SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 34
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CHAPTER 1: MAGAZINES WORK
CHAPTER 2: ATTENTION MATTERS
CHAPTER 3: QUALITY ATTENTION AND MAGAZINES
CHAPTER 4: WHAT’S AT THE CENTRE OF ATTENTION?
CHAPTER 5: PAY LESS FOR MORE ATTENTION
CONCLUSION
METHODOLOGY
2
3
8
13
18
25
27
28
CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The effectiveness of magazines is
much underestimated, as a recent report
from the Radio Centre ‘Re-evaluating
media’ underlined. An aggregate of all the
media scores in this study shows that the
gap between evidence and perception is
the starkest for magazines.
Narrowing this perception gap is an
important challenge facing the magazine
industry. Our own effectiveness work has
demonstrated the power of magazines
when it comes to long and short term
effects including brand equity, customer
acquisition and activation.
We are keen to tackle this perception
challenge. This report serves to answer
the question ‘why should advertisers and
agencies invest in magazines?’
In today’s media landscape attention is
hugely important. Attention to advertising
matters more than it ever has. There are
more times and places where we can
capture the consumer‘s attention, yet
numerous studies show attention to
advertising is declining. Why? Because
attention is a finite resource and we are in
danger of over exploiting it.
When it comes to attention to
advertising, it seems the more attention
we try to squeeze out of consumers, the
more they find ways to defend against it.
Digital detox, banner blindness and
adblocking are all symptoms of an
advertising ecosystem that is overloaded.
In our rush to embrace all the new ways
we can reach the consumer, to continually
mine and measure this using the new tools
of digitalisation and data, we have focused
too heavily on eyeballs.
Not all reach is equal, and now is the
time to consider quality attention. Quality
attention matters. The neuroscience
evidence shows that advertising that is
encoded into memory is a predictor of
future behavior.  We need to start to
prioritise environments where ad
avoidance is low. These spaces where
advertising is welcome provide a
under-appreciated value.
Magazines provide high quality
attention that is immersive and focused,
more importantly attention to its
advertising is one of the highest. This is
because they provide a positive content
and advertising experience, a relevant
context that enhances receptivity to
advertising and a highly trusted environ-
ment. With magazines, advertising is not
rejected, but seen as a positive part of the
experience.
What’s more, this high-quality
attention doesn’t need to be expensive.
Analysis of CPTs for commonly planned
and bought audiences shows that
magazines are exceptional value.
A BRIEF NOTE ON REPORT SCOPE
Measuring attention is complex; no single
study will be able to provide us with the
full picture and our whitepaper in
collaboration with Bournemouth
university made this apparent. This report
is the start of a journey, from which we
hope some interesting debate will emerge.
We are committed to building our
understanding of attention and the unique
role that magazine media plays for
advertisers.
This report includes evidence for
magazines in print and online, although it
is unashamedly print focused. When it
comes to attention, it is magazine print
environments that deliver the most
focused type of attention. This is not to
dismiss the role of online or indeed any
other channel. All channels have their
own unique part to play and this report
simply serves to underline the modern
role of magazines.
Throughout the report we will clearly
indicate if we are referring to magazines
in print or online.
2
MAGAZINES WORK
THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MAGAZINES
IS MUCH UNDERESTIMATED
CHAPTER 1
Being able to prove the effectiveness of
your marketing has always been critical
and in the current climate of uncertainty,
arguably it’s more important than ever.
Fuelled by the proliferation of data and a
culture of justification, as an industry we
have built up an enviable body of
effectiveness work in the UK.
Every channel has its own
effectiveness evidence and magazines are
no exception. A deeper dive into this
evidence will also reveal against which
objectives different channels excel. This
detail is where a lot of the most useful
information is, because effective campaigns
require a mix of media and figuring out the
role for each channel is a critical question.
This is where the bulk of this paper focuses.
But before we get into that, it’s worth
briefly reviewing the effectiveness
evidence available for magazines.
In ‘Re-evaluating Media’ from the
Radio Centre we find that Magazines
and Newspapers are joint third after TV
and Radio when it comes to generating
ROI. This is significant because in a
survey of advertisers and agencies, for
the same study, magazines were placed
ninth in terms of their perceived ability
to deliver ROI.
3
Source: ‘Re-evaluating media, 2017 (Radiocentre/ Ebiquity)
1
2
3=
3=
5
6
7
8
9
10
WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS
TV
RADIO
NEWSPAPERS
MAGAZINES
ONLINE VIDEO
DIRECT MAIL
SOCIAL MEDIA (PAID)
ONLINE DISPLAY
OUT OF HOME
CINEMA
1
2=
2=
2=
5
6
7
8
9
10
WHAT ADVERTISERS & AGENCIES THINK
TV
RADIO
SOCIAL MEDIA (PAID)
ONLINE VIDEO
DIRECT MAIL
OUT OF HOME
ONLINE DISPLAY
NEWSPAPERS
MAGAZINES
CINEMA
INCREASES IN ROI
‘ALL TYPES OF PRESS APPEAR TO BE EFFECTIVE, BUT CONSUMER
MAGAZINES SEEM TO PRODUCE SURPRISINGLY BIG EFFECTS, GIVEN
THEIR SHARE OF THE BUDGET’
4
Source: ‘Media in Focus’, 2017 (IPA)
At Magnetic, we know that the ability
of magazine to deliver against advertiser
objectives is much underestimated. One of
the challenges is that magazine closures
and circulation figures are often used as
shortcuts to aid decision making about
magazine spend. The reality is that the
decline of magazines is much overstated. If
you look at ABCs for example, you can see
that magazine circulation has stabilised in
recent years. However, the ad spend
decline is much steeper.
