1. Patents an Introduction
Pratt Professional Masters Program Seminar Series
November 30, 2012
Ruthie D. Lyle, PhD
IBM Master Inventor
Registered Patent Agent
rlylecannon@gmail.com
2. The information provided in this
presentation is for informational
purposes only. This presentation
does not serve as legal advisement
or an interpretation of patent
assets. For all concerns, please
consult a licensed Intellectual
Property Attorney or Patent Agent.
2
3. Overview
• Why should you
How care?
• What is a patent? • How is patent protection • Why should
enabled? corporations care
about developing a
What • How does a patent patent strategy?
work?
• How can inventive ideas
Why
impact the marketplace?
3
4. Patents – Enablement
When were patent laws first
considered in the United States?
What agencies enables patent
protection and govern patent laws?
Interesting “Patent Firsts”
4
5. When?
“.. To promote the Progress of Science and
useful Arts, by securing for limited Times
to Authors and Inventors the exclusive
Right to their respective Writings and
Discoveries; …”
The Constitution of the USA
Article 1 – The Legislative Branch
Section 8 – Powers of Congress
Signed April 10, 1790 by President George
Washington
Reference: http://www.usconstitution.net/xconst_A1Sec8.html
5
6. Enabling Patent Protection
United Stated Patent and World Intellectual Property
Trademark Office (USPTO) Organization (WIPO)
“to encourage creative
activity, to promote the
protection of intellectual
property throughout the
world”.
Specialized Agency of the United
Nations created in 1967, for
the express purpose of
governing international laws
that increase protection for
intellectual property, for
example the Patent
Cooperation Treaty
References:
http://www.usptocareers.gov/Pages/WhyWork/About.aspx
http://www.wipo.int/pct/en/texts/articles/atoc.htm
6
7. First Issued US Patent
"Improvement, not known before such Discovery, in the making
of Pot ash and Pearl ash by a new apparatus and Process“
The first patent issued in the United States to Samuel
Hopkins of Pittsford, Vermont in 1790.
Pot ash was used to make: soap, glass, etc; and was thought to
be a key aspect of the emerging chemical industry in the
nineteenth century.
7
9. Patents – Basic Nuts and
Bolts
What is a patent and how does it
work?
How can a comparison between a
patent asset and real-estate asset be
used to “get a feeling for” what
protection a patent provides legally?
9
10. …exclude others from making,
using, offering for Sale …
References: http://www.uspto.gov/patents/ 10
11. General Patent Format
Title
List of Inventors
Assignee
References Cited
Abstract
Drawings
Background/Summar
y
Description of
Embodiments
Claims
11
12. How Patents Work
For a certain period of time patent-holders (sometimes the
inventor themselves) are allowed to control how their
inventions are used, potentially allowing them to reap
financial rewards for their work.
• An Inventor conceives a novel, useful,
Conception non-obvious idea
• Patent prosecution process is
Prosecution successfully completed (US and/or PCT)
Patent
• Patent Issued
Asset
12
13. Comparing to a Real Estate
Asset
Generally, in real estate a deed defines where the
boundaries of a property begin and end. The owner of
the property can choose to negotiate a compromise or
easement with a potential trespasser.
At a high-level patent claims defines the legal
boundaries of what is protected in a patent. The owner
of the patent can choose to negotiate a compromise
such as a license or assignment with an infringer.
13
14. Patents – The Value
Why is a fundamental knowledge of
patent important to you?
Why is a solid patent strategy
important to companies?
What can we learn from the recent
patent wars we’ve read about in the
news?
14
15. An Example, in the News …
Reference: http://www.jdjournal.com/2012/07/24/apple-sues-samsung-over-its-android-technology-for-2-525-billion / 15
17. Patent Assets Enable
Freedom
of
Action
Patent
Assets
Licensing
and
Assignment
Cross- Opportunities
Licensing
Opportunities
17
18. Court Battles Go Way Back
Reference:
http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20121022/BIZ07/310229982/1234/biz07
18
19. Closing Thoughts
Personal Opportunities
A Neat Idea!
Patent Research Tools and Resources
Explorations on Your Own
19
20. Personal Opportunities
Enhance your
professional
credentials
Academic Tech
Transfer and Start-
ups Opportunities
Corporate
Employee Inventor
Compensation
Programs
20
21. Gorilla Glass – a “neat” idea!
Reference http://www.corninggorillaglass.com
21
22. Research -Tools and
Resources
Patent and Patent Application Searches
USPTO:
http://www.uspto.gov/patents/process/search/index.jsp
Google Patents: http://www.google.com/patents
FreePatentsOnline: http://www.freepatentsonline.com/
Check Patent Application Status
Public Pair: portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair
(including PCT applications)
Other Resources
Reference: http://www.uspto.gov/patents/
22
23. Exploration on Your Own
1. Practice using one or more patent search tools and
locate patent number 8,170,872. Retrieve a PDF
copy of the patent and complete a cursory review
noting the format.
