FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
[論文紹介] Asgardアーキアのゲノムはアクチンを制御するプロフィリンをコードしている (Genomes of Asgard archaea encode profilins that regulate actin)
1. Asgardアーキアのゲノムは
アクチンを制御するプロフィリンをコードしている
2018.10.23
PMID: 30283132
M1 永田 祥平
LETTER https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-018-0548-6
Genomes of Asgard archaea encode profilins that
regulate actin
Caner Akıl1,2
& Robert C. Robinson1,2,3
*
The origin of the eukaryotic cell is unresolved1,2
. Metagenomics
sequencing has recently identified several potential eukaryotic gene
homologues in Asgard archaea3,4
, consistent with the hypothesis
that the eukaryotic cell evolved from within the Archaea domain.
However, many of these eukaryotic-like sequences are highly
divergent and the organisms have yet to be imaged or cultivated,
which brings into question the extent to which these archaeal
proteins represent functional equivalents of their eukaryotic
counterparts. Here we show that Asgard archaea encode functional
profilins and thereby establish that this archaeal superphylum has a
regulated actin cytoskeleton, one of the hallmarks of the eukaryotic
cell5
. Loki profilin-1, Loki profilin-2 and Odin profilin adopt the
typical profilin fold and are able to interact with rabbit actin—an
interaction that involves proteins from species that diverged more
than 1.2 billion years ago6
. Biochemical experiments reveal that
mammalian actin polymerizes in the presence of Asgard profilins;
however, Loki, Odin and Heimdall profilins impede pointed-end
elongation. These archaeal profilins also retard the spontaneous
nucleation of actin filaments, an effect that is reduced in the presence
of phospholipids. Asgard profilins do not interact with polyproline
motifs and the profilin–polyproline interaction therefore probably
evolved later in the Eukarya lineage. These results suggest that
Asgard archaea possess a primordial, polar, profilin-regulated
actin system, which may be localized to membranes owing to the
sensitivity of Asgard profilins to phospholipids. Because Asgard
archaea are also predicted to encode potential eukaryotic-like genes
involved in membrane-trafficking and endocytosis3,4
, imaging is
now necessary to elucidate whether these organisms are capable of
generating eukaryotic-like membrane dynamics that are regulated
by actin, such as are observed in eukaryotic cell movement,
podosomes and endocytosis.
Recently, metagenomics studies have identified genes from Asgard
archaea (Heimdall, Loki, Thor and Odin) that are homologous to
eukaryotic genes that encode machineries involved in membrane
ca d
Verrucosispora sediminis
Actinomadura sp.
Saccharopolyspora flava
Streptomyces avermitilis
Nocardia soli
1
/LC7/MgLB
4. 4
背景:生物の分類 -3ドメイン説とその終焉-
Williams T a, Foster PG, Cox CJ, Embley TM. An archaeal origin of eukaryotes supports only two primary domains of life. Nature. 2013;504(7479):231‒6.
ion now debatedis whethercorecomponents of the eukaryotic
eage descend from a common ancestor shared with Archaea,
ree-domains tree14
(Fig. 1), which is also often called the ‘uni-
or‘treeof life’15–17
,or from withintheArchaea,asproposed by
ost hypotheses for eukaryotic origins2
. The archaeal-host sce-
the greatest phylogenetic support is the eocyte hypothesis18
,
poses a sister-group relationship between eukaryotes and the
span of time, the accumulation of multiple substitutions in
protein sequences might have erased any signal that would
relationship between archaeal and eukaryotic core genes to
lished21
. However, more recent simulations and empirical s
gest that there are reasons to be cautiously optimistic that thi
case: functional constraints vary across real DNA and protein
so that sites evolve at different rates22–25
. Fast-evolving sites
ll and MolecularBiosciences, University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne NE2 4HH, UK. 2
Departmentof Life Sciences, Natural History Museum,London SW7 5BD, UK. 3
Cen
Euryarchaeota
Eocytes/Crenarchaeota
Eukaryota
Bacteria
Eocytes/Crenarchaeota
Paraphyletic Archaea
Three-domains hypothesis Eocyte hypothesis
Thaumarchaeota
Aigarchaeota
Korarchaeota
Euryarchaeota
Eocytes/Crenarchaeota
Eukaryota
Bacteria
Euryarchaeota
Eocytes/Crenarchaeota
Monophyletic Archaea
Thaumarchaeota
Aigarchaeota
Korarchaeota TACK TACK
a b
ompeting hypotheses for the origin of the eukaryotic host cell.
d three-domains tree14
depicts cellular life divided into three major
ic groups or domains: the Bacteria, Archaea and Eukaryota—the
enting the host lineage, sometimes also called the nuclear or
plasmic lineage5
, that acquired the mitochondrial endosymbiont.
he Archaea and Eukaryota are most closely related to each other
y share a common ancestor that is not shared with Bacteria.
ed eocyte tree recovers the host-cell lineage nested within the
Archaea as a sister group to the eocytes (which Woese et al.14
call
Crenarchaeota); this implies that, on the basis of the small set of c
there are only two primary domains of life—the Bacteria and the Ar
modern formulation shown here the eocyte hypothesis implies tha
relative of the eukaryotic nuclear lineage is one, or all, of the TAC
which include newly discovered relatives of the eocytes/Crenarcha
Both trees have been traditionally rooted on the bacterial stem, con
some published analyses5–8
.
アーキア
近年,真核生物はアーキアの1系統であると考えられるようになってきた。
➤ 3ドメイン仮説 ➤ エオサイト仮説 (2ドメイン)
→最新の手法で慎重に系統樹を構築した結果,真核生物はアーキアの系統内に入った。
5. 5
背景: 真核生物に最も近いアーキア の発見
➤ 真核生物の特徴を多く持つアーキア(ロキアー
キオータ)の発見 (2015年)
(上部) Spang A, Saw JH, Jørgensen SL, Zaremba-Niedzwiedzka K, Martijn J, Lind AE, et al. Complex archaea that bridge the gap between prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Nature. 2015;521(7551):173‒9.
