2. WELCOMEWELCOME
Opening Remarks
Introducing our Distinguished Panelists
MODERATOR: Mark Kelson – Manatt, Phelps
& Phillips, LLP
Tao Xiong – Broad & Bright
Changchun Yuan – Broad & Bright
Jun Li – Broad & Bright
Jim Pitrat – SingerLewak
3. AGENDAAGENDA
General Introduction
Overview of China’s foreign investment regime
Due diligence in China
Structuring investment in China
Strategies to protect IP and other rights in China
5. CHINA’S ECONOMIC GROWTHCHINA’S ECONOMIC GROWTH
REMAINS HIGH IN SPITE OFREMAINS HIGH IN SPITE OF
GLOBAL RECESSIONGLOBAL RECESSION
During the past 30 years, the average annual
GDP growth rate is about 10%.
Despite the global crisis, China’s economy grew
about 11.9% in the first quarter of 2010.
In the second quarter of 2010, China’s economy
surpassed Japan’s, taking its place as the world’s
number two economy.
Now China is so hot, so attractive – All roads lead
to China.
6. FOREIGN INVESTMENTFOREIGN INVESTMENT
IN CHINAIN CHINA
Since 1980, the average increase rate is 20% annually.
In 2008, actual foreign investment used was
USD92.4 billion. In 2009, due to the global economic
crisis, the investment used dropped 2.6%, but still reached
USD90 billion.
Currently, China has more than 430,000 (including
branches) FIEs, and investment made by foreign investors
reached USD350 billion.
In 2009, China was listed as the number two most
attractive country for investment after the United States.
According to the World Investment Report 2010 (United
Nations on August 12, 2010), China will be the most
attractive country for investment in 2011-2012.
Among the developing countries, China has been listed as
first among the most attractive countries for 18 years.
7. ARGUMENTS IN CHINAARGUMENTS IN CHINA
Is China a good place for investment?
Complaints from investors:
heavily regulated market
bureaucratic barriers
foreign exchange control
IP protection
Local protectionism
fewer privileges (national treatment, tax, etc.)
tougher employment law
8. RISKS IN INVESTINGRISKS IN INVESTING
IN CHINAIN CHINA
Doing business in China is an investment – like all
investments – with risks.
Are risks in China any different from those in
other countries?
Expert says: What makes overseas operations
more complex for international investors is that
many of the operational issues in China are
exacerbated by the very fact that they are so far
from the comforts of home, and from a familiar
regulatory and legal environment.
9. CHINESE POLITICALCHINESE POLITICAL
AND LEGAL SYSTEMAND LEGAL SYSTEM
Political System
Unitary state (central government vs. federal
government)
Vertical relationship
Central government (Beijing)
Provincial
Municipal
County
Township
(Village)
10. CHINESE POLITICALCHINESE POLITICAL
AND LEGAL SYSTEMAND LEGAL SYSTEM
Used to be a planned economy, in which
government makes and implements
economic plans
Many government agencies participate in market
regulation
NDRC, MOFCOM, SAFE, SAIC, SASAC, CSRC, CBRC,
SFDA
All of these agencies have their counterparts/
subordinates at various levels of government
11. CHINESE POLITICALCHINESE POLITICAL
AND LEGAL SYSTEMAND LEGAL SYSTEM
Legal System
Civil law tradition (not common law)
Codified law (not case law) – precedents’
instructive function
Administrative regulations (too many, too
complicated)
Local regulations
12. CHINESE POLITICALCHINESE POLITICAL
AND LEGAL SYSTEMAND LEGAL SYSTEM
Court and trial system
Supreme Court – Beijing
High Court – Provincial Level
Intermediate Court – Municipal Level
Primary Court – County Level
In addition to these ordinary courts, there are special
courts such as military court, maritime court and railway
court
Litigation – One first-instance trial and one appeal
13. CHINESE POLITICALCHINESE POLITICAL
AND LEGAL SYSTEMAND LEGAL SYSTEM
Legal Profession
Lawyers are licensed by the Ministry of Justice – qualified
nationally
There is a national bar
A lawyer can practice anywhere in the country
Foreign lawyers in China are not allowed to give advice on
Chinese law
Currently, China has 190,000 lawyers, one attorney for
every 6,977 people.
In California, currently the number of active attorneys is
169,016 (if inactive lawyers are counted, about the same
as China). Current population of California is 37,205,591,
one lawyer for every 220 people.
14. LAW AND REGULATIONSLAW AND REGULATIONS
CONCERNING FOREIGNCONCERNING FOREIGN
INVESTMENTINVESTMENT
Market entry (foreign investment
guidelines/catalog)
Company formation (Rep Office, JV, WOFE,
Partnership, etc.)
