SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 24
Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?
Professor Tony Brown
Senior Staff Specialist
Department of Emergency Medicine
Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital
Competing Interests Declaration
Professor Tony Brown
Educational / research funding:
Astra Zeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, Roche,
Sanofi-Aventis, Shire.
Avant.
550,000
550,000
> 1 / minute
550,000
> 1 / minute
>150 this morning
550,000
> 1 / minute
>150 this morning
> 5,600
(MedlineTM)
Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?
Aims
• What are journals for ?
• What do they do ?
• Who benefits ?
• What are the problems ?
• What are the alternatives ?
What are journals for ?
What are journals for ?
• Registration
• Certification
• Awareness
• Archiving
What do they do ?
What do they do ?
• Online submission
• Peer review
• Editorial decision
• Production
• Publication
Who benefits ?
Who benefits ?
• Author
• Publisher
• Editor / peer reviewers
What are the problems?
What are the problems?
• Peer review
• Most papers are rubbish
• Research hijacked
• Restricted full-text access
What are the problems?
Peer review
“Slow, expensive, ineffective, a lottery, biased,
incapable of detecting fraud and prone to
abuse”
Smith R. BMJ 2004;329:242-4
What are the problems?
Most papers are rubbish
• “Words on paper rarely lead directly to change
– and thank goodness they don’t, considering
the rubbish that journals often publish”.
Smith R. BMJ 2004;329:242-4
• Few trials are valid and relevant ( <1% – 7% )
Haynes RB. ACP J Club 1993;119:A22-A23
Scott I, Glaziou P. Med J Aust 2012;197:374-8
What are the problems?
Research hijacked
Radcliffe Publishing
2013
Harper Collins 2013
What are the problems?
Restricted full-text access
$24 billion
biomedical publishing industry
What are the alternatives?
What are the alternatives?
• Release ALL data / publish negative trials
• Focus on the reader
• Post publication review
• ‘publish then filter’
• rating systems / Web 2.0 tools / crowdsourcing
• Educational / translational focus …
What are the alternatives?
Educational / translational focus
Websites Blog posts
Case studies Teaching videos
Podcasts Elearning modules
Apps
ALL informed by the best literature
Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?
Conclusions
• Not yet – but smelling badly !
• Return the focus back onto the reader
• Expect and embrace all forms of
post publication review
• Focus on education / translation
Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?
Conclusions
• Not yet – but smelling badly …
• Return the focus back onto the reader
• Expect / embrace post publication review
• Focus on education / translation
• EXCEPTION !
Emerg Med Australas 2014; 26 (1). Feb issue

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Brown: Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?

Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
André Tomlin
 
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publicationPublish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
Ian Brown
 
Personal strategies for improving your ref publications
Personal strategies for improving your ref publicationsPersonal strategies for improving your ref publications
Personal strategies for improving your ref publications
azlina kamaruddin
 
What is health chp 1
What is health chp 1What is health chp 1
What is health chp 1
spiller1
 

Ähnlich wie Brown: Is the Peer Review Journal Dead? (20)

Understanding scientific peer review
Understanding scientific peer reviewUnderstanding scientific peer review
Understanding scientific peer review
 
Getting your Rural Health Research Published
Getting your Rural Health Research PublishedGetting your Rural Health Research Published
Getting your Rural Health Research Published
 
BioMed Central , an editorial perspective
BioMed Central, an editorial perspectiveBioMed Central, an editorial perspective
BioMed Central , an editorial perspective
 
What Should PCORI Study?
What Should PCORI Study?What Should PCORI Study?
What Should PCORI Study?
 
2012 10-16 gettingpublishedslideshare
2012 10-16 gettingpublishedslideshare2012 10-16 gettingpublishedslideshare
2012 10-16 gettingpublishedslideshare
 
Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
Andre Tomlin - Using social media to communicate the findings of Cochrane rev...
 
Publishing Connect NUI Galway - 31st Jan 2017
Publishing Connect NUI Galway - 31st Jan 2017Publishing Connect NUI Galway - 31st Jan 2017
Publishing Connect NUI Galway - 31st Jan 2017
 
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publicationPublish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
Publish or Perish - A guide to submitting papers for peer-reviewed publication
 
Write for the AORN Journal
Write for the AORN JournalWrite for the AORN Journal
Write for the AORN Journal
 
Personal strategies for improving your ref publications
Personal strategies for improving your ref publicationsPersonal strategies for improving your ref publications
Personal strategies for improving your ref publications
 
Approaches to Peer Review
Approaches to Peer ReviewApproaches to Peer Review
Approaches to Peer Review
 
Predatory Publishing
Predatory PublishingPredatory Publishing
Predatory Publishing
 
WCACS2017 SOME.pptx
WCACS2017 SOME.pptxWCACS2017 SOME.pptx
WCACS2017 SOME.pptx
 
Evaluating medical evidence for journalists
Evaluating medical evidence for journalistsEvaluating medical evidence for journalists
Evaluating medical evidence for journalists
 
What is health chp 1
What is health chp 1What is health chp 1
What is health chp 1
 