Furthermore, the closing of titles
commands understandable headlines but
the opening of titles and launch of new
initiatives less so. The publishing industry
is in the midst of large-scale change,
constantly moving resources to more
relevant areas of the business, including
digital, events and licensing. Whilst all this
is happening, a report by the IPA - ‘Media
in Focus’, shows that magazines have
become more effective over the last ten
years. They show surprisingly big results
when considering the average share of
budget they attract.
Magnetic have carried out a number
of effectiveness studies covering a range
of topics including long- and short-term
effectiveness, brand metrics and ROI, as
well as addressing the effectiveness of
magazines in print and online. For a
detailed understanding of these areas
please see the individual reports cited in
the appendix.
Source: ‘Media in Focus’, 2017 (IPA)
0
2,000,000
4,000,000
6,000,000
8,000,000
10,000,000
12,000,000
14,000,000
16,000,000
18,000,000
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
2010 2017201620152014201320122011
CIRCULATION MAGAZINES £ACTIVELY PURCHASED
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
NO PRESS CONSUMER MAGS NEWSPAPERS INSERTS BUSINESS MAGS
AVERAGENUMBEROFVERYLARGEBUSINESSEFFECTS
1.1
1.9
1.5
1.4
1.25
CIRCULATION(ABCs)
ACTIVELYPURCHASED(ABCs)
MAGAZINES FACILITATE BRAND DISCOVERY
AND DRIVE CUSTOMER ACQUISITION
5
We know from the expert analysis of
Les Binet and Peter Field, in collaboration
with the IPA, that it’s not enough to look
at brand or activation effects in isolation.
In fact, brand building and activation have
a symbiotic relationship. Fail to invest
sufficiently in brand building and, not only
will you fail to build brand equity but, you
will also get a poor response to any
activation work. Spend too little on
activation and you may build strong
brands, but you will struggle to convert
that into results.
Our own study with Peter Field
(’Bridging the Long- and Short-term
Divide’) found that magazines were strong
at driving the following long-term effects;
sale gain, market share gain and customer
acquisition gain. In particular, campaigns
that included magazines showed an
astounding 161 percent higher level of
customer acquisition gain relative to
campaigns that didn’t include magazine
media.
This is a significant finding in today’s
media environment where digital is often
viewed as reigning supreme at delivering
new customers, due to an ability to target
tightly defined audiences. This evidence
suggests that the context offered by
magazine media, which better facilitates
brand discovery, offers an alternative to
the precision point targeting and
optimisation of a purely digital driven
customer acquisition strategy.
PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA
Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic)
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
SALES GAIN
23%
UPLIFT
MARKET SHARE GAIN
74%
UPLIFT
CUSTOMER ACQUISITION GAIN
161%
UPLIFT
%REPORTINGVERYLARGEBUSINESSEFFECTS
NON-USERS OF MAGAZINES USERS OF MAGAZINES
MAGAZINES DELIVER ACTIVATION EFFECTS
6
In our report ‘Bridging the Long- and
Short-term Divide’, we were able to prove
for the first time that, not only do
magazines deliver long term brand value,
they also deliver significant activation
effects. Using magazines in the mix,
results in a 30 percent uplift in activation
effects.
This includes short-term direct
response metrics such as trial, web visits,
search and click throughs. We attribute
the success in activation performance to
the diversification of magazine media
across digital channels.
Other studies such as ‘Profit Ability’ by
Thinkbox, show that print is second only
to TV in terms of delivering both long-
and short-term effects, so it’s clear that
physical magazines have a strong role to
play in the media mix, but what about
magazines online?
ACTIVATION EFFECTS UPLIFT FROM MAGAZINE USAGE
PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA
Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic)
44%
33%
22%
11%
0%
NON-USERS OF MAGAZINES
34%
USERS OF MAGAZINES
44%
%REPORTINGVERYLARGEACTIVATIONEFFECTS
30%
UPLIFT
QUALITY ENVIRONMENTS ONLINE DELIVER STRONGER EFFECTS
7
We have looked at the performance of
magazines online in a number of our
studies. With ‘Metrics That Matter’ we
found that, compared to other digital
environments, magazines online delivered
a stronger brand impact. With campaigns
that used online magazine environments
seeing a 41 percent improvement in KPIs
compared to campaigns that used other
online environments.
The reality is, the best approach is to
use a range of online environments
including quality publishing sites such as
magazines. In our study ‘Bridging the
Long- and Short-term Divide’ we
compared campaigns that used magazines
against those that didn’t. We found that, if
a client was using online rich media, and
they combined this with magazines, they
saw a 44 percent uplift in very large
business effects, compared to campaigns
that didn’t use magazines at all.
We will continue to build and update
our effectiveness evidence; however,
alongside this we believe it is also
important to explore why magazines
work, the rest of the report focuses here.
MAGAZINE MULTIPLIER EFFECTS WITH ONLINE VIDEO
Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic)
PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA
1.8
1.4
0.9
0.5
0
O/L VIDEO WITHOUT MAGAZINES
1.3
O/L VIDEO WITH MAGAZINES
1.8
%REPORTINGVERYLARGEACTIVATIONEFFECTS
44%
UPLIFT
Source: ‘Metrics That Matter’, 2016 (Magnetic)
0.12
0.09
0.06
0.03
0
OTHER DIGITAL ENVIRONMENTS MAGAZINE BRANDS ONLINE
AVERAGEMEDIAKPICONTRIBUTION
41%
UPLIFT
ATTENTION MATTERS
ATTENTION TO ADVERTISING IS DECLINING
CHAPTER 2
The proliferation of media, especially
always on mobile technology, means there
are more times and places where we can
capture consumers’ attention. To put these
changes into a real-world context, it’s
worth knowing that android sends out 11
billion notifications per day, and on
average, consumers check their phone 150
times per day for short bursts of 30
seconds.