(下部) Zaremba-Niedzwiedzka K, Caceres E, Saw J, Backstrom D, Juzokaite L, Vancaester E, et al. Asgard arcahea illuminates the origin of eukaryotic cellular complexity. Nat Publ Gr. Nature
Publishing Group; 2017;541(7637):353‒8.
ARTICLERESEARCH
a
0.1
Lokiarchaeum
sp. GC14_75
Odinarchaeote LCB_4
Heimdallarchaeote AB_125
Thorarchaeote
W
O
R_83
Heimdallarchaeote LC_3
ThorarchaeoteAB_25
Heimdallarchaeote LC_2
Thorarchaeote
W
OR_45
LokiarchaeoteCR_4
LC
LCB
CR
WOR
RP
AB, 0.25 m.b.s.f.
AB, 0.5 m.b.s.f.
AB, 1.25 m.b.s.f.
AB, 1.75 m.b.s.f.
b
c
0.3
Thorarchaeote WOR_83
Odinarchaeote LCB_4
Bathyarchaeota
Lokiarchaeum sp. GC14_75
Thorarchaeote AB_25
Korarchaeota
Aigarchaeota
Heimdallarchaeote LC_3
Heimdallarchaeote AB_125
Euryarchaeota
Odinarchaeote RP_19
Thaumarchaeota
Heimdallarchaeote LC_2
Lokiarchaeote CR_4
Crenarchaeota
91
74
100
100100
82
84
100
100
87
42
100
46
100
85
28
52
97
100
41
94
100
Eukarya
0.2
Heimdallarchaeote LC_2
Lokiarchaeum sp. GC14_75
Aigarchaeota
Heimdallarchaeote LC_3
Thorarchaeote WOR_45
Thaumarchaeota
Crenarchaeota
Odinarchaeote LCB_4
Eukarya
Korarchaeota
Thorarchaeote WOR_83
Lokiarchaeote CR_4
Heimdallarchaeote AB_125
Bathyarchaeota
Thorarchaeote AB_25
1
10.94
1
1
1
1
1
0.99
0.54
1
0.99
1
10.98
1
0.77
0.94
TACK
d
Lokiarchaeum sp. GC14_75
Lokiarchaeote CR_4
Odinarchaeote LCB_4
Thorarchaeote AB_25
Thorarchaeote WOR_45
Thorarchaeote WOR_83
Heimdallarchaeote AB_125
Heimdallarchaeote LC_2
Heimdallarchaeote LC_3
Information
processing
Cell division/
cytoskeleton
DNApolymerase,ε-like
TopoisomeraseIB
RNApolymerase,Afused
RNApolymerase,subunitG
(rpb8)
RibosomalproteinL22e
RibosomalproteinL28e/Mak16
Tubulins*
Actin-relatedprotein(ARP-like)
Conservedlokiactins
Gelsolin-domainproteinProfilin
Endosomal
sorting
Ubiquitin
system
Trafficking
machinery
Ost
complex
ARP2/3complex,subunit4-like
ESCRT-I:steadinessboxdomain
ESCRT-I:Vps28-like
ESCRT-II:Vps25-like
ESCRT-II:EAP30domain
ESCRT-III:Vps2/24/46-like
ESCRT-III:Vps20/32/60-like
Ubiquitin-domainprotein
Ubiquitin-activatingE1candidates
E2-likeubiquitinconjugatingprotein
ExpansionofsmallGTPases
Longin-domainprotein
EukaryoticRLC7familiyprotein
TRAPP-domainprotein
Sec23/24-likeprotein
WD40–Armadillogenecluster
Arrestin-domain
RibophorinI
OST3/OST6-like
STT3-like
Heimdallarchaeota
Lokiarchaeota
Odinarchaeota
Thorarchaeota
Figure 1 | Identification and phylogenomics of Asgard archaea.
a, Maximum-likelihood tree, inferred with RAxML and PROTCATLG
model, based on metagenomic contigs containing conserved ribosomal
proteins (see Methods) revealing the Asgard superphylum. Slow, non-
parametric maximum-likelihood bootstrap support values above 50 and
90 are indicated with empty and filled circles, respectively. Abbreviations
of the sites mentioned are as follows: LC, Loki’s Castle; CR, Colorado
River aquifer (USA); LCB, Lower Culex Basin (Yellowstone National Park,
sequences inferred with RAxML and GTRGAMMA model (c) showing
high support for the phylogenetic affiliation between Asgard archaea and
eukaryotes (support values in red). a–c, Scale bars indicate number of
substitutions per site. Numbers at branches refer to Bayesian posterior
probabilities (b) and slow non-parametric maximum-likelihood bootstrap
values (c). Trees were rooted with Euryarchaeota + DPANN (a, b) and
with Bacteria (c). Branch length value corresponding to cut branch in c is
➤ さらに近いアーキア群:Asgard上門の発見 (2017年)
数多くの「真核生物特異的」なタンパク質を保有
Asgardアーキア:
Ordin, Loki, Thor, Heimdall
真核生物→
メタゲノム配列ベースで,数多くの真核生物特異的な遺伝子を持つアーキア群が発見され
た。
10. 10
Asgardアクチンは真核アクチンと同様の機能・特性を持つと考えられる。
Extended Data Fig.1
Asgardアーキアはアクチンを保有する
ホモログ (相同) = 同一の祖先から進化したもの
nd are here referred to as the ‘Asgard actins’. b, Models of the Asgard
ctins. The Asgard actins were modelled using I-TASSER. The ‘C-score’
s a confidence score for estimating the quality of predicted models,
which is typically in the range of −5 to 2 and in which a high C-score
ignifies a model with a high confidence. Template modelling scores
TM-scores’) range between 0 and 1, and values greater than 0.5 indicate
models of the correct topology and a value of 1 indicates an exact match.
