1. Lessons from the field:
An analysis of online instructors’
lessons learned about teaching online
Joni Dunlap
University of Colorado Denver
Patrick Lowenthal
Boise State University
2.
3.
4.
5.
6. We created a list of “lessons learned”
about teaching online courses
so far…
10. Data collection
• CiTE 2011, Denver, CO
• CU Online Symposium 2011, Aurora, CO
• Colorado Learning & Teaching with
Technology (COLTT) 2011, Boulder, CO
• ED-MEDIA 2012, Denver, CO
• EDUCAUSE Learning Initiative (ELI) 2013,
Denver, CO
10
11. Your lessons…
Now it’s your turn!
What are your lessons learned?
Go to
http://tinyurl.com/LessonsLearnedELI2013
13. Analysis of “lessons learned”
• Shared preliminary themes with conference
colleagues, modified based on feedback
• Review of results, seven themes emerged:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Preparation
Student support
Assessment and expectations
Structure and presentation
Engagement and activity
Presence
Personal impact
13
14. #1. Preparation
• Be prepared up front to be flexible
(expect the unexpected, no matter
how prepared you think you are)…
• Be well prepared. Quality comes from
advanced thoughtfulness.
• Have plans A, B, C... for all modalities
• Nothing beats preparation
• Technology fails. Have a back-up plan.
14
15. #1. Preparation
• Be prepared up front to be flexible
(expect the unexpected, no matter
how prepared you think you are)…
• Be well prepared. Quality comes from
advanced thoughtfulness.
• Have plans A, B, C... for all modalities
• Nothing beats preparation
• Technology fails. Have a back-up plan.
15
16. #1. Preparation
• Be prepared up front to be flexible
(expect the unexpected, no matter
how prepared you think you are)…
• Be well prepared. Quality comes from
advanced thoughtfulness.
• Have plans A, B, C... for all modalities
• Nothing beats preparation
• Technology fails. Have a back-up plan.
16
17. #1. Preparation
• Be prepared up front to be flexible
(expect the unexpected, no matter
how prepared you think you are)…
• Be well prepared. Quality comes from
advanced thoughtfulness.
• Have plans A, B, C... for all modalities
• Nothing beats preparation
• Technology fails. Have a back-up plan.
17
18. #1. Preparation
• Be prepared up front to be flexible
(expect the unexpected, no matter
how prepared you think you are)…
• Be well prepared. Quality comes from
advanced thoughtfulness.
• Have plans A, B, C... for all modalities
• Nothing beats preparation
• Technology fails. Have a back-up plan.
18
19. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
19
20. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
20
21. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
21
22. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
22
23. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
23
24. #2. Student Support
• Address all learning styles
• Champion the student voice
• Prompt and frequent feedback is a
must
• Give students choices
• Make sure your students can’t get lost
• Account for cultural differences
24
25. #3. Assessment & Expectations
• Have effective rubrics
• Grade frequently...if you don’t grade,
they don’t do
• Model what you want from students
• Be more concrete and explicit with
instructions
25
26. #3. Assessment & Expectations
• Have effective rubrics
• Grade frequently...if you don’t grade,
they don’t do
• Model what you want from students
• Be more concrete and explicit with
instructions
26
27. #3. Assessment & Expectations
• Have effective rubrics
• Grade frequently...if you don’t grade,
they don’t do
• Model what you want from students
• Be more concrete and explicit with
instructions
27
28. #3. Assessment & Expectations
• Have effective rubrics
• Grade frequently...if you don’t grade,
they don’t do
• Model what you want from students
• Be more concrete and explicit with
instructions
28
29. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
29
30. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
30
31. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
31
32. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
32
33. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
33
34. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
34
35. #4. Structure & Presentation
• Put information in digestible chunks
• Use guest lectures where appropriate
• Assign meaningful work
• Use technology intentionally
• Integrate visual components
• Be careful about “eye candy” for
technology’s sake
• Know your technology and make it
relevant to course objectives
35
36. #5. Engagement and activity
• You can never do too much to get
students to engage
• Create opportunities for students to
create community and solve their own
problems
• Give students the opportunity to
construct the learning
• Make a connection between student
career needs and assignments
36
37. #5. Engagement and activity
