SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 32
Social Identity, Natural Resources,  & Peacebuilding Arthur Green McGill University 28 June 2010 CAPRi International Research Workshop on Collective Action, Property Rights, and Conflict in NRM Siem Reap, Cambodia
www.onepennysheet.com www.daylife.com ,[object Object]
Arguments ,[object Object],[object Object]
Arguments ,[object Object],[object Object]
Outline of Presentation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Three Main Questions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Context ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Theoretical Framework I: Social Identity? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Theoretical Framework II: Social Identity? ,[object Object],[object Object]
Theoretical Framework III: Five Links ,[object Object]
Theoretical Framework IV: Five Links ,[object Object],[object Object]
Theoretical Framework V: Five Links ,[object Object],[object Object]
Methods ,[object Object],Chiapas, Mexico: Desk review and interviews with experts. Aceh, Indonesia: Dissertation fieldwork, interviews (experts and locals), and survey data.
Case Study I: Aceh, Indonesia ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Case Study I: Aceh, Indonesia ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Case study II: Abyei, Sudan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Case study II: Abyei, Sudan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Case Study III:  Chiapas, Mexico (Kate Luscher)
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Case Study III:  Chiapas, Mexico Acteal Massacre 1997 (www.libertadlatina.org)
Conclusion: Possible Policy Responses Social identity–natural resource link Possible policy responses 1. Resources are at the center of conflicts between groups that have mobilized according to historic identity frames or defined themselves in reference to the resource conflict. ,[object Object],[object Object],2. Social identities are the main way in which people organize resources in the absence of a centralized territorial authority. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Social identity–natural resource link Possible policy responses 3. Resources have symbolic cultural or political meaning and may be indivisible.  ,[object Object],[object Object],4. Winning or losing takes on a symbolic significance even if the resources themselves are of marginal importance. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],5. Spillover into non-conflict related resources. ,[object Object]
Conclusion: Future Research ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thank You! Arthur (Gill) Green  [email_address]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Policy responses ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Policy responses ,[object Object],[object Object]
Policy responses ,[object Object],[object Object]
Policy responses ,[object Object]
Violent Conflict, SI, and NR ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Violent Conflict, SI, and NR ,[object Object],[object Object]

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch

How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...
How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...
How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...CAPRi
 
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...CAPRi
 
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...CAPRi
 
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...CAPRi
 
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...CAPRi
 
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical Framework
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical FrameworkResource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical Framework
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical FrameworkCAPRi
 
TV in the 21st Century
TV in the 21st CenturyTV in the 21st Century
TV in the 21st CenturySpencer97
 
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptx
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptxJosé patiño p´ractica 3.pptx
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptxjose20031991
 
The fall of advertising
The fall of advertisingThe fall of advertising
The fall of advertisingsallygudewill
 
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition Report
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition ReportExpedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition Report
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition ReportPatrick Sheng-Hua Huang
 
Fiscalidad en internet
Fiscalidad en internet Fiscalidad en internet
Fiscalidad en internet mayragn23
 
Forest conflict in Asia & collective action
Forest conflict in Asia & collective actionForest conflict in Asia & collective action
Forest conflict in Asia & collective actionCAPRi
 
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...CAPRi
 
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...CAPRi
 
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle Profile
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle ProfileUploading Videos to Your Kloodle Profile
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle ProfilePhillip Hayes
 
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)Andrew Donnelly
 
Filling in your employment history on Kloodle
Filling in your employment history on KloodleFilling in your employment history on Kloodle
Filling in your employment history on KloodlePhillip Hayes
 
Third party involvement in collective water governance
Third party involvement in collective water governanceThird party involvement in collective water governance
Third party involvement in collective water governanceCAPRi
 

Andere mochten auch (20)

How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...
How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...
How can collective action and customary laws help to manage conflicts over na...
 
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...
Local Community vs Oil Palm Plantation Company: Two case studies from West Ka...
 
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...
Role of Customary Law and Communities in Natural Resource Management in Post-...
 
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...
LOOKING BEYOND THE OBVIOUS: Uncovering the features of natural resource confl...
 
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...
Political Conflicts and Community Forestry: Understanding the Impact of the D...
 
