Want to be known for innovative technical ideas? As patents become more valuable, it is essential for technologists to have a firm grasp of the basic principles of patentability and innovation. This workshop will introduce intellectual property concepts and provide opportunities for participants to explore concepts through tangible hands-on exercises.
1. Releasing the Innovator in You !!!
You've to add text takes
Click got what it
Presented by, IBM Corporation
National Society of Black Engineers
39th Annual Convention
March 27th – 31st, 2013
1 IBM
2. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
The IBM Team
Dr. Ruthie D. Lyle Eustus Dwayne Nelson
SaaS Project Manager Senior Attorney
Pascal A Nsame Stacy N Brown
Q&R Engineering SL Program Manager
Executive Sponsor
Drew Valentine, Esq.
VP and HR Leader, Dev & Manufacturing
2
3. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Abstract
As innovation becomes more valuable,
it is essential for technologists to have a firm
grasp of the basic principles of innovation and
patentability to address business challenges.
This workshop will
Introduce intellectual property concepts and
provide opportunities for participants to explore
these concepts
3
4. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Agenda
Topic Speaker
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
Opening & Introductions
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Slide Presentation
IBM A History of Innovation Pascal A Nsame
Q&R Engineering
Eustus Dwayne Nelson
Intellectual Property Concepts & Terms
Patent Attorney
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
USPTO Filing process
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Stacy Brown
Obtaining Value From Patents
Patent Licensing and Assignment
A Cast of Participants
Discussion, Q&A, Closing The Team
4
5. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
How are you using technology to differentiate your
organization and deliver business value to your client?
20 Years of IBM Innovations at Work
– Scaling innovation with creativity to address business
challenges of today and tomorrow while gaining insights.
5
6. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
2011: LASIK Technology
(1/10 IBM National Medal)
– U.S. President Barack
Obama recognized
IBM Research
scientists James
Wynne, Rangaswamy
Srinivasan and
Samuel Blum with the
2011 National Medal of
Technology and
Innovation
– the country's most
prestigious award
given to leading
innovators for
technological
achievement
– for "designing,
developing, and
implementing laser
technology that
improves people’s
health, including
LASIK eye surgery."
6
7. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Are you prepared for what is next, today?
History of technical Diversity
– In 1985, Dr. Mark Dean, and his co-inventor created a
microcomputer system with means for attaching peripherals
like disk drives, video gear, microphones, speakers, and
scanners. Dr. Dean holds three of IBM’s original nine PC
patents.
– Holder of 20 patents
– First Black IBM Fellow 1996
– Black Engineer of the Year Award 1997
– National Inventors Hall of Fame in 1997.
– Currently, IBM VP & CTO of IBM Africa.
Patent #4528626
Today:
IBM has 2 Black IBM Fellows and
9 Black IBM Distinguished Engineers
7
8. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Are you prepared for what is next, today?
Meet Osamuyimen Stewart
Chief Scientist, IBM Research-Africa
8
9. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Are you prepared for what is next, today?
"Let’s also make sure that a high school diploma puts our kids on a path to a good job. Right now,
countries like Germany focus on graduating their high school students with the equivalent of a
technical degree from one of our community colleges, so that they’re ready for a job. At schools like
P-TECH in Brooklyn, a collaboration between New York Public Schools, the City University of New
York, and IBM, students will graduate with a high school diploma and an associate degree in
computers or engineering." -Barack Obama, President of the United States
“Take a close look at monthly unemployment figures – specifically the requirements for unfilled
positions – and our nation’s fundamental economic challenge becomes clear. We have a “skills
crisis,” not a jobs crisis. In New York City, for example, the January 2013 Real Time Jobs Report
documents more than 300,000 unfilled jobs – nearly 1,000 at IBM, and thousands more at companies
such as AT&T, JP Morgan Chase and Citigroup.” - Stanley S. Litow, IBM
http://www.urbanresearch.org/docs/lmis_pubs/January%202013%20RT%20Jobs%20Report.pdf
9
10. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
National Inventor's Day
In recognition of the enormous contribution inventors make to
the nation and the world,
Honoring Scientists and the Congress designated February 11,
Engineers the anniversary of the birth of the inventor Thomas Alva Edison
– President Barack Obama who had over 1,000 patents,
talks with the as National Inventors' Day.
