SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 11
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Public Financial Management Reform in Kosovo
Doug Hadden, FreeBalance
dhadden@freebalance.com

Executive Overview
The Government of Kosovo has achieved remarkable results in Public Financial Management
(PFM) reform. This post-conflict country once managed through a United Nations mandate
has sequenced legal reform, improved governance, and achieved international PFM standards
under difficult conditions.
Sequencing PFM reform is considered a good government practice, although “it is impossible
to prescribe a sequence of reforms which is appropriate in all circumstances (DFID 2001).”
There are numerous lessons in the Kosovo experience linking reform to context that can be
leveraged by governments around the world.

 Achievements                                     Importance of Public Financial
  Improved governance as demonstrated            Management Reform
    by Public Expenditure and Financial
    Accountability (PEFA) assessments             Research has shown a statistically relevant link
  Appropriate sequencing of PFM reform           between good governance indicators and
  Capacity built for budget execution, cash      development (Kaufmann, Kraay & Mastruzzi
    management and procurement                    2008). For example, countries whose
    government-wide                               governments achieve higher good governance
  Decentralization of budget execution           indicators tend to have higher GDP per capita
    reflecting successful capacity building       and longer average life expectancy.
  PFM achieving International and
    European standards                       PFM reform is acknowledged to be a
                                             mechanism to improve good governance. “The
quality of public financial management (PFM) systems is a key determinant of government
effectiveness. The capacity to direct, manage and track public spending allows governments
to pursue their national objectives and account for the use of public resources and donor
funds (de Renzio & Dorotinsky 2007).”
Financial Management Information Systems (FMIS) or Government Resource Planning
(Government Resource Planning) are recognized as technology tools to assist in PFM reform.
“The establishment of an FMIS has consequently become an important benchmark for the
country’s budget reform agenda, often regarded as a precondition for achieving effective
management of the budgetary resources. Although it is not a panacea, the benefits of an
FMIS could be argued to be profound. (Diamond & Khemani 2005).”

History of PFM Reform in Kosovo
PFM reform in Kosovo began with the United Nations Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) in 1999.
UNMIK created an administrative structure creating the “Central Fiscal Authority (CFA),
later renamed the Ministry of Finance and Economy (MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND
ECONOMY) (Rodin-Brown 2008).” The financial system was upgraded through the use of
an Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS) funded by the Canadian
International Development Agency (CIDA), the Swedish International Development Agency
(SIDA), and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) (Rodin-
Brown 2008).


International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                      13
USAID provided funding for “the main areas of government fiscal management: tax policy
and analysis, tax administration, expenditure policy, budget management and control,
intergovernmental fiscal relations, and sub-
national government finance (USAID,
                                               South Eastern Europe Regional Comparisons &
2006).”                                        Government Challenges
Since 1999, the Government of Kosovo has               Lowest per capita GDP PPP
enhanced legal reform, control, fiscal
decentralization and purchasing.
Challenges

Economic
Kosovo has experienced dire
macroeconomic conditions during and after
the breakup of the Yugoslav federation.
The economy “was essentially decimated
                                                     Highest unemployment
by the Kosovo War (Tang 2010).”
“Kosovo is one of the poorest countries in
Europe (World Bank 2009).” Improved
economic development is critical to
country stability (Bytyci 2009).

Capacity and Sustainability
Like many post-conflict countries, Kosovo
has been challenged to effectively and
financially achieve sustainable PFM
reform. PFM capacity needed to be built.             Lowest Human Development Index
“The Albanian-speaking majority who
remained in Kosovo after the war did not
include an experienced cadre of technical,
professional and managerial specialists
ready to take up key positions (USAID
2006).” Capacity building required
government ownership in order to ensure
sustainability. At first “public expenditure
management in Kosovo was almost
entirely handled by internationals (Sigma
2004).”
Government Goals
The Government of Kosovo has strategic plans to increase economic growth, improve
governance, and reduce poverty (Tang 2010). These plans are also designed to achieve
European Union membership (Tandberg & Pavesic-Skerlep 2009).

Improved Governance and Transparency




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                               14
The Government of Kosovo recognizes how good governance can improve development
results (MTEF 2009). Social cohesion can   PEFA Assessments
be achieved through governance reform       Donor Partnership: “PEFA aims to support
through transparent institutions,             integrated and harmonized approaches to
decentralization and improved access to       assessment and reform in the field of public
                                              expenditure, procurement and financial
citizen services (World Bank 2009).
                                                          accountability”
The Government of Kosovo is now focused                 Completed two Public Expenditure and
on executing the full budget in order to                  Financial Accountability (PEFA) assessments
achieve the best results (Tang 2010 and                 Over 75 National and Sub-national PEFA
                                                          assessments have been completed
MTEF 2009). Public Expenditure and
                                                        Less than 10 countries have completed two
Financial Accountability (PEFA)                           PEFA assessments
assessments have been used by the                      PEFA Comparisons
Government of Kosovo to set priorities for              Kosovo PEFA improvements from 2007 to 2009
improved governance.
The Government of Kosovo has achieved
significant improvements in governance
between 2007 and 2009 according to the
PEFA assessments. The 2009 PEFA
assessment exceeds PEFA assessment
averages (de Renzio 2009). This assessment
also exceeds the average for South Eastern
Europe, although many countries in the
region have not completed a PEFA
assessment or have not completed an
assessment for more than two years.
It should be noted that the government                  Kosovo exceeds international average
context is critical in assessing PFM.
Governments focus on those assessment
criteria that is critical for improvement.
Even the Government of Norway was not
able to achieve top marks across all criteria
(Mundal 2008). The Government of Kosovo
has achieved excellent results (B and
higher) for over half of the assessment
criteria.


2009 Kosovo PEFA Assessment – “A”
 PI-3 Aggregate revenue out-turn compared to original approved budget
 PI-5 Classification of the budget
 PI-7 Extent of unreported government operations
 PI-16 Predictability in the availability of funds for commitment of expenditures
 PI-17 Recording and management of cash balances, debt and guarantees
 PI-25 Quality and timeliness of annual financial statements




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                        15
Sequence of PFM Reform in Kosovo
                                                             Good Practice: Sequencing PFM
Phasing of PFM “reform, through achieving gradual            Reform
manageable steps (DFID 2005)” is considered a good            Kosovo began with simple
practice. The sequence of reform depends on the                 centralized financial management
country context. “Implementing public finance                 Initial system configured to
reforms of any kind requires an understanding of the            Yugoslav model before updating to
entire public finance system in place in that country.          international standards
It requires an understanding of the institutional             Improvements to financial
                                                                management processes followed
arrangements (Rodin-Brown 2008).”                               legal reform
Technology solutions like Government Resource                 Decentralization to line ministries
Planning should follow reform. “The Kosovo                      and municipal governments
                                                                followed capacity building
environment was unique; the fiscal management                 Support of the Treasury Single
requirements were NOT. System implementation can                Account enables managing all
be achieved in a matter of weeks; financial                     government funds
management reform takes years (Brajshori 2007).”              Addition of government
Governments tend to implement budget, treasury and              accounting, fixed asset
accounting standards before embarking on                        management and purchasing
                                                                functionality in line with
performance management initiatives (Tandberg &                  government objectives
Pavesic-Skerlep 2009).
                                                              Development and improvement of
Legal Reform                                                    the macro-fiscal framework
                                                                including support of Medium Term
Legal reform is required before embarking on public             Expenditure Frameworks to align
financial management reform (Spietzer 2008).                    budgets with government
“Technology is an early building block in creating              objectives
good governance and must be introduced in a phased            Sequencing of transparency
                                                                efforts including publishing
implementation to allow absorption of key                       monthly, quarterly and yearly
government reforms. Technology should be                        budget reports
supported by sound governance legislation: rules,
regulations, finance administrative instructions etc. (Brajshori 2007).”
The Government of Kosovo has phased institution building with the legal framework
(SIGMA 2009-PEM). This has resulted in a constitution in line with European standards (EU
2008). Legal reform has also enabled the support for public sector accounting standards such
as the IMF Government Financial Statistics (GFS) and the International Public Sector
Accounting Standards (IPSAS) (Smith-EMSG 2009, PEFA, 2009).
Budget and Treasury Management
Financial management began by using the practices used by the Yugoslav model (Rodin-
Brown 2008). The Kosovo Financial Management Information System (KFMIS), using the
FreeBalance Accountability Suite, was initially implemented in 26 days to support budget
controls (Rodin-Brown 2008). Successful implementation bred more reform (Brajshori
2007). The KFMIS was extended and modernized following the reform program set by the
Government of Kosovo.
Budget execution and treasury management were the initial priorities. Procurement,
decentralization and revenue modernization followed. The modernization of PFM enables
governments to establish credibility. The Government of Kosovo has established credibility




