1. Name _______________ GIVER DEBATE
Period ______ RUBRIC
Final Grade ______
For student reference only-
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS RUBRIC!
Item Possible Points
Points Received
Debate #1
Chapters 1-12
Is control a good way to create order?
List five quotes as evidence from the book. 5
Use appropriate citation.
Ex. “But he does not know how to get there” (88).
Debate #2
Chapters 13-23
Is Jonas’ community a utopia?
(Utopia=Perfect Society) 5
List five quotes as evidence from the book.
Use appropriate citation.
Ex. “But he does not know how to get there” (88).
Participation in Debate
You must participate with at least one argument during
each debate to receive credit. 5
Reading Checks
Receive one point per reading check quiz.
5
Total 20

2. Debate #1, Chapters 1-12
Is control a good way to create order?
List five quotes as evidence from the book using appropriate citations.
Ex. “But he does not know how to get there” (88).
1. __________________________________
2. __________________________________
3. __________________________________
4. __________________________________
5. __________________________________
Debate #2, Chapters 13-23
Is Jonas’ community a utopia?
List five quotes as evidence from the book using appropriate citations.
Ex. “But he does not know how to get there” (88).
1. __________________________________
2. __________________________________
3. __________________________________
4. __________________________________
5. __________________________________