This should mean our job is getting
easier. But all the signs are that attention
to advertising is in decline. A recent report
from Teixeira shows a steep decline in the
number of adverts viewed. In the online
environment viewability is widely
acknowledged as a significant challenge,
and a viewable advert doesn’t necessarily
mean the consumer has paid attention to
the advert. Furthermore, the rise of
adblocking software means that all these
opportunities that are being opened up to
reach the consumer are compromised.
TGI data tells a similar story about
attitudes to advertising, with 51 percent of
consumers agreeing that they feel
bombarded by advertising, this up from 45
percent in 2015. Recently, a study from the
Advertising Association think tank
Credos, showed that public favourability
towards advertising hit a record low of 25
percent in December 2018. According to
Credos, shis was the latest measure in a
"long-term decline" in trust in advertising.
There is an inherent contradiction in
attention. As Herb Simon explains, there is
an inverse relationship between the
availability of information and attention.
Increased information results in a scarcity
of attention. This means that attention has
become a precious commodity in our
content rich world.
8
Source: ‘Attention Please the White Paper, 2018 (Bournemouth University)
Source: ‘Attention 2.0’, 2018 (Lumen, Ipsos MORI) Source: TGI, 2018
‘WHAT INFORMATION CONSUMES IS RATHER OBVIOUS: IT CONSUMES THE ATTENTION OF
ITS RECIPIENTS. HENCE A WEALTH OF INFORMATION CREATES A POVERTY OF ATTENTION,
AND A NEED TO ALLOCATE THAT ATTENTION EFFICIENTLY AMONG THE OVERABUNDANCE OF
INFORMATION SOURCES THAT MIGHT CONSUME IT.’
HERBERT A SIMON
CONSUMERS CHECK THEIR PHONE 150 TIMES/DAY FOR SHORT BURSTS OF 30 SECONDS
ANDROID SENDS OUT 11 BILLION NOTIFICATIONS PER DAY
OF ONLINE USERS IN
BRITAIN CLAIM TO
USE AN AD BLOCKER
OF CONSUMERS FEEL
BOMBARDED BY
ADVERTISING
51%47%
THE MEDIA INDUSTRY IS FOCUSED ON REACH AND INTERRUPTIVE ATTENTION
9
The digitalisation of content and
distribution has made attention cheaper
and easier to capture, and the abundance
of data has enabled optimisation. This has
resulted in a reach led approach to
attention, focused on interruptive
strategies, grabbing attention and
maximising eyeballs.
The reality is however, that attention
is a finite resource. Put simply there are
only so many hours in the day. Attention
strategies that are based on the premise of
interruption, capitalising on low quality
attention and maximising reach could
prove problematic for the long-term
health of advertising. Attempting to
squeeze more and more attention out of
increasingly distracted consumers risks
undermining our overall capacity for
attention to advertising.
Communication strategists such as
Oliver Feldwick* and Faris Yakob* have
questioned the sustainability of an
attention-grabbing approach. So how do
we achieve a more sustainable approach?
ACHIEVING A SUSTAINABLE APPROACH TO ATTENTION
The starting point is an appreciation
that not all attention is equal, and that we
need to place greater emphasis on quality
attention. Quality attention is not just
clicks, it can’t be measured in eyeballs
alone, it’s about time well spent, it’s about
focused and immersive attention. Yacob
asks us to consider a spectrum of
attention, to acknowledge for example that
the requisite two seconds online hoping to
attract a thumb is very different to
watching a 30 second commercial in a
darkened movie theatre*.
So instead of grabbing attention, we
need to think about cultivating attention
over the long term; this is a more
sustainable approach. This means
prioritising an approach that values
meaningful media experiences, where
advertising isn’t interruptive and ad
avoidance is low.
*Sources: https://medium.com/@oliverfeldwick/fixing-the-distraction-economy-60525d68b02 | https://medium.com/@faris/
how-to-balance-your-media-plans-8f24858985953
HOW TO MEASURE ATTENTION?
The challenge, as always, comes back
to measurement. Whilst it’s relatively
straightforward to make an intellectual
argument for quality attention, advertisers
will inevitably want to be able to quantify
‘quality attention’. The difficulty here is
that with a mix of complex and subtly
different metrics, it is incredibly hard to
compare attention across different
platforms.
Time spent is one of the standard ways
to measure attention, unfortunately it’s
not as simple as that. A recent report from
Ipsos MORI and Lumen** acknowledges
that, even in the online environment
where dwell time is a standard metric, this
doesn’t provide the full picture. Analysis of
creative performance of digital ads found
that a well created digital advert can
deliver recognition at a glance and aid
brand impact. When a weaker ad might
not perform even with a longer dwell
time.
In our ‘Attention Please’ whitepaper in
collaboration with Bournemouth
University, we outlined the need to
consider intensity of attention; this refers
to a more qualitative understanding of
attention.
**https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf
THERE ARE DIFFERENT TYPES OF ATTENTION
10
Source: Attention Please: the White Paper,
2018  (Bournemouth University)
With this in mind, Bournemouth
University developed a framework for
understanding attention, which acknowl-
edges there are different types. Informed
by a variety of theories, they assert that
attention sits on a spectrum from top
down, which is conscious and immersive,
to bottom up, which is unconscious and
fast.
Alongside this we also need to
consider how people process information.
Information can be processed cognitively,
i.e. analytically based on supporting
arguments, often text based or lists of
attributes or features. Or they can be
processed emotionally based on value
expressive goals linked to self identity.
Typically these are more reliant on
imagery and seek to meets moods, desires
and feelings.