CNUDST Workshops -Why quality articles
CNUDST Workshops -Why quality articlesCNUDST Workshops -Why quality articles
CNUDST Workshops -Why quality articles
 
Evidence based practice
Evidence based practiceEvidence based practice
Evidence based practice
 
Publishing Tips from the Field Nathan Grills
Publishing Tips from the Field Nathan GrillsPublishing Tips from the Field Nathan Grills
Publishing Tips from the Field Nathan Grills
 
Interpreting the Medical Literature
Interpreting the Medical LiteratureInterpreting the Medical Literature
Interpreting the Medical Literature
 
Pharmacology 502 fall 2022.pptx
Pharmacology 502 fall 2022.pptxPharmacology 502 fall 2022.pptx
Pharmacology 502 fall 2022.pptx
 

Mehr von SMACC Conference

CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdfCSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
SMACC Conference
 
Dilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
Dilating the Dogma of VasospasmDilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
Dilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
SMACC Conference
 

Mehr von SMACC Conference (20)

Precision Medicine in Acute Brain Injury
Precision Medicine in Acute Brain InjuryPrecision Medicine in Acute Brain Injury
Precision Medicine in Acute Brain Injury
 
CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdfCSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
CSD by Jeffcote Coda 22.pdf
 
Subdural Haemorrhage and MMA embolisation
Subdural Haemorrhage and MMA embolisationSubdural Haemorrhage and MMA embolisation
Subdural Haemorrhage and MMA embolisation
 
Andy Neill - More neuroanatomy pearls for neurocritical care
Andy Neill - More neuroanatomy pearls for neurocritical careAndy Neill - More neuroanatomy pearls for neurocritical care
Andy Neill - More neuroanatomy pearls for neurocritical care
 
The BONANZA Trial and PbTO2 Monitoring
The BONANZA Trial and PbTO2 MonitoringThe BONANZA Trial and PbTO2 Monitoring
The BONANZA Trial and PbTO2 Monitoring
 
Dilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
Dilating the Dogma of VasospasmDilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
Dilating the Dogma of Vasospasm
 
EVD Tips and Tricks
EVD Tips and TricksEVD Tips and Tricks
EVD Tips and Tricks
 
There is no such thing as mild, moderate and severe TBI - by Andrew Udy
There is no such thing as mild, moderate and severe TBI - by Andrew UdyThere is no such thing as mild, moderate and severe TBI - by Andrew Udy
There is no such thing as mild, moderate and severe TBI - by Andrew Udy
 
TBI Debate - Mild, moderate and severe categories work
TBI Debate - Mild, moderate and severe categories workTBI Debate - Mild, moderate and severe categories work
TBI Debate - Mild, moderate and severe categories work
 
TBI: when to stop and when to give time
TBI: when to stop and when to give timeTBI: when to stop and when to give time
TBI: when to stop and when to give time
 
Ketamine in Brain Injury by Toby Jeffcote
Ketamine in Brain Injury by Toby JeffcoteKetamine in Brain Injury by Toby Jeffcote
Ketamine in Brain Injury by Toby Jeffcote
 
Managing Complications of Chronic SCI by Bonne Lee
Managing Complications of Chronic SCI by Bonne LeeManaging Complications of Chronic SCI by Bonne Lee
Managing Complications of Chronic SCI by Bonne Lee
 
EEG and Status Eplilepticus by Tania Farrar
EEG and Status Eplilepticus by Tania FarrarEEG and Status Eplilepticus by Tania Farrar
EEG and Status Eplilepticus by Tania Farrar
 
Browne Neuro symposium.pptx
Browne Neuro symposium.pptxBrowne Neuro symposium.pptx
Browne Neuro symposium.pptx
 
Paediatric Stroke by Shree Basu
Paediatric Stroke by Shree BasuPaediatric Stroke by Shree Basu
Paediatric Stroke by Shree Basu
 
Hypertensing Spinal Cord Injury - gold standard or wacky?
Hypertensing Spinal Cord Injury - gold standard or wacky?Hypertensing Spinal Cord Injury - gold standard or wacky?
Hypertensing Spinal Cord Injury - gold standard or wacky?
 
Optimal Cerebral Perfusion Pressure
Optimal Cerebral Perfusion PressureOptimal Cerebral Perfusion Pressure
Optimal Cerebral Perfusion Pressure
 
The Power of Words - Death and Language.ppt
The Power of Words - Death and Language.pptThe Power of Words - Death and Language.ppt
The Power of Words - Death and Language.ppt
 
Sepsis and Antimicrobial Stewardship - Two Sides of the Same Coin
Sepsis and Antimicrobial Stewardship - Two Sides of the Same CoinSepsis and Antimicrobial Stewardship - Two Sides of the Same Coin
Sepsis and Antimicrobial Stewardship - Two Sides of the Same Coin
 
Brain injury outcomes and predictors
Brain injury outcomes and predictorsBrain injury outcomes and predictors
Brain injury outcomes and predictors
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
Sheetaleventcompany
 
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
adilkhan87451
 
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
Sheetaleventcompany
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
VIP Hyderabad Call Girls Bahadurpally 7877925207 ₹5000 To 25K With AC Room 💚😋
 
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
 
Call Girls Mysore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mysore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mysore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mysore Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
💚Call Girls In Amritsar 💯Anvi 📲🔝8725944379🔝Amritsar Call Girl No💰Advance Cash...
 