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical Framework
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical FrameworkResource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical Framework
Resource Conflict, Collective Action, and Resilience: An Analytical Framework
 
TV in the 21st Century
TV in the 21st CenturyTV in the 21st Century
TV in the 21st Century
 
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptx
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptxJosé patiño p´ractica 3.pptx
José patiño p´ractica 3.pptx
 
The fall of advertising
The fall of advertisingThe fall of advertising
The fall of advertising
 
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition Report
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition ReportExpedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition Report
Expedition - Raleigh Int. 15K Expedition Report
 
Fiscalidad en internet
Fiscalidad en internet Fiscalidad en internet
Fiscalidad en internet
 
Forest conflict in Asia & collective action
Forest conflict in Asia & collective actionForest conflict in Asia & collective action
Forest conflict in Asia & collective action
 
TIK BAB 5 DAN 6
TIK BAB 5 DAN 6TIK BAB 5 DAN 6
TIK BAB 5 DAN 6
 
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...
 
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...
The Outbreak of Peace: Communal Land Management and Traditional Governance in...
 
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle Profile
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle ProfileUploading Videos to Your Kloodle Profile
Uploading Videos to Your Kloodle Profile
 
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)
Kloodle - Shaban Dar (new)
 
Filling in your employment history on Kloodle
Filling in your employment history on KloodleFilling in your employment history on Kloodle
Filling in your employment history on Kloodle
 
Color theory 2015
Color theory 2015Color theory 2015
Color theory 2015
 
Third party involvement in collective water governance
Third party involvement in collective water governanceThird party involvement in collective water governance
Third party involvement in collective water governance
 

Ähnlich wie Social Identity, Natural Resources, & Peacebuilding

Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequality
Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequalitySocio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequality
Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequalityInfoMenu Engineering
 
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docx
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docxWeek 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docx
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docxjessiehampson
 
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land Rights
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land RightsProperty theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land Rights
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land RightsGlobal Land Tool Network
 
Indigenous peoples land and resource rights
Indigenous peoples land and resource rightsIndigenous peoples land and resource rights
Indigenous peoples land and resource rightsDr Lendy Spires
 
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, http
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, httpContemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, http
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, httpAlleneMcclendon878
 
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...SPERI
 
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in Vietnam
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in VietnamResearch paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in Vietnam
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in VietnamSPERI
 
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docx
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docxWhose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docx
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docxhelzerpatrina
 
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality assignmentcafe1
 
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in Laos
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in LaosEquity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in Laos
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in LaosIIED
 
21EDSConclusion.pptx
21EDSConclusion.pptx21EDSConclusion.pptx
21EDSConclusion.pptxJohanNoren1
 
Putting Inequality in its Place: Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...
Putting Inequality in its Place:   Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...Putting Inequality in its Place:   Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...
Putting Inequality in its Place: Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...JJ Widener
 
Political Economy of Land and Conflicts
Political Economy of Land and ConflictsPolitical Economy of Land and Conflicts
Political Economy of Land and ConflictsCAPRi
 
Music Censorship Essay
Music Censorship EssayMusic Censorship Essay
Music Censorship EssayTasha Williams
 
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In Planning
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In PlanningSocial Justice, Equity And Feminism In Planning
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In PlanningTareq Zarouni
 
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904Nameless RV
 
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docx
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docxWhether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docx
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docxhelzerpatrina
 

Ähnlich wie Social Identity, Natural Resources, & Peacebuilding (20)

Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequality
Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequalitySocio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequality
Socio economic rights of citizenship and regional inequality
 
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docx
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docxWeek 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docx
Week 3Social vulnerability to disaster myth of community, gen.docx
 
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land Rights
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land RightsProperty theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land Rights
Property theory, metaphors and the Continuum of Land Rights
 
Indigenous peoples land and resource rights
Indigenous peoples land and resource rightsIndigenous peoples land and resource rights
Indigenous peoples land and resource rights
 
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, http
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, httpContemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, http
Contemporary Justice Review, 2013Vol. 16, No. 4, 394–411, http
 
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...
Case study: Community-based natural resource management: Case of Thai ethnic ...
 
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in Vietnam
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in VietnamResearch paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in Vietnam
Research paper: Community Based Natural Resources Management in Vietnam
 
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docx
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docxWhose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docx
Whose Right to JerusalemGILLAD ROSEN and ANNE B. SHLAY.docx
 
Land governance and marxism
Land governance and marxismLand governance and marxism
Land governance and marxism
 
41 43
41 4341 43
41 43
 
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality
Race, Power, and Justice: Exploring the Dynamics of Inequality
 
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in Laos
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in LaosEquity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in Laos
Equity workshop: Justice and wellbeing in Protected Area management in Laos
 
21EDSConclusion.pptx
21EDSConclusion.pptx21EDSConclusion.pptx
21EDSConclusion.pptx
 
Putting Inequality in its Place: Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...
Putting Inequality in its Place:   Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...Putting Inequality in its Place:   Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...
Putting Inequality in its Place: Rural Consciousness and the Power of Persp...
 
