SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 30
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Composing in New Realms -
Extended Metaverse Workshop
This presentation will give multiple operational
definitions of the metaverse for those actively using
communication and collaboration technologies.
Participants will be able to adapt and build on the
material for their own areas of expertise.
Agenda
● “Operational Definition” and Examples
● “Canonical Metaverse” and Examples
● “Extended Metaverse” and Examples
● Dialogue and New Options
Presenter: James G Neville (Sitearm), Owner,
Development One LLC, Independent Consultancy
Specializing in Online Presence
Experience: Corporate 25 years, Entrepreneurial 20
years
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Composing in New Realms -
Extended Metaverse Workshop
Welcome to the Extended Metaverse Workshop in Zoom. This presentation will give
multiple operational definitions of the metaverse to adapt and build on for your area of
expertise
My offline name is James and my online name is Sitearm. I am a practitioner in
applied online presence. I have 25 years corporate experience in analysis and
business and 20 years entrepreneurial experience in entertainment and arts.
Today we will cover Operational Definition, Canonical Metaverse, and Extended
Metaverse; then segue into Dialogue to create new options and ideas for use going
forward.
Please have something to write with and something to write on, and jot down your
thoughts throughout the presentation.
Protocols
Data will be presented in voice
and image.
Please use text chat for
questions and when asked for
responses.
As time allows, voice will be
enabled as well.
I will call you by your screen
name.
The stream will be moderated
and recorded.
At close of recording, you are
welcome to stay and dialogue
further.
We will start and end on time.
Part One - Data
2 Agenda
5 Animation
20 Presentation
Part Two - Reflection
5 Prompts
Part Three - Dialogue
5 Animation
20 Roundtable
3 Debrief
Timeline (nominal) and Protocols
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Timeline (nominal) and Protocols
Our timeline is Data, Reflection, Dialogue.
Data will be presented in voice and image.
Reflection will be in self-written notes.
Dialogue will be in text chat and voice.
Please use text chat for questions and when asked for responses.
As time allows, voice will be enabled as well.
I will call you by your screen name.
The stream will be moderated and recorded.
At close of recording, you are welcome to stay and dialogue further.
We will start and end on time.
We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the
animation is to help clear the mind and awareness.
1. Take a breath.
2. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable.
3. Watch and listen to the following animation.
4. Notice thoughts and sensations.
Animation
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Animation
We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the
mind and awareness. So…
Take a breath.
Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable.
Watch and listen to the following animation.
Notice thoughts and sensations.
PLAY Possibility Four pp01 - 3663 556
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMSJ80gb5BY
Part One - Data
People do not agree on the
metaverse.
Isn’t the metaverse just a
bunch of cartoon
characters?
Isn’t the metaverse just
another big company
scheme to make money
and steal our personal
information?
Is the metaverse really a
thing? Should we even take
it seriously?
Does it matter,
economically?
Does it matter, socially?
Does it matter,
academically?
Do I have a say in what the
metaverse is and what it is
for?
What is the government
doing about it and do we
even want to know?
Is OpenSimulator a
metaverse?
Is Zoom a metaverse?
Is a Door a metaverse?
What are the minimum
requirements to qualify as a
metaverse?
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Part One - Data
People do not agree on the metaverse.
Isn’t the metaverse just a bunch of cartoon characters?
Isn’t the metaverse just another big company scheme to make money and steal our
personal information?
Is the metaverse really a thing? Should we even take it seriously?
Is OpenSimulator a metaverse?
Is Zoom a metaverse?
Is a Door a metaverse?
What are the minimum requirements to qualify as a metaverse?
Example: “The Metaverse is a
Hustle”
Image courtesy F Minus
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “The Metaverse is a Hustle”
This cartoon shows two moviegoers who have paid for “4D glasses” so that they will
experience the “illusion of the passage of time.” One of them appears to be skeptical.
Does this remind you of anything?
Example: “The Metaverse is Like a
Hat”
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “The Metaverse is Like a Hat”
This diagram shows that 3D and 2D online content both require an electronic
infrastructure to deliver them. Yet pride of emphasis is given to 3D and the rest is
deemphasized. Does this remind you of anything?
Example: “Alexander Graham Bell
Invented the Metaverse”
Image courtesy Pinterest
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “Alexander Graham Bell Invented the Metaverse”
This photograph shows a bizarre mashup of technologies required to create a 1900’s
working caricature of a modern phone. Does this remind you of anything?
Example: “We Are Already Living in
the Metaverse”
The metaverse is reality in the
digital age.
The metaverse is a persistent,
online, digital environment, with
2-way, multi-user, co-creative,
instant access.
● Cable (wire)
● Radio (wireless)
● Device (desktop, mobile)
● Platform (operating system)
● App (code)
Earth's Submarine Fiber Optic
Cable Network
Image courtesy T Morgan-Wall
Mobile Network Towers
Image courtesy Science ABC
Image courtesy Statista.com
Favorite social media platforms in
Spain (2018 to 2022)
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “We Are Already Living in the Metaverse”
This slide shows two definitions of the metaverse:
The metaverse is reality in the digital age.
The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user,
co-creative, instant access.
The first definition is a bit grandiose and the second a bit idealistic, although more
specific. Do these remind you of anything?
Operational Definitions Change
Concepts Into Measurements
"An operational definition is a
procedure agreed upon for
translation of a concept into
measurement of some kind."
There is no true value of any
characteristic, state, or condition
that is defined in terms of
measurement or observation.
Change of procedure for
measurement (change of
operational definition) or
observation produces a new
number."
W. Edwards Deming, The New
Economics for Industry,
Government, and Education, 1994
Operational—Able to be used
Definition—Formal statement of
meaning
Measurement—ascertained by
comparison with a standard
Change—many valid definitions
Image courtesy T Hessing
“I know it when I see it.”
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Operational Definitions Change Concepts Into Measurements
The last slide said,
“The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user,
co-creative, instant access.”
This is an example of an Operational Definition.
An Operational Definition Changes a Concept Into a Measurement
The business consultant and statistician, W Edwards Deming,
helped the Japanese automobile industry become world-class in the 1950’s.
Deming changed grandiose concepts of “quality” into specific measures.
Deming stated that no concept is usable, in practice, until it has been translated into a
measurement procedure that can be observed and reported.
This means that you can ask yes / no questions about the concept, supported by
numbers.
For example, regarding the definition of metaverse that it has “instant access”...
. Traditional Email would be OUT as a metaverse.
. Instant Messaging would be IN.
Deming emphasized that if you change the yes / no questions that are being asked,
then you are changing the operational definition.
In particular, there can be more than one valid definition.
Example: Chair Has More Than
One Valid Definition
“chair”
1. A seat for one person having
four legs and a backrest.
2. Something that supports like a
chair.
“Lady Chair” image courtesy R Alekseev
“Bean Bag Chair” image courtesy Wayfair
definition courtesy Dictionary.com
“I know a chair when I see it.”
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: Chair Has More Than One Valid Definition
According to Dictionary.com, “A chair is a seat for one person with four legs and a
backrest.”
The picture on the left shows a “Lady Chair” with 4 legs but with the front two legs
crossed.
This meets the definition but does not look comfortable to sit on.
The picture on the right shows a “Bean Bag Chair” with no legs at all.
But you can sit on it and it looks more comfortable. It also looks harder to move.
Dictionary.com also says, “A chair is something that supports (like a chair).”
So there are multiple Operational Definitions for “Chair” distinguished by yes / no
questions such as:
. Four Legs? Yes / No
. Backrest? Yes / No
. Support? Yes / No
. Comfortable? Yes / No
. Easy to Move? Yes / No
I give Lady Chair 4 out of 5.
I give Bean Bag Chair 3 out of 5.
Both are different yet both are (operationally) “chairworthy.” *humor*
The operational definitions change based on the yes / no questions that are most
important to your use case.
