SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 40
miRNA activity in
Arabidopsis thaliana plants
Helen Oh
Andrew Tsai
Purpose



 To identify potential genes that regulate miRNA
    activity, especially in regards to growth and
                    development.
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
   Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
     Screen using BASTA
     Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
     Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
     Germination assay
     BASTA assay
either too slow (ABA hypersensitive) or too fast (ABA hyposensitive), these collection of

Mutagenize with T-DNA
 mutant plants will be highly enriched in mutations that affect miRNA activity. In sum, we
 will direct our studies on screening for mutations that enhance or diminish the response
 of Arabidopsis plants to the plant hormone abscisic acid (ABA). This approach has

      insertion
 already resulted in the identification of a number of interesting genes, and will hopefully
 lead to identification of a number more within this semester's class.
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
   Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
   Screen using BASTA
     Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
     Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
     Germination assay
     BASTA assay
Screen using BASTA




  I1. Mutagenesis strategy using T-DNA containing three tandem strong
 rview of procedure Brian Gregory used to prepare the mutagenized seed th
 screen. B) Cartoon depicting thegerminated is inserted into the plant genom
                     Ten plants T-DNA that on BASTA.
ns. Shown is a random gene that is induced by the insertion (green arrow, r
   borders of the T-DNA (RB, LB, orange), the herbicide resistance gene exp
                                                               r
DNA that we will use to select mutagenized seedlings (BASTA , purple), and
 enhancers (35S enhancers, red).
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
   Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
   Screen using BASTA
   Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
     Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
     Germination assay
     BASTA assay
Screen using ABA



 Six plants displayed mutated responses to ABA ,
   specifically they displayed hypersensitive root
                        growth.
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
   Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
   Screen using BASTA
   Screen using ABA
   Screen for typical mutant miRNA
    phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
     Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
     Germination assay
     BASTA assay
Screen for typical mutant
    miRNA phenotype
 HOAT2-2
Screen for typical mutant
   miRNA phenotypes
 HOAT3-2
Screen for typical mutant
    miRNA phenotype
 HOAT5-2
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
     Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
     Screen using BASTA
     Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
   Find location of T-DNA insertion
   Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
   Germination assay
   BASTA assay
Find location of T-DNA
           insertion

 TAIL PCR was
  performed.




                              AD1/AD2
 This gel shows
  that AD primers




                        AD2
  are about 100 bps.
Find location of T-DNA
            insertion

 TAIL PCR product for




                         HOAT2-2AD1

                                      HOAT2-2AD2

                                                   HOAT2-2AD3
  HOAT2-2AD2 and




                                                                HOAT3-2AD1

                                                                             HOAT3-2AD2

                                                                                          HOAT3-2AD3

                                                                                                       HOAT5-2AD1
  HOAT3-2AD2 are
  about 750 bps.

 Lower bands are AD
  primers.
Find location of T-DNA
         insertion


 Heavy upper bands could be




                                HOAT5-2AD2


                                             HOAT5-2AD3
  due to precipitated DNA.

 Lower bands are AD primers.
Find location of T-DNA
             insertion

 DNA sequence analysis
  performed.

 HOAT3-2:
   Had greater or equal to 200
    as alignment score.
   Expected value was 0.0.
Find location of T-DNA
            insertion

 AT3G09720 codes for a




                            upstream
  protein with a p-loop.
   Binds nucleotides and




                                       upstream
    ATP
   Helicase functions



                                            downstream
 AT3G09730 has no
  known function.
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
     Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
     Screen using BASTA
     Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
   Determine whether miRNA target genes
    are affected
   Germination assay
   BASTA assay
Determine whether miRNA
 target genes are affected


         GRF3 is a known target of miRNA.

 Look at amount of mRNA transcribed from GRF3 to
   determine if miRNA activity is potentially altered.
Determine whether miRNA
 target genes are affected




                                        HOAT2-2




                                                            HOAT5-2
                                                  HOAT3-2




                                                                      Col-0
 Non-degraded RNA has
  the following bands: 28s
  rRNA and 18s rRNA.
                             28s rRNA
 Create cDNA for HOAT3-2    18s rRNA
  and HOAT5-2.
Determine whether miRNA
    target genes are affected
                26 cycles
      HOAT3-2

                HOAT5-2


                                                                                   sqPCR was
                                Col-0
                          DDL

                                                                                    performed.