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                      16
in fiscal management by assuming a portion of Yugoslav government debt (World Bank
2009).
Sequence of PFM Reform in Kosovo: 1999 to 2009
LEGAL REFORM                                                 TECHNOLOGY MODERNIZATION
                                                              Pilot Government Resource
 UNMIK administration                                1999     Planning system implemented in
                                                               26 days
                                                              Full Government Resource
                                                      2000
                                                               Planning project launched
 UNMIK Regulation on the Establishment of the
  Kosovo Board on Standards for Financial
                                                      2001    Deployment to all 5 Regions
  Reporting (KBSFR)
 Law on Kosovo Civil Service
                                                              Training and Certification of
 Ministry of Finance and Economy established
                                                      2002     Ministry of Finance
 Kosovo Accounting Standards (KAS) developed
                                                              Core system goes live
                                                              Sustainability and Capacity
 Law on Financial Management and                              Training
  Accountability (LFMA)                                       System available in Serbian and
 Law on Public Procurement                           2003     Albanian
 Public Service Laws on Recruitment,                         Deployment to all 30
  Probationary Period, Appeals, Termination                    Municipalities
                                                              Payroll interface
                                                              Revenues module goes live
 Law on International Financial Agreements
                                                      2004    Local sustainability team in place
 Public Service Law on Official Travel
                                                              Bank Electronic Interface
 Medium Term Expenditure Framework
  introduced
 Suppression of Corruption Law & creation of the             Budget system interface
                                                      2005
  Office of Ombudsperson                                      VPN to all budget institutions
 Public Service Laws on Gender Equality and
  Independent Oversight Board
 Cash and Debt Management division created
 All tax and not tax revenue implemented via
                                                              Asset Module goes live
  Treasury Single Account
                                                      2006    Disaster recover site established
 Law on Internal Auditing
                                                              Purchasing Module goes live
 Public Service Law on Civil Service Code of
  Conduct
 First PEFA Assessment
 Law on Preventing Conflict of Interest in                     Support for IPSAS and GFS in
                                                      2007
  Exercising Public Function                                     Chart of Accounts and in 2006
 Independent Anti-Corruption Agency                             financial reports
  established
 Republic of Kosovo Constitution in force
 Law on Public Financial Management and
  Accountability (LFMA) putting MTEF in legal                   Chart of Accounts (COA) adapted
  force                                               2008       to support program oriented
 Law on Local Government Finances (LLGF)                        budgeting
 Law on Local Self Government (LLSG)
 Law on Publicly Owned Enterprises
 Second PEFA Assessment                                      Payment decentralization to
 PFM Reform Action Plan                                       hospitals and municipalities
                                                      2009
 Law on Membership of the Republic of Kosovo                 Regional treasuries closed
  in the International Monetary Fund and World                Enhanced reporting pilot



International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                          17
Bank Group Organizations
 Law on Public-Private-Partnerships and
  Concessions in Infrastructure and the
  Procedures for Their Award
 Law on Internal Audit
 Law on Public Debt
 Law on Declaration and Origin of the Property
  and presents of Public Senior Officials
 Law on Salaries of Civil Servants
                                                      2010
 Law on the Civil Service of the Republic of
  Kosovo
 Law on Access to Public Documents

Important Developments
Improving PFM has cross-cutting effects. Many challenges remain in Kosovo because of the
historical and macro-economic situation. Nevertheless, there have been improved economic
development, financial management, transparency and civil service capacity building.
Economic Developments
 “Kosovo and Albania were the only two countries in the Western Balkans that experienced
   positive economic growth in 2009 (Tang 2010).”
 “Amidst signs that the worldwide recession is easing, the slowdown in Kosovo’s economic growth
   has remained orderly (IMF 2009/09).”
Financial Management and Transparency
 “Kosovo has made significant progress in establishing a workable public financial management
   system, including a sound legal framework (World Bank 2009).”
 “The greatest strength of the Kosovo PFM is its treasury system; not because of its sophistication in
   terms of functionality or its classification system, but simply because it is comprehensive and is able
   to produce timely and reasonable analytical reports (PEFA 2007).”
 “Treasury Department external audits show zero (or near-zero) errors. (Smith 2009-EMSG)”
 “In the broad sense of the term, the internal control structure has been established in Kosovo. The
   basic legal framework is sound, with clear structures of accountability (SIGMA 2008).”
 “Other strengths are found in the areas of internal audit and control and external audit where
   the process is in place and capacity is being built up for effective implementation (PEFA, 2009)
 “Good fiscal reports are produced based on the information extracted from the treasury system and
   the reports from the Auditor General are available on the Internet (PEFA 2007).”
 “Information about budget execution is produced monthly, quarterly and annually (SIGMA 2006-
   PEM)”
 “Improvement in reports by structure of the budget and present fund balance commitment for each
   economic category and budgetary organization. All reports are presented in compliance with IPSAS.
   (PEFA 2009)”
 “The quality of Treasury reporting has enabled complex strategic fiscal planning (i.e. MTEF) that is
   based on detailed current and historical fiscal analysis. Moreover, improvements in Treasury
   reporting have increased the level of public debate on fiscal issues, including within politics and
   media (USAID 2006).”
 “The 2009-2011 Budget incorporated detailed multi-year ceilings for both capital and recurrent
   elements. Further, preparation has commenced in full accordance with the timetable specified in
   the LPFMA. Of most critical importance is that the MTEF was completed by the end of April, which is
   earlier than previous years and provides a solid base for the rest of the process. (Smith 2009-EMSG)”
 Noticeable progress was achieved in the area of availability of main municipal budget process
   related documents to municipal stakeholders and general public. (Smith, 2009-EMSG)”
Capacity Building
 “Comprehensive Training and Certification Program and mentoring of local staff - some are still with
   Treasury after five years (Brajshori 2007)”




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                            18
 “A very strong macroeconomic analysis department exists. It is widely acknowledged to be an
  important and integral part of the MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY. The department uses a
  small but sophisticated macroeconomic model to perform regular forecasts of the Kosovo
  economy and analysis of specific issues (Smith 2007-EMSG).”
 “This year, MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY staff took the lead in drafting the Budget
  Regulation and conducting necessary communication with the UNMIK Legal Office, with the
  Advisors playing mainly supportive roles. MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY staff
  demonstrated its capacity to produce required budget documents, with increasing focus on
  improving the quality of the budget presentation. (Smith 2007-EMSG)”
 “In contrast to preparation of the prior MTEF, which depended on internationals to develop and
  run the required macroeconomic models and to write most parts of the final document, the
  analysis and drafting of the 2008-2010 MTEF was largely a Kosovar effort (Redbern, Fox,
  Gellerson 2009).”