Deming gives us good news and a warning:
It is NOT an issue if there is more than one operational definition.
It IS an issue if you and others you are meeting with are using different definitions and
do not know it.
Example: Metaverse Has More
Than One Valid Definition
“metaverse”
1. A shared, realistic, and
immersive computer
simulation.
2. A theoretical or emergent
networked online space.
“Hiro Protagonist” image courtesy I Medrano
“Metaverse” image courtesy Catapult Digital
definition courtesy Dictionary.com
“I know a metaverse when I see
it.”
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: Metaverse Has More Than One Valid Definition
According to Dictionary.com, “A metaverse is a shared, realistic, and immersive
computer simulation.’
Dictionary.com also says, “A metaverse is a theoretical or emergent networked online
space.”
So there are multiple Operational Definitions for “metaverse” distinguished by yes / no
questions.
Test Number One: An avatar is
something you can see outside
yourself that represents you.
Can you see your own avatar?
Test Number Two: A free
camera allows a movable
perspective of the virtual
environment in which your
avatar is immersed. Can you
see behind other avatars and all
around them?
Test Number Three: Can you
change your avatar,
environment, and content?
Test Number Four: Can you
visit whole other regions made
by others?
Example: “Seven Tests to
Distinguish Metaverse Apps”
Test Number Five: Does the
platform allow users to
exchange in-world currency
and real-world currencies
interchangeably? Can
developers make real-world
money by participating in a
virtual environment economy?
Test Number Six: Does the
platform combine digital and
physical environments
simultaneously?
Test Number Seven: Does your
use case require bolt-on
hardware and software to make
the platform work?
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “Seven Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps”
Here are seven yes / no questions I find useful to distinguish metaverse apps.
I give OpenSimulator 4 out of 7.
I give Zoom 3 out of 7.
Example: “Seven More Tests to
Distinguish Metaverse Apps”
Is the platform...
Instantaneous (online),
synchronous (two-way), and
many-to-many (multi-user)
interactive?
Collaborative and
build-and-create capable?
Turn-the-crank ready (stable
and expandable to many more
users)?
Does the platform…
Allow users to communicate
flexibly, including private as well
as public, text as well as voice?
Play well with other
technologies and devices ?
Is the platform…
Accessible in terms of costs,
equipment, and bandwidth?
Secure in terms of your user
identity and your intellectual
property?
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Example: “Seven More Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps”
Here are seven more tests.
I give OpenSimulator 6 out of 7.
I give Zoom 7 out of 7.
OpenSimulator is an Example of a
Canonical Metaverse
“He’s in a computer-generated
universe that his computer is
drawing onto his goggles and
pumping into his earphones.
In the lingo, this imaginary place
is known as the Metaverse.”
“He is not seeing real people, of
course. This is all a part of the
moving illustration drawn by
his computer according to
specifications coming down
the fiber-optic cable. The
people are pieces of software
called avatars. They are the
audiovisual bodies that people
use to communicate with each
other in the Metaverse.”
Image courtesy RO Ness
Neal Stephenson, Snow
Crash, 1992
Canonical—included in the
books accepted as genuine.
Digital Embodiment—3D, fluid,
free camera view of recreated
self, environment, and others.
Tilia—software and services for
virtual economies with ability to
convert real-world money into
in-world currency and back.
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
OpenSimulator is an Example of a Canonical Metaverse
OpenSimulator and Second Life is the Ur-Example of a Canonical Metaverse.
It is Canonical because there is a book about it, “Snow Crash”, written in 1992.
Think about your own experiences in OpenSimulator and in Real Life, as we read
what Neal Stephenson said back then…
*begin quote*
“He’s in a computer-generated universe that his computer is drawing onto his goggles
and pumping into his earphones.
In the lingo, this imaginary place is known as the Metaverse.”
“He is not seeing real people, of course.
This is all a part of the moving illustration drawn by his computer according to
specifications coming down the fiber-optic cable.
The people are pieces of software called avatars.
They are the audiovisual bodies that people use to communicate with each other in
the Metaverse.”
*end quote*
A Canonical Metaverse provides digital embodiment and 3D, fluid, free camera views
of a recreated self, environment, and others.
Canonical (3D) Metaverse
Platforms
Counting platforms which
roughly fit the classic Snow
Crash definition, it's over 505
million monthly active users.
Those include:
● Roblox (202M MAU)
● Minecraft (174M MAU)
● Fortnite (81M MAU)
● Zepeto (22M MAU)
● Avakin Life (11M MAU)
● Rec Room (7M MAU)
● IMVU (7M MAU)
● VRChat (4.5M MAU)
● AltSpace VR (1M MAU)
● Second Life (1M MAU)
0.5 billion is a significant (10%)
percent of the world adult
population (> 20 years old)
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Canonical (3D) Metaverse Platforms
10% of the world's adult population already use canonical (3D) metaverse platforms.
Zoom is an Example of an
Extended Metaverse
“The definition of metaverse,
now, is sort of a future-forward
social hub, a space where
avatars can meet, an
ecosystem for connected
apps. A VR- and AR-ready
dream of bringing people into
some sort of virtual universe
that's as creation-friendly as a
Minecraft, as popular as a
Fortnite, and as useful as Zoom,
Slack and Google Docs.
The future of tech doesn't lie just
in VR or AR, but in a mix of many
devices accessing a shared
online world, which may be more
immersive and 3D than the
internet you're currently using to
read this story.”
Image courtesy S Stein
Scott Stein, CNET, 2021
Extended—made larger.
Virtual Environment—A
networked shared work space.
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Zoom is an Example of an Extended Metaverse
“What is the Metaverse” became a hot topic in public awareness and media because
of
A) The Pandemic in 2019 forcing people to communicate using “2-way” “instant
access” apps like Zoom, and
B) Facebook in 2021 renaming itself to “Meta”
In response to the new “buzz”, Scott Stein, a senior technical editor at CNET,
published a contemporary definition of metaverse in 2021.
Think about the apps and platforms you use or see used, every day, as we read his
definition.
*begin quote*
“The definition of metaverse, now, is sort of a future-forward social hub, a space
where avatars can meet, an ecosystem for connected apps.
“A VR- and AR-ready dream of bringing people into some sort of virtual universe that's
as creation-friendly as a Minecraft, as popular as a Fortnite, and as useful as Zoom,
Slack and Google Docs.
“The future of tech doesn't lie just in VR or AR, but in a mix of many devices
accessing a shared online world, which may be more immersive and 3D than the
internet you're currently using to read this story.”
*end quote*
Notice the operational elements:
. Connected Apps? Yes / No
. Space Where Avatars Can Meet? Yes / No
. VR and AR Ready? Yes / No
. Creation Friendly? Yes / No
. Popular? Yes / No
. Useful? Yes / No
. More Immersive and 3D? Yes / No
. I give OpenSimulator 5 out of 7.
. I give Zoom 5 out of 7 as well.
Theorists Try to Cover the Bases
Stylianos Mystakidis, MDPI,
2022
“The Metaverse is the post-reality
universe, a perpetual and persistent
multiuser environment merging
physical reality with digital virtuality. It
is based on the convergence of
technologies that enable multisensory
interactions with virtual environments,
digital objects and people such as
virtual reality (VR) and augmented
reality (AR). Hence, the Metaverse is
an interconnected web of social,
networked immersive environments in
persistent multiuser platforms. It
enables seamless embodied user
communication in real-time and
dynamic interactions with digital
artifacts. Its first iteration was a web
of virtual worlds where avatars were
able to teleport among them. The
contemporary iteration of the
Metaverse features social, immersive
VR platforms compatible with
massive multiplayer online video
games, open game worlds and AR
collaborative spaces.”
Image courtesy S Mystakidis
The attempt, with what is
certain, to make the
uncertain certain, will leave
the uncertainty as it was.
Ancient Chinese Epigraph
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Theorists Try to Cover the Bases
Stylianos Mystakidis (stee-LAN-ohs MYS-ta-KEE-dis), a professor at the University of
Patras (PAH-tras), published an academic definition of metaverse in 2022.
I find it a useful reference
A Remote-Controlled Door Hints at
an Extreme Metaverse
Development One LLC
9
“Arm Balance” image courtesy Learn Genetics
Image courtesy Amazon
Smart Doorbell
Smart Door Opener
Image courtesy Amazon
Proprioception—the sense that
perceives location, movement,
and action of parts of the body.
Extended Mind Theory—
technology becomes part of
our minds.
Internet of Things—web-enabled
hardware that acts on data from
its environments and human
instructions.
We extend our sense of self into
the tools we use to express
ourselves. These include
