SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 27
DEBATE 101
By:
Oktafia Rachmawati Putri
(Universitas Bakrie)
Session 1i: Debate In A Glance
Session 3: Motion Understanding – Case Building
Session 4: Constructing Argument
Session 5: Constructing Rebuttal
Session 2: Roles of Speakers
AGENDA
SESSION 1
DEBATE IN A GLANCE
Debating is…
•A clash between government and opposition team
•Developing communication skills
•Arranging, organizing and delivering effective arguments
•The objective of the debate is to convince the adjudicators (and audience) that your team is
the most convincing (through your reasoning, arguments and explanations) and therefore
deserve to win the debate.
•Debating requires sufficient knowledge, skills, willingness, and tireless practices!
• Asian parliamentary system
– 3 speakers per team, 7 minutes speech, with POI
• Australs parliamentary system
– 3 speakers per team, 8 minutes speech, no POI
• British parliamentary system
– 2 speaker per team, 4 teams debating in a round
– 7 minutes speech, with POI
Debate Intro
Debate Formats
• Affirmative/Government vs. Negative/Opposition
• Asian: Points of Information (POI) are allowed during speech
• Australs: No Points of Information (POI) are allowed during speech
• Asian: Substantive Speech: 7’20” | Reply Speech: 5’20”
• Australs: Substantive Speech: 8’20” | Reply Speech: 6’20”
• Speech duration and order:
1st
Affirmative (7’20”) 1st
Opposition (7’20”)
2nd
Affirmative (7’20”) 2nd
Opposition (7’20”)
3rd
Affirmative (7’20”) 3rd
Opposition (7’20”)
Reply Opposition (5’20”)Reply Affirmative (5’20”)
Debate Formats
ASIAN & AUSTRALS
• Issue or topic that you will debate upon
• Full propositional statement, not question or phrase
• Affirmative: defend the motion | Negative: oppose the motion
Motion
• Types of Motion:
– Proposal motion
• Concerned with practical problems. The motion ask the debater to
propose specific solvency to deal the problem
• Example: THW allow gay couples to adopt children
– Judgment motion
• Concerned with question of right or wrong. The motion ask the debater
to prove a general fact/statement
• Example: THBT capitalism has failed
– Comparison motion
• Concerned with two values in conflict. The motion ask the debater to
prefer a value over another value based on hierarchy outlined in the
motion
• Example: THBT free trade is better than fair trade
• Case: a complete set of argumentation to defend or oppose the motion
• Anatomy of a case:
– Set up: definition of a motion into a debatable context
– Arguments: reasoning why your team is right
– Responses: reasoning why your opponent is wrong
Case
• Matter (content) - 40%
– Arguments (logic, use of evidences, relevance)
• Manner (delivery) - 40%
– Public-speaking skills: vocal style, use of language, use of notes, eye contact,
gesture, stance, dress, impression of sincerity, and humor
– Personal attacks on opponents reduce manner points
• Method (structure) - 20%
– Structure: of individual speech and of team’s case
– Response to the dynamics of the debate
Debate Assessment
What do We Talk about on Debates?
SESSION 2
ROLES OF SPEAKERS
Role of Speakers
Roles – 1st
Affirmative
• Defines the motion (see the elements of definition)
• Presents Affirmative’s theme line = GOAL
• Outlines Affirmative’s team split
• Delivers first part of split
– Foundation of case (basic justification)
– For proposal debate: provide the complete model include: urgency of proposal,
model feasibility and how the model effectively achieve the objective
– Preemptive argument e.g.: how your issue should be weighted more than other
issue
• Summarizes/recaps own speech
Role of Speakers
Roles – 1st
Negative
• Responds the definition (accept/reject)
• Provides negation = A-
• Rebuts 1st Affirmative briefly (usually focus on the objective and basic justification
of aff’s stance)
• Presents Negative’s theme line and team split
• Delivers first part of split (the positive case of opposition):
– Foundation of the case (basic justification)
– Counter proposal if necessary (the model, feasibility, effectiveness, and brief
model comparison)
– In what way aff’s idea is not acceptable
• Summarizes/recaps own speech
Role of Speakers
Roles – 2nd
Speakers
• Clarifies/ reminds the adjudicators what the room of debate is and how
previous speakers fulfill their burden of proof. shows to adju if your opponent
fail to engage properly
• Briefly reiterates team’s case (in general) and shows how your team still has
upper hand
• Defends your 1st
speaker argument (answer the rebuttals given towards your 1st
speaker)
• Attack previous speakers
• Delivers 2nd part of split (the extension of your case).
Your extension should be distinguished from your foundation. It could be
analysis on other point of view/ other actor involved, analysis on various
scenario, deeper analysis on wider perspective, or further implications that may
happen.
Watch for: contradiction (your extension backstabbing your argument) and
additional burden of proof
• Summarizes/recaps own speech
Role of Speakers
Roles – 3rd
Speakers
• Identify the fulfillment of burden of proof from both teams, your opponent’s engagement,
