van Asten P. 2014. Implementing Climate-Smart Agriculture. Copenhagen, Denmark: CGIAR Research Program on Climate Change, Agriculture and Food Security.
Contents:
1. CCAFS – what we do
2. What is CSA in the African context
3. Best bet CSA technologies
4. CSA services and approaches
5. How can we identify the priorities?
6. Collaborative possibilities
2. 1. CCAFS – what we do
2. What is CSA in the African context
3. Best bet CSA technologies
4. CSA services and approaches
5. How can we identify the priorities?
6. Collaborative possibilities
3. 1. Climate-Smart technologies, practices, and
portfolios
3. Low emissions
development
2. Climate information services and climate-informed
safety nets
4. Policies and institutions for climate-resilient
food systems
4. #1. Outcome orientated
• E.g. research measured by
tracking development targets
not publications
• Well developed theories of
change
#2. Partnership focussed
• Involves all 15 CGIAR
Centres and non-CGIAR
Centres
• Development partners are
crucial for success
#3. Major focus on gender and
social inequality
• 10% of the budget to make
sure that technologoes and
approaches empower
marginalised groups and
women
5. #4. Part of the development process
Working with partners to change
opinions and worldviews
Working with
partners to
understand what
works
Working with
partners to make
it happen
Research evidence
Policy and
Institutional Change
CSA implementation
10. Alternate-Wetting-and-Drying
Keep flooded for
1st 15 days and
at Flowering Irrigate
when water drops to
15 cm below the
surface
Summer/
Autumn
Winter/
Spring
30% water
20-50% GHG
Without compromising
yield
(AWD)
12. Conservation Agriculture
Reduces soil
erosion by
up to 80%
Buffers
against
drought
Reduces loss of
soil organic carbon
Country
Area under
CA (1000 ha)
CA as % of
arable land*
Zimbabwe 332 8.3%
Zambia 200 5.6%
Mozambique 152 2.7%
Malawi 65 1.7%
Kenya 33 0.6%
Tanzania 25 0.2%
Source: FAO Conservation Agriculture Program and FAOSTAT, 2014
13. Conservation Agriculture – tailoring to
social context
Farmer type 1 –
hand hoes
Farmer type 2 –
ox ploughs
Step 1 Planting basins or
pointed stick for
planting directly
into residues
Tillage only in
narrow furrows
Some form of mechanical weeding or
introduce herbicides if market available
Step 2 Graduate from
hand hoes to jab
planters if market
can supply, or
access contracting
services
Replace plough
with no-till direct
seeders
Jab planters
Photo: J. Kienzle/FAO
No-till direct seeder
Photo: T. Lumpkin/CIMMYT
Planting basins
Photo: ICRISAT
Tillage in narrow furrows
Photo: CFU
14. NIGER Bringing back the Sahel’s ‘underground forest’
5 million ha of land restored, over
200 million trees re-established
•Additional half a million tonnes
of grain per year
•Reduces drought impacts
•Sequestration of carbon in soil
and trees
15. AFRICA Drought-tolerant maize boosts food security
DTMA has developed 100
new varieties released
across 13 countries; 2
million smallholders
•Yields up to 35% more grain
•Resilience to drought
• Reduces need to use more land
16. Hardy Animals in Nyando, Climate-Smart Villages, Kenya
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
2010/11 2012 2013
Percentage HHs
Not introduced any new animal types or
breeds
Introduced 1 or 2 new animal types
and/or new breeds
Introduced 3 or more new animal types
and/or new breeds
n=140 n=320
Pure Galla goats and Galla goat crosses
Pure Red Maasai Sheep and
Red Maasai Sheep Crosses
n=200
Outcomes, 2011 to 2013; ILRI and partners
• (33%) more HHs introduced 3 or more new animal types in 2012 compared to (20%) in 2013 I relation to the baseline year of 2010/11.
• In 2013, 61% of households applied the changes to resilient galla goats (tolerate heat, fast growth rate, mature early) as compared to
(48%) to the hardy Red Maasai sheep (tolerate heat, better withstand parasite load, fast growth rate).
• Adoption of these changes has led to an increase, adding nearly 1,000 improved crosses to the local small ruminant population in 7
villages in Nyando
18. Seasonal weather
forecasts in Senegal
15 community radio stations
2 million farmers get forecasts
better food security outcomes
19. Index-based insurance
• Allows for rapid pay-outs when the level of a
weather indicator hits a certain value
• Needs good local weather data
• Can be linked to input markets (e.g. Insurance
paid on input purchases)
• Can be cell phone linked (pyaments and
payouts)
20. Climate-smart villages
Index-based
insurance
Climate
information
services
Climate-smart
technologies
Local
adaptation
plans
• Policy
• Private sector
• Development
initiatives
• Learning sites
• Multiple partners
21. Local adaptation planning: One women’s present is another women’s future
1. Identify climate analogues
2. Farmer-to-farmer visits
22. Getting the message out: ag advisories
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Relative 2012 = 100%
Food
demand
Grain yield
per ha
GDP
Cell phone
penetration
Global Harvest Initiative 2013
FAOSTAT
World Bank/Standard Chartered
GSMA/Deloitte
Sub-Saharan Africa
30. Our vision
• To be a knowledge partner on major
development initiatives
• To listen so we do the research that matters
to you
Our questions
• How can we back-stop development efforts?