Operation (capital requirement, foreign exchange
control, tax, employment)
Incentives (tax holidays, preferential tax
treatment, land supply, local financial
subsidies, etc.)
15. RISKS IN CHINARISKS IN CHINA
Common risks
Regulatory and compliance risk
Socio-poli-economic risk (big picture, long-term
strategy issue)
Integrity and corruption risk
IP risk
Business partner risk
Supply chain risk
Restructuring risk
HR and labor risk
Dispute resolution risk
Natural disaster
16. RISKS IN CHINARISKS IN CHINA
Some are overlooked, while others are exaggerated, e.g.,
Guanxi vs. normal business rules.
People often say “China is different,” and “China is all
about Guanxi.”
Guanxi (government interference plays an important role in
China; Chinese traditional culture pays attention to a close
personal relationship).
People tend to strengthen personal relationships through
gifts, kickbacks, etc. But if you take it for granted, then
you may be in big trouble (anti business bribery laws in
China, Foreign Corrupt Practices Act in the United States).
17. RISK MANAGEMENTRISK MANAGEMENT
Ordinary business principles and prudence should
be followed (don’t only trust someone who has
good connections) – biggest risks
1. business plan/feasibility study
2. due diligence
3. auditing
4. risk evaluation/countermeasures/preparation for
unwanted surprises
5. partner screening
6. negotiation
7. contract draft and review
8. expert advice and opinion
18. DO YOUR HOMEWORKDO YOUR HOMEWORK
Like all other investments
Do your homework
Consult professionals
20. FOREIGN INVESTMENTFOREIGN INVESTMENT
INDUSTRY CATALOGINDUSTRY CATALOG
Encouraged
Examples: software, certain high-tech businesses, high-end
services (logistics, business process outsourcing, etc.)
Permitted
Examples: retail, wholesale distribution, services consultancy
Restricted
Examples: telecom (including Internet), insurance, bank, print
and publishing (special approval required)
Prohibited
Examples: gambling, primary schools, etc.
The Catalog is amended from time to time, latest update as
of October 2007.
21. FORMS OF ENTRYFORMS OF ENTRY
Greenfield investment
Creating a China entity from scratch
Governed by a special set of regulations and rules on the
setup of FIEs (vs. Company Law)
Mergers and acquisitions
Direct onshore equity acquisition by offshore entity
Indirect offshore equity acquisition by offshore entity
Asset acquisition
Governed primarily by the Foreign M&A Regulations (the
so-called “Circular 10”)
22. FORMS OFFORMS OF
ESTABLISHMENTESTABLISHMENT
Representative office
Generally not permitted to “do business” in China
Limited functions: primarily marketing and liaison functions
May not enter into sales contract on behalf of offshore parent
company
Joint ventures
Equity joint ventures (EJV) and Cooperative joint ventures
(CJV)
Parties to an EJV share profits based on their respective shares in
the equity investment, while parties to a CJV may split the profits
disproportionately to their equity percentages.
CJV allows a foreign investor to accelerate its withdrawal of
investment amount out of the CJV.
The highest authority of an EJV is the board of directors, while a
CJV may be managed through a joint management committee.
Required for certain businesses (e.g., restricted industries)
23. FORMS OFFORMS OF
ESTABLISHMENTESTABLISHMENT
Wholly foreign-owned enterprise (WFOE)
Increasingly popular and common form of establishment
for foreign investors
Joint stock company (FICLS)
Capital of an FICLS consists of shares of equal par value
Paid-in capital at least RMB30 million
Existing FIEs must be converted into an FICLS when
seeking a public listing in China
Foreign-invested partnership
Newly issued regulations in late 2009, allowing “foreign-
invested partnerships” effective March 1, 2010
24. Company Name
Reservation with local AIC
Industry preapproval (if
applicable)
Obtain Approval Certificate
from local MOC
Obtain Business License
from local AIC
Tax
registration
Enterprise
ID
registration
SAFE
registration
Finance
registration
Customs
registration
Statistic
registration
FOREIGN INVESTMENTFOREIGN INVESTMENT
REGULATORS ANDREGULATORS AND
ESTABLISHMENT PROCEDURESESTABLISHMENT PROCEDURES
Note: The approval level of MOC may differ under various total amount and national industry guidance.
