This document outlines a presentation comparing entrepreneurship in design houses versus manufacturing. It discusses factors to consider for entrepreneurs such as passion, risk-taking ability, and experience. When starting a business, mentors can provide knowledge and experience though may lack funds. Manufacturing provides jobs but requires large funds, while design houses have smaller funds requirements but also smaller profits. The document compares the manufacturing process, team structure, fundraising options, and concludes that manufacturing is needed for India's overall growth, and India must move faster economically to compete globally.
Entrepreneurship: Choosing Between Design House and Manufacturing
1. Entrepreneurship: Design House
versus Manufacturing
Prof. Girish Kumar
Electrical Engineering Department
IIT Bombay
gkumar @ee.iitb.ac.in
prof.gkumar@gmail.com
Ex-Chairman, Wilcom Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
2. Outline of Presentation
Why Entrepreneur? Do you have the quality?
When to start business
Why Manufacture – Advantages and Disadvantages
Team
Funds
Manufacturing Process
Design House versus Manufacturing
Conclusions
3. Why Entrepreneur?
Great Idea and/or Product
Competition
Make Money
Create Jobs
Independent (your own boss)
Fame
Power
5. When to Start Business
Immediately After Graduation
Young, dynamic, enthusiasm, will to succeed but
Lack of experience, knowledge, may not have funds.
Mentor – faculty may be a good choice. They have
knowledge, experience, contact, but may not have funds.
Most of high tech companies in USA are near Stanford,
UC Berkley, Harvard, MIT.
After Working for a Few Years
Have experience, financially stable but inertia, family
resistance
6. Why Manufacture - Advantages
Generates Employment to large number of people
- 10% to 20% White collar jobs
- 80% to 90% Blue collar jobs
(4+ crore people in India are unemployed)
Reduces Dependency on Foreign Countries
Export (brings money to the country)
Generates wealth for the nation
Solution for India’s Growth
7. Why Manufacture - Disadvantages
Requires 100% working product
Requires Large Funds
Survival of the fittest
Labour / Union problems
Too many procedures, formalities, etc.
(Currently, India ranks in the bottom 15%
for starting a company but situation is
improving with the current Govt.)
8. Comparison of Industries
% Cost Manufacturing IT /
Design
Trading
Raw Material 40 - 60% 1 -10% 75 - 95%
Salary 5 - 10% 40 - 50% 1 – 5%
Other Expenses 10 – 30% 10 – 15% 3 – 10%
Profit before Tax 10 – 40% 25 – 45% 2 – 10%
9. TEAM
Single Person Army
- One person can not do everything.
- Business requires diversified skills.
Large Team
- Responsibilities are shared
- Equity is to be shared
- People may have different ideas / goals
10. FUNDS
A few examples of promoter’s holding in company
Name Organization Equity Held
Premji Wipro >70%
Ambani RIL >45%
Nandan Infosys <10%
Narayanmurty Infosys <10%
Rich Family - Larger Share of Pie
11. FUNDS (Contd.)
Business runs on money. It comes from where?
FFF – Family, Friends and Fools
(I do not believe in third F, i.e. Fools, as it
leads to fourth F, i.e. Failure)
If you exploit someone or someone exploits
you, it does not work for a long time.
You have to create Win - Win situation.
12. How to Raise Funds?
First Step : Business Plan
Having a good idea / product is only 10 to 20% of business
activity. Development of finished product, manufacturing,
testing, packaging, marketing / selling, distribution, etc. are
80 to 90%.
Every Entrepreneur should read books on entrepreneurship,
marketing, management, etc.
(Spend several weeks or months – remember this is for your
knowledge and not for exam).
Market Research, Product Differentiation, SWOT analysis,
Outsourcing (0 - 100%), Certification, Pricing, Marketing,
Distribution, P&L projections, Cash Flow, etc.
13. How to Raise Funds (Contd.)
Second Step: Raising Initial Funds
Convince Family and Friends
Bank Loan – will ask for collateral
Angel Investor /Strategic Investor/ VC
- Valuation of Company
- Sharing the Equity
- Exit Route for Investor (M&A, IPO, etc.)
14. Manufacturing Process
Vendor Development for raw material and outsourcing
Manual, semi-automation, automation – Quantity/day
Machinery and place of manufacturing
Recruitment of People
- Part time, Full time, Contract – Single or Double Shift
- Pay Package
Accounting
Quality Control – ISO Certification
15. Design House vs Manufacturing
COMMON GOALS
Compete with the best in the world
Make yourself, employees and investors happy
Create wealth for the country
Design House Manufacturing
No. of Employees Small Large
Fund Requirement Small Large
Turnover Small Large
% Profit Large Small
16. CONCLUSIONS
Can start as a design house – convert to manufacturing.
Manufacturing is the only solution for the overall
growth of country.
To the response of a report that India will overtake
China in next few decades, China said that the economy
of China is moving at a rabbit’s pace (rabbit will not
sleep), so how India, who is moving at Tortoise pace,
can overtake them.
INDIA MUST MOVE AT THE SPEED OF A TIGER.