Small Law Office Management for the Legal Professional
1. Small Office
Management for the
Legal Professional
November 14, 2007
Oklahoma City, OK
Shawn J. Roberts
sroberts@brownroberts.com
2. What is a small law firm?
A 2002 survey conducted by the OBA revealed the
following:
31% of respondents work as solo practitioners
43% of respondents work in law firms of 10 or
fewer attorneys
http://www.okbar.org/public/about/survey02.htm
3. Disarray
a mental state characterized by a lack of
clear and orderly thought and behavior; "a
confusion of impressions" untidiness
(especially of clothing and appearance)
disorder: bring disorder to
4. Chaos
• a state of extreme confusion and disorder
• the formless and disordered state of
matter before the creation of the cosmos
• (Greek mythology) the most ancient of
gods; the personification of the infinity of
space preceding creation of the universe
• (physics) a dynamical system that is
extremely sensitive to its initial conditions
5. What is the problem with loosely
organized chaos?
--high likelihood of costly mistakes
--toxic work environment for some or all of
people in the office
--spending more non-billable time than
necessary to accomplish tasks
7. 1. Decision-making Levels
→Create order out of chaos with clear and
consistent decision-making process
→Identify the different areas in which decisions
need to be made
→ Determine which decisions should be made by
which people in the firm
Purchasing basic office supplies vs. Purchasing a new
conference table
8. Management Principle:
Profession vs. Business
• Over 6,000 lawyers in Oklahoma County
• Many legal services are viewed as
commodities
• Adopt customer service principles from
other businesses
• Analyze cost/benefit of a client
9. Dealing with your law firm should be
marked with the following:
• Ease (relative)
• Pleasant
• Consistent
• Quality
10. 2. Staffing the Office
Organizing the TEAM
Refers to people who work at the firm and
people that provide critical services to the firm
on a regular basis – IT, banker, copier,
Finding Staff
11. Optimizing Law Office Performance
Know and recognize the role the staff plays in the firm’s
success
Value Add
Example
Recognize contributions to the bottom-line other than
billable hours
Staff is first level of contact with customers
will person make positive first impression
capable of handling intake information
Focus on skills not titles
13. Perform on the things you can
control
There are many things that are out of the control of
the attorney. However, being reliable and
responsible is ALWAYS within the control of the
law office. A fundamental element of being
reliable is meeting deadlines.
14. Why are deadlines such a big deal
in law offices?
Because often the consequences of missing
one are severe and not easily remedied
Avoiding malpractice
15. Elements of the System
Immediate & automatic calendaring of relevant events
Double checking of entries & notifications
Sufficient time for preparation and performance
Reminders to avoid missing deadlines
Regular follow-up
16. Things to consider in designing system
A. Who is required to perform the tasks
B. What activity needs to be performed
C. Where the activity will take place
17. Litigation Docket Control
System should include:
Statute of limitations
Due dates for pleadings
Due dates for motions
Due dates for briefs and other documents
Due dates for responses to discovery
Scheduling of depositions
Scheduling of trial or hearing dates
Notices of appeal
18. 2. Form Database
It is about LEVERAGE.
Doing something once but continuing to get
value out of an infinite number of times
19. • contracts drafted and/or reviewed,
• Petitions, Summons, Answers,
• Interrogatories, Requests for Production of Documents,
• motions for summary judgment,
• orders,
• legal memoranda,
• legal briefs,
• letters on topics such as collection, probate pleadings,
• divorce pleadings,
• tax documents,
• wills, trusts and powers of attorneys.
20. Necessary Elements
• A central storage place;
• Easy access for anyone wishes to use it;
• An index or sorting mechanism that allows quick
location and retrieval of documents; and
• A commitment by the law office to build and
maintain the database.
21.
22. Finding Practice Tools
What are we talking about?
Sample Briefs, Motions, Complaints and
Settlements
Forms and Contracts
Jury Verdicts
23. Places to Look
• Google it
• OSCN it
• For appellate briefs you
can . . .
– Supreme Court at Findlaw
– www.appellate.net
– Selected Federal
– and
– state courts
7th & 8th Circuits
Florida, Kentucky, Michigan,
Missouri, Montana, North Carolina
North Dakota, Texas, Wisconsin
25. Forms of Communication with the
Public
• Unified Presentation in all forms of contact with
the public:
– Face to Face
– Telephone
– Email
– Written Documents
28. What does this signature tell the
recipient?
