SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 2
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
16/12/2016 Cleaning up | The Economist
http://www.economist.com/node/16542611/print 1/2
Brazil's congress
Cleaning up
A campaign against corruption
Jul 8th 2010 | SÃo Paulo
ORGANISED crime takes several forms in Brazil. One is politics—a lucrative trade. Of the 513
members of the lower house of Congress, 147 face criminal charges in the supreme court or are
under investigation, and the same goes for 21 of the 81 senators, according to Congresso em Foco, a
website that acts as a watchdog. Some—nobody knows quite how many—have already been
convicted in lower courts. Most of the crimes involve either violating campaign-finance laws or
stealing public money.
Hitherto the politicians had little to worry about. Although the law was changed to limit
parliamentary immunity for corruption, Brazilian justice is patient. Politicians have the right to be
tried by the supreme court, but many cases lapse before they are heard. When the supreme court
recently convicted two politicians for corruption, it was the first successful prosecution since
democracy was restored in 1985. Since legislators who are impeached lose their right to run for
office, many of those in serious trouble simply resign pre-emptively. They then stand in the next
election and get straight back to business.
But a new law approved last month will disqualify from political office for eight years all those
convicted of a serious crime, as well as those whose resignations were motivated by a desire to avoid
impeachment, as determined by the electoral tribunals. To the chagrin of some of those shamed into
voting for the measure, the electoral court ruled that the law will apply not just to those convicted in
16/12/2016 Cleaning up | The Economist
http://www.economist.com/node/16542611/print 2/2
future, but also to those who already have a criminal record and those who resigned under a cloud
during the current congress.
Quite how wide a net the new law will cast is not clear. Two politicians convicted of crimes gained
interim injunctions from supreme-court justices which, if confirmed, would allow them to register
candidacies. And politicians facing well-documented corruption charges who have yet to be
convicted may be able to crawl back to office at the next election in October.
Nevertheless, some notorious figures may be forced out. They include Paulo Maluf, a former mayor
of São Paulo who has been convicted of “maladministration” (a catch-all offence used for officials
suspected of corruption), and is wanted by a New York prosecutor for money laundering. The same
goes for Joaquim Roriz, who resigned as a senator for Brasília in 2007 after being accused of
stealing 223m reais ($120m) from a state bank. But Jader Barbalho, who resigned from the Senate
in 2001 over corruption claims and faces six separate charges in the supreme court, has not been
convicted. Elected as a deputy in 2002, he is likely to stand for office in Para, an Amazonian state,
this year.
The law, dubbed ficha limpa (“clean record”), amounts to “a revolution”, says Sylvio Costa of
Congresso em Foco. It is the result of a petition to Congress signed by some 1.5m citizens, and was
passed in record time. It follows the failure of a series of political-reform bills in Congress.
Even if some of the questioned politicians persuade state electoral courts to register their
candidacies, the voters may be less forgiving. David Fleischer, a political scientist at the University
of Brasília, points out that of 69 deputies accused of skimming money from ambulance contracts in
2006, only five kept their seats in that year's election. This time some of them might not even get on
the ballot.
This article appeared in the The Americas section of the print edition

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Was ist angesagt? (6)

Local Alcohol Profiles for England: July 2018
Local Alcohol Profiles for England: July 2018Local Alcohol Profiles for England: July 2018
Local Alcohol Profiles for England: July 2018
 
Medical records – Game Changers in Doping Cases
Medical records – Game Changers in Doping CasesMedical records – Game Changers in Doping Cases
Medical records – Game Changers in Doping Cases
 
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigationHow to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
 
Local alcohol profiles for england december 2018
Local alcohol profiles for england december 2018Local alcohol profiles for england december 2018
Local alcohol profiles for england december 2018
 
Woglr september 2012
Woglr september   2012Woglr september   2012
Woglr september 2012
 
EDI 2009- Government Investigations
EDI 2009- Government InvestigationsEDI 2009- Government Investigations
EDI 2009- Government Investigations
 

Ähnlich wie Cleaning up _ The Economist

New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazil
New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazilNew constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazil
New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkC8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkFatin Nazihah Aziz
 
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazil
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazilThe referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazil
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazil
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazilThe lessons of the mensalão trial in brazil
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018Burson-Marsteller Brasil
 
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italy
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italyLava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italy
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italyFernando Alcoforado
 
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazil
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazilThe dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazil
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizens
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizensThe destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizens
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizensFernando Alcoforado
 
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...Fernando Alcoforado
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018Burson-Marsteller Brasil
 
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisis
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisisRefound republic in brazil to overcome current crisis
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisisFernando Alcoforado
 
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...Fernando Alcoforado
 
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...Fernando Alcoforado
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018Burson-Marsteller Brasil
 
The failure of justice in brazil
The failure of justice in brazilThe failure of justice in brazil
The failure of justice in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018Burson-Marsteller Brasil
 