medical prosthetics and
eyeglasses, as well as bicycles,
automobiles, and makeup.
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
A Remote-Controlled Door Hints at an Extreme Metaverse
The top picture shows a Smart Doorbell.
The delivery lady rings the doorbell.
The camera in the doorbell sends the picture to the grandmother’s phone app.
The grandmother knows it is safe to open the door.
The bottom picture shows a Smart Door Opener.
The phone app can trigger the door to open.
There is more.
The top right picture shows a lady doing a yoga Arm Balance pose.
She is using her brain to monitor her senses
and her muscles to control her body,
This is Proprioception—the sense that perceives location, movement, and action of
parts of the body.
What is the connection?
The grandmother is using her brain to monitor her
(electronic) senses (the doorbell) and is using
(electronic) muscles (the door motor) to control her
(electronic) body (the door).
This is the Internet of Things—web-enabled hardware that acts on data from its
environments and human instructions.
This is Extended Mind Theory—as a prosthetic limb can become part of a body,
technology such as computers and remote devices become part of our minds.
The Smart Doorbell and Smart Door Opener are available now on Amazon.com
This is the Extended Metaverse gone wild!
When Was the Metaverse
Invented?
1929 Link Trainer (physical flight simulator)
1957 Neuroprosthetics (cochlear implant)
1973 Cell Phone (Motorola)
1975 Microsoft
1976 Apple
1983 Apple Mouse (popular 2D visual interface)
1992 “Snow Crash” (portrayal of
metaverse and avatar in text fiction)
1993 Mosaic (popular text and graphics internet browser)
1994 Deming (formal definition of operational definition)
1994 Amazon (most popular ecommerce)
1995 eBay
1998 Google (popular search engine)
1998 PayPal (popular e-payment system)
1999 Internet of Things (Kevin Ashton)
2002 Smartphone
2003 Second Life (popular canonical
metaverse)
2003 Skype (voice over internet)
2003 WordPress (popular app for user-created websites)
2004 Facebook
2005 YouTube
2006 Google Docs
2006 Twitter
2007 OpenSimulator
2009 “Avatar” (popular portrayal of avatar in image fiction)
2009 WhatsApp
2010 Instagram
2011 Smart Glasses (Google Glass)
2012 Oculus (popular 3D visual interface)
2012 Zoom (popular extended metaverse)
2014 VRChat
2015 AltspaceVR
2015 Discord
2015 Google Becomes Alphabet
2016 Pokémon GO (smartphone AR)
2016 Sinespace
2021 Facebook Becomes Meta
2021 Scott Stein, CNET (contemporary definition of
metaverse)
2022 Stylianos Mystakidis, MDPI Encyclopedia (academic
definition of metaverse)
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
When Was the Metaverse Invented?
The metaverse arrived without us noticing it.
We don’t realize it now, until we look back:
“Snow Crash” came out in 1992, thirty years ago.
But that is also when The Internet became a thing.
Ten years later, Second Life came out in 2003.
But that is also when The Internet of Things became a thing.
Another ten years later, Zoom came out in 2012.
But that is also when The Oculus Headset became a thing.
And another ten years later, Facebook renamed itself as Meta.
Which brings us back to today.
Recap
As a concept, the metaverse
exists in minds and imaginations.
As practice, the metaverse exists
in the multiple,
physically-realized design
specifications with which we
create, communicate, and
collaborate.
These design specifications are
called Operational Definitions.
Sometimes our use cases
exclude particular metaverse
apps from being used in favor of
others.
And sometimes metaverse apps
become so attractive we find
new use case needs we never
had before.
An operational definition
translates concepts into
measurement procedures. There
can be be more than one.
The metaverse is an immersive,
digitally embodied, 3D,
computer-generated universe.
The metaverse is an evolving
ecosystem of digitally and
physically connected apps.
The metaverse is physical reality
in the digital age.
The metaverse is a persistent,
online, digital environment, with
2-way, multi-user, co-creative,
instant access.
The metaverse is a bizarre new
extension of physical mind into
physical body and space.
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Recap
As a concept, the metaverse exists in minds and imaginations.
As practice, the metaverse exists in the multiple, physically-realized design
specifications with which we create, communicate, and collaborate.
These design specifications are called Operational Definitions.
Sometimes our use cases exclude particular metaverse apps from being used in favor
of others.
And sometimes metaverse apps become so attractive we find new use case needs
we never had before.
Animation
We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the
animation is to help clear the mind and awareness.
1. Take a breath.
2. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable.
3. Watch and listen to the animation.
4. Notice thoughts and sensations.
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Animation
We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the
mind and awareness. So…
Take a breath.
Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable.
Watch and listen to the animation.
Notice thoughts and sensations.
PLAY Comfording Six pp02 2662 557
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7duNBrUFFoM
Part Two - Reflection
Before we begin the dialogue we will take a few minutes
for self-reflection. Please have something to write with
and something to write on, and jot down your thoughts
for these for questions:
Regarding the material you’ve seen so far…
1. What caught your attention?
2. What confirmed your own thoughts?
3. What surprised you?
4. What needs to be said that hasn’t been said yet?
Type “ready” in chat when you are done
~~
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Part Two - Reflection
Before we begin the dialogue we will take a few minutes for self-reflection. Please
have something to write with and something to write on, and jot down your thoughts
for these for questions:
Regarding the material you’ve seen so far…
What caught your attention?
What confirmed your own thoughts?
What surprised you?
What needs to be said that hasn’t been said yet?
Type “ready” in chat when you are done
Part Three - Dialogue
Participants Questions
What caught your attention?
What confirmed your own
thoughts?
What surprised you?
What needs to be said that
hasn’t been said yet?
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
~~
Close and Debrief
1. What did you like about this workshop?
2. What did you wish about this workshop?
3. What can you use going forward in your own work?
~~
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
Close and Debrief
We will now close with a short debrief. Please respond in text chat…
What did you like about this workshop?
What did you wish about this workshop?
What can you use going forward in your own work?
This ends the workshop and the recording. Thank you for your participation!
Selected References
● Favorite social media platforms in Spain in from 2018 to 2022,
https://www.statista.com/statistics/765008/networks-social-preferred-by-the-users-in-spain/
● Realizing "REAMDE"; how crypto empowers gold farmers, Robert Osazuwa Ness, Mar 25, 2021,
https://newsletter.altdeep.ai/p/realizing-reamde-how-crypto-empowers
● Metaverse, Stylianos Mystakidis, 10 February 2022, https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8392/2/1/31/htm
● What is "embodiment" in virtual reality? - Virtual Bodyworks,
https://www.virtualbodyworks.com/posts/what-is-embodiment-in-virtual-reality
● What Is a Smart Doorbell and How Does It Work?,
https://www.familyhandyman.com/article/what-is-a-smart-doorbell/
● Proprioception, https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/proprioception
● The extended mind in science and society,
https://www.ed.ac.uk/ppls/philosophy/research/impact/the-extended-mind-in-science-and-society
● What is the internet of things (IoT)?,
https://www.techtarget.com/iotagenda/definition/Internet-of-Things-IoT
● W. Edwards Deming, The New Economics for Industry, Government, and Education, 1994, 2018
● Neal Stephenson, Snow Crash, 1992
● Scott Stein, Microsoft, Facebook and everyone else are building the metaverse. Will you want to live
there?, CNET Aug 2021
● Tyler Morgan-Hall, Earth's Submarine Fiber Optic Cable Network [OC], Reddit, Sep 2021
● Science ABC, What Are Cell Towers And How Do They Work? 2021
● What is the Metaverse One pp01 C3663 556 SCORE,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1voZNLA3cE
● The five (and more) human senses, https://www.livescience.com/60752-human-senses.html
● Cognition and Perception: Is There Really a Distinction?
https://www.psychologicalscience.org/observer/cognition-and-perception-is-there-really-a-distinction
● Metaverse Platforms Infographic: Now Well Over Half A Billion Monthly Users!,
https://nwn.blogs.com/nwn/2022/10/metaverse-market-nick-mitham-infographic-q4-2022.html
● Q4 Metaverse Universe Update, https://www.metaversed.consulting/blog/q4-universe-chart-update
● DATASTREAM Visualizing the World’s Population by Age Group,
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-worlds-population-2020-by-age/
Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop
jn: 15-dec-2022
Development One LLC
01
SLIDES:
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1qs9DNQysArk8Pp2q5YoQdapkCDojcNkPCv
JNjgSznhQ/edit?usp=sharing