and battle happen during the debate. Explain that your team still has upper hand.
• From each battles happen ensure the adjudicator that your team win those battles by
providing holistic rebuttals for everything given by your opponent. Arrange your rebuttals
for each battles so the adjudicators easily understand how your rebuttals contribute.
• Some important elements to be a good 3rd
speaker:
– Your main duty is to attack. Since you are the last hope of your team, attack
everything given by your opponents. Focus on arguments or responses that you
consider essential and could determine the winner of that round.
– Hinder unnecessary repetition. Sometimes you need to be creative to extend the
previous rebuttal. (Tips: use multilevel approach on developing your rebuttal). Identify
contradiction, hung case, and new matter.
– Be structurized! Always use sign posting to help adjudicators understand.
– 3rd
Aff is discouraged from bring new matter. 3rd
Neg is prohibited from bring new
matter. New example is not a new matter.
GAME
ON
SESSION 3
MOTION UNDERSTANDING – CASE BUILDING
Case Building
BRAINSTORM
CONTEXTUALIZE
STANCE
B.O.P
Wikipedia
Hard vs Soft
Disclaimer
Motion Understanding
THIS HOUSE WOULD CRIMINALIZE FPI
WOULD
1. Does this motion require mechanism?
2. Do we have to create a completely new mechanism or modify from SQ?
FPI
1. Does this proposal apply to the organization as an entity? Or should it also affect
each members of FPI?
2. Should we debate be about whether FPI is a good organization or not?
CRIMINALIZE FPI
1. How should the ‘criminalize’ be?
• Government ban the existence of FPI
• Stops any activities and anything related with FPI, and punish those who do
not obey
• Restrict any such organization (radical ones) to exist and grow (but WAIT.
We’re not going to debate that far!)
Motion understanding is helping you to get early definition
Case Building
A. Write down any relevant ideas and knowledge that you have.
B. Don’t be lazy! Think! Analyse!
C. Do this approx. 5 -10 Min Individually
• FPI = a religious organization
• Has been existing in Indonesia for quite long time
• All organization want to spread their values to attract followers
• All organization/entity should follow the country’s rules
• Country’s rules = don’t create destruction, do not force!
• Majority of Indonesian citizens = moslems
• FPI wants to keep the societies in ‘moslem’ values and tracks
• Society is okay with moslems’ values
• But, is society OK with what FPI usually does?
• Government has responsibility to protect society
• Government has obligation not to limit the society’s freedom of expressions
• There is no special mechanisms for dealing with FPI
1. BRAINSTORM TO PREPARE THE SET UP
Case Building
A. Describe Status Quo
• Focus on the matter that becomes the issue of the motion
• Where and what happen  Notice the setting element
(Liberal democratic countries, under developed countries)
• Pay attention to specific term
B. Identify The Controversy
• Controversy usually happens when certain actor is violated
• Controversy usually happens when some values are conflicting
2. CONTEXTUALIZE THE DEBATE
Case Building
A. Declare your position to the controversy
B. Clear! No room for multi intepretation
• How, Who, and When
• Sometimes all, but sometimes not
C. Explain your position with simple elaboration or mechanism
• Mechanism is also necessary to avoid unnecessary harms
D. Beware of creating “soft stance”
3. DECLARE YOUR STANCE
Hard vs Soft
Case Building
A. Identify what you should prove to make your stance stands
B. Show your opponent burden of proof
• Add disclaimer to dismiss possible unimportant harms
C. Elaborate! Elaborate! Elaborate!
4. IDENTIFY BURDEN OF PROOF
Disclaimer
SESSION 4
CONSTRUCTING ARGUMENT
Constructing Argument
The point you’re trying to make that you believe to be true
1. IDEA/ASSERTION
Argument is not an assertion. Argument has anatomy
The logical and analytical explanation to prove your idea. Reason.
2. ANALYSIS
Something like a statistic, a survey, a case study, or an analogy to give
Greater credibility to your idea and analysis.
3. EVIDENCE
The Conclusion. So What.
4. LINK BACK
SESSION 5
CONSTRUCTING REBUTTAL
Constructing Rebuttal
Rebuttal is an argument. Rebuttal has anatomy
1. Rebuttal is a process of proving how you opponent’s arguments are wrong
2. You need to prove otherwise: A- Theory:
• A rebuttal should contradict an argument
• A rebuttal should not give asymmetric rebuttal to the argument (B, not A-)
3. Never mix your rebuttal with argument. Argument explains why your team is
right, rebuttal explains why your opponent is wrong
4. An effective rebuttal is not “pre-prepared rebuttal”. A good rebuttal is about
effectively attacking your opposition’s argument as they were presented. You
should pay attention to your opponent’s argument
5. A good rebuttal consists of layered rebuttal that could answer every possible
scenario from your opponent’s argument: Even if rebuttal
• Even if rebuttal: Proving that, although your opponent maybe right, we can
still rebut that point
LET’S GET THE GAME STARTED!