• You can never do too much to get
students to engage
• Create opportunities for students to
create community and solve their own
problems
• Give students the opportunity to
construct the learning
• Make a connection between student
career needs and assignments
37
38. #5. Engagement and activity
• You can never do too much to get
students to engage
• Create opportunities for students to
create community and solve their own
problems
• Give students the opportunity to
construct the learning
• Make a connection between student
career needs and assignments
38
39. #5. Engagement and activity
• You can never do too much to get
students to engage
• Create opportunities for students to
create community and solve their own
problems
• Give students the opportunity to
construct the learning
• Make a connection between student
career needs and assignments
39
40. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
40
41. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
41
42. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
42
43. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
43
44. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
44
45. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
45
46. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
46
47. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
47
48. #6. Social Presence
• Know your audience
• Be accessible
• Be kind
• Have a sense of humor
• Use synchronous technologies
• Show your character...personality is a good
thing
• Being present matters
• Create a sense of community
• Put faces with names
48
49. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
49
50. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
50
51. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
51
52. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
52
53. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
53
54. #7a. Personal Impact, on teaching
• The world is your audience
• I’ve learned how to use an iPad
• Online teaching isn’t about taking your faceto-face course materials & uploading them
to a course!
• It’s important to teaching faculty how to
teach online
• Use tools like the Quality Matters rubric when
designing
• Mini-lectures are better lectures!
54
55. #7b. Personal Impact, on time
• Teaching online can be done
anytime/anywhere, but it sure stinks to
be teaching while on vacation
• Don’t underestimate the time
commitment to teach online
55
56. #7b. Personal Impact, on time
• Teaching online can be done
anytime/anywhere, but it sure stinks to
be teaching while on vacation
• Don’t underestimate the time
commitment to teach online
56
57. “Lessons learned” = recommendations
• What are your thoughts
about the seven themes?
• What are your “lessons
learned”?
• What would you add, is
there a missing theme?
?
57
58. Joni Dunlap | joni.dunlap@ucdenver.edu
Patrick Lowenthal | patricklowenthal@boisestate.edu
Contact Us
Hinweis der Redaktion
Background on Stefan Sagmeister: designer, TED Talks, his Things I’ve Learned in My Life So Far project.
Stefan Sagmeister’s List:
Helping other people helps me.2. Having guts always works out for me.3. Thinking that life will be better in the future is stupid. I have to live now.4. Organising a charity group is surprisingly easy.5. Being not truthful always works against me.6. Everything I do always comes back to me.7. Assuming is stifling.8. Drugs feel great in the beginning and become a drag later on.9. Over time I get used to everything and start taking for granted.10. Money does not make me happy.11. My dreams have no meaning.12. Keeping a diary supports personal development.13. Trying to look good limits my life.14. Material luxuries are best enjoyed in small doses.15. Worrying solves nothing.16. Complaining is silly. Either act or forget.17. Everybody thinks they are right.18. If I want to explore a new direction professionally, it is helpful to try it out for myself first.19. Low expectations are a good strategy.20. Everybody who is honest is interesting.
Image source: http://blog.ted.com/2009/07/21/twitter_snapsho_15/
We were inspired by Stefan’s work, so decided to come up with our own list of things we’d learned about teaching online.
There were five of us: Patrick, Joni, Brian, Ellen, and Storm.
But over the years, I have found that feedback is perhaps one of the best ways to establish this connection with students.
So I am thinking of feedback in very general terms here as things like the feedback given on student projects, feedback given to students discussion postings (w/in the threaded discussion), and general feedback given to students about how they are doing in the class.
There are multiple ways I give students feedback.
Break room into 10 small groups. Each small group contributes one, and enters it in Google Docs.
http://tinyurl.com/3hgswvb