Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
Why Stock Brokers Earn Less than Real Estate Brokers
1. WHY STOCK BROKERS
EARN LESS THAN REAL
ESTATE BROKERS?
Manan Choksi
Regional Director
RE/MAX Mumbai Gujarat Maharashtra
2. Agenda:
• Stock broking current scenario
• Why real estate broking?
• What is a real estate broking business?
• What are the new trends in this business?
• How will real estate broking look in next 10 years?
• What makes a profitable business?
• The RE/MAX Concept.
3. What % of Net worth is in Real Estate?
Net-worth Distribution
Real Estate
Stocks
Mutual Fund
Insurance
Gold
4. WHAT IS THE NUMBER 1
THREAT TO A STOCK
BROKERS’ BUSINESS?
5. Stock broking current scenario
• Average Daily volume falling
• From a peak of 14,000 crore to ?
• No Differentiation between brokers
• Value addition to customer
• Internet broking eating in to market share
8. Comparison as an Asset Class
Equity
• Highly volatile
• Liquid
• Coupled with foreign
markets
• Market prices determined
by handful of FIs
• Inflation dents returns
• Not need based
Real Estate
• Stable
• Not easily liquid able
• Relatively decoupled.
• Market prices determined by
local economies and
domestic conditions
• Returns are hedged
• Every one needs Real Estate
9. Stock Broking
• No local knowledge
necessary
• Exchange is your network
• Low commission per
transaction
• Works 9 to 6
Real Estate Broking
• Local knowledge very
much important
• You require the network to
be built
• High commission per deal
• Works at his own time
10. Revenue per transaction
Stock Brokers
• Average transaction size
of Rs. 20,000
• Say a 0.50%
commission
• Total revenue: Rs.100
• So you need 2,000
transactions to get 2
lakhs.
Real Estate
• On a deal of 1 crore:
• A commission of 2%
• Total Revenue: 2 lakh
• On a rental transaction of
25,000
• Commission of 1 rent.
• Total Revenue 25,000
11. Return on Time invested
Stock Broking
• Upto the minute updates
on the stocks you trade
• Highly disciplined job of 9
to 4
• Back office work there
after
Real Estate Broking
• Less updates to track
• Work on your own
schedule
• Less number of
transactions so less back
office work
12. Why real estate broking?
• Name 5 National stock broking companies
• Name 5 Financial institution
• Name 5 Real estate broking companies
13. • Number of brokers in Ahmedabad: Approx. 10,000 active.
• Number of deals : 10,000-12,000 registrations a month
• Estimate of primary deals being done by brokers: 50%-
60% (increasing as number deals reduce)
• Investors from all India have invested in Gujarat
14. • With Tata Nano, Ford, Peugot setting up plants in Gujarat, real
estate is going to be in demand
• Migration of people to cities is set to grow: 70% of India still
stays in villages.
• Gujarat’s GDP is growing faster than the rest of India since 3 or
more years.
• 3 of the top 100 growing cities in world are in Gujarat
• Number 1 city : Ahmedabad
• Best state: Gujarat in Real estate transparency survey 2011
15. What is a real estate broking
business?
• Broker is a party that arranges transactions
between a buyer and a seller, and gets a
commission when the deal is executed.
17. What does a buyer want?
• Inventory
• Agent time
• Guidance
• Saving of his time
• Quick Closure
18. What does a seller want?
• More genuine buyers
• Get best price for his property
• Liquidate at the earliest
• Agent’s time
• Guidance of valuation
• Relevant buyers consider his property
19. Live Demonstration
• Each participant has one card showing number / alphabet
• They have to match:
• 1-A
• 2-B
20. Why a broker cannot satisfy?
• Getting and retaining best employees
• Training
• Advertisement Budget
• No Surety of Income
• Limited budget for Running costs
• Network
21. Why employees don’t stay?
• Employer gets the lion’s share of income
• Boss gives little value addition to each deal once the
employee becomes experienced
• Lack of independence
• Lack of Personal Identity
• Limited office growth
22. Get access to HNI/NRI clients?
• Get relevant training and provide good service.
• Get properties which they would prefer:
• 100% white for NRI
• Give a good ROI for HNI
• Provide a experience to client to gain trust
• Use technology extensively
23. How to increase deals?
• Give more options to buyers
• Employ more agents to serve the customer better
• Use technology to increase the viewers of the
property
24. TECHNOLOGY: HOW
IMPORTANT?
Example of A listing
Property with an excellent view over looking a river, sea and a hill.
Very upmarket locality.
3 bed room, fully furnished, good wood work.
Parking for 2 cars.
25. Technology: How important?
• Buyers require more information e.g.: floor plan, elevation
photos, views, amenities etc.
• Cost of petrol increases so buyers prefer to see properties
over internet and short list rather than visit each and every
option
• Buyers don’t have time
• Buyers can be outside city or even country.
• Buyers want to share information with others
26. What are the new trends in this business?
• Role of Media
• Resale properties
• Dependence on agents as plethora of options emerge
• Technology
• Foreign investments : both ways
• White money
27. How will real estate broking look in next
10 years?
• Earlier share broking was dominated by Mumbai based
firms
• Then regional stock exchanges existance
• NSE Came in to operation :
• Technology
• Risk Management
• Franchising
• Research
• Customer retention becomes the only important factor in
determining your success.
39. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
Established in Denver, Colorado (USA) in 1973 by –
Dave Liniger
The only internation
real estate broking
company still owned
and operated by the
original promoter
45. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
Business Model:
A business model working
successfully in more than
7000 offices and created
millions of entrepreneurs
worldwide
46. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
Only real estate
company to
feature in the book
“50 Companies
That Changed the
World” by Howard
Rothman
58. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
OFFICES IN AHMEDABAD
1 Mr. Vivek Parikh Satellite RE/MAX Metro
2 Mr.Nishant Makhija Vastrapur RE/MAX Real Estate Services
3 Mr. Sumeet Sethi Nehrunagar RE/MAX First Choice
4 Mr. Anand Choksi Satellite RE/MAX Advantage
5 Mr. Ankit Patel Memnagar RE/MAX Castlemore Realty
6 Mr.Tushar Gandhi S.G. Highway RE/MAX Vintron Gold
7 Mr. Chetan Parikh Ellisbridge RE/MAX Milkatz
8 Mr. Nikul Patel Sardar Patel RE/MAX Achievers
9 Mr. Manish Shah Maninagar RE/MAX Real Estate Experts
10
Mr. Nirav Vakharia/Mr. Harit
Parikh
Stadium RE/MAX REALTY SOLUTIONS
11 Mr. Manan And Chintan Patel Bodakdev RE/MAX Mann Realty
12 Mr. Bhavesh Shah Thaltej RE/MAX Property Center
64. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
AWARDS:
Among all regions of India North Gujarat won the
award for:
Best Broker Agent
Best Broker Office
Best Regional Office
Award was of return air ticket of Las Vegas to the
Annual RE/MAX Convention March 2012
65. REFLECTIONS OF GREATNESS
RE/MAX India
HOW TO JOIN RE/MAX ?
There are two options to be a part of the
revolution in real estate broking:
If you have an office or if you plan to buy one: join as
a Broker Office (BO) : Talk to Mr. Devansh Kothari for
appointment : 9879167987
If you want to work as a Broker Associate with a BO
then please talk to Ms. Salma Khatoon for
appointment: 9909066999