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republic
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republicBrazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republic
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republicFernando Alcoforado
 
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazil
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazilReform of the constitution or political backlash in brazil
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...Fernando Alcoforado
 

Ähnlich wie Cleaning up _ The Economist (20)

New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazil
New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazilNew constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazil
New constituent with the failure of the political institutions of brazil
 
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkC8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
 
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazil
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazilThe referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazil
The referendum as weapon of government to cool the popular revolt in brazil
 
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazil
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazilThe lessons of the mensalão trial in brazil
The lessons of the mensalão trial in brazil
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | March 2018
 
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italy
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italyLava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italy
Lava jato operation will have the same fate of clean hands of italy
 
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazil
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazilThe dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazil
The dismantling of political and legal super structure in brazil
 
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizens
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizensThe destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizens
The destiny of brazil is in the hands of citizens
 
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...
Michel temer removal and new constitution to re order the political system of...
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | February 2018
 
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisis
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisisRefound republic in brazil to overcome current crisis
Refound republic in brazil to overcome current crisis
 
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...
The shameful submission of the majority of the chamber of deputies to corrupt...
 
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...
The failure of the political system of the economic system of the justice and...
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | April 2018
 
The failure of justice in brazil
The failure of justice in brazilThe failure of justice in brazil
The failure of justice in brazil
 
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018
Public Affairs - Monthly Newsletter | June 2018
 
SPRING 2016 Alex Article
SPRING 2016 Alex ArticleSPRING 2016 Alex Article
SPRING 2016 Alex Article
 
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republic
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republicBrazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republic
Brazil will not overcome current crisis without the refoundation of the republic
 
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazil
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazilReform of the constitution or political backlash in brazil
Reform of the constitution or political backlash in brazil
 
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...
How to take the corrupt michel temer presidency to the end and start the poli...
 

Cleaning up _ The Economist

  • 1. 16/12/2016 Cleaning up | The Economist http://www.economist.com/node/16542611/print 1/2 Brazil's congress Cleaning up A campaign against corruption Jul 8th 2010 | SÃo Paulo ORGANISED crime takes several forms in Brazil. One is politics—a lucrative trade. Of the 513 members of the lower house of Congress, 147 face criminal charges in the supreme court or are under investigation, and the same goes for 21 of the 81 senators, according to Congresso em Foco, a website that acts as a watchdog. Some—nobody knows quite how many—have already been convicted in lower courts. Most of the crimes involve either violating campaign-finance laws or stealing public money. Hitherto the politicians had little to worry about. Although the law was changed to limit parliamentary immunity for corruption, Brazilian justice is patient. Politicians have the right to be tried by the supreme court, but many cases lapse before they are heard. When the supreme court recently convicted two politicians for corruption, it was the first successful prosecution since democracy was restored in 1985. Since legislators who are impeached lose their right to run for office, many of those in serious trouble simply resign pre-emptively. They then stand in the next election and get straight back to business. But a new law approved last month will disqualify from political office for eight years all those convicted of a serious crime, as well as those whose resignations were motivated by a desire to avoid impeachment, as determined by the electoral tribunals. To the chagrin of some of those shamed into voting for the measure, the electoral court ruled that the law will apply not just to those convicted in
  • 2. 16/12/2016 Cleaning up | The Economist http://www.economist.com/node/16542611/print 2/2 future, but also to those who already have a criminal record and those who resigned under a cloud during the current congress. Quite how wide a net the new law will cast is not clear. Two politicians convicted of crimes gained interim injunctions from supreme-court justices which, if confirmed, would allow them to register candidacies. And politicians facing well-documented corruption charges who have yet to be convicted may be able to crawl back to office at the next election in October. Nevertheless, some notorious figures may be forced out. They include Paulo Maluf, a former mayor of São Paulo who has been convicted of “maladministration” (a catch-all offence used for officials suspected of corruption), and is wanted by a New York prosecutor for money laundering. The same goes for Joaquim Roriz, who resigned as a senator for Brasília in 2007 after being accused of stealing 223m reais ($120m) from a state bank. But Jader Barbalho, who resigned from the Senate in 2001 over corruption claims and faces six separate charges in the supreme court, has not been convicted. Elected as a deputy in 2002, he is likely to stand for office in Para, an Amazonian state, this year. The law, dubbed ficha limpa (“clean record”), amounts to “a revolution”, says Sylvio Costa of Congresso em Foco. It is the result of a petition to Congress signed by some 1.5m citizens, and was passed in record time. It follows the failure of a series of political-reform bills in Congress. Even if some of the questioned politicians persuade state electoral courts to register their candidacies, the voters may be less forgiving. David Fleischer, a political scientist at the University of Brasília, points out that of 69 deputies accused of skimming money from ambulance contracts in 2006, only five kept their seats in that year's election. This time some of them might not even get on the ballot. This article appeared in the The Americas section of the print edition