Thesis

1. THESIS SEMINAR
TOPIC ON
Study of stability and genetic diversity in faba bean
(Vicia faba L.) under terminal heat
1

2. 2
DESCRIPTION OF THE STUDENT AND ADVISOTY
COMMITTEE
Name of the student SOURAV RANJAN NANDA
Degree program M.Sc. (Ag.)
Department Genetics and Plant Breeding
Registration No. AP/BAU/5400/2020
Major Subject Genetics and Plant Breeding
Minor Subject Biotechnology
Advisory Committee member Dr. Jay Lal Mahto
Dr. Krisha Prasad
Dr. Madhuparna Banarjee
Dr. C.S Mahto

3. Botanical description:
• Kingdom : Plantae
• Family : Fabaceae
• Scientific Name – Vicia faba
• Chromosome no : 12(2n=2x)
• Mode of pollination :Partial Allogamous species
Important uses-
 Good source of protein
 Used as medicine for the treatment of Parkinson's disease.
 Green manure crop
3

4. 4
 To estimate stability among faba beans
genotypes under terminal heat.
 To estimate genetic diversity among faba
beans genotypes under terminal heat.
OBJECTIVES

5. List of material used in the study (Materials received from coordinated unit)
GENOTYPE CODE GENOTYPE CODE
ET226411 G1 Basabeer G19
ET226420 G2 ET226428 G20
ET226423 G3 ET226430 G21
ET226416 G4 ET226422 G22
ET226410 G5 RFB-6 G23
ET226425 G6 PRT-12 G24
ET226418 G7 ET226421 G25
ET226413 G8 ET226429 G26
ET226417 G9 Hanma-2 G27
RFB-14 G10 ET226424 G28
ET226431 G11 ET226427 G29
HFB-1 G12 ET226432 G30
ET226415 G13 ET226426 G31
ET226414 G14 Sambad-75 G32
ET226408 G15 Habidulla G33
Rebaya-40 G16 ET226419 G34
Hudalbu G17 Vikrant G35
Hanma-1 G18 5

6. Environments Date of Sowing
1) Environment 1 10/11/2021
2) Environment 2 24/11/2021
3) Environment 3 08/12/2021
6

7. 7
Sl.
No.
Date 2021-2022 Temperature (℃)
Sl.
No
Date 2021-2022 Temperature (℃)
Max Min Max Min
1 5th Nov- 11th Nov 28.8 17.4 14 5th Feb-11th Feb 23.8 9.6
2 12th Nov- 18th Nov 28.7 17.7 15 12th Feb-18th Feb 25.2 8.8
3 19th Nov- 25th Nov 29.0 19.2 16 19th Feb-25th Feb 26.0 11.6
4 26th Nov - 2nd Dec 26.0 9.3 17 26th Feb- 4th Mar 26.7 13.8
5 3rd Dec- 9th Dec 26.8 9.9 18 5th Mar-11th Mar 29.7 13.5
6 10th Dec- 16th Dec 25.7 7.5 19 12th Mar-18th Mar 32.3 15.0
7 17th Dec -23rd Dec 22.0 3.6 20 19th Mar-25th Mar 34.9 15.4
8 24th Dec- 31st Dec 23.3 8.0 21 26th Mar-1st Apr 34.4 15.2
9 1st Jan-7th Jan 21.0 5.6 22 2nd Apr- 8th Apr 36.1 16.3
10 8th Jan-14th Jan 25.9 13.2 23 9th Apr- 15th Apr 38.1 20.4
11 15th Jan-21st Jan 23.4 7.4 24 16th Apr- 22nd Apr 38.9 23.8
12 22nd Jan-28th Jan 24.5 10.9
13 29th Jan-4th Feb 23.3 7.1
METEOROLOGICAL DATA RECORD DURING CROP PERIOD (NOVEMBER,
2021 – April, 2022)

8. 1. Days to flower initiation(days)
2. Days to 50% flowering (days)
3. Days to pod initiation(day)
4. Plant height (cm)
5. Number of primary branches per plant (Number)
6. Number of pods per plant (Number)
7. Number of clusters per plant (Number)
8. Number of pods per cluster (Number)
9. Day to maturity (days)
10. Number of seeds per pod (Number)
11. Number of seed per plant (Number)
12. Seed yield per plant (g)
13. Seed yield per plot (kg)
14. 100-seed weight (g)
15. Total protein content (%)
16. Disease and pest incidence (Charcoal rot, Ascochyta blight, Pod Borer-%) 8

9. Pooled Analysis of variance for E1,E2,E3
**= significant at 1%, *= significant at 5%
Mean sum of square
df
Days
to
Flowe
r
initiati
on
Days
to 50%
flower
ing
Days
to pod
initiati
on
Plant
height
(cm)
Num
ber of
Prima
ry
branc
hes /
plant
Numb
er of
Pods /
plant
Numb
er of
Cluster
s /
plant
Num
ber of
Pods
/
cluste
r
Day
to
Mat
urity
Num
ber
of
Seed
s /
pod
Num
ber of
seed
/
plant
Seed
yield
/
plant
Seed
yield
/
plot
100-
seed
weight
(g)
Total
protei
n
conte
nt (%)
Replicat
ion×E
6
0.29
1
0.25
6
1.02
8
8.22
**
0.07
6
0.90
3
0.00
5
0.01
2
2.0
1
0.0
1
16.4
**
0.49
0
0.0
012
1.77
0.39
8
Genot
ype
34
3.6*
*
2.25
**
4.73
**
59.1
**
0.69
0
68.4
**
0.75
7
0.04
1
26.
9**
0.0
46
571.
7**
48.8
2**
0.0
26
31.86
**
2.0*
*
E+(G
×E)
70
13.6
**
8.9*
*
12.1
**
58.2
**
0.94
1
38.2
2**
2.37
8**
0.03
9
73.
6**
0.0
78
254.
5**
48.5
6**
0.0
20
21.89
**
2.39
2**
Environ
ment(E)
2
377.
2**
251.
6**
270.
43**
1394
**
20.4
7**
747.
4**
49.0
6**
0.18
5
195
**
0.5
7
369
1**
872.
4**
0.2
8
184**
22.0
5**
*=Significant at 5%, **=Significant at 1%
9

10. G × E 68
2.89
3**
1.72
5**
4.50
0**
18.9
32**
0.36
7
17.3
6**
1.1 0.03
18.
2**
0.0
64
153.
5**
24.3
3**
0.0
1**
17.1
31**
1.814
**
Environ
ment
(Linear)
1
754.
4**
503.
3**
540.
86**
2786
.2**
40.9
5**
1495
**
98.1
2**
0.37
1
391
9**
1.1
4
738
2**
174
5**
0.5
7
367.
5**
44.10
**
G ×E
(Linear)
34
1.94
0**
1.45
7
3.81
2**
26.1
24**
0.35
2
27.2
2**
1.56
0**
0.03
3
15.
3**
0.0
62
220.
8**
22.6
5**
0.0
15
8.87
**
1.95*
*
Pooled
Deviatio
n
35
3.73
7**
1.93
7**
5.04
1**
11.4
04**
0.37
0
7.28
**
0.43
7
0.03
5
20.
4**
0.0
63
83.6
4**
25.2
7**
0.0
08
24.6
6**
1.62
Pooled
Error
20
4
0.47
9
0.68
7
1.49
5*
11.9
26**
0.08
1
1.89
**
0.02
3
0.01
4
2.9
3**
0.0
20
17.6
3**
1.07
5
0.0
01
2.41
**
0.51
Total
10
4
10.3
26
6.70
9.69
1
58.5
00
0.85
9
48.1
2
1.84
8
0.03
9
58.
38
0.0
68
358.
21
48.6
49
0.0
22
25.1
5
2.26
10

11. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 55.33 48.33 51.33 51.67 1.02 1.66 *
2 ET226420 52.00 50.00 50.67 50.89 0.31* 0.40
3 ET226423 53.67 48.67 49.67 50.67 0.81 -0.44
4 ET226416 52.67 47.67 51.00 50.44 0.65 3.31 **
5 ET226410 54.33 48.00 52.00 51.44 0.84 4.80 **
6 ET226425 53.00 48.33 47.33 49.56 0.88 1.22
7 ET226418 52.00 49.00 51.00 50.67 0.39* 0.89
8 ET226413 55.67 48.33 52.67 52.22 0.99 5.44 **
9 ET226417 58.00 48.67 53.67 53.44 1.30 6.85**
10 RFB-14 55.00 48.33 46.67 50.00 1.27 3.67 **
11 ET226431 54.33 48.67 51.00 51.33 0.83 0.76
12 HFB-1 53.67 50.67 47.33 50.56 0.74 7.79**
13 ET226415 55.33 49.67 49.67 51.56 0.99 -0.04
14 ET226414 55.00 48.00 52.67 51.89 0.91 6.95 **
15 ET226408 54.33 48.67 50.33 51.11 0.88 -0.11
16 Rebaya-40 56.00 50.00 45.33 50.44 1.35 17.45**
17 Hudalbu 55.33 49.33 52.00 52.22 0.87 1.28
18 Hanma-1 55.67 49.33 52.33 52.44 0.91 1.89 *
11
Environment index and stability of Days to flower initiation under different environments (2021-22)

12. 12
19 Basabeer 54.67 48.00 48.33 50.33 1.14 -0.20
20 ET226428 54.00 47.33 46.67 49.33 1.20 1.16
21 ET226430 54.67 50.00 44.33 49.67 1.18 22.92**
22 ET226422 55.67 47.67 50.67 51.33 1.20 1.34
23 RFB-6 55.33 47.00 51.67 51.33 1.15 6.13**
24 PRT-12 56.67 48.33 51.33 52.11 1.25 1.24
25 ET226421 56.67 47.00 47.00 50.22 1.68* 0.79
26 ET226429 56.67 50.67 52.00 53.11 0.96 -0.37
27 Hanma-2 55.33 51.67 48.00 51.67 0.88 9.79 **
28 ET226424 56.00 51.00 49.67 52.22 0.96 2.05 *
29 ET226427 56.67 48.00 50.67 51.78 1.33 0.56
30 ET226432 55.67 49.00 50.33 51.67 1.07 -0.42
31 ET226426 55.67 50.67 51.33 52.56 0.83 -0.47
32 Sambad-75 51.00 49.00 48.67 49.56 0.37* -0.24
33 Habidulla 57.33 50.67 50.33 52.78 1.18 0.58
34 ET226419 55.33 47.33 45.33 49.33 1.52* 5.50 **
35 Vikrant 54.67 47.00 49.67 50.44 1.16 0.81
Environmental Index 3.752 -2.343 -1.41
Mean 54.952 48.857 49.790 51.19
S Em± 1.33 0.4164
C.V. 2.563 2.639 1.642
CD5% 2.295 2.101 1.332
CD 1 % 3.048 2.790 1.769

13. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 64.00 60.00 63.00 62.33 0.769 -0.520
2 ET226420 64.33 62.00 64.33 63.56 0.467* -0.184
3 ET226423 64.33 59.67 62.00 62.00 0.861 -0.440
4 ET226416 64.67 61.00 62.33 62.67 0.661 -0.060
5 ET226410 65.00 61.00 63.67 63.22 0.759 -0.659
6 ET226425 65.00 56.33 62.00 61.11 1.641 -0.642
7 ET226418 64.33 59.33 64.33 62.67 1.001 1.578
8 ET226413 66.67 60.67 65.00 64.11 1.149 -0.467
9 ET226417 67.00 60.33 61.00 62.78 1.145 7.419**
10 RFB-14 65.33 61.00 63.67 63.33 0.815 -0.672
11 ET226431 64.67 59.33 64.33 62.78 1.057 1.099
12 HFB-1 65.33 59.33 63.00 62.56 1.128 -0.667
13 ET226415 63.67 59.00 63.33 62.00 0.924 0.606
14 ET226414 63.00 57.33 64.00 61.44 1.166 5.618**
15 ET226408 63.67 58.67 62.67 61.67 0.97 -0.194
16 Rebaya-40 62.67 62.67 64.33 63.22 0.053* 1.137
17 Hudalbu 66.67 61.33 62.67 63.56 0.942 1.982*
18 Hanma-1 65.33 61.33 62.00 62.89 0.696 1.550
19 Basabeer 65.00 58.00 61.67 61.56 1.296 -0.325
Environment index and stability of Days to 50% flowering under different environments(2021-22)
13

14. 20 ET226428 64.33 57.00 61.00 60.78 1.363 -0.433
21 ET226430 64.33 58.33 61.67 61.44 1.117 -0.550
22 ET226422 64.00 60.00 63.33 62.44 0.78 -0.236
23 RFB-6 65.67 58.33 60.67 61.56 1.311 2.701 *
24 PRT-12 63.00 59.67 61.00 61.22 0.604 -0.297
25 ET226421 64.00 60.00 61.00 61.67 0.706 0.820
26 ET226429 62.33 58.00 63.00 61.11 0.889 2.708 *
27 Hanma-2 64.33 60.33 65.33 63.33 0.833 3.358*
28 ET226424 65.33 59.00 64.00 62.78 1.226 0.005
29 ET226427 65.67 59.67 62.00 62.44 1.086 0.673
30 ET226432 65.00 59.67 62.33 62.33 0.984 -0.369
31 ET226426 65.00 58.67 67.33 63.67 1.342 13.656**
32 Sambad-75 66.33 59.67 62.33 62.78 1.209 0.838
33 Habidulla 67.67 59.00 64.00 63.56 1.62 -0.544
34 ET226419 66.67 60.33 61.67 62.89 1.11 3.894 **
35 Vikrant 67.33 60.00 62.67 63.33 1.321 1.785
Environmental Index 2.425 -2.879 0.454
Mean 64.905 59.600 62.933 62.48
S Em 0.98 0.367
C.V. 2.066 2.428 2.407
CD 5 % 2.185 2.358 2.468
CD 1 % 2.901 3.131 3.278
14

15. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for days to Flower initiation in faba bean
bi
bi
15
bi

16. 16
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for days to 50% flowering in faba bean
bi

17. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 76.333 72.333 69.000 72.556 1.170 4.3392 *
2 ET226420 74.000 69.667 67.333 70.333 1.137 1.422
3 ET226423 73.333 72.333 66.667 70.778 0.784 14.874**
4 ET226416 72.000 69.000 69.667 70.222 0.555 -1.283
5 ET226410 72.667 64.333 67.000 68.000 1.460 1.821
6 ET226425 71.667 70.000 67.667 69.778 0.583 1.333
7 ET226418 71.333 69.333 66.667 69.111 0.686 2.198
8 ET226413 71.667 71.333 68.667 70.556 0.340* 2.136
9 ET226417 73.667 65.000 73.333 70.667 0.953 32.719*
10 RFB-14 77.333 72.667 65.333 71.778 1.715* 26.258 *
11 ET226431 70.333 71.00 70.667 70.667 -0.105* -1.428
12 HFB-1 73.000 69.000 72.333 71.444 0.492* 3.967
13 ET226415 72.000 69.333 68.667 70.000 0.622 -1.230
14 ET226414 74.667 69.333 70.000 71.333 1.040 -1.302
15 ET226408 72.333 68.667 68.000 69.667 0.829 -1.220
16 Rebaya-40 75.333 72.333 69.000 72.222 0.962 4.2918 *
17 Hudalbu 75.000 70.000 69.000 71.333 1.140 -0.901
18 Hanma-1 73.000 66.667 72.667 70.778 0.705 16.24 **
19 Basabeer 76.000 69.000 69.000 71.333 1.454 -1.475
Environment index and stability of Days to pod initiation under different environments (2021-22)
17

18. 20 ET226428 75.000 69.333 72.000 72.111 0.906 1.916
21 ET226430 78.000 68.000 70.000 72.000 1.873* 0.279
22 ET226422 76.667 69.333 72.333 72.778 1.218 2.780
23 RFB-6 76.000 66.667 67.667 70.111 1.837* -1.094
24 PRT-12 73.667 70.667 72.333 72.222 0.454 -0.142
25 ET226421 74.333 68.000 67.000 69.778 1.417 -0.881
26 ET226429 74.000 70.333 68.000 70.778 0.999 1.400
27 Hanma-2 72.000 67.667 68.000 69.222 0.866 -1.443
28 ET226424 72.000 71.000 69.000 70.667 0.411* 0.574
29 ET226427 75.333 68.333 71.667 71.778 1.115 3.831
30 ET226432 73.667 69.667 70.000 71.111 0.797 -1.441
31 ET226426 75.000 70.667 74.000 73.222 0.561 3.952
32 Sambad-75 77.000 66.667 72.000 71.889 1.604 12.180 **
33 Habidulla 78.333 71.000 69.000 72.778 1.726 0.758
34 ET226419 72.333 70.000 68.333 70.222 0.654 -0.018
35 Vikrant 80.333 71.000 70.000 73.778 2.040 -0.834
Environmental Index 6.64 -0.725 -5.915
Mean 79.429 72.063 66.873 71.05
S Em 1.58 0.571
C.V. 3.055 2.929 2.940
CD 5 % 3.696 3.313 3.328
CD 1 % 4.909 4.399 4.420 18

19. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 69.00 70.27 67.70 68.99 0.085* -9.102
2 ET226420 79.43 66.87 66.80 71.03 1.053 5.722
3 ET226423 82.63 73.80 70.40 75.61 0.989 -10.008
4 ET226416 78.87 66.37 68.83 71.36 0.859 17.05
5 ET226410 82.70 70.70 68.87 74.09 1.137 -1.859
6 ET226425 80.73 72.83 63.47 72.34 1.355 -8.536
7 ET226418 77.20 69.00 63.03 69.74 1.127 -11.811
8 ET226413 82.27 72.70 72.33 75.77 0.825 -2.591
9 ET226417 69.47 69.70 67.63 68.93 0.134* -10.690
10 RFB-14 71.73 75.90 69.60 72.41 0.121* 7.557
11 ET226431 82.07 73.43 65.93 73.81 1.277 -11.362
12 HFB-1 73.20 73.40 73.70 73.43 -0.039* -11.815
13 ET226415 75.87 71.10 70.80 72.59 0.42* -9.695
14 ET226414 74.27 71.43 68.30 71.33 0.469* -11.526
15 ET226408 77.37 66.40 64.43 69.40 1.061 -4.282
16 Rebaya-40 83.73 85.43 75.20 81.46 0.619* 17.866
17 Hudalbu 86.07 82.23 72.63 80.31 1.033 -1.005
18 Hanma-1 81.47 71.97 66.00 73.14 1.236 -11.698
19 Basabeer 72.87 69.90 69.43 70.73 0.282* -11.221
Environment index and stability of plant height under different environments (2021-22)
19

20. 20 ET226428 75.07 57.07 59.07 63.73 1.353 37.150*
21 ET226430 81.20 68.93 57.20 69.11 1.895* -9.647
22 ET226422 72.07 58.50 55.47 62.01 1.357 -2.146
23 RFB-6 76.40 77.13 67.27 73.60 0.672 12.673
24 PRT-12 82.47 77.23 69.50 76.40 1.011 -8.099
25 ET226421 76.80 74.07 57.53 69.47 1.456* 36.657*
26 ET226429 82.00 63.93 57.90 67.94 1.955* -1.633
27 Hanma-2 77.20 73.47 68.73 73.13 0.663 -10.815
28 ET226424 80.73 58.03 58.57 65.78 1.854* 50.230 *
29 ET226427 85.33 75.23 65.80 75.46 1.543* -10.598
30 ET226432 95.07 76.30 69.60 80.32 2.063* -2.153
31 ET226426 86.73 75.83 69.37 77.31 1.39* -11.484
32 Sambad-75 84.27 77.97 67.87 76.70 1.276 -4.537
33 Habidulla 79.07 80.03 73.63 77.58 0.395 -0.429
34 ET226419 86.67 76.03 64.80 75.83 1.722* -8.637
35 Vikrant 78.00 79.00 73.16 76.72 0.35 -2.110
Environmental Index 6.64 -0.725 -5.915
Mean 79.429 72.063 66.873 72.79
S Em 2.38 0.378
C.V. 7.305 9.269 8.059
CD 5 % 9.454 10.883 8.781
CD 1 % 12.556 14.453 11.662
20

21. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for days to pod initiation in faba bean
bi
bi
21

22. 22
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for plant height in faba bean
bi

23. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 4.133 3.067 2.933 3.3778 0.845 -0.0501
2 ET226420 5.067 3.067 3.067 3.7333 1.446 0.1388
3 ET226423 5.8 2.8 2.733 3.7778 2.206* 0.3623 *
4 ET226416 3.667 2.667 2.8 3.0444 0.65 0.0147
5 ET226410 4.8 2.667 2.867 3.4444 1.433 0.2937 *
6 ET226425 5.8 3 3.267 4.0222 1.878* 0.568 **
7 ET226418 4.467 3 2.933 3.4667 1.097 0.013
8 ET226413 4.4 3.067 2.667 3.3778 1.184 -0.073
9 ET226417 5.8 3.267 3.133 4.0667 1.905* 0.1885
10 RFB-14 5.867 4.533 3.133 4.5111 1.733* 0.1418
11 ET226431 3.733 3.533 2.933 3.4 0.474 0.0028
12 HFB-1 5.267 3.533 3.8 4.2 1.107 0.2278
13 ET226415 4.8 2.733 3.467 3.6667 1.092 0.720 **
14 ET226414 5.133 3 2.733 3.6222 1.689* 0.0421
15 ET226408 3.933 2.667 3.4 3.3333 0.513 0.4199 *
16 Rebaya-40 5.4 3 3 3.8 1.735* 0.2355 *
17 Hudalbu 4.533 4.533 3.267 4.1111 0.696 0.4227 *
18 Hanma-1 4.067 3.933 2.933 3.6444 0.646 0.199
19 Basabeer 5.267 5.867 4.067 5.0667 0.555 1.239 **
Environment index and stability of number of primary branches under different environments (2021-22)
23

24. 20 ET226428 4.4 2.667 3 3.3556 1.07 0.2707 *
21 ET226430 4.667 3.133 2.2 3.3333 1.621* -0.0541
22 ET226422 4.133 2.867 2.933 3.3111 0.879 0.0309
23 RFB-6 4.4 4.6 4 4.3333 0.185* 0.0658
24 PRT-12 4.067 3.933 2.667 3.5556 0.792 0.3793 *
25 ET226421 4.067 3.933 3.333 3.7778 0.426* 0.0121
26 ET226429 3.333 3.333 2.333 3 0.549 0.233
27 Hanma-2 5.733 4.2 3.467 4.4667 1.511 -0.0782
28 ET226424 4.133 2.333 2.933 3.1333 0.972 0.4936 **
29 ET226427 4 5.067 3.9 4.3222 -0.131* 0.735 **
30 ET226432 3.333 3.4 3.067 3.2667 0.135* -0.0399
31 ET226426 4 2.667 2.8 3.1556 0.891 0.0691
32 Sambad-75 4.467 3.8 3.4 3.8889 0.702 -0.0762
33 Habidulla 4.667 4.267 3.267 4.0667 0.838 0.1368
34 ET226419 4.333 5.2 2.6 4.0444 0.801 2.6734 **
35 Vikrant 4.867 4.467 3.4 4.2444 0.875 0.173
Environmental Index 0.846 -0.203 -0.643
Mean 4.587 3.537 3.098 3.74
S Em 0.43 0.562
C.V. 11.679 14.297 13.921
CD 5 % 0.873 0.824 0.703
CD 1 % 1.159 1.094 0.933 24

25. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 14.867 9.4 11.133 11.8 0.568 -0.0172
2 ET226420 20.2 10.4 10.133 13.5778 1.241 -1.8516
3 ET226423 22.467 9.6 20.467 17.5111 0.886 60.457 **
4 ET226416 23.5 12 12.4 15.9667 1.409 -1.4896
5 ET226410 24.5 7.067 9.167 13.5778 2.038* 1.9731
6 ET226425 21.833 8.533 9.833 13.4 1.574* -0.2107
7 ET226418 13.433 8.267 8.7 10.1333 0.616 -1.6593
8 ET226413 20.067 8.533 8.4 12.3333 1.449* -1.803
9 ET226417 25.267 8.667 6.9 13.6111 2.19* -1.3102
10 RFB-14 43.1 17.133 15.5 25.2444 3.350* -1.7176
11 ET226431 21 13.933 12.3 15.7444 0.991 -1.0038
12 HFB-1 26.4 22.8 19.8 23 0.648 2.0289
13 ET226415 16.5 10.133 8.5 11.7111 0.903 -0.9659
14 ET226414 22.6 14.933 13.8 17.1111 1.032 -1.5449
15 ET226408 10.867 11.067 13.9 11.9444 -0.213* 1.9623
16 Rebaya-40 27.2 15.8 14.1 19.0333 1.536* -1.1443
17 Hudalbu 28 14.067 13.233 18.4333 1.795* -1.8312
18 Hanma-1 22.767 18.867 16.433 19.3556 0.648 0.6081
19 Basabeer 22.267 24.467 12.867 19.8667 0.494* 63.636 **
Environment index and stability of number of pod per plant under different environments (2021-22)
25

26. 20 ET226428 15.8 16.2 14.533 15.5111 0.06* -0.5036
21 ET226430 16.933 13 10.533 13.4889 0.655 0.6781
22 ET226422 9.667 14.867 12.3 12.2778 -0.479* 1.8524
23 RFB-6 30.733 23.467 21.033 25.0778 1.069 0.3114
24 PRT-12 26.467 19.867 18.167 21.5 0.937 -0.8898
25 ET226421 14.867 8.467 10.1 11.1444 0.691 -0.13
26 ET226429 10.667 9.733 9.1 9.8333 0.159* -1.6922
27 Hanma-2 26.1 23.8 20.067 23.3222 0.535 4.477
28 ET226424 27.7 5.933 15.5 16.3778 2.084* 50.72**
29 ET226427 25.333 12.267 12.767 16.7889 1.598* -1.3368
30 ET226432 13.467 8.2 9 10.2222 0.605 -1.3627
31 ET226426 24.8 5.933 12.5 14.4111 1.921* 24.0 **
32 Sambad-75 31.333 21.267 20.133 24.2444 1.332 -1.6182
33 Habidulla 26.667 23.867 20.667 23.7333 0.562* 2.6925
34 ET226419 15.867 21.133 20 19 -0.582* -0.9836
35 Vikrant 27.933 23.267 21.5 24.2333 0.7 -0.6781
Environmental Index 5.333 -2.503 -2.830
Mean 22.033 14.198 13.870 16.700
S Em 1.908 .412
C.V. 13.858 14.320 13.584
CD 5 % 4.975 3.313 3.070
CD 1 % 6.607 4.399 4.077
26

27. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for days to pod initiation in faba bean
bi
bi
27

28. 28
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for number of pod per plant in faba bean

29. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 1.8 0.8 0.8 1.1333 0.478* 0.0036
2 ET226420 3.267 0.533 1.267 1.6889 1.069 0.7756 **
3 ET226423 1.867 1 1 1.2889 0.414* -0.003
4 ET226416 4 0.867 0.7 1.8556 1.551* 0.1439 **
5 ET226410 3.333 0.867 0.933 1.7111 1.157 0.1729 **
6 ET226425 3 0.667 1.067 1.5778 0.986 0.3672 **
7 ET226418 0.867 0.8 0.533 0.7333 0.118 0.0002
8 ET226413 2.267 1.333 0.6 1.4 0.683 0.0649
9 ET226417 5.333 0.8 0.7 2.2778 2.198* 0.4357 **
10 RFB-14 4.4 2.4 0.933 2.5778 1.43* 0.3031 **
11 ET226431 4.333 0.733 0.9 1.9889 1.666* 0.4508 **
12 HFB-1 1.6 2.8 0.5 1.6333 0.17 2.5428 **
13 ET226415 5.533 1 0.5 2.3444 2.328* 0.1643 **
14 ET226414 2.667 0.867 0.667 1.4 0.925 0.0063
15 ET226408 1.8 0.733 0.433 0.9889 0.607 -0.0228
16 Rebaya-40 4.933 0.6 0.667 2.0667 2.049* 0.5344 **
17 Hudalbu 4.667 1 0.5 2.0556 1.914* 0.062
18 Hanma-1 5.333 0.8 1.067 2.4 2.08* 0.7897 **
19 Basabeer 0.933 0.8 0.667 0.8 0.107* -0.0194
Environment index and stability of number of cluster per plant under different environments (2021-22)
29

30. 20 ET226428 2.2 0.733 0.7 1.2111 0.712 0.0248
21 ET226430 2.133 1 0.667 1.2667 0.649 -0.0226
22 ET226422 0.533 1.533 0.567 0.8778 -0.165* 0.5455 **
23 RFB-6 6.933 0.6 0.7 2.7444 2.994* 1.1711 **
24 PRT-12 3.533 2.467 0.5 2.1667 1.145 1.0355 **
25 ET226421 2.333 1 0.167 1.1667 0.906 0.0625
26 ET226429 1.133 2.8 0.533 1.4889 -0.064* 2.7241 **
27 Hanma-2 3.333 1.4 1.267 2 0.967 0.0315
28 ET226424 3.8 0.8 0.667 1.7556 1.477* 0.1428 **
29 ET226427 1.8 0.6 1.267 1.2222 0.358* 0.3408 **
30 ET226432 1.733 2.2 0.733 1.5556 0.251* 0.9234 **
31 ET226426 2.467 1.6 0.533 1.5333 0.759 0.2382 **
32 Sambad-75 2.667 1.933 0.933 1.8444 0.674 0.2191 **
33 Habidulla 2.667 1.4 0.467 1.5111 0.907 0.1098 *
34 ET226419 1.6 1.4 0.6 1.2 0.354* 0.1855 **
35 Vikrant 3.2 1.067 0.667 1.6444 1.149 -0.0124
Environmental Index 1.340 -0.434 -0.906
Mean 2.971 1.198 0.726 1.631
S Em .467 .394
C.V. 13.599 14.831 17.660
CD 5% 0.658 0.290 0.209
CD 1 % 0.874 0.384 0.277 30

31. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 2.067 2.567 2.633 2.4222 2.811* 0.0940**
2 ET226420 2.133 2 2.3 2.1444 1.757 -0.0014
3 ET226423 2.233 2.1 2.167 2.1667 -0.084 -0.005
4 ET226416 2.133 2.2 2.3 2.2111 1.093 -0.0125
5 ET226410 2.033 2.2 2.1 2.1111 -0.027 0.0002
6 ET226425 2.167 2.1 2.333 2.2 1.536 -0.01
7 ET226418 2.033 2.933 2.233 2.4 -1.407* 0.411 **
8 ET226413 2.2 2.233 2.133 2.1889 -0.636 -0.013
9 ET226417 2.533 2.233 2.333 2.3667 -0.583 0.0292
10 RFB-14 2.033 2.133 2.433 2.2 2.823* -0.0119
11 ET226431 2.367 2.167 2.133 2.2222 -1.177* 0.0033
12 HFB-1 2.1 2.333 2.2 2.2111 0.015 0.0136
13 ET226415 2.4 2.133 2.667 2.4 2.988* 0.0335
14 ET226414 2.033 2 2.233 2.0889 1.688 -0.0123
15 ET226408 2.1 2 2.133 2.0778 0.594 -0.008
16 Rebaya-40 2.467 2.3 2.8 2.5222 3.182* 0.0082
17 Hudalbu 2.6 2.2 2.733 2.5111 2.378 0.080 **
18 Hanma-1 2.267 2.2 2.3 2.2556 0.484 -0.0111
19 Basabeer 2.167 2.1 2.267 2.1778 1.01 -0.0106
Environment index and stability of number of pod per cluster under different environments (2021-22)
31

32. 20 ET226428 2.1 2.267 2.267 2.2111 0.762 -0.0015
21 ET226430 2.133 2.333 2.233 2.2333 0.125 0.006
22 ET226422 2.133 2.1 2 2.0778 -0.941* -0.0136
23 RFB-6 2.133 2.367 2.333 2.2778 0.804 0.0112
24 PRT-12 2.8 2.3 2.233 2.4444 -2.812* 0.094 **
25 ET226421 2 2.1 2.4 2.1667 2.823 -0.0119
26 ET226429 2.267 2 2.1 2.1222 -0.43 0.0205
27 Hanma-2 2.2 2.133 2.367 2.2333 1.536 -0.01
28 ET226424 2.067 2.267 2.167 2.1667 0.125 0.006
29 ET226427 2.467 2.3 2.233 2.3333 -1.288* -0.0026
30 ET226432 2.067 2 2.767 2.2778 5.743* -0.0035
31 ET226426 2.133 2 2.3 2.1444 1.757 -0.0014
32 Sambad-75 2.067 2.5 2.267 2.2778 0.14 0.0800**
33 Habidulla 2 2.067 2.533 2.2 3.986* -0.0137
34 ET226419 2.067 2.267 2.533 2.2889 3.018* -0.001
35 Vikrant 2.133 2.167 2.3 2.2 1.204 -0.0137
Environmental Index -0.049 -0.035 0.084
Mean 2.195 2.209 2.328 2.243
S Em .131 1.801
C.V. 13.599 14.831 17.660
CD95% 0.322 0.333 0.342
CD99% 0.428 0.443 0.454 32

33. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for number of cluster per plant in faba bean
bi
33

34. 34
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for number of pod per cluster in faba bean
bi

35. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 137.667 139.667 128 135.1 0.69 21.6 **
2 ET226420 142.667 138.667 129.333 136.9 0.906 -1.2
3 ET226423 139.333 132.333 123 131.6 1.095 -2.9
4 ET226416 140.667 136.333 117.333 131.4 1.604* 17.3 **
5 ET226410 135.667 136.333 117.667 129.9 1.265 42.3 **
6 ET226425 134.667 134 130 132.9 0.322* -1.8
7 ET226418 135.667 135 118.333 129.7 1.209 26.4 **
8 ET226413 134.333 137 118.667 130 1.115 54.1 **
9 ET226417 134.333 125 121.333 126.9 0.846 6.9
10 RFB-14 143.333 131.333 127.667 134.1 1.014 16.3 *
11 ET226431 144.333 126.667 121.333 130.8 1.488* 38.9 **
12 HFB-1 145 130.667 117.667 131.1 1.815* 2.2
13 ET226415 136.667 126.667 121 128.1 1.028 4.7
14 ET226414 133 133.667 122 129.6 0.775 15.8 *
15 ET226408 138 136 120.667 131.6 1.2 15.8 *
16 Rebaya-40 140 132.667 121.667 131.4 1.233 -2.8
17 Hudalbu 142.667 138.667 121 134.1 1.489* 14.6 *
18 Hanma-1 142.667 128 130.333 133.7 0.762 56.2 **
19 Basabeer 142.667 132.667 127.667 134.3 0.981 6
Environment index and stability of days to maturity under different environments (2021-22)
35

36. 20 ET226428 135.667 138.333 123 132.3 0.905 39.6 **
21 ET226430 135.667 136.333 130 134 0.401 3.3
22 ET226422 137 123 118.667 126.2 1.187 23.0 **
23 RFB-6 131.667 122.333 122.333 125.4 0.589 16.3 *
24 PRT-12 132 131.667 123 128.9 0.628 5
25 ET226421 145.333 131.667 122 133 1.539* 6.7
26 ET226429 141.667 134 123 132.9 1.254 -2.9
27 Hanma-2 139 125 122 128.7 1.094 27.8 **
28 ET226424 140.667 141.333 131.667 137.9 0.635 10.3 *
29 ET226427 141 125.667 120 128.9 1.364 24.7 **
30 ET226432 139.667 137.333 120.667 132.6 1.314 18.5 **
31 ET226426 132.667 135.333 124.667 130.9 0.578* 21.3 **
32 Sambad-75 134.333 122.667 125.667 127.6 0.526* 39.5 **
33 Habidulla 131 128.333 124.333 127.9 0.448* -2.9
34 ET226419 135.333 124.667 120.333 126.8 0.977 9.5 *
35 Vikrant 141.667 128.333 130 133.3 0.725 43.8 **
Environmental Index 7.067 0.771 -7.838
Mean 138.219 131.924 123.314 131.2
S Em 3.2 .400
C.V. 2.110 2.087 2.603
CD 5% 4.752 4.486 5.230
CD 1% 6.311 5.958 6.946
36

37. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 2.733 2.6 2.667 2.6667 -0.507* -0.0196
2 ET226420 3 3 3.067 3.0222 0.068* -0.0172
3 ET226423 3.067 2.933 2.667 2.8889 -0.848* 0.0393
4 ET226416 3.067 2.667 3 2.9111 -1.383* 0.009
5 ET226410 2.933 2.933 3.067 2.9778 0.137* -0.0088
6 ET226425 2.333 3 3.333 2.8889 3.217* 0.1588 **
7 ET226418 2.6 3.067 2.933 2.8667 1.876* -0.02
8 ET226413 2.8 3.2 2.733 2.9111 1.247 0.0564
9 ET226417 2.733 3.2 2.6 2.8444 1.398* 0.1144 *
10 RFB-14 2.6 3.267 2.8 2.8889 2.397* 0.0254
11 ET226431 2.667 2.933 3.067 2.8889 1.287 0.0086
12 HFB-1 3.2 3.133 3.333 3.2222 -0.082* 0.0005
13 ET226415 2.933 3.133 2.8 2.9556 0.521* 0.0274
14 ET226414 2.867 3 2.533 2.8 0.097* 0.0952 *
15 ET226408 3.2 3.267 2.8 3.0889 -0.191* 0.1062 *
16 Rebaya-40 2.333 3.4 2.8 2.8444 3.985* 0.0304
17 Hudalbu 2.667 3.133 3.4 3.0667 2.286* 0.0840 *
18 Hanma-1 2.867 3 3.133 3 0.712 -0.0011
19 Basabeer 2.8 2.8 3 2.8667 0.205* 0.0053
Environment index and stability of number of seeds per pod under different environments (2021-22)
37

38. 20 ET226428 2.8 2.667 3.2 2.8889 -0.028* 0.1340 **
21 ET226430 2.867 2.8 2.467 2.7111 -0.629* 0.0588 *
22 ET226422 2.667 2.467 2.8 2.6444 -0.521* 0.0274
23 RFB-6 2.667 2.8 3.133 2.8667 0.917 0.0679 *
24 PRT-12 2.6 2.733 2.933 2.7556 0.78 0.0163
25 ET226421 2.6 2.867 3.067 2.8444 1.355 0.0293
26 ET226429 2.6 3.067 3.4 3.0222 2.354* 0.1210 **
27 Hanma-2 2.6 3.267 2.8 2.8889 2.397* 0.0254
28 ET226424 2.867 2.667 2.6 2.7111 -0.931* -0.0099
29 ET226427 2.467 2.933 3.067 2.8222 2.149* 0.0268
30 ET226432 2.733 3.333 2.8 2.9556 2.041* 0.0595 *
31 ET226426 2.867 2.933 3.267 3.0222 0.629 0.0588 *
32 Sambad-75 3.133 3.133 2.8 3.0222 -0.342* 0.0502
33 Habidulla 2.4 3.4 2.533 2.7778 3.425* 0.1846 **
34 ET226419 2.733 3.267 3 3 2.027* -0.0127
35 Vikrant 2.467 3.2 3 2.8889 2.958* -0.0198
Environmental Index -0.142 0.108 0.034
Mean 2.756 3.006 2.931 2.897
S Em 0.177 .387
C.V. 8.373 8.024 9.093
CD95% 0.376 0.393 0.434
CD99% 0.499 0.522 0.577 38

39. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for days to maturity in faba bean
bi
39

40. 40
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for number of seed per pod in faba bean
bi

41. Environment index and stability of number of seeds per plant under different environments (2021-22)
SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 42.467 24.467 28.233 31.7222 0.876 0.75
2 ET226420 56.8 32.033 31.233 40.0222 1.409 -13.59
3 ET226423 64.633 28.367 54.6 49.2 1.132 413.4 **
4 ET226416 69.3 37.7 36.4 47.8 1.807* -11.96
5 ET226410 67 21.267 27.8 38.6889 2.329* 61.76 *
6 ET226425 52.267 24.8 31.367 36.1444 1.309 32.38
7 ET226418 37.033 23.933 25.3 28.7556 0.684 -12.65
8 ET226413 53.533 26.733 21.8 34.0222 1.663 -17.36
9 ET226417 69.067 25.933 18.167 37.7222 2.670* -17.16
10 RFB-14 112.3 52.333 43.567 69.4 3.643* -17.42
11 ET226431 54.1 40 35.833 43.3111 0.928 -15.97
12 HFB-1 72.133 70.3 65.7 69.3778 0.259* -9.72
13 ET226415 47.167 32 23.933 34.3667 1.12 -3.88
14 ET226414 67.8 42.567 34.967 48.4444 1.666* -11.95
15 ET226408 30.667 36.233 39.233 35.3778 -0.412* -15.68
16 Rebaya-40 62.533 53.6 39.6 51.9111 0.974 49.63
17 Hudalbu 72.5 43.667 41.967 52.7111 1.666 -14.24
18 Hanma-1 58.667 53.9 49.133 53.9 0.428 -10.75
19 Basabeer 61.9 68.7 37.267 55.9556 0.688 429.5 **
41

42. 20 ET226428 44.067 43.433 46.767 44.7556 -0.07* -12.61
21 ET226430 47.867 37.6 27.567 37.6778 0.913 12.45
22 ET226422 25.667 39.767 34.6 33.3444 -0.61* 5.41
23 RFB-6 82.333 65.633 65.533 71.1667 0.935 -14.92
24 PRT-12 68.433 55.5 52.833 58.9222 0.812 -17.42
25 ET226421 38.433 25.467 30.7 31.5333 0.546 4.73
26 ET226429 27.633 29.7 31.133 29.4889 -0.16* -17.08
27 Hanma-2 67.867 76 56.433 66.7667 0.21* 166.2 **
28 ET226424 79.467 15.8 40.433 45.2333 2.71* 489.2 **
29 ET226427 61.8 36 39.033 45.6111 1.336 3.57
30 ET226432 34.433 27.367 25.367 29.0556 0.462 -17.26
31 ET226426 71.6 17.633 40.933 43.3889 2.22* 409.10**
32 Sambad-75 97.2 66.7 56.233 73.3778 2.05* -3.877
33 Habidulla 63.2 80.967 52.733 65.6333 -0.03* 389.6 **
34 ET226419 42.6 69.3 60.033 57.3111 -1.17* 58.93 *
35 Vikrant 68.7 74.933 64.233 69.2889 0.01* 40.1111
Environmental Index 11.765 42.867 40.305
Mean 59.233 47.468
S Em± 17.678 17.924 6.466 .629
C.V(%) 11.832 12.347 11.770
CD at 5% 11.419 16.397 15.632
42

43. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 14.333 4.667 6.8 8.6 0.86 13.66 **
2 ET226420 9.667 6.933 6.133 7.5778 0.368 -0.9351
3 ET226423 13.667 4.867 8.667 9.0667 0.618 18.872**
4 ET226416 14 8.733 5.6 9.4444 0.85 -1.0337
5 ET226410 15.333 6.933 5.6 9.2889 1.03 1.7201
6 ET226425 11.667 7 7.6 8.7556 0.453 1.5898
7 ET226418 10 12.733 4.667 9.1333 0.42 23.826**
8 ET226413 7.667 14.733 5.4 9.2667 0.062* 46.147**
9 ET226417 10 6.867 7.4 8.0889 0.293 0.2893
10 RFB-14 32.333 17.067 6.2 18.5333 2.622* 0.865
11 ET226431 15 4.6 6.733 8.7778 0.94 15.287**
12 HFB-1 21.333 9.467 7.8 12.8667 1.436 5.0339 *
13 ET226415 12 10.4 6.733 9.7111 0.499 1.0953
14 ET226414 10.333 5.067 6.333 7.2444 0.459 3.5422 *
15 ET226408 20.667 6.333 5.133 10.7111 1.663 10.546**
16 Rebaya-40 23.667 37.667 5.267 22.2 1.357 435.20 **
17 Hudalbu 21.667 26.133 8.2 18.6667 1.108 112.08**
18 Hanma-1 35.333 13.6 4.6 17.8444 3.159* 0.9288
19 Basabeer 18 11.2 5.6 11.6 1.235 -0.0278
Environment index and stability of seed yield per plant under different environments (2021-22)
43

44. 20 ET226428 11.667 7.267 9.067 9.3333 0.318 3.6936 *
21 ET226430 12.667 5.267 4.733 7.5556 0.851 2.1955
22 ET226422 12.333 3.6 6.333 7.4222 0.705 14.05**
23 RFB-6 19.333 11.667 5.4 12.1333 1.389 0.1959
24 PRT-12 11 12.867 12.133 12 -0.138* -0.2321
25 ET226421 13 5.933 4.333 7.7556 0.909 0.2691
26 ET226429 15 4.267 6.4 8.5556 0.976 16.054**
27 Hanma-2 28 18.067 11.333 19.1333 1.676 -0.5312
28 ET226424 20.333 4.133 4.6 9.6889 1.717* 22.01 **
29 ET226427 18.667 6.133 5.333 10.0444 1.432 8.60 **
30 ET226432 18.333 16.133 6.533 13.6667 1.091 18.31 **
31 ET226426 25.333 5.467 10.667 13.8222 1.695 68.021**
32 Sambad-75 13.667 9.867 3.733 9.0889 0.957 3.51 *
33 Habidulla 20.333 16.133 15.667 17.3778 0.497 -0.1783
34 ET226419 14.333 6.4 4.933 8.5556 0.991 1.0902
35 Vikrant 17.667 16.267 12.333 15.4222 0.501 1.7082
Environmental Index 5.411 -.985 -4.427
Mean 16.810 10.413 6.971 11.398
S Em± 3.554 .712
C.V(%) 14.942 14.351 15.266
CD at 5% 4.092 2.435 1.734
CD at 1% 5.435 3.234 2.303
44

45. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for number of seed per plant in faba bean
bi
bi
45

46. 46
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for seed yield per pod in faba bean
bi

47. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 0.167 0.233 0.133 0.1778 0.305 0.0030 *
2 ET226420 0.1 0.1 0.133 0.1111 -0.204* -0.0006
3 ET226423 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.1333 -0.611* -0.0001
4 ET226416 0.3 0.367 0.333 0.3333 -0.102* 0.0014
5 ET226410 0.3 0.233 0.1 0.2111 1.121 -0.0006
6 ET226425 0.267 0.2 0.2 0.2222 0.306 0.0008
7 ET226418 0.233 0.1 0.133 0.1556 0.408 0.0063 **
8 ET226413 0.167 0.067 0.133 0.1222 0.051* 0.0045 **
9 ET226417 0.1 0.2 0.267 0.1889 -0.866* 0.0011
10 RFB-14 0.433 0.5 0.133 0.3556 1.935 0.0140 **
11 ET226431 0.367 0.333 0.1 0.2667 1.579 0.0006
12 HFB-1 0.467 0.2 0.233 0.3 1.02 0.0245 **
13 ET226415 0.267 0.1 0.133 0.1667 0.561 0.0098 **
14 ET226414 0.5 0.167 0.1 0.2556 1.937* 0.0295 **
15 ET226408 0.133 0.1 0.1 0.1111 0.153* -0.0003
16 Rebaya-40 0.467 0.733 0.133 0.4444 2.444* 0.0818 **
17 Hudalbu 0.533 0.4 0.1 0.3444 2.445* -0.0006
18 Hanma-1 0.433 0.367 0.133 0.3111 1.732* -0.0004
19 Basabeer 0.1 0.1 0.233 0.1444 -0.815* 0.0003
Environment index and stability of seed yield per plot under different environments (2021-22)
47

48. 20 ET226428 0.433 0.267 0.2 0.3 1.172 0.005 **
21 ET226430 0.4 0.5 0.1 0.3333 1.986* 0.021 **
22 ET226422 0.133 0.233 0.033 0.1333 0.764 0.009 **
23 RFB-6 0.367 0.4 0.2 0.3222 1.069 0.0035 *
24 PRT-12 0.367 0.4 0.133 0.3 1.477 0.005 **
25 ET226421 0.2 0.267 0.1 0.1889 0.713 0.005**
26 ET226429 0.433 0.2 0 0.2111 2.293* 0.006 **
27 Hanma-2 0.5 0.433 0.233 0.3889 1.528 -0.0006
28 ET226424 0.4 0.267 0.2 0.2889 1.019 0.0030 *
29 ET226427 0.3 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.307 0.0178*
30 ET226432 0.167 0.233 0.133 0.1778 0.305 0.0030 *
31 ET226426 0.1 0.1 0.133 0.1111 -0.204* -0.0006
32 Sambad-75 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.1333 -0.611* -0.0001
33 Habidulla 0.3 0.367 0.333 0.3333 -0.102* 0.0014
34 ET226419 0.3 0.233 0.1 0.2111 1.121 -0.0006
35 Vikrant 0.267 0.2 0.2 0.2222 0.306 0.0008
Environmental Index 0.076 0.025 -0.101
Mean 0.330 0.280 0.154 0.254
S Em± 0.063 0.698
C.V(%) 13.274 16.554 25.602
CD at 5% 0.071 0.076 0.064
CD at 1% 0.095 0.100 0.085 48

49. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 27 21.667 31.667 26.7778 0.486 45.200 **
2 ET226420 37.333 33.333 32 34.2222 1.102 0.2692
3 ET226423 38.667 26.333 34.667 33.2222 2.359 18.377 **
4 ET226416 37.667 34 31 34.2222 1.158 5.8163
5 ET226410 41.667 31 35.667 36.1111 2.252 1.5447
6 ET226425 29.333 31.667 31 30.6667 -0.522* -2.3653
7 ET226418 36.667 29.667 27 31.1111 1.956 7.290 *
8 ET226413 38.333 32.667 29.333 33.4444 1.681 9.330 *
9 ET226417 37 31.333 28 32.1111 1.681 9.3307 *
10 RFB-14 28.667 30.667 28.333 29.2222 -0.301 -0.1546
11 ET226431 31 23 29.333 27.7778 1.453 11.0847 *
12 HFB-1 35 33.667 25 31.2222 1.053 44.919**
13 ET226415 32 31.667 32 31.8889 0.055 -2.3489
14 ET226414 37.667 32 41 36.8889 0.652 34.54 **
15 ET226408 39 33 39.667 37.2222 0.93 15.50 **
16 Rebaya-40 35.667 28.333 28.667 30.8889 1.788 -1.66
17 Hudalbu 35 44 29.667 36.2222 -1.033* 91.377 **
18 Hanma-1 33.667 26 31 30.2222 1.481 4.8665
19 Basabeer 42.333 41.667 31.667 38.5556 1 58.524 **
Environment index and stability of under 100-seed weight different environments (2021-22)
49

50. 20 ET226428 29.333 29 27.333 28.5556 0.222 -0.6111
21 ET226430 30.667 32.333 25.333 29.4444 0.171 24.040 **
22 ET226422 32.667 24.667 36 31.1111 1.035 54.206 **
23 RFB-6 27 27.333 25.333 26.5556 0.084 -0.17
24 PRT-12 27.333 24 31.667 27.6667 0.186 26.802 **
25 ET226421 37.333 25.333 22.333 28.3333 3.222* 14.611 **
26 ET226429 35.667 21.333 40 32.3333 1.992 146.84**
27 Hanma-2 37.333 30 34 33.7778 1.482 1.5048
28 ET226424 35.667 31.333 32 33 1.017 -2.3722
29 ET226427 43 36.333 29 36.1111 2.263 41.91 **
30 ET226432 35 30.667 36.333 34 0.6 11.3815 *
31 ET226426 29.667 25.333 38 31 0.016 80.494 **
32 Sambad-75 35 30.667 24.333 30 1.602 28.230 **
33 Habidulla 38.333 37 35.333 36.8889 0.469 -0.1854
34 ET226419 36.667 32.667 30.333 33.2222 1.185 3.3763
35 Vikrant 28 27.333 26.667 27.3333 0.221 -2.0143
Environmental Index 2.600 -1.724 -0.876
Mean 34.638 30.314 31.162 32.038
S Em± 3.511 1.532
C.V(%) 7.947 9.005 8.280
CD at 5% 4.485 4.447 4.204
CD at 1% 5.956 5.906 5.583
50

51. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for seed yield per plot in faba bean
bi
51

52. 52
Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for seed yield per plot in faba bean
bi

53. SL NO. Genotypes E1 E2 E3 Mean bi S-²Di
1 ET226411 25.67 24.10 23.47 24.41 0.486 45.200 **
2 ET226420 22.90 24.37 22.83 23.37 1.102 0.2692
3 ET226423 24.57 25.80 25.53 25.30 2.359* 18.377 **
4 ET226416 24.90 23.70 23.63 24.08 1.158 5.8163
5 ET226410 24.77 24.83 24.30 24.63 2.252* 1.5447
6 ET226425 26.60 24.73 23.93 25.09 -0.522* -2.3653
7 ET226418 26.53 26.70 24.90 26.04 1.956 7.2900 *
8 ET226413 24.50 26.77 24.17 25.14 1.681 9.3307 *
9 ET226417 23.50 25.30 26.97 25.26 1.681 9.3307 *
10 RFB-14 25.53 24.53 24.07 24.71 -0.301* -0.1546
11 ET226431 28.07 24.47 23.67 25.40 1.453 11.0847 *
12 HFB-1 27.27 24.03 22.83 24.71 1.053 44.919**
13 ET226415 27.33 23.57 25.60 25.50 0.055 -2.3489
14 ET226414 26.43 25.57 22.20 24.73 0.652 34.54 **
15 ET226408 24.10 24.23 24.80 24.38 0.93 15.50 **
16 Rebaya-40 26.70 27.57 26.30 26.86 1.788 -1.6686
17 Hudalbu 27.00 22.50 22.40 23.97 -1.033* 91.377**
18 Hanma-1 25.57 26.23 26.20 26.00 1.481 4.8665
19 Basabeer 24.47 22.63 23.90 23.67 1 58.52 **
Environment index and stability of protein content under different environments (2021-22)
53

54. 20 ET226428 28.03 25.10 24.73 25.96 0.222 -0.6111
21 ET226430 27.70 22.60 23.53 24.61 0.171 24.041 **
22 ET226422 25.43 24.70 26.73 25.62 1.035 54.20**
23 RFB-6 24.47 26.40 21.40 24.09 0.084 -0.17
24 PRT-12 26.90 24.60 22.57 24.69 0.186 26.802**
25 ET226421 26.40 24.60 25.53 25.51 3.222* 14.61 **
26 ET226429 26.80 25.80 26.30 26.30 1.992 146.85**
27 Hanma-2 26.60 24.40 25.40 25.47 1.482 1.5048
28 ET226424 26.87 25.33 26.10 26.10 1.017 -2.3722
29 ET226427 25.50 25.60 24.50 25.20 2.263* 41.91 **
30 ET226432 27.20 27.17 23.83 26.07 0.6 11.3815 *
31 ET226426 26.90 24.83 24.77 25.50 0.016 80.495 **
32 Sambad-75 25.43 25.77 22.20 24.47 1.602 28.230**
33 Habidulla 26.10 23.30 24.23 24.54 0.469 -0.1854
34 ET226419 25.93 21.50 24.43 23.96 1.185 3.3763
35 Vikrant 25.50 24.10 27.10 25.57 0.221 -2.0143
Environmental Index 3.752 -2.343 -1.410
Mean 25.948 24.784 24.430 25.054
S Em± 0.901 1.135
C.V(%) 4.974 4.652 5.242
CD at 5% 2.103 1.879 2.086
CD at 1% 2.793 2.495 2.771 54

55. Mean, regression coefficient and deviation from regression for total protein content in faba bean
bi
1-G1, 2-G2, 3-G3, 4-G4, 5-G5, 6-G6, 7-G7, 8-G8, 9-G9, 10-G10, 11-G11, 12-G12, 13-G13, 14-G14, 15-G15, 16-G16, 17-G17, 18-G18, 19-G19, 20-G20,
21-G21, 22-G22, 23-G23, 24-G24, 25-G25, 26-G26, 27-G27, 28-G28, 29-G29, 30-G30, 31-G31, 32-G32, 33-G33, 34-G34, 35-G35
55

56. Canonical roots analysis of different characters in faba bean in
different environments
ENVIRONMENT 1 Vector 2 Vector 3 Vector
Root 1 678.280 605.090 310.818
2 1396.268 568.383 429.793
3 538.502 412.761 218.025
% Var. Exp. 1 30.051 26.808 13.771
2 45.564 18.548 14.025
3 29.986 22.984 12.14
Cum. Var. Exp. 1 30.051 56.859 70.630
2 45.564 64.112 78.138
3 29.986 52.969 65.11
Days to Flower
initiation(days) 1
0.008 0.062 0.003
2 0.028 0.051 0.078
3 0.66 0.072 0.147 56

57. Days to 50% flowering (days) 1 0.072 -0.002 -0.024
2 0.074 -0.034 0.027
3 0.157 -0.018 0.012
Days to pod initiation(day) 1 0.094 -0.060 -0.021
2 0.002 0.062 0.091
3 0.019 -0.055 0.075
Plant height (cm) 1 0.048 -0.023 -0.003
2 0.133 0.006 -0.030
3 -0.015 -0.128 0.146
Number of Primary branches /
plant (No.) 1
0.050 0.015 -0.042
2 0.111 0.025 -0.333
3 0.111 -0.034 0.207
Number of Pods / plant (No.) 1 0.443 0.127 0.047
2 0.227 0.138 -0.601
3 -0.322 -0.549 -0.074
57

58. Number of Clusters / plant (No.) 1 0.164 0.819 -0.149
2 0.034 0.861 0.207
3 -0.157 -0.063 0.337
Number of Pods / cluster (No.) 1 -0.061 -0.271 -0.017
2 -0.051 -0.03 0.109
3 -0.015 0.116 0.076
Day to Maturity (days) 1 -0.020 0.245 0.395
2 -0.047 -0.088 0.554
3 -0.215 -0.16 -0.209
Number of Seeds / pod (No.) 1 -0.165 -0.210 0.173
2 0.116 -0.116 -0.176
3 -0.089 -0.023 0.189
58

