Presentation given at the 2013 Illinois SHRM State Conference by Paul Hebert, VP Solutions Design at Symbolist. This presentation was a discussion on how current technology-enabled HR systems for recognition and rewards may actually be causing lower engagement by creating psychological distance between people and creating a technology crutch for what is essentially a human and relationship issue in the work place.
2. ILSHRM 2013
Breaking News!
2013 Global Assessment Trends
Report - Engagement one of
1
King’s College London - of
organizations say Engagement
in 2013.2
Benefits Research 2013 -
cited Employee Engagement as
top issue shaping benefits.3
Humanize Employee Engagement
2
1 http://www.hrmagazine.co.uk/hro/news/1076406/engaging-workforce-priority-hr-2013-report?elqTrack=true
2 http://www.mybinc.com/blog/employment-engagement/#.Ueq3T411_jI
3 http://www.employeebenefits.co.uk/benefits/staff-motivation/engagement-is-leading-focus-for-employers/101812.article
8/19/2013
4. ILSHRM 2013
2010 global engagement score was
(down from 20091)
of employees are now
disengaged or under engaged2
Number of fully engaged employees
dropped to 2
North America sees
since 2008 3
Humanize Employee Engagement
4
1. http://www.aon.com/attachments/thought-leadership/Trends_Global_Employee_Engagement_Final.pdf
2. http://www.prweb.com/releases/2011/10/prweb8866720.htm
3. http://www.hrreporter.com/articleview/18033-north-america-sees-lowest-levels-of-employee-engagement-since-2008-aon-hewitt
8/19/2013
6. ILSHRM 2013 Humanize Employee Engagement
6http://www.gomadthinking.com/employee-engagement-a-priority-for-2013/
Access to needed
resources, tools,
and support
An energizing environment
that promotes physical, emotional
and social well-being
8/19/2013
16. ILSHRM 2013
Remove humans remove compassion
• Quote on inner machiavelli
• Ethics
• Etc.
Humanize Employee Engagement
168/19/2013
17. ILSHRM 2013
People who use social networks like Facebook or
Linkedin are to know their neighbors
and to provide them companionship.
Humanize Employee Engagement
17http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/05/does-technology-reduce-social-isolation/
8/19/2013
19. ILSHRM 2013
19
Humanize Employee Engagement
Some of those
people lived within
walking distance of
Simone.“
"Everyone just carried
on arguing with each
other on Facebook like
it wasn't happening.
8/19/2013
20. ILSHRM 2013
A 2010 study found that while
nearly report
reading posts from a close friend
that seemed like a cry for
emotional help…
to see the distressed friend.
Humanize Employee Engagement
20http://m.theepochtimes.com/n2/technology/social-networking-isolation-college-students-facebook-myspace-twitter-44049.html8/19/2013
21. ILSHRM 2013
The happiest participants
spent
and
than the unhappiest
participants
Happiest participants had
and one third
as much small talk as the
unhappiest participants.
Humanize Employee Engagement
21http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/03/100304165902.htm
The happy life is social
and conversationally
deep rather than
solitary and superficial
8/19/2013
22. ILSHRM 2013
Low Social Interaction Is Like…
• Smoking 15
cigarettes a day
• Being an alcoholic
• Worse than not
exercising
• Twice as harmful as
obesity
Humanize Employee Engagement
22http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/07/100727174909.htm8/19/2013
23. ILSHRM 2013
Social connections – friends, family,
neighbors or colleagues –
Humanize Employee Engagement
23http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/07/100727174909.htm8/19/2013
25. ILSHRM 2013
25
Humanize Employee Engagement
While online tools help
people communicate with
one another, without the
visual cues of actual
human contact these
digital relationships carry
misunderstandings and
cause confusion.
Students report that at
least they
are uncertain whether the
sender is joking or serious.
8/19/2013
26. ILSHRM 2013 Humanize Employee Engagement
26
In the real world,
These are the cues we
use to gauge whether
someone is listening to
us, agrees with us, is
attracted to us, or wants
us to shut up.
8/19/2013
27. ILSHRM 2013
27
Humanize Employee Engagement
When Animal Kingdom opened in Orlando the first visitors
complained that the real animals were not as "realistic" as the
animatronic creatures in other parts of Disneyworld.
8/19/2013
28. ILSHRM 2013
28
Humanize Employee Engagement
The need to find another human
being to share one’s life with has
always puzzled me.
Maybe because I’m
so interesting all
by myself.
8/19/2013
30. ILSHRM 2013
30
Humanize Employee Engagement
I was the
choice.
It calculated I had a
45% chance of survival,
Sarah only had 11%
chance.
That was
somebody's baby.
A would have
known that.8/19/2013
31. ILSHRM 2013
31
Humanize Employee Engagement
you are
OK… They did not need to ask permission from anybody
to do so.”
Herb Kelleher, founder of Southwest Airlines
“Colleen [Barret] is primarily responsible for the humanistic
culture we have at Southwest… she ascertained that
that would evolve in
a given station.
8/19/2013
35. ILSHRM 2013
35
Humanize Employee Engagement
http://www.slideshare.net/missrogue/happiness-as-your-business-model-414463?from_search=9
• Interacting with others
• Connecting with people
• Connecting people
• Giving/Generosity
• Feeling loved
• Emotional security
• Acknowledgement and Support
8/19/2013
36. ILSHRM 2013
36
Humanize Employee Engagement
Passive Activism
People no longer need to take to
the streets to protest. They can do
so within the comfort of their
homes. Is it good to have passive
activism or is it just
adding unnecessary noise and
mislabeling comfortable
complacency?
http://thenextweb.com/insider/2011/10/30/are-new-technologies-making-us-happier/
8/19/2013
39. ILSHRM 2013
We’ve for what we think is a
better experience – we like the speed of microwaves but at
the expense of good tasting food.
Humanize Employee Engagement
398/19/2013
40. ILSHRM 2013 Humanize Employee Engagement
40
The simple truth is that
technology is still a poor
substitute for human interaction.
Google—the company where
Mayer grew up—believes that
people needs to be together for
maximum productivity.
8/19/2013
43. ILSHRM 2013
43
Humanize Employee Engagement
Franz Boas, founder of American anthropology,
maintained that the shared language of a community is
the most essential carrier of their common culture.
8/19/2013
44. ILSHRM 2013
Oral communication unites people in
groups. Writing and reading are solitary
activities that throw the psyche back on itself.
44
Humanize Employee Engagement
8/19/2013
45. ILSHRM 2013
45
Humanize Employee Engagement
As Aristotle explained, “When the
storytelling in a culture goes bad
the result is decadence.”
8/19/2013
47. ILSHRM 2013
47
Humanize Employee Engagement
“When data is
ubiquitously accessible,
than the ability to place
these facts in context and
Daniel Pink, A Whole New Mind
8/19/2013
48. ILSHRM 2013
48
Humanize Employee Engagement
Idle chatter can be the social glue from which networks of
trust and norms of reciprocity and potential social capital
can emerge.
Howard Rheingold
8/19/2013
49. ILSHRM 2013
49
Humanize Employee Engagement
The key to successful communicating is realizing
that communication is an opportunity to
motivate and inspire, and all communication
emotional connection to make an impact.
Bert Decker8/19/2013
50. ILSHRM 2013
50
Humanize Employee Engagement
Creates psychological distance and
negative physical affects
Decreases communication clarity
Creates - faux relationships -Being
there and not being there
Removes context around
information reducing meaningful
knowledge transfer
8/19/2013
61. ILSHRM 2013
Creates a “family
tree” for new
employees that
includes staff
photos and a map
of the office.
618/19/2013
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-
business/careers/career-advice/life-at-work/companies-
shift-strategies-to-retain-employees/article13368016/
Humanize Employee Engagement
63. ILSHRM 2013
8/19/2013
Humanize Employee Engagement
63
•Retention among frontline
staff soared from 3% to 67%
•The company had its 2 most
profitable quarters ever
64. ILSHRM 2013
8/19/2013 64
Humanize Employee Engagement
“You’re either a giver or a taker, givers tend
to get stuff back while takers fight for every
last nickel . . . they never have abundance.”
73. ILSHRM 2013
73
Humanize Employee Engagement
that
designs jobs, or work systems
or systems of employment or
democratic processes,
Don Tapscott
8/19/2013
74. ILSHRM 2013
74
Humanize Employee Engagement
• Decrease caring behaviors
• Decrease recognition flexibility
• Increase our use of it as a substitute for reality
• Decrease your organization’s ability to
communicate clearly
• Reduce the impact on future behaviors
8/19/2013
75. ILSHRM 2013
If an organization is nothing more than an instrument
or a machine, used to enrich the owners or top
managers of the organization, then we would be
justified to show it no more commitment than
necessary to obtain our paychecks.
Humanize Employee Engagement
758/19/2013
76. ILSHRM 2013
76
Humanize Employee Engagement
http://www.leadingwithlift.com/blog/2013/03/20/work-life-enrichment-and-being-willing-to-die-for-the-organization-that-would-kill-you-for-caring/#sthash.bsr9Acni.dpuf
If, however, you think of an organization as being made
up of the intersecting lives of human beings, each with
his or her own wants, needs, hopes, desires, fears, and
humanity…
a place where one can have a livelihood,
connect with a personal identity, and contribute to one’s
own growth and to society’s as well.
8/19/2013