The TM-score and r.m.s.d. are estimated by linear regression, and the
stimated errors are the root-mean-squared TM-score or r.m.s. deviations.
➤ Asgardアクチンの構造モデリング
哺乳類 (真核生物)
アクチン
Asgardアクチン
① 真核アクチンと非常に類似した構造を取る
RMSD: 平均二乗偏差(Root Mean Square Deviation)
タンパク質構造の非類似性や誤りの指標
TM-score: モデル評価の指標.0.0-1.1の値を取り,1.1
は正解構造との肝炎一致を示す。
LETTERRESEARCH
Extended Data Fig. 1 | Asgard actins. a, Phylogenetic tree of the
polymerizing actin fold. This phylogenetic tree reveals that the variability
observed between the Asgard and eukaryotic actins is approximately
similar in magnitude to the variability found within bacterial MreBs
and lower than that observed within bacterial FtsAs or ParMs, which
indicates a probable conservation in function between the Asgard and
and are here referred to as the ‘Asgard actins’. b, Models of the Asgard
actins. The Asgard actins were modelled using I-TASSER. The ‘C-score’
is a confidence score for estimating the quality of predicted models,
which is typically in the range of −5 to 2 and in which a high C-score
signifies a model with a high confidence. Template modelling scores
(‘TM-scores’) range between 0 and 1, and values greater than 0.5 indicate
MreB: アクチンアナログ
桿状バクテリアの形状を制御
(球状のバクテリアにはない)
➤ Asgardアクチンと真核アクチン・他のアクチン
相同タンパク質との構造ベースの系統関係
ParM:
構造的にはアクチンに類似
FtsA: チューブリンホモログ
Asgardアクチン
真核生物アクチン
② Asgardアクチンは他の原核生物が持つア
クチン相同タンパク質と異なり,真核生物
アクチンと非常に近接した系統を形成する
真核アクチンと別系統を構成することから,真核のコンタミである可能性は低い
11. 11
プロフィリンとアクチンの各配列相同性一覧
Supplementary Table 1
Supplementary Table 1. Pairwise percentage sequence identities of actins and profilins. a,
Actins. From sequence identity LokiActin, OdinActin, ThorActin and HeimdallActin are referred to
a: アクチン b: プロフィリン
① Asgardアクチンはヒトアクチンと58-60%と
高い配列相同性を示す。
② Asgardプロフィリンとヒトプロフィリン
は11-17%の配列相同性しか示さない。
Asgardプロフィリンの特性・機能を調べる必要がある。
ヒト-Asgard間→
Asgardアクチンはヒトアクチンと非常に類似しているため機能的に同等と考えられるが, プロフィリンはあまり似てないため..
12. 12
Asgardメタゲノムはプロフィリンをコードする
ical profilin fold and are able to interact with rabbit actin—an
eraction that involves proteins from species that diverged more
n 1.2 billion years ago6
. Biochemical experiments reveal that
mmalian actin polymerizes in the presence of Asgard profilins;
wever, Loki, Odin and Heimdall profilins impede pointed-end
by actin, such as are observed in eukaryotic cell movement,
podosomes and endocytosis.
Recently, metagenomics studies have identified genes from Asgard
archaea (Heimdall, Loki, Thor and Odin) that are homologous to
eukaryotic genes that encode machineries involved in membrane
2
c
N
C
Loki
loop
Loki profilin-1
Human profilin
N
C
N
Loki profilin-2
from rabbit α-actin complex
Loki
loop
N
C
from rabbit α-actin complex
Odin profilin
f
N
C
b
a
77
99
82
83
99
83
84
61
69
100
e
N
C
Loki
loop
from rabbit α-actin complex
Loki profilin-1
d
Verrucosispora sediminis
Actinomadura sp.
Saccharopolyspora flava
Streptomyces avermitilis
Nocardia soli
Frankia sp.
Thermus Thermophilus
Candidatus Thorarchaeota 1
Candidatus Thorarchaeota 2
Zea mays
Arabidopsis thaliana
Dictyostelium discoideum
Monosiga brevicollis
Schizosaccharomyces pombe
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Neurospora crassa
Galdieria sulphuraria
Monodelphis domestica
Homo sapiens
Xenopus tropicalis
Danio rerio
Tetrahymena pyriformis
Paramecium tetraurelia
Noctiluca scintillans
Plasmodium falciparum
Toxoplasma gondii
Trepomonas sp.
Spironucleus salmonicida
Leishmania braziliensis
Trypanosoma brucei
Entamoeba histolytica
Porphyra umbilicalis
Strongylocentrotus purpuratus
Lottia gigantea
Thor profilin
Odin profilin
Heimdall profilin
Loki profilin-3
Loki profilin-1
Loki profilin-2
1
Roadblock/LC7/MgLBEukaryoticprofilins
Asgard
profilins
1 | Asgard metagenomes encode genuine profilins. a, Schematic
he structure of Loki profilin-1. The partially disordered extended
p (Loki loop) is indicated by a dotted line. N and C indicate the
pective termini. Data collection and refinement statistics are found
upplementary Table 2a. b, The structure of human profilin-1 for
mparison (RCSB Protein Data Bank (PDB) code: 1FIL). c, Profilin
logenetic tree of Asgard and eukaryotic profilins calculated from
structure-based sequence alignment using the Asgard profilin structures
in this figure. Protein sequences of the Roadblock/LC7/MgLB group
are used as an outgroup because their structures have similar topologies
to profilins. Sequence and PDB accession codes used in the alignment are
given in Supplementary Table 1b. d–f, Loki profilin-1 (d), Loki profilin-2 (e)
and Odin profilin (f) structures taken from the rabbit α-actin complex
structures. Details are found in Fig. 3.
