1. Next
Genera*on
Ver*cal
Axis
“Drag”
Style
Wind
Turbines
Getting
it
Right!
Proper
Siting
of
Wind
Turbines
&
Selection
of
the
Right
Wind
Turbine
Technology
Presenta(on
by:
Daniel
Cook,
Vice
President
Urban
Power
USA
3rd MA Sustainability Communities Conference
2nd MA Sustainability Campuses Conference
3. Massachuse>s
Wind
Energy
Profile
Next Generation
Vertical Axis Drag Style
Wind Energy Opportunities
4. Small
Wind
Systems
Small-‐scale
wind
power
systems
have
the
capacity
to
produce
up
to
100
kW
of
electrical
power
DarrieusVAWT
Next Generation
Drag StyleVAWT
5. Tradi(onal
“LiI”
Style
Horizontal
Axis
Wind
Turbines
High
Efficiency
Require
Laminar
Flow
(smooth)
Wind
Work
well
in
wind
speeds
between
18-‐35
mph
Generates
torque
from
high
rotor
speeds
Generator
located
on
turbine
Lots
of
moving
parts
Require
taller
tower
to
eliminate
turbulent
air
Feather
or
shut
down
when
winds
above
35
mph
6. Tradi(onal
“LiI”
Style
Ver(cal
Axis
Wind
Turbines
High
Efficiency
Require
Laminar
Flow
(smooth)
Wind
Work
well
in
wind
speeds
between
18–35
mph
Generator
repairs
require
turbine
disassembly
Generates
torque
from
high
rotor
speed
Shut
down
when
wind
speed
greater
than
35
mph
Require
taller
tower
to
eliminate
turbulent
air
Generally
Don’t
operate
at
low
wind
speeds
7. “LiI”
Style
Wind
Turbine
Wind turbine blade requires smooth laminar flow
wind to create lift for the turbine to spin effectively
and fast.
Lift type wind turbines don’t become efficient until
the wind is approximately 18 mph
8. Savonius
Ver(cal
Axis
Drag
Style
Wind
Turbine
Because of the curvature, the scoops experience less drag
when moving against the wind than when moving with the
wind. The differential drag causes the Savonius turbine to
spin.
There is resistance on the back side of the scoop resulting
in lower efficiencies than traditional wind turbines.
Resistance
Impulse Force
9. Next
Genera*on
Ver(cal
Axis
“Drag”
Style
Wind
Turbines
Significant increase in electrical production
Massachusetts Manufacturer
Work in turbulent wind and laminar flow wind
Work on Flat roof tops
Requires ≥30% larger sweep area
10. Next
Genera*on
Ver(cal
Axis
“Drag”
Style
Wind
Turbines
Use
wind
loading
like
a
sail
to
create
force
Produces
torque
by
spinning
a
large
mass
slowly
Produce
more
electricity
at
lower
wind
speeds
6-‐18
mph,
less
at
18-‐35
mph
and
more
at
high
wind
speeds
>
35
mph
Work
in
turbulent
wind
Don’t
require
tall
towers
Can
be
Roof
Mounted
Few
moving
parts
Bird
&
bat
friendly
16. Capacity
Factor
The
ra*o
of
an
energy
produc*on
system’s
actual
output
over
*me
to
it
poten*al
output
Solar PV:
13% - 15%
Wind:
20% - 40%
Note: Wind produces approximately 2X more
electricity than Solar PV per KW when
properly sited and equipment properly selected
17. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Site
Tes(ng
Wind
Speed
&
Air
Flow
Anemometer Testing
Laminar Flow (smooth) Wind
Turbulent Wind (caused by buildings, trees and
other nearby obstructions)
18. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Site
Selec(on
“lift” style wind turbines should be 2X the height of
obstructions & 20X the distance from obstructions
20. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Product
Selec(on
Does the wind turbine work in turbulent wind?
(are their buildings trees or other obstructions
nearby?)
Does wind turbine require smooth laminar flow
wind away from any obstructions?
Are predominant winds between 18 - 35 mph?
Are predominant winds below 18 mph and/or
above 35 mph?
21. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Performance
Important that wind manufacturers and wind
developers apply their wind turbines to the
optimal wind location (wind speed & wind type –
laminar and/or turbulent wind) to ensure optimal
capacity factor/performance so customer
expectations are met.
Lift type wind turbines should NOT be placed in
turbulent wind locations such as on or near
buildings, near trees and other obstructions that
can cause turbulence.
22. Wind
Energy
Assessments
Consulting
a
wind
map,
obtaining
previously
measured
data
Taking
your
own
measurements
with
anemometer
Hire
consultant
to
test
wind
speed
1
year
of
data,
or
Use
1-‐
2
months
anemometer
data
to
do
correlation
study
23. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Monitoring
Wind turbines should be monitored in real time,
and record daily, weekly, monthly, annual and
historic wind energy production relative to actual
wind speeds.
24. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Tradi(onal
Horizontal
Axis
Wind
Turbine
are
properly
applied
in
Laminar
Flow
Winds
only!!!
Op*mum
performance
between
18
mph
–
42
mph
25. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Poor
Applica(ons
“Lift” Style
Horizontal &
Vertical Axis Wind
Turbines in the
Turbulent Urban
Environment of
Boston
(5 wind turbines with
combined 15.6 KW
capacity = 15,583 kWhs
in 3 years 7 months)
15.6KW - 15,583 kWhs in 43 mos – ave. 362 kWhs /mo
26. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Turbulent
Wind
Properly
Applied
Next Generation
“Drag” Style
Wind Turbines in a
Turbulent Environment
(1.8 KW capacity = 3,433
kWhs in 8 month –
Easthampton, MA wind
speed less than Boston)
18,452 kWh in
3 years 7 months
27. Small
Wind
Turbines:
Summary
Get it Right!
Site the RightWind EnergyTechnology
in the RightWind Location
Lift Style Horizontal & Vertical Axis Wind Turbines in
Laminar Flow Wind only with speeds between 18 mph – ±42 mph
Traditional Vertical Axis Drag Style Wind Turbines in
Turbulent and/or Laminar Flow Wind ±8 mph – 42 mph
Next Generation Vertical Axis Drag Style Wind Turbines
in Turbulent and/or Laminar Flow Wind ±8 mph – ±70 mph