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie SLIDES w. NOTES - Extended Metaverse Workshop in Zoom OSCC 2022.pdf

Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
Markus Breuer
 

Ähnlich wie SLIDES w. NOTES - Extended Metaverse Workshop in Zoom OSCC 2022.pdf (20)

Web 2.0 Expo Ny--How to Submit a Winning Proposal
Web 2.0 Expo Ny--How to Submit a Winning ProposalWeb 2.0 Expo Ny--How to Submit a Winning Proposal
Web 2.0 Expo Ny--How to Submit a Winning Proposal
 
Engage Your Audience With PowerPoint Decks: Webinar
Engage Your Audience With PowerPoint Decks: WebinarEngage Your Audience With PowerPoint Decks: Webinar
Engage Your Audience With PowerPoint Decks: Webinar
 
How to make data-driven interactive PowerPoint presentations for operations
How to make data-driven interactive PowerPoint presentations for operationsHow to make data-driven interactive PowerPoint presentations for operations
How to make data-driven interactive PowerPoint presentations for operations
 
Episode 245: How Customer Experience Starts with Accessibility
Episode 245: How Customer Experience Starts with AccessibilityEpisode 245: How Customer Experience Starts with Accessibility
Episode 245: How Customer Experience Starts with Accessibility
 
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including TextThe Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
 
Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
Usability in Virtual Worlds (Metaverse08)
 
Red & White_TEMPLATE.pptx
Red & White_TEMPLATE.pptxRed & White_TEMPLATE.pptx
Red & White_TEMPLATE.pptx
 
MVP to MLP - Minimum Lovable Product
MVP to MLP - Minimum Lovable ProductMVP to MLP - Minimum Lovable Product
MVP to MLP - Minimum Lovable Product
 
Functional requirements: Thinking Like A Pirate
Functional requirements: Thinking Like A PirateFunctional requirements: Thinking Like A Pirate
Functional requirements: Thinking Like A Pirate
 
Emerging technologies: augmented (AR) and virtual reality (VR)
Emerging technologies: augmented (AR) and virtual reality (VR)Emerging technologies: augmented (AR) and virtual reality (VR)
Emerging technologies: augmented (AR) and virtual reality (VR)
 
Are You An User Experience Designer
Are You An User Experience DesignerAre You An User Experience Designer
Are You An User Experience Designer
 
082508 Kzero Metanomics Transcript
082508 Kzero Metanomics Transcript082508 Kzero Metanomics Transcript
082508 Kzero Metanomics Transcript
 
My Dream Vacation Essay Paris
My Dream Vacation Essay ParisMy Dream Vacation Essay Paris
My Dream Vacation Essay Paris
 
Outline Dream Presentatie
Outline Dream PresentatieOutline Dream Presentatie
Outline Dream Presentatie
 
10 Page Essay
10 Page Essay10 Page Essay
10 Page Essay
 
10 Page Essay
10 Page Essay10 Page Essay
10 Page Essay
 
Perfect Pitch Deck Template
Perfect Pitch Deck TemplatePerfect Pitch Deck Template
Perfect Pitch Deck Template
 
Interactive XAI for ODSC East 2023
Interactive XAI for ODSC East 2023Interactive XAI for ODSC East 2023
Interactive XAI for ODSC East 2023
 
Notes From User Experience Week 2008
Notes From User Experience Week 2008Notes From User Experience Week 2008
Notes From User Experience Week 2008
 
Nicole Glaros - Rocking the elevator pitch
Nicole Glaros - Rocking the elevator pitchNicole Glaros - Rocking the elevator pitch
Nicole Glaros - Rocking the elevator pitch
 

Mehr von Siterma The World In 4D

SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt LindenSLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
Siterma The World In 4D
 

Mehr von Siterma The World In 4D (20)

Sustainable Event Production in Second Life®
Sustainable Event Production in Second Life®Sustainable Event Production in Second Life®
Sustainable Event Production in Second Life®
 
SLIDES & NOTES - VWBPE - Composing in the Hybrid Metaverse 23,24,25-Mar-2023.pdf
SLIDES & NOTES - VWBPE - Composing in the Hybrid Metaverse 23,24,25-Mar-2023.pdfSLIDES & NOTES - VWBPE - Composing in the Hybrid Metaverse 23,24,25-Mar-2023.pdf
SLIDES & NOTES - VWBPE - Composing in the Hybrid Metaverse 23,24,25-Mar-2023.pdf
 
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Slides Only
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Slides OnlyTeamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Slides Only
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Slides Only
 
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Speaker's Notes
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Speaker's NotesTeamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Speaker's Notes
Teamwork & Collaboration Online 18-Feb-2021 - Speaker's Notes
 
2662 pulse story 09 jun-2020
2662 pulse story 09 jun-20202662 pulse story 09 jun-2020
2662 pulse story 09 jun-2020
 
Final report sine space mini user case study 28-apr-2020
Final report   sine space mini user case study 28-apr-2020Final report   sine space mini user case study 28-apr-2020
Final report sine space mini user case study 28-apr-2020
 
