The internet has changed voiceover industry. Some good, some bad. World Voices members J. Michael Collins and Matt Cowlrick take on the discussion of P2P sites for VO. Check out the Q & A of the lively #WoVoChat Twitter chat!
4. A1: Online sites allow talent from around the country
and around the world to access the industry like never
before. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A1: Online sites create an open and dynamic
marketplace where success is based on merit, not
connections. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A1: Online sites create work where none existed by
allowing clients access to voice talent in a manner free
of bureaucracy. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A1: Online sites help talent grow and progress in their
career by enabling them to develop their business from
the ground up. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
5. A1: They level the playing field and give new
producers access to voices with the online tools they
understand. #WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
A1: They bring jobs, educational content, connect
people to people and sometimes sponsor community
events. #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
A1: Democratize the audition process, so talent
doesn’t need to be in LA or NYC here in the US.
#WoVoChat
@vallencourt
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A1: They allow talent to connect with customers they
may not meet otherwise. #WoVoChat
@lisaricevoice
7. A2: P2P founders often come from industries such as
tech & marketing & don’t have the same experience in
VO as agents and talent. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A2: As such, focus is sometimes on transactions
(fees, subscriptions) rather than fair rates and
conditions for talent. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A2: Talent can become too fixated on P2P’s & not seek
direct relationships w/ad agencies, production houses &
marketing depts. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A2: Some P2P’s have a reluctance to be transparent
about their processes, which prevents accountability.
#WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
8. A2: P2P’s are bad in that they teach talent to conform
to their guidelines and needs, not necessarily those of
the talent. #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
A2: They inhibit (or sometimes prohibit) VO client
communications. #WoVoChat
@PeterBishipVO
A2: As a producer I have to sit through many levels of
“professional”. #WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A2: Too much encouragement for speed-auditioning.
#WoVoChat
@JCDunnVOX
10. A3: Yes and No. P2P’s are growing their base in the
local and regional commercial markets, but not so
much in the national market. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A3: P2P’s are acting as clearing houses for jobs many
agents don’t handle, like internal narration and
elearning. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A3: P2P’s offer an egalitarian marketplace that requires
not introductions or contacts, unlike most leading
agencies. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A3: Online sites help talent grow and progress in their
career by enabling them to develop their business from
the ground up. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
12. A4: The owners make money by subscribing the
clients too, not just the talent. #WoVoChat
@CourVo
A4: The site has some way of qualifying the
professionalism of the talent. #WoVoChat
@CourVo
A4: Owners hold to minimum compensation formulas for
the different genres, and keep to them. #WoVoChat
@CourVo
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A4: Auditions come with a report of how many people
have auditioned already.(some do so now) #WoVoChat
@CourVo
13. A4: Talent have access to all or most of the available
jobs. #WoVoChat
@CourVo
A4: The use of understood rates to eliminate
underbidding and dragging down rates for the entire
VO industry. #WoVoChat
@JCDunnVOX
A4: Some type of rating for studio/audio quality would be
nice. #WoVoChat
@lisaricevoice
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A4: One that requires a reasonable and fair structure for
work performed, and weeds out unprofessional talent.
#WoVoChat
@vallencourt
14. A4: Something that doesn’t intervene with vo-client
relationships. #WoVoChat
@AudioCaroline
A4: Incorporates feedback for the artist. Poor quality?
Didn’t like the tone/pacing? Bad read? Etc.
#WoVoChat
@scottmedvetz
A4: Where the needs of the VO talent are just as
important as the needs of the client. We both need each
other. #WoVoChat
@FaithCoonsVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A4: Tools and resources to be successful for a
freelancing lifestyle. #WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
16. A5: Audition aggressively for all jobs that are within
your ability range. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A5: Cultivate and nurture long term relationships with
clients to grow self-sustaining business. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A5: Present yourself in a professional manner at all
times, from your demo to our profile, to the language
you use with clients. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A5: Be aware of the quality of your competition. Amateurs
do not have success on the big two sites. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
17. A5: Currently? Sit in your booth and jump on every
audition that suits your skills. #WoVoChat
@AudioCaroline
A5: Be lucky enough to get ahead every time.
