications
26. www.greenchemistry.net
Bio-based Recirculated Sustainable
Complex with
many relevant
criteria
Hugely
challenging to
implement
Describes
biomass
utilisation
Environmental
impact is not
considered
Incorporates full
life cycle
coverage
Easily validated
and understood
Increasing
complexity
How does ‘recirculation’ fit within bio-based
product standardisation?
27. www.greenchemistry.net
Fossil reserves
Not recirculated
Bio-based carbon
Fossil carbon
C
C
Sustainability criteria (EN 16751)
Bio-based content
(CEN/TS 16640)
Biomass sustainability
(e.g. PEFC ST 1003) &
waste feedstocks
(e.g. ISCC PLUS 260-05)
End-of-life options:
•Mechanical recycling
•Chemical recycling
•Biodegradation
Vertical
standards
(e.g. CEN/TS
16766)
and
ecolabels
C
C
renew loop
recycle loop
reuse loop
(1) The InfoCard is a dissemination tool introduced by the European Chemical Agency (ECHA) to make the technical information published from the substance databases of the Agency more accessible to the general public.
(2) Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals REACH aims to improve the protection of human health and the environment through the better and earlier identification of the intrinsic properties of chemical substances. This is done by the four processes of REACH, namely the registration, evaluation, authorisation and restriction of chemicals. REACH also aims to enhance innovation and competitiveness of the EU chemicals industry.
(3) TCE will be subject to authorisation as of next week (carcinogen).
The first step in the authorisation process is to identify those substances that may have serious effects on human health or the environment and, therefore, the risks resulting from their use must be properly controlled and the substances progressively replaced when possible.
A Member State or ECHA at the request of the European Commission, can propose a substance to be identified as a Substance of Very High Concern (SVHC). If identified, the substance is added to the Candidate List, which includes candidate substances for possible inclusion in the Authorisation List (Annex XIV).
Focus on hydrocarbons and dipolar aprotics – the answer is not different versions of these compounds, but different substances that completely avoid the old issues.
p-Cymene made from limonene – more stable but still not very stable. We have evaluated the use of limonene in some detail – the context is very important.
Lipophilicity determines performance but also environmental damage – therefore answer is management of solvent and capture after use.
p-Cymene is able to replace toluene (sometimes), but better still by understanding the role of the solvent new alternatives can be found that are much better than traditional options. p-Cymene is unlike ethanol so such a successful substitution cannot be made just by ‘like-for-like’ observations.
Cyrene – designed specifically to provide optimum performance from a bio-based platform molecule – unlike typical dipolar aprotics.
Applications: typical reactions of dipolar aprotics (some stability issues), real potential is high tech sectors, formulations to replace ‘difficult’ solvents.
Bio-based solvents is the only vertical standard produced by TC 411. Will become a full standard later this year.
Circular economy is cradle-to-cradle. Incineration and biodegradation is only valuable in a circular economy if the products are 100% bio-based – the material is recirculated. Do not assume bio-based = green or = compatible with a circular economy. Product design is important.
Definitions and test methods to help design for end-of-life and appreciate circular economy needs have been produced by the Open-Bio consortium.