This document discusses using children's literature to promote empathy and action. It aims to show how literature can represent challenging times and responses to crises. Literature provides opportunities for developing understanding of others through windows into different lives and experiences. The document also provides strategies for using literature to foster empathy, such as discussion questions, poems, and plans for community action. It emphasizes how literary experiences can create caring attitudes and courage to address social issues.
1. Engaging readers through
children’s literature explorations
for empathy and action
Patricia A. Crawford
University of Pittsburgh
Sherron Killingsworth Roberts
University of Central Florida
3. Purposesof
today’ssession
To illuminate the ways in which
challenging times, and responses to
these times, are represented in
children’s literature
To consider ways to use children’s
literature as springboards for
empathy and action
To refocus attention on the role of
the affective domain and critical
thinking during literary explorations
4. Rationalefor
session#1:
Theworld
Difficult times in which we live
Daily challenges for all children
Friendships
Family life
School life
Extreme challenges for many
children around the globe
Human Crises
Natural Disasters
6. Daybyday
Kidd and Castano
(2013) found that, as
opposed to generic
fiction or nonfiction,
adults who read a
mere 15 minutes of
quality fiction
significantly increased
their levels of
empathy. Imagine
what 15 minutes of
reading high quality
fiction could
accomplish with much
more impressionable
youth.
10. Literaturemakes
important
connections
Literature provides provocative
invitations to better understand and care
for ourselves in the midst of difficult
daily life and crisis-oriented situations.
Literature demonstrates the complex,
layered nature of our lives, even amidst
crises.
Literature provides models of ways to
respond to others when confronted with
dilemmas.
Literature provides invitations toward
empathy and action by examining the
complex internal and external factors.
11. Literature changes us; it’s
a transaction between the
reader and the text; the
world and the word…
A book’s not a book until we read it.
Tough times and stressors call for ways to deconstruct
and to figure issues and ourselves out
with vicarious characters in vicarious
situations.
12. THE
TRANSACTION
I am reminded of ….personally.
I am reminded of …..locally (something
in my life now).
I am reminded of … globally.
15. TouchstoneTexts
Refugees Other crises include…
Poverty
War
Loss of life
Homelessness
Lack of education
Discrimination against girls
Leaving friends and the known
18. LiteraryModels
forEmpathy
andAction
Both material and human costs
accompany crises; solving material
problems may not resolve related deep
human needs and issues.
One day Emaje took me to a
place where she said the lion in my
belly would never roar again…
‘but I cannot go with you.”
21. Literature changes us;
Some strategies for
empathy • Frayer model for food scarcity; hunger
• Lessons learned
• Poetry
• Found poems
• I used to …but now…
• Collaborative haiku
22. Literature changes us;
some strategies for action
• Posters
• Graffiti boards
• Petitions
• Social media impacts
• Everyday Acts of Kindness
• Action plans with community
partners
• Maps or timelines for our
journeys
• Letters to make a difference
24. Resources
Fillable T-Chart for Listing and Comparing
http://www.readwritethink.org/classroom-
resources/printouts/chart-30225.html
https://www.ewg.org/kid-safe-chemicals-act-blog/send-
a-kids-letter-to-congress/
25. References
Bishop, R. S. (1990). Multicultural literacy: Mirrors,windows, and sliding glass doors. Perspectives:
Choosing and Using Books for the Classroom 6(3). Retrieved from RIF:
https://www.psdschools.org/webfm/8559
Beckett, S. (2012). Crossover picturebooks: A genre for all ages. London, UK: Routledge.
Botelho, M. J., & Rudman, M. K. (2009). Critical multicultural analysis of children's literature:
Mirrors, windows, and doors. Language, Culture, and Teaching series. New York, NY: Routledge.
Crawford, P. A., & Roberts, S. K. (2009). Ain’t gonna study war no more? Explorations of war
through picture books. Childhood Education, 6, 370-374.
Leland, C., Lewison, M., & Harste, J. (2012). Teaching children’s literature: It’s critical! New York,
NY: Routledge.
Marsh, E. E., & White, M. D. (2006). Content analysis: A flexible methodology. Library trends, 55(1),
22-45.
26. References-continued
Roberts, S. K., & Crawford, P. A. (2008). Real life calls for real books: Literature to help children
cope with family stressors. Young Children, 63(5), 12-17.