• Actin primers (above).                              26 cycles
                                        HOAT3-2
                                                  HOAT5-2


                                                                  Col-0
                                                            DDL


                                                                          Col-0
• GRF3 primers (below).
Determine whether miRNA
 target genes are affected
 qPCR was performed.
                                   qPCR
              1200


              1000


              800
Percentages




              600


              400


              200


                0
                     Col-0   DDL                 HOAT3-2   HOAT5-2
                                    Plant Name
HOAT3-2

  HOAT5-2

   DDL




              26 cycles
  Col-0

 HOAT3-2
                            Actin primers
  HOAT5-2

  DDL         30 cycles

   Col-0

HOAT3-2, 30               26 cycles

HOAT3-2, 30               30 cycles

 Col-0, 30                26 cycles

 Col-0, 30                30 cycles

HOAT3-2, 20               26 cycles
                                                                             target genes are affected




HOAT3-2, 20               30 cycles
                                                                            Determine whether miRNA




 Col-0, 20                26 cycles
                                            ATG09730 and ATG09720 primers




 Col-0, 20                30 cycles
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
   Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
   Screen using BASTA
   Screen using ABA
   Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
   Find location of T-DNA insertion
   Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
   Germination assay
   BASTA assay
Germination Assay

 plated onto ABA plates of concentrations:
  0 μM
  0.5 μM
  1 μM
  1.5 μM
Germination Assay

                    0 μM ABA                    • Baseline
              100
               90
                                                • note 3-2 low
               80
               70

  Percent
               60
                                                germination
               50
Germination
               40
               30
               20
               10
                0
                    wt   2-2        3-2   5-2
                          Experimental
Germination Assay


                    0.5 μM ABA                      • Mimics 0 ABA control
              100
               90                                   • T-value of 0.5275
               80
               70

  Percent
               60                                   • Don’t see too much
               50
Germination
               40
               30                                   from this plate
               20
               10
                0
                    wt   2-2          3-2     5-2
                               Experimental
Germination Assay

                    1 μM ABA                    • Start seeing trends
              100
               90
               80
                                                • 3-2, 5-2 hypersensitive
               70

  Percent
               60
               50
                                                • 2-2 ambiguous
Germination
               40
               30
               20
               10
               0
                    wt   2-2        3-2   5-2
                          Experimental
Germination Assay


                    1.5 μM ABA                  • Similar to 1.0 μM ABA
              100
               90                               • 3-2, 5-2
               80
               70
               60
  Percent
               50
Germination
               40
               30
               20
               10
                0
                    wt   2-2        3-2   5-2
                          Experimental
Germination Assay


    Seeds from HOAT 2-2 may have a T-DNA
insertion but are not hyper/hyposensitive to ABA!
Overview

 To identify those potential genes:
     Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions
     Screen using BASTA
     Screen using ABA
     Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes
     Find location of T-DNA insertion
     Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected
     Germination assay
   BASTA assay
BASTA Assay - Theory
   HYPOTHESIS: ABA hyper/hyposensitivity
        caused by T-DNA insertion.
GIVEN:
 T-DNA insertion confers BASTA resistance
 ABA-hypersensitive plants on BASTA – should all
  have T-DNA insertion


Plated surviving plants from ABA treatment onto
BASTA plates
BASTA Assay

             Survival on BASTA                        • Data does not confirm
           100

            80                                        theory
            60
Percent                                    Col-0      • Most surviving plants
Survival    40                             HOAT 2-2
                                           HOAT 3-2
            20                                        have BASTA resistance
                                           HOAT 5-2
             0
                 0.5        1        1.5
                       [ABA] in μM
BASTA Assay - Conclusions

Seeds from HOAT 2-2 HAVE a T-DNA insertion
  but are not hyper/hyposensitive to ABA!
   Contrary to original screen

   2-2 originally identified as hypersensitive
Possible Explanations

    Chance from first hyper/hyposensitivity assay
     (n = 1)
    NOT chance from this experiment
     n = large (despite contamination)
    Possibly growth conditions

