SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 13
Ambani vs. Ambani The Court Judgment goes beyond the brother’s fight
What is the fight about? RIL agreed to sell RNRL 80mmscmd of gas from KG Basin for 17 years at $2.34 per mmbtu for its Dadari power plant. With RIL not supplying he gas, RNRL went to court against it for not implementing this part of a family MoU signed when the empire was being carved up between the two brothers.
Where does Petroleum ministry come in? RIL got the right to look for gas in the KG basin after signing a PSC with the government. In the PSC, the government gets a share of RIL’s KG profits. Since profit are related to the price, the government say it has the right to vet each contract RIL signs to sell gas. The ministry used this to reject the RIL-RNRL contract, saying it was not an arms-length one.
So what’s the problem? RNRL argues the ministry’s role under the PSC is limited to ensuring it gets fair share of profits theoretically.  RIL can give the gas away free as long as it gives the government its share of the profit, Based on either the price fixed by the government or on a competitive arms-length bidding process.
Interestingly, while answering question in parliament, the government stance for year has been that its role is limited to ensuring it gets its share of profits. The Bombay High Court has ruled that the family MoU does not violate the PSC- that is, the ministry could not cancel the RIL-RNRL agreement.  RIL challenged this in the Supreme Court.
How was the contract an arms-length one when there was no bidding? In 2003, NTPC invited global firms to bid to supply it gas for its Kawas-Gandhar power plant for 17 years. RIL bid the lowest $2.34 per mmbtu and NTPC gave it a latter of intent in June 2004.  The RIL-RNRL contract was based on this since it was signed in the same time period except,  The RNRL contract was for 28 mmscmd of gas while the NTPC one was for 12 mmscmd.
RIL later objected to some of the clauses in the NTPC tender and refused to supply the gas. NTPC went to court against RIL. RNRL argues that since the contract was based one NTPC one, it was an arms-length one.
What is the market price of this gas? RIL had called for bids from buyers in April 2007, and they bid an average price of $4.33 per mmbtu. After some minor tweaking, the government accepted $4.20 per mmbtu as the price.
Do RIL and the government lose at the $2.34 price? Compared to $4.20, they do. RIL’s cost of producing gas, according to the DGH, is $1.28 per mmbtu, so it doesn’t really lose at $2.34 though it does earn less. The government’s gain/losses are more complicated. If gas prices are raised, fertilizer and electricity prices also go up and consumers end up paying more – to keep them at the same level, the hike required in government subsidies will be much more than the increased profits it gets when the gas is priced at $4.20.
How does RIL’s capital expenditure come in here? Under the PSC, RIL first gets to recover its capital and operating costs out of whatever revenues get generated; it is only after this that the government get a share in the profit – this share rises as RIL’s revenue to cost ratio rises. If its capital expenditure goes up, the government’s profit fall. The DGH says the capital expenditure has been verified by independent experts including the CAG – the CAG’s report, however, has not been made public.
RNRL has pointed out that these experts weren’t really independent and were connected with RIL in various ways. Besides, two of the four member management committee that okays RIL’s costs for the KG basin are employees of RIL under the PSC, this will be common for all contractors, not just RIL.
Is there a larger policy issue here? The policy through which the government is now allocating gas Dadri cannot get gas under its allocation formula – came into being seven years after the PSC was signed. So the issue is whether a government can come up with a government can come up with a policy after private sector players have come in and invested billions.
Thank you for your proper response and support! For further information contact:  +91-9427913540 vasant_parakhiya@yahoo.com From : Parakhiya Vasant ssopcon@yahoo.com

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Pidilite Industries | Company Analysis
Pidilite Industries | Company AnalysisPidilite Industries | Company Analysis
Pidilite Industries | Company AnalysisRohan Bharaj
 
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030 LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030 LightCastle Partners
 
Power and politics of ambani brothers
Power and politics of ambani brothersPower and politics of ambani brothers
Power and politics of ambani brothersNeha Chauhan
 