Conclusions
Road to Good Governance
                                         Kosovo Good Governance Regional Comparisons
Globalization has created a          Kosovo needs to improve governance
competitive environment for
countries. Risk and opportunity
are key drivers for businesses.
Good governance creates country
stability and encourages business
investment to fuel economic
growth. Improving governance is
a strategic objective for the
Government of Kosovo “to
create an effective
administration, professional,
transparent in accordance with democratic principles and oriented towards providing the best
possible services to citizens (MTEF 2010).
Government Resource Planning Modernization Scorecard
The scope of reform and modernization differs among governments based on the country
context. Government Resource Planning functionality in the Government of Kosovo is
comprehensive and decentralized. Further modernization of automation is part of the PFM
Reform Action Plan.
                       Functionality               Decentralization         Modernization
                        Budget controls            Line ministries         Segregation of duties
Public Financial
                        Assets                     Regions                 IPSAS & GFS
Management
                        Audit                      Municipalities          Accrual accounting
                        Cash management                                     Bank reconciliation
Government              Cash controls                                       EFT
Treasury                Debt management            Delegated treasury      Treasury Single
Management              Investment                                           Account
                          management                                         Cash forecasting
                                                                             Procurement
                                                                             e-Procurement
Public Expenditure      Expenditure Controls
                                                    Delegated purchasing    Procurement
Management              Purchasing
                                                                              transparency
                                                                             Grant management




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                       19
Government                Non-tax revenue
Receipts                  Income tax               Local tax collection     Case management
Management                Customs
                          Payroll                                            Recruitment
                          Pensions                                           Talent management
Civil Service             Workforce                                          Capacity building
                                                   
Management                 management                                         Performance appraisal
                                                                              Succession planning
                        Civil service planning
                                                                              Self-Service
                                                                              PEFA assessments
                        Budget                     Budget delegation        Program budgeting
                         classifications            Bottom-up Budgets        MTEF
Government              Management                                           Budget transparency
Performance              reporting                                            Macro-fiscal
Management              Budget preparation         Local PEFA                framework
                        Budget circular             assessments              Scenario planning
                                                    Citizen services         Performance budgets
                                                                              Outcome measures
Items highlighted in white have been implemented, in gray have yet to be implemented
Roadmap for Reform
The Government of Kosovo Public Financial Management Reform Plan (PFMRAP 2009)
identified numerous important reforms leveraging Government Resource Planning systems.
Public Financial Management
 Reduce under-spending particularly in important infrastructure projects and gradual increase in
   accrual reporting
 Improve timeliness and accuracy of municipal financial data
 Improve audit capacity for all budget organizations and reduce delays in reporting external audit
   reports
Government Treasury Management
 More timely revenue reconciliation and daily bank reconciliation reporting
 Increase regularity of cash flow forecasts and link debt and cash management functionality
Public Expenditure Management
 Reach more markets in public tendering to ensure competitive pricing, simplify and monitor
   procurement procedures
 Grants Commission to manage transfers to municipalities
Government Receipts Management
 Improve tax audits and reduce tax arrears while increasing the automation of tax management
Civil Service Management
 Improve payroll controls and payroll forecasting
 Integration of human resources data to enable improve audit
 Support civil service reform through automated human resource management
 Upgrade ICT systems to support integrated human resources, payroll and financial management
Government Performance Management
 Improve budget formulation and strategic planning – ensure that budget calendar is followed
 More effective multiple year planning including better linkage of budgets with government
   objectives
 Use of performance information in budget preparation and improved monitoring and evaluation
 Improve managerial reporting
 Improve donor coordination




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                            20
Government of Kosovo Lessons Learned
Many governments can leverage the experience of the Government of Kosovo. Other
countries share many of the challenges and opportunities with Kosovo.
Focus of Development
 “Development strategy should be balanced between effectively implementing programs that could
   lessen societal tensions in the short-term while simultaneously putting in place the foundations for
   stable institutions and sustained growth in the medium- to longer-term (World Bank 2009).”
Decentralization for Regional and Ethnic Issues
 “Institutional strengthening and good governance, including effective central and municipal
   government and establishment of a level playing field for the different ethnic groups, will be crucial
   to longer term development and stability (World Bank 2009).”
Technology Follows Reform
 “Technology is an early building block in creating good governance and must be introduced in a
   phased implementation to allow absorption of key government reforms. Technology should be
   supported by sound governance legislation: rules, regulations, finance administrative instructions
   etc. (Brajshori 2007.)”
Government Ownership Critical to Improvements
 “Preparing a time-bound Public Financial Management Reform Action Plan designed to address the
   key weaknesses identified by the PEFA self-assessment (World Bank 2009).”
Donor Co-ordination can Accelerate Development
 “One of the most important issues affecting reforms in this area is the lack of effective donor co-
   ordination, which results in an ineffective use of most of the resources provided. (SIGMA 2009-PEM).”

Bibliography
Brajshori, Behxhet (2007) Achievements and Challenges in the Management of the Public
Finances in Kosovo, International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management,
http://www.icgfm.org/documents/Brajshori_kosovoEng.ppt
Brajshori, Behxhet (2009) Brajshori. Economic and Financial Developments in Kosovo and
the global crisis, International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management
http://www.slideshare.net/icgfmconference/country-responses-to-the-financial-crisis-kosovo
Bytyci, Fatos (2009) After billions in aid, Kosovo still poor and idle, Reuters
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBYT832920._CH_.2400
Department for International Development (2001) UK, Understanding and reforming public
expenditure management
http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.dfid.gov.uk/documents/publications/
pfma-pem.pdf
-----------(2005) A Platform Approach to Improving Public Financial Management
http://www.train4dev.net/fileadmin/Resources/General_Documents/DfID_A%20Platform%2
0Approach%20to%20PFM.pdf
de Renzio, Paolo (2009) Taking Stock: What do PEFA Assessments tell us about PFM
systems across countries Overseas Development Institute
http://www.odi.org.uk/resources/download/3333.pdf
Diamond, Jack, Khemani, Pokar (2005) Introducing Financial Management Information
Systems in Developing Countries, International Monetary Fund
http://www.unescobkk.org/fileadmin/user_upload/epr/MTEF/04Financial_Planning/02Moder




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                           21
nization_of_public_sector_management/040204004Diamond,%20J.%20and%20Khemani,%
20P.%20%282005%29.pdf
Dorotinsky, William (2003)The World Bank’s Experience with Financial Management
Information System, The World Bank
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTRANETFINANCIALMGMT/Resources/K-L/KL-
COURSE-MATERIALS/ReviewWBprojIFMISdorotinsky.pdf
European Union (2008) EU Commission Kosovo Progress Report http://www.wbc-
inco.net/attach/kosovo_progress_report_en.pdf
International Monetary Fund (2009/06) Republic of Kosovo—IMF Staff Visit Concluding
Statement http://www.imf.org/external/np/ms/2009/062409.htm
-----------(2009/09) Republic of Kosovo—IMF Staff Visit, Concluding Statement
http://www.imf.org/external/np/ms/2009/091609.htm
Kaufmann, Daniel, Kraay, Aart, Mastruzzi, Massimo (2008) Governance Matters VII:
Aggregate and Individual Governance Indicators 1996-2007
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1148386
Kosovo, Government of, (PEFA 2007) Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability
(PEFA) Public Financial Management Assessment http://www.Ministry of Finance and
Economy-
ks.org/old/Shqip/English/mefwww/departamentet/pmakroekonomike/PEFA/pefaangmakro.p
df
----------MidTerm Expenditures Framework (MTEF 2009), 2010-2012 http://www.mef-
rks.org/en/download/mid-term-expenditure-framework/midterm-expenditures-framework-
2010-2012/2130-midterm-expenditures-framework-2010-2012/download
----------Medium Term Expenditures Framework 2011-2013 (MTEF 2010) http://www.mef-
rks.org/en/download/mid-term-expenditure-framework/medium-term-expenditure-
framework-2011--2013/2777-medium-term-expenditure-framework-2011--2013/download
----------Public Financial Management Reform Action Plan (PFM RAP 2009)
http://www.mef-rks.org/en/download/other-publications-and-reports/2421-public-financial-
management-reform-action-plan-pfm-rap/download
----------Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA 2009) Public Financial
Management Assessment http://www.mef-rks.org/en/download/other-publications-and-
reports/2032-public-expenditure-and-financial-accountability-pefa-public-financial-
management-assessment
Mundal, Håkon (2008) Public Financial Management Performance Report – Norway,
Norwegian Agency for International Cooperation
http://www.norad.no/en/Tools+and+publications/Publications/Publication+Page?key=109797
Redbern, F. Stevens, Fox, James W., Gellerson, Mark (2009) Evaluation of the Economic
Management for Stability and Growth Program, Kosovo, United States Agency for
International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACN920.pdf
Rodin-Brown, Edwin (2008) Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: A
Practical Guide, United States Agency for International Development
http://www.fiscalreform.net/images/ifmis_rodinbrown_080425.pdf



