The document discusses the role of school social workers in linking research, theory, and practice to support students. It outlines objectives to explore how social workers can epitomize their work with students through this link, and ways to enhance engagement between student services and academics. The document then provides background on the presenter's work implementing a brief, solution-focused reentry model using qualitative research with social work students. Outcomes showed that around 50% of students did not reenter the juvenile justice system.
2. The precept of social work in schools is that the
service and classroom curricula are equal in
importance
The demands that are placed on School Social
Workers requires a shift in thinking and a closer
link between research and intervention.
There is a tension that exist within social work in
the relationship between theory and practice
To be an effective practitioner it is important for
you to have a sound theoretical base
3. Objectives:
1. Explore How School Social Workers can
epitomize their work with students to link
Research, Theory & Practice
2. Up scaling of School Social Workers supporting a
strong relationship with Academia and Student
Service Personnel and the balancing of power
between the two entities
3. Ways to enhance engagement and connection
between the Student Services and Academia
4. Workshop Objectives:
• Effective re-entry practices are critical to curtailing high
rates of juvenile recidivism and providing youths with
the services and support needed to promote successful
re-integration into the community.
• The intervention that will be presented has a dual
purpose - One to support the youths in realizing that
their current situation is just a pause, a break; and
engaging them in activities that will place them back on
the steps that will lead them to their plan for their life.
• The other purpose is to help Social Workers in schools
in their roles as they provide support to students
5. BACKGROUND
Opportunities to engage in small scale qualitative
research
As the School Social Worker hired by MDCPS to
support the students who are receiving their
education through Dept. of Juvenile Justice, I
developed and implemented Re-entry procedures
using Brief Solution Focus Therapy based on
Theory of Hope
Social Work Students used theory and evidence
based intervention in their practice and also
engaged in the process of research
6. BACKGROUND
The Research
Changing Lives Through H.O.P.E; The implication for
Solution Oriented work with Adolescents involved with
Juvenile Justice.
I begin with the assumption that human actions are goal
directed; and goals are the targets of mental actions; in
order to reach their goals, people must view themselves as
being capable of generating workable routes to those
goals
I hypothesize; If Hope is such a critical element of every
successful person, as evidenced in President Obama’s
book “The Audacity of Hope: Thoughts on Reclaiming the
American Dream”. The empowerment of youths in
identifying a goal and envisioning a future is critical to
them becoming successful individuals.
7. My working thesis is that HOPE four letters; when
said individually means nothing but strung
together form one of the most powerful word in
the work of a School Social Worker re-entering
students into the education community.
I engage in solution oriented, forward looking
youth centered approach when working with the
students.
The goal of the research was to develop an
educational counseling transition/re-entry model
of intervention through the youth identified
vocational/ educational future focused goal
8. Model of Implementation:-
Train Social Work Masters level students
during their internship in the use of Brief
Solution Focused Therapy
Model the use of Brief Solution Focused
therapy for students
Train students on the use of the Solution
Focus Transition/Re-entry Questionnaire as a
guide during their sessions with youths
Circular strength based youth centered
responsive questioning techniques
9. Model of Implementation:
Research is an integral part of being a social
worker
Create an environment that supports the
development of Social Scientists
Opportunities to engage in small scale qualitative
research
Build Student’s confidence as evidence based
practitioners; thinking of an answerable question
they can research
Provide opportunities for students to read and
review research articles, focusing on the research
quality and methodology
10. BACKGROUND INFORMATION/JUSTIFICATION
Youth Violence is a source of concern for Public
Health
The education of our youths contributes to the
decline in the homicide rate
Effective re-entry practices are critical to curtailing
high rates of juvenile recidivism
Research indicates that most youth who re-offend
do so within nine months of release from a Juvenile
justice program, therefore making successful re-
entry practices a critical component of success.
11. BACKGROUND INFORMATION/JUSTIFICATION
Blomberg, T.G., Bales, W.E. & Piquero A.R (2011)
research examined how educational achievement
and attendance contributes to recidivism across
race and sex of Florida students released from
juvenile justice commitment programs one year
post release
Students with high educational achievement were
less likely to reoffend, hence having a lowering
recidivism rate.
12. BACKGROUND INFORMATION/JUSTIFICATION
The Labelling theory focuses on the triggering
effects that labels may have as they serve to
exclude individuals from certain activities. Labels
serve as social control; labelled offenders have
fewer options to conventional life, which can lead
to weak social bonds.
Educational attainment as a positive label leads to
career attainment.