• Precisely who the message is from
• All contact information to contact the
sender
• Unified message for all recipients
• All the information necessary to create a
basic contact
30. Components of File Management
System
• Preparing files
• Opening files
• Logging the contents of files
• Putting documents in files
• Getting files out
• Putting files away
• Closing Files
• Destroying documents in files
31. A documented file management
system tells everyone in the office:
• What to do when a new matter is
opened
• Where to find the key documents in
a matter
• Where to find a file
• Where to return a file to Sample Policy, p. 28
of written material
32. Color-Coded Filing Scheme
Red Domestic Relations Bloody & Heated
Green Real Estate Money & Grass
Blue Probate & Wills Sadness & Blues
Yellow Litigation Caution
Pink Business Matters In the Pink
Peachy Best clients favorite color Peach
Warren Miller, Institute of Law Management & Economics, OBA 1979
34. Items to consider when closing a
file:
• Are there any originals to return to the client?
• The Index or system that will be used to track
the closed files
• Where are the closed files going to be stored?
– Ease of access
– Digital????
35. Destroying Files
• The Oklahoma RPC allow attorneys to
destroy files
• RPC is not specific on how long files must
be maintained or how they should be
destroyed
• Consider the OBA Journal Article by Jim
Calloway on the topic
Closing Files, Destroying Files and Making Money, Oklahoma Bar Journal, August 4,
2007, Vol. 78, No. 21, pages 1979-1981.
37. 1. Digital Documents
How many people have a PAPERLESS law office?
What are some of the ways that your offices uses digital
documents?
How many people have e-filed?
39. What makes more sense is the “Paper LESS
Office™”
• Process focuses on turning physical paper
into electronic paper, while the paper itself
gets filed away and may not need to be
accessed until file destruction or closure
• Store docs as Searchable PDFs
• Connect them to Client/Matter files via
document management functions
• Instant access to the “digital paper” from
anywhere, anytime
• Stop wasting time chasing paper files
40. Ways that DIGITAL can impact the law office
• frees up storage space
– especially for closed files
• frees up time that would be spent
searching for and retrieving documents
• saves paper, reduces clutter
• review, track and label documents more
efficiently
41. Core Components
1. Scanner
2. Digital Document Software
3. System for tracking digital files
42. An example from our office
1. Xerox DocuMate 510
2. Adobe Acrobat Professional
3. Documents saved in file management
system built into Windows XP
44. Necessary Actions
• Create all documents as PDFs
The Lawyer’s Guide to Adobe Acrobat
• Scan all incoming documents as PDFs
David Masters
One more advantage: access documents
from any Internet-enabled computer
45. Practical Uses
Transfer large quantities of documents,
quickly, without making copies
Deliver a document to someone for
immediate review, regardless of where the
person is located: The handheld device
view
46. Richard Keyt: Simple Inexpensive Way to
Create the Paperless Law Office
1. I bought two Xerox Documate 262 scanners (one for each of us) for
about $900 each. It's about the size of a shoe box and sits next to
our flat panel computer monitors.
2. Each of us has Adobe Acrobat. I have the Pro version
(approximately $400) and my wife has the standard version
(approximately $250).
3. We networked our two computers using a peer to peer network. All
data files are saved on my computer. I make regular backups onto
DVDs and hard drives and store the back up media in a safe
deposit box at my bank.
4. We use Time Matters for many things, including document
management. It is $350 for the first Pro user and $200 for each
additional user. I've used Time Matters since 1998.
47. 2. Office Software
The Mechanical engine
of the law office
Makes the machines
run
Can either promote
efficiency or create
endless opportunities
for struggle
48. Suites of Office Software
Microsoft Office
WordPerfect Office
OpenOffice.org
Google Docs & Spreadsheets
49. Control the office software do not allow
it control and limit you. This means:
• Get software that people can use
• Get help if you don’t know how to use it
• Make the software do what you want to do with it
• Use the features and functions of the software
you have
52. Why written office policies?
• Increasing the chances a tasks can be
performed correctly and consistently
• Alleviating the need for the person who created
the policy to explain it each time
• Increasing efficiency by eliminating the number
of questions that must be asked about each task
53. Essential Policies
Job descriptions
Structure of office
Supplies and equipment
Office docket control system
Communications
Billing
54. Law Office PPrroocceedduurreess MMaannuuaall ffoorr SSoollooss
aanndd SSmmaallll FFiirrmmss, Third Edition,
DDeemmttrriiooss DDiimmiittrriioouu, ABA Law Practice
Management Section.