Political Economy of Land and Conflicts
Political Economy of Land and ConflictsPolitical Economy of Land and Conflicts
Political Economy of Land and Conflicts
 
Chapter one
Chapter oneChapter one
Chapter one
 
Music Censorship Essay
Music Censorship EssayMusic Censorship Essay
Music Censorship Essay
 
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In Planning
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In PlanningSocial Justice, Equity And Feminism In Planning
Social Justice, Equity And Feminism In Planning
 
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904
Annurev lawsocsci-102209-152904
 
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docx
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docxWhether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docx
Whether you are using the works of Lenski, Svalastoga, Sorokin, .docx
 

Mehr von CAPRi

Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...
Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...
Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...CAPRi
 
Newton et al.
Newton et al.Newton et al.
Newton et al.CAPRi
 
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticos
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticosRecursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticos
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticosCAPRi
 
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster Resources
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster ResourcesResources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster Resources
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster ResourcesCAPRi
 
The Commons: Governance and Collective Action
The Commons: Governance and Collective ActionThe Commons: Governance and Collective Action
The Commons: Governance and Collective ActionCAPRi
 
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...CAPRi
 
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...CAPRi
 
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in Bangladesh
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in BangladeshNatural resource conflicts and community organisations in Bangladesh
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in BangladeshCAPRi
 
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...CAPRi
 
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict Countries
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict CountriesNot Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict Countries
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict CountriesCAPRi
 
Institutional Demensions of Climate Change
Institutional Demensions of Climate ChangeInstitutional Demensions of Climate Change
Institutional Demensions of Climate ChangeCAPRi
 
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010CAPRi Overview Feb 2010
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010CAPRi
 

Mehr von CAPRi (12)

Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...
Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...
Institutional Dimensions of Climate-Smart-Agriculture: The Role of Property R...
 
Newton et al.
Newton et al.Newton et al.
Newton et al.
 
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticos
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticosRecursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticos
Recursos, derechos y cooperación:carteles didácticos
 
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster Resources
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster ResourcesResources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster Resources
Resources, Rights and Cooperation: Educational Poster Resources
 
The Commons: Governance and Collective Action
The Commons: Governance and Collective ActionThe Commons: Governance and Collective Action
The Commons: Governance and Collective Action
 
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...
Whose Land is this Anyways? The role of collective action in maintaining comm...
 
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...
Land, Power and Peace: Tenure systems and the formalization agenda in post-ge...
 
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in Bangladesh
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in BangladeshNatural resource conflicts and community organisations in Bangladesh
Natural resource conflicts and community organisations in Bangladesh
 
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...
Conflict, Cooperation & Collective Action: land use, water rights and water s...
 
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict Countries
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict CountriesNot Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict Countries
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict Countries
 
Institutional Demensions of Climate Change
Institutional Demensions of Climate ChangeInstitutional Demensions of Climate Change
Institutional Demensions of Climate Change
 
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010CAPRi Overview Feb 2010
CAPRi Overview Feb 2010
 

Social Identity, Natural Resources, & Peacebuilding

  • 1. Social Identity, Natural Resources, & Peacebuilding Arthur Green McGill University 28 June 2010 CAPRi International Research Workshop on Collective Action, Property Rights, and Conflict in NRM Siem Reap, Cambodia
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. Thank You! Arthur (Gill) Green [email_address]
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. One example is the conflict between coca growers and livelihood projects in Columbia (Yezer 2011). In the Apurímac and Ene River Valley in 2002, coca growers ( cocaleros ) rallied against “zero coca” alternative-livelihood projects supported by international nongovernmental organizations. Opposing these international livelihood projects, participants in a peasant rally asserted their cultural right to produce and grow coca by chewing and displaying coca leaves as part of an array of ethnic symbols that included traditional clothing and the Tawantinsuyu (Inca) flag. They rejected externally imposed programs to replace coca cultivation and, soon after, they forced CARE to leave the region, displaying their willingness to forgo foreign aid programs in order to continue engaging in coca production. An obvious question in this case is whether, if coca had no economic value, its cultivation would have been so energetically defended as a cultural right. Nonetheless, this example shows how cultural, political, and economic values can become united in an identity-based discourse.
  2. While the economic aspects of NR in post-war peacebuilding are important there are at least five ways in which natural resources, social identity, and conflict linkages manifest in postwar scenarios.