Living Structures in Second Life Virtual Worlds Projects
Living Structures in Second Life Virtual Worlds ProjectsLiving Structures in Second Life Virtual Worlds Projects
Living Structures in Second Life Virtual Worlds Projects
 
Team Operations Tips IOLE Autumn 2017
Team Operations Tips IOLE Autumn 2017Team Operations Tips IOLE Autumn 2017
Team Operations Tips IOLE Autumn 2017
 
Sitearm - Presentation Tips For Virtual Collaboration Projects
Sitearm - Presentation Tips For Virtual Collaboration ProjectsSitearm - Presentation Tips For Virtual Collaboration Projects
Sitearm - Presentation Tips For Virtual Collaboration Projects
 
"Is One Life Enough" (IOLE) Professional Social Media Course
"Is One Life Enough" (IOLE) Professional Social Media Course"Is One Life Enough" (IOLE) Professional Social Media Course
"Is One Life Enough" (IOLE) Professional Social Media Course
 
"Military Open Simulator Enterprise Strategy (MOSES)" Community
"Military Open Simulator Enterprise Strategy (MOSES)" Community"Military Open Simulator Enterprise Strategy (MOSES)" Community
"Military Open Simulator Enterprise Strategy (MOSES)" Community
 
(DSG) Distributed Scene Graph technology for (MOSES) Military Open Simulator ...
(DSG) Distributed Scene Graph technology for (MOSES) Military Open Simulator ...(DSG) Distributed Scene Graph technology for (MOSES) Military Open Simulator ...
(DSG) Distributed Scene Graph technology for (MOSES) Military Open Simulator ...
 
Content creation examples and tips
Content creation examples and tipsContent creation examples and tips
Content creation examples and tips
 
Virtual collaboration tips and tools
Virtual collaboration tips and toolsVirtual collaboration tips and tools
Virtual collaboration tips and tools
 
Sitearm - Introduction to Avatar Role Play
Sitearm - Introduction to Avatar Role PlaySitearm - Introduction to Avatar Role Play
Sitearm - Introduction to Avatar Role Play
 
Sitearm - Supporting Teaching in Virtual Worlds
Sitearm - Supporting Teaching in Virtual WorldsSitearm - Supporting Teaching in Virtual Worlds
Sitearm - Supporting Teaching in Virtual Worlds
 
Working Together in Virtual Worlds 19 apr-2012 SITEARM
Working Together in Virtual Worlds 19 apr-2012 SITEARMWorking Together in Virtual Worlds 19 apr-2012 SITEARM
Working Together in Virtual Worlds 19 apr-2012 SITEARM
 
Sitearm - Virtual Collaboration Tool And Project Tips
Sitearm - Virtual Collaboration Tool And Project TipsSitearm - Virtual Collaboration Tool And Project Tips
Sitearm - Virtual Collaboration Tool And Project Tips
 
SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt LindenSLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
SLCC 2011 - The Future of Commerce in Second Life by Jeff Vogt - SL Vogt Linden
 
SLCC 2011 - How SL Businesses and Non-Profits Work Together for a Mutually Be...
SLCC 2011 - How SL Businesses and Non-Profits Work Together for a Mutually Be...SLCC 2011 - How SL Businesses and Non-Profits Work Together for a Mutually Be...
SLCC 2011 - How SL Businesses and Non-Profits Work Together for a Mutually Be...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
Health
 
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdfSociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
SocioCosmos
 
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
Heena Escort Service
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
ZurliaSoop
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
ZurliaSoop
 
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdfCapstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
eliklein8
 
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdfCapstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
eliklein8
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
💊💊 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN SEMARANG 087776-558899 ABORSI KLINIK SEMARANG
 
Kayamkulam Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Kayamkulam Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsKayamkulam Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Kayamkulam Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Coorg Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Coorg Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsCoorg Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Coorg Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
SEO Expert in USA - 5 Ways to Improve Your Local Ranking - Macaw Digital.pdf
SEO Expert in USA - 5 Ways to Improve Your Local Ranking - Macaw Digital.pdfSEO Expert in USA - 5 Ways to Improve Your Local Ranking - Macaw Digital.pdf
SEO Expert in USA - 5 Ways to Improve Your Local Ranking - Macaw Digital.pdf
 
Madikeri Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Madikeri Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsMadikeri Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Madikeri Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
JUAL PILL CYTOTEC PALOPO SULAWESI 087776558899 OBAT PENGGUGUR KANDUNGAN PALOP...
 
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
+971565801893>> ORIGINAL CYTOTEC ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHABI<<
 
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdfSociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
Sociocosmos empowers you to go trendy on social media with a few clicks..pdf
 
Content strategy : Content empire and cash in
Content strategy : Content empire and cash inContent strategy : Content empire and cash in
Content strategy : Content empire and cash in
 
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
Meet Incall & Out Escort Service in D -9634446618 | #escort Service in GTB Na...
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
Jual Obat Aborsi Palu ( Taiwan No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan C...
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
Jual Obat Aborsi Kudus ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cy...
 
Jhunjhunu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Jhunjhunu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsJhunjhunu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Jhunjhunu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Sri Ganganagar Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Sri Ganganagar Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsSri Ganganagar Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Sri Ganganagar Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Marketing Plan - Social Media. The Sparks Foundation
Marketing Plan -  Social Media. The Sparks FoundationMarketing Plan -  Social Media. The Sparks Foundation
Marketing Plan - Social Media. The Sparks Foundation
 
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdfCapstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone project part 2.pdf
 
Enhancing Consumer Trust Through Strategic Content Marketing
Enhancing Consumer Trust Through Strategic Content MarketingEnhancing Consumer Trust Through Strategic Content Marketing
Enhancing Consumer Trust Through Strategic Content Marketing
 
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdfCapstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
Capstone slidedeck for my capstone final edition.pdf
 
The Butterfly Effect
The Butterfly EffectThe Butterfly Effect
The Butterfly Effect
 
BVG BEACH CLEANING PROJECTS- ORISSA , ANDAMAN, PORT BLAIR
BVG BEACH CLEANING PROJECTS- ORISSA , ANDAMAN, PORT BLAIRBVG BEACH CLEANING PROJECTS- ORISSA , ANDAMAN, PORT BLAIR
BVG BEACH CLEANING PROJECTS- ORISSA , ANDAMAN, PORT BLAIR
 