• Asgardプロフィリンの構造を決定し真のプロフィリンであることを示した。
• 特徴的な構造 (Loki loop)の存在を確認した。
Fig.1
a: Asgardプロフィリン単体の立体構造
b: ヒトプロフィリン単体の立体構造
d,e,f: 哺乳類アクチン複合体構造のAsgardプロフィリン部分
typical profilin fold and are able to interact with rabbit actin—an
interaction that involves proteins from species that diverged more
than 1.2 billion years ago6
. Biochemical experiments reveal that
mammalian actin polymerizes in the presence of Asgard profilins;
however, Loki, Odin and Heimdall profilins impede pointed-end
by actin, such as are observed in eukaryotic cell movement,
podosomes and endocytosis.
Recently, metagenomics studies have identified genes from Asgard
archaea (Heimdall, Loki, Thor and Odin) that are homologous to
eukaryotic genes that encode machineries involved in membrane
c
N
C
Loki
loop
Loki profilin-1
Human profilin
N
C
N
Loki profilin-2
from rabbit α-actin complex
Loki
loop
N
C
from rabbit α-actin complex
Odin profilin
f
N
C
b
a
77
99
82
83
99
83
84
61
69
100
e
N
C
Loki
loop
from rabbit α-actin complex
Loki profilin-1
d
Verrucosispora sediminis
Actinomadura sp.
Saccharopolyspora flava
Streptomyces avermitilis
Nocardia soli
Frankia sp.
Thermus Thermophilus
Candidatus Thorarchaeota 1
Candidatus Thorarchaeota 2
Zea mays
Arabidopsis thaliana
Dictyostelium discoideum
Monosiga brevicollis
Schizosaccharomyces pombe
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Neurospora crassa
Galdieria sulphuraria
Monodelphis domestica
Homo sapiens
Xenopus tropicalis
Danio rerio
Tetrahymena pyriformis
Paramecium tetraurelia
Noctiluca scintillans
Plasmodium falciparum
Toxoplasma gondii
Trepomonas sp.
Spironucleus salmonicida
Leishmania braziliensis
Trypanosoma brucei
Entamoeba histolytica
Porphyra umbilicalis
Strongylocentrotus purpuratus
Lottia gigantea
Thor profilin
Odin profilin
Heimdall profilin
Loki profilin-3
Loki profilin-1
Loki profilin-2
1
Roadblock/LC7/MgLBEukaryoticprofilins
Asgard
profilins
Fig. 1 | Asgard metagenomes encode genuine profilins. a, Schematic
of the structure of Loki profilin-1. The partially disordered extended
loop (Loki loop) is indicated by a dotted line. N and C indicate the
respective termini. Data collection and refinement statistics are found
in Supplementary Table 2a. b, The structure of human profilin-1 for
comparison (RCSB Protein Data Bank (PDB) code: 1FIL). c, Profilin
phylogenetic tree of Asgard and eukaryotic profilins calculated from
structure-based sequence alignment using the Asgard profilin structures
in this figure. Protein sequences of the Roadblock/LC7/MgLB group
are used as an outgroup because their structures have similar topologies
to profilins. Sequence and PDB accession codes used in the alignment are
given in Supplementary Table 1b. d–f, Loki profilin-1 (d), Loki profilin-2 (e)
and Odin profilin (f) structures taken from the rabbit α-actin complex
structures. Details are found in Fig. 3.
➤ Asgardプロフィリンとヒトプロフィリンの立体構造 ➤ Asgardプロフィリンの系統関係
→外群
真核生物の
プロフィリン
Asgard
プロフィリン
Asgardプロフィリンは真核プロフィリンと
関連しつつも独立した系統を構成する。
部分的に乱れたループ
13. 13
Asgardプロフィリンは哺乳類アクチンの重合を制御する
LETTERRESEARCH
Odin profilin
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Heimdall profilin
Human profilin
versus Odin profilin
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Actin (2 μM)
8 μM
16 μM
32 μM
64 μM
128 μM
Thor profilin
0 10,000 20,000
JYIM01000447
JYIM01000257
Found in archaea Only bacteria Loki profilins Only Asgard Only eukaryotes
8792949487909192919294748292928891919074878596
Loki profilin-3
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
a b c d
e f g h
i
Human profilin Loki profilin-1
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Loki profilin-2
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Thorprofilin
Fig. 2 | Asgard profilins modulate polymerization of mammalian actin
in vitro. a, Pyrene–actin polymerization profiles of 2 µM rabbit α-actin
profilin. Thor profilin was not observed to have profilin activity and is not
included in subsequent discussions of Asgard profilins. h, Comparison of
Asgardプロフィリンは哺乳類アクチンを調節する上で機能的であることを示した。
→Asgardアーキアにはプロフィリン制御のアクチン系が存在することを示唆。
→Thorはプロフィリン活性なしと判断
Fig.2 手法:ピレン-アクチン重合アッセイ
アクチン重合反応に取り込まれると蛍光の増強が起こるピレン標識アクチンを用いて,アクチンの重合/脱重合反応を蛍光で測定
ヒトとOdinのプロフィン性能比較
実線: ヒト,紫: Odin プロフィン
ヒトプロフィリン8倍投入して同程度の性能
縦軸:
↑アクチンが重合
↓プロフィンによって重合が制御 (抑制)されている
ゲルゾリン (gelsolin): アクチン繊維を切断し,その末端に
留まることでその後のアクチン重合を阻害 (キャップ)する。
※ゲルソリン-アクチンは片側 (P端)からしか重合できない。線: ウサギαアクチンのみ
線: ウサギαアクチン + ⃝⃝プロフィリン
a-f:
赤: アクチンのみで重合開始
青: 非蛍光アクチンシード存在下で重合開始
黒: ゲルゾリン結合状態の非蛍光アクチンシード存在下で重合開始
d, e: OrdinとHeimdallプロフィリンはゲルゾリン-アクチン
のP端からの伸長を防ぐ能力が弱い。
14. 14
Loki profilin遺伝子とその周辺領域
maintenance and function, including trafficking, N-glycosylation,
ribosomes, endosomal sorting complexes required for transport, the
ubiquitination system, and cytoskeletal processes that include actin and
eukaryotic profilins (7–24%) (Supplementary Table 1b). T
questions about their authenticity. To address this issue,
explored the properties of Asgard profilin-like proteins.
