"Aflasafe: a case study for aflatoxin reduction in crops" presentation by "Ranajit Bandyopadhyay, International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Ibadan, Nigeria"
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
"Aflasafe: a case study for aflatoxin reduction in crops "
1. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Aflasafe:
A case study for
aflatoxin reduction
in crops
Ranajit Bandyopadhyay
IITA, Ibadan, Nigeria
On behalf of the Aflasafe Team
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
FAO Symposium: The role of agricultural biotechnologies in
sustainable food systems and nutrition
Rome, 15 – 17 February 2016
2. P
• Highly toxic metabolite
produced by the ubiquitous
Aspergillus flavus fungus
• The fungus resides in soil and
crop debris, infects crops and
produces the toxin in the field
and in stores
• Potent at extremely low doses
• Death, liver cancer, immune-
suppression, stunted growth
• Lowers animal productivity
• Negatively impacts trade
• Contaminates food,
feed and milk
• Climate change
increasing
incidence and
severity of
aflatoxins
Aflatoxin Facts
Photo: Peter Cotty
3. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Pre-Harvest Problem
Aflatoxin (ppb) Maize (n = 241) Peanut (n = 188)
> 4 70 54
> 10 52 41
> 20 24 29
Samples (%) with Aflatoxin
At harvest -- Nigeria
Kenya data: CDC & Ministry of Health, 2004
Aflatoxin (ppb) Maize (n = 342)
> 20 53
> 100 34
> 1000 7
In Farmers’ Store -- Kenya
Increases
after
Harvest
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
5. www.iita.org
• IITA
• USDA
• AATF
• BMGF/USAID
• Doreo Partners
• National institutions
Strong Partnership
www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
6. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Almost one million
acres of several crops
treated annually in
the US with 2 EPA-
Approved products !
Production Room
Atoxigenic Strain Manufacturing Facility
Arizona Cotton Research & Protection Council
(Funded and Governed by the Farmers of Arizona),
Phoenix, Arizona
Biocontrol Works!
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
7. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Biocontrol Works!
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
It Works in
Africa Too
8. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Biocontrol Principles
In nature, some strains produce a lot
(toxigenic), and others no aflatoxin
(atoxigenic) (Donner, Soil Biol Biochem
2009)
Atoxigenic strains are already present on
the crop (Atehnkeng et al., IJFM, 2008)
Increase the frequency of atoxigenic
strains to competitively displace
toxigenic strains (Cotty & Bayman,
Phytopath 1993) to reduce aflatoxin
contamination
Atoxigenic strains can be applied without
increasing infection and without
increasing the overall quantity of A. flavus
on the crop or in the environment (Cotty,
Phytopath 1994; Atehnkeng et al., Biological
Control 2014)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0 20 40 60 80 100
AflatoxinB1(ng/gX10,000)
Isolates (%) in Applied Atoxigenic Strain
Strains move from
field to stores
Multiple year & crop
carry-over effect
(Jaime & Cotty,
Phytopath 2006)
We use only native
strains
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
9. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Strain Selection Criteria
In the laboratory (~5,000 strains):
• Does not produce aflatoxin
• VCG/SSR group with
Wide geographic distribution
No toxigenic member
• Defective in >2 aflatoxin & CPA
genes
• Outcompetes toxigenic strains
8-12 native strains
selected for field tests
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
After field application:
• Superior capacity to colonize,
multiply and survive in soil
• Superior frequency of isolation
from grains
• Superior capacity to reduce
aflatoxin
4 native strains
formulated into
the final
product
10. Broadcast
@ 10 kg/ha 2-3 weeks
before flowering
Sporulation on moist soil
Spores
Insects
Aflasafe in 2.5 & 5 kg bags
3-20
days
Wind
Soil
colonization
30-33 grains m-2
How Does aflasafe Work?
11. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Nigeria: Efficacy on Maize
372
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2009 2010 2011 2012
Aflasafe™
Control
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2009 2010 2011 2012
82 94 83 86 82 93 89 90
51 14 199 38 51 14 166 38Fields (#)
Less (%)
At Harvest After Storage
*All means of aflasafe and control pairs significantly different; Student’s t-test (P<0.05)
*
Aflatoxin(ppb)
12. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Area Sample Treatment
Mean
Aflatox
(ppb)
Reduct.