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Discourse Analysis
Discourse AnalysisDiscourse Analysis
Discourse AnalysisAyesha Mir
 
Lexical cohesive analysis
Lexical cohesive analysisLexical cohesive analysis
Lexical cohesive analysisUspan Sayuti
 
Critical reading as a part of critical writing
Critical reading as a part of critical writingCritical reading as a part of critical writing
Critical reading as a part of critical writingUniversity of North Dakota
 
Testing vocabulary
Testing vocabulary Testing vocabulary
Testing vocabulary FAIZAN RAZA
 
Language in argumentative essays
Language in argumentative essaysLanguage in argumentative essays
Language in argumentative essaysAnaAlbi
 
Common rhetorical functions in academic writing
Common rhetorical functions in academic writingCommon rhetorical functions in academic writing
Common rhetorical functions in academic writingmariaahmad82
 
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics Aseel K. Mahmood
 
Argumentative Essays
Argumentative EssaysArgumentative Essays
Argumentative EssaystheLecturette
 
Discourse analysis and phonology
Discourse analysis and phonologyDiscourse analysis and phonology
Discourse analysis and phonologyAhmed
 
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...Sabikaa
 
Discourse analysis
Discourse analysisDiscourse analysis
Discourse analysishamid mnati
 
Issues of identity in a multicultural society
Issues of identity in a multicultural societyIssues of identity in a multicultural society
Issues of identity in a multicultural societyTehreemSajjad3
 
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical Thinking
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical ThinkingCritical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical Thinking
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical ThinkingJamie Bisset
 
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)1213anita
 
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...OdalisVega1
 
Social-Media Assisted Language Learning
Social-Media Assisted Language LearningSocial-Media Assisted Language Learning
Social-Media Assisted Language LearningKee-Man Chuah
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Discourse Analysis
Discourse AnalysisDiscourse Analysis
Discourse Analysis
 
Lexical cohesive analysis
Lexical cohesive analysisLexical cohesive analysis
Lexical cohesive analysis
 
Critical reading as a part of critical writing
Critical reading as a part of critical writingCritical reading as a part of critical writing
Critical reading as a part of critical writing
 
Testing vocabulary
Testing vocabulary Testing vocabulary
Testing vocabulary
 
Language in argumentative essays
Language in argumentative essaysLanguage in argumentative essays
Language in argumentative essays
 
Common rhetorical functions in academic writing
Common rhetorical functions in academic writingCommon rhetorical functions in academic writing
Common rhetorical functions in academic writing
 
Assessing vocabulary
Assessing vocabularyAssessing vocabulary
Assessing vocabulary
 
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics
Speech acts theory in sociolinguistics
 
Argumentative Essays
Argumentative EssaysArgumentative Essays
Argumentative Essays
 
Lexical cohesion
Lexical cohesionLexical cohesion
Lexical cohesion
 
Discourse analysis and phonology
Discourse analysis and phonologyDiscourse analysis and phonology
Discourse analysis and phonology
 
What is a debate
What is a debateWhat is a debate
What is a debate
 
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...
Literature and Culture. Strategies to overcome cultural problems in language ...
 