Odin profilin
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Human profi
versus Odin pr
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Actin (2 μM)
8 μM
16 μM
32 μM
64 μM
128 μM
Thor profilin
0 10,000 20,000
JYIM01000447
JYIM01000257
Found in archaea Only bacteria Loki profilins Only Asgard Only eukaryotes
8792949487909192919294748292928891919074878596
Loki profilin-3
0 50 100 150
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
e f g h
i
0 50 100 150 200 250
Time (min)
0 50 100 150
Time (min)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
Time (min)
0 50 100 150 200 250
Time (min)
Thorprofilin
Fig. 2 | Asgard profilins modulate polymerization of mammalian actin
in vitro. a, Pyrene–actin polymerization profiles of 2 µM rabbit α-actin
(dashes, 10% pyrene–actin) or 2 µM rabbit α-actin with 128 µM human
profilin-1 (dots) either initiated alone (red), initiated in the presence of
0.3 µM non-fluorescent actin seeds (blue), or initiated in the presence
of 0.3 µM non-fluorescent gelsolin-capped actin seeds (black).
b–f, Polymerization profiles as in a, using the specified Asgard profilin
at 256 µM (instead of 128 µM human profilin-1). Loki profilin-3 and, to
a lesser extent, Loki profilin-1 showed a marked increase in fluorescence
on mixing with pyrene–actin; however, their profiles appear to be typical
for Asgard profilins, albeit superimposed upon the initial increases. The
basis of the increase is unknown, but we speculate that it may be due to
oligomer formation. Titrations and expansions of the lag phase regions
are in Extended Data Figs. 2, 3. g, Pyrene–actin polymerization profiles
of 2 µM rabbit α-actin titrated with increasing concentrations of Thor
profilin. Thor profilin was not observed to have profilin activity
included in subsequent discussions of Asgard profilins. h, Com
the inhibition of actin nucleation in the pyrene–actin assay reve
human profilin-1 (solid lines; red 2 µM, green 4 µM, orange 32
approximately eightfold more potent than Odin profilin (purple
16 µM, dots 64 µM, dots-and-dashes 256 µM). Actin control (2
shown as a solid black line. Comparisons for other Asgard profi
shown in Extended Data Fig. 3b. i, Schematic alignment of the p
contigs that contain the Loki profilin-1 and Loki profilin-2 gene
Lines connect homologous genes, with nucleotide percentage id
indicated below (Supplementary Table 3b). Genes with homolo
previously found in archaea are coloured blue, and genes curren
to Asgard archaea are coloured red. Genes with homologues tha
been found to date in bacteria or eukaryotes are coloured black
respectively. The Loki profilins are in green. AU, arbitrary units
Fig.2
Loki profilin-1のcontig→
Loki profilin-2のcontig→
Lokiプロフィリン遺伝子 (緑色)とその遺伝子周辺領域含めて全体的に相同性が認められる。
→ Loki profilin-1, 2は2つの異なるLokiアーキア系統であり,真核生物のコンタミではないことを確認。
15. 15
Asgardプロフィリンと哺乳類アクチン複合体の共結晶構造
LETTER RESEARCH
of Loki profilin-1 on the two ends of actin filaments. Low concentra-
tions of human profilin-1 or Loki profilin-1 did not slow elongation at
the barbed ends (Extended Data Figs. 2, 3). Higher concentrations of
human profilin-1 and Loki profilin-1 showed small decreases in elon-
gation rates (Fig. 2a, b), consistent with dynamic barbed end binding by
profilin10
, but at least tenfold more archaeal profilin than human pro-
filin was required to achieve similar effects (Extended Data Figs. 2, 3).
Gelsolin–actin seeds grow only at the pointed ends. As with lower
concentrations of human profilin-1, high concentrations of Loki
profilin-1 partially inhibited the elongation of pointed ends (Fig. 2a, b).
Spontaneous polymerization of actin monomers depends on a slow,
rate-limiting nucleation step. Loki profilin-1 slowed the time course
of actin polymerization, but required concentrations that were more
than 30 times higher than those required when using human profilin-1
(Fig. 2a, b). Because barbed ends elongate under these conditions, this
experiment demonstrates that high concentrations of Loki profilin-1
inhibit spontaneous nucleation; presumably, the higher concentrations
of Loki profilin-1 that are required are due to its low affinity for rabbit
α-actin. These data suggest that, despite the divergence between
Lokiarchaeota and eukaryotes, Loki profilin-1 is partially functional
in regulating mammalian actin in vitro, which in turn indicates a
profilin-regulated actin system in these archaea.
To demonstrate that the Loki profilin-1 activity is not an isolated case
that may be due to eukaryotic contamination in the metagenomes, we
produced five other potential Asgard profilins for the in vitro assays
(Extended Data Fig. 3c). Loki profilin-2 shares 87% and 91% identity
with Loki profilin-1 at amino acid and nucleotide levels, respectively.
Comparison of their parent contigs reveals global homology and a high
percentage of typical archaeal genes (Fig. 2i). Thus, Loki profilin-1
and Loki profilin-2 appear to come from two related strains of
Lokiarchaeota.Lokiprofilin-2displayedsimilaractivitytoLokiprofilin-1
in the polymerization assay (Fig. 2c). Heimdall profilin showed a lesser,
but measurable, ability to inhibit spontaneous actin nucleation (Fig. 2d),
whereas Odin profilin (Fig. 2e) and Loki profilin-3 (Fig. 2f) showed
higher activity relative to Loki profilin-1. The presence of the Loki
loop in Loki profilin-1 and Loki profilin-2, but not in Loki profilin-3,
indicates possible functional divergence (Extended Data Fig. 5a).