Flow Chart
26. GENERALGENERAL
CONSIDERATIONS FORCONSIDERATIONS FOR
CHINA INVESTMENTCHINA INVESTMENT
Business objectives/scope
Industry specialties and products
Site selection issues
Overall business model
Entity selection
IP ownership and protection
Financing strategy
International structure
Foreign exchange control issues
Tax issues
Repatriation strategy
Exit strategy
27. DUE DILIGENCEDUE DILIGENCE
IN CHINAIN CHINA
Common practices
Almost no central registration system for security
interest
Court files are not public and mostly not searchable
Management interview very important (not all
transactions are documented in China)
Key issues to watch – examples
Tax incentives and government subsidies
Land use rights and zoning
Social security payments
28. DUE DILIGENCEDUE DILIGENCE
IN CHINAIN CHINA
Site selection issues
Location shopping: business model, local preferential
policies, availability of labor and talents, etc.
Investment LOI or agreement with local governments
Caveat: Local government may not have the authority to
sign the documents.
Know your business partner
Be engaging
Do homework (background check)
Be discreet – challenging or withdrawing
30. U.S. Co.
CHINA Op Co.
STRUCTURES FORSTRUCTURES FOR
CHINA INVESTMENTCHINA INVESTMENT
Direct ownership of Chinese company
31. U.S. Co.
CHINA Op Co.
HOLD Co.
STRUCTURES FORSTRUCTURES FOR
CHINA INVESTMENTCHINA INVESTMENT
Ownership through one or more intermediate
holding companies
Treaty countries/territories: Hong Kong, Singapore,
Barbados, Ireland, and Mauritius
32. INVESTMENT STRUCTURESINVESTMENT STRUCTURES
– TAX CONSIDERATIONS– TAX CONSIDERATIONS
Investment structure has to be right from the
beginning as later change may be taxable
Tax planning must be supported by economic
substance
Overall tax rate
Taxation of income flows from China to ultimate investor
Deferral
Use funds for business purposes
Where current period repatriation or recognition of income
in home country would increase tax burden
Exit
Minimize taxation on capital gain
33. DIRECT OWNERSHIP –DIRECT OWNERSHIP –
CONSIDERATIONSCONSIDERATIONS
Treaty between United States and China would
limit dividend withholding tax to 10%
Disposition of shares in China entity subject to
10% capital gains tax in China
Changes in shareholder(s) require regulatory
approval of Chinese authorities
34. OWNERSHIP THROUGH AOWNERSHIP THROUGH A
HOLDING COMPANY –HOLDING COMPANY –
CONSIDERATIONSCONSIDERATIONS
Shares in Holdco may be transferred without
Chinese government approval
Shares in Holdco may be transferred without
Chinese capital gains tax – much more difficult to
achieve after 2008
Increased focus on anti-avoidance and taxation of
nonresident enterprises
More anti-treaty shopping rules
Taxation of indirect share transfers
Access to reduced dividend withholding tax rate –
must show substantive business reasons, other
than tax avoidance objective
35. BENEFITS OF ANBENEFITS OF AN
INTERMEDIARY HOLDINGINTERMEDIARY HOLDING
COMPANYCOMPANY
Allow U.S. Co. to establish an entity with its own terms and
conditions without being limited to Chinese JV laws
Avoid future Chinese governmental approval on transfer of
ownership in China entity, which saves time and money
Provide an additional buffer from potential liability arising
from U.S. Co.’s China investment
Facilitate future financing strategies for China operations
and expansion
Allows an opportunity for expatriate tax planning where
appropriate (dual employment contracts, etc.)
CHINA Op Co.
37. HOW TO AVOID DISPUTEHOW TO AVOID DISPUTE
AND PROTECT YOURAND PROTECT YOUR
RIGHTS IN CHINARIGHTS IN CHINA
Due to legal and cultural differences, dispute
easier to arise in cross-border transactions
Chinese companies become more litigious
More uncertainty in Chinese laws and regulations
More difficulty in enforcement
38. HOW TO MITIGATE RISKSHOW TO MITIGATE RISKS
OF DOING BUSINESS INOF DOING BUSINESS IN
CHINACHINA
Understand Chinese culture and local business
practices
Plan carefully and move slowly
Form strong business relationships
Establish close relations with government officials
Localization of Management
39. MAJOR TYPES OFMAJOR TYPES OF
DISPUTEDISPUTE
Dispute with Chinese Joint Venture Partners
Dispute with Suppliers and Distributors
IP Infringement
Dispute with Employees
Dispute with Government Authorities
40. HOW TO AVOID DISPUTEHOW TO AVOID DISPUTE
WITH JV PARTNERWITH JV PARTNER
Is your partner able to deliver what you expect?