Discourse analysis
Discourse analysisDiscourse analysis
Discourse analysis
 
Issues of identity in a multicultural society
Issues of identity in a multicultural societyIssues of identity in a multicultural society
Issues of identity in a multicultural society
 
Esp
EspEsp
Esp
 
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical Thinking
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical ThinkingCritical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical Thinking
Critical Evaluation: Critical Reading & Critical Thinking
 
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)
Speech Act (Andrew D. Cohen)
 
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...
Ethnolinguistic vitality/ ANGUAGE POLICY AND LANGUAGE PLANNING IN MULTILINGUA...
 
Social-Media Assisted Language Learning
Social-Media Assisted Language LearningSocial-Media Assisted Language Learning
Social-Media Assisted Language Learning
 

Ähnlich wie Debate 101 oktafia

Basic Debating Skills (2)2.ppt
Basic Debating Skills (2)2.pptBasic Debating Skills (2)2.ppt
Basic Debating Skills (2)2.pptzohrearabzadeh
 
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at Grenfell
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at GrenfellHow to Debate Effectively - International Students at Grenfell
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at GrenfellPatrick Arsenault, RCIC 🍁
 
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppthow-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.pptKingCajayon1
 
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptx
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptxDebate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptx
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptxDianOctaviani12
 
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла Поппера
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла ПоппераМатериалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла Поппера
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла ПоппераGalina Trushkina
 
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauan
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauanAsian Parliamentary Debate natanauan
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauanMc Neil Natanauan
 
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppthow-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.pptKhausalyaaVerasingam
 
Parliamentary style debate
Parliamentary style debateParliamentary style debate
Parliamentary style debateSivabala Naidu
 
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.ppt
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.pptIntroduction to Basic Debating Skills.ppt
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.pptFayaz Rashid
 
Huckabee debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)
Huckabee   debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)Huckabee   debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)
Huckabee debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)shuckabe
 
Basic debating skills
Basic debating skillsBasic debating skills
Basic debating skillsjtoma84
 

Ähnlich wie Debate 101 oktafia (20)

Summary of debate
Summary of debateSummary of debate
Summary of debate
 
Summary of debate
Summary of debateSummary of debate
Summary of debate
 
Basic Debating Skills (2)2.ppt
Basic Debating Skills (2)2.pptBasic Debating Skills (2)2.ppt
Basic Debating Skills (2)2.ppt
 
Debate 07 08
Debate 07 08Debate 07 08
Debate 07 08
 
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at Grenfell
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at GrenfellHow to Debate Effectively - International Students at Grenfell
How to Debate Effectively - International Students at Grenfell
 
Materi debat 1
Materi debat 1Materi debat 1
Materi debat 1
 
te natanauan
te natanauante natanauan
te natanauan
 
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppthow-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
 
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptx
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptxDebate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptx
Debate materials Opinion & thoughts.pptx
 
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла Поппера
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла ПоппераМатериалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла Поппера
Материалы для подготовки к проведению дебатов в формате Карла Поппера
 
Debate guide
Debate guideDebate guide
Debate guide
 
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauan
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauanAsian Parliamentary Debate natanauan
Asian Parliamentary Debate natanauan
 
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppthow-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
how-to-give-a-persuasive-speech.ppt
 
Parliamentary style debate
Parliamentary style debateParliamentary style debate
Parliamentary style debate
 
Asigmen ( aidil )
Asigmen ( aidil )Asigmen ( aidil )
Asigmen ( aidil )
 
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.ppt
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.pptIntroduction to Basic Debating Skills.ppt
Introduction to Basic Debating Skills.ppt
 
Ejved adj seminar
Ejved adj seminarEjved adj seminar
Ejved adj seminar
 
how to be a good debator
how to be a good debatorhow to be a good debator
how to be a good debator
 
Huckabee debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)
Huckabee   debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)Huckabee   debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)
Huckabee debate notes and format 3 w rubric (2)
 
