Monday 24th August 2015 saw one of the biggest stock market crashes in China. St. James's Place published a special bulletin to let their investors know to stay clam and that the incident wasn't unexpected. This bulletin contains some great advice.
The Great Fall in China August 2015 - Special market bulletin St. James's Place
1. SPE CI A L I N V E STM E N T BU L L E T I N
CHINA GDP ANNUAL GROWTH RATE
6%
7%
8%
9%
10%
11%
12%
13%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Source: Bloomberg, 25 August 2015
SPE CI A L I N V E STM E N T BU L L E T I N
The Great Fall of China
AUGUST 2015
The constant ebb and flow between investor fear and optimism seems firmly positioned toward the former as
we reach the end of the summer. Global equity markets have reversed the gains of earlier in the year in a series
of trading sessions which saw a sea of red across dealersâ screens, culminating in what has already been termed
âBlack Mondayâ. So, whatâs causing the fall in equity markets around the world and what should you do if youâre
invested or were thinking of investing prior to the recent downturn?
Blame game
The blame for the dramatic falls witnessed in global share prices can be placed firmly at the door of China.
With an economy growing at around 7% a year, one might think thereâs little to worry about â especially
when compared to the comparatively anaemic GDP figures of the US and UK, which stand at 2.3% and 2.6%
respectively. However, whilst both Western economies appear to be over most of the major hurdles experienced
in the aftermath of the financial crisis of 2008/09, and are on an upward trend, Chinaâs GDP growth has been
in a state of gradual decline for five years since peaking at around 12% a year.
1
2. SPE CI A L I N V E STM E N T BU L L E T I N
This slowdown in the pace of Chinese expansion has been well understood for a number of years. However, a
combination of disappointing economic data, recent excessive share price rises, and thin trading volumes at the
height of summer, proved a potent combination to put first the Chinese stock market, and then global markets,
into reverse.
Chinaâs trade figures released in mid-August provided evidence to suggest that world trade may be contracting,
as the value of Chinaâs exports and imports fell by over 8% year-on-year in July. Whatâs more, this weakness was
broad-based, with exports to the US, the EU, and to other emerging economies, all declining in July. This data
was followed by the preliminary Caixin China Manufacturing Purchasing Managersâ Index (a gauge of Chinese
manufacturing activity), which fell to a 77-month low in August and sparked further concerns about Chinaâs failed
attempts to reinvigorate slowing growth.
What goes upâŠ
Whilst investors have enjoyed a gradual upward move in international equity markets over the last 12 months or
so, the Shanghai Stock Exchange Composite Index had surged by more than 155% since May 2014. This has been
fuelled by a government-sponsored market access programme that encouraged many local, first-time investors
into the market, creating a boom to rival that of tech stocks at the start of the millennium. Whilst experienced
investors may reflect on the adage that what goes up must come down, many local investors panicked and dumped
recently-acquired shares when it became obvious that the governmentâs attempts to prop up an overheated
market were unsuccessful. The Peopleâs Bank of China has responded to the continued fall in share prices by
further cutting interest rates in an attempt to stimulate economic growth.
Wasatch Advisors, managers of the St. Jamesâs Place Emerging Market Equity fund, provide a professional
investorâs perspective: âWeâve never invested in Chinese A-shares due to our concerns regarding growth,
valuations and transparency. When we do decide to pursue additional opportunities in China, itâs likely that
our investments will be through the H-shares traded in Hong Kong, where corporate governance is better and
speculation tends to be less extreme.â
2
SHANGHAI COMPOSITE INDEX IN YUAN
Source: Bloomberg, 25 August 2015 Please be aware that past performance is not indicative of future performance.
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
140%
160%
Aug 12 Nov 12 Feb 13 May 13 Aug 13 Nov 13 Feb 14 May 14 Aug 14 Nov 14 Feb 15 May 15 Aug 15
SHANGHAI COMPOSITE INDEX
Just 20 years ago such developments would barely have caused a ripple in international markets, but with China
now accounting for around 15% of global GDP, a slowdown in the largest engine of global growth was bound to
have some knock-on effects.
3. SPE CI A L I N V E STM E N T BU L L E T I N
âIt is no surprise that growth concerns in China would whack the markets,â commented Richard Rooney of
Burgundy Asset Management. âChina is the foundation of the global growth story for many multinationals.â
As Chinaâs consumption of resources has slowed, commodity prices have also been falling, with the obvious
impact on the share prices of mining and commodity stocks around the globe and those emerging markets heavily
reliant on these industries. In fact, most commodity prices are near 52-week lows, as evidenced by Brent Crude
oil which stands at just over $42 per barrel at the time of writing.
In stark contrast to China, one further factor that has been playing on investorsâ minds is the fear of potential
interest rate rises in the US and the UK. Forecasters had predicted a September rate rise by the US Federal
Reserve, followed by the Bank of England perhaps in the first quarter of 2016, reflecting the return to better
health of these economies. Whilst the recent volatility may not be sufficient to delay these moves, it will certainly
cause the authorities to be wary about raising rates too far too fast.
Food for thought
Accurately predicting short-term market movements remains highly speculative and prone to failure, and it would
be foolish to suggest that further falls in markets are unlikely to follow in the days or weeks ahead. That said,
it will have come as little surprise to experienced investors that the UK and other equity markets have almost
completely reversed the sharp falls seen on Monday. As we have stated in the past, so often the best days to invest
follow the steepest falls.
However, unlike previous market slides, we believe that things today are in broadly positive shape and that there
are reasons to think opportunistically or, for those currently invested, to remain confident that they can ride out
the storm.
Major economies such as the US, UK, eurozone and Japan are generally improving, with data suggesting that
there is little to support the case for a significant global economic downturn.
The gradual decline in Chinaâs growth rate is nothing new and whilst economic data remains âsluggishâ, it
seems insufficient to support the case for the âhard landingâ that many had initially feared.
Whilst a fall in commodity prices will impact on the profitability of certain commodity-linked companies,
the net effect will be beneficial for global consumers.
The fundamentals of companies havenât changed overnight. Whilst the FTSE 100 Index is down by 9.9% since
the start of the year, the FTSE 250 is marginally up. This reflects the significant weighting of commodity-
linked companies within the blue-chip index compared with its mid-cap peer. Likewise, the recent fall in
prices will, no doubt, present selective buying opportunities.
The situation surrounding Greece seems to be resolved for the time being, as âGrexitâ appears more unlikely
following an âŹ86 billion international bailout from which it can start to service debt liabilities.
Such a market event once again provides a demonstration of the value of maintaining a balanced and
appropriately-diversified investment portfolio.
Short-term volatility is an inherent feature of equity markets. However, with the support of very accommodative
monetary policy worldwide, markets have marched higher for four years without much volatility, which perhaps
makes recent events more unsettling. The advice to investors remains the same; to maintain a well-diversified
portfolioandkeepfocusonthelonger-termobjectivesthatinvestmentinrealassetshasprovencapableofachieving.
Wasatch Advisors and Burgundy Asset Management are fund managers for St. Jamesâs Place.
3