1. Hydraulic Fracturing in Canada
Richard Dunn
Vice President, Regulatory and Government Relations,
Encana Canadian Division
Brussels| January 22| 2013
2. Overview
Encana Profile
Industry Response to Stakeholder
Shale Gas Concerns
Encana’s Experience
Shale pics
1 1
3. Encana Corporation
Aggressively pursuing liquids growth
Production Volumes
Greater Sierra • 2011 Actual:
(inc. Horn River) Natural Gas (MMcf/d) 3,333
Cutbank Ridge Liquids (Mbbls/d) 24
(inc. Montney)
Peace River Arch • 2012 Forecast:
3,000
Bighorn Natural Gas (MMcf/d)
Liquids (Mbbls/d) 30
Duvernay
Coalbed Methane
Clearwater Oil
Collingwood/Utica
Deep Panuke
Jonah
Niobrara/Mancos DJ Niobrara
Piceance
Mississippian Lime
San Juan
Eaglebine
Existing Key Resource Play
Haynesville
Texas New Liquids Play
Tuscaloosa
2
4. Western Canada
Significant Unconventional Plays
Western Canada
Estimated Gas In Place
Horn River (GIP):
Shale
Alberta: 3400 Tcf
BC: 1200 Tcf
Total: 4600 Tcf
Total Canadian Production:
Montney Silt
~6Tcf/year
Duvernay
Deep Basin Shale
Tight Gas
Coal Bed
Methane
Encana Land 3
5. North American Gas Production by Type
Conventional, Tight Gas/CBM, and Shale
Long term growth in shale production offsets conventional declines.
Bcf/d
Forecast
48 bcf/d
~50%
4
Source: Encana Fundamentals, IHS
6. Benefits of Shale Gas Development
Security of supply
– New unconventional natural gas reservoirs have uncovered hundreds
of years of North American supply
Improved competitiveness
– LNG exports have the potential to add $ 1 trillion to Canada’s GDP
– Sustained low NG prices saving North American manufacturing
operations upwards of $11B annually
GHG emission reductions
– Conversions to natural gas fired power generation have caused U.S.
energy-related emissions dropped to a 20 year low in 2012 (1992
levels)
5
7. Working with Canadian Governments
Canadian operators work under rigorous regulatory regimes that
have been set out by our provincial and federal regulators
– Provide effective and efficient operating frameworks that enable both
environmental protection and resource development.
Important for industry (Canadian Association of Petroleum
Producers – CAPP) to work with governments to develop mutual
understanding of technical, business and social considerations
– Leads to improved policy and regulations, delivering “win – win” results
Operating practices developed by CAPP complement robust
regulations
6
8. Public Concerns About Shale Gas
“Frac fluids contain
Transparency dangerous chemicals that
aren’t disclosed to public”
“Fracturing can have
Water Quality adverse effects on drinking
water”
Water “Fracturing uses enormous
Quantity amounts of water”
“Fracturing & associated
Seismicity waste-water disposal cause
earthquakes”
7
9. Industry Response to Public Concerns
CAPP Guiding Principles for Hydraulic Fracturing
Guiding Principles:
– Protection of quality and quantity of
fresh water
Hydraulic Fracturing :
– Fracturing fluid additive disclosure
– Baseline groundwater testing
– Wellbore integrity
– Water sourcing and reuse
8
10. CAPP Hydraulic Fracturing Operating Practices
Recognized in the IEA Golden Rules for Hydraulic Fracturing
Fracturing Fluid Additive Disclosure
Fracturing Fluid Additive Risk Assessment
Baseline Groundwater Testing
Wellbore Construction and Quality Assurance
Water Sourcing, Measurement and Reuse
Fluid Transport, Handling, Storage and Disposal
Anomalous Induced Seismicity
http://www.capp.ca/canadaIndustry/naturalGas/ShaleGas/Pages/default.aspx#operating
9
11. 1 Fracturing Fluid Additive Disclosure
Public Concern: “Frac fluids contain undisclosed dangerous chemicals”
Industry Response:
• Publicly disclose, on a well-
by-well basis, the chemical
ingredients in additives
used
Additive name, supplier, purpose,
chemical name & maximum
concentrations
• BC and Alberta have moved
to make disclosure
mandatory
10
12. 2 Fracturing Fluid Additive Risk Assessment
Public Concern: “Fracturing can have adverse effects on drinking water”
Industry Response:
• Identify and manage potential
health and environmental risks
associated with these additives
Builds awareness
Selection of greener fracturing fluids
with lower risk profiles, where possible
• Develop risk management
plans for each well fractured
11
13. 3 Wellbore Construction and Quality Assurance
Public Concern: “Fracturing can have adverse effects on drinking water”
Industry Response:
• Comply with rigorous
provincial regulatory
requirements and good
engineering practices
• Confirm wellbore integrity
prior to fracturing
• Undertake remedial actions,
when required
12
14. 4 Water Sourcing, Measurement and Reuse
Public Concern: “Fracturing
uses enormous amounts of
water”
Industry Response:
• Evaluate available water
supply sources
Recycled water
Saline groundwater
Wastewater sources
Fresh groundwater
Surface water
• Measure and report
government regulated
water withdrawals
• Reuse water as much as
practical
13
15. 5 Anomalous Induced Seismicity
Public Concern: “Fracturing & associated waste-water disposal cause earthquakes”
Industry Response:
• Assess the potential for anomalous
induced seismicity
• Monitor during operations
• Implement procedures to mitigate
anomalous induced seismicity as
required
• Consistent with the
recommendations from the
regulator’s (OGC) investigation
www.bcogc.ca/node/8046/download?documentID=1270
14
17. Encana Experience
Fracturing Fluid Additive Risk Assessment
Developed a Responsible Products Program
– Assessed ingredients being used in hydraulic fracturing fluids
against government health and environmental criteria
Program has influenced product selection and procurement
– Eliminated use of diesel, benzene, arsenic, cadmium, chromium,
lead & mercury in completions products
16
18. Encana Experience
Water Sourcing, Measurement and Reuse
Debolt Source Water Plant
A result of aquifer mapping
of the region
− Industry/government
effort to understand
groundwater capacity
Uses water from deep,