Bottom up: system 1- intuitive, automatic, effortless, associated, fast, unconscious, often occurs when multi-tasking, stimulus driven
Top Down: system 2- controlled, effortful, deductive, slow, self-aware, usually solo focused attention, goal driven
Emotion processing: feeling-based processes, aroused by value expressive goals
Cognitive processing: information is processed rationally, aroused by utilitarian goals
ATTENTION
ATTENTION
ATTENTION
ATTENTION
COGNITIVE
(THINKING / WORDS)
EMOTIONAL
(FEELING / VISUAL)
TOP DOWN
(SLOW)
BOTTOM UP
(FAST)
11
Source: PHD
Source: PHD
It can be argued that different
objectives and sectors are better suited to
different types of attention, so it’s
important to consider this when planning
a campaign. A useful way to think about
this is the idea that attention has different
modes: studying, soaking up, skimming
and scanning. You might select one of
these on the basis of the creative you are
working with, the message that you are
trying to communicate or the behaviour
you are trying to change. Advertisers can
use any or all of these modes depending
on their objectives. For example, the above
Smart Energy campaign used all four
modes deploying cinema and advertorials
in magazines for top down immersive
attention and display advertising and
video online to achieve bottom up
interruptive attention.
Media channels don’t naturally sit in
one mode or another; many straddle a
number of modes depending on how the
channel is deployed and the creative
treatment. A magazine for example, can
be studied, soaked up or skimmed
depending on the title, whether the
consumer is reading in print on, social or
online, and the creative approach taken
with the commercial message. For
example, a display advert, a partnership
strategy, a home page take-over or an
online influencer campaign.
From this framework, the important
take out is to work with the type of
attention that your brand objectives,
creative and media channels are best
suited to. This is the best way to achieve a
higher quality of attention.
STUDYING
SKIMMING
SOAKING UP
SCANNING
COGNITIVE EMOTIONAL
TOP DOWN
BOTTOM UP
COGNITIVE EMOTIONAL
TOP DOWN
BOTTOM UP
Magazines
Outdoor TV
Cinema
QUALITY ATTENTION DRIVES ACTIONS
12
Measuring attention is undeniably a
challenge. A single metric is unlikely to
fully account for the different types of
attention and all the variety of factors that
influence it. In our ‘Attention Please’
whitepaper Bournemouth university
highlighted five contextual factors that
need to be considered when measuring
attention.
a) Advertising goals: Purpose of the
advertisement (desired outcome, remind,
inform, change attitude, build brand etc).
b) Personal goals: Utilitarian or value
expressive (and specific nature of those
goals).
c) Media moment: how the media is being
experienced (escapism, diversion, killing
time).
d) Media brand/channel relationship:
Consumers’ relationship with particular
media brands (pleasure, purpose, trust,
relevance, credibility, personal connection,
emotion, control, personal choice, loyalty).
e) Advertising relationship: Consumers’
relationship with an advertisement (part
of experience, relevance, distracting,
annoying etc).
So is all this complexity worth our
attention because ultimately the measure
of success in advertising comes back to
proving effective outcomes. For attention
to be taken seriously as a topic, there
needs to be a link between attention and
important KPIs, such as purchase and
consideration.
Neuroscience provides some compel-
ling insight into this question. In this field,
attention is referred to as memory
encoding, and memory encoding is seen to
be a crucial metric.  The science shows
that if something isn’t stored into memory,
no matter how much we enjoy it at the
time, it can’t possibly affect our future
behaviour – if it’s not stored away into
memory, it’s simply not there in our heads.
The significance of memory goes even
deeper than this, because our brains are
very selective about what is stored away,
and we tend to encode things for which
the brain has already identified a use.  
Therefore if something is encoded into
memory, this is both an enabler and
predictor of likely future behaviour.
In neuroscience, we find that attention
really matters because the ultimate goal of
any campaign is always to create some
kind of behaviour change.
SOLO FOCUS = % NOT DOING ANYTHING ELSE AT THE TIME
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
90%
68%
45%
23%
0%
58%
MAGAZINES
60%
NEWSPAPERS
30%
TV
11%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
20%
OOH
52%
DIGITAL DISPLAY
(WEBSITES)
35%
SOCIAL
87%
CINEMA
QUALITY ATTENTION
& MAGAZINES
ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES
IS WELCOMED NOT AVOIDED
CHAPTER 3
From our Attention framework we
know that understanding the media
moment is a key component to attention.
So we decided to ask consumers about
their media consumption behaviour.
We chose a claimed survey rather
than monitoring or observing actual
behaviour because we were keen to
understand why people were attending to
something.  Measuring behaviour in situ
has become more popular due to the
availability of eye tracking technology.
However, we are fascinated not just by
eyeballs and where they are looking and
for how long, but also more detailed
questions about what is going on inside
people’s brains and what is driving their
behaviour.
In our consumer data we noticed that
targeted media such as magazines,
newspapers and cinema generally tend to
command the most focused top down
attention. Consumers are more likely to
state that they are doing other things
while consuming broadcast media.
Divided attention is inherently more
competitive, advertising has to work
harder to compete with the alternative
and is more reliant on bottom up attention.
What magazines, newspapers and
cinema have in common is that they are
self-selecting and in most cases, paid for,
their content is often oriented to areas of
special interest to the consumer. This goes
some way to explain why they are
commanding a different type of attention.
13
Although we were interested in the
media moment, the relationship consumers
have with advertising in different media
channels was the area we were most keen
to explore, so we asked a number of
questions on this topic area.
It’s here that we found some strong
results for magazines;  57 percent of
consumers stated that magazine
advertising is part of the experience, the
highest score for any channel.
Consumers tend to experience
magazine advertising more positively than
advertising in other channels. They are
much less likely to think the adverts are
annoying or feel bombarded by them.  
This is because magazine advertising
is less interruptive, not disrupting the core
reason that consumers are engaging,
which is to consume the content. In the
magazine environment there are lots of
opportunities for advertiser objectives and
consumer interests to collide, which is
probably why magazine advertising is the
most welcomed type of advertising.