International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                               22
Smith, Matthew (2007-EMSG) Kosovo Economic Management for Stability and Growth,
United States Agency for International Development
http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACL494.pdf
-----------(2007-EDI) Kosovo Economic Development Initiative, Final Project Report, United
States Agency for International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACL385.pdf
-----------(2009-EMSG) Economic Management for Stability and Growth, Annual Report,
United States Agency for International Development
http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACO702.pdf
Spitzer, Deborah (2008) quoted at http://icgfm.blogspot.com/2008/12/good-practices-for-
sequencing-pfm.html
Support for Improvement in Governance and Management (SIGMA 2004) Public
Expenditure Management in Kosovo
https://www.sigmaweb.org/dataoecd/38/32/34991431.pdf
-----------(SIGMA 2006-PEM) SIGMA Kosovo Public Expenditure Management Assessment
http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/30/21/37739132.pdf
-----------(SIGMA 2009-PEM) SIGMA Kosovo Public Expenditure Management System
Assessment http://www.sigmaweb.org/dataoecd/31/42/43912978.pdf
Symansky, Steven (2005) Public Expenditure Management in Post Conflict Countries, World
Bank http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTRANETFINANCIALMGMT/Resources/K-
L/KL-COURSE-MATERIALS/6sessionSymanskyPEMPostConflict.pdf
Tanberg, Eivind, Pavesic-Skerlep, Mia (2009) Advanced Public Financial Management
Reforms in South East Europe, International Monetary Fund
http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/wp09102.pdf
Tang, Stephanie (2010) Balance of Power: Kosovo Topic B: Economic Development in
Kosovo, Northwestern University
http://www.numun.org/pdfs/2010/BOP%20Kosovo%20Topic%20B.pdf
United States Agency for International Development (2006) Kosovo Economic
Reconstruction Project: Development Alternatives
http://www.fiscalreform.net/pdfs/kosovo_tax_and_expenditure_2006.pdf
World Bank (2009) Interim Strategy Note for Republic of Kosovo for the Period FY10-
FY11, http://siteresources.worldbank.org/KOSOVOEXTN/Resources/297769-
1266424306995/Kosovo_full_report.pdf




International Journal of Governmental Financial Management                                23

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
Alexander Decker
 
Hacia una UME genuina
Hacia una UME genuinaHacia una UME genuina
Hacia una UME genuina
ManfredNolte
 
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
Jean-Marc Lepain
 
Public Finance Management
Public Finance ManagementPublic Finance Management
Public Finance Management
Yulia Muravyeva
 
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis Por FMI 2010
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis   Por FMI 2010Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis   Por FMI 2010
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis Por FMI 2010
EMPRESARIOS HACIENDO PAÍS
 
Una UEM auténtica
Una UEM auténticaUna UEM auténtica
Una UEM auténtica
ManfredNolte
 
A year-of-consolidation-and-reform
A year-of-consolidation-and-reformA year-of-consolidation-and-reform
A year-of-consolidation-and-reform
ireportergr
 
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
Jean-Marc Lepain
 
Public financial management assessment in the philippines
Public financial management assessment in the philippinesPublic financial management assessment in the philippines
Public financial management assessment in the philippines
CHED
 
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
Jean-Marc Lepain
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
 
Hacia una UME genuina
Hacia una UME genuinaHacia una UME genuina
Hacia una UME genuina
 
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
Lao PDR: Public Expenditure Mangement Review 2008
 
Public Finance Management
Public Finance ManagementPublic Finance Management
Public Finance Management
 
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis Por FMI 2010
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis   Por FMI 2010Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis   Por FMI 2010
Desempeño de las Reglas fiscales alternativas en Perú análisis Por FMI 2010
 
Una UEM auténtica
Una UEM auténticaUna UEM auténtica
Una UEM auténtica
 
A year-of-consolidation-and-reform
A year-of-consolidation-and-reformA year-of-consolidation-and-reform
A year-of-consolidation-and-reform
 
Report IMF for Greece - 20 july 2017
Report IMF for Greece -  20 july 2017Report IMF for Greece -  20 july 2017
Report IMF for Greece - 20 july 2017
 
Chap3 m0-why pub i is important-pp6
Chap3 m0-why pub i is important-pp6Chap3 m0-why pub i is important-pp6
Chap3 m0-why pub i is important-pp6
 
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessonsDorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
 
Tue 1000 Alvarez
Tue 1000 AlvarezTue 1000 Alvarez
Tue 1000 Alvarez
 
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation
 
IRSFInterimReport
IRSFInterimReportIRSFInterimReport
IRSFInterimReport
 
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
 Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
Public Sector Productivity - Ronnie Downes and Sean Dougherty, OECD
 
14 financial administration
14   financial administration14   financial administration
14 financial administration
 
Debt Restructuring, Institutions, and Markets: Dr. Lili Liu, Global Lead, Dec...
Debt Restructuring, Institutions, and Markets: Dr. Lili Liu, Global Lead, Dec...Debt Restructuring, Institutions, and Markets: Dr. Lili Liu, Global Lead, Dec...
Debt Restructuring, Institutions, and Markets: Dr. Lili Liu, Global Lead, Dec...
 
Fiscal Rules and Debt Restructuring: The European Union Experience - Country ...
Fiscal Rules and Debt Restructuring: The European Union Experience - Country ...Fiscal Rules and Debt Restructuring: The European Union Experience - Country ...
Fiscal Rules and Debt Restructuring: The European Union Experience - Country ...
 
Public financial management assessment in the philippines
Public financial management assessment in the philippinesPublic financial management assessment in the philippines
Public financial management assessment in the philippines
 
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
Strengthening provincial planning and budgeting capacity (laos 2010)
 
Building better budgets - Helping governments strengthen PFM around the world
Building better budgets - Helping governments strengthen PFM around the worldBuilding better budgets - Helping governments strengthen PFM around the world
Building better budgets - Helping governments strengthen PFM around the world
 

Andere mochten auch

Mtondia pefa cdc child protection lecture
Mtondia pefa cdc   child protection lectureMtondia pefa cdc   child protection lecture
Mtondia pefa cdc child protection lecture
Nicodemus Karisa
 

Andere mochten auch (7)

Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
 
Icgfm david ostermeyer keynote new methods of delivering development assistance
Icgfm david ostermeyer keynote new methods of delivering development assistanceIcgfm david ostermeyer keynote new methods of delivering development assistance
Icgfm david ostermeyer keynote new methods of delivering development assistance
 
Mtondia pefa cdc child protection lecture
Mtondia pefa cdc   child protection lectureMtondia pefa cdc   child protection lecture
Mtondia pefa cdc child protection lecture
 
Day1 sp3 icgfm may 2014-phil_sinnett_en
Day1 sp3 icgfm may 2014-phil_sinnett_enDay1 sp3 icgfm may 2014-phil_sinnett_en
Day1 sp3 icgfm may 2014-phil_sinnett_en
 
Workshop Session I: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Assess...
Workshop Session I: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Assess...Workshop Session I: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Assess...
Workshop Session I: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Assess...
 