56. 1. The Management and “Control”
of Time
A. Implement the digital law office
Deliver documents digitally instead of with hard copy
A. Self-study. Consider spending one week recording
every minute of your office time, including trips to the
restroom and personal phone calls and drop-in visitors.
C. Analyze office staff to ensure that right people are in
right positions performing the right functions
D. Affirmatively address client deadlines and demands
57. 2. Return phone calls and
message
• Be reliable and consistent
• Return messages by end of the day they
are left
• Directly impacts firm image and reputation
58. 3. Managing People
• Listen to podcasts on management
– http://davidmaister.com/podcasts/
• Consider an HR consultant to address
issues that suck the life out of the office
– Low morale
– Frequent staff turnover
59. 4. Maintain a Contact Database
• Organize a contact database
• Allow everyone in the office to access
• Enter every contact you have in it – then
you will not have to enter it again or
search for the information
60. OBA Tips
1. Don’t let the staff get caught between dueling lawyers
2. Be Flexible
3. Staff training is a good
4. Do something nice and unexpected
5. Be careful with criticism
6. Everyone loves a bonus
Motivating Law Firm Staff, Jim Calloway, Oklahoma Bar Journal, Published 77 OBJ 3115 (Nov. 4,
2006)
61. Web Resources
• Jim Calloway’s Law Practice Tips Blog
• http://jimcalloway.typepad.com/
• Blawg Directory: Law Practice
• http://www.abajournal.com/blawgs/law+practice
• ABA Law Practice Management Section
• http://www.abanet.org/lpm/home.shtml
62. The Balancing Act: Time and
Financial Management
• Challenges to handling the Workload
• Avoiding systems that create burden
• Timekeeping and Billing
• Tips and Tricks for Efficient Time and Financial
Management
64. The workload can seem overwhelming when:
Deadlines mount with no plan for meeting them
Focus is on the volume of work rather than the
steps needed to complete the work
Clients are not informed of progress on project
leading to client pressure for completion usually
on an unreasonable basis
65. Planning to handle the work load
• Establishing reasonable completion schedules for major and
minor projects
– List the players and each players role
– List each component part that must be completed to complete the
project
– Get agreement from the team on completion dates on each phase
» Sharing the completion schedule with
clients
66. Gather necessary information from client;
Analyze information and determine precisely which documents
will be drafted (one to two days, performed by attorney);
Communication with client for follow up questions and gathering
of additional documentation (telephone conference with client by
attorney)
Initial drafts of documents (performed by legal assistant usually
one to two days)
Review of initial drafts by attorney (one to two days)
Send initial drafts of documents to client for review and comment
Conference with client to answer questions, discuss comments
and make revisions to the documents (within 10 days of time
drafts go out to clients)
Finalize documents, including making all necessary documents
and preparation of transfer documents (one to two days after
client conference, combination of attorney and legal assistant)
Document signing ceremony (usually within one week of
finalization of documents)
File necessary transfer documents with government and/or third
parties (usually within one week of document signing ceremony,
performed by legal assistant)
68. An office system might simply
increase burden if:
• No one in the office can explain why the
system is used
• The system is used simply because it “has
always been done that way” or “everyone
else does it like that”
• Execution of the system invariably leads to
frustration, anxiety, confusion etc. . .
70. 1. Timekeeping
• Different Methods/Same Results
Recorded with a pen and paper
Dictated
Inputted directly into billing program by a staff person
Inputted directly in the billing program by the attorney
72. 2. Billing and Collecting
• Bring another person in the office into the
process
73. a. Review the billing
• Print, distribute, review
• Revise
The billing is a communication on behalf of the
law office
74. b. Deliver the bills to the Client
On a consistent basis
Cumulative Effect Loss
At least once a month
Regularity keeps the office on track
Communicates organization, reliability and
responsibility to client
In the manner most convenient to
the client
75. Collecting the Bill – pre-invoice
The First Meeting
Written Fee Agreement
Periodic Updates
Establishing what to charge
76. Collecting the Bill –
post-invoice
When will the law office first contact a client who has
not paid a bill?
How far behind do clients have to be on their bills for
the firm to withdraw from representation or cease work
on the matter?
What type of contact will be used and when will it
occur?
How long does a client have before the law office (if
part of the policy) send a matter to a collection
agency?