14
ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES IS WELCOMED NOT REJECTED
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
90%
68%
45%
23%
0%
82%
MAGAZINES
75%
NEWSPAPERS
42%
TV
58%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
58%
DIGITAL DISPLAY
53%
SOCIAL
70%
CINEMA
‘IF THIS MEDIA DIDN’T HAVE ANY ADVERTISING, IT WOULD BE A LOT BETTER’ NET DISAGREE
WITH MAGAZINES ADVERTISING IS PART OF THE EXPERIENCE
‘THE ADVERTS ARE A PART OF THE EXPERIENCE’ NET AGREE
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
57%
MAGAZINES
47%
NEWSPAPERS
44%
TV
47%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
27%
DIGITAL DISPLAY
27%
SOCIAL
55%
CINEMA
Calculated using the average of the following statements:
The adverts are annoying / I feel bombarded by the advertising in this media
NET AGREE (SEE STATEMENTS BELOW)
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
35%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
14%
MAGAZINES
15%
NEWSPAPERS
31%
TV
28%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
12%
OOH
33%
DIGITAL DISPLAY
32%
SOCIAL
16%
CINEMA
MAGAZINE ADVERTISING DOESN’T ATTRACT NEGATIVE PERCEPTIONS
MAGAZINES BENEFIT FROM CONTEXTUAL RELEVANCY
15
Consumers also find magazine
advertising to be more relevant than
advertising in other channels; which again
explains why it’s welcomed and people pay
more attention to it.
Relevancy and attention are closely
linked. In another study, ‘Home Truths’
focused on home furnishing and electron-
ics advertisers, we found that relevantly
placed adverts achieved more attention.
Note the higher scores on the relevantly
placed ads above and left.
This study used an eye tracking
approach and uncovered some interesting
behaviour. We found that for contextually
relevant ads respondents were continually
switching their gaze from left to right and
swapping their attention between
advertising and editorial. Adverts placed
in these environments experience on
average eight times the number of double
takes. Demonstrating the impact of
advertising and editorial working together
in perfect synergy. Our motors study
‘Accelerate’ used the same approach and
reached similar conclusions for car
advertisers. We believe these types of
results are likely to be mirrored in other
high value, high interest sectors.
https://magnetic.media/in-
sight/home-truths-tv-audio
https://magnetic.media/in-
sight/home-truths-connected-technology
https://magnetic.media/insight/acceler-
ate-automotive-report-magnetic
50%
38%
25%
13%
0%
43%
MAGAZINES
34%
NEWSPAPERS
24%
TV
23%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
14%
OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY
24%
27%
SOCIAL
31%
CINEMA
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
MAGAZINE ADS PERFORM BEST ON AD RELEVANCY
RELEVANCY
Thinking about each of the statements below, please select the media channels which you believe apply to each statement.
On a scale of 1-5, how much do you agree with the following - ‘The adverts are relevant to me’.
Base: All adults within each media quota group for each channel.
ADVERTISING PLACED IN A RELEVANT CONTEXT ACHIEVES
A GREATER SHARE OF ATTENTION
Source: ‘Home Truths’, 2018 (Magnetic)
44% 56%
22% 78%
76% 24%
49% 51%
CAN MAGAZINES ONLINE DELIVER QUALITY ATTENTION?
16
So far, we have focused predominantly
on attention in print environments. We
believe it’s important to start here, to
re-state the role of printed magazines
where the case for quality attention is
strongest. However, there is already
evidence to suggest that magazine online
environment achieve a quality of attention
that is better than the digital average.
Lumen, a research agency focused on eye
tracking, online measurement and
attention have a great deal of evidence
about publisher environments which
supports the idea that premium editorial
environments deliver a higher quality of
attention. Work they conducted for us
found that advertising on motors
magazine sites can result in an eight per
cent uplift in likelihood to see the advert.
Furthermore, a digital analytics
company (Moat) conducted some analysis
for us as part of our ‘Metrics That Matter’
study. They compared a selection of
magazine sites to the norms for all Moat
subscribers. They found that the
interaction rate was more than 18 percent
higher for magazine brands online when
compared with other digital
environments, and that interaction time
was 30 percent higher.
Source: Lumen
LIKELIHOOD TO SEE AD DWELL TIME WITH ADS
100%
0%
1.6
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
20%
40%
60%
80%
CAR MAGAZINES OTHER SITES OTHER SITES
59%
68%
0.8
1.5
CAR MAGAZINES
PLACING YOUR CREATIVE IN AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE CONSUMERS PAY
MORE ATTENTION MAKES YOUR INVESTMENT WORK HARD FOR YOU
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
69%
59%
52%
61%
33%
54%
37%
40%
35%
29%
21%
17%
15%
15%
ATTENTION TO CHANNEL ATTENTION TO ADS IN CHANNEL
CINEMA
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERS
TV
COMMERCIAL RADIO
DIGITAL DISPLAY
SOCIAL
CREATIVE HAS A ROLE TO PLAY
MAKE YOUR CREATIVE WORK HARDER WITH MAGAZINES
17
We agree that creative is an important
element to consider if your ambition is to
cultivate high quality attention. Good
creative, however, can be a costly
investment. So it’s good to know that
placing your creative in an environment
where consumers are more likely to pay
attention, certainly ensures that
investment works hard for you. Which is
why we found it particularly interesting
that magazines were the media where
claimed attention to content and attention
to advertising were both high and closely
matched. From this you can see that
magazines successfully convert attention
to their channel into attention to
advertising.
Our attention framework also
acknowledges that advertising goals are a
crucial part of attention and that creative
has a role to play. We know from the IPA’s
strong body of work on effectiveness that
creativity is a powerful force.
This is also further supported by the
brilliant work of System 1*  whose
long-term analysis of creative and what
drives effectiveness reveals three
important creative principles; fame,
feeling and fluency.  