2. Considering the more recent Gorilla Glass and early
Cabinet Bed patents, in the context of the capabilities
of their time, reflect on the tremendous impact
patents can have on the market place.
3. Read the online article, Apple’s patent war is old hat
by Susan Decker and form your own opinion on the
impact of patent litigation in light of US Constitution
Article 1, Section 8.
23
Good afternoon, I am …I’m thrilled to be hear with you to talk about a topic that I’ve so very passionate about.I’m coming to you with my own experiences and when you can share your journey, it alwaysSeems interesting.Please hold your questions until the end of the presentation, so we can ensure that all the materialIs covered in the alotted time.
What is a patent?How does it work?How is patent protection enabled?How can inventive ideas impact the market place?Career OpportunitiesExploration on your own
The first US patent board (post constitution) consisted of Thomas Jefferson, Henry Knox and Edmund RandolphPatent Term is roughly 20 years (can be adjusted based on particular situations and type of patent sought)The key is you have a monopoly for the idea for a period of time.
Wide variety of markets were impacted because of this idea.The patent grant you see reproduced above was the first one issued by the United States, to Samuel Hopkins of Pittsford, Vermont in 1790. Two other patents were granted that year: one for a special process of making candles and one for improved flour milling machinery. The Hopkins patent was for an "Improvement, not known before such Discovery, in the making of Pot ash and Pearl ash by a new apparatus and Process", and was granted for a term of fourteen years. The name potash refers to several potassium salts, mild alkalis, which were derived from the ashes of timber or other plants. It was also known in a caustic form when mixed with lime. In reacting with fats or oils, potash produced a soft soap. It was an essential ingredient in the manufacture of glass, alum (salts of aluminum--used chiefly in medicine), and saltpeter (an important ingredient in gun powder). Potash also played an important role in bleaching, mining, metallurgy, and other industrial interests. Its many applications served as an indication of the emerging chemical industry in the nineteenth century. In the summer of 1956, the Vermont Historic Sites Commission erected a marker at the former residence of Samuel Hopkins. The original patent granted to him still exists in the collections of the Chicago Historical Society.
Civil war fought from 1861-1865 between the Union (North) and the confederacy.Key Takeaway a statement about the inventive spirit:1)identified a need, 2)think of a fix3)then pursued patent protectionHow did she get the knowledge to go forward? If she can do it given her experiences what about you?
Answers the question, what are patent assets important to a company?At this point I’d like to remind you of the previous disclaimer. Our exchange today is moreto drive thought and reflection, and does not imply any interpretation or opinion of myselfOr my company (SMILE)
“The secret of all effective originality in advertising is not the creation of newand tricky words and pictures, but one of putting familiar words and pictures into new relationships.” Leo Burnett, Pioneer American Advertising Executive 1891-1971
What are you looking for?From PriorSmart.com (search for an inventor, Ruthie Lyle)Click on the buttons to the right to show how the site can interface to other sites easily.Compared sitesSearching for patent information is tricky for a number of reasons. First, different search engines provide different search capabilities. Some allow you to search for terms that are in close proximity. Some allow for complex combined, Boolean search logic (and, or, not). Some allow for wildcards so that you can generate a very expansive result list. In addition to all these search factors, there are differing options of searching through different fields. Some allow you to search through only certain fields at a time (title, abstract, specification, etc), while others allow you to combine the fields. This is why it’s difficult to come up with a list of “best of” list because they are all so different. Click on the links below to be redirected to the corresponding analysis below.http://trentostler.com/blog/the-best-of-free-patent-search/Boliven Canadian Patent DatabaseEsp@cenetFreePatentsOnline Google Patent SearchKIPRISPatent LensPatSnap.comPatentSurf.netSumoBrainUSPTOWIPO PATENTSCOPEBoliven
We’ve talked about:What a patent is, and how it worksWe’ve considered a “real-world” example to explore the value and importance of patent assetsWe’ve talked about why you want would want to learn moreThank you for the opportunity to stop by and have a discussion with you. I’m passionate aboutthis topic and find it to be a treat to be able to give presentations on this topic.