(%)
Mean
Aflatox
(ppb)
Reduct.
(%)
Mean
Aflatox
(ppb)
Reduct.
(%)
Diourbel
Harvest
Treated 1.9
93
6.6
87
3.7
82
Control 29.7 50.1 20.3
Storage
Treated 4.4
86
2.1
91
6.9
81
Control 31.3 22.1 35.5
Nioro
Harvest
Treated 4.4
75
5.6
76
5.4
90
Control 17.6 23.1 55.7
Storage
Treated 3.5
95
2.8
94
11.5
84
Control 52.1 46.7 72.5
*All means of aflasafe treated and control pairs significantly different; Student’s t-test (P<0.05)
n = number of famers’ fields
Senegal: Efficacy of aflasafe SN01
2010 (n=40) 2011 (n=34) 2012 (n=71)
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
13. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Kenya: Efficacy of aflasafe KE01™
Area (fields) Control Treated
Reduction
(%)
Hola (n = 20) 885 20 98
Bura (n = 16) 105 7 93
Makueni (n = 15) 85 1 99
Aflatoxin (ppb)
*All means of aflasafe treated and control pairs significantly different; Student’s t-test (P<0.05)
38
20
0
88
60
33
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Treated
Control
Fields (%) above
10 ppb in 3 areas
Fields(%)
Deadly (3,700 ppb & 2,270 ppb)
533 ppb
Hola
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
14. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Aflasafe Development in Africa
Senegal
Burkina
Faso
Ghana
Nigeria
Kenya
Tanzania
Mozambique
Zambia
Rwanda
Malawi
Burundi
Uganda
The
Gambia
Strain
development in
progress
Products under
testing in
farmers’ fields
Product ready
for registration
Product
registered
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
Current
emphasis
changed from
country-specific
strain and
products to
regional strains
and regional
products
15. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Challenges
• Aflatoxin is a hidden problem
• Chemical analysis required
• Awareness is low
• Long incubation for expression of
liver cancer
• Regulations either non-existent or
poorly enforced
• Market does not usually discriminate
• Demonstration of product value
• Lack of biopesticide manufacturers
The value of a
technology on the
shelf is as much
as the cost of the
space it occupies
on the shelf.
Must translate
knowledge into
usable products
and practices to
benefit people
But……
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
16. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
This Manufacturing Facility in IITA-Ibadan can
supply aflasafe to treat 2 million ha annually
Large-scale: capacity 5 tons/hour
Product cost: $12 to $18.75/ha
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
18. Poultry Feeding Study
$3,200 net
profit from
10,000 birds
in 8 weeks
www.iita.orgMycored Europe, 28 May, 2013A member of CGIAR consortium
Aflasafe maize feed
Toxic maize feed
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
19. Innovation Platform
• Platform meetings with
leadership and members of
Poultry Association of
Nigeria, feed manufacturers,
maize aggregators, aflasafe
farmers, vet professionals
and regulators
• Poultry farmers to buy all
aflasafe maize at a negotiated
premium
• Agriculture ministry to fund
NAFDAC to set up aflatoxin
testing facilities in each state
www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
20. www.iita.orgwww.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Integrated approach to manage aflatoxins
Aggregation
Aflasafe
Inputs & training to
improve productivity
Farmer groups/
value chain/Finance
Training for
pre/postharvest
afla management
Awareness and
sensitizations
Policy and advocacy
Market linkages
Aflatoxin testing
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
21. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Parameters 2013/2014 2014/2015
Number of implementers 4 9
Total Aflasafe purchased (tons) 24 58.2
Number of farmers 1,015 3,271
Treated area (ha) 1,457 4,998
Maize aggregated for sale (tons) 2,031 7,220
Samples with <4 ppb AF (%) 99.0% 93%
Samples with <10 ppb AF (%) 99.5% 96%
samples with < 20 ppb AF (%) 99.5% 98%
Return on Investment (ROI) 210% 489%
Average sale price over market rate 13% 17%
Aflasafe maize kept for family 46% 20.3%
Aflasafe benefits Smallholder farmers
Smallholder farmers have safer crops, improved income and better health
Grain lots meet
international
standards
Higher income
Better health
22. www.iita.org
• Managed by the National
Irrigation Board (NIB)
• Highly productive area
but aflatoxin-prone
• Maize frequently
rejected as >50% strains
in soil are highly toxic
Maize grown under center pivot in Galana-
Kulaku, which is a part of 1 million acre Jubilee
Food Security project of the Kenyan Govt.