Wipro
WiproWipro
Wipro-
 
Presentation on cipla project
Presentation on cipla projectPresentation on cipla project
Presentation on cipla projectPratyush Mishra
 
Air India - Turnaround strategy
Air India - Turnaround strategyAir India - Turnaround strategy
Air India - Turnaround strategyMayank Agrawal
 
Adani Wilmar IPO Details
Adani Wilmar IPO Details Adani Wilmar IPO Details
Adani Wilmar IPO Details Prasath S
 
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGeckoCoinGecko
 
Takeover battle between grasim and l&t
Takeover battle between grasim and l&tTakeover battle between grasim and l&t
Takeover battle between grasim and l&tMohammed Bharmal
 
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limited
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limitedDhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limited
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limitedSohail Nathwani
 
Wesco case B2B case study
Wesco case B2B case studyWesco case B2B case study
Wesco case B2B case studyAbhijeet Kumar
 
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure: Digital for climate?
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure:  Digital for climate?Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure:  Digital for climate?
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure: Digital for climate?Fabernovel
 
Smoky valley company case
Smoky valley company caseSmoky valley company case
Smoky valley company caseFenella Andrade
 
Cement Industry Analysis (India)
Cement Industry Analysis (India)Cement Industry Analysis (India)
Cement Industry Analysis (India)PRAKASH KUMAR
 
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambani
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambaniLeadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambani
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambaniTirtha Mal
 
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action accenture
 
Project report (1)
Project report (1)Project report (1)
Project report (1)Amrit Kumar
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Pidilite Industries | Company Analysis
Pidilite Industries | Company AnalysisPidilite Industries | Company Analysis
Pidilite Industries | Company Analysis
 
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030 LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030
LightCastle Partners Bangladesh Hi-Tech industries Vision 2030
 
Power and politics of ambani brothers
Power and politics of ambani brothersPower and politics of ambani brothers
Power and politics of ambani brothers
 
Wipro
WiproWipro
Wipro
 
Presentation on cipla project
Presentation on cipla projectPresentation on cipla project
Presentation on cipla project
 
Air India - Turnaround strategy
Air India - Turnaround strategyAir India - Turnaround strategy
Air India - Turnaround strategy
 
Netflix case study
Netflix case studyNetflix case study
Netflix case study
 
Adani Wilmar IPO Details
Adani Wilmar IPO Details Adani Wilmar IPO Details
Adani Wilmar IPO Details
 
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko
2023 Q2 Crypto Industry Report | CoinGecko
 
Takeover battle between grasim and l&t
Takeover battle between grasim and l&tTakeover battle between grasim and l&t
Takeover battle between grasim and l&t
 
IB- pestle-analysis-of-india
IB-   pestle-analysis-of-india IB-   pestle-analysis-of-india
IB- pestle-analysis-of-india
 
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limited
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limitedDhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limited
Dhirubhai ambani successful business man----reliance industries limited
 
Wesco case B2B case study
Wesco case B2B case studyWesco case B2B case study
Wesco case B2B case study
 
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure: Digital for climate?
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure:  Digital for climate?Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure:  Digital for climate?
Study Ardian & Fabernovel - The Augmented Infrastructure: Digital for climate?
 
Project on anand mahindra
Project on anand mahindraProject on anand mahindra
Project on anand mahindra
 
Smoky valley company case
Smoky valley company caseSmoky valley company case
Smoky valley company case
 
Cement Industry Analysis (India)
Cement Industry Analysis (India)Cement Industry Analysis (India)
Cement Industry Analysis (India)
 
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambani
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambaniLeadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambani
Leadership Style of the richest Indian Mukesh ambani
 
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action
The Decade to Deliver: A Call to Business Action
 
Project report (1)
Project report (1)Project report (1)
Project report (1)
 

Andere mochten auch

Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after the
Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after theGrowth of mukesh & anil ambani after the
Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after theGuneet Singh
 
Reliance presantation
Reliance presantationReliance presantation
Reliance presantationAMIT SACHDEV
 