BOTTOM LINE: We have a lot of factors at work
         here that we don’t know about!
Possible Explanations

                                                      Possible interaction
             Survival on BASTA
           100
                                                      between ABA and
            80

Percent
            60
                                           Col-0
                                                      BASTA
Survival    40                             HOAT 2-2
                                           HOAT 3-2
            20
                                           HOAT 5-2
             0
                 0.5        1        1.5
                       [ABA] in μM
Conclusions

HOAT 2-2, HOAT 3-2, HOAT 5-2

  Root growth assay  potential to have miRNA
   mutations

  Observable “miRNA phenotypes”
Conclusions

HOAT 3-2, HOAT 5-2
   Increase in GRF3 expression – KNOWN   miR396-
    REGULATED GENE

   Decrease in ATG09720 gene expression  T-DNA
    insertion inside gene.


Future work: How do changes in these gene
expressions explain original phenotype?
References
 Earley, et al., An endogenous F-box protein regulates
  ARGONAUTE1 in Arabidopsis thaliana Silence 2010, 1:15

 Rodriguez RE, Mecchia MA, Debernardi JM, Schommer
  C, Weigel D, Palatnik JF. 2010. Control of cell proliferation in
  Arabidopsis thaliana by microRNA miR396. Development
  137, 103–112.
 Dr. John Wagner, personal communication.

 Allison Lesher, personal communication.

 NCBI BLAST database: gene identification

 TAIR database: gene information

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch

Mi rna data analysis 2013
Mi rna data analysis 2013Mi rna data analysis 2013
Mi rna data analysis 2013Elsa von Licy
 
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...QIAGEN
 
Micro rna edsc350_macabali
Micro rna edsc350_macabaliMicro rna edsc350_macabali
Micro rna edsc350_macabaliKari Ann Bitgue
 
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)Marios Kyriazis
 
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...QIAGEN
 

Andere mochten auch (6)

Mi rna data analysis 2013
Mi rna data analysis 2013Mi rna data analysis 2013
Mi rna data analysis 2013
 
miRNA Revolution
miRNA RevolutionmiRNA Revolution
miRNA Revolution
 
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...
Advanced miRNA Expression Analysis: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webin...
 
Micro rna edsc350_macabali
Micro rna edsc350_macabaliMicro rna edsc350_macabali
Micro rna edsc350_macabali
 
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)
Micro RNAs and ageing Dr Felekkis 2014 (1)
 
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...
Functional Analysis of miRNA: miRNA and its Role in Human Disease Webinar Ser...
 

Ähnlich wie miRNA Activity in Arabidopsis thaliana

Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT
  Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT  Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT
Gene silencing and editing in plant PPTMesele Tilahun
 
final presentation Zangos
final presentation Zangosfinal presentation Zangos
final presentation ZangosGEORGOS ZANGOS
 

Ähnlich wie miRNA Activity in Arabidopsis thaliana (6)

Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT
  Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT  Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT
Gene silencing and editing in plant PPT
 
Honors ~ DNA 1011
Honors ~ DNA 1011Honors ~ DNA 1011
Honors ~ DNA 1011
 
Ap2 Alpha
Ap2 AlphaAp2 Alpha
Ap2 Alpha
 
Protein synthesis
Protein synthesisProtein synthesis
Protein synthesis
 
final presentation Zangos
final presentation Zangosfinal presentation Zangos
final presentation Zangos
 
