SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 8
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
+
MBA Consulting
Curriculum 2010-11:
Continued Feedback




                      Alternative Internship Pathways
                      Presentation & panel

                      J-P Martins
                      Associate Director Consulting Careers
                      February 2011
+
    Summary

    n    The event was excellently received
          n    100% of respondents would recommend the Alternative Internship Pathways event
          n    However, only 12 of 43 attendees submitted feedback surveys (28%)

    n    This is an annual event – a presentation and panel aimed at highlighting
          internship routes other than strategy consulting that can still lead to successful
          permanent applications in the autumn

    n    This year the event was held earlier than in previous years, in an attempt to
          head off despondency before it sets in amongst the first years
          n    Many of the attendees were still in recruitment processes with consulting firms at LBS

    n    In another change this year, I held the panel discussion first, before focusing on
          data from previous years
          n    The panel comprised 3 second year students that successfully applied to strategy
                consulting in the autumn having failed to secure a ‘milkround’ internship last Spring
+
    Quantitative survey data
+
    Alternative Internship Pathways: all
    respondents would recommend it
    strongly
                                                    0%          25%         50%         75%        100%



    The format and content of the session were                  7                       5
                                      excellent

              The presenters and panellists were                    8                       4
                       engaging and informative

        The event was well organised - logistics   1                    7                   4
                   and venue were appropriate

       I would strongly recommend this event to             6                       6
             next year's first year MBA students


                                        Disagree Strongly   Disagree        Agree           Agree Strongly



    Response rate: 12/43 (28%)
+
    Comments
+
    Alternative Internship Pathways:
    What should we do differently?
    n    Nothing (x 4)
    n    Maybe add more students on the panel
    n    The event should be organised better
    n    A pre-survey of reasons for rejection will be useful
    n    Have up to date information to be able to compare it to current results
    n    More personal advices
    n    I don’t know how to implement this but advice sounds very generic – heard all that before. If there
          was any way to push the panelists to be more specific (at the expense of being less politically
          correct), I think people will appreciate that more
    n    A more extensive panel of students would be useful for a balanced perspective of experiences. I
          would have liked to have seen more of an explanation about the feasibility of approaching firms
          for permanent recruitment who you were unsuccessful with when applying for internship
          applications. It would be good to get a better understanding as to whether repeat approaches for
          the same firms are ever successful. There is rumour that this is easiest if you were dinged at or
          before a first round interview (unless specifically asked to reapply). Additionally, a high level
          timeline of recommended actions to take to approach permanent recruitment for consulting would
          be useful
    n    Perhaps the panel could be more structured, or less Q&A from students for the panel?
+
    Alternative Internship Pathways:
    What should we keep the same?
    n    Everything (x2)
    n    Definitely keep the numbers that paint an optimistic picture and the panel (x2)
    n    Bring 2nd year students to talk about their experiences (x2)
    n    The format of the session
    n    Keep a panel and statistics
    n    This was an incredibly helpful event. Hearing the 2nd years experience and your data were
          both especially helpful
    n    Presentation and panel both worth having
+
    Surprisingly, no other comments
    attached to quantitative questions
                  Format and Content                       Presenter and Panellists

    n    No comments                           n    No comments




           Organisation – venue and logistics                       General

    n    No comments                           n    No comments

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch

How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...
How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...
How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...Tim Washington
 
Do more sales equal more profit? How will you know?
Do more sales equal more profit?  How will you know?Do more sales equal more profit?  How will you know?
Do more sales equal more profit? How will you know?Wilson Perumal and Company
 
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating Environments
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating EnvironmentsHigh-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating Environments
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating EnvironmentsWilson Perumal and Company
 
Portfolio Optimization Under Uncertainty
Portfolio Optimization Under UncertaintyPortfolio Optimization Under Uncertainty
Portfolio Optimization Under UncertaintyAdam Butler
 
Operational Strategy Roadmap
Operational Strategy RoadmapOperational Strategy Roadmap
Operational Strategy RoadmapRoss Hilton
 
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantage
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantageCreating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantage
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantageWilson Perumal and Company
 
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!Wilson Perumal and Company
 
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)Phase2
 
Portfolio optimization overview
Portfolio optimization overviewPortfolio optimization overview
Portfolio optimization overviewTim Washington
 
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their people
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their peopleOperational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their people
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their peopleantientropics
 