Ambani vs. ambani
Ambani vs. ambaniAmbani vs. ambani
Ambani vs. ambaniJonty Mohta
 
Anil ambani final
Anil ambani finalAnil ambani final
Anil ambani finalAjay Khot
 
Family business entrepreneurs
Family business entrepreneursFamily business entrepreneurs
Family business entrepreneursFenella Andrade
 
Succesion planning in family business
Succesion planning in family business Succesion planning in family business
Succesion planning in family business Ranjit Achary
 
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai Ambani
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai AmbaniManagement Lessons From Dhirubhai Ambani
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai AmbaniNISHA SHAH
 
Family business succession & growth
Family business succession & growthFamily business succession & growth
Family business succession & growthRikitacjdd
 
Introduction to Family Businesses
Introduction to Family BusinessesIntroduction to Family Businesses
Introduction to Family Businessescommandeleven
 
The Family Business Power Point Presentation
The Family Business Power Point PresentationThe Family Business Power Point Presentation
The Family Business Power Point PresentationRonaldFilian
 
Keys to Family Business Success
Keys to Family Business SuccessKeys to Family Business Success
Keys to Family Business SuccessShem Cohen
 
Indian family businesses
Indian family businessesIndian family businesses
Indian family businessesmaheshtcm
 
Project report on reliance
Project report on relianceProject report on reliance
Project report on reliance9928424289
 

Andere mochten auch (20)

Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after the
Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after theGrowth of mukesh & anil ambani after the
Growth of mukesh & anil ambani after the
 
Reliance presantation
Reliance presantationReliance presantation
Reliance presantation
 
Ambani vs. ambani
Ambani vs. ambaniAmbani vs. ambani
Ambani vs. ambani
 
RIL vs RNRL
RIL vs RNRLRIL vs RNRL
RIL vs RNRL
 
Anil ambani final
Anil ambani finalAnil ambani final
Anil ambani final
 
Anil ambani
Anil ambaniAnil ambani
Anil ambani
 
Family business entrepreneurs
Family business entrepreneursFamily business entrepreneurs
Family business entrepreneurs
 
Succesion planning in family business
Succesion planning in family business Succesion planning in family business
Succesion planning in family business
 
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai Ambani
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai AmbaniManagement Lessons From Dhirubhai Ambani
Management Lessons From Dhirubhai Ambani
 
Family business succession & growth
Family business succession & growthFamily business succession & growth
Family business succession & growth
 
Mukesh Ambani Strategic Management
Mukesh Ambani Strategic ManagementMukesh Ambani Strategic Management
Mukesh Ambani Strategic Management
 
Introduction to Family Businesses
Introduction to Family BusinessesIntroduction to Family Businesses
Introduction to Family Businesses
 
New ppt over reliance
New ppt over relianceNew ppt over reliance
New ppt over reliance
 
The Family Business Power Point Presentation
The Family Business Power Point PresentationThe Family Business Power Point Presentation
The Family Business Power Point Presentation
 
Dhirubhai ambani
Dhirubhai ambaniDhirubhai ambani
Dhirubhai ambani
 
Keys to Family Business Success
Keys to Family Business SuccessKeys to Family Business Success
Keys to Family Business Success
 
Indian family businesses
Indian family businessesIndian family businesses
Indian family businesses
 
Family business
Family businessFamily business
Family business
 
Project report on reliance
Project report on relianceProject report on reliance
Project report on reliance
 
Family business
Family businessFamily business
Family business
 

Ähnlich wie Mukesh Ambani vs. Anil Ambani

Reliance KG Basin Gas Scam
Reliance KG Basin Gas ScamReliance KG Basin Gas Scam
Reliance KG Basin Gas ScamApoorva Yadav
 
Case Of Krishna Godhavari Basin
Case Of Krishna Godhavari BasinCase Of Krishna Godhavari Basin
Case Of Krishna Godhavari BasinTICS
 
City gas distribution
City gas distributionCity gas distribution
City gas distributionSneha Santra
 
