1. +
Firefighter Down!
Special Consideration for the Resuscitation of the Downed Firefighter
Christopher Watford, Michael Herbert
2. +
License
This work is released as Free Open Access Meducation! #FOAM
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-
ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
You are free to:
Share: copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt: remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even
commercially.
We cannot revoke these freedoms as long as you follow the license terms.
Under the following terms:
Attribution: you must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and
indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in
any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
ShareAlike: if you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you must distribute
your contributions under the same license as the original.
No additional restrictions: you may not apply legal terms or technological
measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
2
3. +
Who Are These Guys?
Christopher Watford, BS, NRP
Lieutenant, Leland Fire/Rescue
Paramedic, New Hanover EMS
Senior Editor, EMS 12-Lead Blog
Lead Software Engineer, GE
Nuclear
Michael Herbert, BA, NREMT-P
Clinical Educator, Advanced
Circulatory
FF/Paramedic, Leland
Fire/Rescue
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
3
4. +
Conflict of Interest Disclosure
Christopher Watford
None
Michael Herbert
Employed by Advanced Circulatory
as a clinical educator.
Advanced Circulatory is the
manufacturer of the ResQPOD and
ResQGARD.
Advanced Circulatory has had no
financial or editorial input into this
presentation or its contents.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
4
5. +
Disclaimer
This presentation and our opinions do
not reflect the views or opinions of our
employers.
We’re not speaking for them, we’re
speaking for us.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
5
6. +
Why Listen to Us?
We are not the experts.
We encourage you to question our
assumptions
We encourage you to question our assertions.
We would like you to ask for our references.
We would like your feedback on our proposed
solution to a problem.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
6
7. +
Objectives
Understand the epidemiology of Firefighter fatalities
Define physiological changes during stress
Define physiological changes during firefighting
Define risks during firefighting
Understand pathophysiology of HCN exposure
Define barriers to treatment during Firefighter
resuscitation
Understand treatment goals during Firefighter
resuscitation
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
7
8. +
Captain
David Heath
New Hanover County
Fire Rescue
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM
Today 2014
8
9. +
Epidemiology
CDC/NIOSH Fire Fighter
Fatality Investigation and
Prevention Program
“Each year an average of 100 fire
fighters die in the line of duty.
To address this continuing
national occupational fatality
problem, NIOSH conducts
independent investigations of
fire fighter line of duty deaths.
This web page provides access
to NIOSH investigation reports
and other fire fighter safety
resources.”
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
9
13. +
Trauma Fatalities
Collapsing structures most common
traumatic etiology
Motor vehicle collisions second most
common
Being struck by a vehicle also common!
Asphyxiation likely if trapped or lost
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
13
14. +
Trauma Fatalities (en route)
Rollovers very common
Too fast, high center of gravity,
inexperience, weather
Intersection collisions common
Too fast, driving without due regard
Overuse of lights and sirens?
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
14
15. +
Trauma Fatalities (on scene)
Working an MVC is one of the most
dangerous jobs a firefighter or EMS
provider will do.
Spend more time blocking the scene
Backers are even more important on
busy fire scenes
Numerous fatalities from apparatus
repositioning
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
15
16. +
Trauma Fatalities (overhaul)
Structure collapse during overhaul is a
real concern
Toxic gasses during overhaul too
Electrocution rare, but happens
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
16
17. +
Medical Fatalities
Heart Attacks are the number one cause
of line of duty deaths in fire fighters.
Autopsies of firefighters include findings such
as: cardiomegaly, hypertrophy, severe CAD,
etc.
Heat exhaustion fairly common during
training events
Heat exhaustion coupled with cardiovascular
risks is a dangerous mix!
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
17
19. +
Medical Fatalities (cont.)
CVA’s are comparatively rare
Cardiomyopathies and channelopathies should be
considered in younger firefighters who collapse
Do you know what medical problems your crew
has?
Comorbid factors may play a large role in FF fatalities
Certain Cancers are now recognized as resulting
from Line of Duty incidents!