Thor profilin displayed no measurable ability to inhibit actin nuclea-
a
b
c
Loki
profilin-1
Loki
profilin-2
Loki
loop
Loki
loop
Actin
1 1
2
2
3
4
3
4
C
N
C
N
Odin
profilin
24
C
N
d
180
LETTER RESEARCH
of Loki profilin-1 on the two ends of actin filaments. Low concentra-
tions of human profilin-1 or Loki profilin-1 did not slow elongation at
the barbed ends (Extended Data Figs. 2, 3). Higher concentrations of
human profilin-1 and Loki profilin-1 showed small decreases in elon-
gation rates (Fig. 2a, b), consistent with dynamic barbed end binding by
profilin10
, but at least tenfold more archaeal profilin than human pro-
filin was required to achieve similar effects (Extended Data Figs. 2, 3).
Gelsolin–actin seeds grow only at the pointed ends. As with lower
concentrations of human profilin-1, high concentrations of Loki
profilin-1 partially inhibited the elongation of pointed ends (Fig. 2a, b).
Spontaneous polymerization of actin monomers depends on a slow,
rate-limiting nucleation step. Loki profilin-1 slowed the time course
of actin polymerization, but required concentrations that were more
than 30 times higher than those required when using human profilin-1
(Fig. 2a, b). Because barbed ends elongate under these conditions, this
experiment demonstrates that high concentrations of Loki profilin-1
inhibit spontaneous nucleation; presumably, the higher concentrations
of Loki profilin-1 that are required are due to its low affinity for rabbit
α-actin. These data suggest that, despite the divergence between
Lokiarchaeota and eukaryotes, Loki profilin-1 is partially functional
in regulating mammalian actin in vitro, which in turn indicates a
profilin-regulated actin system in these archaea.
To demonstrate that the Loki profilin-1 activity is not an isolated case
that may be due to eukaryotic contamination in the metagenomes, we
produced five other potential Asgard profilins for the in vitro assays
(Extended Data Fig. 3c). Loki profilin-2 shares 87% and 91% identity
with Loki profilin-1 at amino acid and nucleotide levels, respectively.
Comparison of their parent contigs reveals global homology and a high
percentage of typical archaeal genes (Fig. 2i). Thus, Loki profilin-1
and Loki profilin-2 appear to come from two related strains of
Lokiarchaeota.Lokiprofilin-2displayedsimilaractivitytoLokiprofilin-1
in the polymerization assay (Fig. 2c). Heimdall profilin showed a lesser,
but measurable, ability to inhibit spontaneous actin nucleation (Fig. 2d),
whereas Odin profilin (Fig. 2e) and Loki profilin-3 (Fig. 2f) showed
higher activity relative to Loki profilin-1. The presence of the Loki
loop in Loki profilin-1 and Loki profilin-2, but not in Loki profilin-3,
indicates possible functional divergence (Extended Data Fig. 5a).
Thor profilin displayed no measurable ability to inhibit actin nuclea-
tion (Fig. 2g). Odin profilin was approximately eightfold less potent in
inhibiting spontaneous actin nucleation, relative to human profilin-1
(Fig. 2h). Odin profilin and Heimdall profilin showed very weak abili-
ties to prevent pointed-end elongation in the gelsolin–actin seed assay.
These data demonstrate that actin-regulating profilins are present in
a
b
c
Loki
profilin-1
Loki
profilin-2
Loki
loop
Loki
loop
Actin
1 1
2
2
3
4
3
4
C
N
C
N
Odin
profilin
Actin
2
24
4
C
N
d
180
Fig.3
Asgardアーキアと真核生物が共通のプロフィリン-アクチン相互作用様式を持つことを示し
た。
➤ Lokiプロフィリン-1
地熱環境に生息Odinのプロフィリンは最もコンパクトな構造を取る
filin was requ
Gelsolin–ac
concentrati
profilin-1 pa
Spontaneou
rate-limiting
of actin poly
than 30 time
(Fig. 2a, b). B
experiment
inhibit spont
of Loki profi
α-actin. Th
Lokiarchaeo
in regulatin
profilin-regu
To demon
that may be d
produced fiv
(Extended D
with Loki pr
Comparison
percentage o
and Loki pr
Lokiarchaeot
in the polym
but measurab
whereas Od
higher activ
loop in Loki
indicates po
Thor profilin
tion (Fig. 2g)
inhibiting sp
(Fig. 2h). Od
ties to preven
These data d
three branch
collected from
(Loki and He
Tobetteru
determined t
and Odin pr
and Loki pro
a similar ori
b
c
Loki
profilin-1
Loki
profilin-2
Loki
loop
Loki
loop
1 1
3
3
C
N
C
N
Human
profilin
Odin
profilin
Actin
1 1
2
2
3
4
3
4
C
N
C
N
d
Fig. 3 | The structures of the Loki profilin-1, Loki profilin-2 and
Odin profilin complexes with rabbit α-actin. a, Back and front views
of the structure of the Loki profilin-1–rabbit α-actin complex. Rabbit
α-actin is shown as a surface and Loki profilin-1 is shown in schematic
concentrati
profilin-1 pa
Spontaneou
rate-limiting
of actin poly
than 30 time
(Fig. 2a, b). B
experiment
inhibit spont
of Loki profi
α-actin. Th
Lokiarchaeo
in regulatin
profilin-regu
To demon
that may be d
produced fiv
(Extended D
with Loki pr
Comparison
percentage o
and Loki pr
Lokiarchaeot
in the polym
but measurab