Education gap exist between black and white
students. White male students are more likely to
be labelled gifted and black male students labelled
mentally retarded
13. BACKGROUND INFORMATION/JUSTIFICATION
The use of labels contributes to the outcome of
educational attainment.
Effective intervention is needed to redirect the path
of students’ lives; turning points are needed
towards more adaptive paths.
Research also shows a correlation between school
attendance and re-arrests
Students with higher absences from school leads to
higher arrests upon release.
14. As a Social Worker; Hope is critical to the success
of my role in providing the young people I serve
with a glimpse into the possibilities of them being
a part of the American dream once they Exit the
Programs with support that means no return.
Successful outcome is measured by completion of
Secondary Education, post secondary training,
college/vocational education and shift in
thinking; begin to think about career goals
15. H.O.P.E. four letters; when said individually
means nothing but strung together form one of
the most powerful word in the work of a Social
Worker. Hope springs vision of a future. Young
people need to know that there is a future for
them; a future that is their vision their preferred
future; not one that is designed by adults, but
one where they have a voice. Young people who
have experienced any period of incarceration
need to know that they are valued and have a
future.
16. H – HELP PROVIDED
O – OPPORTUNITIES TO INSPIRE/SHARE
P – PASSION PROJECTING TOWARDS THE
FUTURE
E – ENGAGING EXIT WITH NO RETURN
17. The goal of this intervention is to support young
people on a journey that is solution oriented and
directed by them; they have an active voice in
how their story is told and ends. Supporting
students in realizing their future perfect, and
realize that nothing lies beyond their reach
Youths without the vision of a future have a
harder time in life; they have no positive
motivation, no sense of purpose, and no hope of
being any different than they currently are.
18. THE INTERVENTION WAS A PART OF MIAMI-
DADE COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
TRANSITION/RE-ENTRY PLAN FOR 2014-
2015 SCHOOL YEAR
21. School Social Worker
receives notification of
student’s exit from JJC
School to Program.
Planning for re-entry
begins
Transition/Exit meeting
held at program School
Social Worker receives
notification of meeting
attends meetings if
program is local
Submit written feedback
for out of county Re-
entries
School Social Worker
reviews student’s
electronic records;
engage in solution
focused goals oriented
interview with student if in
a Local Program. Contact
SPED representative for
input; contacts JPO for
input and acts on
recommendations from all
parties.
Consults with
Administrators from One
Stop Educational and
Community Service Center
Student receives
successful placement
based on
recommendation
Re-entry process
completed.
25. Solution Focus Re-Entry /Transition
Questionnaire
Collaborative inquiry in which the students
will affirm their best qualities
Shift the attention away from problems and
towards possibilities and hope (what is
wanted)
Follow-up sessions would involve the co-
construction of achievable homework task or
activity, relevant to the student’s strengths,
successes and goal
26. • The Solution Focus Re-entry Questionnaire is
also used with students who re-entered from
out of county placements and are receiving
their post commitment support through AMI
Kids Inc.
27. The conversations support students on their
journey towards identifying their preferred
future; goals and recognizing the skills,
abilities and strengths they have within them.
The students over time come to see
possibilities; noticing times when they
engaged in positive activities and interactions
with others; not dwell on past mistakes.
We only glance in the past and focus on the
future and all the possibilities that it holds.
Students identify career goals, interest and
passions that they have.
28. Responses are non-judgmental, circular
questioning is utilized; the student leads the
discussions responses are to what the students
say in the conversation.
Listening is the key; active listening without
prejudice, assuming a position of ignorance and
curiosity.
Students will engage in scaling as an activity of
identifying how close they are to their goals
during each session; students will start each
session by identifying what has been different
and better since the last meeting.
29. The intervention should be for a maximum of
nine sessions. The purpose of the
intervention is to support the youth; in the
end they will not stay focused on where they
are now, realizing that their current situation
is just a pause a break and engaging in
activities that will place them back on the
steps that will lead them to their plan for
their life.
30. A Key Component to Success is
Consulting with Parent other educators;
Administrators and JPO
32. Collaboration Brings Results
One Stop Educational and Community Service
Center Key component of successful Re-entry
for students involved with DJJ
33. The One Stop Process – An Example of a
successful re-entry from a Local Commitment
Program
34. Successful Re-entry from Dade Juvenile to
Alonso and Tracy Mourning High
Student engaged in Solution Oriented Work
identifying his goal and preferred future of
returning to High School upon his release
38. Of the approximately 50 students that we
have provided re-entry service to from their
exit of the commitment program to follow-up
approximately 25 or 50% have not reentered
the Juvenile Justice system.