Take your time to select a right partner
Build trust with your partner
Have a detailed and practical JV Contract
Have a clear exit strategy
41. HOW TO AVOID DISPUTEHOW TO AVOID DISPUTE
WITH SUPPLIER ANDWITH SUPPLIER AND
DISTRIBUTORDISTRIBUTOR
Have clear criteria for supplier or distributor
selection
Keep certain level of control over your suppliers
and distributors
Take particular care for IP protection
42. HOW TO PROTECT IPHOW TO PROTECT IP
RIGHTSRIGHTS
China does protect IP rights and makes the
system work for your benefit
Register IP rights timely
Take both defensive and offensive measures
Educate your Chinese employees
Classify IP rights and limit their access
43. HOW TO AVOID LABOR-HOW TO AVOID LABOR-
RELATED DISPUTERELATED DISPUTE
Know both national and local rules relating to
labor and social welfare
Formulate work-related disciplinary rules and
bylaws
Have a country-tailored and detailed labor
contract
Be careful of the procedural requirements
44. HOW TO DEAL WITHHOW TO DEAL WITH
PRC GOVERNMENTPRC GOVERNMENT
Make efforts and take time to build a trustful
relationship with government
Know the scope and limits of each governmental
authority
Set clear internal guidance on dealing with
officials
Put all important things in writing
45. HOW TO RESOLVE AHOW TO RESOLVE A
DISPUTEDISPUTE
Applicable Law Issue
Litigation vs. Arbitration
Choose a Favorable Venue
47. Risks – considerations for companies doing business in China
Accounting & control challenges in dealing with foreign
subsidiaries
Tax considerations from a U.S. standpoint
48. COMMON FOREIGN OWNEDCOMMON FOREIGN OWNED
ENTITIES IN CHINAENTITIES IN CHINA
-Wholly Owned Foreign Enterprise (WOFE)
-Representative Office
-Joint Venture
49. IP IN CHINA vs. IP NOT IN CHINAIP IN CHINA vs. IP NOT IN CHINA
COST SHARING vs. COST PLUSCOST SHARING vs. COST PLUS
-Transfer pricing requirement and enforcement in China
-Transfer pricing requirement in U.S.
-U.S. CFC rules and subpar F income
-Holding company structure
50. CORPORATE TAXESCORPORATE TAXES
IN CHINAIN CHINA
-Corporate Income Tax (rate change in 2008, tax holiday
grandfather treatment, new holiday for qualified industry and
special zones)
-Business Tax
-Value Added Tax
51. PRC NEW TAX DEVELOPMENT :PRC NEW TAX DEVELOPMENT :
REPRESENTATIVE OFFICEREPRESENTATIVE OFFICE
-Circular 18 effective 1/1/2010
-Limited head count requirement
-Using actual profit method to file quarterly CIT and BT
-Other methods: “actual revenue-based method” (ETR
8.75%) or “cost plus method” (ETR 10.94%)
-Minimum deemed profit rate for cost plus is 15% increased
from previous 10% (the deemed profit rate stipulated in
Circular 19 is generally in the range of 15%-50% dependent
on the type of activities engaged by the nonresident
enterprises)
-Tax authority no long accept tax exemption applications
-Treaty treatment
52. PRC NEW TAX DEVELOPMENT :PRC NEW TAX DEVELOPMENT :
TRANSFER PRICINGTRANSFER PRICING
-Circular 2 issued in 2009 focus on transfer pricing issues
-500 transfer pricing tax officials by the end of 2010 with
intensive training
-167 cases closed in 2009 resulted in RMB 16.09B taxable
income adjustment and RMB 2.09B additional tax
-Transfer pricing report required if revenue > RMB 40M.
A Benchmark report should be in place for revenue < RMB
40M
53. U.S. COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTSU.S. COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS
FOR FOREIGN ENTITIESFOR FOREIGN ENTITIES
-Form 5471 – Information Return of U.S. Persons With
Respect To Certain Foreign Corporations
-Form 8858 – Information Return of U.S. Persons With
Respect To Foreign Disregarded Entities
-Form 8865 – Return of U.S. Persons With Respect to Certain
Foreign Partnerships
-TD F 90-22.1 - Report of foreign bank and financial accounts
54. RISKS – CONSIDERATIONSRISKS – CONSIDERATIONS
FOR COMPANIES DOINGFOR COMPANIES DOING
BUSINESS IN CHINABUSINESS IN CHINA
55. ACCOUNTING & CONTROLACCOUNTING & CONTROL
CHALLENGES IN DEALINGCHALLENGES IN DEALING
WITH FOREIGNWITH FOREIGN
SUBSIDIARIESSUBSIDIARIES