#WoVoChat
@steveovoice
A5: Taking the time to participate but finding which one is
worth your time consistently, that’s the conundrum.
#WoVoChat
@FaithCoonsVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A5: Bid over the range if that’s what the job is worth to
YOU. Don’t get into a lowball war. #WoVoChat
@PeterBishopVO
19. A6: The P2P’s have certainly introduced functionality,
speed and cloud-based service to the marketplace.
#WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A6: In time there may be more of a convergence of the
traditional agency model & online casting. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A6: Some production houses have vetted, professional
talent banks & have developed and intuitive casting
process for the client. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A6: As their marketing efforts become more competitive
vs. P2Ps(investment in SEO & ads) we may see more
traffic to those sites. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
20. A6: The new VO paradigm production approach will
be streamlined, efficient and consistent. We all work
as partners. #WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
A6: Pay-to-play but not ALL day. Spend a fraction of
your time on them and then spend the rest of your day
doing REAL marketing! #WoVoChat
@voiceoversbytd
A6: I hope it is & lead to client seeking VO’s directly &
that we can also serve as the client care mgmt they need
in a project. #WoVoChat
@FaithCoonsVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
22. A7: Neither. They are marketplaces where we sell our
wares. Like any marketplace they charge rent in
various forms. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A7: They are companies who exist for the purpose of
profit, not to hold hands and sing cumbaya. Your job
is to earn from them. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A7: They can be forces for good if talent hold the line on
pricing. P2Ps are creating work from thin air, which
helps us all. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A7: They can be evil if we give in to the myth of too much
competition and undercut prices. Then it will be a race to
the bottom. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
23. A7: If they work for you, got for it. If they don’t, move
on. #WoVoChat
@jerrysvoice
A7: No black and white here. Shades of grey.
#WoVoChat
@scottmedvetz
A7: Like everything in life there are always two sides of
the coin. Some are more evil than good & vice versa. U
need to be wise. #WoVoChat
@FaithCoonsVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A7: More like “not for everyone”.#WoVoChat
@ChuckDavisCreat
24. A7: They are neither good nor evil. Like money-they
are a tool. It’s how YOU use them that defines them.
#WoVoChat
@VObyMoe
A7: Websites are good in theory. How people use them
and run them can turn evil. Every action is a reaction to
something else. #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
A7: Not evil but frustrating. From producer side, I’ve
looked to P2P for VO types to fill niches and
searching was frustrating. #WoVoChat
@karndawn
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A7: Those are strong opposites. Each P2P has pros
and cons. Talent must decide how much they want to
invest time and money wise. #WoVoChat
@lisaricevoice
26. A8: Not all clients are the same. A local company may
not have the same budget/exposure as a
multinational. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A8: By listing publicly on a site, seekers may find it
cheaper to book through P2P than directly, cutting your
ability to negotiate. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A8: There is the danger you will be seen as an item on a
shop shelf, rather than a professional vendor. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A8: You are in less control of your career. Inflation
adjusts annually; does P2P’s rate card? #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
27. A8: I never list rate cards on my site. When working with
clients direct, everyone has a different budget.
#WoVoChat
@voiceoversbytd
A8: Removes negotiating power, doesn’t take into
account localized overhead, puts power of pricing in
the wrong hands…not done... #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
A8: Every project is a different animal with different
needs. Price accordingly, not with a cookie cutter rate
card. #WoVoChat
@AudioCaroline
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A8: That is the key to all of this! Do not undersell
yourself! Everybody has a price of how much they will
charge. Think about it! #WoVoChat
@BobGlavinVO
28. A8: Because OUR rates are often not the same as the
clients. Both ways. #WoVoChat
@steveovoice
A8: The union has a rate card…but you can bet your
sweet bippy that Brad Pitt doesn’t work to it! #WoVoChat
@PeterBishipVO
A8: If you send a rate card will they smile or gag?
