SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 9
Problematizing Digital Research Evaluation and
Emerging Practices in Practice-Based Arts, Humanities
and Social Science Research
Dr Muriel E. Swijghuisen Reigersberg
(Goldsmiths, University of London)
m.swijghuisen@gold.ac.uk
Goldsmiths….
• Is a research intensive, small research university
• Has over 15 EU grants and many smaller UK ones
• Specialises in interdisciplinary research rooted in arts, humanities and
social science subjects.
• Conducts a lot of practice-based research that is not digital
• Needs to collaborate and develop new ways of thinking about
research dissemination or risk becoming unsustainable in national
research exercises.
Funders of Goldsmiths Research
(not all mandate open access and open data and much
research remains unfunded)
ORCIDs, DOIs and Research at Goldsmiths
Goldsmiths recognises the importance of ORCID nos and DOIs for tracking its
research activity at University level.
Not many researchers have ORCID IDs and/ or use DOIs (yet)
Reasons for this current absence of engagement vary:
1. Definitions of data do not ‘fit’ with what researchers believe they are
producing practically and ontologically
2. Many researchers produce monographs that are not yet open access
3. (Citation) metrics work differently in AHSS research
4. Open data creates challenges for researchers in copyright, intellectual
property rights and ethics
Emerging Approaches (1):
Transforming Musicology
http://www.transforming-musicology.org/
Project explores how software tools developed by the music information
retrieval (MIR) community can be applied in musical study. The project
comprises three specific case studies of MIR applications which:
1. enhance the use of digitally encoded sources in studying 16th-century lute
and vocal music and using such sources to develop new musical pattern
matching techniques to improve existing MIR tools;
2. augment traditional study of Richard Wagner's leitmotif technique through
audio pattern matching and supporting psychological testing;
3. explore how musical communities on the Web engage with their music by
employing MIR tools in developing a social platform for furthering musical
discussion online.
For further information contact Prof Tim Crawford: t.crawford@gold.ac.uk
Emerging Approaches (2):
Photomediations: An Open Book
http://photomediationsopenbook.net
1. Photomediations: An Open Book’s online form allows for easy
sharing of its content.
2. Promotes ‘open access’, ‘open scholarship’ and ‘open education’,
3. Explores a low-cost hybrid publishing model
4. Provides a good model of how AHSS researchers in the visual arts
might approach the production of open access monographs and arts
catalogues,
5. Licencing and copy right issues foregrounded.
For further information contact Prof Joanna Zylinska: j.zylinska@gold.ac.uk
Emerging Approaches (3):
Citizensense
http://www.citizensense.net
1. Investigates the relationship between technologies and practices of
environmental sensing and citizen engagement.
2. Produces scientific data sets to support social science enquiries and activism
3. Uses mobile and other technologies to monitor air quality and to collect other
crowd sourced environmental data
4. Has developed website that collects live data sensing on air quality for public
access
5. Very suitable for using DOIs and ORCID to help map both academic and social
impact
6. Highly interdisciplinary and demonstrates the way in which boundaries between
AHSS and other types of research can be broken down and how the use of DOIs
and ORCIDs can become very valuable in measuring impact
For further information contact Dr Jennifer Gabrys: j.gabrys@gold.ac.uk
Afterthoughts and the next steps…
Dr Muriel Swijghuisen Reigersberg
m.swijghuisen@gold.ac.uk

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Was ist angesagt? (6)

Digital literacy & reserach ethics
Digital literacy & reserach ethicsDigital literacy & reserach ethics
Digital literacy & reserach ethics
 
IDIMC 5-minute madness presentation
IDIMC 5-minute madness presentationIDIMC 5-minute madness presentation
IDIMC 5-minute madness presentation
 
Beyond Open Access: Open Science and Research Integrity
Beyond Open Access: Open Science and Research IntegrityBeyond Open Access: Open Science and Research Integrity
Beyond Open Access: Open Science and Research Integrity
 
What's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and Impact
What's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and ImpactWhat's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and Impact
What's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and Impact
 
Fresh minted research: assigning DOIs to theses and their underlying data
Fresh minted research: assigning DOIs to theses and their underlying dataFresh minted research: assigning DOIs to theses and their underlying data
Fresh minted research: assigning DOIs to theses and their underlying data
 
