"Policy Options for Managing Waterfront Vulnerability to Flooding" presentation by Betsy Blair, NYSDEC Hudson River National Estuarine Research Reserve, from the 4/13/12 Columbia-Greene Revitalizing Hudson Riverfronts forum .
"Policy Options for Managing Waterfront Vulnerability to Flooding" by Betsy Blair
1. Managing
Waterfront
Vulnerability
to
Flooding:
How
can
we
adapt?
Betsy
Blair,
NYSDEC
Marine
Habitat
Protec9on/Hudson
River
NERR
Kris9n
Marcell,
Hudson
River
Estuary
Program/Cornell
WRI
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
3. Can we build smarter?
• Define vulnerable areas (now
and future)
• Design waterfronts to provide
– Economic benefits
– Environmental benefits
– Safety NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
4. What are our
vulnerabilities
now and into
the future?
What
What is the natural
lifespan of assets do
infrastructure? we want to
conserve?
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
5. Considerations at the site
level
• Economic • Social
• Visual • Political
• Environmental • Funding/Administration
• Technical
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
6. Potential Strategies
• Protection: armoring or adding sand to
the shoreline
• Accommodation: elevation of land,
structures or critical systems; designing
to flood
• Strategic Relocation: keeping or
moving structures out of harm’s way
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
8. For good reason
Infrastructure
Oil terminals
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
Cultural landmarks
9. Can we do better?
Don’t do this if you don’t
have to!
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
10. 10 Steps to better shore
zones
• Preserve physical • Tread lightly
diversity • Don’t make dead
• Resist tidiness ends
• Don’t squeeze the • Don’t make it so
zone hard
• Prevent pollution • Give shores room to
• Reduce wave move
damage • Be careful about
building
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
12. Coxsackie Boat Launch
Demonstration Site
Eroding
Shoreline
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
13. Dept of Urban Studies and Planning,
School of Architecture + Planning at MIT
http://bronx.mit.edu/meet-your-waterfront-plan
“…the gabions are arranged in an
undulating pattern along the
riparian edge to disperse wave
motion and slow water speeds.”
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
15. Elevated structures with
flood gates, Hamburg,
Germany
Wave attenuation,
Brooklyn Bridge Park
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
16. Allow Room for Rivers
Village of Tarrytown
• Shoreline “eco-corridor”
with swales and native
grasses
• www.scenichudson.org
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
18. Over the long
term in many
areas
greenways and
parks may be
better uses of
the shore than
buildings.
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
19. Iona Island
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
20. Limit development in highest
risk areas
Town of Pleasant Valley
– Floodplain Protection:
Zoning code limits uses
in 100 yr floodplain to
uses minimally affected
by high water Dobbs Ferry
– http://pleasantvalley-
ny.gov/
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
Saugerties
21. Don’t drown wetlands!
Town of East Hampton
– Examined sea level rise and storms in
comprehensive plan
– Studied changing wetland boundaries
– Prohibits building of bulkheads that would block
wetland movement.
– 150’ setback and no build zones in high hazard
floodplains
– http://www.nyswaterfronts.com/LWRP/Town%20of
%20East%20Hampton/default/
Town_of_East_Hampton_LWRP.htm
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
22. City of Hudson riverfront
Present day, low tide
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
23. City of Hudson riverfront
Simulation: Inundation -- high tide with 4 feet of
sea level rise
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
24. City of Hudson riverfront
Simulation: Armored protection
at high tide with 4 feet of sea
level rise
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
26. City of Kingston waterfront
Simulation: Armored protection with elevated sea level (low
tide).
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
27. City of Kingston waterfront
Simulation: Accommodation to elevated sea level
(low tide), vegetated revetment, flood-proofed
buildings
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
28. City of Kingston waterfront
Simulation: Strategic retreat with elevated sea
level (low tide)
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
29. Questions?
Betsy Blair
NYS DEC Hudson River NERR
Phone: (845) 889-4745 x113
Email: bablair@gw.dec.state.ny.us
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation