The document provides an overview of a study conducted by TellusVenture Associates for the East Bay Broadband Consortium. The study objectives were to gather information on broadband availability, infrastructure, and adoption in three counties. Data was collected from carriers and analyzed to determine availability patterns and compare to benchmarks. Mobile broadband coverage was found to be widespread but speeds varied significantly by location and carrier. Commercial broadband varied widely by area and often required significant costs for businesses. Reported download speeds for businesses ranged from 10-50 Mbps in most areas.
2. TellusVenture Associates
East Bay Broadband Consortium study objectives
• Gather information about broadband availability, infrastructure and adoption
in Alameda, Contra Costa and Solano Counties.
• Including residential, business, anchor institution and mobile services.
• Do tabular and mapping analysis of the data to determine availability patterns
at a regional, county and city level.
• Determine broadband service benchmarks.
• Evaluate availability against benchmarks.
3. TellusVenture Associates
Broadband availability data gathered by CPUC
• Three kinds of technology - wireline, fixed wireless and mobile.
• Three very different segments: mobile, commercial and residential.
• Reports from carriers, plus CPUC does mobile field testing.
• Reporting methods vary: by census block, street address, map blobs.
• Carriers report advertised, not actual, speeds.
• Quality varies from "fair enough" to "aspirational".
• Reported service provides a reasonably consistent basis for making relative
comparisons.
4. TellusVenture Associates
Mobile broadband coverage widespread
• Six carriers report mobile broadband service availability in region:
AT&T
Clearwire
Metro PCS
Sprint
T-Mobile
Verizon
• Some level of service available outdoors nearly everywhere.
• Dead spots occur for individual carriers, but build-outs continue.
• Tower permits, fiber connectivity can be problematic.
• Spectrum auctions planned for 2014 could bring major improvements,
including in-building access.
5. Mobile carriers report
excellent broadband
service, mostly 10
Mbps or better
• Verizon, T-Mobile say 10+
Mbps, pretty much everywhere.
• AT&T is more granular, reporting
lower speeds in outlying areas.
• Sprint, Clearwire report lower
speeds, in 3 to 6 Mbps range.
• Bandwidth shared, so personal
results will vary.
6. CPUC’s field test
results say “not so
fast”
• Nimitz corridor between Bay
and San Mateo bridges
matches claims, more or less.
• 6 Mbps along Eastshore
corridor, San Ramon and
Livermore valleys.
• 1.5 to 3+ Mbps elsewhere.
7. TellusVenture Associates
Commercial/industrial broadband is different
• Ten specialized business broadband companies offer various levels of service
via copper, fiber, fixed wireless:
DigitalPath
Etheric Networks
Level 3 Communications
MegaPath
New Edge Networks
PAETEC Communications
TW Telecom
Valley Internet
Verizon
Vista Broadband Networks
• Claimed service area is often aspirational: sometimes it just means they’ll
come out to see if they can actually provide service.
• Even if available, often requires significant installation costs and/or delay.
• For economic development and commercial real estate purposes, block by
block, even parcel by parcel, verification is necessary.
8. TellusVenture Associates
Business providers generally advertise 25 to 50 Mbps in western Alameda
County and 10 to 25 Mbps in the east.
Alameda
County
Contra
Costa
County
San
Joaquin
County
Santa
Clara
County
Alameda
Alamo
Alamo
Oaks
Albany
Atherton
Belmont
Berkeley
Brentwood
Burlingame
Canyon
Castro
Valley
Danville
Diablo
Dublin
East Palo Alto
El Cerrito
Emeryville
Foster City
Fremont
Hayward
Hillsborough
Kensington
Kilkare
Woods
Komandorski
Village
Lafayette
Livermore
Menlo Park
Millbrae
Moraga
Mount
Eden
Newark
Oakland
Orinda
Palo
Alto
Palomar
Park
Piedmont
Pleasanton
Redwood
City
Rheem
Valley
Russell
City
San Carlos
San Leandro
San Lorenzo
San Mateo
San
Ramon
Saranap
Tracy
Union City
Walnut Creek
Walnut Heights
3rd Ave
Grant Line Rd
42nd Ave
RocklinDr
Middle Ln
Saratoga
Dr
HollySt
East Trl
FremontBlvd
Industrial Pkw
y
Blacow
Rd
Harder Rd
DavitLn
Newell Ave
CampusDr
RydinRd
Kaiser D
r
Brisa St
IngallsSt
Airp
ort
Dr
Olive Ave
8th St
JarvisAve
Cha
te
auDr
Dutton Ave
B
St
2
8th Ave
Valot
a
Rd
Cany
on R
d
Geary Rd
Cargo
W
ay
Hay
ne Rd
B road
way
13thA
ve
FallonRd
East Ave
M
ilm
ont
Dr
Central Ave
Howard Rd
Bockman Rd
35th
Ave
SycamorePkw
y
Viney
ard
Ave
Bancr
oft
Av
e
Portola Ave
Linne Rd
Deer Hill Rd
La
mmers Rd
SellersAve
C
ushing
Pkwy
PacificAve
J
eff
er
s
o
n
A
ve
Broadw
a
y
Ter
Bethany Rd
Crow
Canyon Rd
Decoto
Rd
Farm
Hill
Blvd
Concord Ave
12th
St
Clare
mont
A
ve
UnionCityBlvd
K
eller
A ve
Hayw
ard Blvd
Norri
s Ca nyon
Rd
1st
St
Ralston Ave
Ced
ar
Blvd
D
iablo
Ca m ino
Canada
Rd
Foot
h
illRd
11th St
Hopyard
Rd
Concannon Blvd
Byron
Rd
Altamont
P
ass Rd
County Hwy 2063
Marsh Creek Rd
Foothill Blvd
Tassajara Camino
CorralHollowRd
Vasc
o Rd
San
R
amonValleyBlvd
TracyBlvd
WillowRd
Fe
l ter Rd
GreenvilleRd
MidwayRd
LivermoreAve
Par
r
ott
Dr
MissionBlvd
Dee
r
Va
lleyRd
Hig
h
land
Rd
3rdSt
C
al
averas
R
d
Byron
Hwy
CalaverasAve
Re
dwoo
d
Rd
CountyHwy J2
MinesRd
·|}þ82
·|}þ260
·|}þ24
·|}þ77
·|}þ262
·|}þ84
·|}þ114
·|}þ61
·|}þ84
·|}þ185
·|}þ13
·|}þ35
·|}þ4
·|}þ123
·|}þ238
·|}þ92
£¤101
§¨¦80
§¨¦980
§¨¦205
§¨¦280
§¨¦880
§¨¦880
§¨¦680
§¨¦680
§¨¦580
§¨¦580
§¨¦580
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
ALAMEDA COUNTY
Business Broadband Service
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
Business Broadband Service
No Reported Service
Download Tier, Upload Tier
11, 11
10, 10
9, 9; 9, 7
8, 8
7, 7; 7, 6
6, 6; 6, 5
UNDERSERVED
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/23/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors.
®
1 in = 17,000 feet
9. TellusVenture Associates
Central business districts in Contra Costa County have advertised speeds
in the 25 to 50 Mbps range, mostly 10 to 25 Mbps elsewhere.
Alameda
County
Contra
Costa
County
Sacramento
County
San
Joaquin
County
Solano
County
Alameda
Alamo
Alamo
Oaks
Albany
Antioch
Benicia
Berkeley
Birds
Landing
Brentwood
Brisbane
Canyon
Castro
Valley
Clayton
Clyde
Concord
Cowell
Danville
Diablo
Dublin
El Cerrito
El Sobrante
Emeryville
Hayward
Hercules
Kensington
Komandorski
Village
Lafayette
Livermore
Los
Medanos
Maltby
Martinez
Moraga
Oakland
Orinda
Pacheco
Piedmont
Pinole
Pittsburg
Pleasant Hill
Pleasanton
Port
Chicago
Rheem
Valley
Richmond
Rodeo
Russell City
San
Francisco
San
Leandro
San Lorenzo
San
Pablo
San
Ramon
Saranap
Selby
Shore
Acres
South San
Francisco
Terminous
Tiburon
Vallejo
Vine
Hill
Walnut Creek
Walnut Heights
West
Pittsburg
1St
7th St
Grant Line Rd
2ndSt
A
t las
Rd
Swan
W
ay
Muir Rd
30th St
HollySt
East Trl
Arnold Dr
Newell Ave
CampusDr
RydinRd
Laurel Rd
Winslow St
Brisa St
Fairmont
Dr
Airp
ort
Dr
8th St
Oakley Rd
BancroftRd
4th
St
StanyanSt
Esmond Ave
Georgi a St
Canyon Pkwy
SansomeSt
P
ortol
aDr
Dutton Ave
B
St
Cypress Rd
Cany
on R
d
Mansell St
Daviso n Dr
Wilbur Ave
Pacific Ave
5thSt
B road
w
ay
13th
A
ve
FallonRd
East Ave
Bockman Rd
35th
Ave
Bay St
B
ayshoreRd
Viney
ard
Ave
Bancr
oft
Av
e
Portola Ave
Deer Hill Rd
Country Hills Dr
Silver Ave
BeniciaRd
Neroly
Rd
Bethany Rd
Sand Creek Rd
Bush St
Broadwa
yTer
Crow
Canyon Rd
County Hwy J2
Concord Ave
Delta Rd
R
ose
D
r
Pinole Val ley R
d
S
an
Pa
blo
Da
m
Rd
12th
St
Clare
mont
A
ve
Cutting Blvd
Norri
s Ca nyon
Rd
Franklin
Canyon
R
d
1st
St
Palomar
es
R
d
MainSt
Kirker Pass
Rd
Treat Blvd
Lak e H erman Rd
Byron
Rd
D
iablo
Ca m ino
Foot
h
illRd
Hopyard
Rd
Concannon Blvd
SellersAve
Altamont
P
ass Rd
Alhambra Valley
Rd
Montezuma Hills
Rd
County Hwy 2063
Marsh Creek Rd
M
a
carthurBlvd
Foothill Blvd
Mis
sionSt
Tassajara Camino
Vasc
o Rd
San
R
amonValleyBlvd
Ascot
P
kw
y
Hill crest
Ave
Blu
m
e
Dr
WillowRd
DoloresSt
Cana
l
Blvd
Mc
e
we
n
Rd
GreenvilleRd
MidwayRd
S
tMarysRd
Empire
Mi
ne
Rd
LivermoreAve
B
ailey
Rd
Hig
h
land
Rd
ReliezValle
y
Rd
RailroadAve
Richmon
d Pkwy
DeerValle
y Rd
Byron
Hwy
Re
dwoo
d
Rd
Lone Tree Way
·|}þ260
·|}þ24
·|}þ77
·|}þ92
·|}þ82
·|}þ29
·|}þ61
·|}þ238
·|}þ84
·|}þ242
·|}þ185
·|}þ13
·|}þ160
·|}þ37
·|}þ84
·|}þ12
·|}þ123
·|}þ4
·|}þ4
£¤101
§¨¦80
§¨¦80
§¨¦580
§¨¦980
§¨¦205
§¨¦280
§¨¦780
§¨¦880
§¨¦680
§¨¦680
§¨¦580
§¨¦580
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
Business Broadband Service
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
Business Broadband Service
No Reported Service
Download Tier, Upload Tier
11, 11
10, 10
9, 9; 9, 7
8, 8
7, 7; 7, 6
6, 6; 6, 5
UNDERSERVED
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/23/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors.
®
1 in = 17,000 feet
10. TellusVenture Associates
Business broadband providers advertise 25 to 50 Mbps in Fairfield/
Cordelia area, but generally lower speeds further away from that center.
Napa
County
San Joaquin
County
Solano
County
Sonoma
County
Yolo
County
Benicia
Birds
Landing
Clarksburg
Clyde
Courtland
Davis
Dixon
Fairfield
Isleton
Napa
Pittsburg
Port
Chicago
Rio Vista
Rodeo
Saint
Helena
Selby
Shore
Acres
Sonoma
Terminous
Thornton
Vacaville
Vallejo
Walnut
Grove
West
Pittsburg
West Sacramento
Winters
Yountville
CourageDr
T
St
HeathDr
1stSt
B ig Ho
r
n
Blvd
39thSt
21stSt
Henry St
PlazaDr
Shasta Dr
VandenRd
21st Ave
M
oor
e Blvd
California Dr
Missi on Dr
Stone Blvd
Travis Blvd
Madrone Rd
45thSt
Y St
Boyes Blvd
Weber Rd
Georgi a St
5th St
H St
Desmond Rd
EubanksDr
65thSt
Yellow
st
on
e
D
r
Oak Kno
l
lAve
Vaca Valley Rd
Chiles Rd
5th
St
Davis Rd
PorterRd
Allendale Rd
Lambert Rd
Fry Rd
Linden Rd
Tabor Ave
Airp
ortRd
MaceBlvd
B
ayshoreRd
Leveroni Rd
AbernathyRd
Elmira Rd
Hutchinson D
r
LandParkDr
Yountvil
le
C
ross
R
d
Trancas St
Meadowview Rd
LyonRd
Mc
ew
en
R
d
Elk Grove Blvd
65thStExpy
Hagen R d
C e
m
ent Hill Rd
Wat erfront Rd
Riversi
deBlvd
Benicia Rd
N St
Broadway
CountyHwy98
Swan Rd
Oakville Cross Rd
Las Amigas
R
d
47th Ave
Hiddenb
r
o
oke
Pkwy
Lakeville
Hwy
Sievers Rd
StevensonBridgeRd
Big
RanchRd
CenterPkwy
Vaca Valley Pkwy
Linda
VistaAve
WaltersRd
Rose
D
r
Dixon Ave
Rockvi
lle
R
d
Oakv
il le Gr
ad
e
2ndSt
Covell Blvd
Binghamton Rd
Hilb
orn R
d
J St
Laguna Blvd
Hood Franklin Rd
O
r
ang
e
D
r
GibsonCanyonRd
Lak eH erman
Rd
StocktonBlvd
County Hwy 31
Tremont Rd
Air Base Pkwy
Cordelia Rd
Hawkins Rd
BrucevilleRd
B
irds
Landing
Rd
Can telow Rd
A
r
n
oldDr
Wo
o
d
e
n
Valle
yRd
Florin Rd
Montezuma Hills
Rd
Putah Creek Rd
Silverado
Trl
Midway Rd
M
arshall Rd
Ascot
P
kw
y
3rd
A
ve
EastAve
SolanoAve
Tuolu
m
neSt
FSt
GateRd
RushRi
ver Dr
Cuttings
W
harfRd
MiniDr
1stAve
Ter
m
inous
R
d
Road 32a
DuhigRd
Bur
nd
ale
Rd
Gloria Dr
LibertyIslandRd
8thSt
Ma
nge l
s
Blvd
24thSt
PeabodyRd
Lower
ChilesV
al le
y
Rd
L
o
pes
Rd
Pocket
Rd
MeridianRd
CountyHwy89
Bu
cke
yeRd
LewisRd
T r in it
y
R
d
S
u
mme
rsetDr
PedrickRd
Suisu
n
ValleyRd
CountyRoad104
ShilohRd
BulkleyRd
ChilesPopeValle
y
R
d
FreeportBlvd
River
RdK n
oxville
Rd
Sou
th p
ort
Pkwy
County Hwy E13
CountyHwyJ8
Dry
C
reek
Rd
PleasantsValleyRd
·|}þ121
·|}þ29
·|}þ221
·|}þ116
·|}þ29
·|}þ99
·|}þ12
·|}þ37
·|}þ12
·|}þ121
·|}þ12
·|}þ113
·|}þ160
·|}þ84
·|}þ128
·|}þ128
£¤50
§¨¦780
§¨¦505
§¨¦680
§¨¦5
§¨¦80
§¨¦80
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
SOLANO COUNTY
Business Broadband Service
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
Business Broadband Service
No Reported Service
Download Tier, Upload Tier
11, 11
10, 10
9, 9; 9, 7
8, 8
7, 7; 7, 6
6, 6; 6, 5
UNDERSERVED
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/23/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors.
®
1 in = 19,000 feet
11. TellusVenture Associates
Residential broadband analysis
• Consumer broadband infrastructure is a generally reliable indicator of all
types of service availability and core infrastructure. Most AT&T and Comcast
construction to date is based on expected revenue from consumers.
• Evaluation is based on grading according to advertised download and upload
speeds, which provides a relative comparison even when ground truth differs.
• Comcast and AT&T are the dominant residential broadband providers in the
region.
• Astound and Sonic offer competitive service in limited urban and suburban
areas.
• Frontier, Wave and Winters Broadband serve rural Solano County areas.
• Adoption data is limited, but shows a pattern of greater adoption in generally
suburban areas than generally urban or rural areas.
12. Adoption rates beat
statewide average,
suburbs skew higher
Alameda County 78%
Contra Costa County 87%
Solano County 78%
EBBC 81%
California 75%
Darker areas have higher
and lighter areas have
lower residential adoption
13. Lower adoption rates
in urban areas west
of the hills.
Alameda County 78%
Contra Costa County 87%
Solano County 78%
EBBC 81%
California 75%
Darker areas have higher
and lighter areas have
lower residential adoption
14. TellusVenture Associates
Residential broadband grading criteria
F
Two competing providers, both advertising maximum download speeds of at
least 25 Mbps and maximum uploads speeds of 6 Mbps, or 3 or more
competing providers offering that standard of service in combination.
Competing providers, both advertising maximum download speeds of at least
10 Mbps and maximum uploads speeds of 6 Mbps.
Competing providers, one advertising max down/up speeds of at least 10/6
Mbps and the remainder meeting CPUC's minimum 6 down/1.5 up standard.
At least one provider advertising speeds that meet the CPUC's minimum
standards of 6 Mbps down and 1.5 Mbps up.
At least one provider offers service, but no service is available that meets the
CPUC's minimum standard of 6 Mbps down and 1.5 Mbps up (underserved).
Or no service at all (unserved).
D
C
B
A
15. TellusVenture Associates
Examples
F
Astound (or Sonic) and/or Comcast and/or AT&T offering their best levels of
service.
Comcast Xfinity cable modem service and mid-level AT&T Uverse DSL.
AT&T DSL and Comcast cable modem service.
Only one provider, e.g. AT&T or Comcast or Winters Broadband, meets spec.
Service via outdated DSL equipment or nothing at all.
D
C
B
A
16. TellusVenture Associates
Alameda
County
Contra
Costa
County
San
Joaquin
County
Santa
Clara
County
Alameda
Alamo
Alamo
Oaks
Albany
Ashland
Atherton
Belmont
Berkeley
Brentwood
Burlingame
Canyon
Castro
Valley
Danville
Diablo
Dublin
East Palo Alto
El Cerrito
Emeryville
Foster City
Fremont
Hayward
Hillsborough
Kensington
Kilkare
Woods
Komandorski
Village
Lafayette
Livermore
Menlo Park
Millbrae
Moraga
Mount Eden
Newark
Oakland
Orinda
Palo
Alto
Palomar
Park
Piedmont
Pleasanton
Redwood
City
Rheem Valley
Russell
City
San Carlos
San Leandro
San Lorenzo
San
Mateo
San Ramon
Saranap
Tracy
Union City
Walnut Creek
Walnut Heights
4th St
Monarch
Rd
3rd Ave
1st St
CapuletRd
HazelAve
PoeDr
ShorelineDr
Link St
42ndAv e
VillarealDr
Hansen Rd
Ascalano Ln
QuarryLn
ParkDr
Sycamore Valley Rd
Smith St
BranniganSt
NicoletAve
Wicklund Cir
Swan
W
ay
FalconDr
AlvaradoSt
M
arine
Pk
wy
HollySt
Avenue B
East Trl
Executive Pkwy
FremontBlvd
Industrial Pkw
y
AthensDr
D
avitLn
PasadenaDr
RydinRd
DyerSt
Walnut Ave
Kaiser Dr
Rhee
m
Blvd
66th
Ave
M
arin
Ave
Ingalls
St
Olive Ave
Airp
ort
Dr
2ndAve
Starr
St
8th
St
JarvisAve
Seven Hills Rd
23rd
Ave
R
osew
o
od
Dr
DoughertyRd
Ch
at
eau Dr
B St
28th Ave
Valot
a
R
d
Can
yon
R
d
A
St
Geary Rd
Cargo
W
ay
Fo
othillRd
Esc
uelaPkwy
H
ayn e
R
d
S
unolBlvd
Man
n
i ng Rd
Greenbro
okDr
B road w
ay13th
Av
e
Rose St
FallonRd
East Ave
M
ilm
ontD
r
Central Ave
Howard Rd
Bockman Rd
H
il
l sdale Blvd
SycamorePk
w y
FiveCan
yo
ns
P
kw
y
Vin
eyard
Ave
Banc
roft
A
ve
Linne Rd
Deer Hill Rd
Clubhous e
Dr
Foothill
Dr
La
mmers Rd
Dwight Way
Cherry St
S
a
n
Pabl
oD
am
Rd
SellersAve
Whipple Rd
PacificAve
Jef
fer
s
o
n
A
v
e
B
rione
s
V
alley Rd
Bethany Rd
Crow
Canyon Rd
Farm
Hill
Blvd
WalnutBlvd
12th
St
Clare
mont
A
v
e
UnionCity
Blvd
Hayw
ard
Blvd
Norris
Cany on
R
d
1st St
R alston Ave
Diablo Camino
Canada
Rd
11th St
Concannon Blvd
Sk
y
l in
e
B
lvd
Byron
Rd
A
ltam
o
nt Pass Rd
Coun
ty
Hwy 2063
M
arsh
Creek
Rd
Tassajara Camino
CorralHollowRd
Vasco
Rd
L a k
e
C
h
a
bot
R
d
TracyBlvd
Ce
ntralAve
WillowRd
Club D
r
F
el ter Rd
Monter
e
y
Blvd
Co
liseum
Way
MountainHousePkwy
GreenvilleRd
Ple
a
santonSunolRd
MidwayRd
LivermoreAve
Parro
t
t
D
r
MissionBlvd
Deer
Valley
Rd
H
ig
hland
Rd
3rdSt
C
ala veras R
d
Byron
Hw
y
CalaverasAve
R
ed
wood
Rd
County Hwy J2
MinesRd
·|}þ82
·|}þ260
·|}þ24
·|}þ77
·|}þ262
·|}þ84
·|}þ114
·|}þ61
·|}þ84
·|}þ185
·|}þ13
·|}þ35
·|}þ4
·|}þ123
·|}þ238
·|}þ92
£¤101
§¨¦80
§¨¦980
§¨¦205
§¨¦280
§¨¦880
§¨¦680
§¨¦580
§¨¦580
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
ALAMEDA COUNTY
EBBC Project Area
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
CPUC Wireline Data
GRADE
A
B
C
D
F
No Data Reported
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/16/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors.
®
1 in = 17,000 feet
Residential broadband availability grading by census block (unweighted)
17. TellusVenture Associates
Alameda
County
Contra
Costa
County
Sacramento
County
San
Joaquin
County
Solano
County
Alameda
Alamo
Alamo
Oaks
Albany
Antioch
Ashland
Benicia
Berkeley
Birds
Landing
Brentwood
Brisbane
Canyon
Castro
Valley
Clayton
Clyde
Concord
Cowell
Crockett
Danville
Diablo
Dublin
El Cerrito
El Sobrante
Emeryville
Hayward
Hercules
Kensington
Komandorski
Village
Lafayette
Livermore
Los
Medanos
Maltby
Martinez
Moraga
North
Richmond
Oakland
Orinda
Pacheco
Piedmont
Pinole
Pittsburg
Pleasant Hill
Pleasanton
Port
Chicago
Port
Costa
Rheem
Valley
Richmond
Rodeo
Russell City
San
Francisco
San
Leandro
San
Lorenzo
San
Pablo
San
Ramon
Saranap
Selby
Shore
Acres
South San
Francisco
Terminous
Tiburon
Vallejo
Vine
Hill
Walnut Creek
Walnut Heights
West
Pittsburg
1St
7th St
Grant Line Rd
2ndSt
A
t las
Rd
Swan
W
ay
Muir Rd
30th St
HollySt
East Trl
Arnold Dr
Newell Ave
CampusDr
RydinRd
Laurel Rd
Brisa St
Fairmont
Dr
Airp
ort
Dr
8th St
Oakley Rd
BancroftRd
4th
St
StanyanSt
Georgi a St
Canyon Pkwy
SansomeSt
P
ortol
aDr
Dutton Ave
B
St
Cypress Rd
Cany
on R
d
Mansell St
Daviso n Dr
Wilbur Ave
Pacific Ave
5thSt
B road
w
ay
13th
A
ve
FallonRd
East Ave
35th
Ave
Bay St
B
ayshoreRd
Viney
ard
Ave
Bancr
oft
Av
e
Portola Ave
Deer Hill Rd
Country Hills Dr
Silver Ave
BeniciaRd
Neroly
Rd
Bethany Rd
Sand Creek Rd
Bush St
Broadwa
yTer
Crow
Canyon Rd
County Hwy J2
Concord Ave
Delta Rd
R
ose
D
r
Pinole Val ley R
d
S
an
Pa
blo
Da
m
Rd
12th
St
Clare
mont
A
ve
Cutting Blvd
Norri
s Ca nyon
Rd
Franklin
Canyon
R
d
1st
St
Palomar
es
R
d
MainSt
Kirker Pass
Rd
Treat Blvd
Lak e H erman Rd
Byron
Rd
D
iablo
Ca m ino
Foot
h
illRd
Hopyard
Rd
Concannon Blvd
SellersAve
Altamont
P
ass Rd
Alhambra Valley
Rd
Montezuma Hills
Rd
County Hwy 2063
Marsh Creek Rd
M
a
carthurBlvd
Foothill Blvd
Mis
sionSt
Tassajara Camino
Vasc
o Rd
SanR
amonValleyBlvd
Ascot
P
kw
y
Hill crest
Ave
Blu
m
e
Dr
WillowRd
DoloresSt
Cana
l
Blvd
GreenvilleRd
MidwayRd
S
tMarysRd
Empire
Mi
ne
Rd
LivermoreAve
B
ailey
Rd
Hig
h
land
Rd
ReliezValle
y
Rd
RailroadAve
DeerValle
y Rd
Byron
Hwy
Re
dwoo
d
Rd
Lone Tree Way
·|}þ260
·|}þ24
·|}þ77
·|}þ92
·|}þ82
·|}þ29
·|}þ61
·|}þ238
·|}þ84
·|}þ242
·|}þ185
·|}þ13
·|}þ160
·|}þ37
·|}þ84
·|}þ12
·|}þ123
·|}þ4
·|}þ4
£¤101
§¨¦80
§¨¦80
§¨¦580
§¨¦980
§¨¦205
§¨¦280
§¨¦780
§¨¦880
§¨¦680
§¨¦680
§¨¦580
§¨¦580
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
EBBC Project Area
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
CPUC Wireline Data
GRADE
A
B
C
D
F
No Data Reported
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/16/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors. ®
1 in = 17,000 feet
Residential broadband availability grading by census block (unweighted)
18. TellusVenture Associates
Napa
County
San Joaquin
County
Solano
County
Sonoma
County
Yolo
County
Benicia
Birds
Landing
Clarksburg
Clyde
Courtland
Crockett
Davis
Dixon
Fairfield
Isleton
Napa
Pittsburg
Port
Chicago
Port
Costa
Rio Vista
Rodeo
Saint
Helena
Selby
Shore
Acres
Sonoma
Terminous
Thornton
Vacaville
Vallejo
Walnut
Grove
West
Pittsburg
West Sacramento
Winters
Yountville
HeathDr
Big Hor
n
Blvd
M
oor
e Blvd
Travis Blvd
45thSt
Y St
Weber Rd
5th S
t
Sutterville Rd
EubanksDr
GregoryAve
J St
5thSt
MapleAve
PorterRd
Allendale Rd
Fry Rd
Tuolu
mneSt
NewellDr
29thSt
MaceBlvd
Ulat is Dr
Elmira Rd
W St
Trancas St
LyonRd
Elk Grove Blvd
65thStExpy
Hagen Rd
Waterfront Rd
DuhigR
d
Benicia Rd
CountyHwy98
Swan Rd
Las Amigas
R
d
47th Ave
Lakevi
lleHwy
Sievers Rd
BigRanchRd
Li
nda
VistaAve
WaltersRd
R
oseDr
Dixon Ave
Rock
vill
e
Rd
Oakvi
l le
G
r
ade
Covell Blvd
Binghamton Rd
Hilb
orn R
d
DeerParkR
d
Laguna Blvd
Hood Franklin Rd
Buck
ey
eRd
Or
ang
e
Dr
GibsonCanyonRd
Old
S
ono
m
a Rd
Lake Herman
Rd
StocktonBlvd
County Hwy 31
Tremont Rd
Air Base Pkwy
Cordelia Rd
Hawkins Rd
BrucevilleRd
Birds L
andingRd
Cant elow Rd
Arnold
Dr
Wood
e
n
Vall
eyRd
Florin Rd
Mon
te
zuma
Hills Rd
Putah Creek Rd
SilveradoTrl
Midway Rd
M
a
rshall Rd
T St
3rd
A
ve
EastAve
GateRd
MiniD
r
1stAve
Road 32a
Burn
d
ale
R
d
Gloria
Dr
LibertyIslandRd
8thSt
M
a
ngel
s
Blvd
24thSt
PeabodyRd
Lo
p
esRd
Poc
ket Rd
MeridianRd
CountyHwy89
LewisRd
Tri nit y
R
d
PedrickRd
Suisu
n
ValleyRd
CountyRoad104
ShilohRd
BulkleyRd
ChilesPopeValle
y
Rd
FreeportBlvd
K n
oxville
Rd
Sout
hp
ortP
kwy
County Hwy
E13
CountyHwyJ8
Dry
Creek
Rd
PleasantsValleyRd
·|}þ121
·|}þ29
·|}þ221
·|}þ116
·|}þ29
·|}þ99
·|}þ12
·|}þ37
·|}þ12
·|}þ121
·|}þ12
·|}þ113
·|}þ160
·|}þ84
·|}þ128
·|}þ128
£¤50
§¨¦780
§¨¦505
§¨¦680
§¨¦5
§¨¦80
§¨¦80
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
SOLANO COUNTY
EBBC Project Area
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
CPUC Wireline Data
GRADE
A
B
C
D
F
No Data Reported
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 12/14/2012 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors. ®
1 in = 19,000 feet
Residential broadband availability grading by census block (unweighted)
19. TellusVenture Associates
Spread of grades around
statewide average
Grades for fixed residential
service, weighted by households
Alameda County C 2
Contra Costa County C+ 2.3
Solano County C- 1.8
East Bay Region C 2.1
20. Berkeley C+ 2.4
Alameda C 2.2
Albany C 2.2
Oakland C 2.1
Emeryville C 2.1
San Leandro C 2.1
Newark C 2
Fremont C 2
Hayward C- 1.9
Union City C- 1.9
Livermore C- 1.9
Dublin C- 1.8
Pleasanton C- 1.8
Piedmont D+ 1.5
Alameda County
Residential broadband availability
is reasonably consistent and
generally around the statewide
average.
21. Concord A- 3.8
Walnut Creek B+ 3.4
Pleasant Hill B- 2.9
San Pablo C 2.2
El Cerrito C 2.2
Richmond C 2.1
Pinole C 2
Martinez C 2
Lafayette C 2
Brentwood C 2
Oakley C 2
Danville C- 1.9
Hercules C- 1.9
Pittsburg C- 1.9
Antioch C- 1.9
Unincorporated C- 1.8
San Ramon C- 1.8
Clayton D 1
Orinda D 1
Moraga D 1
Contra Costa County
Central county includes best and
some of worst consumer
broadband availability in region.
22. Vallejo C 2
Benicia C 2
Suisun City C- 1.9
Vacaville C- 1.9
Fairfield C- 1.8
Dixon D 1.1
Rio Vista D- 0.9
Solano County
Rural broadband availability does
not keep pace with urban/
suburban areas.