59. Number of seed / plant (No.) 1 0.267 -0.096 0.090
2 0.025 -0.301 -0.029
3 -0.055 -0.227 0.121
Seed yield / plant (g) 1 0.301 0.040 0.775
2 0.688 -0.215 0.184
3 0.179 -0.69 -0.049
Seed yield / plot (Kg) 1 0.733 -0.268 -0.319
2 0.609 0.216 0.056
3 0.155 -0.209 0.707
100-seed weight (g) 1 -0.002 -0.164 0.238
2 0.194 -0.16 0.284
3 0.48 -0.163 -0.285
Total protein content (%) 1 -0.164 0.132 -0.136
2 0.098 -0.005 0.023
3 0.235 -0.178 -0.325 59

60. Contribution Percent of different characters of faba bean in
over environments
Character
Contribution %
ENVIRONMENT 1 ENVIRONMENT 2 ENVIRONMENT 3
Days to flower
initiation(days) 0.34 0.17 20.67
Days to 50% flowering
(days) 0.17 1.01 0.17
Days to pod
initiation(day) 0.17 1.18 0.50
Plant height (cm) 0.50 0.34 0.17
Number of primary
branches / plant (No.) 0.67 2.52 0.34
Number of pods / plant
(No.) 6.55 14.79 14.79
60

61. Number of clusters /
plant (No.) 26.72 21.68 12.27
Number of pods /
cluster (No.) 0.001 1.18 1.68
Day to maturity (days) 5.38 9.08 5.71
Number of seeds / pod
(No.) 1.01 0.50 0.50
Number of seed / plant
(No.) 3.87 0.001 0.17
Seed yield / plant (g) 14.96 19.16 17.65
Seed yield / plot (Kg) 34.29 23.03 10.76
100-seed weight (g) 5.21 5.04 11.43
Total protein content (%) 0.17 0.34 3.19
61

62. Cluster Distances of different character of faba bean in
environment 1
Grou
p. I
Grou
p. II
Grou
p. III
Grou
p. IV
Grou
p. V
Grou
p. VI
Grou
p.
VII
Grou
p.
VIII
Grou
p. IX
Gro
up.
X
Gro
up.
XI
Gro
up.
XII
Gro
up.
XIII
Gro
up.
XIV
Gro
up.
XV
Gro
up.
XVI
Grou
p. I
8.48 9.79
10.4
5
10.1
6
10.6
4
9.73
10.3
8
9.74
10.1
1
13.1
2
9.94
12.9
8
14.4
7
13.4
6
14.7
1
14.9
2
Grou
p. II
0 9.39
15.3
1
14.8
7
13.9
1
12.7
7
13.5
8
14.2
8
14.2
5
12.3
5
14.3
6
16.9
6
18.3
1
18.5
8
18.9
7
Grou
p. III
8.42
12.9
2
12.9
7
12.6
1
10.6
4
14.2
9
14.2
6
12.6
3
11.4
8
12.0
8
14.0
9
16.9
9
15.9
2
16.0
5
Grou
p. IV
0 5.55 6.31 8.87 8.77 6.75
13.0
2
9.95
13.0
4
9.97
11.7
3
10.8
10.3
4
Grou
p. V
0 6.36 8.27 9.75 9.07
11.0
3
12.2
1
12.1
9
8.7
15.2
3
9.24
10.8
9
Grou
p. VI
0
11.2
4
7.52 7.68 14.9 7.61
14.9
8
10.5
5
11.9
13.5
9
9.41
Grou
p. VII
0
13.9
2
12.2
6
6.87
13.2
9
10.4
3
10.0
1
17.6
7
10.0
5
14.9
2
62

63. Group
. VIII
0 6.76 16.6
10.5
1
15.0
6
15.0
6
10.6
1
14.5
1
12.7
9
Group
. IX
0
16.0
5
9.22
15.3
2
13.9
8
9.77 13.3 10.5
Group
. X
0
17.5
8
8.13
12.8
4
21.0
6
9.54
18.6
9
Group
. XI
0
17.1
3
14.6
8
10.0
3
18
11.5
8
Group
. XII
0
15.4
2
19.4
3
10.2
9
17.3
Group
. XIII
0
19.6
9
11.4
7
12.4
4
Group
. XIV
0
18.7
4
14.2
9
Group
. XV
0
13.9
1
Group
. XVI
0
63

64. Cluster Distances of different character of
faba bean in environment 2
Group. I Group. II Group. III
Group. I 11.59 18.19 27.62
Group. II 0 16.14
Group. III 0
64

65. Cluster Distances of different character of faba bean in
environment 3
Group
. I
Group.
II
Group.
III
Group.
IV
Group.
V
Group
. VI
Group.
VII
Group.
VIII
Group.
IX
Group.
X
Group.
XI
Group.
XII
Group. I 7.04 8.24 10.29 8.75 11.49 8.02 7.97 9.24 9 13.43 10.84 9.69
Group. II 0 11.93 5.29 11.7 8.14 11.34 10.6 11.6 13.99 11.51 10.79
Group. III 7.46 13.51 11.59 9.39 10.54 14.47 9.49 9.38 9.63 13.18
Group. IV 0 13.25 9.15 12.27 11.67 12.86 15.24 12.44 11.5
Group. V 7.99 10.58 12.12 13.47 10.86 16.09 15.09 10.26
Group. VI 0 9.51 11.52 8.9 11.15 10.27 10.72
Group.
VII
0 8.14 7.85 14.96 12.11 7.9
Group.
VIII
0 12.1 17.78 13.66 9.31
Group. IX 0 14.36 11.91 11.56
Group. X 0 8.24 18.02
Group. XI 0 15.57
Group.
XII
0

66. Clustering by tocher method in faba beans in environment 1
66

67. Clustering by tocher method in faba beans in environment 2
67

68. Clustering by tocher method in faba beans in environment 3
68

69. Cluster means of different character of faba bean in environment 1
Days to
Flower
initiation
(days)
Days
to
50%
flowe
ring
(days
)
Days to
pod
initiatio
n(day)
Plan
t
heig
ht
(cm
)
Num
ber
of
Prim
ary
branc
hes /
plant
(No.)
Numb
er of
Pods /
plant(
No.)
Num
ber
of
Clust
ers /
plant
(No.)
Num
ber
of
Pods
/
clust
er
(No.)
Day
to
Matu
rity
(days
)
Num
ber
of
Seed
s /
pod
(No.)
Num
ber
of
seed
/
plant
(No.)
See
d
yiel
d /
pla
nt
(g)
See
d
yiel
d /
plo
t
(Kg
)
100-
see
d
wei
ght
(g)
Tota
l
prot
ein
cont
ent
(%)
Group. I
55.11 64.64 73.82 81.4
3
4.33 19.62 2.29 2.18 136.3
6
2.72 53.2
0
14.
44
0.3
3
34.2
4
26.4
2
Group. II
55.67 64.00 76.67 72.0
7
4.13 9.67 0.53 2.13 137.0
0
2.67 25.6
7
12.
33
0.1
3
32.6
7
25.4
3
Group. III
54.00 64.33 73.67 77.9
9
4.63 19.03 2.37 2.13 141.4
4
2.96 53.6
2
14.
83
0.1
6
38.7
2
24.5
6
Group. IV
55.33 66.67 75.00 86.0
7
4.53 28.00 4.67 2.60 142.6
7
2.67 72.5
0
21.
67
0.5
3
35.0
0
27.0
0
Group. V
56.00 62.67 75.33 83.7
3
5.40 27.20 4.93 2.47 140.0
0
2.33 62.5
3
23.
67
0.4
7
35.6
7
26.7
0
Group. VI
55.33 64.33 72.00 77.2
0
5.73 26.10 3.33 2.20 139.0
0
2.60 67.8
7
28.
00
0.5
0
37.3
3
26.6
0
Group.
VII
54.33 64.67 70.33 82.0
7
3.73 21.00 4.33 2.37 144.3
3
2.67 54.1
0
15.
00
0.3
7
31.0
0
28.0
7
Group.
VIII
57.33 67.67 78.33 79.0
7
4.67 26.67 2.67 2.00 131.0
0
2.40 63.2
0
20.
33
0.4
3
38.3
3
26.1
0
69

70. Group.
IX
54.67 67.3
3
80.33 78.
00
4.87 27.93 3.20 2.13 141.
67
2.47 68.7
0
17.
67
0.5
3
28.
00
25.
50
Group.
X
55.33 63.6
7
72.00 75.
87
4.80 16.50 5.53 2.40 136.
67
2.93 47.1
7
12.
00
0.2
7
32.
00
27.
33
Group.
XI
53.67 65.3
3
73.00 73.
20
5.27 26.40 1.60 2.10 145.
00
3.20 72.1
3
21.
33
0.4
7
35.
00
27.
27
Group.
XII
58.00 67.0
0
73.67 69.
47
5.80 25.27 5.33 2.53 134.
33
2.73 69.0
7
10.
00
0.1
0
37.
00
23.
50
Group.
XIII
55.67 65.3
3
73.00 81.
47
4.07 22.77 5.33 2.27 142.
67
2.87 58.6
7
35.
33
0.4
3
33.
67
25.
57
Group.
XIV
51.00 66.3
3
77.00 84.
27
4.47 31.33 2.67 2.07 134.
33
3.13 97.2
0
13.
67
0.6
0
35.
00
25.
43
Group.
XV
55.33 65.6
7
76.00 76.
40
4.40 30.73 6.93 2.13 131.
67
2.67 82.3
3
19.
33
0.3
7
27.
00
24.
47
Group.
XVI
55.00 65.3
3
77.33 71.
73
5.87 43.10 4.40 2.03 143.
33
2.60 112.
30
32.
33
0.4
3
28.
67
25.
53
70