Legal Ethics and Social Media: Use in Litigation
Legal Ethics and Social Media: Use in LitigationLegal Ethics and Social Media: Use in Litigation
Legal Ethics and Social Media: Use in Litigation
 

Ähnlich wie Problematizing Digital Research Evaluation and Emerging Practices in Practice-Based Arts, Humanities and Social Science Research

Ähnlich wie Problematizing Digital Research Evaluation and Emerging Practices in Practice-Based Arts, Humanities and Social Science Research (20)

RIDE 2010 presentation - Supporting researchers at the British Library
RIDE 2010 presentation - Supporting researchers at the British LibraryRIDE 2010 presentation - Supporting researchers at the British Library
RIDE 2010 presentation - Supporting researchers at the British Library
 
The promise of #citizenscience
The promise of  #citizenscienceThe promise of  #citizenscience
The promise of #citizenscience
 
Social scholarship
Social scholarshipSocial scholarship
Social scholarship
 
How can citizen science achieve for neuroscience what it's achieved for nature?
How can citizen science achieve for neuroscience what it's achieved for nature?How can citizen science achieve for neuroscience what it's achieved for nature?
How can citizen science achieve for neuroscience what it's achieved for nature?
 
Participatory Research: Extending Open Science beyond the ivory tower - Open ...
Participatory Research: Extending Open Science beyond the ivory tower - Open ...Participatory Research: Extending Open Science beyond the ivory tower - Open ...
Participatory Research: Extending Open Science beyond the ivory tower - Open ...
 
Sabina Leonelli, Professor of Philosophy and History of Science, University o...
Sabina Leonelli, Professor of Philosophy and History of Science, University o...Sabina Leonelli, Professor of Philosophy and History of Science, University o...
Sabina Leonelli, Professor of Philosophy and History of Science, University o...
 
Embedded Industry Research
Embedded Industry ResearchEmbedded Industry Research
Embedded Industry Research
 
Case by case: Open research in different disciplines​ (Dr Dorka Tamas)
Case by case: Open research in different disciplines​ (Dr Dorka Tamas)Case by case: Open research in different disciplines​ (Dr Dorka Tamas)
Case by case: Open research in different disciplines​ (Dr Dorka Tamas)
 
Case by case: ​ Open research in different disciplines​​
Case by case: ​ Open research in different disciplines​​Case by case: ​ Open research in different disciplines​​
Case by case: ​ Open research in different disciplines​​
 
Open Science What? Why? For What? How?
Open Science What? Why? For What? How?Open Science What? Why? For What? How?
Open Science What? Why? For What? How?
 
Co design and societal influence - atm seminar 160316
Co design and societal influence - atm seminar 160316Co design and societal influence - atm seminar 160316
Co design and societal influence - atm seminar 160316
 
Open Science Opens Careers
Open Science Opens CareersOpen Science Opens Careers
Open Science Opens Careers
 
2011 odh webinar.nitle
2011 odh webinar.nitle2011 odh webinar.nitle
2011 odh webinar.nitle
 
Open Science - Paradigm Shift or Revival of Old Ideas?
Open Science - Paradigm Shift or Revival of Old Ideas?Open Science - Paradigm Shift or Revival of Old Ideas?
Open Science - Paradigm Shift or Revival of Old Ideas?
 
Citizen Science - Insights, opportunities and approaches for biomedical research
Citizen Science - Insights, opportunities and approaches for biomedical researchCitizen Science - Insights, opportunities and approaches for biomedical research
Citizen Science - Insights, opportunities and approaches for biomedical research
 
Strategic options for Digital Participation in the UK national museums
Strategic options for Digital Participation in the UK national museumsStrategic options for Digital Participation in the UK national museums
Strategic options for Digital Participation in the UK national museums
 
Citizen Science in Open Science context: measuring & understanding impacts of...
Citizen Science in Open Science context: measuring & understanding impacts of...Citizen Science in Open Science context: measuring & understanding impacts of...
Citizen Science in Open Science context: measuring & understanding impacts of...
 
Vida Mildažienė and Eglė Marija Ramanuskaitė - Steps Towards Open Science and...
Vida Mildažienė and Eglė Marija Ramanuskaitė - Steps Towards Open Science and...Vida Mildažienė and Eglė Marija Ramanuskaitė - Steps Towards Open Science and...
Vida Mildažienė and Eglė Marija Ramanuskaitė - Steps Towards Open Science and...
 