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
19
20. +Physiological Effects
of Firefighting
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014 20
21. +
Physiological Effects of Firefighting
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
21
22. +
The Stress of Firefighting
Firefighters:
perform strenuous physical work
while wearing heavy personal
protective equipment (PPE)
often in hot environments and under
physiologically stressful conditions
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
22
23. +
The Stress of Firefighting
Firefighting results in
significant cardiovascular
and thermal strain as a result
of:
strenuous work
heavy and insulating PPE
psychological stress
environmental extremes
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
23
24. +
Physiology of Stress in Firefighting
Strenuous firefighting activities can
lead to:
Attainment of maximal HR
Elevated core temperature
Dehydration
Decreased stroke volume
Increased arterial stiffness
Alterations of myocardial function
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
24
25. +
Other Stress of Fire/EMS Response
Alarm Response
“Noxious Arousal” from pager
T-wave inversion seen even in healthy
subjects
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
25
26. +
Cardiovascular Effects of Note
At the Attainment of Maximal Heart Rate…
Subendocardial viability ratio (SEVR):
Decreases
Index of myocardial oxygen supply and demand
Decrease in myocardial perfusion relative to cardiac
workload.
Rate Pressure Product: Increases
Determines the myocardial workload
Increases significantly during firefighting activity due to
the increase in myocardial oxygen consumption.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
26
27. +
Question
Is a reduced SEVR and increased RPP
related to sudden cardiac events during
firefighting?
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
27
28. +
Answer
We don’t know…
More research into the effects of
firefighting is needed!
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
28
29. +
Hematological and Blood Chemistry
Changes
Hemoconcentration
~15% reduction in plasma volume
Release of platelets from the spleen and lymph tissue
Platelet count increased significantly (18%)
H&H increases
Hemoglobin (Hgb) and hematocrit (Hct) revealed small but
significant increases (P<0.001)
Platelet closure time decreased significantly (15%
ADP, 20% EPI)
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
29
30. +
Hematological and Blood Chemistry
Changes
*Decreased Platelet closure time == Quicker Clotting
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
30
Smith et al. 2013 - Clotting and fibrinolytic changes after firefighting activities
31. +
Fibrinolytic changes
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
31
Smith et al. 2013 - Clotting and fibrinolytic changes after firefighting activities
32. +
Coagulatory changes
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
32
Smith et al. 2013 - Clotting and fibrinolytic changes
after firefighting activities
33. + Changes from Baseline
Coagulation
1.45
1.22
1.38
1.09
200%
175%
150%
125%
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
FVIII TF
Pre Post 120Post
450%
400%
350%
300%
250%
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
Fibrinolytic
Tpa act Tpa agn
Pre Post 120Post
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
33
Horn et al 2010: Effects of Fire Fighting and On Scene Rehab on Hemostasis
34. +
Risks of SCA during Firefighting
2007 study by Kales
and coworkers clearly
demonstrated that the
relative risk of
suffering from a fatal
cardiac event was 10–
100 times greater
following fire-suppression
activities
than during non-fire
duties.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
34
35. +
Summary
Studies suggest there is an
increased risk of
thrombosis due to a
procoagulatory state,
hours after firefighting.
In effect an increased
vulnerability to myocardial
infarction after fighting fire.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
35
36. +
How do we address this?
NIOSH and NFPA stress Prevention and Detection
as the key!
Reduce modifiable risk factors
Fitness and Nutrition Programs
Smoking Cessation Programs
Screening and Detection
Annual Physicals
Assessment of Cardiovascular Risks
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
36
38. Used with permission from Capt. Steve Jones – Burlington Fire
Dept
Ammonia Methane
Dioxin
Benzene
Chloromethane
Bromomethane
Oxides of Nitrogen
Carbonyl Fluoride
Furfural
Sulfur Dioxide
Formaldehyde
Phosgene
Ethylene
Carbon Dioxide
Hydrogen Sulfide PCB’s
Acrolein
Carbon Monoxide
Hydrogen Cyanide
Benzopyrine
Alcohols Acetic Acid
39. +
Let’s concentrate on the “toxic
twins”…
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
39
40. +
Toxic Twins
Hydrogen Cyanide Carbon Monoxide
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
40
41. +
Cyanide
Extremely poisonous,
colorless chemical, with faint
almond* smell.
24 times more toxic then CO
Synergistic toxicity with CO
IDLH – 50ppm
NIOSH REL – 5ppm
OSHA PEL – 10ppm
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
41
42. +
Pathophysiology of Cyanide
Histotoxic hypoxia
Inability of cells to take up or
utilize oxygen from the
bloodstream
Despite physiologically
normal delivery of oxygen to
such cells.