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio Optimization
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio OptimizationPDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio Optimization
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio OptimizationWilson Perumal and Company
 
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programs
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programsOperational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programs
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programsWilson Perumal and Company
 
150213 apics houston waging war on complexity in supply chains vf
150213 apics houston   waging war on complexity in supply chains vf150213 apics houston   waging war on complexity in supply chains vf
150213 apics houston waging war on complexity in supply chains vfWilson Perumal and Company
 
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseverance
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseveranceInspiration’ from the joy of perseverance
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseveranceNews World India
 

Andere mochten auch (18)

How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...
How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...
How Project Portfolio Management Ties Leadership, Strategic IQ, and Organizat...
 
Lean Six Sigma For A Complex World
Lean Six Sigma For A Complex WorldLean Six Sigma For A Complex World
Lean Six Sigma For A Complex World
 
Do more sales equal more profit? How will you know?
Do more sales equal more profit?  How will you know?Do more sales equal more profit?  How will you know?
Do more sales equal more profit? How will you know?
 
Portfolio Complexity Diagnostic Health Check
Portfolio Complexity Diagnostic Health CheckPortfolio Complexity Diagnostic Health Check
Portfolio Complexity Diagnostic Health Check
 
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating Environments
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating EnvironmentsHigh-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating Environments
High-Reliability Organizations: Managing Risk In Complex Operating Environments
 
Webinar Product optimization
Webinar Product optimization Webinar Product optimization
Webinar Product optimization
 
Portfolio Optimization Under Uncertainty
Portfolio Optimization Under UncertaintyPortfolio Optimization Under Uncertainty
Portfolio Optimization Under Uncertainty
 
Operational Strategy Roadmap
Operational Strategy RoadmapOperational Strategy Roadmap
Operational Strategy Roadmap
 
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantage
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantageCreating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantage
Creating and executing a strategy to preserve your company’s scale advantage
 
Wilson Perumal & Company Complexity Workshop
Wilson Perumal & Company Complexity WorkshopWilson Perumal & Company Complexity Workshop
Wilson Perumal & Company Complexity Workshop
 
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!
Operational Excellence Management Systems: 10 things you must get right!
 
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)
Strategic Management of Multiple Projects (aka Project Whispering)
 
Portfolio optimization overview
Portfolio optimization overviewPortfolio optimization overview
Portfolio optimization overview
 
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their people
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their peopleOperational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their people
Operational Discipline: 15 Characteristics of great companies and their people
 
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio Optimization
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio OptimizationPDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio Optimization
PDMA: 5 Key Lessons for Successful Portfolio Optimization
 
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programs
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programsOperational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programs
Operational Excellence: Getting the most out of your Lean and Six Sigma programs
 
150213 apics houston waging war on complexity in supply chains vf
150213 apics houston   waging war on complexity in supply chains vf150213 apics houston   waging war on complexity in supply chains vf
150213 apics houston waging war on complexity in supply chains vf
 
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseverance
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseveranceInspiration’ from the joy of perseverance
Inspiration’ from the joy of perseverance
 

Ähnlich wie Alternative Internship Pathways Feedback 2011

Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011
Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011
Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011JPStrategy
 
PLC Assessment and Reporting
PLC Assessment and ReportingPLC Assessment and Reporting
PLC Assessment and ReportingHobsons APAC
 
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow Lenka Boorer, Pris...
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow  Lenka Boorer, Pris...Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow  Lenka Boorer, Pris...
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow Lenka Boorer, Pris...ePortfolios Australia
 
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET)
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET) Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET)
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET) SEDA
 
Feedback Practical Tools 2011
Feedback   Practical Tools 2011Feedback   Practical Tools 2011
Feedback Practical Tools 2011JPStrategy
 
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptx
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptxRev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptx
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptxMarkLoveenAng
 
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentation
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentationEuro 2015 prioritisation presentation
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentationIan Seed
 
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant Orientation
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant OrientationPerformance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant Orientation
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant OrientationGovLoop
 
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011JPStrategy
 
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013Ryan O'Connell
 
Take one step
Take one step Take one step
Take one step SEDA
 
Changing the assessment narrative
Changing the assessment narrativeChanging the assessment narrative
Changing the assessment narrativeTansy Jessop
 
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?RichardM_Walker
 

Ähnlich wie Alternative Internship Pathways Feedback 2011 (20)

Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011
Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011
Make The Most 1st 2 Years Feedback 2011
 
PA550_Simulation Presentaion
PA550_Simulation PresentaionPA550_Simulation Presentaion
PA550_Simulation Presentaion
 
Summer Program Planning: Training Wheels (And Taking them Off!)
Summer Program Planning: Training Wheels (And Taking them Off!)Summer Program Planning: Training Wheels (And Taking them Off!)
Summer Program Planning: Training Wheels (And Taking them Off!)
 