Rates are all over the place in US. I try to work with
client’s budget. #WoVoChat
@jacksvoices
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A8: On occasion, the client may be willing to pay more
than your published rate. “He he mentions price first,
loses.” Confucius #WoVoChat
@Joes_SpeakEasy
30. A9: Talent and training. Don’t jump online before you
are ready. Work with a qualified coach. You will be
competing against pros! #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A9: Awesome demos. 50% of online jobs are cast
through private invite and direct booking from you
demo. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
A9: Technical savvy. You must have quality acoustics
and the ability to edit your audio well. If in doubt, talk to
the EWABS guys. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A9: Patience. It doesn’t happen overnight. It took me 6
months to book my first 30 or so jobs online with 15 years
pro experience. #WoVoChat
@jmcvoiceover
31. A9: Advertisers are under constant pressure. Become
the best possible production partner to support those
needs. #WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
A9: Listen to how the client wants the script read and
submit 2-3 takes. There are too many people in this biz
who don’t listen. #WoVoChat
@voiceoversbytd
A9: Be smart in choosing the jobs you are legitimate for,
and have the compensation you deserve. #WoVoChat
@CourVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
32. A9: Just being the best service provider/partner
possible. #WoVoChat
@ChuckDavisCreat
A9: Practice, patience, persistence, professionalism.
#WoVoChat
@MelsBritishVOs
A9: Let’s not forget technical standards. Don’t use a $50
USB mic on the kitchen table…as some P2P’s tell you is
fine! #WoVoChat
@PeterBishopVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A9: Take risks with copy reads. Be something everyone
else is NOT. #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
34. A10: Educate yourself on usage and appropriate
rates. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A10: Think long term career. Perpetual buyouts can bring
about severe loss for you business in the future.
#WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
A10: Don’t see the internet as it was 5 years ago. Jobs for
web are not as ‘non-broadcast’ as they used to be. #rates
#WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A10: Don’t be afraid to speak up & ask tough questions
of both P2P staff AND your fellow talent. Take ownership
of your industry. #WoVoChat
@DownUnderVO
35. A10: Speak up! Hold to your rates! You’re worth
it!#WoVoChat
@CourVo
A10: Don’t settle for low rates. #WoVoChat
@LorencePamela
A10: Stand for what you know you are worth and avoid
everything you wish did not exist. #WoVoChat
@StevenLowell
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A10: Don’t give the lowball postings the time of day.
#WoVoChat
@AudioCaroline
36. A10: Provide quality and don’t underbid your talent and
skill. #WoVoChat
@vallencourt
A10: Talent need to actively create, improve and take
responsibility for the success of their career.
#WoVoChat
@VO_Kennelly
A10: Send them a copy of this #wovochat! Best piece of
customer feedback they’ll ever get in one place.
#WoVoChat
@MelsBritishVOs
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
A10: Realize it’s not going away & decide how you want
to interact with P2P without judging others who do.
Think like a biz owner. #WoVoChat
@FaithCoonsVO
37. #WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
Join Us for the next #WoVoChat on
Wednesday, March 11th
12pmPT/2pmCT/3pmET!
Topic: ISDN vs. IP Alternatives
38. Check out the entire 2-25-15 #WoVoChat at
our Storify:
bit.ly/WoVoChat_5
Join us every 2nd & 4th Wednesday of the month in 2015
for #WoVoChat at 12pmPT/2pmCT/3pmET!
#WoVoChat www.worldvo.org
January 14th & 28th July 8th & 22nd
February 11th & 25th August 12th & 26th
March 11th & 25th September 9th & 23rd
April 8th & 22nd October 14th & 28th
May 13th & 27th November 11th & 25th
June 10th & 24th December 9th & 23rd