77. Time Action Description
Within 30 days Track and record billing Track and enter time into billing program time
entries on a daily basis; keep client up to date on
fees; prepare prebills for review on thirtieth day of
billing cycle
Day 30 Review prebills and finalize
billing, mail out (bills are due
upon receipt)
Circulate prebills within the firm, review and make
revisions, print out final bills and place in mail to
client on first business day after final day of billing
cycle
Day 61 Reminder telephone call Office manager or collection supervisor calls
billing contact at client’s office to remind them that
payment has not been received
Day 71 Reminder Letter Simple letter from office manager or collections
supervisor enclosing copy of invoice and
reminding that payment needs to be made promptly
Day 86 Problem Call Office manager or collections supervisor calls
client to determine if there is problem with
payment of the bill
Day 101 Collection Letter Office manager or collection supervisor sends
letter requesting (demanding) payment on bill that
is now at least 70 days overdue and giving 10 days
to make payment
Day 117 Final Call Office manager or collections supervisor makes
telephone call to client to alert them that if payment
is not made the matter will be turned over to
79. Things to consider
Understand the Firm
Try out the Application
Get information
What is being used locally?
Stick with major players
Get training
80. Budgeting and Account Management
QuickBooks or comparable program
• Basic Accounting Program
– Acts as checkbook
– Use additional features such as payroll
– Allows manipulation data
• Control of Overhead
81. C. Tips and Tricks for Efficient Time
and Financial Management
Avoid tracking minimal costs
Credit Cards (with oversight)
Track all time during the month
83. A. Important of Building Strong
Client Relationships
1. Effective Representation
2. Trust
3. Satisfaction
4. Counselor
5. Repeat business
6. Referrals
84. B. Verbal Communication
• Setting a common objective
• Clearly identifying responsibilities
• Establishing schedules
• Stating expectations
– Define success!
85. Active Listening
• Stop talking and listen
• Remove distractions
– ELIMINATE CELL PHONES
• Make the speaker comfortable
• Give auditory and visual clues
• Empathize
• Be patient
• Ask questions
• Repeat – seek confirmation
87. Tips
• Signed written fee agreement
• Have someone proofread your documents
• Written Materials,
Communicate with the client about P. 100
the
case on a regular basis, in a form that the
client desires
– No substitute for face to face contact
• Understand e-mail – its limitations and
benefits
88. Building Rapport with Clients
Put new clients at ease
Find common interests and make small
talk
Continue to develop your relationship
Follow up with client relationships
Be consistent and frequent
Hinweis der Redaktion
Show old CLE presentations
Establish my credibility to talk about small law office management issues
-- nine years as attorney
--worked at three other places prior to starting current firm
--B&R founded on January 28, 2002
Talk about form of presentation: follows written material, with additions, HOPE to provide some additional material to what is in the written material
Attorney tend to be focused on bringing in clients and then doing the legal work associated with the clients. These two things are perceived as vital for the survival and prosperity of the law firm and they are. These tasks can be enormously time-consuming and energy draining.
However, the efficient operation of the firm is dependent on a sound structure. A firm cannot survive without the influx of business but it cannot thrive without structure and order. The absence of structure and is disarray or chaos.
Time spent planning and organizing is at least initially time spent not doing billable work. But the goal of proper planning and organizing is to become more efficient and effective, ultimately allowing the attorney to bill more time with less effort.
Process needs to be documented but also leave room for flexibility
There are at least two aspects to any law practice: (1) the profession, represented in the practice of law, which includes the lawyer as strategist, technician and counselor; (2) the business, where lawyer operates as a businessman
Many people are going to come to you with pre-conceived negative ideas about attorneys -- DON’T reinforce these ideas but rather shatter the stereotypes
My experience has been that it is easy for lawyers to ignore or miss customer issues while focusing solely on quality work – however there are many lawyers doing quality work, so that is not necessarily a distinguishing characteristic
Ask employees.
Ask friends and family.
Ask other practitioners especially in larger firms.
Review resumes from previous candidates.
Consider using part-time employees or even persons who are retired from other careers.