whereas Od
higher activ
loop in Loki
indicates po
Thor profilin
tion (Fig. 2g)
inhibiting sp
(Fig. 2h). Od
ties to preven
These data d
three branch
collected from
(Loki and He
Tobetteru
determined t
and Odin pr
and Loki pro
a similar ori
(Fig. 1b, d, e,
Loki profilin
(Extended D
b
c
Loki
profilin-1
Loki
profilin-2
Loki
loop
Loki
loop
1 1
3
3
C
N
C
N
Human
profilin
Odin
profilin
Actin
1 1
2
2
3
4
3
4
C
N
C
N
d
Fig. 3 | The structures of the Loki profilin-1, Loki profilin-2 and
Odin profilin complexes with rabbit α-actin. a, Back and front views
of the structure of the Loki profilin-1–rabbit α-actin complex. Rabbit
α-actin is shown as a surface and Loki profilin-1 is shown in schematic
representation. b, The Loki profilin-2–rabbit α-actin complex. c, The
Odin profilin–rabbit α-actin complex. d, Structure of the published
➤ Lokiプロフィリン-2
➤ ヒトプロフィリン-1➤ Odinプロフィリン
ウサギαアクチン →
数字はサブドメインを示す
(比較用)
・LokiプロフィリンのC末端ヘリックスは,ヒトプロフィリン-1と比較して,アクチンサブドメイン1上の結合部位からわずかにずれる。
・Lokiループはアクチンとの結合で整列し,アクチンサブドメイン3の表面に近接して存在する。
16. 16
Asgardプロフィリンと真核プロフィリンの差異
LETTERRESEARCH
20
40
60
80
orescence(AU)
20
40
60
80
orescence(AU)
20
40
60
80orescence(AU)
20
40
60
80
orescence(AU)
K69
K90
K71 K58
K60
K71
K60
i j k l
e f g h
Asn9
Tyr6
Human profilin
Trp3
Trp31
Tyr139
His133
Leu134
N Polyproline
N-helix
C-helix
C
Ile32
Ile5
Ile8
Asp11
Lys129
Leu130
Leu133
N-helix
Loki profilin-1
C-helix
a b c d
Val32
Ile5
Ile8
Asp11
Lys129
Leu130
Leu133
N-helix
Loki profilin-2
C-helix
Ile28
Leu3
Leu6
Arg9
Gln114
Leu115
Ile118
N-helix
Odin profilin
C-helix
Fig.4
芳香族アミノ酸:フェニルアラニン (Phe),トリプトファン (Trp),ヒスチジン (His),チロシン (Tyr),etc.
➤ プロフィリン上のポリプロリン結合領域
真核生物のプロフィリンは,プロフィリンのN末端およびC末端ヘリックスの間にある芳香族残基との相互作用により,
ポリプロリンモチーフに結合することによって,アクチンフィラメント核形成および伸長機械に組み込まれる。
Asgardプロフィリンには芳香族残基によるポリプロリン結合溝が存在しない。
→Asgardメタゲノムには真核生物様のポリプロリンリッチなアクチン核形成また
は伸長タンパク質の遺伝子が存在せず,一致する結果。
→プロフィリン‒ポリプロリン間の相互作用は,真核生物ドメイン系統で後に進化したのでは。
AsgardプロフィリンがAsgardメタゲノムに由来し,真核生物のコンタミではないことを裏付け
る。
17. 17
Asgardプロフィリンと真核プロフィリンの差異
LETTERRESEARCH
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
0 50 100 150 200 250
0
20
40
60
80
Time (min)
Fluorescence(AU)
Actin (2 μM)
hP (10 μM)
PIP2 (20 μM)
PIP2 (40 μM)
PIP2 (160 μM)
K69
K90
K71 K58
K60
K71
K60
i j k l
e f g h
Actin (2 μM)
LokiP1 (50 μM)
PIP2 (50 μM)
PIP2 (100 μM)
PIP2 (200 μM)
Actin (2 μM)
LokiP2 (50 μM)
PIP2 (50 μM)
PIP2 (100 μM)
PIP2 (200 μM)
Actin (2 μM)
OdinP (50 μM)
PIP2 (50 μM)
PIP2 (100 μM)
PIP2 (200 μM)
Asn9
Tyr6
Human profilin
Trp3
Trp31
Tyr139
His133
Leu134
N Polyproline
N-helix
C-helix
C
Ile32
Ile5
Ile8
Asp11
Lys129
Leu130
Leu133
N-helix
Loki profilin-1
C-helix
a b c d
Val32
Ile5
Ile8
Asp11
Lys129
Leu130
Leu133
N-helix
Loki profilin-2
C-helix
Ile28
Leu3
Leu6
Arg9
Gln114
Leu115
Ile118
N-helix
Odin profilin
C-helix
Fig. 4 | Asgard profilins do not bind to polyproline motifs but are
sensitive to phospholipids. a, The polyproline-binding site on human
profilin-1 (PDB code: 2PAV)12
. The polyproline ligand is shown in
black, with the respective termini labelled as N or C, and the residues on
human profilin-1 that interact with the polyproline motif are labelled
in blue. b–d, Equivalent residues to those shown in a, from the Loki
profilin-1 (b), Loki profilin-2 (c) and Odin profilin (d) structures. In the
structures of Asgard profilins, the N- and C-terminal helices are tightly
in e, for structures of Loki profilin-1 (f), Loki profilin-2 (g) and Odin
profilin (h) complexes with actin, with the basic residues indicated. Views
rotated by 180° are shown in Extended Data Fig. 7a. i, Pyrene–actin
polymerization profiles of rabbit α-actin (2 µM, orange) supplemented
with human profilin-1 (hP, 10 µM, pink) and subsequently with increasing
concentrations of PtdIns-(4,5)-P2(1,2-dipalmitoyl) (blue), a soluble
version of PIP2. j–l, Similar polymerization profiles to those shown in i, for
Loki profilin-1 (LokiP1, j), Loki profilin-2 (LokiP2, k) and Odin profilin
Fig.4
ホスファチジルイノシトール-4,5-ビホスフェート (PtdIns (4,5) P2 ; PIP2):真核細胞膜でアクチンを調節するための
機能性リン脂質
e-f: タンパク質の電荷分析. 青: 正電荷,赤: 負電荷
➤ ヒトプロフィリン ➤ Lokiプロフィリン-1 ➤ Lokiプロフィリン-2 ➤ Odinプロフィリン-1
塩基性残基
i-l: PIP2とプロフィリンのアクチン重合阻害能との関連
Asgardプロフィリンとアクチンの相互作用もリン脂質によって制御される。
→ 膜に局在している可能性を示唆。
PIP2はAsgardプロフィリンと弱く相互作用し,プロフィリンによるアクチン重合阻害を抑制する
18. 18
総括
まとめ/掲載理由
本論文では,これまで配列レベルでしか存在が予測されていなかったAsgardアーキアプロ
フィリンが実際に真核生物プロフィリンと酷似した立体構造を取ることを明らかにし,真
核生物のアクチンと相互作用して重合を制御することを示した。
これらは真核生物が持つ細胞骨格系の原型と考えられ,真核生物がアーキアから進化した
ことを強く裏付けた。
感想
• 構造決定タンパク質選定の目の付け所が良い。
• Asgardアーキアのアクチンの立体構造・相互作用はどうなっているのか。
• 核の起源についても気になるところではある。
organisms — an archaeal host cell1–3
and a
bacterium from which eukaryotic organelles
called mitochondria emerged4
. Some insights
into the biological properties of the host have
come from the closest known archaeal rela-
tives of eukaryotes, the Asgard superphylum5,6
.