71. Cluster means of different character of faba bean in
environment 2
Days
to
Flower
initiati
on(day
s)
Days
to
50%
flowe
ring
(days)
Days
to pod
initiati
on
(day)
Plant
height
(cm)
Numb
er of
Primar
y
branch
es /
plant
(No.)
Numb
er of
Pods /
plant
(No.)
Numb
er of
Cluster
s /
plant
(No.)
Num
ber
of
Pods
/
clust
er
(No.
)
Day to
Maturi
ty
(days)
Num
ber of
Seeds
/ pod
(No.)
Num
ber of
seed
/
plant
(No.)
Seed
yield
/
plant
(g)
Seed
yield /
plot
(Kg)
100-
seed
weig
ht (g)
Total
prote
in
conte
nt (%
Group.
I
48.8 59 69.3 71.3 3.52 14.1 1.2
2
2.
2
131 2.9 42 9.1 0.26 29 24.
7
Group.
II
49.3 61 70.0
0
82.2 4.5
3
14.0 1.00 2.
2
138 3.1 43 26. 0.40 44 22.
5
Group.
III
50.0 62 72.
3
85.
4
3.00 15.
8
0.60 2.
3
132 3.4 53 37 0.73 28 27.
5
71

72. Cluster means of different character of faba bean in environment 3
Days to
Flower
initiation
(days)
Days to
50%
flowering
(days)
Days to
pod
initiation
(day)
Plant
height
(cm)
Numbe
r of
Primary
branch
es /
plant
(No.)
Number
of Pods /
plant(No
.)
Numb
er of
Cluster
s /
plant
(No.)
Numb
er of
Pods /
cluster
(No.)
Day to
Maturit
y (days)
Numb
er of
Seeds
/ pod
(No.)
Numb
er of
seed /
plant
(No.)
Seed
yield
/
plan
t (g)
See
d
yiel
d /
plot
(Kg)
100-
seed
weigh
t (g)
Total
prot
ein
cont
ent
(%)
Grou
p. I
51.07 63.24 69.17 67.9 3.16 11.45 0.79 2.35
122.
62
2.93
32.9
4
5.
99
0.
14
32.
52
24.
05
Grou
p. II
50.67 63.33 72.33 55.4 2.93 12.3 0.57 2
118.
67
2.8 34.6
6.
33
0.
03
36
26.
73
Grou
p. III
46.76 62.57 69.52 67.7 3.17 16.27 0.77 2.42
123.
71
3.04
49.0
4
6.
37
0.
16
27.
86
24.
07
Grou
p. IV
52 63 68 57.9 2.33 9.1 0.53 2.1 123 3.40
31.1
3
6.
4
0.
01
40
26.
3
Grou
p. V
49.8 63 69.2 71.0 3.11 20.17 0.78 2.32
124.
47
2.79
56.1
7
12
.4
0.
17
32.
47
24.
97
Grou
p. VI
49.67 64 69 58.7 2.93 15.5 0.67 2.17
131.
67
2.6
40.4
3
4.
6
0.
2
32
26.
1
72

73. Grou
p.
VII
51 62.3 69.6 68.8 2.8 12.4 0.7 2.3 117 3 36.4 5.6
0.3
3
31 23.6
Grou
p.
VIII
53.6 61 73.3 67.6 3.1 6.9 0.7 2.33 121 2.6 18.1 7.4
0.2
7
28 26.9
Grou
p. IX
51.6 60.6 67.6 67.2 4 21.0 0.7 2.33 122 3.1 65.5 5.4 0.2
25.
33
21.4
Grou
p. X
44.3 61.6 70 57.2 2.2 10.5 0.67 2.23 130 2.4 27.5
4.7
3
0.1
25.
33
23.5
Grou
p. XI
47 61 67 57.5 3.3 10.1 0.17 2.4 122 3 30.7
4.3
3
0.1
22.
33
25.5
Grou
p.
XII
51.3 67.3 74 69.3 2.8 12.5 0.53 2.3 124 3.3 40.9
10.
67
0.3 38 24.7
73

74. Disease and Pest incidence-
No incidence of disease has been observed due
to unfavorable environmental conditions. The pest
susceptibility percentage range between in 5% to
10%, which shows that there is less incidence of pod
borer. The genotype like Hudalbu, Habidulla, Rebaya-
40 show high pest susceptibility % as 7%, 8% and
7.5%. The maximum genotype show pest
susceptibility less than 0%. The environment was not
favorable for pod borer for infestation due to high
temperature during pod development stage .
74

75. DISCUSSION
75

76. Stability performance of different genotypes for different characters
Sr.n
o
Name of the trait Stable genotypes as per Ebharhart and Russel model
1
Days to Flower
initiation
ET226423,ET226425,ET226408,Basabeer,ET226428,
Vikrant
2
Days to 50%
flowering
ET226411, ET226423, ET226415, ET226408,Basabeer,
ET226422, ET226427 ,ET226432
3
Days to pod
initiation
ET226420, ET226410, ET226425, ET226418,
ET226415, ET226408,Hudalbu, ET226428, ET226421,
ET226429, Hanma-2,ET226419
4 Plant height (cm)
ET226423, ET226410, Hudalbu,Hanma-1,PRT-
12,Hanma-2,Sambad-75, ET226413,ET226431,RFB-6
5
Number of Primary
branches / plants
Hanma-2,Sambad-75,Habidulla,Vikrant
6
Number of Pods /
plants
RFB-6,Hanma-2,Sambad-75,Vikrant
76

77. 7 Number of Clusters / plants Hanma-2
8 Number of Pods / clusters ET226417,Hanma-1,
9 Day to Maturity ET226417,PRT-12
10 Number of Seeds / pods ET226413, Hanma-1
11 Number of seed / plants Rebaya-40, Hudalbu,Hanma-1,RFB-6,PRT-12
12 Seed yield / plant Basabeer,RFB-6,Hanma-2,Habidulla,Vikrant
13 Seed yield / plot (Kg) ET226431
14 100-seed weight (g)
ET226420,ET226410.ET226415,Hanma-
2,ET226424,Habidulla,ET226419
15 Total protein content (%) ET226415,Hanma-1,Hanma-2,ET226424,Vikrant
77

78. Stability performance of different genotypes for different characters in faba bean
Sl.
No.
Genotypes Da
ys
to
Flo
wer
init
iati
on
Days
to
50%
flower
ing
Day
s to
pod
initi
atio
n
Plant
heigh
t (cm)
Numbe
r of
Primary
branch
es /
plants
Numb
er of
Pods /
plants
Numbe
r of
Cluster
s /
plants
Num
ber
of
Pods
/
clust
ers
Da
y
to
Mat
urit
y
Numb
er of
Seeds
/ pods
Numb
er of
seed /
plants
Seed
yield
/
plant
Seed
yield
/ plot
(Kg)
100-
seed
weig
ht (g)
Tota
l
prot
ein
cont
ent
(%)
1 ET226411 * 1
2 ET226420 * * 2
3 ET226423 * * * 3
4 ET226416 0
5 ET226410 * * * 3
6 ET226425 * * 2
7 ET226418 * 1
8 ET226413 * * 2

79. 9 ET226417 * * 2
10 RFB-14 0
11 ET226431 * * 2
12 HFB-1 0
13 ET226415 * * * * 4
14 ET226414 0
15 ET226408 * * * 3
16
Rebaya-
40
* 1
17 Hudalbu * * * 3
18 Hanma-1 * * * * * 5
19 Basabeer * * * 3
20 ET226428 * * 2
79

80. 21
ET22
6430
0
22
ET22
6422
* 1
23
RFB-
6
* * * 3
24
PRT-
12
* * * 3
25
ET22
6421
* * 2
26
ET22
6429
* 1
27
Han
ma-2
* * * * * * * * 8
80

81. 28 ET226424 * 1
29 ET226427 * 1
30 ET226432 * 1
31 ET226426 0
32
Sambad-
75
* * * 3
33 Habidulla * * * * 4
34 ET226419 * * 2
35 Vikrant * * * * * 5
81

82. Conclusion
Temperature is a important factor for the crop- growth. Due to increase in the
temperature high heat stress obververd in the later phase of the growth which
decrease the yield and induce force maturity.Increase in temperature
significantly reduced the days to flowering, days to maturation and height.
Like highest post anthesis temperature above the 27° C contributed to decline
the number of pod, yield per plant under environment three than environment
one.
Genotype×Environment interaction and stability analysis revealed significant
differences among the genotypes for all the characters over environment
except number of clusters / plants, number of pods / clusters, number of
seeds / pods, indicating the presence of the considerable amount of genetic
variability in the experimental materials. the mean sum square for the
environment (linear) was significant to all character except number of seeds /
pods, number of pods / clusters, seed yield / plot. ET226431 had high
stability performance for the yield. ET226415,Hanma-1,Hanma-
2,ET226424,Vikrant had high stability performance towards the protein
content which is important quantitative character for pulse crop. The
genotypes Hanma-2 were most stable for maximum character under three
different environments. and also stable for terminal heat. The maximum
genotypes were stable the character days to pod initiation.
82

83. Based on the mean values of D2 analysis of 35 genotypes of faba bean (Vicia
faba L.) under present investigation revealed the existence of considerable
genetic diversity among them.
ENVIRONMENT 1- Hybridization between the genotypes (RFB-14) of cluster X
with (ET226414) of cluster XIV, ET226415 genotype of cluster XII with
(ET226414) of cluster XIV, HFB-1 of cluster XII with ET226414 of cluster XIV
may be exploited for development of varieties suitable for higher yield.
ENVIRONMENT 2 -Hybridization between the any one genotypes of cluster I
with (Rebaya-40) of cluster III, may be exploited for development of varieties
for higher yield.
ENVIRONMENT 3- Hybridization between the genotypes (ET226430) of
cluster X with (ET226426) of cluster XII, ET226417 genotype of cluster VIII
with (ET226430) of cluster X may be exploited for development of varieties for
higher yield. These genotypes in the most divergent clusters may be able to
take advantage of the maximum divergence under different environment.
Conclusion
83

84. 84
Images taken during the sowing, germination, data observation and harvesting

85. • Field visit by Dr. O.N.Singh (V.C,BAU), Dr. Sohan Ram ( EX- Chairman,GPB,BAU) and
Dr. H.L.Raiger (P.I AICRPPC)
85

86. THANK YOU
86