Rosenblatt, L. (1994). The reader, the text, the poem: The transaction theory of the literary work.
Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University.
Sipe, L. (2008). Storytime! Young children’s literary understanding in the classroom. New York,
NY: Teachers College Press.
Szente, J. (Ed.). (2018). Assisting young children caught in disasters. New York, NY: Springer.
Szente, J., & Wang, X.C. (Eds.). (2009). Helping children cope with the impact of war, terrorism,
and disaster. Childhood Education, International Focus Issue 2009, 85(6). Olney, MD: Association
for Childhood Education International.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1986). Thought and Language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Wolfenbarger & Sipe, L. (2007). A unique literary and visual art form: Recent research on
picturebooks. Language Arts, 84, 273-280.
Hinweis der Redaktion
Welcome! So glad you are here!
Introductions of presenters
Intro’s all around….quietly sit with this idea
Broad purposes listed above. In general, we acknowledge that today’s children live in a world of stressors (both large and small). We need to help them to navigate these stressor and crises by providing strategies, tools, and tangible support. We believe that children’s literature, and the responses that are made to it, provide excellent means for realizing these purposes. We’re excited about engaging with you on this topic and hope that you will leave with a cadre of titles, pedagogical strategies, and a renewed perspective after your engagement with the material and with others in the session.
In terms of our foundational beliefs, we borrow from the Frierian notion that children must read both the word and the world. Perhaps in this case, their reading of the world comes first….. We are probably all aware of the staggering challenges which children face today. All children face daily challenges and stressors on a daily basis. Some children face extreme challenges…. Human crises and natural disasters. This little girl could be a one peeking out to find a playmate on the playground, but in reality, she is a child in Syria—and certainly not the most graphic depiction of a child in this situation… Kids are navigating these difficult circumstances every single day. Even children who are not navigating these types of circumstances personally, are living them vicariously through the 24 hour news cycle….
This is where literature comes in to provide a different type of vicarious experience from the news cycle reality. Instead, quality books have the potential to provide an opportunity to serve as both windows and mirrors; provide a forum from which children can view deep experiences through the eyes of characters, begin to develop perspective taking, and alternative, empathetic ways of approaching problems and pain.
Wemberly Worried…. We wanted to start with a story that most of you might be familiar with….. How many of you know this story either from your work with children, or growing up as a child, or whatever?
Consider the broad range of Wemberly’s worries and the way they take over the page…. Similar to the ways in which worries can seem to take over our own worlds. We’ve all felt it. In the end, Wemberly might still be a worrier. However, her immediate worries are faced and resolved. She is aided by caring adults who take different perspectives: parents who worry along with her; a grandmother who is able to ground worries against a broader background of life and information, and a teacher who is able to understand the nature of Wemberly’s concerns and address them in practical ways. Wemberly’s concerns are acknowledged and embraced by caring others, who locate their response at the intersection of empathy and action.
We acknowledge that not all concerns can be addressed so neatly, but Wemberly provides a bit of a template for considering how we might acknowledge and address some concerns. Let’s take a look at how this might apply to our own lives and work. We’re going to ask you to take a minute to do some thinking and generate some thoughts about concerns we confront in daily life. Please make a quick T-chart (two columns). Take one minute to generate a list of personal worries and concerns (you will not have to share your list with anyone) . Now take another minute to generate another list of worries you have observed in the lives of your students…. Take a minute to compare the two lists…. What do you notice? We all live in worlds in which we have both personal worries and stressors, as well as large scale worries, when we might feel like the world, or the environment, or the
Add pic
When I was young in the mountains…
Also quiet and understated…. Sparse; but powerful CURRENT dif’t setting ; different culture Both books always accessible and in print. Enduring!
As we examined touchstone texts for issues related to daily stressors of poverty or giant crises, these themes became apparent. … So these books can help drive home the notion that empathy can be turned to action.
It’s impossible for us to take on wars, refugees, all the world’s WORRIES, but we can do something! And that something can make a different.
The problems we are facing are so complex. Books can give us the window to see that even our best responses may not be totally satisfying or satisfactory. Not perfect solutions!
Having a good intention and knowing how to meet a need is Not the same thing.
That’s really where …we come in… that’s where teachers and adults might come in.
And CRITICAL thinking….. Out of the DUDT
This letter might be
Sherron’s vision of caring/courage. These are times when we all (both children and adults) need courage to address a plethora of different problems….