The genomes of organisms belonging to this
archaeal group encode a suite of proteins
typically involved in functions or processes
thought to be eukaryote-specific. The func-
tions of these ‘eukaryotic genes’ in Asgard
archaea have been elusive, but in a paper in
Nature, Akıl and Robinson7
provide evidence
that some of them encode proteins that are
structurally and functionally similar to their
eukaryotic counterparts.
Apart from their nucleus and energy-
producing mitochondria, eukaryotic cells
are characterized by a complex internal sys-
tem of membrane-bound compartments (the
endomembrane system), and by a dynamic
network of proteins such as actin, called the
cytoskeleton. The latter gives the cells their
shape and structure, but is also involved in a
variety of cellular processes specific to eukary-
otes8
. These features are thought to have been
present in the last common ancestor of all
eukaryotes, which lived about 1.8 billion years
ago9
, but no life forms have been found that
represent an intermediate between eukaryotes
and their bacterial and archaeal ancestors.
The seemingly sudden emergence of cellu-
lar complexity in the eukaryotic lineage is a
conundrum for evolutionary biologists.
Several of the proteins produced by Asgard
archaea are evolutionarily related to proteins
that in eukaryotes modulate complex cellular
processes5,6
. The identification of these pro-
teins raised the question of whether Asgard
archaea have some primitive versions of
certain eukaryotic properties. If they do, it
would suggest that the last archaeal ancestor
of eukaryotes already displayed a certain —
albeit probably limited — degree of cellular
ota and Heimdallarchaeota)5,6
is based solely
on metagenomics analyses. The cells have yet
to be observed under a microscope, and have
not been cultured in vitro. Nevertheless, Akıl
and Robinson were determined to gain insight
into the properties of Asgard proteins related
totheeukaryoticproteinsactinandprofilin.In
eukaryotes, profilin regulates the polymeriza-
tion of actin into filaments of the cytoskeleton.
These filaments have pivotal roles in processes
that include vesicle and organelle movement,
cell-shape formation and phagocytosis8
, in
whichcellsingestforeignparticlesorothercells.
To produce Asgard profilins, Akıl and
Robinson expressed these proteins in the bac-
terium Escherichia coli using a circular DNA
Asgardprofilinscouldinteractwitheukaryotic
actins. Remarkably, despite being separated by
2 billion to 3 billion years of evolution9
, several
of the Asgard profilins bound to mammalian
actinandregulateditspolymerizationkinetics.
Asgard and mammalian profilins seem to have
similar effects on mammalian actin, although
the Asgard proteins act less efficiently. These
results suggest that Asgard archaea harbour a
profilin-regulated actin cytoskeleton — a cel-
lular feature generally regarded as a defining
characteristic of eukaryotic cells (Fig. 1).
The inference of a primitive dynamic actin
cytoskeleton in Asgard archaea sheds light
on the biological properties of the ancestor
of eukaryotes. In eukaryotic cells, the energy
Figure 1 | Cellular complexity along the tree of life. The Eukarya (organisms whose cells harbour
DNA in a nucleus) are thought to have arisen from a merger between their last archaeal ancestor and a
bacterium. In addition to a nucleus, eukaryotes have several characteristics that are thought to separate
them from archaea, including: a complex internal system of membranes called endomembranes; a
structural feature called the actin cytoskeleton, the dynamics of which are regulated by the protein
profilin; and energy-producing organelles called mitochondria, which arose from the bacterial partner.
But Akıl and Robinson7
provide evidence that members of the Asgard superphylum — an extant group of
archaea thought to be related to eukaryotes — harbour a primitive profilin-regulated actin cytoskeleton.
If the last archaeal ancestor of eukaryotes had this feature, it might have enabled the cell to wrap around its
presumed bacterial partner. In addition, it is possible that Asgard archaea and the last archaeal ancestor of
eukaryotes carry primitive endomembrane systems. (Cells and cellular features are not drawn to scale.)
Bacterial
partner
Eukarya
Last archaeal ancestor
of eukaryotes
Asgard
archaea
Other
archaea
Mitochondrion
Nucleus
Actin
cytoskeleton
Primitive
endomembrane
system
Primitive actin
cytoskeleton
DNA
Cytoskeleton-
mediated interaction?
Profilin
Endomembrane
system
Eme L, Ettema TJG. The eukaryotic ancestor shapes up. Nature. 2018;562(7727):352‒3.
19. 19
Fig. 1補足データ
Extended Data Fig. 2
Appendix
LETTER RESEARCH
Extended Data Fig. 2 | Titration data. Titration data for the polymerization profiles that are shown in Fig. 2a–f.