SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 4
CHOICE OF LAW

a) overview

Art. 11 – 16 ⇒ functions:

Which law applies? Only one law applies - no loopholes,
no double protection.

example: NL - resident works in B; B resident works in NL –
         Which law applies, if there were not Art. 11?

b) Art.11 I: only one law applies
   Art.11 II: workplace is the decisive connecting factor
   Art. 12: more than one employment (previously lex domicilii
   now lex loci laboris)

ECJ – 9.3.2006 – C-493/04: double contributions?

c) options:
• EC-officials (Art.15)                                          1
• lex contractus (Art.16)
STRUCTURE OF CHOICE- OF- LAW- RULES


MATTER +            CONNECTING    ⇒             NATIONAL
SUBSTANTIVE         FACTOR                      LAW


examples:                examples:
social assistance        residence
compensation             stay
promotion                citizenship
social insurance         workplace = contract


connecting factor connects =     links matter with specific
                                 national substantive law

                                                              2
WORKPLACE

⇒ not necessarily the place where someone does his/her work
  at the moment

two problems:

1. working temporarily abroad
2. working regularly abroad

solutions: ⇒ workplace = residence of the employer

1. if work abroad does not exceed 24 months or agreement Art. 16

ECJ – 26.1.2006 – C-2/05: Effect of E101 form


                                                               3
UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS

a) overview

main objective:      state of last employment is the
                     competent state = bears burden

ECJ – 9.11.2006 – C-346/05: coverage of a period of employment

b) Totalization

c) amount of benefits

d) looking for a job outside the competent state

e) frontier worker

f) work permit for third country nationals?

ECJ – 11.1.2007 – C-208/05                                       4

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Mehr von trESS Network

2013 - trESS presentation EN
2013 - trESS presentation EN2013 - trESS presentation EN
2013 - trESS presentation ENtrESS Network
 
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROVtrESS Network
 
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/EStrESS Network
 
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age PensionstrESS Network
 
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/092010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09trESS Network
 
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...trESS Network
 
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in EuropetrESS Network
 
2010 - Review 2009/10
2010 - Review 2009/102010 - Review 2009/10
2010 - Review 2009/10trESS Network
 
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing worktrESS Network
 
2010 - Föräldrapenning
2010 - Föräldrapenning2010 - Föräldrapenning
2010 - FöräldrapenningtrESS Network
 
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet SverigetrESS Network
 
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund applicationtrESS Network
 
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/042010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04trESS Network
 
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studiestrESS Network
 
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?trESS Network
 
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomajtrESS Network
 
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la 2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la trESS Network
 
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information 2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information trESS Network
 
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli ProfesionaletrESS Network
 
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...trESS Network
 

Mehr von trESS Network (20)

2013 - trESS presentation EN
2013 - trESS presentation EN2013 - trESS presentation EN
2013 - trESS presentation EN
 
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV
2010 - ANALIZA PRIMEROV
 
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES
2010 - Priprave na izvajanje novih Uredb 883/2004/ES in 987/2009/ES
 
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions
2010 - Modernised EU Social Security Coordination and Old-Age Pensions
 
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/092010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09
2010 - BISTVENE NOVOSTI V UREDBAH 883/04 in 987/09
 
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...
2010 - Kratek pregled zgodovinskega razvoja koordinacije sistemov socialne va...
 
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe
2010 - Advising Individuals on Their Rights in Europe
 
2010 - Review 2009/10
2010 - Review 2009/102010 - Review 2009/10
2010 - Review 2009/10
 
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work
2010 - Regulations 883/2004 & 987/2009 - Ongoing work
 
2010 - Föräldrapenning
2010 - Föräldrapenning2010 - Föräldrapenning
2010 - Föräldrapenning
 
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige
2010 - Familjeförmåner/Inkomstbaserad föräldrapenning Fallet Sverige
 
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application
2010 - Öresundsöverenskommelsen - the Öresund application
 
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/042010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04
2010 - Lagvalsreglerna i förordning 883/04
 
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies
2010 - National trESS Seminar - Case studies
 
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?
2010 - Where do we stand – what problems do we have?
 
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj
2010 - Coordonarea modernizată a sistemelor de asigurări de şomaj
 
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la 2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la
2010 - Pregătiri la nivel naţional pentru trecerea la
 
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information 2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information
2010 - EESSI - Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information
 
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale
2010 - C.N.P.A.S. Accidente de Muncă şi Boli Profesionale
 
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...
2010 - Întâmpinarea Regulamentelor (CE) nr. 883/2004 şi nr. 987/2009 de către...
 

2012 - CHOICE OF LAW

  • 1. CHOICE OF LAW a) overview Art. 11 – 16 ⇒ functions: Which law applies? Only one law applies - no loopholes, no double protection. example: NL - resident works in B; B resident works in NL – Which law applies, if there were not Art. 11? b) Art.11 I: only one law applies Art.11 II: workplace is the decisive connecting factor Art. 12: more than one employment (previously lex domicilii now lex loci laboris) ECJ – 9.3.2006 – C-493/04: double contributions? c) options: • EC-officials (Art.15) 1 • lex contractus (Art.16)
  • 2. STRUCTURE OF CHOICE- OF- LAW- RULES MATTER + CONNECTING ⇒ NATIONAL SUBSTANTIVE FACTOR LAW examples: examples: social assistance residence compensation stay promotion citizenship social insurance workplace = contract connecting factor connects = links matter with specific national substantive law 2
  • 3. WORKPLACE ⇒ not necessarily the place where someone does his/her work at the moment two problems: 1. working temporarily abroad 2. working regularly abroad solutions: ⇒ workplace = residence of the employer 1. if work abroad does not exceed 24 months or agreement Art. 16 ECJ – 26.1.2006 – C-2/05: Effect of E101 form 3
  • 4. UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS a) overview main objective: state of last employment is the competent state = bears burden ECJ – 9.11.2006 – C-346/05: coverage of a period of employment b) Totalization c) amount of benefits d) looking for a job outside the competent state e) frontier worker f) work permit for third country nationals? ECJ – 11.1.2007 – C-208/05 4