Of the 50% that re-entered the Justice System
approximately 10 or 5% of them have been
due to parole violation such as school
nonattendance
39. CONCLUSION
A study by Davis, Gervin, White, Williams, Taylor and
McGriff about Bridging the Gap Between Research,
Evaluation and Evidence-Based Practice shares the
following:
1. The integration of evaluation practice into social
work curricula and field setting has been a
challenge for the social work profession.
2. Students’ lack of enthusiasm about research,
statistics anxiety, and poor preparation have
contributed to courses like research method and
statistics as the most unanticipated courses for
students.
40. Conclusion
1. Social Workers who serve as field instructors
rarely embrace the use of research in their
practice and tend to use the least
sophisticated research method
The goal of the research was to identify
strategies that would increase the use of
research, evidenced based practice as a
standard for social work education and field
instruction
41. CONCLUSION
Many advantages to carrying out research as a
practitioner
1. Allows you to engage in qualitative social science
research
2. Social Work students help with the time pressures
that can accompany the research
3. Research data can inform future practice
4. Provide real time data for use in intervention
discussions
5. Enhancement of social worker’s capacity and quality
of work
42. Instruction
Classroom
Knowledge of
Students
Academic needs
Academic
Theories
Current
Research
• Practice
Knowledge of
Students needs
• Knowledge of
Theories
• Interventions
Resources
• Current
Research
Student
Success
ACADEMIA SOCIAL
WORKER
43.
44. Blomberg, T.G., Bales, W.E. & Piquero A.R
(2011). Is educational achievement a
turning point for incarcerated delinquents
across race and sex? Journal of Youth and
Adolescence, 202-216 doi:10.1007/s10964-
011-9680-4
Blundo, R, Bolton, K & Hall, C (1999) Research
on Hope and Solution Focused Practice
University of North Carolina at
Wilmington
Davis, S, Gervin, D, White, G, Williams, A,
Taylor, A & McGriff, E (2013) Bridging the
Gap between research, evaluation, and
evidence based practice
45. Metcalf, L(2000) Solution Focused RTI:- A
Positive Personalized Approach to
Response to Intervention (1st ed.) San
Francisco, CA; Jossey-Bass
Seagram, B.M.C.(1997) The Efficacy of
Solution Focused Therapy With Young
Offenders Unpublished Dissertation York
University (Canada)
Selekman, M (2005) Pathways to Change
(2nded.) New York, Guilford
Hinweis der Redaktion
GUIDING PRINCIPLES
What is know about effective social work practice? Walsh, 2013, Two literature reviews published 40 years ago by Fischer (1973, 1976) created a stir within the profession by concluding that there was no evidence for the effectiveness of casework; effectiveness was difficult to determine because of a lack of rigor in research methods. The researchers recommended that social workers increase the structure of their interventions
Data, Outcomes, measurable goals success
Walsh (2013) states that many students reported to their professors during their field placements that their field instructors frequently informed them that “they don’t operate with any theory. They just do what they have to do to get results.” Other comments have been that their supervisors statement that he or she “has not use for academic types who waste time talking about abstractions rather than getting things done.” or that theoreticians, “ have no idea what goes on in the real world.”
As an educator who believed it is critical that social work interventions should be evidenced based, and social workers should engage in research as a basis to inform their practice; I provide this opportunity for students whom I supervise in the field.
Provide students the opportunity to support the research and expand their knowledge of the Theory of Hope
Provide a opportunity for practitioner who may have an hostile feeling towards the idea of theory; I am convinced that all social practitioners operate fro a theoretical basis, we may not always be able to articulate our perspectives; we have automatically learned, absorbed and revised ideas about how to work with clients.
As our profession push towards more evidence-based practice; it is my goal that this method of field education will promote the process of systemically choosing interventions without adherence to a particular theoretical base. The process involved engaging in direct modeling/coaching, discussing with students how do you read a research article, evaluates it’s validity, author’s purpose, funding backing behind the article
A question that’s based on their information needs in terms of their client’s issues, the interventions they are using, effectiveness theoretical concepts, previous research with this population. Student’s will become practitioners that realize that we owe it to our clients to start thinking about questions we provide services that are essential to their quality of life.
Current law states that education is the single most important factor in the rehabilitation of adjudicated delinquent youth and requires that youth in the Juvenile Justice system be afforded the opportunity to obtain a high quality education.
The article provided evidence from various research that show the link between education and delinquency
Various theories contribute to the education achievement of students. The labelling theory was particularly interesting for me as it informs my practice. Labelling theory focuses on the triggering effects that labels may have as they serve to exclude individuals from certain activities. Labels serve as social control; labelled offenders have fewer options to conventional life, which can lead to weak social bonds. Many students I work with are labelled and often time they display behaviors that support this label and leads to exclusion from traditional schools. This then starts the trajectory of their school career in a downward spiral.
The second research question is there are difference in the percentage of re-arrests within 1-year post release for students with above average attendance and those with below average attendance. Students with below average attendance were likely to be re-arrested 52.4% compared to students with above average attendance 40.8%. This study has implication for the quality of education services provided to students while in commitment Program, re-entry services including educational follow-up.
Often times others have created various scenarios in adolescent lives that causes them to loose (if they possessed it before), never see (blocks, ie. Emotional, financial resources etc) HOPE. It is my expressed desire that the measurement of success of this outcome will be the contribution to dismantling the School to Prison Pipeline.
Notification received of student’s exit from Juvenile Justice Center School and transporting to Program; Student’s information is entered unto a log and a print out of their electronic records is stored in preparation of their return.
The transition Worksheet is completed prior to the Transition/Exit Meeting to allow for an efficient and expeditious meeting.
The goal of the process is successful completion of high school therefore the need to have the students begin thinking about their future career goals and engage in a shift in thinking and begin to focus on their preferred future.
The goal of the intervention is to support the students in visualizing themselves in their own idea of a positive career future. The key here is to find out the benefits in the students’ minds and building a platform on which to build and Agreement as to their preferred future. Supporting the students as they find pathways to their desire goals and becoming motivated to use those pathways is a key component of this work. The students defined hope will serve as the motivation and drive to succeed.
use as a guide in my solution oriented conversations with the students as they return to Miami Dade County Public Schools from their commitment Programs.
The goal of these conversations is to support the students on their journey towards identifying their preferred future; goals and recognizing the skills, abilities and strengths they have within them. Through the intervention students over time come to see possibilities; noticing times when they engaged in positive activities and interactions with others; not dwell on past mistakes. We only glance in the past and focus on the future and all the possibilities that it holds. Students identify career goals, interest and passions that they have.
Historically most juvenile justice intervention has been either behavioral or psycho-analytical, with the rate of recidivism it is now time for us to look at a variety of eclectic approach and not use a one size fits all models where we try to shape the youth to suit the intervention. For workers to achieve maximal effectiveness in reaching these youths, paradigm shifts are needed in the ways that we intervene and the needs of the youths are understood and actualized in these programs. As such providing a diverse youth centered approach to intervention is imperative to the survival of American society.
Working collaboratively with all stakeholders is key to a successful transition/re-entry Attached are sample of communication with both
Recording is important for accountability and follow-up
Collaboration in action brings results
Upon release from Juvenile Justice Center; students are required to visit the One Stop Educational Center to discuss their various school entry options, Collaboration with the School Counselor Assigned to the Center helps with successful re-entry of these students.
Working collaboratively with input from Dr. Theron Clark Administrator over the One Stop Educational and Community Service Center achieved a successful reentry for our student
Services provided to students after exit meeting from AMI Kids Inc. Consultation with Dr. Clarke and Ms. Tabitha Young as to appropriate setting for students who have been unsuccessful with Day treatment Program.
Measuring Outcome – How effective
Efforts to bridge the gap between practice and research and to engage in evidence based practice has been around since 1915 at the National Conference of Charities and Corrections. It again surgaced in the late 1960’s and early 1970’s in respose to accountability. Due to the recent re-emgernce of accountability both in schools and practice the need for evidence based practice is again on the increase.
Overall, the findings suggest that students are not actively engaging in evidence-based research. In addition, field instructors do not possess a standard definition of evaluation or regularly engage in evaluation. As a result a significant gap exists between social work theory, training, and practice. In addition field instructors possess insufficient knowledge and skills of EBP to assist students in the field setting. Some social workers are uncertain about how to implement EBP in practice.
The CSWE stresses the importance of engaging in research-informed practice and practice-informed research as a curricula and practice area (Council of Social Work Educatrion, 2008)
Collaborative relationship leads to student wins increase in academics increase in graduation rates desire outcomes
There are practical ways for clinical social workers to participate in research regarding their practice effectiveness. Most of these opportunities derive from a principle of collaboration between researchers and practicing social workers. Developing university/agency relationships.