Joining it all up: developing research-practice linkages in the UK
Joining it all up: developing research-practice linkages in the UKJoining it all up: developing research-practice linkages in the UK
Joining it all up: developing research-practice linkages in the UK
 
UKSG 2023 - Libraries as hubs for innovation and co-creation
UKSG 2023 - Libraries as hubs for innovation and co-creationUKSG 2023 - Libraries as hubs for innovation and co-creation
UKSG 2023 - Libraries as hubs for innovation and co-creation
 

Mehr von ORCID, Inc

Mehr von ORCID, Inc (20)

ORCID Overview: Why your Lifelong Identifier is Important in the Digital Age ...
ORCID Overview: Why your Lifelong Identifier is Important in the Digital Age ...ORCID Overview: Why your Lifelong Identifier is Important in the Digital Age ...
ORCID Overview: Why your Lifelong Identifier is Important in the Digital Age ...
 
Identifying Springer's Author (with ORCID iD) on SpringerLink (H. Aziz)
Identifying Springer's Author (with ORCID iD) on SpringerLink (H. Aziz)Identifying Springer's Author (with ORCID iD) on SpringerLink (H. Aziz)
Identifying Springer's Author (with ORCID iD) on SpringerLink (H. Aziz)
 
ORCID at UniKL (P. Hamzah)
ORCID at UniKL (P. Hamzah)ORCID at UniKL (P. Hamzah)
ORCID at UniKL (P. Hamzah)
 
ORCID Integration Videos
ORCID Integration VideosORCID Integration Videos
ORCID Integration Videos
 
ORCID as a Community Initiative (N. Miyairi)
ORCID as a Community Initiative (N. Miyairi)ORCID as a Community Initiative (N. Miyairi)
ORCID as a Community Initiative (N. Miyairi)
 
Introduction and Welcome to the 2017 ORCID Malaysia Workshop (N. Miyairi)
Introduction and Welcome to the 2017 ORCID Malaysia Workshop (N. Miyairi)Introduction and Welcome to the 2017 ORCID Malaysia Workshop (N. Miyairi)
Introduction and Welcome to the 2017 ORCID Malaysia Workshop (N. Miyairi)
 
MyRID: ORCID Integration in Malaysia (T. Dharmalingam)
MyRID: ORCID Integration in Malaysia (T. Dharmalingam)MyRID: ORCID Integration in Malaysia (T. Dharmalingam)
MyRID: ORCID Integration in Malaysia (T. Dharmalingam)
 
Spreading the ORCID Word: ORCID Communications Webinar (2016.12)
Spreading the ORCID Word: ORCID Communications Webinar (2016.12)Spreading the ORCID Word: ORCID Communications Webinar (2016.12)
Spreading the ORCID Word: ORCID Communications Webinar (2016.12)
 
ORCID @ Khalifa University
ORCID @ Khalifa UniversityORCID @ Khalifa University
ORCID @ Khalifa University
 
ORCID Integration with Institutional Repositories (D. Grenz)
ORCID Integration with Institutional Repositories (D. Grenz)ORCID Integration with Institutional Repositories (D. Grenz)
ORCID Integration with Institutional Repositories (D. Grenz)
 
Research in a world where machines read (M. Buys)
Research in a world where machines read (M. Buys)Research in a world where machines read (M. Buys)
Research in a world where machines read (M. Buys)
 
ORCID Collect & Connect: understanding integrations and the API (M. Buys)
ORCID Collect & Connect: understanding integrations and the API (M. Buys)ORCID Collect & Connect: understanding integrations and the API (M. Buys)
ORCID Collect & Connect: understanding integrations and the API (M. Buys)
 
Benefits to researchers who use ORCID (P. Purnell)
Benefits to researchers who use ORCID (P. Purnell)Benefits to researchers who use ORCID (P. Purnell)
Benefits to researchers who use ORCID (P. Purnell)
 
Research Management & Publishing (M. Jagerhorn)
Research Management & Publishing (M. Jagerhorn)Research Management & Publishing (M. Jagerhorn)
Research Management & Publishing (M. Jagerhorn)
 
ORCID overview: why your lifelong identifier is important in the digital age ...
ORCID overview: why your lifelong identifier is important in the digital age ...ORCID overview: why your lifelong identifier is important in the digital age ...
ORCID overview: why your lifelong identifier is important in the digital age ...
 