SLIDES w. NOTES - Extended Metaverse Workshop in Zoom OSCC 2022.pdf

  • 1. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop This presentation will give multiple operational definitions of the metaverse for those actively using communication and collaboration technologies. Participants will be able to adapt and build on the material for their own areas of expertise. Agenda ● “Operational Definition” and Examples ● “Canonical Metaverse” and Examples ● “Extended Metaverse” and Examples ● Dialogue and New Options Presenter: James G Neville (Sitearm), Owner, Development One LLC, Independent Consultancy Specializing in Online Presence Experience: Corporate 25 years, Entrepreneurial 20 years Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop Welcome to the Extended Metaverse Workshop in Zoom. This presentation will give multiple operational definitions of the metaverse to adapt and build on for your area of expertise My offline name is James and my online name is Sitearm. I am a practitioner in applied online presence. I have 25 years corporate experience in analysis and business and 20 years entrepreneurial experience in entertainment and arts. Today we will cover Operational Definition, Canonical Metaverse, and Extended Metaverse; then segue into Dialogue to create new options and ideas for use going forward. Please have something to write with and something to write on, and jot down your thoughts throughout the presentation.
  • 2. Protocols Data will be presented in voice and image. Please use text chat for questions and when asked for responses. As time allows, voice will be enabled as well. I will call you by your screen name. The stream will be moderated and recorded. At close of recording, you are welcome to stay and dialogue further. We will start and end on time. Part One - Data 2 Agenda 5 Animation 20 Presentation Part Two - Reflection 5 Prompts Part Three - Dialogue 5 Animation 20 Roundtable 3 Debrief Timeline (nominal) and Protocols Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Timeline (nominal) and Protocols Our timeline is Data, Reflection, Dialogue. Data will be presented in voice and image. Reflection will be in self-written notes. Dialogue will be in text chat and voice. Please use text chat for questions and when asked for responses. As time allows, voice will be enabled as well. I will call you by your screen name. The stream will be moderated and recorded. At close of recording, you are welcome to stay and dialogue further. We will start and end on time.
  • 3. We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the mind and awareness. 1. Take a breath. 2. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable. 3. Watch and listen to the following animation. 4. Notice thoughts and sensations. Animation Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Animation We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the mind and awareness. So… Take a breath. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable. Watch and listen to the following animation. Notice thoughts and sensations. PLAY Possibility Four pp01 - 3663 556 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMSJ80gb5BY
  • 4. Part One - Data People do not agree on the metaverse. Isn’t the metaverse just a bunch of cartoon characters? Isn’t the metaverse just another big company scheme to make money and steal our personal information? Is the metaverse really a thing? Should we even take it seriously? Does it matter, economically? Does it matter, socially? Does it matter, academically? Do I have a say in what the metaverse is and what it is for? What is the government doing about it and do we even want to know? Is OpenSimulator a metaverse? Is Zoom a metaverse? Is a Door a metaverse? What are the minimum requirements to qualify as a metaverse? Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Part One - Data People do not agree on the metaverse. Isn’t the metaverse just a bunch of cartoon characters? Isn’t the metaverse just another big company scheme to make money and steal our personal information? Is the metaverse really a thing? Should we even take it seriously? Is OpenSimulator a metaverse? Is Zoom a metaverse? Is a Door a metaverse? What are the minimum requirements to qualify as a metaverse?
  • 5. Example: “The Metaverse is a Hustle” Image courtesy F Minus Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “The Metaverse is a Hustle” This cartoon shows two moviegoers who have paid for “4D glasses” so that they will experience the “illusion of the passage of time.” One of them appears to be skeptical. Does this remind you of anything?
  • 6. Example: “The Metaverse is Like a Hat” Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “The Metaverse is Like a Hat” This diagram shows that 3D and 2D online content both require an electronic infrastructure to deliver them. Yet pride of emphasis is given to 3D and the rest is deemphasized. Does this remind you of anything?
  • 7. Example: “Alexander Graham Bell Invented the Metaverse” Image courtesy Pinterest Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “Alexander Graham Bell Invented the Metaverse” This photograph shows a bizarre mashup of technologies required to create a 1900’s working caricature of a modern phone. Does this remind you of anything?
  • 8. Example: “We Are Already Living in the Metaverse” The metaverse is reality in the digital age. The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user, co-creative, instant access. ● Cable (wire) ● Radio (wireless) ● Device (desktop, mobile) ● Platform (operating system) ● App (code) Earth's Submarine Fiber Optic Cable Network Image courtesy T Morgan-Wall Mobile Network Towers Image courtesy Science ABC Image courtesy Statista.com Favorite social media platforms in Spain (2018 to 2022) Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “We Are Already Living in the Metaverse” This slide shows two definitions of the metaverse: The metaverse is reality in the digital age. The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user, co-creative, instant access. The first definition is a bit grandiose and the second a bit idealistic, although more specific. Do these remind you of anything?
  • 9. Operational Definitions Change Concepts Into Measurements "An operational definition is a procedure agreed upon for translation of a concept into measurement of some kind." There is no true value of any characteristic, state, or condition that is defined in terms of measurement or observation. Change of procedure for measurement (change of operational definition) or observation produces a new number." W. Edwards Deming, The New Economics for Industry, Government, and Education, 1994 Operational—Able to be used Definition—Formal statement of meaning Measurement—ascertained by comparison with a standard Change—many valid definitions Image courtesy T Hessing “I know it when I see it.” Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Operational Definitions Change Concepts Into Measurements The last slide said, “The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user, co-creative, instant access.” This is an example of an Operational Definition. An Operational Definition Changes a Concept Into a Measurement The business consultant and statistician, W Edwards Deming, helped the Japanese automobile industry become world-class in the 1950’s. Deming changed grandiose concepts of “quality” into specific measures. Deming stated that no concept is usable, in practice, until it has been translated into a measurement procedure that can be observed and reported. This means that you can ask yes / no questions about the concept, supported by numbers. For example, regarding the definition of metaverse that it has “instant access”...
  • 10. . Traditional Email would be OUT as a metaverse. . Instant Messaging would be IN. Deming emphasized that if you change the yes / no questions that are being asked, then you are changing the operational definition. In particular, there can be more than one valid definition.
  • 11. Example: Chair Has More Than One Valid Definition “chair” 1. A seat for one person having four legs and a backrest. 2. Something that supports like a chair. “Lady Chair” image courtesy R Alekseev “Bean Bag Chair” image courtesy Wayfair definition courtesy Dictionary.com “I know a chair when I see it.” Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: Chair Has More Than One Valid Definition According to Dictionary.com, “A chair is a seat for one person with four legs and a backrest.” The picture on the left shows a “Lady Chair” with 4 legs but with the front two legs crossed. This meets the definition but does not look comfortable to sit on. The picture on the right shows a “Bean Bag Chair” with no legs at all. But you can sit on it and it looks more comfortable. It also looks harder to move. Dictionary.com also says, “A chair is something that supports (like a chair).” So there are multiple Operational Definitions for “Chair” distinguished by yes / no questions such as: . Four Legs? Yes / No . Backrest? Yes / No . Support? Yes / No . Comfortable? Yes / No . Easy to Move? Yes / No
  • 12. I give Lady Chair 4 out of 5. I give Bean Bag Chair 3 out of 5. Both are different yet both are (operationally) “chairworthy.” *humor* The operational definitions change based on the yes / no questions that are most important to your use case. Deming gives us good news and a warning: It is NOT an issue if there is more than one operational definition. It IS an issue if you and others you are meeting with are using different definitions and do not know it.