• 238 tons aflasafe
ordered (8.1 tons
airlifted for emergency
treatment) from IITA in
Nigeria
• The entire crop of 200 ha
treated with aflasafe
• Harvested grains had <4
ppb aflatoxins (meets
strict European limit) in
spite of delayed harvest
Aflasafe KE01 in the Aflasafe
factory in IITA-Nigeria ready
for shipment to Kenya
Maize crop being treated
with Aflasafe KE01 in Galana
Aflasafe helps Kenya food security project
23. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Scaling-Up and Models
• Nigeria: AgResults farmers to
produce 260,000 tons of
Aflasafe maize; Public-private
partnership model
• Senegal: Area-wide treatment
in 2013 and 2014 with 16 tons;
20 tons use projected in 2015;
private sector led model
• Kenya: Government buy-in;
about 230 tons procured;
excellent support; public model
• Africa-wide: >500K ha by 2018
• Critical role of PACA and RECs
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
Senegal
Kenya
24. www.iita.orgA member of CGIAR consortium
Current and future biocontrol efforts
• Full registration, licensing and stewardship
of product
• Create a sustainable system
(commercialization/public good) where
small holder farmers have access to
Aflasafe and are incentivized to utilize
Aflasafe to control aflatoxin levels
• Strategy development and implementation
for commercialization (manufacturing,
marketing and distribution)
• Advocacy, awareness, demonstration of
product value
• Training and technical back-stopping
• Develop second generation product
• Develop regional strains
Agriculture for Nutrition & Health
25. • Aflatoxins in food and feed pervasive
in Africa
• Contamination starts in the field
• Biological control with other
practices can dramatically reduce
aflatoxin contamination and improve
food safety and security
• Efforts underway to pilot
commercialization of aflatoxin
biocontrol and develop regional
strains
• The pilots need to be up-scaled and
efforts to improve efficacy needs a
fillip for wide-spread impact on
health and trade in Africa
Summary
26. Made Possible by Many National Partners in Ministries, Industry, and on the Farm
Nigeria
For more information about aflatoxin biocontrol for Africa, check out: www.aflasafe.com
IITA
Tucson
USDA/ARS
IITA, USDA, & Doreo have Teamed up to Bring
Aflatoxin Prevention to Africa
Hinweis der Redaktion
Results of efficacy trials on farmers’ fields in Senegal. Three years of data (two shown) and large numbers of farmers’ fields. Aflasafe is effective in reducing aflatoxin concentration in groundnuts in Senegal as in Nigeria.
Aflasafe is a biopesticide developed by IITA and USDA-ARS and registered by NAFDAC for aflatoxin mitigation in maize and groundnut in Nigeria. The demonstration-scale manufacturing aflasafe facility, funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation under the aegis of Partnership for Aflatoxin Control in Africa, was built in 2014 to supply aflasafe to farmers. This is the largest aflatoxin biocontrol product manufacturing plant and has the highest production throughput in the world. Nigerian farmers are purchasing aflasafe to treat their maize fields. Aflasafe (www.aflasafe.com) is packaged in 2.5 kg and 5 kg bags and available for sale at IITA’s Business Incubation Platform.