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On Ril
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On RilIndolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On Ril
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On RilJagannadham Thunuguntla
 
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On Ril
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On RilTimes Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On Ril
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On RilJagannadham Thunuguntla
 
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELP
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELPIndian revenue sharing contract & HELP
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELPNishant Mehta
 
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011Rameez Shaikh
 
production sharing contract
production sharing contractproduction sharing contract
production sharing contractSaurav Kumar
 
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)Flame Of Truth
 
Kg gas the flame of truth - 2
Kg gas   the flame of truth - 2Kg gas   the flame of truth - 2
Kg gas the flame of truth - 2kirby1973
 
TTNGL APO Roadshow
TTNGL APO RoadshowTTNGL APO Roadshow
TTNGL APO Roadshowttnglapo
 

Ähnlich wie Mukesh Ambani vs. Anil Ambani (20)

Kg Basin
Kg BasinKg Basin
Kg Basin
 
Ril vs rnrl
Ril vs rnrlRil vs rnrl
Ril vs rnrl
 
Kg Basin, RIL
Kg Basin, RILKg Basin, RIL
Kg Basin, RIL
 
Reliance KG Basin Gas Scam
Reliance KG Basin Gas ScamReliance KG Basin Gas Scam
Reliance KG Basin Gas Scam
 
Help
HelpHelp
Help
 
Case Of Krishna Godhavari Basin
Case Of Krishna Godhavari BasinCase Of Krishna Godhavari Basin
Case Of Krishna Godhavari Basin
 
City gas distribution
City gas distributionCity gas distribution
City gas distribution
 
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On Ril
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On RilIndolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On Ril
Indolink June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles By 362 Pts After HC Ruling On Ril
 
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On Ril
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On RilTimes Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On Ril
Times Now June 15, 2009 Sensex Tumbles After HC Ruling On Ril
 
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELP
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELPIndian revenue sharing contract & HELP
Indian revenue sharing contract & HELP
 
Gas Price Hike Impact
Gas Price Hike ImpactGas Price Hike Impact
Gas Price Hike Impact
 
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011
General Carbon Newsletter - April 2011
 
Nl energy july 11 - july 17, 2015
Nl energy july 11 - july 17, 2015Nl energy july 11 - july 17, 2015
Nl energy july 11 - july 17, 2015
 
Revenue and Fiscal System of Oil and Gas in Indonesia
Revenue and Fiscal System of Oil and Gas in IndonesiaRevenue and Fiscal System of Oil and Gas in Indonesia
Revenue and Fiscal System of Oil and Gas in Indonesia
 
Beacon June 2014
Beacon June 2014Beacon June 2014
Beacon June 2014
 
production sharing contract
production sharing contractproduction sharing contract
production sharing contract
 
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)
KG Gas: The Flame Of Truth (ENGLISH)
 
Kg gas the flame of truth - 2
Kg gas   the flame of truth - 2Kg gas   the flame of truth - 2
Kg gas the flame of truth - 2
 
RSCPSC_PPT_V2.pptx
RSCPSC_PPT_V2.pptxRSCPSC_PPT_V2.pptx
RSCPSC_PPT_V2.pptx
 
TTNGL APO Roadshow
TTNGL APO RoadshowTTNGL APO Roadshow
TTNGL APO Roadshow
 

Mehr von Vasantkumar Parakhiya (20)

NEETY EURO ASIA SOLAR ENERGY
NEETY EURO ASIA SOLAR ENERGYNEETY EURO ASIA SOLAR ENERGY
NEETY EURO ASIA SOLAR ENERGY
 
Shree yogkshem foundation 4 human dignity
Shree yogkshem foundation 4 human dignityShree yogkshem foundation 4 human dignity
Shree yogkshem foundation 4 human dignity
 
Sewa
SewaSewa
Sewa
 
Saath the suicide prevention org.
Saath the suicide prevention org.Saath the suicide prevention org.
Saath the suicide prevention org.
 
