NO MARKETING CHANNEL CAN STAND ALONE
WHAT EVERY YOU DO OFFLINE WILL INFLUENCE ONLINE LEAD GENERATION
TIME PRESSURE IS SHORTING LEAD CYCLES & SALES CYCLES
JUST BEING IN THE CHANNEL ISN'T ENOUGH A CONSISTENT, CLEAR, COMPELLING & CREDIBLE MESSAGE IS A MUST
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Digital Dealer 15 Its Called A Marketing Mix For A Reason
1. Digital Dealer | 15 October 2013 |
Las Vegas
It’s Called A Marketing Mix
For A Reason.
Channel attribution
in a multi-channel marketing world
Larry Bruce
President / CEO, OnlineDrive
@pcmguy
2. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
There are no expert
marketers. only,
experienced marketers
and expert testers
“
125
20% 12.1
Million
Dealerships
Control Group
In Market Visitors
1
Million
Emails Sent
?
2200+ 600,000
Surveyed Buyers
Direct Mail Pieces Sent
Which channel would produce
the highest lead generation for the client?
!
Note :
Lead Definition – Call, Sub Form, email, chat where
good contact information was collected
The avg. customer only took 57 days to purchase a vehicle
3. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
“
The goal of a test is
not just to get a lift...
it’s to get a learning
03%
3rd Party
02%
Email Marketing had the highest impact on lead generation
04%
Traditional
Media
Sites
05% Content
Marketing
09% Organic
Website
Social Media
11%
PPC
+
12%
Direct Mail
37%
Email Marketing
!
17% Website Behavioral
Targeting
Most channels significant dependencies to one another critical to success
4. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Sustainable Competitive
advantage can only be
achieved through superior
understanding of
your customers behavior
Why it’s called a marketing mix for a reason
“
79%
of Offline source leads
continued their
research online
93%
of Digital source leads were
tracked at 2 or more online
properties owned by the client
87%
of all cases More Leads
equated to More Shows & Sales
5. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Email Marketing
64%
70
60
50
46%
36%
40
Lift CTR
Lift Conversion Rate
30
24%
17%
20
14%
10
0
Social Media
3%
1%
Direct Mail
Traditional Media
Other Factors
PPC
68%
212%
79%
Lift in conversion when directed to
a landing page vs. dealerships
Random Access Website
Lift in CTR when there is
a Single Clear Call To Action
Lift in CTR when the email is
an email not an ad and is
from a person
6. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Website Behavioral
180%
172%
Targeting
160%
140%
120%
112%
Traffic
Lift in Conversion
100%
80%
60%
66%
47%
40%
20%
0%
14%
10% 16%
Traditional Content
Media
Marketing Email
Marketing PPC
Major Factors
1%
3%
Website
Organic
1%
2%3%
3rd Party Sites
72%
Targeting service customers for test drives accounted for over 72% of the lift when using website
behavioral targeting when driven by an incentive.
7. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
“
Number 1 way
to conquest
new customers
Direct Mail
78%
80%
Lift in Visitor Rate
Lift in Conversion
60%
PPC
Website Behavioral Targeting
Website Organic
Content Marketing
3rd Party Sites
40%
20%
12%
0%
Electronic
Media
“
6%
3% 2%
Email
Marketing Social Media
The goal of the Direct Mail piece is no longer to get the call or the visit
to the store. It’s to get the visit to a landing page. Tell the prospect just
enough to get he visit to the landing page, Explain the offer & get the
lead.
“
No Change in
46%
8. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
PPC is a combination of
Search Marketing, Display
Marketing and Remarketing
these things are not mutually
exclusive
PPC (Pay Per Click Marketing)
“
60%
54%
Lift in CTR
Lift in Conversion
50%
40%
No Change in
30%
Website Behavioral Targeting
Content Marketing
3rd Party Sites
20%
18%
14%
14%
7% 7%
10%
0%
Electronic
Media
6%
4%
Email
Marketing Website Direct
Organic Mail
The Biggest Influences on PPC come from within :
Search &
Display
19%
26%
Remarketing as
Targeted Display
16%
35%
4%4%
Social
Media
Remarketing
9%
7%
9. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
If I am your ideal prospect…
WHY should I do business
with you over any other store
in the market?
Website Organic
“
80%
78%
70%
Lift in Traffic
60%
Lift in Conversion
50%
No Change in
Social Media
Direct Mail
3rd Party Sites
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
41%
31%
9% 14%
12%
2%
Electronic Content
Email
Media
Marketing Marketing PPC
!
1% 6%
Social
Media
2%
3%
Direct
3rd Party
Mail
sites
There were several contributing sub factors critical to the success of organic traffic
10. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Website Conversion Amplifiers
Conversion rates for Organic traffic to the dealership main website rose 47% when adding
Incentive Based Behavioral Targeting to the site.
Sites with USP’s (Unique Selling Propositions) avg. 11% higher conversion rates.
Sliders with VALUE got avg. CTR of 5% and avg. Conversion rate of 6%.
Sites using Value Your Trade pg. converted 58% more leads than those with out and 101%
higher lead volume with a 57% show rate using Inventive Based Behavioral Marketing.
Service Test Drive Program avg. 58 leads from service per month with a 16% Sale Ratio
Specials Page – 36% Lift in conversion for sites with current specials page & 69% Lift in
conversion when Incentive Based Behavioral Marketing was added.
There was an additional 25% Lift in conversion when specials pages were linked to their own
dedicated microsite.
11. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
The content is
NOT the marketing
Content Marketing
“
300%
277%
Lift in Traffic
250%
Lift in Conversion
200%
150%
No Change in
118%
100%
Direct mail
3rd Party Sites
37%
50%
12% 6%
8%
0%
Email
Social
Marketing Media
Conversion Amplifiers
Display Marketing with in the content itself
with a
3% 3%
Website Electronic
Organic Media
1%
PPC
93% Lift in CTR,
22% Lift in Conversion, Incentive Based Behavioral Targeting 13%Lift in Conversion.
12. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
People are not likely to
remember your commercial…
they are most likely to
Remember HOW your
commercial made them feel
“
180%
160%
140%
#1
largest
impact
channel
Lift in Conversion
Lift in Traffic
#1
largest
#1
largest
impact
channel
impact
channel
78%
Lift in CTR
Lift in Visitor Rate
112%
41%
54%
40%
#3
largest
impact
channel
78%
80%
60%
impact
channel
171%
120%
100%
Electronic Media
#1
largest
#4
largest
impact
channel
46%
24%
18%
20%
14%
3% 3%
0%
Website
Organic
PPC
Electronic Media
Direct
Mail
Website
Behavioral
Targeting
Email
Marketing
Content
Marketing
13. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
NADA Data 2013
Advertising and the Dealership
Electronic Media
$7.2 Billion
2002
2012
8.5%
26.5%
10.8%
5%
7.4%
20.2%
9.6%
16.7%
46.7%
Newspaper
15.7%
Radio
16.9%
Television
Direct Mail
In 2012 Ad spend rose $800,000,000 over 2011
yet expense per vehicle sold fell 1.1% to $621 over 2011
15.9%
Internet
Where is
the Fat ?
Other
14. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
The only marketing channel
we could find that is
truly an island
“
3rd Party
Sites were
the last
impact channel
3rd Party
Sites were
the last
impact channel
3%
3rd Party Sites
Lift in Traffic
Lift in Conversion
No Change in
2%
Email Marketing
PPC
Direct Mail
Content Marketing
1%
0%
Website Behavioral
Targeting
Website
Organic
They have a place in your marketing mix however they are ALONE
15. “ with
Talk
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
your customers and
prospects not just
at them
“
#1
largest
Audience
impact
channel
Social Media
Conversation
Conversion
Lift in Conversion
Lift in CTR
70%
#2
largest
64%
Website Behavioral
Targeting
50%
40%
#5
largest
20%
Goals
impact
channel
impact
channel
3% 2%
12%
10%
0%
#5
largest
4% 4%
37%
#3
largest
impact
channel
36%
30%
Awareness,
Loyalty,
Conversion
Lift in Visitor Rate
impact
channel
60%
No Change in
Lift in Traffic
Email
Marketing
Content
Marketing
PPC
Direct
Mail
6%
Website
Organic
Give away fans are useless, less than 6% bought with in 12 months of the give away.
People who
your dealership on
are 43% more likely to buy from your store
16. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
People buy the way
they buy, NOT the way
YOU want to sell them
“
1
st you should understand
the primary goal
in each channel
Conversion
Email
Website Behavioral Targeting
Direct Mail
PPC
Website Organic
3rd Party Sites
?
What is the right
Marketing Mix?
Awareness
Social Media
Content Marketing
Electronic Media
Traffic
3rd Party Sites
17. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Customers do not see your marketing
the same way you do with specific
messages in specific channels for
specific vehicles, vehicle types, makes
or models. Overlap will happen whether
you want it to or not, you will have to
integrate the pieces to achieve
significant gains.
“
That starts with a consistent message
across all Marketing Channels
?
What is the right
Marketing Mix?
18. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Budget Allocation By The Numbers
Overall Budget
Digital Break Down
Social
Media
Other
7%
8%
3rd Party
Sites
Digital
35%
Direct Mail
10%
10%
Website
Organic
Email
Marketing
20%
Website
Behavioral Targeting
15%
15%
Content
Marketing
15%
Electronic
PPC
35%
30%
19. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
In Automotive
Lead Generation PRICE
was a secondary concern
Largest Amplifiers
To SHOWS AND SALES
96%
of all customers surveyed said they
visited the dealerships website
before visiting the store
You MUST answer
the WHY QUESTION…
WHY should I do business with you?
52% lower bounce rate and 11% higher conversion when the dealer
added USP’s to the home page of the site. With a 57% show rate.
Why should I give you my information?
Website Incentive Based Behavioral Targeting accounted for
17% of the overall lead volume, with a 63% avg. show rate.
“
20. “
Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Largest Amplifiers
To SHOWS AND SALES
“
When working to build
your business
you must be responsive
59%
Leads called with in
5 minutes
of inquiry were had a 311%
higher show rate to
the dealership.
60%
52%
47% 46%
43%
50%
40%
30%
Call
22%
17%
Email
11%
20%
Form
Chat
10%
0%
Show
39%
Sale Ratio
The show rate diminished by
from 10 - 20 minute and there was absolutely
NO CHANGE in show rate from 20 minutes to 24 hours.
21. Larry Bruce | President / CEO, OnlineDrive
Largest Amplifiers
to SHOWS AND SALES
Why?...
91%
of customers that were called within 5 min
surveyed were still at their computer when called.
Note:
Scripting best practice is Give & Get.
You should have something of value
to give to get what you want …
good... re-contact information!
22. Question?
Larry Bruce
President / CEO, OnlineDrive
@pcmguy
lbruce@theonlinedrive.com
“To really use “BIG DATA” the marketer must see the Path… basically the
route to the message AND the Pattern Followed… the behavior exhibited
when the respondent landed.”