Inhibits cytochrome
C-oxidase
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
42
43. +
Signs & Symptoms of CN toxicity
Headache
Confusion
Anxiety
Blurred vision
Loss of judgment
Increased respiratory
rate
Dyspnea
Cardiac arrhythmias
Seizures
Coma
Death
MODERATE
EXPOSURE
SERIOUS EXPOSURE
Used with permission from Capt. Steve Jones – Burlington Fire
Dept
44. +
Cyanide Poisoning
Cyanide exposure:
Expected in those exposed to smoke in
closed-space fires
Important cause of incapacitation and death
in smoke-inhalation victims
Cyanide can act independently of, and
perhaps synergistically with, carbon
monoxide to cause morbidity and mortality
(“Toxic Twins”)
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
44
45. +
Columbia Fire Department Study
Eight month study
monitoring CO and
HCN at fires.
Found extremely high
HCN levels at calls
Found no correlation
between CO and HCN
production
Used with permission from Capt. Steve Jones – Burlington Fire
Dept
46. +
Food for thought…
Air monitoring of
these firefighters at
this moment found
HCN levels to be:
38 ppm
46
Used with permission from Capt. Steve Jones – Burlington Fire
Dept
48. +
Suggested Literature Review
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
48
Report of the Investigation Committee into the Cyanide Poisonings of
Providence Firefighters. J. Curtis Varone, Thomas N. Warren, Kevin Jutras,
Joseph Molis, Joseph Dorsey. May 30, 2006.
49. + Special
Considerations during
Resuscitation
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014 49
50. +
RIT
If the downed firefighter is inside a
structure, you’ll need to effect rescue.
MAYDAY incidents are chaotic and
communication will be poor.
Frequent training for RIT will improve
chance of a rescue.
Consider that it may take upwards of 15
minutes to rescue a downed firefighter.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
50
51. +
Determining the Etiology
RIT has just rescued a downed firefighter.
Does not appear to be breathing.
Is it trauma?
Blunt? Penetrating?
Asphyxiation?
Is it medical?
Does it matter initially?
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
51
52. +
Getting them out of their gear!
Extrication.
We’re at an impasse until we get these
guys out of their turnout gear.
Their gear is going to be hot, wet,
maybe even contaminated.
Their gear is in the way of what we
need to be doing: Chest Compressions!
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
52
53. +
FD-CPR
Concept began with Hilton Head Island Fire &
Rescue
Video showing the time delay to get firefighter out
of gear
Thanks to Capt. Tom Bouthillet for sharing their
experience on Youtube
Revised with the help of input from numerous
firefighters and EMS providers.
Proposed Process: FD-CPR
10 Steps to Doff Gear and perform CPR
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
53
55. +
Treatment
CPR, CPR, and more CPR.
Consider the etiology
Was their air cylinder empty? Early adv airway.
Was their mask off? Early adv airway and
consider HCN.
Did they simply collapse suddenly? Std pit
crew.
Structure collapse? Check rhythm, transport
decision?
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
55
56. +
Your Plan?
What is your plan for:
EMS response to structure fires?
Rehab?
RIT?
Downed firefighters?
Cyanide exposure?
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
56
58. +
References
NIOSH Fire Fighter Fatality Investigation and Prevention Program.
http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/fire/
Brandt-Rauf PW, et al. Health hazards of fire fighters: exposure assessment. Br J
Indust Med. 1988; 45:606-612.
Smith DL, et al. Effect of strenuous live-fire fire fighting drills on hematological blood
chemistry and psychological measures. J Therm Biol. 2001; 26:375-379.
CDC. Fatalities Among Volunteer and Career Firefighters: United States, 1994-2004.
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 2006; 55(16):453-455.
Dweck MR, et al. Noxious arousal induces T-wave changes in healthy subjects. J
Electrocardiol. 2006; 39:324-330.
NIOSH. Preventing Fire Fighter Fatalities Due to Heart Attacks and Other Sudden
Cardiovascular Events. Publication Number 2007-133. June 2007.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
58
59. +
References
Geibe JR, et al. Predictors of On-Duty Coronary Events in Male Firefighters in the
United States. Am J Cardiol. 2008; 101:585-589.
Fahs CA, et al. Impact of Excess Body Weight on Arterial Structure, Function, and
Blood Pressure in Firefighters. Am J Cardiol. 2009; 104:1441-1445.