Basic debating skills
Basic debating skillsBasic debating skills
Basic debating skills
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Presentation on Engagement in Book Clubs
Presentation on Engagement in Book ClubsPresentation on Engagement in Book Clubs
Presentation on Engagement in Book Clubssamaasim06
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...henrik385807
 
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Hasting Chen
 
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)Chameera Dedduwage
 
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptx
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptxMathematics of Finance Presentation.pptx
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptxMoumonDas2
 
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...Pooja Nehwal
 
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...Sheetaleventcompany
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardstick
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, YardstickSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardstick
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardsticksaastr
 
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxNikitaBankoti2
 
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AIMicrosoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AITatiana Gurgel
 
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara Services
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara ServicesVVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara Services
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara ServicesPooja Nehwal
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfCTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfhenrik385807
 
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Kayode Fayemi
 
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510Vipesco
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceDelhi Call girls
 
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )Pooja Nehwal
 
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New Nigeria
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New NigeriaIf this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New Nigeria
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New NigeriaKayode Fayemi
 
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024eCommerce Institute
 
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024eCommerce Institute
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Presentation on Engagement in Book Clubs
Presentation on Engagement in Book ClubsPresentation on Engagement in Book Clubs
Presentation on Engagement in Book Clubs
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 128 Call Me: 8448380779
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Sven Zoelle - Most Crucial Invest to Digitalisation_slid...
 
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
Re-membering the Bard: Revisiting The Compleat Wrks of Wllm Shkspr (Abridged)...
 
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)
Introduction to Prompt Engineering (Focusing on ChatGPT)
 
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptx
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptxMathematics of Finance Presentation.pptx
Mathematics of Finance Presentation.pptx
 
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls Service Pooja 9892124323 Real Russian Girls Looking Mo...
 
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
No Advance 8868886958 Chandigarh Call Girls , Indian Call Girls For Full Nigh...
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardstick
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, YardstickSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardstick
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Lucas Price, Yardstick
 
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docxANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
ANCHORING SCRIPT FOR A CULTURAL EVENT.docx
 
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AIMicrosoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
Microsoft Copilot AI for Everyone - created by AI
 
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara Services
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara ServicesVVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara Services
VVIP Call Girls Nalasopara : 9892124323, Call Girls in Nalasopara Services
 
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdfCTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
CTAC 2024 Valencia - Henrik Hanke - Reduce to the max - slideshare.pdf
 
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
Governance and Nation-Building in Nigeria: Some Reflections on Options for Po...
 
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510
Thirunelveli call girls Tamil escorts 7877702510
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 93 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
WhatsApp 📞 9892124323 ✅Call Girls In Juhu ( Mumbai )
 
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New Nigeria
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New NigeriaIf this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New Nigeria
If this Giant Must Walk: A Manifesto for a New Nigeria
 
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024George Lever -  eCommerce Day Chile 2024
George Lever - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
 
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
Andrés Ramírez Gossler, Facundo Schinnea - eCommerce Day Chile 2024
 