ORCID in the Publishing Workflow (Mochammad Tanzil Multazam)
ORCID in the Publishing Workflow (Mochammad Tanzil Multazam)ORCID in the Publishing Workflow (Mochammad Tanzil Multazam)
ORCID in the Publishing Workflow (Mochammad Tanzil Multazam)
 
What in the World is ORCID? (Haak)
What in the World is ORCID? (Haak)What in the World is ORCID? (Haak)
What in the World is ORCID? (Haak)
 
ORCID as a Community Initiative (Miyairi)
ORCID as a Community Initiative (Miyairi)ORCID as a Community Initiative (Miyairi)
ORCID as a Community Initiative (Miyairi)
 
ORCID Integration Videos
ORCID Integration VideosORCID Integration Videos
ORCID Integration Videos
 
The Latest on ORCID API v2
The Latest on ORCID API v2 The Latest on ORCID API v2
The Latest on ORCID API v2
 

Problematizing Digital Research Evaluation and Emerging Practices in Practice-Based Arts, Humanities and Social Science Research

  • 1. Problematizing Digital Research Evaluation and Emerging Practices in Practice-Based Arts, Humanities and Social Science Research Dr Muriel E. Swijghuisen Reigersberg (Goldsmiths, University of London) m.swijghuisen@gold.ac.uk
  • 2. Goldsmiths…. • Is a research intensive, small research university • Has over 15 EU grants and many smaller UK ones • Specialises in interdisciplinary research rooted in arts, humanities and social science subjects. • Conducts a lot of practice-based research that is not digital • Needs to collaborate and develop new ways of thinking about research dissemination or risk becoming unsustainable in national research exercises.
  • 3. Funders of Goldsmiths Research (not all mandate open access and open data and much research remains unfunded)
  • 4.
  • 5. ORCIDs, DOIs and Research at Goldsmiths Goldsmiths recognises the importance of ORCID nos and DOIs for tracking its research activity at University level. Not many researchers have ORCID IDs and/ or use DOIs (yet) Reasons for this current absence of engagement vary: 1. Definitions of data do not ‘fit’ with what researchers believe they are producing practically and ontologically 2. Many researchers produce monographs that are not yet open access 3. (Citation) metrics work differently in AHSS research 4. Open data creates challenges for researchers in copyright, intellectual property rights and ethics
  • 6. Emerging Approaches (1): Transforming Musicology http://www.transforming-musicology.org/ Project explores how software tools developed by the music information retrieval (MIR) community can be applied in musical study. The project comprises three specific case studies of MIR applications which: 1. enhance the use of digitally encoded sources in studying 16th-century lute and vocal music and using such sources to develop new musical pattern matching techniques to improve existing MIR tools; 2. augment traditional study of Richard Wagner's leitmotif technique through audio pattern matching and supporting psychological testing; 3. explore how musical communities on the Web engage with their music by employing MIR tools in developing a social platform for furthering musical discussion online. For further information contact Prof Tim Crawford: t.crawford@gold.ac.uk
  • 7. Emerging Approaches (2): Photomediations: An Open Book http://photomediationsopenbook.net 1. Photomediations: An Open Book’s online form allows for easy sharing of its content. 2. Promotes ‘open access’, ‘open scholarship’ and ‘open education’, 3. Explores a low-cost hybrid publishing model 4. Provides a good model of how AHSS researchers in the visual arts might approach the production of open access monographs and arts catalogues, 5. Licencing and copy right issues foregrounded. For further information contact Prof Joanna Zylinska: j.zylinska@gold.ac.uk
  • 8. Emerging Approaches (3): Citizensense http://www.citizensense.net 1. Investigates the relationship between technologies and practices of environmental sensing and citizen engagement. 2. Produces scientific data sets to support social science enquiries and activism 3. Uses mobile and other technologies to monitor air quality and to collect other crowd sourced environmental data 4. Has developed website that collects live data sensing on air quality for public access 5. Very suitable for using DOIs and ORCID to help map both academic and social impact 6. Highly interdisciplinary and demonstrates the way in which boundaries between AHSS and other types of research can be broken down and how the use of DOIs and ORCIDs can become very valuable in measuring impact For further information contact Dr Jennifer Gabrys: j.gabrys@gold.ac.uk
  • 9. Afterthoughts and the next steps… Dr Muriel Swijghuisen Reigersberg m.swijghuisen@gold.ac.uk