Horn GP, et al. The Effects of Fire Fighting and On-Scene Rehabilitation on
Hemostatis. University of Illinois Fire Service Institute. November 2010.
Estes CR, Marsh SM, Castillo DN. Surveillance of Traumatic Firefighter Fatalities: An
Assessment of Four Systems. Pub Health Rep. 2011; 126:540-551.
Kunadharaju K, Smith TD, DeJoy DM. Line-of-duty deaths among U.S. firefighters:
An analysis of fatality investigations. Acc Anal and Prev. 2011; 43:1171-1180.
Smith DL, et al. Effect of Live-Fire Training Drills on Firefighters’ Platelet Number
and Function. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2011; 15:233-239.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
59
60. +
References
Dries DJ, Endorf FW. Inhalation injury: epidemiology, pathology, treatment stragies.
Scand J Trauma Resus Emerg Med. 2013; 21(31):1-15.
IAFF. Heart Disease in the Fire Service. 2013.
http://www.iaff.org/hs/index.htm
Smith DL, Barr DA, Kales SN. Extreme sacrifice: sudden cardiac death in the US
Fire Service. Extr Phys Med. 2013; 2(6):1-9.
Mbanu I, et al. Seasonality and Coronary Heart Disease Deaths in United States
Firefighters. Chronobiol Int. 2007; 24(4):715-726.
Poston WSC, et al. An examination of the benefits of health promotion programs for
the national fire service. BMC Pub Health. 2013; 13(805):1-14.
Yang J, et al. Sudden Cardiac Death Among Firefighters ≤45 Years of Age in the
United States. Am J Cardiol. 2013; 112:1962-1967.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
60
61. +
References
Fent KW, et al. Systemic Exposure to PAHs and Benzene in Firefighters
Suppressing Controlled Structure Fires. Ann Ccup Hyg. 2014; 58(7):830-845.
Hostler D, et al. A Randomized Controlled Trial of Aspirin and Exertional Heat Stress
Activation of Platelets in Firefighters during Exertion in Thermal Protective Clothing.
Prehosp Emerg Care. 2014; 18:359-367.
Hunter A, et al. Abstract 27: Fire simulation exposure causes impairment of
endothelial function and increased thrombogenicity in healthy firefighters. Heart.
2014; 100(Suppl 3):A14-A15.
Kales SN, Smith DL. Sudden cardiac death in the fire service. Occup Med. 2014;
64:228-232.
Perroni F, et al. Psychophysiological Responses of Firefighters to Emergencies: A
Review. Open Sport Sci J. 2014; 7(Suppl-1, M3):8-15.
Smith DL, et al. Clotting and Fibrinolytic Changes after Firefighting Activities. Med
Sci Sports Exerc. 2014; 46(3):448-454.
Watford, Herbert - Firefighter Resuscitation - EM Today 2014
61
Hinweis der Redaktion
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Notices:
You do not have to comply with the license for elements of the material in the public domain or where your use is permitted by an applicable exception or limitation.
No warranties are given. The license may not give you all of the permissions necessary for your intended use. For example, other rights such as publicity, privacy, or moral rights may limit how you use the material.
Focus on the prevalence of cardiomyopathy and cardiomegaly in those <35!
http://millhillavecommand.blogspot.com/2014/02/sudden-cardiac-death-among-firefighters.html
Results: In the 20 minutes after arousal, no changes were seen in overall QT/RR relationship in any
of the groups. However, marked T-wave morphology changes, including T-wave inversion, were
observed in all the arousal events. Postural changes only accounted for a small proportion of change
in T-wave morphology.
Subendocardial Viability Ratio (SEVR) provides an estimate of the arterial system’s ability to perfuse myocardial tissue (i.e., supply oxygen to the heart muscle), in order to meet the heart’s energy requirements. If SEVR decreases from baseline levels, the heart will be faced with a reduced energy reserve, potentially resulting in lower tolerance for strenuous physical activities such as fighting a fire.
Rate pressure product is a measure of the stress put on the cardiac muscle based on the number of times it needs to beat per minute (HR) and the arterial blood pressure that it is pumping against (SBP). It will be a direct indication of the energy demand of the heart and thus a good measure of the energy consumption of the heart.
Encourage folks to push for more research through advocacy groups.
The increase in platelet number likely reflects a combination of hemoconcentration (i.e., the 5-7% decrease in plasma volume) and a release of platelets from the spleen and lymph tissue secondary to sympathetic nerve stimulation.