  • 13. Example: Metaverse Has More Than One Valid Definition “metaverse” 1. A shared, realistic, and immersive computer simulation. 2. A theoretical or emergent networked online space. “Hiro Protagonist” image courtesy I Medrano “Metaverse” image courtesy Catapult Digital definition courtesy Dictionary.com “I know a metaverse when I see it.” Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: Metaverse Has More Than One Valid Definition According to Dictionary.com, “A metaverse is a shared, realistic, and immersive computer simulation.’ Dictionary.com also says, “A metaverse is a theoretical or emergent networked online space.” So there are multiple Operational Definitions for “metaverse” distinguished by yes / no questions.
  • 14. Test Number One: An avatar is something you can see outside yourself that represents you. Can you see your own avatar? Test Number Two: A free camera allows a movable perspective of the virtual environment in which your avatar is immersed. Can you see behind other avatars and all around them? Test Number Three: Can you change your avatar, environment, and content? Test Number Four: Can you visit whole other regions made by others? Example: “Seven Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps” Test Number Five: Does the platform allow users to exchange in-world currency and real-world currencies interchangeably? Can developers make real-world money by participating in a virtual environment economy? Test Number Six: Does the platform combine digital and physical environments simultaneously? Test Number Seven: Does your use case require bolt-on hardware and software to make the platform work? Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “Seven Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps” Here are seven yes / no questions I find useful to distinguish metaverse apps. I give OpenSimulator 4 out of 7. I give Zoom 3 out of 7.
  • 15. Example: “Seven More Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps” Is the platform... Instantaneous (online), synchronous (two-way), and many-to-many (multi-user) interactive? Collaborative and build-and-create capable? Turn-the-crank ready (stable and expandable to many more users)? Does the platform… Allow users to communicate flexibly, including private as well as public, text as well as voice? Play well with other technologies and devices ? Is the platform… Accessible in terms of costs, equipment, and bandwidth? Secure in terms of your user identity and your intellectual property? Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Example: “Seven More Tests to Distinguish Metaverse Apps” Here are seven more tests. I give OpenSimulator 6 out of 7. I give Zoom 7 out of 7.
  • 16. OpenSimulator is an Example of a Canonical Metaverse “He’s in a computer-generated universe that his computer is drawing onto his goggles and pumping into his earphones. In the lingo, this imaginary place is known as the Metaverse.” “He is not seeing real people, of course. This is all a part of the moving illustration drawn by his computer according to specifications coming down the fiber-optic cable. The people are pieces of software called avatars. They are the audiovisual bodies that people use to communicate with each other in the Metaverse.” Image courtesy RO Ness Neal Stephenson, Snow Crash, 1992 Canonical—included in the books accepted as genuine. Digital Embodiment—3D, fluid, free camera view of recreated self, environment, and others. Tilia—software and services for virtual economies with ability to convert real-world money into in-world currency and back. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 OpenSimulator is an Example of a Canonical Metaverse OpenSimulator and Second Life is the Ur-Example of a Canonical Metaverse. It is Canonical because there is a book about it, “Snow Crash”, written in 1992. Think about your own experiences in OpenSimulator and in Real Life, as we read what Neal Stephenson said back then… *begin quote* “He’s in a computer-generated universe that his computer is drawing onto his goggles and pumping into his earphones. In the lingo, this imaginary place is known as the Metaverse.” “He is not seeing real people, of course. This is all a part of the moving illustration drawn by his computer according to specifications coming down the fiber-optic cable. The people are pieces of software called avatars. They are the audiovisual bodies that people use to communicate with each other in
  • 17. the Metaverse.” *end quote* A Canonical Metaverse provides digital embodiment and 3D, fluid, free camera views of a recreated self, environment, and others.
  • 18. Canonical (3D) Metaverse Platforms Counting platforms which roughly fit the classic Snow Crash definition, it's over 505 million monthly active users. Those include: ● Roblox (202M MAU) ● Minecraft (174M MAU) ● Fortnite (81M MAU) ● Zepeto (22M MAU) ● Avakin Life (11M MAU) ● Rec Room (7M MAU) ● IMVU (7M MAU) ● VRChat (4.5M MAU) ● AltSpace VR (1M MAU) ● Second Life (1M MAU) 0.5 billion is a significant (10%) percent of the world adult population (> 20 years old) Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Canonical (3D) Metaverse Platforms 10% of the world's adult population already use canonical (3D) metaverse platforms.
  • 19. Zoom is an Example of an Extended Metaverse “The definition of metaverse, now, is sort of a future-forward social hub, a space where avatars can meet, an ecosystem for connected apps. A VR- and AR-ready dream of bringing people into some sort of virtual universe that's as creation-friendly as a Minecraft, as popular as a Fortnite, and as useful as Zoom, Slack and Google Docs. The future of tech doesn't lie just in VR or AR, but in a mix of many devices accessing a shared online world, which may be more immersive and 3D than the internet you're currently using to read this story.” Image courtesy S Stein Scott Stein, CNET, 2021 Extended—made larger. Virtual Environment—A networked shared work space. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Zoom is an Example of an Extended Metaverse “What is the Metaverse” became a hot topic in public awareness and media because of A) The Pandemic in 2019 forcing people to communicate using “2-way” “instant access” apps like Zoom, and B) Facebook in 2021 renaming itself to “Meta” In response to the new “buzz”, Scott Stein, a senior technical editor at CNET, published a contemporary definition of metaverse in 2021. Think about the apps and platforms you use or see used, every day, as we read his definition. *begin quote* “The definition of metaverse, now, is sort of a future-forward social hub, a space where avatars can meet, an ecosystem for connected apps.
  • 20. “A VR- and AR-ready dream of bringing people into some sort of virtual universe that's as creation-friendly as a Minecraft, as popular as a Fortnite, and as useful as Zoom, Slack and Google Docs. “The future of tech doesn't lie just in VR or AR, but in a mix of many devices accessing a shared online world, which may be more immersive and 3D than the internet you're currently using to read this story.” *end quote* Notice the operational elements: . Connected Apps? Yes / No . Space Where Avatars Can Meet? Yes / No . VR and AR Ready? Yes / No . Creation Friendly? Yes / No . Popular? Yes / No . Useful? Yes / No . More Immersive and 3D? Yes / No . I give OpenSimulator 5 out of 7. . I give Zoom 5 out of 7 as well.
  • 21. Theorists Try to Cover the Bases Stylianos Mystakidis, MDPI, 2022 “The Metaverse is the post-reality universe, a perpetual and persistent multiuser environment merging physical reality with digital virtuality. It is based on the convergence of technologies that enable multisensory interactions with virtual environments, digital objects and people such as virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR). Hence, the Metaverse is an interconnected web of social, networked immersive environments in persistent multiuser platforms. It enables seamless embodied user communication in real-time and dynamic interactions with digital artifacts. Its first iteration was a web of virtual worlds where avatars were able to teleport among them. The contemporary iteration of the Metaverse features social, immersive VR platforms compatible with massive multiplayer online video games, open game worlds and AR collaborative spaces.” Image courtesy S Mystakidis The attempt, with what is certain, to make the uncertain certain, will leave the uncertainty as it was. Ancient Chinese Epigraph Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Theorists Try to Cover the Bases Stylianos Mystakidis (stee-LAN-ohs MYS-ta-KEE-dis), a professor at the University of Patras (PAH-tras), published an academic definition of metaverse in 2022. I find it a useful reference