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on WhatsappMost Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
Most Beautiful Call Girl in Bangalore Contact on Whatsapp
 
Top Rated Call Girls Kerala ☎ 8250092165👄 Delivery in 20 Mins Near Me
Top Rated Call Girls Kerala ☎ 8250092165👄 Delivery in 20 Mins Near MeTop Rated Call Girls Kerala ☎ 8250092165👄 Delivery in 20 Mins Near Me
Top Rated Call Girls Kerala ☎ 8250092165👄 Delivery in 20 Mins Near Me
 
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉7877925207 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
 
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
 
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030} ❤️VVIP RIDDHI Call Girl in Jaipur Raja...
 
Andheri East ) Call Girls in Mumbai Phone No 9004268417 Elite Escort Service ...
Andheri East ) Call Girls in Mumbai Phone No 9004268417 Elite Escort Service ...Andheri East ) Call Girls in Mumbai Phone No 9004268417 Elite Escort Service ...
Andheri East ) Call Girls in Mumbai Phone No 9004268417 Elite Escort Service ...
 
Independent Call Girls Service Mohali Sector 116 | 6367187148 | Call Girl Ser...
Independent Call Girls Service Mohali Sector 116 | 6367187148 | Call Girl Ser...Independent Call Girls Service Mohali Sector 116 | 6367187148 | Call Girl Ser...
Independent Call Girls Service Mohali Sector 116 | 6367187148 | Call Girl Ser...
 
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
Dehradun Call Girls Service {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Dehradun U...
 
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Chintal ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Chintal ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Chintal ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Chintal ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Se...
 
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
 
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...Top Rated  Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
Top Rated Hyderabad Call Girls Erragadda ⟟ 9332606886 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine ...
 
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Amritsar Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
8980367676 Call Girls In Ahmedabad Escort Service Available 24×7 In Ahmedabad
8980367676 Call Girls In Ahmedabad Escort Service Available 24×7 In Ahmedabad8980367676 Call Girls In Ahmedabad Escort Service Available 24×7 In Ahmedabad
8980367676 Call Girls In Ahmedabad Escort Service Available 24×7 In Ahmedabad
 
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mumbai Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 

Brown: Is the Peer Review Journal Dead?

  • 1. Is the Peer Review Journal Dead? Professor Tony Brown Senior Staff Specialist Department of Emergency Medicine Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital
  • 2. Competing Interests Declaration Professor Tony Brown Educational / research funding: Astra Zeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, Roche, Sanofi-Aventis, Shire. Avant.
  • 4. 550,000 > 1 / minute
  • 5. 550,000 > 1 / minute >150 this morning
  • 6. 550,000 > 1 / minute >150 this morning > 5,600 (MedlineTM)
  • 7. Is the Peer Review Journal Dead? Aims • What are journals for ? • What do they do ? • Who benefits ? • What are the problems ? • What are the alternatives ?
  • 9. What are journals for ? • Registration • Certification • Awareness • Archiving
  • 10. What do they do ?
  • 11. What do they do ? • Online submission • Peer review • Editorial decision • Production • Publication
  • 13. Who benefits ? • Author • Publisher • Editor / peer reviewers
  • 14. What are the problems?
  • 15. What are the problems? • Peer review • Most papers are rubbish • Research hijacked • Restricted full-text access
  • 16. What are the problems? Peer review “Slow, expensive, ineffective, a lottery, biased, incapable of detecting fraud and prone to abuse” Smith R. BMJ 2004;329:242-4
  • 17. What are the problems? Most papers are rubbish • “Words on paper rarely lead directly to change – and thank goodness they don’t, considering the rubbish that journals often publish”. Smith R. BMJ 2004;329:242-4 • Few trials are valid and relevant ( <1% – 7% ) Haynes RB. ACP J Club 1993;119:A22-A23 Scott I, Glaziou P. Med J Aust 2012;197:374-8
  • 18. What are the problems? Research hijacked Radcliffe Publishing 2013 Harper Collins 2013
  • 19. What are the problems? Restricted full-text access $24 billion biomedical publishing industry
  • 20. What are the alternatives?
  • 21. What are the alternatives? • Release ALL data / publish negative trials • Focus on the reader • Post publication review • ‘publish then filter’ • rating systems / Web 2.0 tools / crowdsourcing • Educational / translational focus …
  • 22. What are the alternatives? Educational / translational focus Websites Blog posts Case studies Teaching videos Podcasts Elearning modules Apps ALL informed by the best literature
  • 23. Is the Peer Review Journal Dead? Conclusions • Not yet – but smelling badly ! • Return the focus back onto the reader • Expect and embrace all forms of post publication review • Focus on education / translation
  • 24. Is the Peer Review Journal Dead? Conclusions • Not yet – but smelling badly … • Return the focus back onto the reader • Expect / embrace post publication review • Focus on education / translation • EXCEPTION ! Emerg Med Australas 2014; 26 (1). Feb issue