23. Concord A- 3.8
Walnut Creek B+ 3.4
Pleasant Hill B- 2.9
Berkeley C+ 2.4
Alameda C 2.2
Dixon D 1.1
Clayton D 1
Orinda D 1
Moraga D 1
Rio Vista D- 0.9
Top and bottom five
for residential
broadband
Most cities in the region are right
around the statewide average.
Competitive carriers make a
difference; rural characteristics
and difficult terrain factors push
rankings lower.
26. • Astound, AT&T and Comcast all offer top end services in most places in Concord.
• Other top 5 cities – Walnut Creek, Pleasant Hill, Berkeley, Alameda – have a history of
three-way residential broadband competition.
Contra
Costa
County
Imhoff Dr
B
uchanan Rd
Gail Dr
A
rnol
d Dr
NetherbyDr
BlumRd
Pheasant Dr
LucilleLn
CenterAve
Grant
St
OakRd
ClearlandDr
Paso Nogal Rd
Muir Rd
PutnamBlvd
Olivera Rd
Waterfront Rd
MarketSt
CleavelandRd
EastSt
PattersonBlvd
Gregory Ln
DiamondBlvd
D
enkingerR
d
BancroftRd
Leland Rd
San
Sim
eon
Dr
Power Ave
Oak Park Blvd
Golf Club Rd
Boyd Rd
SanMarcoRd
Geary Rd
Marsh Creek Rd
Evora Rd
Arnold Industrial Way
Chilpancingo Pkwy
Parkside Dr
SolanoWay
TurtleC
re ek Rd
Willow Pass Rd
OakGroveRd
AlhambraAve
ContraCostaBlvd
W
illow
Pass
Rd
TaylorBlvd
Concord Blvd
Kirker Pass
Rd
Treat Blvd
Ygnac
io
ValleyRd
Clayton
Rd
Cowell Rd
Clayton Rd
Pacheco
Blvd
PortChicagoHwy
Dri
ftwood
D
r
Coggins Dr
BabelLn
GalindoSt
Ayer
s Rd
Meadow
Ln
Jo
nesRd
M
orello
Ave
MeridianParkBlvd
PleasantHillRd
MainSt
RailroadAve
Oakhurst
Dr
R
eliezValleyR
d
M
onum
ent Blvd
BaileyRd
·|}þ242
·|}þ4
·|}þ4
·|}þ4
§¨¦680
§¨¦680
Sources: Esri, DeLorme, NAVTEQ, TomTom, Intermap, iPC, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China
(Hong Kong), and the GIS User Community
EAST BAY BROADBAND CONSORTIUM
CITY of CONCORD
City of Concord
Legend
Major Roads
Road Classification
Highway
Secondary Roads
Highway Ramp
County Boundary
Consortium Boundary
CPUC Wireline Data
GRADE
A
B
C
D
F
No Data Reported
Prepared by Watsonville GIS Center 01/16/2013 (TELL1201).
This Document is a graphic representation only of best available sources.
The City of Watsonville assumes no responsibility for any errors. ®
1 in = 3,750 feet
27. TellusVenture Associates
Conclusions
• On the whole, the region meets or beats statewide averages for residential
broadband availability and, consequently, core network infrastructure.
• Rural areas lag behind.
• Gaps exist in urban coverage and adoption rates.
• Room for improvement in mobile coverage, areas with denser populations
and higher traffic have more bandwidth, but also more usage.
• Competition improves broadband availability.
• Areas that have (or had) three wireline competitors have the best service.
• Up to six mobile competitors, carriers still investing in infrastructure.
• Commercial/industrial service very competitive, except when it’s not.
• Cities with high grades prove that excellent broadband is possible for all.
30. TellusVenture Associates
Methodology
• Separated residential service providers from business.
• Weeded out fixed wireless Internet service providers that were either out of
the region or submitted low quality data.
• Handled mobile coverage separately.
• Different usage case, and carrier's service reporting not comparable to
wireline reporting. Apples and oranges.
• Considered both upload and download speeds.
• For simplicity's sake, will be mostly talking about download speeds today.
31. TellusVenture Associates
Developing the grading criteria
• Reporting and grading is by census block. Regional, county and city grade
point averages are weighted by number of households.
• CPUC has set a minimum service benchmark of one provider offering 6 Mbps
down and 1.5 Mbps up. That's a barely passing grade, a D.
• If an area doesn't have at least that, it flunks, an F.
• County, regional and statewide service average is consistent, on a mean,
median and mode basis: two competing wireline service providers, both
meeting the CPUC's minimum service benchmark and at least one claiming
to offer better than 10 Mbps down and 6 up. That's a C.
• Areas with better infrastructure have better claimed speeds, with 10 Mbps
and 25 Mbps reasonably consistent benchmark levels. Those service levels
set the A and B benchmarks.