More recently, work conducted by
Lumen and Ipsos MORI has uncovered
how creative can impact on attention in
the online environment. Here they find
that many of the established principles
hold true. Their report Attention 2**,
underlines the importance of distinctive
brand assets, strong visuals and a simple
message; which they find are more likely
to get the audience's attention and more
importantly drive brand recall or
recognition.
To fully understand how to cultivate
attention, we need to explore how media
environment and creative interact and are
best deployed to achieve quality attention.
This is one of the areas we plan to explore
further in the next phase of ‘Pay Attention’.
Sources: *https://www.system1research.com/blog/fame-feeling-and-fluency-the-only-brand-metrics-you-will-ever-need
**https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf
92%
DIGITAL
Source: PAMCo Oct 2017–Sep 2018
MAGAZINES ARE TIME WELL SPENT
89%
PRINT
MAGAZINES – A POSITIVE EXPERIENCE
Immersion and undivided attention on
one thing for a sustained period makes our
brains calmer and less anxious. It’s why
reading books helps us sleep. It’s why
reading magazines make us smile.
Evidence of a link between magazine
reading and a positive effect on wellbeing
comes from two separate studies.
‘Moments That Matter’ uncovered a 6
percent uplift in subjective wellbeing; a
metric developed by world renown
happiness expert Professor Paul Dolan.
A study from Hearst, ‘The Power of
Positivity’, has also revealed that
magazines alongside cinema, music
streaming and a selection of your
favourite tv shows on demand make
people feel more positive than other media
experience. This group of media experi-
ences really excels at harnessing positivity.
It is significant at a time when the
debate about the impact of digital content
on our happiness still rages, especially
with regards to social media. The debate
tends to focus on the nature of the content
and the impact on our wellbeing of
constantly switching tasks. Furthermore;
the Hearst study made a link between the
ability of magazines to make readers
happy and advertising effectiveness. The
study found that 26 percent of magazine
consumers went on to buy a product they
had seen advertised, versus 11 percent for
non-magazine readers.
Although this is predominantly a print
led argument, PAMCo, the audience
measurement currency for the industry,
finds that 92 percent of readers agree
magazine content online is also time well
spent.
WHAT’S AT THE CENTRE
OF ATTENTION?
MAGAZINES CULTIVATE ATTENTION THROUGH THE
RELATIONSHIP THEY HAVE WITH THEIR READERS
CHAPTER 4
The case for magazines as a quality
attention environment is strong, but what
is it about magazines that enable them to
successfully deliver this for advertisers? A
closer look at the relationship they have
with their readers and the nature of
magazine content starts to reveal what is
at the centre of this attention. Three
underlying qualities explain our
hypothesis.
Magazines offer advertisers quality
attention because they are
- Positive
- Relevant
- Trusted
18
19
This speaks for the nature of the
content playing a key role rather than just
the channel. When readers are immersed
in quality content, whether that be in
print or online, they are less inclined to
switch away and get distracted. They see
reading magazines as time well spent, time
when they want to keep their attention
focused.
The fact that reading a magazine is
experienced positively by the consumer
and is considered time well spent provides
benefits for advertisers too. As we have
shown in ‘Attention Please’, this benefit
translates to the way advertising is
experienced in magazines. Magazines are
the highest scoring channel when it comes
to positive attitudes towards advertising
and the lowest scoring channel when it
comes to negative attitudes to advertising.
The attention that magazines cultivate
is highly positive and valued by the
consumer and this provides a high quality
environment for advertisers.
CONSUMERS HAVE POSITIVE PERCEPTIONS OF ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
30%
23%
15%
8%
0%
30%
MAGAZINES
21%
NEWSPAPERS
15%
TV
13%
COMMERCIAL
RADIO
9%
OOH
14%
DIGITAL DISPLAY
15%
SOCIAL
20%
CINEMA
Calculated using the average of the following statements:
‘The adverts are relevant to me’ / ‘I love the range of advertising this media gives me’ / ‘The adverts feature brands I like’
MAGAZINES - A RELEVANT CONTEXT
20
We know that brand relevancy is an
important KPI from our ‘Metrics That
Matter’ study. According to the analysis
conducted, relevancy is an interesting
brand perception as it has the biggest
impact on brand KPIs, but is the hardest
for media to move.
This study found that magazines were
the number one channel at driving brand
relevancy, a distinctiveness or level of
differentiation that is more targeted.
Magazine content is largely aimed at
to consumer interests, be that fashion or
football, television or travel, so relevancy
is at the core of magazines. A recent report
from Enders Analysis underlined the
value of being present in these passion
orientated environments and the value of
the ‘passion pound’. It found that people
are spending more money on passions.
The report charts the rise of the passion
pound. It identifies a rising ‘Identity
Economy’, where identity categories made
up 52 percent of discretionary household
spending last year, and captured 79
percent of the growth in spend in the last
five years.
