SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 4
• Whitty (2002) sees a contradiction between
Labour's policies to tackle inequality and its
commitment to marketisation. EMA's encourage
working class students to stay on until they are
18-tuition fees deter people away from university.
• Also critics point out that there is a continued
existence of both selective grammar schools and
fee-paying private schools. Despite the Labour
Party's long-standing opposition to private
schools as bastions of middle and upper-class
privilege.
Gender
• The tripartite system has led girls to be included
in higher education.
• Policies like GIST have reduced gender
differences in subject choice.
Ethnicity
• Policies aimed at improving achievement of
children from minority ethnic backgrounds have
gone through several phases.
• Assimilation policies focused on the need for pupils to
assimilate into mainstream British culture as a way of
raising their achievement.
• Multicultural education (MCE) policies aimed to
promote achievements from minority ethnic groups by
valuing all cultures in the school curriculum thereby
raising minority achievements. The MCE has been
criticised on several grounds:
• Maureen Stone argues that black pupils do not fail for
lack of self esteem, so MCE is misguided.
• The New Right criticise MCE for perpetuating cultural
divisions.
• Social inclusion of pupils and policies to raise
achievement of minority ethnic groups. Policies include:
• the detailed monitoring of exam results by ethnicity and
help for voluntary 'Saturday schools' in the black
community.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - Redação
Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - RedaçãoComo a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - Redação
Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - RedaçãoMatheus Alves
 
Religion and social change 1
Religion and social change 1Religion and social change 1
Religion and social change 1Beth Lee
 
Functionalist theories of religion
Functionalist theories of religionFunctionalist theories of religion
Functionalist theories of religionlil-slide-share
 
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolar
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolarAtual prática da avaliação educacional escolar
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolarRenato Feliciano
 
Functionalism sociology
Functionalism sociologyFunctionalism sociology
Functionalism sociologytaialynn3
 
Globalisation, democracy and social movements
Globalisation, democracy and social movementsGlobalisation, democracy and social movements
Globalisation, democracy and social movements17525709
 
Theories of religion
Theories of religionTheories of religion
Theories of religionMomna Rani
 
Seminário química orgânica
Seminário química orgânicaSeminário química orgânica
Seminário química orgânicaCristina Monteiro
 

Was ist angesagt? (10)

Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - Redação
Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - RedaçãoComo a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - Redação
Como a meritocracia contribui para a desigualdade social - Redação
 
Religion and social change 1
Religion and social change 1Religion and social change 1
Religion and social change 1
 
Eleições e reforma eleitoral no Brasil
Eleições e reforma eleitoral no BrasilEleições e reforma eleitoral no Brasil
Eleições e reforma eleitoral no Brasil
 
Functionalist theories of religion
Functionalist theories of religionFunctionalist theories of religion
Functionalist theories of religion
 
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolar
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolarAtual prática da avaliação educacional escolar
Atual prática da avaliação educacional escolar
 
Functionalism sociology
Functionalism sociologyFunctionalism sociology
Functionalism sociology
 
Globalisation, democracy and social movements
Globalisation, democracy and social movementsGlobalisation, democracy and social movements
Globalisation, democracy and social movements
 
Theories of religion
Theories of religionTheories of religion
Theories of religion
 
Seminário química orgânica
Seminário química orgânicaSeminário química orgânica
Seminário química orgânica
 
Introdução à química
Introdução à químicaIntrodução à química
Introdução à química
 

Andere mochten auch

Pierre bourdieu (1984)
Pierre bourdieu (1984)Pierre bourdieu (1984)
Pierre bourdieu (1984)farzana0596
 
Crime and mass media
Crime and mass mediaCrime and mass media
Crime and mass mediaRimab96
 
Gender differences in education
Gender differences in educationGender differences in education
Gender differences in educationfarzana0596
 
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capital
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capitalBourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capital
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capitallucylee79
 
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and Agency
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and AgencyBourdieu, Pierre: Structure and Agency
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and AgencyRara Pun
 
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieu
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre BourdieuSTRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieu
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieuelma22
 
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2guest576281
 
Self fulfilling prophecy
Self fulfilling prophecySelf fulfilling prophecy
Self fulfilling prophecyfarzana0596
 
