The document discusses intentional communication and intervention approaches to improve it. It defines intentional communication as gestures, vocalizations or verbalizations directed at someone for a communicative purpose. It notes research showing the importance of frequent intentional communication for language development. The rest of the document discusses tools for assessing intentional communication like the Communication Matrix, and intervention approaches like Intensive Interaction, Lilliworks Active Learning, DIR, and RDI.
1. It’s in the interaction!
Pamela R. Mitchell, Ph.D.
Kent State University
Speech Pathology
October 2009
Song: More Than Words by Extreme, c. A&M Records,
1990
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 1
2. Overview
Intentional Communication
Assessment
Intervention Approaches
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 2
3. Intentional Communication
Defined
intentional communication:
gesture, vocalization, verbalization
or combination
directed toward someone
serves a communicative purpose
Wetherby & Prizant, 1993
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 3
4. Importance of IC
High frequency communicators used more sophisticated signals and broader range of
communicative functions than low frequency (Cirrin & Rowland, 1985)
Distal gesturers had increased rates of communicative acts, initiation, repairs and word-like
vocalizations compared to “contact” gesturers (McClean, et al. 1991)
Relationship shown between rate of intentional communication and increased
communication “sophistication” (Ogletree &Wetherby, 1992)]
Children with higher rates of intentional communication demonstrated earlier language
development than those with lower rates (Smith &Von Tetzchner, 1986; Mundy, et al., 1995;
Yoder & Warren, 1999b)
Frequent production of intentional communicative acts preceded the emergence of symbolic
communication (Warren & Yoder, 1998)
Individuals who demonstrated intentionality were more likely to acquire a greater number of
graphic symbols than those who did not (Stephenson & Linfoot, 1996)
Intentional communication more likely to be detected and reciprocated by communicative
partners (Carter & Iacono, 2002, Yoder & Warren, 1997a)
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 4
5. Importance, cont.
Intentional communicative acts may elicit language-facilitating maternal
responses (Yoder & Warren, 1993)
Intentional communication correlated with maternal responsivity which is
associated with later language abilities in children with disabilities (Yoder &
Warren, 1998)
Frequency of prelinguistic intentional communication predicts expressive and
receptive language levels in children with disabilities a year or more later (Yoder
& Warren, 1999; Mundy et al, 1995; Smith & von Tetzchner, 1986)
Child intentional communication predicted maternal responsivity 6 months later,
(Yoder & Warren, 1999)
Intentional communication delayed or doesn’t occur in many special needs
children, which inhibits development of symbolic communication (Yoder et al,
2001)
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 5
8. Intervention
Approaches
Intensive Interaction
Lilliworks Active Learning
Greenspan, DIR
Gutstein, RDI
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 8
9. Fundamentals of Communication:
Intensive Interaction (Nind, 1999)
The fundamentals of communication can be characterized as
things like: (Nind, 1999)
• Learning to give brief attention to another person.
• To share attention with another person.
• Learning to extend those attentions, learning to concentrate on
another person.
• Developing shared attention into 'activities'.
• Taking turns in exchanges of behavior.
• To have fun, to play.
• Using and understanding eye contacts.
• Using and understanding of facial expressions.
• Using and understanding of non-verbal communication such as
gesture and body language.
• Learning use and understanding of physical contacts.
• Leaning use and understanding of vocalizations, having those
vocalizations become more varied and extensive, then gradually
more precise and meaningful.
Song: Please be patient with me, Wilco, c. Nonesuch Records, 2007
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 9
10. INTENSIVE
INTERACTION VIDEO
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 10
11. Aims of Intensive
Interaction
Develop:
sociability
fundamental communication abilities
cognitive abilities
emotional well-being
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 11
12. Rules of Thumb, Intensive
Interaction
take your time
be relaxed and playful
be available
establish “sequences”
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 12
13. Lilliworks Principles
http://www.lilliworks.com
1. Every One Can Learn
“Unless impacted by survival, every child and older learner can learn. It is
up to the parent, therapist or educator to keep finding the right
situation/environment with enough support, responsiveness and interest to
engage the learner.”