Source: ‘Metrics That Matter’, 2016 (Magnetic)
10%
8%
5%
3%
0%
RELEVANCE
QUALITY
PRESENCE
INNOVATION
VALUEFORMONEY
TASTE
EMOTION
TRUST
QUALITY(PERFORMANCE)
KNOWLEDGE
RANGE
PERSONALITY
PRESENCE(PACKAGING)
HERITAGE
TRUST(RELIABLE)
EXPERT
HEALTH
REPUTATION
EASYTOUSE
CONVENIENCE
CUSTOMERUNDERSTANDING
CUSTOMERSERVICE
MODERN
LEADER
INTEGRITY
STYLISH
CUSTOMERCARE
ACCEPTABILITY
DIFFERENCE
APPEAL
CULTURE(TRADTION)
PRESTIGE(LUXURY)
NOSTALGIA
FAMILY
SUITABILITY(VERSATILITY)
STANDSOUT
CULTURE
BONDING
ASSOCIATION
POPULAR
OFFERS
KIDREQUEST
PRESTIGE(PREMIUM)
SPEED/TIME
GUIDANCE
SUITABILITY(OCCASION)
FAMILY(CHILDREN)
TEXTURE
PRESTIGE
FAMILY(FRIENDS)
EVALUATION OF ICE DATABASE MADE UP OF 65 STUDIES FROM 2010-2015
AVERAGEMEDIAKPICONTRIBUTION
GROWTH OF THE PASSION POUND
Source: ‘Passion Pays’, 2018 (Enders/Magnetic)
£THE IDENTITY ECONOMY ACCOUNTS FOR
52% OF HOUSEHOLD SPENDING…
…AND 79% OF GROWTH IN
SPEND IN THE LAST 5 YEARS
RELEVANCE AN IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTOR TO BRAND KPIs
% CONTRIBUTION TO BRAND KPIs
21
Source: PAMCo, Oct17-Sep18
Source: ‘Passion Pound’, 2018 (Enders/ Magnetic)
Magazine content speaks to these
passions, covering subject matter as
diverse as fashion, food and film, music,
motoring and make-up, subject matter
that really matters to their audiences.  
PAMCo tells us that readers feel a close
connection to magazine content, 72
percent of readers in both print and
online agree.
The Enders report makes a connection
between the economic opportunity of the
passion pound and a missed marketing
opportunity.  In ‘Identity Economy’
categories, ad spend grew spend just 1.7
percent in two years, much lower than
overall ad growth of 12 percent. This
discrepancy can be explained by the
ongoing shift to online performance
channels like search and in-feed social
media advertising.
The report calls for more investment
in emotionally and culturally relevant
media, such as magazines, citing academic
research that suggests media
environments that make our identity
more salient have a positive impact on
decision making. It calls for less reliance of
hyper-targeted behavioural-led strategies
which may reach the right people with the
right message but ignore context. The
report underlines that consumers can be
more receptive to messages based on how
salient their identity as a consumer of the
category is at the time.
READERS FEEL A CLOSE CONNECTION TO MAGAZINES
72%72%
THE MISSED OPPORTUNITY OF THE PASSION POUND
GROWTH IN ADVERTISING SPEND GROWTH IN CONSUMER SPEND
10%
-11%
10%
6%
10%
24%
24%
-1%
-2%
-14%
-18%
-5%
7%
-24%
14%
10%
2%
9%
18%
17%
31%
-15%
11%
24%
8%
11%
28%
10% 10% 0% 10% 10% 10% 10%
FASHION
HOME & DIY
TRAVEL
CARS
HOBBIES
CHARITIES
COMPUTERS & GAMING
FITNESS & SPORTS
FOOD (EATING OUT)
ARTS
MUSIC (AUDIO EQUIPMENT)
GARDENING
PETS
22
Magazines cover subjects that really
matter to their audience and this
passion-driven consumption provides a
highly attentive audience.
What’s more, this audience is more
receptive to commercial messages. As we
have seen in ‘Attention Please’, magazine
advertising is the highest scoring channel
when it comes to advertising being seen as
relevant. These strong results are
underpinned by the opportunity that
magazines offer, a high degree of
contextual relevance.
Using the contextual impact of
magazines doesn’t have to be limited to
passion areas, as the award-winning case
study from Smart Energy proves. With a
clever content strategy, even a subject as
low involvement as your energy provider
can be made relevant by connecting to
areas of consumer interest.
https://magnetic.media/magnetic-case-stu
dies/smart-energy-persuade-67-of-young-
people-to-install-a-smart-meter-with-fully
-integrated-campaign
Magazine brands are experts in content
that matters to consumers, and they can
put brands in front of people who care
about these subject matters. This speaks
volumes when it comes to commanding
attention.
EVEN IF YOU REACH THE RIGHT PEOPLE
WITH THE RIGHT MESSAGE, THEY CAN BE
MORE OR LESS RECEPTIVE TO IT BASED ON
HOW SALIENT THE RIGHT PARTS OF THEIR
IDENTITY ARE AT THE TIME – A FACTOR
AFFECTED BY MEDIA CONTEXT.
Source: ‘Passion Pound’, 2018 (Enders/ Magnetic)
MAGAZINES - A TRUSTED RELATIONSHIP
23
The relationship that magazines have
with their readers is based on trust. This is
backed up by a number of studies from
outside the publishing sector, including
surveys from Kantar and Ofcomm.
These studies both agree that
magazines are the most trusted source for
news. Our own study ‘A Matter of Trust’,
also found that magazines were more
trusted than social media for content on
fashion, beauty, home, motors and
entertainment, as well as news.
PAMCo also backs this up with figures
showing that magazines achieve high
levels of trust across a range of content
areas and an average trust score of 82
percent in print and 84 percent online.
MAGAZINES ARE TRUSTED ACROSS A RANGE OF SECTORS IN PRINT & ONLINE
Source: PAMCo Oct 2017–Sep 2018
Source: ‘News Consumption in the UK’, 2018 (Ofcom) / ‘Trust in News’, 2018 (Kantar)
OF MAGAZINE READERS SAY
THAT THEY TRUST WHAT THEY
READ IN MAGAZINES
80%
OF PEOPLE SAY THAT
MAGAZINES ARE THEIR MOST
TRUSTED SOURCE FOR NEWS
72%
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
ALL MAGAZINES
84%
FOOD MAGAZINES
92%
MOTORS MAGAZINES
89%
HOMES MAGAZINES
89%
82%
91%
86% 87%
PRINT DIGITAL
Source: ‘Passion Content Launch’, 2016 (Magazine Publishers of Australia, Fiftyfive5)
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
MAGAZINES
(PRINT)
MAGAZINES
(ONLINE)
BLOGS INTERNET RADIO
(ONLINE)
NEWSPAPER
(PRINT)
TV
(LIVE)
TV
(ONLINE)
SOCIAL
MEDIA
NEWSPAPERS
(ONLINE)
RADIO
(LIVE)
OOH
‘MAKES ME MORE CONFIDENT ABOUT BUYING PRODUCTS FEATURED OR ADVERTISED HERE’
56% 55%
53%
50%
39% 38%
33%
30%
23%
31%
26%
12%
24
Source: ‘A Matter of Trust’, 2017 (Magnetic/ MediaCom)
Editorial standards and expert journalism
is at the heart of these results. We know
from our ‘Matter of Trust’ study that it’s
relevancy, reliability and expertise that
underpins the trusted status of magazines.