– Presidential Early Career
Award for Scientists and
Engineers (PECASE)
winners
– in the East Room of the
White House, Jan. 13, 2010.
January 13, 2010.
(Official White House Photo by Lawrence Jackson)
10
11. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Agenda
Topic Speaker
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
Opening & Introductions
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Slide Presentation
IBM A History of Innovation Pascal A Nsame
Q&R Engineering
Intellectual Property Concepts & Eustus Dwayne Nelson
Terms Patent Attorney
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
USPTO Filing process
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Stacy Brown
Obtaining Value From Patents
Patent Licensing and Assignment
A Cast of Participants
Discussion, Q&A, Closing The Team
11
12. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
United States Constitution
Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8
The Congress shall have Power …
To promote the Progress of Science and useful
Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors
and Inventors the exclusive Right to their
respective Writings and Discoveries
12
13. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Intellectual Property Primer
Patents Copyrights
Protect inventions that are Protect the particular
new, useful, non-obvious. expression of an idea
Owner has right to exclude against copying
others from making, using (e.g., copyrights
or selling patented protect the expression
invention for limited time, - but not the function -
in exchange for disclosing of computer code). Protection is much
invention to public. narrower than for patents but term is
much longer.
Trade secrets
Trademarks Protect business or
Identify the source of specific technical information
goods or services. Potentially for
very valuable: Provide customer Economic advantage.
recognition.
Protection lasts as long as owner uses
Protection lasts as
mark. long
as secrecy is
maintained.
13
14. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Utility Patents
Inventions
Process
Machine
Article of manufacture
Composition of matter
Must be …
Novel
Useful
Non-obvious
14
15. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Patent Anatomy
Teach the invention to the public
Abstract
Drawings
Specifications
Background
Summary of invention
Detailed description
Claim the benefit of the invention
Claims
15
16. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Agenda
Topic Speaker
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
Opening & Introductions
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Slide Presentation
IBM A History of Innovation Pascal A Nsame
Q&R Engineering
Eustus Dwayne Nelson
Intellectual Property Concepts & Terms
Patent Attorney
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
USPTO Filing process
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Stacy Brown
Obtaining Value From Patents
Patent Licensing and Assignment
A Cast of Participants
Discussion, Q&A, Closing The Team
16
18. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
USPTO Process
Three Major Players
Applicant
USPTO
Court System
Outcomes
Allowance
Abandonment
International Protection?
Yes, via the PCT
18 IBM
19. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
What is the approximate cost to obtain a patent?
The costs range depending on, the applicant’s classification, use of legal
services, etc
• Filing Application Fee (Filing + Search + Examination): $1,600
• Maintenance (renewal) Fees:
Due at 3.5 years: $1,600
Due at 7.5 years: $3,600
Due at 11.5 years: $7,400
Other Fees
Request for Continued Examination (.i.e. CIP)
Appeals
Extension Fees
Post-Grant Proceedings (.i.e. ex parte reexamination)
Revised Fee Schedule: http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/qs/ope/fee031913.htm
19 IBM
20. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Agenda
Topic Speaker
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
Opening & Introductions
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Slide Presentation
IBM A History of Innovation Pascal A Nsame
Q&R Engineering
Eustus Dwayne Nelson
Intellectual Property Concepts & Terms
Patent Attorney
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
USPTO Filing process
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Stacy Brown
Obtaining Value From Patents
Patent Licensing and Assignment
A Cast of Participants
Discussion, Q&A, Closing The Team
20
21. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Value of Patents to Companies
Recoup investment in research and development by selling
unique goods or services for a period of time.
License (or sell) the invention to enable other companies to go
to market with products or services which incorporate the
invention.
Bring patent assets to use in a joint venture with another
organization.
Build a defensive portfolio to cross-license with other
innovative companies.
