This document provides information on photovoltaic system design and calculations. It discusses performance ratio, system losses evaluation, keys to optimize performance ratio, shadowing evaluation for fixed and tracking systems, electrical calculations, and overvoltage protection. The goal is to help designers understand factors that impact solar facility output and properly size system components.
2. Radiation (Wh/m2)
Electric Energy (Wh)
PR = 0,74 - 0.78
System Losses
Considerations
1. The values considered in the following slides are estimated values and should only be used as an approach.
They may vary depending on each location.
2. A detailed Performance Ratio study is fundamental to evaluate the profitability of each solar facility
Defining Performance Ratio (PR)
www.leonardo-energy.org
3. 1. Temperature: (9%) +10ºC 4% received energy
2. Inverter: About 6%. New inverters can reach 4%
3. Cables: AC, DC & other electric devices: < 2%
4. Panel tolerance: It shouldn’t be higher than 3%
5. Pollution, dispersion & reflectance:
1. Fixed panel: approx.3%
2. Suntracking system: 2%.
In urban areas pollution, dispersion and reflectance effects increase system losses by
a further 2%
6. Shadowing: Below 4%. With suntracking systems, a shadowing study might be necessary.
7. Other losses (incidents, etc):
1. Fixed panel: 2%
2. Suntracking system: 4%.
100%
91%
87,4%
85,6%
83%
80,6%
77,3%
75,8%
System Losses evaluation
www.leonardo-energy.org
4. Choose cool locations, as elevated areas
Select inverters with high efficiency and Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT)
Consider extra cable sizing avoiding long traces with voltage drops
Choose solar panels with tolerances between +/- 2-3%
Cleaning the modules in long periods without rain
Balance the separation between panel rows (to avoid shadowing) with the optimization of the surface area
Minimize the impact of breakdowns, with a preventive maintenance.
Keys to optimize the PR
www.leonardo-energy.org
5. Depending on the type of installation, the results of the shadowing study, surface optimization and therefore,
project profitability, may vary.
Study aspects:
Azimuthal deviation from the south (Northern hemisphere) or north (Southern hemisphere)
Tilt of the solar panel
Shadows of extern elements
Shadows of own elements
Shadowing evaluation
FIX - GROUND SUNTRACKING-GROUND FIX - ROOF INTEGRATION
www.leonardo-energy.org
6. Distance between panel rows
A basic rule would be to avoid shadows during the 4 central hours of the day, in the day of the year with
less radiation.
This implies calculating the angle of the sun (height regarding the line of the horizon) to +/-2 hours
regarding the solar midday. This angle will vary depending on the latitude
The objective is to avoid that the top of the front panel projects a shadow to the lowest part of the panel
that is placed behind.
Fix - Ground
d= h / k
Latitude 29° 37° 39° 41° 43° 45°
k 1,600 2,246 2,475 2,747 3,078 3,487
7. Tilt angles
The optimum tilt angle of the solar panel can be expressed by the following simplified formula: Tilt =
Latitude – 10º
In Spain, tilt angles from 30 to 33º is considered as optimum, but tilt angles between 20 – 40º don’t
mean considerable system losses
Tilt angles below 15º in urban areas may cause system losses due to pollution and dirt accumulation on
the panels.
Local land slope will be logically taken into account, which can help reducing distance between the
panel rows to improve the surface profit. (Obviously, the opposite effect can happen)
Fix - Ground
www.leonardo-energy.org
8. Orientation angle
The most favorable orientation is 0º South (North hemisphere).
An orientation deviation below 20º (East or West) cause negligible system losses.
The following graph (which is valid for a 40º latitude) shows how additional losses may appear
depending on the combination of orientation and tilt angle.
Fix - Ground
9. A practical example: Solar Plant in Valdecarabanos (Spain)
Placement optimization
Suntracking - ground
www.leonardo-energy.org
10. Previous tasks:
Environmental conditions
Urban conditions
Topography
External elements shadowing study (trees, electrical posts, etc)
Own elements shadowing study: direct & crossed (in suntracking cases)
Definition of the distance between suntrackers (or panel rows)
Suntracking - ground
Location optimization
www.leonardo-energy.org
12. As grid connected solar facilities are considered as an investment, we have to choose between
the following cases:
To place the solar panels at the optimum tilt and orientation angle.
To adapt the solar panels to the roof shape
Take into account:
Impact of angle orientation.
Impact of tilt angle.