• What are your priority needs for moving CSA
forward?
31. www.ccafs.cgiar.org
Sign up for science, policy and news e-bulletins
Twitter: @cgiarclimate @bcampbell_CGIAR
Hinweis der Redaktion
We believe we do research in a very different way from most research organisations. Why? Here are four reasons
Outcome orientated
Partnership focused ......... (after second bullet point) We have formed a knowledge partnership with IFAD that involves jointly identifying, and then producing, the knowledge products needed to drive IFADs billion dollar program
Major focus on gender and social inequality
Part of the development process.... As the next slide shows
This shows how CA has to be tailored to context; and how CA performs is dependent also on agro-ecological conditions
Farmer Managed Natural Regeneration (FMTR) is spreading across southern Niger, Burkina Faso, Mali and Senegal.
The structure and fertility of the soil has improved = rain soaks into the soil more readily and water tables have risen in some places, making water more accessible and available to plants and people alike.
Together, these changes have increased the resilience of farming systems to extreme weather events, diversifying sources of food and income and protecting land and water resources.
goods and services provided by indigenous trees: timber, firewood, fodder, fibre, medicines, fruits, edible leaves and nuts, fodder, dyes and many environmental services.
We have looked at some examples of technologies; now let us consider more general services and approaches that can help in the uptake of technologies
Better climate forecasts for farmers are crucial.
In Senegal, CCAFS worked with the Met Service and Ag Ministry. In the first two seasons we examined ways that people use (traditional knowlege) to forecast the seasonal weather. We also worked with men and women farmers to understand waht seasonal forecasts were wanted; and in what form. We also supplied seasonal forecasts to some farmers and examined what they did with the forecasts. Farmers receiving and using seasonal forecasts were found to have better food security outcomes.
In the third season, working with the national met service and 15 comunity radio stations, seasonal forecasts were received by about 2 million farmers. The prediction is that htis leads to better food security outcomes – this is now being examined through an imapct assesssment by an external evaluator.
One crucial ingredient for this kind of work is a better working relationship between the NMS and the ag ministry.
This shows how CA has to be tailored to context; and how CA performs is dependent also on agro-ecological conditions
This shows how CA has to be tailored to context; and how CA performs is dependent also on agro-ecological conditions
A crucial part of CSA is broader adaptation planning at the local level.
One tool we use is the climate analogue tool.
You can click your locality on a map, and then the tool tells you where you must go to get a vision of your future climate.
We then work with farmers to visit such sites. Farmers get inspired by what they see and realise some elements of their future.
This leads into local adaptation planning; where farmers indicate the kinds of things they are able to do and would wish to do if they had more resources.
These are trends all put on the same relative scale.
Food demand going forward is not being matched by yield increases
But, we are not that pessimistic – Africa is on the rise – witness GDP
Cell phone coverage is going through the roof.
We think the future is in cell phone advisories, and will assume that within a decade all farmers in SSA have access to smart phones.
In Nigeria, the government has now registered 80% of its farmers on cell phones.
In Kenya, our study sites show 60% access to cell phones.
So, we need much more efort in cell-phone driven development
These are trends all put on the same relative scale.
Food demand going forward is not being matched by yield increases
But, we are not that pessimistic – Africa is on the rise – witness GDP
Cell phone coverage is going through the roof.
We think the future is in cell phone advisories, and will assume that within a decade all farmers in SSA have access to smart phones.
In Nigeria, the government has now registered 80% of its farmers on cell phones.
In Kenya, our study sites show 60% access to cell phones.
So, we need much more efort in cell-phone driven development
There are a vast amount of possible technologies and approaches – where do we put our efforts; what gets selected where?
We have been trying the following approach, first in Colombia where it worked well, and now in Mali. In Colombia the government used it to prioritse its climate smart national investments. It can be used at country level or at project level. We will also do it with the NEPAD CSA Allaiance.
Hit enter!
Key points:
Start with generic list from compendium
Narrow list using indicators of CSA pillars and dimensions
Use weighting of CSA pillars, dimensions, and individual indicators to get a ranked list of “best-bet” practices
Further narrow using economic analysis (CBA)
Address barriers of practices
Great portfolios based on user – discuss tradeoffs across pillars and dimensions for portfolios, discuss barriers and how to address these with the aim of increasing effective implementation
The first step in the prioritisation process was putting together a list of global possibilities. We have now documented 150+ technologies, showing many characteristics (e-g. Agroecologivcal zone, characteristics of the system etc.).
Where the previous exercise is done at Country level, this can lead to country profiles. We are now completing six countries in Latin America, and are considering starting in Africa
Where the previous exercise is done at Country level, this can lead to country profiles. We are now completing six countries in Latin America, and are considering starting in Africa
Where the previous exercise is done at Country level, this can lead to country profiles. We are now completing six countries in Latin America, and are considering starting in Africa