Platelet aggregation was enhanced following fire fighting activity (as evidenced by a shorter time to occulsion) and remained elevated following 120 minutes of recovery. The decreased closure time that persisted even after 120 minutes of recovery suggests that there is an increased risk of thrombosis at least 2 ½ hours after completion of short bouts of fire fighting activity in relatively young, healthy firefighters.
HCT: Closure Time decreases with an increase in Hct
Platelet count: Closure Time decreases with an increase in platelet count
Platelet number and function. Platelet number increased significantly immediately postfirefighting (P<0.001) and returned to baseline values 2 h postfirefighting.
When the blood was exposed to collagen and EPI, platelet closure time decreased significantly immediately postfirefighting (P<0.05) and then returned toward baseline, although it remained significantly lower than baseline at 2 h postfirefighting (P<0.05).
Platelet closure time when the blood was exposed to collagen and ADP decreased significantly after firefighting activity (P = 0.018) but was not different from baseline 2 h postfirefighting.
Reported reference ranges for closure times are:
78 - 199 seconds for the CEPI cartridge
55 - 137 seconds for the CADP cartridge
a system for analysing platelet function in which citrated whole blood is aspirated at high shear rates through disposable cartridges containing an aperture within a membrane coated with either collagen and epinephrine (CEPI) or collagen and ADP (CADP). These agonists induce platelet adhesion, activation and aggregation leading to rapid occlusion of the aperture and cessation of blood flow termed the closure time (CT).
Several fibrinolytic factors reflected a transient increase in
fibrinolysis (Table 5). t-PA activity and antigen were elevated
immediately postfirefighting (P = 0.007 and P = 0.005, respectively),
but there were no significant differences between
prevalues and 2 h postvalues (P = 0.664 and P = 0.947, respectively).
There was also a significant effect of time on
PAI-1 activity. Post hoc analysis revealed that PAI-1 activity
was significantly lower both immediately postfirefighting
and 2 h postfirefighting than prefirefighting (P = 0.027 and
P = 0.020, respectively). PAI-1 antigen did not differ significantly
between pre- and immediately postfirefighting but was significantly lower 2 h postfirefighting than prefirefighting
(P<0.05). When PAI-1 antigen levels were corrected
for changes in plasma volume, there was no significant
time effect.
TF, uncorrected for changes in plasma volume, was significantly increased immediately postfirefighting compared with 2 h postfirefighting (P = 0.018). However, when corrected for changes in plasma volume, TF did not vary significantly with time, suggesting that hemoconcentration was primarily responsible for this change.
FVIII increased significantly immediately postfirefighting (P<0.001) and remained elevated at 2 h postfirefighting (P = 0.002). AT-III did not change significantly
over time (P = 0.055), although there was a strong trend for AT-III to be higher after firefighting and in the recovery period.
aPTT decreased significantly immediately postfirefighting (P = 0.025) and remained significantly below baseline at 2 h postfirefighting (P = 0.032,
Factor VIII increases post-fire fighting and remain elevated at 120 minutes into recovery, but Fibrinolytic variables that increase post-fire fighting return to near baseline levels after 120 minutes of recovery, suggesting a potentially hypercoagulable state in the hours after fire fighting.
NFPA 1582.
“I’m not talking about Steven Tyler and lead guitarist Joe Perry of Aerosmith.”
<wait for audience to laugh, or not>
Relate personal anecdotes of headache after fire fighting. Often ignored!
How many trapped/lost LODD’s were due to “loss of judgment”? Could CN/CO exposure be the causal factor?
5 g infused over 15 minutes (15 mL/min) for the loading dose. A second 5 g infusion over 15 minutes – 2 hours may be indicated.
http://millhillavecommand.blogspot.com/2014/04/cyanokit-whats-evidence-part-1.html
http://millhillavecommand.blogspot.com/2014/04/part-2-different-edit.html
The definitive answer on Cyanokit in downed firefighters is not known. Best available evidence says you should consider it, if you have a strong suspicion of cyanide exposure. Just giving it to give it may not be safe.
Have discussion between key stakeholders (fire, EMS, hospital) as to the best approach to managing suspected CN exposures: EMS carrying on all units, supervisor units only, hospital only?
Reference Houston Southwestern Inn LODD report.
http://cdn.christopherwatford.com/emtoday2014/TX-Houston-SW-Inn-final-report.pdf