Role – look at term broadly, let people know that you value their expertise and contributions
Infrastructure functions that keep the office going – answering phones, technology,
VALUE ADD EXAMPLE: (1) right people in right places; (2) Ruth being friendly and putting people at ease
What is a good “office system”? (One that works)
Looking at Law Office Management Material from 30 years ago, I realize several things:
There are time-tested principle used then that are just as true today, such as, have a system that works and follow it
All office communication and procedure should be addressed – cover the details
Many systems and procedures have been passed from generation to generation of lawyers – some are solid but others are old, outdated and need to be purged
I am going to talk now about office systems and procedures and how having effective ones can reduce stress and tension in the law office.
Can you all give me some examples of things that cause stress or tension in the law office?
RMK Example
Find a system that meets the needs of your particular firm
VITAL TO ANY LAW FIRM THAT DOES LITIGATION
These type of documents can be particularly helpful to people that are actually creating the pleading by typing it into the computer
A position or native impression can be instantly created through a greeting by the office “Director of First Impressions”
Everyone in the law firm must be on board with the mission and participate with in it to make it effective.
Quality and consistent contact with everyone the firm come in contact with in whatever form the contact occurs
Includes the hard copy of files on clients and all digital documents in the office
Our office manager/legal assistant/secretary/receptionist implored me to say:
Filing is often neglected, but one of the most time consuming things in an office (looking for something). Good filing system begins with organization, whatever works for you but HAVE A SYSTEM. We use alphabetical system. Files put in one location by alphabet, saves time in looking up. Also, much time saved in keeping the file current while you work on it, not when you are done with it. Things need to be added to the file chronologically, with most current at the top and fastened down keeps things from getting lost. When closing out files, put them in storage by alphabet also, saves time in looking them up.
Process needs to be modified to fit your law office and it particular circumstances
The case file is the core of any matter, it is often the repository for critical documents, correspondence, pleadings, drafts, it is starting place for organizing a matter, updating a matter, working the file, etc. – The case file needs to be tracked in a logical and consistent way
An organized and documented file management system reduce time spent on frantic office hunts for the file or key documents
Mention sample B&R file policy on Page 28 of the Written material
At some point, unless everything is in digital format, you are going to want to get rid of all the old paper that is closed files. It will probably be when you run out of room in the office
There is more chance of success in reducing the amount of paper used in the law office than focusing
The quickest and easiest way to take advantage of digital is to keeping digital case files for current matters.
An example from my office.
To really get the most out of Adobe Acrobat read The Lawyer’s Guide to Adobe Acrobat, Second Edition by David Masters
Control the office software do not allow it control and limit you. This means:
The policy and procedure manual is the office playbook – it tells the workers what to do to accomplish the desired results
Not talking about HR policies which will be discussed later today
What kind of problems have you encountered with trying to implement office policies?
USE HANDOUT ON “Time wasters”
This was before there was EMAIL, the INTERNET, digital music players like iPods, etc. . .
Part of most of the legal and non-legal software packages discussed today
Have it with you at all times
How many people are in law office that sends bills out on a monthly basis?
Does anyone here every feel like (a) there is to much work to do within the allotted time to complete it? (b) the plan to complete all the work is sometimes fuzzy? (c)
A major project could be a piece of litigation with scheduling order deadlines, an estate planning project, the purchase or sale of a business
An office system need to be easily documented or explained, capable of repetition and it must actually add value to the office rather than suck life out of people
One of the central purposes of doing the work is to be able to bill and then get paid. The law firm that does stellar work without being consistently compensated for it will eventually be remembered only for its stellar reputation when it disappears
I will talk later about billing systems for small law offices, but regardless of the system or software setup an office uses, without commitment and consistency from the humans in the offices, the final product will not be satisfactory.
Give me some examples of timekeeping procedures in your office? Does it vary from attorney to attorney?
Attorneys may be timekeeping differently but it is imperative that all methods leads to the accurate capture of time spent on projects
I have had experience working with other attorneys and seen a lot of different billing practices – the good ones bill regularly
As it is with billing, collecting requires consistency and persistence
Need a written schedule
Not easy to establish and maintain but necessary
Need to not confuse the overall billing system with the software package that is used to track time and produce bills
Either QB or some other comparable program such
Credit Cards reduce administrative burden
A satisfying and successful relationship with clients requires effective communication both verbal and written
What are some complaints you have heard about the way lawyers communicate or don’t communicate with their clients?
I discussed some of these concepts earlier today when talking about collecting the bill but effective verbal communication is critical for a decent lawyer-client relationship
E-mail characteristics: (1) informal; (2) not usually proofread; (3) allows spontaneous communication, without time for reflection; (3) less precise than other written communication