Impact of shadows
Comparison between adapted VS optimum
Roof geometrical limits
Remarks:
Be careful with panels from the same “row” in different planes
Fix - Roofs
OPTIMUM ANGLE & ORIENTATION
ROOF ADDAPTED
www.leonardo-energy.org
13. Two possibilities:
To avoid visual impact, adapting the solar panels to the roof shape
To integrate the panel as a constructive element with a certain function:
Electricity generation
Sunshade effect: special panels which allow some sunlight to go through
Innovative design: usually special structures are required, and this may increase the installation costs
In architectural integration, the solar facility is not considered as just an profitable investment, but also as
an image and design element
Architectural integration
www.leonardo-energy.org
14. Radiation, to the south of Madrid (Spain), for a certain year can be around 4.77 kW-h/m2 (Average)
Annual production
www.leonardo-energy.org
15. Production by kWp (installed)
(4.7 kW-h/ m2 –day x 0.74 x 1.15 x 365 day x 1 kW) / 1 kW/m2
Expected production for this horizontal radiation, with a PR = 0.74, would be: 1460 kW-h
STC
instincdaymed
annual
I
PyeardaysfPRH
kWpE
/
/
Annual production
Hmed-day Average solar radiation per day
PR Performance ratio for the solar installation. Dimensionless
F inc Tilt coefficient: a ratio normally obtained from the optimum tilt for a fixed panel (Which
optimizes its performance). In Spain (Latitude = 40º) it is 1.15
Pinst Installed solar power
ISTC Average irradiance in the horizontal plane
www.leonardo-energy.org
16. Once the modules and inverters are selected, the configuration of the system allows to maximize the produced
energy
It is possible that in some cases we should consider the use of a different module or inverter in order to
improve the system performance.
The configuration of the systems takes into account:
Maximum input voltage of the inverter
Maximum input current of the inverter
Voltage and current at Maximum Power Point
When designing the solar panel configuration in series and parallels, we must take into account that the voltage
and current of the branch will change depending on the temperature. Therefore it will be necessary to choose
extreme values of the region for the calculation.
System configuration
www.leonardo-energy.org
18. Take into account:
Maximum current in the cables
Maximum allowed voltage drop.
If there is a long distance the main factor to determine the cable section will be the voltage drop.
If there is a very short distance the current that flows along the cable will determine the section of the cable
Tramo
Long.
Vnom(V)
Wp inst (kWp)
Inom(A)
Conduct.
∆Vmax(%)
∆Vmax(V)
Seccion (mm2)
Seccióncalc.(mm2)
Seccionestandar(mm2)
Imax_admisible
100% 70% 30% 100% 70% 30%
ZA01 93 541 72 50 22 133 93 40 35 1,0 5,4 131 92 39 97 150 338
ZA02 97 541 72 50 22 133 93 40 35 1,0 5,4 136 95 41 101 150 338
ZA03 115 541 72 50 22 133 93 40 35 1,0 5,4 162 113 48 120 150 338
ZA04 133 541 38 27 12 71 50 21 35 1,0 5,4 100 70 30 74 95 245
Electrical calculation
19. Electrical design
In order to do a simplified earthing calculation, we can start with the following formulas depending on the soil
resistivity and the electrode characteristics
The average values of the resistivity, depending on the type of soil are:
Electrode Soil resistivity (Ohm)
Buried plate R = 0,8 ρ/P
Vertical peg R = ρ/L
Buried conductor R = 2 ρ/L
ρ, soil resistivity (Ohm x m)
P, Plate perimeter (m)
L, Peg or conductor length (m)
Type of Soil Soil resistivity (Ohm)
Cultivable and fertile soils, compact and wet soils 50
Cultivable non fertile soil, or other soils 500
Naked rock soils, and dried and permeable soils 3.000
www.leonardo-energy.org
20. Electrical calculations
The cable sizing is based on the following formulas:
Three Phases
One Phase
Where:
• P = Power
• L = Cable length
• γ = Cable conductivity
• E = Allowed voltage drop
• U= Line voltage
• For example, for LV in Europe:
• 400V in Three-phase
• 230V in One-phase
TABLE OF CONDUCTIVITY DEPENDING ON THE TEMPERATURE
Material γ 20 γ 70 γ 90
Copper 56 48 44
Aluminium 35 30 28
Temperature 20 ºC 70 ºC 90ºC
www.leonardo-energy.org
21. A lightning may produce a transitory overvoltage of short duration,
with a huge amplitude.
The overvoltage produced due to network unbalances is a permanent
overvoltage, with a longer duration and a lower amplitude.
In order to protect our installation against overvoltage, electrical
dischargers can be connected at the input and output of each device to be
protected.
There are three different protection levels:
High Middle Low
Over Voltage
Source: Cirprotect
DEVICE PROTECTION
LEVEL
INVERTER
METER
CC CABINET
TRANSITORY OVERVOLTAGE
PERMANENT OVERVOLTAGE
22. Transformers connection topology
RING
STAR
CABLE BREAK DOWN
NO PRODUCTION
LOSSES
PRODUCTION
LOSSES
In installations where more than one Medium Voltage transformer is required, it is important to define the correct
topology for the connection between all the MV transformers and the main grid (Power line).
The possible connections options are:
www.leonardo-energy.org
The values considered in the following slides are estimated values and should only be used as an approach. They will vary depending on each location.