PLC Assessment and Reporting
PLC Assessment and ReportingPLC Assessment and Reporting
PLC Assessment and Reporting
 
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow Lenka Boorer, Pris...
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow  Lenka Boorer, Pris...Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow  Lenka Boorer, Pris...
Creating a space for students to collate, curate and grow Lenka Boorer, Pris...
 
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET)
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET) Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET)
Recognising Excellence in Teaching (RET)
 
Feedback Practical Tools 2011
Feedback   Practical Tools 2011Feedback   Practical Tools 2011
Feedback Practical Tools 2011
 
Scale up project
Scale up projectScale up project
Scale up project
 
RPMS Re-orientation Workshop
RPMS Re-orientation WorkshopRPMS Re-orientation Workshop
RPMS Re-orientation Workshop
 
Underpinning Excellence in H.E. Toolkit
Underpinning Excellence in H.E. ToolkitUnderpinning Excellence in H.E. Toolkit
Underpinning Excellence in H.E. Toolkit
 
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptx
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptxRev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptx
Rev3RPMS-ReorientationNTOTPerformance-Feedback.pptx
 
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentation
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentationEuro 2015 prioritisation presentation
Euro 2015 prioritisation presentation
 
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant Orientation
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant OrientationPerformance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant Orientation
Performance Management for HR Practitioners - Participant Orientation
 
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011
Feedback Intro To Problem Solving 2011
 
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013
Data-Driven Student Success Programming in Residence Life - ACUHO-I 2013
 
Take one step
Take one step Take one step
Take one step
 
SWT 2015 Impact Report
SWT 2015 Impact ReportSWT 2015 Impact Report
SWT 2015 Impact Report
 
NLHExecutiveSummary
NLHExecutiveSummaryNLHExecutiveSummary
NLHExecutiveSummary
 
Changing the assessment narrative
Changing the assessment narrativeChanging the assessment narrative
Changing the assessment narrative
 
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?
 

Mehr von JPStrategy

Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer survey
Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer surveyAccenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer survey
Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer surveyJPStrategy
 
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCG
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCGThe aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCG
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCGJPStrategy
 
Internship Criteria
Internship CriteriaInternship Criteria
Internship CriteriaJPStrategy
 
Intro To Consulting Prework 1
Intro To Consulting   Prework 1Intro To Consulting   Prework 1
Intro To Consulting Prework 1JPStrategy
 
Brochure Sct 2012 1
Brochure Sct 2012 1Brochure Sct 2012 1
Brochure Sct 2012 1JPStrategy
 
Internship Tips
Internship TipsInternship Tips
Internship TipsJPStrategy
 
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012JPStrategy
 
Make The Most 2012
Make The Most 2012Make The Most 2012
Make The Most 2012JPStrategy
 
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110JPStrategy
 
Mastering Interviews Presentation 18 11 11
Mastering Interviews   Presentation 18 11 11Mastering Interviews   Presentation 18 11 11
Mastering Interviews Presentation 18 11 11JPStrategy
 
Creative Problem Solving Practical Tools Final
Creative Problem Solving   Practical Tools FinalCreative Problem Solving   Practical Tools Final
Creative Problem Solving Practical Tools FinalJPStrategy
 
Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020JPStrategy
 
Bcg Banking Report
Bcg Banking ReportBcg Banking Report
Bcg Banking ReportJPStrategy
 
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011JPStrategy
 

Mehr von JPStrategy (20)

Gorham nickel
Gorham nickelGorham nickel
Gorham nickel
 
Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer survey
Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer surveyAccenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer survey
Accenture personal-lines insurance -US consumer survey
 
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCG
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCGThe aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCG
The aluminum industry ceo agenda 2013 - by BCG
 