Lioness clubs
Lioness clubsLioness clubs
Lioness clubs
 
Krishna old age home
Krishna old age homeKrishna old age home
Krishna old age home
 
Indian red cross society
Indian red cross societyIndian red cross society
Indian red cross society
 
Gmht sewa
Gmht sewaGmht sewa
Gmht sewa
 
Blind school hostel
Blind school hostelBlind school hostel
Blind school hostel
 
Thought
ThoughtThought
Thought
 
Measuring market demand
Measuring market demandMeasuring market demand
Measuring market demand
 
Indian marketing system
Indian marketing systemIndian marketing system
Indian marketing system
 
Developing new market offerings
Developing new market offeringsDeveloping new market offerings
Developing new market offerings
 
Celebrity endrosement
Celebrity endrosementCelebrity endrosement
Celebrity endrosement
 
Advertising & salespromotion
Advertising & salespromotionAdvertising & salespromotion
Advertising & salespromotion
 
Sanj Samachar
Sanj SamacharSanj Samachar
Sanj Samachar
 
Shree Yogkshem
Shree YogkshemShree Yogkshem
Shree Yogkshem
 
Samarpan White
Samarpan WhiteSamarpan White
Samarpan White
 
Social Project
Social ProjectSocial Project
Social Project
 
Saath
SaathSaath
Saath
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423 Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In Turbhe
Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423  Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In TurbheTurbhe Female Escorts 09167354423  Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In Turbhe
Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423 Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In TurbhePriya Reddy
 
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableNitya salvi
 
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service Bhubaneswar
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service BhubaneswarCall Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service Bhubaneswar
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service BhubaneswarCall Girls Mumbai
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyNitya salvi
 
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call GirlsGenuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call GirlsNitya salvi
 
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girlsPakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girlsMonica Sydney
 
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...DipikaDelhi
 
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine Service
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine ServiceDahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine Service
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine ServiceNitya salvi
 
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423 Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423  Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423  Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423 Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...Priya Reddy
 
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...call girls kolkata
 
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call GirlsNitya salvi
 
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...call girls kolkata
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyNitya salvi
 
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Nitya salvi
 
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...call girls kolkata
 
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book now
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book nowUnnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book now
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book nowNitya salvi
 
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...DipikaDelhi
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyNitya salvi
 
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girls
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girlsCall girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girls
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girlsMonica Sydney
 
Kailashahar Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...
Kailashahar  Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...Kailashahar  Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...
Kailashahar Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...Nitya salvi
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423 Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In Turbhe
Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423  Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In TurbheTurbhe Female Escorts 09167354423  Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In Turbhe
Turbhe Female Escorts 09167354423 Turbhe Escorts,Call Girls In Turbhe
 
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Moradabad Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service Bhubaneswar
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service BhubaneswarCall Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service Bhubaneswar
Call Girls Bhubaneswar 9777949614 call me Independent Escort Service Bhubaneswar
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Auraiya Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call GirlsGenuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Gomati Escorts call Girls
 
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girlsPakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Deira 0567006274 Deira Call girls
 
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...
Call girls Service Khammam - 9332606886 Rs 3000 Free Pickup & Drop Services 2...
 
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine Service
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine ServiceDahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine Service
Dahod Call Girl 📞 8617370543 Low Price Genuine Service
 
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423 Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423  Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423  Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...
Ghansoli Escorts Services 09167354423 Ghansoli Call Girls,Call Girls In Ghan...
 
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...
Call girls Service Dombivli - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide y...
 
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls
📞 Contact Number 8617370543VIP Fatehgarh Call Girls
 
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Perumbavoor / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Kushinagar Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls South Tripura Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
 
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...
Call Girls Kozhikode - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide you with...
 
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book now
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book nowUnnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book now
Unnao 💋 Call Girl 8617370543 Call Girls in unnao Escort service book now
 
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...
Call girls Service Berhampur - 9332606886 Our call girls are sure to provide ...
 