KO poster 8:13
KO poster 8:13KO poster 8:13
KO poster 8:13
 

miRNA Activity in Arabidopsis thaliana

  • 1. miRNA activity in Arabidopsis thaliana plants Helen Oh Andrew Tsai
  • 2. Purpose  To identify potential genes that regulate miRNA activity, especially in regards to growth and development.
  • 3. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 4. either too slow (ABA hypersensitive) or too fast (ABA hyposensitive), these collection of Mutagenize with T-DNA mutant plants will be highly enriched in mutations that affect miRNA activity. In sum, we will direct our studies on screening for mutations that enhance or diminish the response of Arabidopsis plants to the plant hormone abscisic acid (ABA). This approach has insertion already resulted in the identification of a number of interesting genes, and will hopefully lead to identification of a number more within this semester's class.
  • 5. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 6. Screen using BASTA I1. Mutagenesis strategy using T-DNA containing three tandem strong rview of procedure Brian Gregory used to prepare the mutagenized seed th screen. B) Cartoon depicting thegerminated is inserted into the plant genom  Ten plants T-DNA that on BASTA. ns. Shown is a random gene that is induced by the insertion (green arrow, r borders of the T-DNA (RB, LB, orange), the herbicide resistance gene exp r DNA that we will use to select mutagenized seedlings (BASTA , purple), and enhancers (35S enhancers, red).
  • 7. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 8. Screen using ABA  Six plants displayed mutated responses to ABA , specifically they displayed hypersensitive root growth.
  • 9. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 10. Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotype  HOAT2-2
  • 11. Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  HOAT3-2
  • 12. Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotype  HOAT5-2
  • 13. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 14. Find location of T-DNA insertion  TAIL PCR was performed. AD1/AD2  This gel shows that AD primers AD2 are about 100 bps.
  • 15. Find location of T-DNA insertion  TAIL PCR product for HOAT2-2AD1 HOAT2-2AD2 HOAT2-2AD3 HOAT2-2AD2 and HOAT3-2AD1 HOAT3-2AD2 HOAT3-2AD3 HOAT5-2AD1 HOAT3-2AD2 are about 750 bps.  Lower bands are AD primers.
  • 16. Find location of T-DNA insertion  Heavy upper bands could be HOAT5-2AD2 HOAT5-2AD3 due to precipitated DNA.  Lower bands are AD primers.
  • 17. Find location of T-DNA insertion  DNA sequence analysis performed.  HOAT3-2:  Had greater or equal to 200 as alignment score.  Expected value was 0.0.
  • 18. Find location of T-DNA insertion  AT3G09720 codes for a upstream protein with a p-loop.  Binds nucleotides and upstream ATP  Helicase functions downstream  AT3G09730 has no known function.
  • 19. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 20. Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  GRF3 is a known target of miRNA.  Look at amount of mRNA transcribed from GRF3 to determine if miRNA activity is potentially altered.
  • 21. Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected HOAT2-2 HOAT5-2 HOAT3-2 Col-0  Non-degraded RNA has the following bands: 28s rRNA and 18s rRNA. 28s rRNA  Create cDNA for HOAT3-2 18s rRNA and HOAT5-2.
  • 22. Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected 26 cycles HOAT3-2 HOAT5-2  sqPCR was Col-0 DDL performed. • Actin primers (above). 26 cycles HOAT3-2 HOAT5-2 Col-0 DDL Col-0 • GRF3 primers (below).
  • 23. Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  qPCR was performed. qPCR 1200 1000 800 Percentages 600 400 200 0 Col-0 DDL HOAT3-2 HOAT5-2 Plant Name
  • 24. HOAT3-2 HOAT5-2 DDL 26 cycles Col-0 HOAT3-2 Actin primers HOAT5-2 DDL 30 cycles Col-0 HOAT3-2, 30 26 cycles HOAT3-2, 30 30 cycles Col-0, 30 26 cycles Col-0, 30 30 cycles HOAT3-2, 20 26 cycles target genes are affected HOAT3-2, 20 30 cycles Determine whether miRNA Col-0, 20 26 cycles ATG09730 and ATG09720 primers Col-0, 20 30 cycles