Debate 101 oktafia

  • 1. DEBATE 101 By: Oktafia Rachmawati Putri (Universitas Bakrie)
  • 2. Session 1i: Debate In A Glance Session 3: Motion Understanding – Case Building Session 4: Constructing Argument Session 5: Constructing Rebuttal Session 2: Roles of Speakers AGENDA
  • 4. Debating is… •A clash between government and opposition team •Developing communication skills •Arranging, organizing and delivering effective arguments •The objective of the debate is to convince the adjudicators (and audience) that your team is the most convincing (through your reasoning, arguments and explanations) and therefore deserve to win the debate. •Debating requires sufficient knowledge, skills, willingness, and tireless practices! • Asian parliamentary system – 3 speakers per team, 7 minutes speech, with POI • Australs parliamentary system – 3 speakers per team, 8 minutes speech, no POI • British parliamentary system – 2 speaker per team, 4 teams debating in a round – 7 minutes speech, with POI Debate Intro Debate Formats
  • 5. • Affirmative/Government vs. Negative/Opposition • Asian: Points of Information (POI) are allowed during speech • Australs: No Points of Information (POI) are allowed during speech • Asian: Substantive Speech: 7’20” | Reply Speech: 5’20” • Australs: Substantive Speech: 8’20” | Reply Speech: 6’20” • Speech duration and order: 1st Affirmative (7’20”) 1st Opposition (7’20”) 2nd Affirmative (7’20”) 2nd Opposition (7’20”) 3rd Affirmative (7’20”) 3rd Opposition (7’20”) Reply Opposition (5’20”)Reply Affirmative (5’20”) Debate Formats ASIAN & AUSTRALS
  • 6. • Issue or topic that you will debate upon • Full propositional statement, not question or phrase • Affirmative: defend the motion | Negative: oppose the motion Motion • Types of Motion: – Proposal motion • Concerned with practical problems. The motion ask the debater to propose specific solvency to deal the problem • Example: THW allow gay couples to adopt children – Judgment motion • Concerned with question of right or wrong. The motion ask the debater to prove a general fact/statement • Example: THBT capitalism has failed – Comparison motion • Concerned with two values in conflict. The motion ask the debater to prefer a value over another value based on hierarchy outlined in the motion • Example: THBT free trade is better than fair trade
  • 7. • Case: a complete set of argumentation to defend or oppose the motion • Anatomy of a case: – Set up: definition of a motion into a debatable context – Arguments: reasoning why your team is right – Responses: reasoning why your opponent is wrong Case
  • 8. • Matter (content) - 40% – Arguments (logic, use of evidences, relevance) • Manner (delivery) - 40% – Public-speaking skills: vocal style, use of language, use of notes, eye contact, gesture, stance, dress, impression of sincerity, and humor – Personal attacks on opponents reduce manner points • Method (structure) - 20% – Structure: of individual speech and of team’s case – Response to the dynamics of the debate Debate Assessment
  • 9. What do We Talk about on Debates?
  • 10. SESSION 2 ROLES OF SPEAKERS
  • 11. Role of Speakers Roles – 1st Affirmative • Defines the motion (see the elements of definition) • Presents Affirmative’s theme line = GOAL • Outlines Affirmative’s team split • Delivers first part of split – Foundation of case (basic justification) – For proposal debate: provide the complete model include: urgency of proposal, model feasibility and how the model effectively achieve the objective – Preemptive argument e.g.: how your issue should be weighted more than other issue • Summarizes/recaps own speech
  • 12. Role of Speakers Roles – 1st Negative • Responds the definition (accept/reject) • Provides negation = A- • Rebuts 1st Affirmative briefly (usually focus on the objective and basic justification of aff’s stance) • Presents Negative’s theme line and team split • Delivers first part of split (the positive case of opposition): – Foundation of the case (basic justification) – Counter proposal if necessary (the model, feasibility, effectiveness, and brief model comparison) – In what way aff’s idea is not acceptable • Summarizes/recaps own speech
  • 13. Role of Speakers Roles – 2nd Speakers • Clarifies/ reminds the adjudicators what the room of debate is and how previous speakers fulfill their burden of proof. shows to adju if your opponent fail to engage properly • Briefly reiterates team’s case (in general) and shows how your team still has upper hand • Defends your 1st speaker argument (answer the rebuttals given towards your 1st speaker) • Attack previous speakers • Delivers 2nd part of split (the extension of your case). Your extension should be distinguished from your foundation. It could be analysis on other point of view/ other actor involved, analysis on various scenario, deeper analysis on wider perspective, or further implications that may happen. Watch for: contradiction (your extension backstabbing your argument) and additional burden of proof • Summarizes/recaps own speech