sub-surface, saline aquifer
for hydraulic fracturing
operations
Benefits include:
– Eliminating use of
surface water
– Less traffic, dust
17
19. Encana Experience
Anomalous induced seismicity
• Installed microseismic arrays to monitor the events
• Results of both Encana and the OGC’s investigations were consistent:
− No event posed risk to public safety, worker
safety or the environment
− Seismic events were contained within the
production zone (~2.6 km below surface)
− Localized and specific to this particular shale gas
formation
− Can be safely managed using prescribed
operating practices
Microseismic activity
18
20. Conclusion
• Industry develops natural gas resources responsibly and efficiently
– Provides security of energy supply while providing benefits to
the economy and environment
– Governed by rigorous regulatory regimes, both at the federal
and provincial levels
– Addressing operational concerns about hydraulic fracturing
through CAPP practices, which is driving the right behaviors
• Development of greener chemicals
• Finding alternative water sources
• Managing anomalous seismic events
19
This slide shows historical and forecasted gas production for North America broken out by type. The four types included are Conventional, Tight Gas, Coalbed Methane, and Shale. For the period Dec 2005 – Dec 2010Conventional gas production decreased 8.9 Bcf/d (17%)Tight gas production increased 2.5 Bcf/d (22%)Coalbed methane gas production increased 0.8 Bcf/d (40%)Shale gas production increased 13 Bcf/d (736%)For the period Dec 2010 – Dec 2015Conventional gas production decreases 8.2 Bcf/d (20%)Tight gas production increases 2.2 Bcf/d (15%)Coalbed methane gas production decreases 0.9 Bcf/d (29%)Shale gas production increases 16.7 Bcf/d (111%)For the period Dec 2015 – Dec 220Conventional gas production decreases 3.6 Bcf/d (11%)Tight gas production increases 2.8 Bcf/d (16%)Coalbed methane gas production decreases 0.4 Bcf/d (17%)Shale gas production increases 15.9 Bcf/d (50%)For the period Dec 2005 – Dec 2020Conventional gas production decreases 20.7 Bcf/d (40%)Tight gas production increases 7.5 Bcf/d (65%)Coalbed methane gas production decreases 0.5 Bcf/d (23%)Shale gas production increases 45.5 Bcf/d (2,587%)Key MessageContinued growth in shale plays will offset the declines in conventional supply areas.
Natural gas offers long term energy cost savings; PwC estimates US manufactures could save upwards of $11B annually*. Source: PwC, December 2011, Shale Gas- A renaissance in US manufacturing? * Estimated values based on projections to 2025Life-cycle GHG emissions from gas-fired electricity production are 36% lower than for coal-fired electricity productionhttp://www.capp.ca/getdoc.aspx?DocId=215278&DT=NTV “In a surprising turnaround, the amount of carbon dioxide being released into the atmosphere in the U.S. has fallen dramatically to its lowest level in 20 years, and government officials say the biggest reason is that cheap and plentiful natural gas has led many power plant operators to switch from dirtier-burning coal.” http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=7350
On January 30, CAPP released a supporting set of six Hydraulic Fracturing Operating Practices to put the Principles into action. Overview of each one.“Say what you do, and do what you say”They explain the industry practices and regulations that are already in place, as well as raise the bar to drive environmental performance improvement.The Operating Practices apply to all CAPP member companies and are consistent across CanadaThe Practices are voluntary but strongly encouraged; however, they are widely respected indicators of strong operations and therefore routinely mandated by member companies even where compliance is not legally required.They are evergreen and will be periodically reviewed and implementation monitored.Other jurisdictions, as far away as New Zealand, have approached CAPP about adopting these Practices.While these practices focus on natural gas, industry is already moving to adapt and apply them to tight oil later this year.
Must disclose those chemical ingredients which are identified on the Material Safety Data Sheet.Trade secrets: if you promote innovation, you must protect it. Discouraging innovation encourages the use of antiquated, known technology.AB – mandatory this yearNB – mandatory to regulators, with intent to make public disclosure mandatory eventually
Increase awareness and understanding of potential product hazards so that appropriate measures can be taken to decrease the likelihood of adverse impacts.Where possible, fracturing fluids with lower risk profiles can be selected.This ultimately increases the market demand for the most environmentally sound fracturing fluids
Sound wellbore design and construction is fundamental to protecting groundwater resources. Wellbore design is strictly regulate by individual provincial regulators.Companies have procedures in place to ensure wellbore integrity prior to initiating hydraulic fracturing operations.
Selection of water sources that are first evaluated from an environmental, social and economic standpoint.Collection and reporting of actual withdrawals as per licence requirements and to CAPP’s Responsible Canadian Energy Program.Maximizing the reuse of all water sources.
Sound wellbore design and construction is fundamental to protecting groundwater resources. Wellbore design is strictly regulate by individual provincial regulators.Companies have procedures in place to ensure wellbore integrity prior to initiating hydraulic fracturing operations.
In 2011, Encana experienced a series of anomalous induced seismicity events in North East BCPreliminary investigation showed low-level seismic activity occurred about 2.6 km underground in a contained zone close to completions operationsInstalled microseismic arrays to monitor the eventsThe British Columbia Oil & Gas Commission (OGC) initiated an investigation