A detailed Performance Ratio study is fundamental to evaluate the profitability of any solar facility
Any evaluation of potential system losses needs to take account of temperature variations, the performance of the inverter and cables, The panel’s tolerances, the effects of pollution, light dispersion or reflectance on performance, any shadowing and other potential losses, particularly the loss of efficiency if fixed panels are chosen over suntracking systems.
Here are some key issues in optimizing the performace ratio of a PV installation:
Temperature and elevation, inverter efficiency, cable sizing, the solar panels’ tolerances, a cleaning schedule for the modules, avoidance of shadowing while optimizing surface area, and a maintenance schedule.
Shadowing and surface optimization can have considerable effect on the plant’s profitability
The main aspects to consider are:
The Azimuthal deviation from the south (if the plant is in the Northern hemisphere) or from the north (if the plant is in the southern hemisphere)
The Tilt of the solar panels
Shadows from external features and
Shadows from features within the solar plant itself.
A basic rule on setting the optimal distance between rows is avoid shadows during the 4 central hours of the day, particularly during the times of the year when solar radiation is lowest.
That means calculating the height of the sun above the horizon) to plus or minus 2 hours at solar midday. The angle will vary depending on the plant’s latitude.
The objective is to avoid a situation where the tops of the front solar panels project a shadow onto the lowest parts of panels placed behind.
The optimum tilt angle of a solar panel can be expressed in a simple formula: Tilt = Latitude – 10º
In Spain, tilt angles from 30 to 33º are considered the optimum, but tilt angles anywhere between 20 and 40º will not result in considerable system losses
Tilt angles below 15º in urban areas may cause system losses because of pollution and dirt accumulation on the panels.
Where the panel is installed on a south-facing slope, the slope can be used to reduce the distance needed between panel rows.
In the Northern hemisphere, the most favorable orientation is 0º South . However, an orientation deviation below 20º East or West will cause negligible system losses.
The graph on this slide (valid at a latitude of 40º) shows the loss-effects of various combination of orientation and tilt angle.
Over the next slides, we will refer to a solar plant built at Valdecarabanos, South of Madrid in Spain by the initial authors of this training material the Generalia Group.
Prior to settling on a location a series of investigations have to be made into the Environmental and urban conditions, including air pollution levels. The topography has to be studied, taking account of shadowing issues and the area that will be needed for panel rows, whether fixed or suntracking systems are used.
Here are the results of a shadowing study for the panel rows at Valdecarabanos. It would result in an average shadowing of 2.78%.
With rooftop facilities a choice has to be made between following the shape of the roof or tilting and orienting the panels to optimize their performance. The option that delivers greatest investment return should be chosen.
The variables to be taken into account are the Impact of the angle of orientation and tilt, any shadowing, a comparison between the expected energy output from the two options, and the roofs geometrical limits.
Care has to be taken when calculating the performance of panels that are on the same “row” but. because of differenes in the underlying roof, are on different planes.
One advantage of adapting the solar panels to the roof shape is a reduction in the visual impact,
It may be possible to use the solar panels for additional functions beyond energy generation. For example, they can act as sunshades or they can act as features in the aesthetic design of the building. If the solar panel can play some additional function in the building, that changes the cost-benefit calculation.
We will consider that the radiation, in the south of Madrid (Spain), for a certain year can be around 4.77 kW-h/m2 (Average)
Here is the formula to calculate the expected annual production of a solar panel. This is for a grid-connected facility. The performance ratio of an off-grid facility would be considerably lower than the 74% used here.
Once the modules and inverters are selected, the configuration of the system should allow maximization of produced energy
In some cases, a range of modules or inverters should be considered in order to find the combination that offers best system performance.
The configuration of the system should take account of the:
Maximum input voltage of the inverter
The Maximum input current of the inverter, and
The voltage and current at Maximum Power Point
When designing the solar panel configuration in series and parallels, take account of the fact that the voltage and current of the branch will change as the temperature changes. Therefore it will be necessary to choose the most extreme values possible in the region when making the calculation.
Here is a screenshot from PVSYS, Solar Plant design software, showing the variables that software takes into account.
In calculating electrical issues, it is very important to take account of the:
Maximum current in the cables and
the Maximum allowed voltage drop.
If the cables cover a long distance, the main factor to determine the cable section will be the voltage drop.
If the cable covers a very short distance the current that flows along the cable will determine the section of the cable
For simplified earthing calculations, start with the following formulas, depending on the soil resistivity and the electrode characteristics
The cable sizing is based on the following formulas
Lightning strikes can produce short periods of transitory overvoltage with huge amplitudes.
Overvoltage produced by network imbalances will be a permanent overvoltage, with longer duration and lower amplitude.
To protect an installation against overvoltage, electrical dischargers should be connected at the input and output of each device needing protection.
The interver and control cabinets will meet a medium level of protection while the meter will need high protection.
In installations where more than one Medium Voltage transformer is required, it is important to define the correct topology for the connections across all Medium Voltage transformers and the Power line on the main grid.
The p connections options are:
a ring or a star
Here is a single line diagram for a solar installation