Follow up slides from Penn Law’s Entrepreneurship Legal Clinic at NextFab event.
http://nextfab.ticketleap.com/penn-law-entrepreneurial-legal-clinic-at-nextfab/details
4. TrademarksA trade secret is information that
is
• economically valuable to your
business,
• isn’t known to people outside
your business,
• and is subject to reasonable
protection from disclosure.
!
Protection lasts as long as it
remains a secret.
Trade
Secrets
4
6. TRADE SECRETS
PA Uniform Trade Secrets Act
To be considered a trade secret:
!
(1) Information must be economically valuable because it is not known
to the public/competitors & it isn't easily ascertainable AND
(2) Reasonable efforts are made by the trade secret owner to maintain
secrecy
6
7. TRADE SECRETS
how to keep it secret
TS owners have a duty to use “reasonable measures” to maintain the
secrecy of the information. They should implement policies such as:
!
• For employees
• Non-disclosure agreements and confidentiality clauses
• Non-compete clauses
• “Confidential” labels
• Limit access to documents w/ trade secret info
• Include trade secret policies in employee handbooks
• Training
• Strict electronic communications & social networking policies
!
• For third-parties (vendors, suppliers, independent contractors, etc.)
• Require non-disclosure agreements
! 7
8. TRADE SECRETS
pros/cons
Pros:
!
• Low cost
• Doesn’t require disclosure/
registration w/ gov’t
• No time limit for protection
• Immediately effective
!
!
!
Cons:
!
• Protection is only effective against
improper acquisition & use or
disclosure
• Doesn’t provide exclusivity
• Independent discovery
• Reverse engineering
• Protection is lost if secret is publicly
disclosed
8
9. Copyright
• What is copyright?
• What can you copyright?
• What rights do you get?
• Registration
• Ownership
9
outline
10. Copyright
Copyright law protects the
expression of an idea, but
copyright does not protect the
idea itself.
!
Copyright does not protect useful
articles or objects with some
useful functionality.
10
18. Compilations
COPYRIGHT // CATEGORIES
Since facts are considered "ideas"
or "discoveries", they are not
copyrightable. However,
compilations of facts are treated
differently.
18
22. what rights do you get?
COPYRIGHT
To reproduce the work
!
To prepare derivative works
!
To distribute copies
!
To publicly perform the work,
!
To publicly display the work
To digitally transmit
22
24. COPYRIGHT
Application form
!
Deposit a clear rendition of the material
being submitted for copyright
!
Pay a nonrefundable filing fee
(as little as $35 for a basic claim in an original work of authorship)
how do you register?
24
29. COPYRIGHT
transfers of rights
assignment - analogous to a sale of property
!
exclusive licenses - only the licensee may
exercise the granted rights
!
nonexclusive licenses - allows licenses to other
parties
!
implied licenses - licenses inferred from a conduct
and not an explicit agreement
[must be
in writing
29
34. How ™ is different from other forms of IP
• Trademarks don’t require creation of anything new
• Just have to establish an association between the
mark and your product in the minds of consumers
• No built in time limitation: You’re in control.
• Scope may broaden over time - can become famous
over time.
TRADEMARKS
34
45. TRADEMARKS
Fanciful
Inherently distinctive;
automatically qualifies for
protection
Arbitrary
Inherently distinctive;
automatically qualifies for
protection
Suggestive
Inherently distinctive;
automatically qualifies for
protection
Descriptive
Must establish secondary
meaning to get protection
Generic Asprin No protection
what type of mark do you have?
45
48. TRADEMARKS
Limited to
geographic area of use
!
!
• Protected only in the areas
where there is actual use
• Cases have also established
protection in a normal
territorial zone of expansion
or where the mark’s
reputation has been
established.
common law protection
• Comes from the continuous prior use of a mark in commerce.
48
49. TRADEMARKS
2005
2007
common law priority
Concurrent use situations
• Each party gets exclusive use in their exclusive geographic
areas.
• Where there’s conflict, it’s resolved in
favor of the earliest user in that
area.
• One user could be the senior
user in one market and a
junior user in another.
49
50. downsides of common law protection
• No ability to recover:
• lost profits
• statutory damages
• attorneys fees
• triple damages for willful infringement
• No national priority
• No right to use ® to give notice of rights in the mark
TRADEMARKS
50
51. • Prima facie evidence of validity
• Nationwide priority as of date of registration
• Constructive notice of the registrant’s ownership of the
mark
• Access to federal courts
• Broad array of remedies (if registered on the Principal
Register)
• Incontestability after 5 years
TRADEMARKS
advantages of federal ®
51
52. • Incontestability immunizes a mark against challenges
that a mark is descriptive or lacks secondary
meaning
• Incontestability does not shield you from challenges on
other bases, such as:
• fraud, abandonment, misrepresentation of source,
fair use, prior third party rights (e.g. concurrent use),
prior registered mark, functionality, or genericism.
TRADEMARKS
what is incontestability?