The role of education
The role of educationThe role of education
The role of educationfarzana0596
 
Material deprivation theory of education
Material deprivation theory of educationMaterial deprivation theory of education
Material deprivation theory of educationlucylee79
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre BourdieuPierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieudave0493
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu Vilma H
 
Tohoku earthquake case study
Tohoku earthquake case studyTohoku earthquake case study
Tohoku earthquake case studyRuth1618
 
Field theory pierre_bourdieu
Field theory pierre_bourdieuField theory pierre_bourdieu
Field theory pierre_bourdieuDavid Engelby
 
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivation
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural DeprivationAS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivation
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivationkirstyodair
 

Andere mochten auch (20)

Pierre bourdieu (1984)
Pierre bourdieu (1984)Pierre bourdieu (1984)
Pierre bourdieu (1984)
 
Ethnicity
EthnicityEthnicity
Ethnicity
 
Crime and mass media
Crime and mass mediaCrime and mass media
Crime and mass media
 
Gender differences in education
Gender differences in educationGender differences in education
Gender differences in education
 
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capital
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capitalBourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capital
Bourdieu and Gerwitz- cultural capital
 
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and Agency
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and AgencyBourdieu, Pierre: Structure and Agency
Bourdieu, Pierre: Structure and Agency
 
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieu
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre BourdieuSTRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieu
STRUCTURES AND THE HABITUS- Pierre Bourdieu
 
Question 6
Question 6Question 6
Question 6
 
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2
June 2009 Mark Schemes Paper 1 And 2
 
Self fulfilling prophecy
Self fulfilling prophecySelf fulfilling prophecy
Self fulfilling prophecy
 
Pupil subcultures
Pupil subculturesPupil subcultures
Pupil subcultures
 
The role of education
The role of educationThe role of education
The role of education
 
Material deprivation theory of education
Material deprivation theory of educationMaterial deprivation theory of education
Material deprivation theory of education
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre BourdieuPierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre BourdieuPierre Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu
 
Tohoku earthquake case study
Tohoku earthquake case studyTohoku earthquake case study
Tohoku earthquake case study
 
Field theory pierre_bourdieu
Field theory pierre_bourdieuField theory pierre_bourdieu
Field theory pierre_bourdieu
 
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivation
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural DeprivationAS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivation
AS Sociology Unit 2 (Education) - Cultural Deprivation
 
Pierre Bourdieu
Pierre      BourdieuPierre      Bourdieu
Pierre Bourdieu
 

Ähnlich wie Criticisms of new labour policies

Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriageCan christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage2idseminar
 
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)AmitsinghBhadoria
 
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdf
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdfWrite about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdf
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdfuplevelway
 
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxLecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxJohanNoren1
 
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxLecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxJohanNoren1
 
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptx
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptxNew-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptx
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptxSibaramPanda8
 
New education-policy-2020-ppt-
New education-policy-2020-ppt-New education-policy-2020-ppt-
New education-policy-2020-ppt-mail2robinson
 
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...IDSP - IE Dissertation Support Project
 
201.17 medicine and health care
201.17 medicine and health care201.17 medicine and health care
201.17 medicine and health carecjsmann
 
Foundation of education 12
Foundation of education 12Foundation of education 12
Foundation of education 12Channy Leang
 
Higher education in the times of massification
Higher education in the times of massificationHigher education in the times of massification
Higher education in the times of massificationAnup Singh
 
Sociology of education
Sociology of educationSociology of education
Sociology of educationdwessler
 
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 education
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 educationSAT/WSA Study materials 1 education
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 educationJiayu Shen
 
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.pptwelduweldegebriel1
 
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.pptwelduweldegebriel1
 
Week 1 Globalization of Education
Week 1 Globalization of EducationWeek 1 Globalization of Education
Week 1 Globalization of EducationElliott Betrand
 
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociology
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociologyEverything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociology
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociologyZoe Dobson
 
Thomas Huddleston
Thomas HuddlestonThomas Huddleston
Thomas Huddlestonfedactio
 
Week 9: Education
Week 9: Education Week 9: Education
Week 9: Education kilgore1
 

Ähnlich wie Criticisms of new labour policies (20)

Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriageCan christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
 
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)
New education-policy-2020 by - amit singh bhadoria(b.com 1 st year)
 
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdf
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdfWrite about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdf
Write about the historical aspect of Gender in Education in India.pdf
 
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxLecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
 
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptxLecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
Lecture 16 Basic Education - SOCI1004.pptx
 
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptx
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptxNew-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptx
New-Education-Policy-2020-PPT-Aarohan.pptx
 
New education-policy-2020-ppt-
New education-policy-2020-ppt-New education-policy-2020-ppt-
New education-policy-2020-ppt-
 
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...
+IDSP20C - E1- Isabel Kempner - School councils: democratic forums or exclusi...
 
201.17 medicine and health care
201.17 medicine and health care201.17 medicine and health care
201.17 medicine and health care
 
Foundation of education 12
Foundation of education 12Foundation of education 12
Foundation of education 12
 
Higher education in the times of massification
Higher education in the times of massificationHigher education in the times of massification
Higher education in the times of massification
 
Sociology of education
Sociology of educationSociology of education
Sociology of education
 
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 education
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 educationSAT/WSA Study materials 1 education
SAT/WSA Study materials 1 education
 
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
 
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt201.18 Educational Systems  and Institutions.ppt
201.18 Educational Systems and Institutions.ppt
 
Week 1 Globalization of Education
Week 1 Globalization of EducationWeek 1 Globalization of Education
Week 1 Globalization of Education
 
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociology
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociologyEverything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociology
Everything education, SY2 (understanding culture) sociology
 
Powerpoint5
Powerpoint5Powerpoint5
Powerpoint5
 
Thomas Huddleston
Thomas HuddlestonThomas Huddleston
Thomas Huddleston
 
Week 9: Education
Week 9: Education Week 9: Education
Week 9: Education
 

Mehr von farzana0596

Mehr von farzana0596 (12)

The role of education
The role of educationThe role of education
The role of education
 
The role of education
The role of educationThe role of education
The role of education
 
The Role of Education
The Role of EducationThe Role of Education
The Role of Education
 
Beliefs in society student blog
Beliefs in society   student blogBeliefs in society   student blog
Beliefs in society student blog
 
Notes for sociology
Notes for sociologyNotes for sociology
Notes for sociology
 
Editing
EditingEditing
Editing
 
Q1
Q1Q1
Q1
 
Q7
Q7Q7
Q7
 
Storyboard final
Storyboard final Storyboard final
Storyboard final
 
Movie
MovieMovie
Movie
 
Shooting schedule 2
Shooting schedule 2Shooting schedule 2
Shooting schedule 2
 
Shooting schedule
Shooting scheduleShooting schedule
Shooting schedule
 

Criticisms of new labour policies

  • 1.
  • 2. • Whitty (2002) sees a contradiction between Labour's policies to tackle inequality and its commitment to marketisation. EMA's encourage working class students to stay on until they are 18-tuition fees deter people away from university. • Also critics point out that there is a continued existence of both selective grammar schools and fee-paying private schools. Despite the Labour Party's long-standing opposition to private schools as bastions of middle and upper-class privilege.
  • 3. Gender • The tripartite system has led girls to be included in higher education. • Policies like GIST have reduced gender differences in subject choice. Ethnicity • Policies aimed at improving achievement of children from minority ethnic backgrounds have gone through several phases.
  • 4. • Assimilation policies focused on the need for pupils to assimilate into mainstream British culture as a way of raising their achievement. • Multicultural education (MCE) policies aimed to promote achievements from minority ethnic groups by valuing all cultures in the school curriculum thereby raising minority achievements. The MCE has been criticised on several grounds: • Maureen Stone argues that black pupils do not fail for lack of self esteem, so MCE is misguided. • The New Right criticise MCE for perpetuating cultural divisions. • Social inclusion of pupils and policies to raise achievement of minority ethnic groups. Policies include: • the detailed monitoring of exam results by ethnicity and help for voluntary 'Saturday schools' in the black community.