21
22. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
The Inventor's Rewards
You are named as an author of an
invention
Opportunity to grow advancement in
technology
Some companies give bonuses for the
creation of IP
Some companies give commission for each
license agreement created using IP you
authored
Get a good feel for how to develop
valuable IP
22
23. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Agenda
Topic Speaker
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
Opening & Introductions
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Slide Presentation
IBM A History of Innovation Pascal A Nsame
Q&R Engineering
Eustus Dwayne Nelson
Intellectual Property Concepts & Terms
Patent Attorney
Dr. Ruthie Lyle
USPTO Filing process
IBM Master Inventor, USPTO Patent Agent
Stacy Brown
Obtaining Value From Patents
Patent Licensing and Assignment
A Cast of Participants
Discussion, Q&A, Closing The Team
23
24. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A Cast of Participants
Part 1: The Problem
Stacy encounters a problem cooking in a regular cooking pan. There MUST be
a better way!
Part 2: The Invention
Pascal develops a solution to the problem. Stacy will be delighted. As the
invention is useful, novel and non-obvious, Pascal later decides to file for a
patent. Pascal is the inventor.
Part 3: The Patent Application
Dwayne is an Attorney who was hired by Pascal to file a patent on the
invention. Dwayne and Pascal discuss claiming strategy and a patent
application is later filed.
Part 4: The Patent Prosecution
Ruthie is a Patent Examiner reviewing Pascal’s application. Ruthie resolves an
issue of claim scope with Dwayne and together they agree on an amendment
that will get a patent for Pascal.
24
25. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
Conclusion
“Genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-
nine percent perspiration.”- Edison
Reference Links
− www.ibm.com/patents
− www.uspto.gov
− www.google.com/patents
− www.delphion.com/
25
27. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
2011: LASIK Technology
(1/10 IBM National Medal)
– U.S. President Barack
Obama recognized
IBM Research
scientists James
Wynne, Rangaswamy
Srinivasan and
Samuel Blum with the
2011 National Medal of
Technology and
Innovation
– the country's most
prestigious award
given to leading
innovators for
technological
achievement
– for "designing,
developing, and
implementing laser
technology that
improves people’s
health, including
LASIK eye surgery."
27
28. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
2008: Blue Gene
◦ Blue Gene was
designed to meet
high-performance
processing needs and
is used for
simulations in particle
physics, materials
science and
environmental
research.
28
29. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
2004: Semiconductor
◦ In 1997, IBM announced it
would manufacture the
first chips using copper
interconnects instead of
aluminum. The new
material would make
microprocessors smaller,
faster and less expensive.
29
30. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1995: Re-writeable Optical Disk
◦ Three IBM scientists
discovered the special
magnetic materials that made
re-writable-optical-disk data
storage possible.
30
31. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1992: UPC Barcode
◦ IBM engineer George
Laurer's 1979 invention of
the UPC barcode system
revolutionized the retail
industry, and changed
the point-of-sale
experience forever.
31
32. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1991: RISC
◦ Today, RISC-based
microprocessors are
used in nearly every
computational device,
from smart-phones to
supercomputers.
32
33. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1988: DRAM
◦ DRAM holds information
short-term, speeding up
how computers access
and use stored
information. Computer
memory became smaller,
denser and cheaper.
IEEE Medal of Honor Video:
https://ieeetv.ieee.org/player/html/viewer?dl=#ieee-medal-of-honor-recipient-dr-robert-dennard
33
34. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1986: Hard Drive
◦ RAMAC (Random Access
Method of Accounting
and Control) was the
world's first "hard disk"
drive.
34
35. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1985: IBM System / 360
◦ The S/360 ushered in an
era of computer
compatibility for the first
time, allowing models
across a product line, and
even from other
companies, to
communicate.
35
36. IBM Workshop @ 2013 NSBE Convention
A History of Innovations
IBM Breakthroughs that have earned
National Medals of Technology & Innovation 10 Times
1975: FORTRAN
◦ IBM programmer John
Backus and his team
produced FORTRAN, the
first high-level
programming language.
36