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 13
14. Lilliworks, cont
2. Active Learning is Hands Off
Challenged learners often act passive and are treated as passive
(everything is done for them). Active Learning involves creating supportive
and responsive environments that are tuned to entice a learner to become
active. When Lilli realized that blind and disabled learners often resisted
any “guided hands” approach, she set about to create environments and
situations that would increase a learner’s inclination to explore on their
own. This means the “teacher” must disengage and not talk nor prompt
until the activity is concluded. Kids learn through repetition (see #8)-
don’t interrupt them.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 14
15. Lilliworks, cont
3. Auditory and Tactile Primacy
Learners with vision impairments and neurological deficits rely upon
hearing as a primary sense. Vision tends to be secondary, owing to
control and processing difficulties. Tactile sense is also a prominent sense.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 15
16. Lilliworks, cont
4. Responsive Environment, Short Sessions
The environment should provide excellent auditory and tactile feedback
(not just stimulation). Use of the Resonance Board provides key vibratory
input. The Essef Board provides optimal reaction to leg movements. The
Little Room provides a warm inviting echo and exploration chamber. As Lilli
says, “if the child cannot go to the room, the room must come to the
child.” Many short sessions are better than one long one, especially when
first using an environment.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 16
17. Lilliworks, cont
5. Mix Variety and Constancy, Provide Comparisons
As anyone does, a learner benefits from moderated variety. That is, don’t
change everything every time, but provide enough variation so that the
environment has interest. Also, provide "alike but different" objects to
invite comparison. Cycling through a large inventory of objects/toys
allows for a rich, constantly interesting environment. Change some of the
objects whenever the learner shows habituation to the objects available.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 17
18. Lilliworks, cont
6. Work up to Weight Bearing
Given the discomfort of bearing weight, provide support until the learner
has some control, and slowing increase the weight load. The Support
Bench and HOPSA Dress are used to control weight on the legs. Start
with no weight, toes barely touching.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 18
19. Lilliworks, cont
7. Emotional Development Involves Mastery
It’s that smile of accomplishing something, doing something to their
environment, rather than the environment doing it to them that fosters a
critical step in emotional development. Related to the Active vs. Passive
learning, that “ see what I can do” smile is a crucial goal.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 19
20. Lilliworks, cont
8. Learning is by Repetition - Allow to fail
Kids learn by repetition. They must do something over and over to invoke
memory and get the variations to make sense. Therefore, allowing them to
have negative results without intervention (e.g. without moving an object
into their hand as they miss on a reach) is as important as not
interrupting with any cheerleading.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 20
21. Lilliworks, cont
9. Talk and Reward at the End of Play
At the end of play is the time for the adult input, the language and
commentary to describe what the learner was doing, and to positively
reinforce their activity. Point at and jiggle the objects and talk about
what they did. Ask questions and use short sentences. When a learner is
ready and can engage in turn-taking games, then a new level has been
achieved.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 21
22. Lilliworks, cont
10. Limit Input, Wait for Response
As a general principle, remember that neurologically impacted learners
usually need more time to take in, process and assemble a response. If
you ask a question, remain quiet as long as possible before asking
something again, and try not to supply their answer without some sign.
This is always subject to judgment, as after a while the question may be
forgotten. Repeat using the exact same words, so additional processing to
understand new input is not needed.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 22
23. DIR, Greenspan
http://www.circlestretch.blogspot.com/
http://www.playworks.cc/DIRmodel.html
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 23
24. Relationship Development Intervention (RDI), Gutstein
http://www.rdiconnect.com/
What are the core deficits in Autism? Researchers in the field of autism agree that autism is a
neurological information processing disorder. Specifically, autism impacts understanding, organizing
and analyzing meaning within change. RDI targets at least five specific core deficit areas of
autism including:
Emotional Referencing: Checking with someone else (or yourself) when you are not sure what to do
Social Co-Regulation: Individuals making mutual adjustments to each other
Declarative Communication: Communication for the purpose of sharing and interacting
Episodic Memory and Executive Function: Development of self and higher level thinking ability
Dynamic Thinking: Flexible thinking and Relative information processing
How is RDI implemented?
RDI is a parent-based model. The parents are the primary therapists, and the Consultant provides the
parents with tools, guidance and support.
Typically, parents will bring their child for the Relationship Development Assessment (RDA), and follow up
with an RDI Consultant. The therapy is primarily implemented in the home. Direct therapy (“lab time”) is
recommended for approximately 5-7 hours/week. Additionally, RDI encourages “lifestyle” changes. Parents
are encouraged to video tape their therapy with the child and review and analyze tapes to determine if
the child is improving.
Follow up with a RDI Consultant is usually every other week or monthly and is very often done via video
tape. The consultant analyzes the video and provides feedback to the coaches.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 24
25. Patiently Contingent
Empathically Engaged
Attentively Expectant
Consistently Strategic
Effective
Song: If you want to sing out, Cat Stevens, c. UMG
Recordings, 1984
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 25