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617370543 Dhalai Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girls
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girlsCall girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girls
Call girls Service in Deira 0507330913 Deira Call girls
 
Kailashahar Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...
Kailashahar  Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...Kailashahar  Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...
Kailashahar Call Girl Whatsapp Number 📞 8617370543 | Girls Number for Friend...
 

Mukesh Ambani vs. Anil Ambani

  • 1. Ambani vs. Ambani The Court Judgment goes beyond the brother’s fight
  • 2. What is the fight about? RIL agreed to sell RNRL 80mmscmd of gas from KG Basin for 17 years at $2.34 per mmbtu for its Dadari power plant. With RIL not supplying he gas, RNRL went to court against it for not implementing this part of a family MoU signed when the empire was being carved up between the two brothers.
  • 3. Where does Petroleum ministry come in? RIL got the right to look for gas in the KG basin after signing a PSC with the government. In the PSC, the government gets a share of RIL’s KG profits. Since profit are related to the price, the government say it has the right to vet each contract RIL signs to sell gas. The ministry used this to reject the RIL-RNRL contract, saying it was not an arms-length one.
  • 4. So what’s the problem? RNRL argues the ministry’s role under the PSC is limited to ensuring it gets fair share of profits theoretically. RIL can give the gas away free as long as it gives the government its share of the profit, Based on either the price fixed by the government or on a competitive arms-length bidding process.
  • 5. Interestingly, while answering question in parliament, the government stance for year has been that its role is limited to ensuring it gets its share of profits. The Bombay High Court has ruled that the family MoU does not violate the PSC- that is, the ministry could not cancel the RIL-RNRL agreement. RIL challenged this in the Supreme Court.
  • 6. How was the contract an arms-length one when there was no bidding? In 2003, NTPC invited global firms to bid to supply it gas for its Kawas-Gandhar power plant for 17 years. RIL bid the lowest $2.34 per mmbtu and NTPC gave it a latter of intent in June 2004. The RIL-RNRL contract was based on this since it was signed in the same time period except, The RNRL contract was for 28 mmscmd of gas while the NTPC one was for 12 mmscmd.
  • 7. RIL later objected to some of the clauses in the NTPC tender and refused to supply the gas. NTPC went to court against RIL. RNRL argues that since the contract was based one NTPC one, it was an arms-length one.
  • 8. What is the market price of this gas? RIL had called for bids from buyers in April 2007, and they bid an average price of $4.33 per mmbtu. After some minor tweaking, the government accepted $4.20 per mmbtu as the price.
  • 9. Do RIL and the government lose at the $2.34 price? Compared to $4.20, they do. RIL’s cost of producing gas, according to the DGH, is $1.28 per mmbtu, so it doesn’t really lose at $2.34 though it does earn less. The government’s gain/losses are more complicated. If gas prices are raised, fertilizer and electricity prices also go up and consumers end up paying more – to keep them at the same level, the hike required in government subsidies will be much more than the increased profits it gets when the gas is priced at $4.20.
  • 10. How does RIL’s capital expenditure come in here? Under the PSC, RIL first gets to recover its capital and operating costs out of whatever revenues get generated; it is only after this that the government get a share in the profit – this share rises as RIL’s revenue to cost ratio rises. If its capital expenditure goes up, the government’s profit fall. The DGH says the capital expenditure has been verified by independent experts including the CAG – the CAG’s report, however, has not been made public.
  • 11. RNRL has pointed out that these experts weren’t really independent and were connected with RIL in various ways. Besides, two of the four member management committee that okays RIL’s costs for the KG basin are employees of RIL under the PSC, this will be common for all contractors, not just RIL.
  • 12. Is there a larger policy issue here? The policy through which the government is now allocating gas Dadri cannot get gas under its allocation formula – came into being seven years after the PSC was signed. So the issue is whether a government can come up with a government can come up with a policy after private sector players have come in and invested billions.
  • 13. Thank you for your proper response and support! For further information contact: +91-9427913540 vasant_parakhiya@yahoo.com From : Parakhiya Vasant ssopcon@yahoo.com