  • 25. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 26. Germination Assay  plated onto ABA plates of concentrations: 0 μM 0.5 μM 1 μM 1.5 μM
  • 27. Germination Assay 0 μM ABA • Baseline 100 90 • note 3-2 low 80 70 Percent 60 germination 50 Germination 40 30 20 10 0 wt 2-2 3-2 5-2 Experimental
  • 28. Germination Assay 0.5 μM ABA • Mimics 0 ABA control 100 90 • T-value of 0.5275 80 70 Percent 60 • Don’t see too much 50 Germination 40 30 from this plate 20 10 0 wt 2-2 3-2 5-2 Experimental
  • 29. Germination Assay 1 μM ABA • Start seeing trends 100 90 80 • 3-2, 5-2 hypersensitive 70 Percent 60 50 • 2-2 ambiguous Germination 40 30 20 10 0 wt 2-2 3-2 5-2 Experimental
  • 30. Germination Assay 1.5 μM ABA • Similar to 1.0 μM ABA 100 90 • 3-2, 5-2 80 70 60 Percent 50 Germination 40 30 20 10 0 wt 2-2 3-2 5-2 Experimental
  • 31. Germination Assay Seeds from HOAT 2-2 may have a T-DNA insertion but are not hyper/hyposensitive to ABA!
  • 32. Overview  To identify those potential genes:  Mutagenize with T-DNA insertions  Screen using BASTA  Screen using ABA  Screen for typical mutant miRNA phenotypes  Find location of T-DNA insertion  Determine whether miRNA target genes are affected  Germination assay  BASTA assay
  • 33. BASTA Assay - Theory HYPOTHESIS: ABA hyper/hyposensitivity caused by T-DNA insertion. GIVEN:  T-DNA insertion confers BASTA resistance  ABA-hypersensitive plants on BASTA – should all have T-DNA insertion Plated surviving plants from ABA treatment onto BASTA plates
  • 34. BASTA Assay Survival on BASTA • Data does not confirm 100 80 theory 60 Percent Col-0 • Most surviving plants Survival 40 HOAT 2-2 HOAT 3-2 20 have BASTA resistance HOAT 5-2 0 0.5 1 1.5 [ABA] in μM
  • 35. BASTA Assay - Conclusions Seeds from HOAT 2-2 HAVE a T-DNA insertion but are not hyper/hyposensitive to ABA!  Contrary to original screen  2-2 originally identified as hypersensitive
  • 36. Possible Explanations  Chance from first hyper/hyposensitivity assay (n = 1)  NOT chance from this experiment n = large (despite contamination)  Possibly growth conditions BOTTOM LINE: We have a lot of factors at work here that we don’t know about!
  • 37. Possible Explanations Possible interaction Survival on BASTA 100 between ABA and 80 Percent 60 Col-0 BASTA Survival 40 HOAT 2-2 HOAT 3-2 20 HOAT 5-2 0 0.5 1 1.5 [ABA] in μM
  • 38. Conclusions HOAT 2-2, HOAT 3-2, HOAT 5-2  Root growth assay  potential to have miRNA mutations  Observable “miRNA phenotypes”
  • 39. Conclusions HOAT 3-2, HOAT 5-2  Increase in GRF3 expression – KNOWN miR396- REGULATED GENE  Decrease in ATG09720 gene expression  T-DNA insertion inside gene. Future work: How do changes in these gene expressions explain original phenotype?
  • 40. References  Earley, et al., An endogenous F-box protein regulates ARGONAUTE1 in Arabidopsis thaliana Silence 2010, 1:15  Rodriguez RE, Mecchia MA, Debernardi JM, Schommer C, Weigel D, Palatnik JF. 2010. Control of cell proliferation in Arabidopsis thaliana by microRNA miR396. Development 137, 103–112.  Dr. John Wagner, personal communication.  Allison Lesher, personal communication.  NCBI BLAST database: gene identification  TAIR database: gene information

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. Should not be severalleaves near cauline leaf (should only be one)
  2. Add circles for the HOAT2-2 and 3-2 for AD2
  3. Fix 9720
  4. SEEDS FROM
  5. Conf. level -> same as control?Null hypothesis same as control. T-stat does not disprove null hypothesis. Also can examine by visual examination – same as 0 ABA.SEEDS FROM
  6. SEEDS FROM
  7. SEEDS FROM
  8. We know it has T-DNA insertion from
  9. If we were to plate…All plants having hypersensitive ABA phenotype are now dead. According to this theory their phenotypes were caused by T-DNA insertions.Remainder should not have T-DNA insertions and thus should not survive on BASTA.
  10. 2152643099
  11. 1st: process
  12. Akin to giving a sick person and a healthy person the same vaccine
  13. 1a) original phenotype was not seen in the most recent germination/BASTA assay