Workshop Session II: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Asses...
Workshop Session II: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Asses...Workshop Session II: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Asses...
Workshop Session II: Public Expenditure Financial Accountability (PEFA) Asses...
 
The need for improvement in Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (...
The need for improvement in Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (...The need for improvement in Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (...
The need for improvement in Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (...
 

Ähnlich wie Hadden public financial management in government of kosovo

Concept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
Concept note for updating yemen pfm action planConcept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
Concept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
Jean-Marc Lepain
 
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
Alexander Decker
 
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνουγράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
irisld
 
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
irisld
 
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνουγράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
irisld
 
Managing public money
Managing public moneyManaging public money
Managing public money
Rahat ul Aain
 
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
Hans van Rijn
 

Ähnlich wie Hadden public financial management in government of kosovo (20)

Final Fiscal
Final FiscalFinal Fiscal
Final Fiscal
 
Philippine Public Financial Management System and its Role in National Develo...
Philippine Public Financial Management System and its Role in National Develo...Philippine Public Financial Management System and its Role in National Develo...
Philippine Public Financial Management System and its Role in National Develo...
 
Relationship between Financial Reporting Reforms and Performance of Selected ...
Relationship between Financial Reporting Reforms and Performance of Selected ...Relationship between Financial Reporting Reforms and Performance of Selected ...
Relationship between Financial Reporting Reforms and Performance of Selected ...
 
Concept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
Concept note for updating yemen pfm action planConcept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
Concept note for updating yemen pfm action plan
 
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
A critical analysis of public financial management reform in ethiopia and tan...
 
4.15 5.00pm Pfm Reform In Benin (Houssou And Mehou) French
4.15 5.00pm Pfm Reform In Benin (Houssou And Mehou) French4.15 5.00pm Pfm Reform In Benin (Houssou And Mehou) French
4.15 5.00pm Pfm Reform In Benin (Houssou And Mehou) French
 
Philippine fiscal and expenditure management reforms - Rolando Toledo - Phili...
Philippine fiscal and expenditure management reforms - Rolando Toledo - Phili...Philippine fiscal and expenditure management reforms - Rolando Toledo - Phili...
Philippine fiscal and expenditure management reforms - Rolando Toledo - Phili...
 
Speech by Minister of Finance (Kosovo), Mr. Avdullah Hoti, OECD-SIGMA Confere...
Speech by Minister of Finance (Kosovo), Mr. Avdullah Hoti, OECD-SIGMA Confere...Speech by Minister of Finance (Kosovo), Mr. Avdullah Hoti, OECD-SIGMA Confere...
Speech by Minister of Finance (Kosovo), Mr. Avdullah Hoti, OECD-SIGMA Confere...
 
Budget Transparency - Natia GULUA, Georgia
Budget Transparency - Natia GULUA, GeorgiaBudget Transparency - Natia GULUA, Georgia
Budget Transparency - Natia GULUA, Georgia
 
Speech, Avdullah Hoti, SIGMA, Paris, 4 December 2015
Speech, Avdullah Hoti, SIGMA, Paris, 4 December 2015Speech, Avdullah Hoti, SIGMA, Paris, 4 December 2015
Speech, Avdullah Hoti, SIGMA, Paris, 4 December 2015
 
Ipsasb panel ron_salole_en
Ipsasb panel ron_salole_enIpsasb panel ron_salole_en
Ipsasb panel ron_salole_en
 
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
 
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνουγράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γ.παπακωνσταντίνου
 
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
ΓΡΑΜΜΑ ΠΡΟΘΕΣΗΣ Γ.ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ
 
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνουγράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
γράμμα πρόθεσης του γιώργου παπακωνσταντίνου
 
Managing public money
Managing public moneyManaging public money
Managing public money
 
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
101115_Taipei__PFM_Final
 
Roundtable on developments in budgeting - Gelardina PRODANI, Albania
Roundtable on developments in budgeting - Gelardina PRODANI, AlbaniaRoundtable on developments in budgeting - Gelardina PRODANI, Albania
Roundtable on developments in budgeting - Gelardina PRODANI, Albania
 
The Cash Basis Ipsas An Alternative View
The Cash Basis Ipsas An Alternative ViewThe Cash Basis Ipsas An Alternative View
The Cash Basis Ipsas An Alternative View
 
Public financial management reforms
Public financial management reformsPublic financial management reforms
Public financial management reforms
 

Mehr von icgfmconference

Mehr von icgfmconference (20)

2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
 
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
 
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_frDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_spDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_enDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
 
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_enDay3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
 
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_enDay3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
 
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_enDay3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
 
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_enDay3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_frDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_spDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_enDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_frDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_spDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_enDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_enDay2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
daisycvs
 
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in OmanMifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
instagramfab782445
 
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan CytotecJual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
ZurliaSoop
 
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pillsMifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Abortion pills in Kuwait Cytotec pills in Kuwait
 
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Nauman Safdar
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Cracking the 'Career Pathing' Slideshare
Cracking the 'Career Pathing' SlideshareCracking the 'Career Pathing' Slideshare
Cracking the 'Career Pathing' Slideshare
 
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
 
Katrina Personal Brand Project and portfolio 1
Katrina Personal Brand Project and portfolio 1Katrina Personal Brand Project and portfolio 1
Katrina Personal Brand Project and portfolio 1
 
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration PresentationUneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
Uneak White's Personal Brand Exploration Presentation
 
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All TimeCall 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
Call 7737669865 Vadodara Call Girls Service at your Door Step Available All Time
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investorsFalcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
Lundin Gold - Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation (Revised)
Lundin Gold - Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation (Revised)Lundin Gold - Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation (Revised)
Lundin Gold - Q1 2024 Conference Call Presentation (Revised)
 
Power point presentation on enterprise performance management
Power point presentation on enterprise performance managementPower point presentation on enterprise performance management
Power point presentation on enterprise performance management
 
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in OmanMifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
 
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
 
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck TemplateNew 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
 
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan CytotecJual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
 
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pillsMifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
 
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for ViewingMckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
Mckinsey foundation level Handbook for Viewing
 
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
 
HomeRoots Pitch Deck | Investor Insights | April 2024
HomeRoots Pitch Deck | Investor Insights | April 2024HomeRoots Pitch Deck | Investor Insights | April 2024
HomeRoots Pitch Deck | Investor Insights | April 2024
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
 
Rice Manufacturers in India | Shree Krishna Exports
Rice Manufacturers in India | Shree Krishna ExportsRice Manufacturers in India | Shree Krishna Exports
Rice Manufacturers in India | Shree Krishna Exports
 
Famous Olympic Siblings from the 21st Century
Famous Olympic Siblings from the 21st CenturyFamous Olympic Siblings from the 21st Century
Famous Olympic Siblings from the 21st Century
 