This slide is in Tabular format compared to pictorial in the previous two slides
An innovative scientific solution in the form of a natural biocontrol has been developed by the United States Department of Agriculture’s Agricultural Research Service (USDA-ARS). This breakthrough technology, already in wide use in the United States, reduces aflatoxins during both crop development and post-harvest storage, and throughout the value chain. Atoxigenic-strain-based biological control is a natural, non-toxic technology that utilizes the ability of native atoxigenic Aspergillus flavus to naturally out-compete their aflatoxin-producing cousins. The International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) and partners have successfully adapted this competitive displacement technology for use on maize and groundnut in various African countries using native micro-flora, developing biocontrol products called Aflasafe (www.aflasafe.com). Field testing of Aflasafe in Nigeria, Senegal, Burkina Faso and Kenya has produced extremely positive results in reducing aflatoxin contamination of maize and groundnut, consistently by 80% to 90%, and even as high as 99%.
Adapting and applying this proven biocontrol solution to address aflatoxin contamination in Africa could dramatically improve nutrition, health and livelihoods of millions of families while reducing commodity losses due to contamination. It is anticipated that this cost effective technology, which can be applied for about $18 per hectare (ha), once developed for the African context and commercialized, could be replicated and applied to other highly vulnerable areas, making the potential return on investment enormous.
IITA and USDA-ARS, together with national partners have already tested the technology with over 4,000 small holder farmers in Nigeria, Senegal, Burkina Faso, Kenya, and Zambia. Aflasafe products are under development for Ghana, Tanzania and Mozambique. At the same time, regional aflasafe products are also being developed for East, West and Southern Africa using atoxigenic strains that co-occur in all countries in a region. More than 60 tons aflasafe was manufactured using a lab-scale method and sold in Nigeria by IITA under the Provisional Registration from biopesticide regulator National Agency for Food and Drugs Administration and Control (NAFDAC). The method of production and application of atoxigenic strain based biocontrol products is fairly simple. A mixture of spores of biocontrol strains are coated on a grain carrier (e.g., sorghum), which also serves as a food source. The atoxigenic strains grow and multiply on and disperse from the carrier to initiate displacement of aflatoxin-producers in the field. Application timing differs with the crop and location. In some crops the product is applied 2-4 weeks prior to flowering. For small fields, the product can be tossed onto the 1 hectare of crop and soil by hand by four persons in 1 hour at an application rate of 10 kg/ha.
In the countries where aflasafe development is most advanced (Nigeria, Senegal, and Kenya), the farmers’ needs and demand for aflasafe far exceeds supply of the product produced using the lab-scale manufacturing method. Thus, lack of manufacturing capacity is a barrier preventing wide use of Aflasafe in target markets. There is an demonstration scale manufacturing facility that has just begun to produce Aflasafe at IITA in Ibadan. The new facility in IITA was built for demonstrating the production process of aflasafe to potential manufacturers as well as for producing sufficient quantity of Aflasafe to meet current demand from farmers and for experimental use to evaluate product efficacy in Africa. The Demonstration-scale Aflasafe manufacturing plant will be commissioned in November 2013 in the IITA campus in Ibadan. All the equipment in the plant is now operational and the manufacturing process has been tested successfully. The capacity of the plant is 5 tons per hour. The inoculum production and quality control labs are now functional. The strain multiplication method for aflasafe production has been successfully tested. The new strain multiplication method can produce 12.8 trillion spores in a 250 ml bottle containing 30 grams sorghum grain substrate; these spores are sufficient to produce 60 tons of aflasafe that can treat 6000 ha of crop.
The plant was used to produce the following amount of aflasafe:
1.5 tons of aflasafe BF01 for Burkina Faso for field efficacy trials
6 tons of aflasafe SN01 for field efficacy trials and market linkage research in Senegal in partnership with the private sector
12 tons of two aflasafe products (6 tons each of aflasafe ZM01 and aflasafe ZM02) for field efficacy trials and market linkage research in Zambia in partnership with the private sector
20 tons aflasafe for distribution to farmers by the AgResults initiative
1 ton of aflasafe KE01 will be produced for efficacy trials in Kenya in 2013
Private sector partners have expressed interest to manufacture aflasafe in in Nigeria, Senegal and Zambia.