  • 22. A Remote-Controlled Door Hints at an Extreme Metaverse Development One LLC 9 “Arm Balance” image courtesy Learn Genetics Image courtesy Amazon Smart Doorbell Smart Door Opener Image courtesy Amazon Proprioception—the sense that perceives location, movement, and action of parts of the body. Extended Mind Theory— technology becomes part of our minds. Internet of Things—web-enabled hardware that acts on data from its environments and human instructions. We extend our sense of self into the tools we use to express ourselves. These include medical prosthetics and eyeglasses, as well as bicycles, automobiles, and makeup. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 A Remote-Controlled Door Hints at an Extreme Metaverse The top picture shows a Smart Doorbell. The delivery lady rings the doorbell. The camera in the doorbell sends the picture to the grandmother’s phone app. The grandmother knows it is safe to open the door. The bottom picture shows a Smart Door Opener. The phone app can trigger the door to open. There is more. The top right picture shows a lady doing a yoga Arm Balance pose. She is using her brain to monitor her senses and her muscles to control her body, This is Proprioception—the sense that perceives location, movement, and action of parts of the body. What is the connection?
  • 23. The grandmother is using her brain to monitor her (electronic) senses (the doorbell) and is using (electronic) muscles (the door motor) to control her (electronic) body (the door). This is the Internet of Things—web-enabled hardware that acts on data from its environments and human instructions. This is Extended Mind Theory—as a prosthetic limb can become part of a body, technology such as computers and remote devices become part of our minds. The Smart Doorbell and Smart Door Opener are available now on Amazon.com This is the Extended Metaverse gone wild!
  • 24. When Was the Metaverse Invented? 1929 Link Trainer (physical flight simulator) 1957 Neuroprosthetics (cochlear implant) 1973 Cell Phone (Motorola) 1975 Microsoft 1976 Apple 1983 Apple Mouse (popular 2D visual interface) 1992 “Snow Crash” (portrayal of metaverse and avatar in text fiction) 1993 Mosaic (popular text and graphics internet browser) 1994 Deming (formal definition of operational definition) 1994 Amazon (most popular ecommerce) 1995 eBay 1998 Google (popular search engine) 1998 PayPal (popular e-payment system) 1999 Internet of Things (Kevin Ashton) 2002 Smartphone 2003 Second Life (popular canonical metaverse) 2003 Skype (voice over internet) 2003 WordPress (popular app for user-created websites) 2004 Facebook 2005 YouTube 2006 Google Docs 2006 Twitter 2007 OpenSimulator 2009 “Avatar” (popular portrayal of avatar in image fiction) 2009 WhatsApp 2010 Instagram 2011 Smart Glasses (Google Glass) 2012 Oculus (popular 3D visual interface) 2012 Zoom (popular extended metaverse) 2014 VRChat 2015 AltspaceVR 2015 Discord 2015 Google Becomes Alphabet 2016 Pokémon GO (smartphone AR) 2016 Sinespace 2021 Facebook Becomes Meta 2021 Scott Stein, CNET (contemporary definition of metaverse) 2022 Stylianos Mystakidis, MDPI Encyclopedia (academic definition of metaverse) Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 When Was the Metaverse Invented? The metaverse arrived without us noticing it. We don’t realize it now, until we look back: “Snow Crash” came out in 1992, thirty years ago. But that is also when The Internet became a thing. Ten years later, Second Life came out in 2003. But that is also when The Internet of Things became a thing. Another ten years later, Zoom came out in 2012. But that is also when The Oculus Headset became a thing. And another ten years later, Facebook renamed itself as Meta. Which brings us back to today.
  • 25. Recap As a concept, the metaverse exists in minds and imaginations. As practice, the metaverse exists in the multiple, physically-realized design specifications with which we create, communicate, and collaborate. These design specifications are called Operational Definitions. Sometimes our use cases exclude particular metaverse apps from being used in favor of others. And sometimes metaverse apps become so attractive we find new use case needs we never had before. An operational definition translates concepts into measurement procedures. There can be be more than one. The metaverse is an immersive, digitally embodied, 3D, computer-generated universe. The metaverse is an evolving ecosystem of digitally and physically connected apps. The metaverse is physical reality in the digital age. The metaverse is a persistent, online, digital environment, with 2-way, multi-user, co-creative, instant access. The metaverse is a bizarre new extension of physical mind into physical body and space. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Recap As a concept, the metaverse exists in minds and imaginations. As practice, the metaverse exists in the multiple, physically-realized design specifications with which we create, communicate, and collaborate. These design specifications are called Operational Definitions. Sometimes our use cases exclude particular metaverse apps from being used in favor of others. And sometimes metaverse apps become so attractive we find new use case needs we never had before.
  • 26. Animation We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the mind and awareness. 1. Take a breath. 2. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable. 3. Watch and listen to the animation. 4. Notice thoughts and sensations. Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Animation We will now watch a brief animation. The purpose of the animation is to help clear the mind and awareness. So… Take a breath. Sit up, stretch, relax, get physically comfortable. Watch and listen to the animation. Notice thoughts and sensations. PLAY Comfording Six pp02 2662 557 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7duNBrUFFoM
  • 27. Part Two - Reflection Before we begin the dialogue we will take a few minutes for self-reflection. Please have something to write with and something to write on, and jot down your thoughts for these for questions: Regarding the material you’ve seen so far… 1. What caught your attention? 2. What confirmed your own thoughts? 3. What surprised you? 4. What needs to be said that hasn’t been said yet? Type “ready” in chat when you are done ~~ Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Part Two - Reflection Before we begin the dialogue we will take a few minutes for self-reflection. Please have something to write with and something to write on, and jot down your thoughts for these for questions: Regarding the material you’ve seen so far… What caught your attention? What confirmed your own thoughts? What surprised you? What needs to be said that hasn’t been said yet? Type “ready” in chat when you are done
  • 28. Part Three - Dialogue Participants Questions What caught your attention? What confirmed your own thoughts? What surprised you? What needs to be said that hasn’t been said yet? Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 ~~
  • 29. Close and Debrief 1. What did you like about this workshop? 2. What did you wish about this workshop? 3. What can you use going forward in your own work? ~~ Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 Close and Debrief We will now close with a short debrief. Please respond in text chat… What did you like about this workshop? What did you wish about this workshop? What can you use going forward in your own work? This ends the workshop and the recording. Thank you for your participation!
  • 30. Selected References ● Favorite social media platforms in Spain in from 2018 to 2022, https://www.statista.com/statistics/765008/networks-social-preferred-by-the-users-in-spain/ ● Realizing "REAMDE"; how crypto empowers gold farmers, Robert Osazuwa Ness, Mar 25, 2021, https://newsletter.altdeep.ai/p/realizing-reamde-how-crypto-empowers ● Metaverse, Stylianos Mystakidis, 10 February 2022, https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8392/2/1/31/htm ● What is "embodiment" in virtual reality? - Virtual Bodyworks, https://www.virtualbodyworks.com/posts/what-is-embodiment-in-virtual-reality ● What Is a Smart Doorbell and How Does It Work?, https://www.familyhandyman.com/article/what-is-a-smart-doorbell/ ● Proprioception, https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/proprioception ● The extended mind in science and society, https://www.ed.ac.uk/ppls/philosophy/research/impact/the-extended-mind-in-science-and-society ● What is the internet of things (IoT)?, https://www.techtarget.com/iotagenda/definition/Internet-of-Things-IoT ● W. Edwards Deming, The New Economics for Industry, Government, and Education, 1994, 2018 ● Neal Stephenson, Snow Crash, 1992 ● Scott Stein, Microsoft, Facebook and everyone else are building the metaverse. Will you want to live there?, CNET Aug 2021 ● Tyler Morgan-Hall, Earth's Submarine Fiber Optic Cable Network [OC], Reddit, Sep 2021 ● Science ABC, What Are Cell Towers And How Do They Work? 2021 ● What is the Metaverse One pp01 C3663 556 SCORE, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1voZNLA3cE ● The five (and more) human senses, https://www.livescience.com/60752-human-senses.html ● Cognition and Perception: Is There Really a Distinction? https://www.psychologicalscience.org/observer/cognition-and-perception-is-there-really-a-distinction ● Metaverse Platforms Infographic: Now Well Over Half A Billion Monthly Users!, https://nwn.blogs.com/nwn/2022/10/metaverse-market-nick-mitham-infographic-q4-2022.html ● Q4 Metaverse Universe Update, https://www.metaversed.consulting/blog/q4-universe-chart-update ● DATASTREAM Visualizing the World’s Population by Age Group, https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-worlds-population-2020-by-age/ Composing in New Realms - Extended Metaverse Workshop jn: 15-dec-2022 Development One LLC 01 SLIDES: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1qs9DNQysArk8Pp2q5YoQdapkCDojcNkPCv JNjgSznhQ/edit?usp=sharing