Hadden public financial management in government of kosovo

  • 1. Public Financial Management Reform in Kosovo Doug Hadden, FreeBalance dhadden@freebalance.com Executive Overview The Government of Kosovo has achieved remarkable results in Public Financial Management (PFM) reform. This post-conflict country once managed through a United Nations mandate has sequenced legal reform, improved governance, and achieved international PFM standards under difficult conditions. Sequencing PFM reform is considered a good government practice, although “it is impossible to prescribe a sequence of reforms which is appropriate in all circumstances (DFID 2001).” There are numerous lessons in the Kosovo experience linking reform to context that can be leveraged by governments around the world. Achievements Importance of Public Financial  Improved governance as demonstrated Management Reform by Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA) assessments Research has shown a statistically relevant link  Appropriate sequencing of PFM reform between good governance indicators and  Capacity built for budget execution, cash development (Kaufmann, Kraay & Mastruzzi management and procurement 2008). For example, countries whose government-wide governments achieve higher good governance  Decentralization of budget execution indicators tend to have higher GDP per capita reflecting successful capacity building and longer average life expectancy.  PFM achieving International and European standards PFM reform is acknowledged to be a mechanism to improve good governance. “The quality of public financial management (PFM) systems is a key determinant of government effectiveness. The capacity to direct, manage and track public spending allows governments to pursue their national objectives and account for the use of public resources and donor funds (de Renzio & Dorotinsky 2007).” Financial Management Information Systems (FMIS) or Government Resource Planning (Government Resource Planning) are recognized as technology tools to assist in PFM reform. “The establishment of an FMIS has consequently become an important benchmark for the country’s budget reform agenda, often regarded as a precondition for achieving effective management of the budgetary resources. Although it is not a panacea, the benefits of an FMIS could be argued to be profound. (Diamond & Khemani 2005).” History of PFM Reform in Kosovo PFM reform in Kosovo began with the United Nations Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) in 1999. UNMIK created an administrative structure creating the “Central Fiscal Authority (CFA), later renamed the Ministry of Finance and Economy (MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY) (Rodin-Brown 2008).” The financial system was upgraded through the use of an Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS) funded by the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), the Swedish International Development Agency (SIDA), and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) (Rodin- Brown 2008). International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 13
  • 2. USAID provided funding for “the main areas of government fiscal management: tax policy and analysis, tax administration, expenditure policy, budget management and control, intergovernmental fiscal relations, and sub- national government finance (USAID, South Eastern Europe Regional Comparisons & 2006).” Government Challenges Since 1999, the Government of Kosovo has  Lowest per capita GDP PPP enhanced legal reform, control, fiscal decentralization and purchasing. Challenges Economic Kosovo has experienced dire macroeconomic conditions during and after the breakup of the Yugoslav federation. The economy “was essentially decimated  Highest unemployment by the Kosovo War (Tang 2010).” “Kosovo is one of the poorest countries in Europe (World Bank 2009).” Improved economic development is critical to country stability (Bytyci 2009). Capacity and Sustainability Like many post-conflict countries, Kosovo has been challenged to effectively and financially achieve sustainable PFM reform. PFM capacity needed to be built.  Lowest Human Development Index “The Albanian-speaking majority who remained in Kosovo after the war did not include an experienced cadre of technical, professional and managerial specialists ready to take up key positions (USAID 2006).” Capacity building required government ownership in order to ensure sustainability. At first “public expenditure management in Kosovo was almost entirely handled by internationals (Sigma 2004).” Government Goals The Government of Kosovo has strategic plans to increase economic growth, improve governance, and reduce poverty (Tang 2010). These plans are also designed to achieve European Union membership (Tandberg & Pavesic-Skerlep 2009). Improved Governance and Transparency International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 14
  • 3. The Government of Kosovo recognizes how good governance can improve development results (MTEF 2009). Social cohesion can PEFA Assessments be achieved through governance reform  Donor Partnership: “PEFA aims to support through transparent institutions, integrated and harmonized approaches to decentralization and improved access to assessment and reform in the field of public expenditure, procurement and financial citizen services (World Bank 2009). accountability” The Government of Kosovo is now focused  Completed two Public Expenditure and on executing the full budget in order to Financial Accountability (PEFA) assessments achieve the best results (Tang 2010 and  Over 75 National and Sub-national PEFA assessments have been completed MTEF 2009). Public Expenditure and  Less than 10 countries have completed two Financial Accountability (PEFA) PEFA assessments assessments have been used by the PEFA Comparisons Government of Kosovo to set priorities for  Kosovo PEFA improvements from 2007 to 2009 improved governance. The Government of Kosovo has achieved significant improvements in governance between 2007 and 2009 according to the PEFA assessments. The 2009 PEFA assessment exceeds PEFA assessment averages (de Renzio 2009). This assessment also exceeds the average for South Eastern Europe, although many countries in the region have not completed a PEFA assessment or have not completed an assessment for more than two years. It should be noted that the government  Kosovo exceeds international average context is critical in assessing PFM. Governments focus on those assessment criteria that is critical for improvement. Even the Government of Norway was not able to achieve top marks across all criteria (Mundal 2008). The Government of Kosovo has achieved excellent results (B and higher) for over half of the assessment criteria. 2009 Kosovo PEFA Assessment – “A”  PI-3 Aggregate revenue out-turn compared to original approved budget  PI-5 Classification of the budget  PI-7 Extent of unreported government operations  PI-16 Predictability in the availability of funds for commitment of expenditures  PI-17 Recording and management of cash balances, debt and guarantees  PI-25 Quality and timeliness of annual financial statements International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 15
  • 4. Sequence of PFM Reform in Kosovo Good Practice: Sequencing PFM Phasing of PFM “reform, through achieving gradual Reform manageable steps (DFID 2005)” is considered a good  Kosovo began with simple practice. The sequence of reform depends on the centralized financial management country context. “Implementing public finance  Initial system configured to reforms of any kind requires an understanding of the Yugoslav model before updating to entire public finance system in place in that country. international standards It requires an understanding of the institutional  Improvements to financial management processes followed arrangements (Rodin-Brown 2008).” legal reform Technology solutions like Government Resource  Decentralization to line ministries Planning should follow reform. “The Kosovo and municipal governments followed capacity building environment was unique; the fiscal management  Support of the Treasury Single requirements were NOT. System implementation can Account enables managing all be achieved in a matter of weeks; financial government funds management reform takes years (Brajshori 2007).”  Addition of government Governments tend to implement budget, treasury and accounting, fixed asset accounting standards before embarking on management and purchasing functionality in line with performance management initiatives (Tandberg & government objectives Pavesic-Skerlep 2009).  Development and improvement of Legal Reform the macro-fiscal framework including support of Medium Term Legal reform is required before embarking on public Expenditure Frameworks to align financial management reform (Spietzer 2008). budgets with government “Technology is an early building block in creating objectives good governance and must be introduced in a phased  Sequencing of transparency efforts including publishing implementation to allow absorption of key monthly, quarterly and yearly government reforms. Technology should be budget reports supported by sound governance legislation: rules, regulations, finance administrative instructions etc. (Brajshori 2007).” The Government of Kosovo has phased institution building with the legal framework (SIGMA 2009-PEM). This has resulted in a constitution in line with European standards (EU 2008). Legal reform has also enabled the support for public sector accounting standards such as the IMF Government Financial Statistics (GFS) and the International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) (Smith-EMSG 2009, PEFA, 2009). Budget and Treasury Management Financial management began by using the practices used by the Yugoslav model (Rodin- Brown 2008). The Kosovo Financial Management Information System (KFMIS), using the FreeBalance Accountability Suite, was initially implemented in 26 days to support budget controls (Rodin-Brown 2008). Successful implementation bred more reform (Brajshori 2007). The KFMIS was extended and modernized following the reform program set by the Government of Kosovo. Budget execution and treasury management were the initial priorities. Procurement, decentralization and revenue modernization followed. The modernization of PFM enables governments to establish credibility. The Government of Kosovo has established credibility International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 16