52
54. • Actual use of the mark in interstate commerce
• Bona fide intent to use (ITU) the mark in interstate commerce (if mark is
inherently distinctive)
• ™ owner has 6 months (auto-extendable to 1 year or 3 years with
good cause) to use and file a Statement of Use
• A claim of priority based on an earlier filed foreign application to register the
mark
• Registration of the mark in a foreign applicants country of origin
• Extension of protection of an international registration under the Madrid
system.
TRADEMARKS
bases for filing
54
55. TRADEMARKS
1. Identify the particular goods or services on or in
connection with which it uses or intends to use the mark
!
• Be specific and don’t leave descriptions open-ended
• Do not list products or services you don't plan on selling. Do not
include products or services that you are not, nor have a real
intention of, selling in the future.
• List only goods/services that you are selling to others
• Can’t add additional goods/services later; will need new
application.
!
!
application must
55
56. TRADEMARKS
application must
2. Submit a drawing of the ™
!
Standard character format - grants
protection to the wording itself without regard
to font, style, size, or color. Most flexible;
broad rights.
!
Stylized or design formats covers design
elements and/or word(s) and/or letter(s)
having a particular stylized appearance.
e.g. Nike
56
58. TRADEMARKS
APPLICATION PUBLICATION
OPPOSITIONREVIEW FOR
STATUTORY
COMPLIANCE
REGISTRATION
CERTIFICATE
ISSUED
• Opposer must file opposition or time
extension request within 30 days of
publication; extendable up to 180 days
• Opposer must have a real interest in the
mark for whom registration is sought.
• Must be owner or exclusive licensee
of a similar mark
• Be in competition with the applicant
• Burden of proof is on the challenger
(opposer)
timeline
58
60. The USPTO bars the registration of marks that:
• are confusingly similar to an existing mark.
• This is the most common reason registrations are
denied
• Looking at likelihood of confusion
TRADEMARKS: STATUTORY BARS
bars to registration
60
61. • similarity between the marks as to appearance, sound,
connotation, etc
• similarity of the nature of the goods/services
• similarity of marketing channels
• conditions under which sales are made (“impulse" vs. more
discerning shoppers)
• fame of the prior mark.
• number and nature of similar marks in use on similar goods.
• extent of actual and potential confusion
• extent of concurrent use
• range of goods for which mark is used
TRADEMARKS: STATUTORY BARS
factors
61
62. • are immoral, scandalous, disparaging, deceptive,
or cause false associations
• comprise the flag, coat of arms, or insignia of the
U.S., any state w/in the union, municipality, or
foreign nation
• incorporate a name, portrait, or signature
TRADEMARKS: STATUTORY BARS
bars to registration
62
63. • are deceptively misdescriptive.
• are primarily geographically descriptive
• are primarily geographically deceptively misdescriptive
• are primarily merely a surname
TRADEMARKS: STATUTORY BARS
bars to registration
63
65. • Generic marks are subject to cancellation! Don’t let your
mark go generic!
• Your mark should indicate who you are and not what
you are.
!
!
Asprin, Escalator, Heroin, Webster’s Dictionary
TRADEMARKS
genericide
65
66. • Don’t abandon your mark!
• If you discontinue use of your mark with intent not to
resume, you’ve abandoned your mark and lose ™
protection!
• If you don’t use your mark for 3 consecutive years,
there is a rebuttable presumption of abandonment.
• Resumption of use: protection will only cover new uses,
not old ones.
TRADEMARKS
abandonment
66
68. TRADEMARKS AND DOMAIN NAMES
domain names ≠ ™
While trademarks are source identifiers in the physical world and
domain names are source identifiers in the online world…
68
69. TRADEMARKS AND DOMAIN NAMES
ACPA claims
The Anti-Cybersquatting Consumer Protection Act is one
mechanism for ™ owners to get domain names.
!
A ™ owner must show:
!
• S/he has a valid TM
• The mark is distinctive or famous
• Defendant’s domain name is identical, confusingly similar to,
or dilutive of plaintiff’s mark
• Defendant acted w/ bad faith intent to profit.
!
69
70. TRADEMARKS AND DOMAIN NAMES
UDRP dispute resolution
ICANN (Internet Corporation for the Assigned Names and
Numbers) offers a dispute resolution procedure (UDRP)
that is global and binding on all domain name registrants.
!
To win, a ™ owner must:
!
• Prove identity or substantial similarity (confusingly similar)
between his mark and challenged domain name
• Establish that domain name holder has no legitimate interest
in the domain
• Show that domain name was obtained/using it in bad faith.
!
!
!
70
73. Trademarks
Trade Dress refers to characteristics of
the visual appearance of a product or its
packaging (or even the design of a
building) that signify the source of the
product to consumers.
Trade
Dress
73
74. Trademarks
Covers
• Product packaging
• Product design
!
can cover features such as size, shape,
color, color combinations, texture,
graphics, and scents.
Trade
Dress
74
76. TRADE DRESS
what is protectable?
!
must be
!
• non-functional
• distinctive
• must be either inherently distinctive or
have acquired secondary meaning
!
!
!
76
77. TRADE DRESS
should you register?
Trade dress is typically unregistered, but registration can be
advantageous for the same reasons as for trademarks.
!
!
!
!
!
77