Internship Criteria
Internship CriteriaInternship Criteria
Internship Criteria
 
Intro To Consulting Prework 1
Intro To Consulting   Prework 1Intro To Consulting   Prework 1
Intro To Consulting Prework 1
 
Brochure Sct 2012 1
Brochure Sct 2012 1Brochure Sct 2012 1
Brochure Sct 2012 1
 
Internship Tips
Internship TipsInternship Tips
Internship Tips
 
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012
Making The Most Of Your Consulting Internship 2012
 
Make The Most 2012
Make The Most 2012Make The Most 2012
Make The Most 2012
 
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110
Citizens Are You Being Served Tcm80 92110
 
Mastering Interviews Presentation 18 11 11
Mastering Interviews   Presentation 18 11 11Mastering Interviews   Presentation 18 11 11
Mastering Interviews Presentation 18 11 11
 
Creative Problem Solving Practical Tools Final
Creative Problem Solving   Practical Tools FinalCreative Problem Solving   Practical Tools Final
Creative Problem Solving Practical Tools Final
 
Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020
 
Bcg Banking Report
Bcg Banking ReportBcg Banking Report
Bcg Banking Report
 
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011
Feedback Intro To Consulting 2011
 
Mi M Feedback
Mi M FeedbackMi M Feedback
Mi M Feedback
 
Type Of Case
Type Of CaseType Of Case
Type Of Case
 
Firm
FirmFirm
Firm
 
Format
FormatFormat
Format
 
Geography
GeographyGeography
Geography
 

Alternative Internship Pathways Feedback 2011

  • 1. + MBA Consulting Curriculum 2010-11: Continued Feedback Alternative Internship Pathways Presentation & panel J-P Martins Associate Director Consulting Careers February 2011
  • 2. + Summary n  The event was excellently received n  100% of respondents would recommend the Alternative Internship Pathways event n  However, only 12 of 43 attendees submitted feedback surveys (28%) n  This is an annual event – a presentation and panel aimed at highlighting internship routes other than strategy consulting that can still lead to successful permanent applications in the autumn n  This year the event was held earlier than in previous years, in an attempt to head off despondency before it sets in amongst the first years n  Many of the attendees were still in recruitment processes with consulting firms at LBS n  In another change this year, I held the panel discussion first, before focusing on data from previous years n  The panel comprised 3 second year students that successfully applied to strategy consulting in the autumn having failed to secure a ‘milkround’ internship last Spring
  • 3. + Quantitative survey data
  • 4. + Alternative Internship Pathways: all respondents would recommend it strongly 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% The format and content of the session were 7 5 excellent The presenters and panellists were 8 4 engaging and informative The event was well organised - logistics 1 7 4 and venue were appropriate I would strongly recommend this event to 6 6 next year's first year MBA students Disagree Strongly Disagree Agree Agree Strongly Response rate: 12/43 (28%)
  • 5. + Comments
  • 6. + Alternative Internship Pathways: What should we do differently? n  Nothing (x 4) n  Maybe add more students on the panel n  The event should be organised better n  A pre-survey of reasons for rejection will be useful n  Have up to date information to be able to compare it to current results n  More personal advices n  I don’t know how to implement this but advice sounds very generic – heard all that before. If there was any way to push the panelists to be more specific (at the expense of being less politically correct), I think people will appreciate that more n  A more extensive panel of students would be useful for a balanced perspective of experiences. I would have liked to have seen more of an explanation about the feasibility of approaching firms for permanent recruitment who you were unsuccessful with when applying for internship applications. It would be good to get a better understanding as to whether repeat approaches for the same firms are ever successful. There is rumour that this is easiest if you were dinged at or before a first round interview (unless specifically asked to reapply). Additionally, a high level timeline of recommended actions to take to approach permanent recruitment for consulting would be useful n  Perhaps the panel could be more structured, or less Q&A from students for the panel?
  • 7. + Alternative Internship Pathways: What should we keep the same? n  Everything (x2) n  Definitely keep the numbers that paint an optimistic picture and the panel (x2) n  Bring 2nd year students to talk about their experiences (x2) n  The format of the session n  Keep a panel and statistics n  This was an incredibly helpful event. Hearing the 2nd years experience and your data were both especially helpful n  Presentation and panel both worth having
  • 8. + Surprisingly, no other comments attached to quantitative questions Format and Content Presenter and Panellists n  No comments n  No comments Organisation – venue and logistics General n  No comments n  No comments