  • 5. in fiscal management by assuming a portion of Yugoslav government debt (World Bank 2009). Sequence of PFM Reform in Kosovo: 1999 to 2009 LEGAL REFORM TECHNOLOGY MODERNIZATION  Pilot Government Resource  UNMIK administration 1999 Planning system implemented in 26 days  Full Government Resource 2000 Planning project launched  UNMIK Regulation on the Establishment of the Kosovo Board on Standards for Financial 2001  Deployment to all 5 Regions Reporting (KBSFR)  Law on Kosovo Civil Service  Training and Certification of  Ministry of Finance and Economy established 2002 Ministry of Finance  Kosovo Accounting Standards (KAS) developed  Core system goes live  Sustainability and Capacity  Law on Financial Management and Training Accountability (LFMA)  System available in Serbian and  Law on Public Procurement 2003 Albanian  Public Service Laws on Recruitment,  Deployment to all 30 Probationary Period, Appeals, Termination Municipalities  Payroll interface  Revenues module goes live  Law on International Financial Agreements 2004  Local sustainability team in place  Public Service Law on Official Travel  Bank Electronic Interface  Medium Term Expenditure Framework introduced  Suppression of Corruption Law & creation of the  Budget system interface 2005 Office of Ombudsperson  VPN to all budget institutions  Public Service Laws on Gender Equality and Independent Oversight Board  Cash and Debt Management division created  All tax and not tax revenue implemented via  Asset Module goes live Treasury Single Account 2006  Disaster recover site established  Law on Internal Auditing  Purchasing Module goes live  Public Service Law on Civil Service Code of Conduct  First PEFA Assessment  Law on Preventing Conflict of Interest in  Support for IPSAS and GFS in 2007 Exercising Public Function Chart of Accounts and in 2006  Independent Anti-Corruption Agency financial reports established  Republic of Kosovo Constitution in force  Law on Public Financial Management and Accountability (LFMA) putting MTEF in legal  Chart of Accounts (COA) adapted force 2008 to support program oriented  Law on Local Government Finances (LLGF) budgeting  Law on Local Self Government (LLSG)  Law on Publicly Owned Enterprises  Second PEFA Assessment  Payment decentralization to  PFM Reform Action Plan hospitals and municipalities 2009  Law on Membership of the Republic of Kosovo  Regional treasuries closed in the International Monetary Fund and World  Enhanced reporting pilot International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 17
  • 6. Bank Group Organizations  Law on Public-Private-Partnerships and Concessions in Infrastructure and the Procedures for Their Award  Law on Internal Audit  Law on Public Debt  Law on Declaration and Origin of the Property and presents of Public Senior Officials  Law on Salaries of Civil Servants 2010  Law on the Civil Service of the Republic of Kosovo  Law on Access to Public Documents Important Developments Improving PFM has cross-cutting effects. Many challenges remain in Kosovo because of the historical and macro-economic situation. Nevertheless, there have been improved economic development, financial management, transparency and civil service capacity building. Economic Developments  “Kosovo and Albania were the only two countries in the Western Balkans that experienced positive economic growth in 2009 (Tang 2010).”  “Amidst signs that the worldwide recession is easing, the slowdown in Kosovo’s economic growth has remained orderly (IMF 2009/09).” Financial Management and Transparency  “Kosovo has made significant progress in establishing a workable public financial management system, including a sound legal framework (World Bank 2009).”  “The greatest strength of the Kosovo PFM is its treasury system; not because of its sophistication in terms of functionality or its classification system, but simply because it is comprehensive and is able to produce timely and reasonable analytical reports (PEFA 2007).”  “Treasury Department external audits show zero (or near-zero) errors. (Smith 2009-EMSG)”  “In the broad sense of the term, the internal control structure has been established in Kosovo. The basic legal framework is sound, with clear structures of accountability (SIGMA 2008).”  “Other strengths are found in the areas of internal audit and control and external audit where the process is in place and capacity is being built up for effective implementation (PEFA, 2009)  “Good fiscal reports are produced based on the information extracted from the treasury system and the reports from the Auditor General are available on the Internet (PEFA 2007).”  “Information about budget execution is produced monthly, quarterly and annually (SIGMA 2006- PEM)”  “Improvement in reports by structure of the budget and present fund balance commitment for each economic category and budgetary organization. All reports are presented in compliance with IPSAS. (PEFA 2009)”  “The quality of Treasury reporting has enabled complex strategic fiscal planning (i.e. MTEF) that is based on detailed current and historical fiscal analysis. Moreover, improvements in Treasury reporting have increased the level of public debate on fiscal issues, including within politics and media (USAID 2006).”  “The 2009-2011 Budget incorporated detailed multi-year ceilings for both capital and recurrent elements. Further, preparation has commenced in full accordance with the timetable specified in the LPFMA. Of most critical importance is that the MTEF was completed by the end of April, which is earlier than previous years and provides a solid base for the rest of the process. (Smith 2009-EMSG)”  Noticeable progress was achieved in the area of availability of main municipal budget process related documents to municipal stakeholders and general public. (Smith, 2009-EMSG)” Capacity Building  “Comprehensive Training and Certification Program and mentoring of local staff - some are still with Treasury after five years (Brajshori 2007)” International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 18
  • 7.  “A very strong macroeconomic analysis department exists. It is widely acknowledged to be an important and integral part of the MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY. The department uses a small but sophisticated macroeconomic model to perform regular forecasts of the Kosovo economy and analysis of specific issues (Smith 2007-EMSG).”  “This year, MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY staff took the lead in drafting the Budget Regulation and conducting necessary communication with the UNMIK Legal Office, with the Advisors playing mainly supportive roles. MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMY staff demonstrated its capacity to produce required budget documents, with increasing focus on improving the quality of the budget presentation. (Smith 2007-EMSG)”  “In contrast to preparation of the prior MTEF, which depended on internationals to develop and run the required macroeconomic models and to write most parts of the final document, the analysis and drafting of the 2008-2010 MTEF was largely a Kosovar effort (Redbern, Fox, Gellerson 2009).” Conclusions Road to Good Governance Kosovo Good Governance Regional Comparisons Globalization has created a  Kosovo needs to improve governance competitive environment for countries. Risk and opportunity are key drivers for businesses. Good governance creates country stability and encourages business investment to fuel economic growth. Improving governance is a strategic objective for the Government of Kosovo “to create an effective administration, professional, transparent in accordance with democratic principles and oriented towards providing the best possible services to citizens (MTEF 2010). Government Resource Planning Modernization Scorecard The scope of reform and modernization differs among governments based on the country context. Government Resource Planning functionality in the Government of Kosovo is comprehensive and decentralized. Further modernization of automation is part of the PFM Reform Action Plan. Functionality Decentralization Modernization  Budget controls  Line ministries  Segregation of duties Public Financial  Assets  Regions  IPSAS & GFS Management  Audit  Municipalities  Accrual accounting  Cash management  Bank reconciliation Government  Cash controls  EFT Treasury  Debt management  Delegated treasury  Treasury Single Management  Investment Account management  Cash forecasting  Procurement  e-Procurement Public Expenditure  Expenditure Controls  Delegated purchasing  Procurement Management  Purchasing transparency  Grant management International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 19
