1. Outline
• The Definition of Participant Role
• The Type of Participant Role
• The Relationship between The Roles and
Grammatical Positions
• Role Frame of A Verb
2. • The semantic analysis of a simple sentence:
– Referring expressions : Actual things, persons
– Predicate :
• Relationship between the things, persons,
• To describe how the things and/or people
participate
• E.g:
RE REREP
John opened the door with the key
3. John opened the door with the key
S O
Instrument affected
S
affected
The key opened the door
The door opened
S O C
agent affected Instrument
4.
5. PARTICIPANT ROLES
• “Participant roles indicate relationships
between a verb/ predicate (and possibly other
predicators) and the referring expressions in a
sentence.” (Hurford, et.al. 2007, p. 257)
• Participant roles: roles associated with a sense
of a verb/ predicate
• It is the semantic relation between the
arguments of the verb and the situation
described by the verb (Jackendoff 1972)
6. TYPE OF PARTICIPANT ROLES:
AGENT
THEME
INSTRUMENT
BENEFICIARY
LOCATION
EXPERIENCER
AFFECTED
7. AGENT
The AGENT of a sentence is the PERSON deliberately carrying
out the action described. (Hurford et al., 2007:245)
e.g.
1. John opened the door with the key
2. A burglar ransacked my house
3. My mother’s bowl was broken by a thief
8. AFFECTED
E.g.
1. John opened the door with the key
2. Muriel dealt the cards carefully to each player
3. The tree was felled by a single blow from Paul’s axe
• The AFFECTED participant is THE THING upon which the
action is carried out. (Hurford et al., 2007:245-246)
• Some semantics refer to the affected participant as the
PATIENT (2007:246)
9. INSTRUMENT
“The Instrument is THE THING (hardly ever a person) by means
of which the action is carried out.” (Hurford et al., 2007:246)
“preposition which is typically used to express instrument is
WITH” (2007:250)
E.g.
1. John opened the door with the key
2. Seymour sliced the salami with a knife
3. Hamish used a screwdriver to open the tin
10. Practice...
• Floyd Smashed the glass with the hammer
• The hammer smashed the glass
• Crippen dissolved the body with the acid
• The acid dissolved the body
• The body dissolved
Agent Affected Instrument
Instrument
Instrument
Affected
Affected
Affected
Affected
Agent
Instrument
11. GRAMMATICAL POSITIONS OF REIN THE SENTENCE
a. Subject Position
Preceding main verb
E.g. 1. John opened the door with the key.
b. Object Position
immediately following main verb
E.g. 1. John opened the door with the key.
c. Complement Position
after the verb, but not immediately, often after
preposition.
E.g. 1. John opened the door with the key.
(Hurford et al., 2007:247)
12. Subject Object Complement
Agent
Affected
Instrument
THE POSSIBLE COMBINATION OF ROLE&
GRAMMATICALPOSITION
(1) The dynamite blew the safe open.
(2) The hut was set alight by vandals.
(3) Alfred burnt the cakes.
(4) Charles built Emily a mahogany bookcase.
(5) Sidney swatted the fly with his hat.
1
1,2
3, 2
3,
4,
45
5
5
The most common combinations : Agent – Subject and
Affected – Object
The rare combinations : Agent in Object position, and
Instrument in Object position
The most versatile position : Subject position and
Complement position
The least versatile : Object position
13. LOCATION
“The role of Location is played by any expression referring to
the PLACE where the action described by a sentence takes
place.” (Hurford et al., 2007:249)
E.g.
1. Caesar was assassinated in Rome
2. I’m meeting Dick at Waverley Station
3. Tallahassee is humid in summer
14. BENEFICIARY
• The Beneficiary is the PERSON for whose benefit or to
whose detriment the action described by the sentence is
carried out. (Hurford et al., 2007:249)
• It is not always be positively affected, but could be
negatively affected (2007:249)
E.g.
1. Keith gave Gill a replica of the Venus de Milo
2. Alan was sent a special offer from the Reader’s Digest
3. Glenn bought a micro-computer for his son
15. Note
• Prepositions which are typically used in connection
with the expression of Location role are : in, at, on,
under, nearby, above (Hurford et al., 2007:250)
• Prepositions which are typically used to express the
Beneficiary role, with or without paraphrasing, are :
for, to (2007:250)
• E.g:
• Keith gave Gill a replica of the Venus de Milo
• Keith gave a replica of the Venus de Milo for Gill
• Alan was sent a special offer from the Reader’s Digest
• The reader’s Digest sent a special offer to Alan
16. Practice...
• It is windy in Edinburgh
• The Prime Minister was sent a letter bomb from the
terrorists
• Ruth knitted a sweater for Bryan
Location
Agent
Agent
Affected
Affected
Note
Both roles are found correlated with both Subject and
Complement position.
Agent
17. EXPERIENCER
“The Experiencer is typically a PERSON who is mentally aware
of, perceives, or experiences the action or state described by
the sentence”. (Hurford et al., 2007:251)
“Experience means = you experience something, it happens to
you, or you feel it ” (Cambridge Dictionary)
E.g.
1. The children heard the loud noise
2. Jane saw a movie last night
3. Janice became sick when she heard the news
18. THEME
“The THEME participant is a THING or PERSON whose
location is described or that is perceived by an Experiencer. “
(Hurford et al., 2007:251)
E.g.
1. The children heard the loud noise
2. Jack saw a play last week
3. The Honda belongs to Jim
Note: Experiencer and Theme roles are correlated to
Subject and object position
19. • E.g.
1. OPEN: (AGENT) AFFECTED (INSTRUMENT)
• John opened the door
• The key opened the door
• The door opened
ROLE FRAME OF A VERB
20. ROLE FRAMEOF A VERB
Participant roles can be included in the
dictionary
In the dictionary entry for each verb in the
language there will be a ‘role frame’
The parentheses indicate that the roles are
optional with this verb
The role not enclosed by parentheses is
obligatory
(Hurford et al., 2007:253).
21. • BLOW UP:
– Vacek blew up the tank with a hand grenade
– The hand grenade blew up the tank
– The tank blew up
BLOW UP: (AGENT) AFFECTED (INSTRUMENT)
• GIVE:
– John gave Mary a book
– Mary was given a book
– A book was given to Mary
GIVE: (AGENT) AFFECTED BENEFICIARY
22. REFERENCE
• Hurford, James R., Heasley, Brendan, and
Smith, Michael B. 2007. Semantics A
Coursebook. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
• Ray Jackendoff. 1972. Semantic interpretation
in generative grammar. The MIT Press,
Cambridge, MA.
Hinweis der Redaktion
3. Hamish open the tin with a screwdriver
The position of a referring expression in a sentence is only very loosely correlated with the role of its referent in the situation described. Let us distinguish three different grammatical positions in the sentence,
the most common combinations of participant role with grammatical position are Agent – Subject and Affected – Object
The rare combinations of participant role with grammatical positionare Agent in Object position, and Instrument in Object position
the most versatile position for the greatest variety of different participant roles are Subject position and Complement position
least versatile grammatical position is Object position
there is some systematic relationship between the semantic roles and the grammatical positions, but it is evidently a complicated relationship.
Tallahassee is the capital of the state of florida
indicating what roles must be, and what roles may be, mentioned in connection with the verb”