  • 14. Role of Speakers Roles – 3rd Speakers • Identify the fulfillment of burden of proof from both teams, your opponent’s engagement, and battle happen during the debate. Explain that your team still has upper hand. • From each battles happen ensure the adjudicator that your team win those battles by providing holistic rebuttals for everything given by your opponent. Arrange your rebuttals for each battles so the adjudicators easily understand how your rebuttals contribute. • Some important elements to be a good 3rd speaker: – Your main duty is to attack. Since you are the last hope of your team, attack everything given by your opponents. Focus on arguments or responses that you consider essential and could determine the winner of that round. – Hinder unnecessary repetition. Sometimes you need to be creative to extend the previous rebuttal. (Tips: use multilevel approach on developing your rebuttal). Identify contradiction, hung case, and new matter. – Be structurized! Always use sign posting to help adjudicators understand. – 3rd Aff is discouraged from bring new matter. 3rd Neg is prohibited from bring new matter. New example is not a new matter.
  • 16. SESSION 3 MOTION UNDERSTANDING – CASE BUILDING
  • 18. Motion Understanding THIS HOUSE WOULD CRIMINALIZE FPI WOULD 1. Does this motion require mechanism? 2. Do we have to create a completely new mechanism or modify from SQ? FPI 1. Does this proposal apply to the organization as an entity? Or should it also affect each members of FPI? 2. Should we debate be about whether FPI is a good organization or not? CRIMINALIZE FPI 1. How should the ‘criminalize’ be? • Government ban the existence of FPI • Stops any activities and anything related with FPI, and punish those who do not obey • Restrict any such organization (radical ones) to exist and grow (but WAIT. We’re not going to debate that far!) Motion understanding is helping you to get early definition
  • 19. Case Building A. Write down any relevant ideas and knowledge that you have. B. Don’t be lazy! Think! Analyse! C. Do this approx. 5 -10 Min Individually • FPI = a religious organization • Has been existing in Indonesia for quite long time • All organization want to spread their values to attract followers • All organization/entity should follow the country’s rules • Country’s rules = don’t create destruction, do not force! • Majority of Indonesian citizens = moslems • FPI wants to keep the societies in ‘moslem’ values and tracks • Society is okay with moslems’ values • But, is society OK with what FPI usually does? • Government has responsibility to protect society • Government has obligation not to limit the society’s freedom of expressions • There is no special mechanisms for dealing with FPI 1. BRAINSTORM TO PREPARE THE SET UP
  • 20. Case Building A. Describe Status Quo • Focus on the matter that becomes the issue of the motion • Where and what happen  Notice the setting element (Liberal democratic countries, under developed countries) • Pay attention to specific term B. Identify The Controversy • Controversy usually happens when certain actor is violated • Controversy usually happens when some values are conflicting 2. CONTEXTUALIZE THE DEBATE
  • 21. Case Building A. Declare your position to the controversy B. Clear! No room for multi intepretation • How, Who, and When • Sometimes all, but sometimes not C. Explain your position with simple elaboration or mechanism • Mechanism is also necessary to avoid unnecessary harms D. Beware of creating “soft stance” 3. DECLARE YOUR STANCE Hard vs Soft
  • 22. Case Building A. Identify what you should prove to make your stance stands B. Show your opponent burden of proof • Add disclaimer to dismiss possible unimportant harms C. Elaborate! Elaborate! Elaborate! 4. IDENTIFY BURDEN OF PROOF Disclaimer
  • 24. Constructing Argument The point you’re trying to make that you believe to be true 1. IDEA/ASSERTION Argument is not an assertion. Argument has anatomy The logical and analytical explanation to prove your idea. Reason. 2. ANALYSIS Something like a statistic, a survey, a case study, or an analogy to give Greater credibility to your idea and analysis. 3. EVIDENCE The Conclusion. So What. 4. LINK BACK
  • 26. Constructing Rebuttal Rebuttal is an argument. Rebuttal has anatomy 1. Rebuttal is a process of proving how you opponent’s arguments are wrong 2. You need to prove otherwise: A- Theory: • A rebuttal should contradict an argument • A rebuttal should not give asymmetric rebuttal to the argument (B, not A-) 3. Never mix your rebuttal with argument. Argument explains why your team is right, rebuttal explains why your opponent is wrong 4. An effective rebuttal is not “pre-prepared rebuttal”. A good rebuttal is about effectively attacking your opposition’s argument as they were presented. You should pay attention to your opponent’s argument 5. A good rebuttal consists of layered rebuttal that could answer every possible scenario from your opponent’s argument: Even if rebuttal • Even if rebuttal: Proving that, although your opponent maybe right, we can still rebut that point
  • 27. LET’S GET THE GAME STARTED!

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. Hard vs Soft is on MAD Pg. 15 In this motion: adopt children above 18 y.o. when they can rationally chose their parent. Disclaimer: As a disclaimer, we would not debate on the issues whether gay is already accepted or not in society. The debate should focus on parental rights issues and whether or not gay is acceptable to take parental role.