  • 8. Government  Non-tax revenue Receipts  Income tax  Local tax collection  Case management Management  Customs  Payroll  Recruitment  Pensions  Talent management Civil Service  Workforce  Capacity building  Management management  Performance appraisal  Succession planning  Civil service planning  Self-Service  PEFA assessments  Budget  Budget delegation  Program budgeting classifications  Bottom-up Budgets  MTEF Government  Management  Budget transparency Performance reporting  Macro-fiscal Management  Budget preparation  Local PEFA framework  Budget circular assessments  Scenario planning  Citizen services  Performance budgets  Outcome measures Items highlighted in white have been implemented, in gray have yet to be implemented Roadmap for Reform The Government of Kosovo Public Financial Management Reform Plan (PFMRAP 2009) identified numerous important reforms leveraging Government Resource Planning systems. Public Financial Management  Reduce under-spending particularly in important infrastructure projects and gradual increase in accrual reporting  Improve timeliness and accuracy of municipal financial data  Improve audit capacity for all budget organizations and reduce delays in reporting external audit reports Government Treasury Management  More timely revenue reconciliation and daily bank reconciliation reporting  Increase regularity of cash flow forecasts and link debt and cash management functionality Public Expenditure Management  Reach more markets in public tendering to ensure competitive pricing, simplify and monitor procurement procedures  Grants Commission to manage transfers to municipalities Government Receipts Management  Improve tax audits and reduce tax arrears while increasing the automation of tax management Civil Service Management  Improve payroll controls and payroll forecasting  Integration of human resources data to enable improve audit  Support civil service reform through automated human resource management  Upgrade ICT systems to support integrated human resources, payroll and financial management Government Performance Management  Improve budget formulation and strategic planning – ensure that budget calendar is followed  More effective multiple year planning including better linkage of budgets with government objectives  Use of performance information in budget preparation and improved monitoring and evaluation  Improve managerial reporting  Improve donor coordination International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 20
  • 9. Government of Kosovo Lessons Learned Many governments can leverage the experience of the Government of Kosovo. Other countries share many of the challenges and opportunities with Kosovo. Focus of Development  “Development strategy should be balanced between effectively implementing programs that could lessen societal tensions in the short-term while simultaneously putting in place the foundations for stable institutions and sustained growth in the medium- to longer-term (World Bank 2009).” Decentralization for Regional and Ethnic Issues  “Institutional strengthening and good governance, including effective central and municipal government and establishment of a level playing field for the different ethnic groups, will be crucial to longer term development and stability (World Bank 2009).” Technology Follows Reform  “Technology is an early building block in creating good governance and must be introduced in a phased implementation to allow absorption of key government reforms. Technology should be supported by sound governance legislation: rules, regulations, finance administrative instructions etc. (Brajshori 2007.)” Government Ownership Critical to Improvements  “Preparing a time-bound Public Financial Management Reform Action Plan designed to address the key weaknesses identified by the PEFA self-assessment (World Bank 2009).” Donor Co-ordination can Accelerate Development  “One of the most important issues affecting reforms in this area is the lack of effective donor co- ordination, which results in an ineffective use of most of the resources provided. (SIGMA 2009-PEM).” Bibliography Brajshori, Behxhet (2007) Achievements and Challenges in the Management of the Public Finances in Kosovo, International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management, http://www.icgfm.org/documents/Brajshori_kosovoEng.ppt Brajshori, Behxhet (2009) Brajshori. Economic and Financial Developments in Kosovo and the global crisis, International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management http://www.slideshare.net/icgfmconference/country-responses-to-the-financial-crisis-kosovo Bytyci, Fatos (2009) After billions in aid, Kosovo still poor and idle, Reuters http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBYT832920._CH_.2400 Department for International Development (2001) UK, Understanding and reforming public expenditure management http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.dfid.gov.uk/documents/publications/ pfma-pem.pdf -----------(2005) A Platform Approach to Improving Public Financial Management http://www.train4dev.net/fileadmin/Resources/General_Documents/DfID_A%20Platform%2 0Approach%20to%20PFM.pdf de Renzio, Paolo (2009) Taking Stock: What do PEFA Assessments tell us about PFM systems across countries Overseas Development Institute http://www.odi.org.uk/resources/download/3333.pdf Diamond, Jack, Khemani, Pokar (2005) Introducing Financial Management Information Systems in Developing Countries, International Monetary Fund http://www.unescobkk.org/fileadmin/user_upload/epr/MTEF/04Financial_Planning/02Moder International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 21
  • 10. nization_of_public_sector_management/040204004Diamond,%20J.%20and%20Khemani,% 20P.%20%282005%29.pdf Dorotinsky, William (2003)The World Bank’s Experience with Financial Management Information System, The World Bank http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTRANETFINANCIALMGMT/Resources/K-L/KL- COURSE-MATERIALS/ReviewWBprojIFMISdorotinsky.pdf European Union (2008) EU Commission Kosovo Progress Report http://www.wbc- inco.net/attach/kosovo_progress_report_en.pdf International Monetary Fund (2009/06) Republic of Kosovo—IMF Staff Visit Concluding Statement http://www.imf.org/external/np/ms/2009/062409.htm -----------(2009/09) Republic of Kosovo—IMF Staff Visit, Concluding Statement http://www.imf.org/external/np/ms/2009/091609.htm Kaufmann, Daniel, Kraay, Aart, Mastruzzi, Massimo (2008) Governance Matters VII: Aggregate and Individual Governance Indicators 1996-2007 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1148386 Kosovo, Government of, (PEFA 2007) Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA) Public Financial Management Assessment http://www.Ministry of Finance and Economy- ks.org/old/Shqip/English/mefwww/departamentet/pmakroekonomike/PEFA/pefaangmakro.p df ----------MidTerm Expenditures Framework (MTEF 2009), 2010-2012 http://www.mef- rks.org/en/download/mid-term-expenditure-framework/midterm-expenditures-framework- 2010-2012/2130-midterm-expenditures-framework-2010-2012/download ----------Medium Term Expenditures Framework 2011-2013 (MTEF 2010) http://www.mef- rks.org/en/download/mid-term-expenditure-framework/medium-term-expenditure- framework-2011--2013/2777-medium-term-expenditure-framework-2011--2013/download ----------Public Financial Management Reform Action Plan (PFM RAP 2009) http://www.mef-rks.org/en/download/other-publications-and-reports/2421-public-financial- management-reform-action-plan-pfm-rap/download ----------Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA 2009) Public Financial Management Assessment http://www.mef-rks.org/en/download/other-publications-and- reports/2032-public-expenditure-and-financial-accountability-pefa-public-financial- management-assessment Mundal, Håkon (2008) Public Financial Management Performance Report – Norway, Norwegian Agency for International Cooperation http://www.norad.no/en/Tools+and+publications/Publications/Publication+Page?key=109797 Redbern, F. Stevens, Fox, James W., Gellerson, Mark (2009) Evaluation of the Economic Management for Stability and Growth Program, Kosovo, United States Agency for International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACN920.pdf Rodin-Brown, Edwin (2008) Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: A Practical Guide, United States Agency for International Development http://www.fiscalreform.net/images/ifmis_rodinbrown_080425.pdf International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 22
  • 11. Smith, Matthew (2007-EMSG) Kosovo Economic Management for Stability and Growth, United States Agency for International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACL494.pdf -----------(2007-EDI) Kosovo Economic Development Initiative, Final Project Report, United States Agency for International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACL385.pdf -----------(2009-EMSG) Economic Management for Stability and Growth, Annual Report, United States Agency for International Development http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDACO702.pdf Spitzer, Deborah (2008) quoted at http://icgfm.blogspot.com/2008/12/good-practices-for- sequencing-pfm.html Support for Improvement in Governance and Management (SIGMA 2004) Public Expenditure Management in Kosovo https://www.sigmaweb.org/dataoecd/38/32/34991431.pdf -----------(SIGMA 2006-PEM) SIGMA Kosovo Public Expenditure Management Assessment http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/30/21/37739132.pdf -----------(SIGMA 2009-PEM) SIGMA Kosovo Public Expenditure Management System Assessment http://www.sigmaweb.org/dataoecd/31/42/43912978.pdf Symansky, Steven (2005) Public Expenditure Management in Post Conflict Countries, World Bank http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTRANETFINANCIALMGMT/Resources/K- L/KL-COURSE-MATERIALS/6sessionSymanskyPEMPostConflict.pdf Tanberg, Eivind, Pavesic-Skerlep, Mia (2009) Advanced Public Financial Management Reforms in South East Europe, International Monetary Fund http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/wp09102.pdf Tang, Stephanie (2010) Balance of Power: Kosovo Topic B: Economic Development in Kosovo, Northwestern University http://www.numun.org/pdfs/2010/BOP%20Kosovo%20Topic%20B.pdf United States Agency for International Development (2006) Kosovo Economic Reconstruction Project: Development Alternatives http://www.fiscalreform.net/pdfs/kosovo_tax_and_expenditure_2006.pdf World Bank (2009) Interim Strategy Note for Republic of Kosovo for the Period FY10- FY11, http://siteresources.worldbank.org/KOSOVOEXTN/Resources/297769- 1266424306995/Kosovo_full_report.pdf International Journal of Governmental Financial Management 23