Magazine brands are experts in
curating high quality content for their
readers. They are a trusted authority for
many consumers when it comes to areas
close to their hearts.
The trusted environment of magazines
delivers quality attention and there is a rub
effect for advertisers. ‘Matter of Trust’ also
found that brands who invested in
magazine advertising saw significant
uplifts in brand attributes connected to
trust. This is backed up by a study from
Magazine Networks Australia which finds
that magazines are the best channel to
build confidence in products. In fact, they
are 77 percent more critical to building
product confidence compared to social
media.
Magazines are highly trusted brands in
themselves and the confidence consumers
have in their content and editorial enables
advertisers to build confidence in their
brands too.
THE DRIVERS OF TRUST IN MEDIA BRANDS
TRUST TRANSLATES INTO BRAND CONFIDENCE
31%
RELEVANCY
& MEANING
9%
TRANSPARENCY
8%
VIEWPOINT
DIVERSITY
5%
REPUTATION
& FAME
27%
RELIABILITY
& ETHICS
20%
EXPERTISE
& OBJECTIVITY
You might expect quality attention to
come at a premium. You only need to look
at average planning costs* to see this is not
the case. We have gathered some planning
costs from a number of sources, including
publicly available data from Ebiquity and
WARC. In partnership with PHD, we
applied a factoring so to get to audience
costs that better reflect the most
commonly planned and bought
demographics, rather than relying on ‘all
adults’ figures,
Of course, these are still average costs.
Buyers will deal with different costs
depending on programmes, titles and
packages. In addition, costs will vary to
some extent by agency group. However, the
shape of the costs on average will remain
broadly the same.
What you will notice here is that
magazines consistently feature in middle of
this range. If you consider that magazine
attention is high, it starts to reveal the
exceptional value that magazines offer.
PAY LESS FOR
MORE ATTENTION
QUALITY ATTENTION DOESN’T HAVE
TO BE EXPENSIVE
CHAPTER 5
25
*CPT data is taken from a combination of Warc data and Ebiquity data published in the ‘Re-evaluating Media’ report. These provide
adult cost per thousands. We then used PHD audience CPT data to apply a factoring to create costs for 16-34s, HH+CH and ABC1s. See
Methodology section for more detailed explanation.
£45.00
£0.00
£5.00
£10.00
£15.00
£20.00
£25.00
£30.00
£35.00
£40.00
SOCIAL DIGITAL DISPLAY RADIO OOH MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS CINEMATV
16-34
£50.00
£45.00
£0.00
£5.00
£10.00
£15.00
£20.00
£25.00
£30.00
£35.00
£40.00
RADIO SOCIAL NEWSPAPERS MAGAZINES OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY CINEMATV
ABC1
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
£60.00
£0.00
£10.00
£20.00
£30.00
£40.00
£50.00
SOCIAL RADIO DIGITAL DISPLAY MAGAZINES OOH NEWSPAPERS CINEMATV
HH KIDS
CPT(£)CPT(£)CPT(£)
MAGAZINES PROVIDE HIGH QUALITY ATTENTION AT EXCEPTIONAL VALUE
26
This becomes even clearer when you
plot attention to advertising and media cost
in combination. It shows that what
magazines deliver is high quality attention
at exceptional value. High quality attention
doesn’t have to be expensive. With
magazines you pay less for more attention.
Magazines have one of the highest levels of
attention to advertising, second only to
cinema, but are more competitive on cost. If
you consider the high attention channels,
magazines have the lowest cost of all of
these for two of the three key buying
audiences. We looked at how Attention vs
CPT analysis changed for 16-34s, HH+CH
and ABC1s; which account for the majority
of the ad spend in the UK market place.
Magazines come out the most favourably
for 16-34s and HH+CH, with Newspapers
being the most competitive high attention
channel for ABC1s.
*CPT data is taken from a combination of Warc data and Ebiquity data published in Re-evaluating media report. These provide adult cost
per thousands. We then used PHD audience CPT data to apply a factoring to create costs for 16-34’s, HH+CH and ABC1’s. See Methodology
section for more detailed explanation.
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
ATTENTION TO ADS: 16–34s ATTENTION & CPT
ATTENTION TO ADS: ABC1s ATTENTION & CPT
ATTENTION TO ADS: HHKIDS ATTENTION & CPT
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
£50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERS
TV
RADIODISPLAY
SOCIAL
OOH
CINEMA
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERSTV
RADIO
DISPLAY
SOCIAL
OOH
CINEMA
£50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERS
TV
RADIO
DISPLAY SOCIAL
OOH
CINEMA
£50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00
CONCLUSION
Magazines are an under-rated media
channel when it comes to effectiveness.
There is a big gap between the evidence
and perceptions of effectiveness.
Given declining trust and openness to
advertising, attention to advertising is an
increasingly important area to consider
when planning campaigns.
Attention comes in many forms, but
the type of attention that magazines offer
warrants more serious consideration.
Magazines offer advertisers a high
attention environment, which translates
into high attention to the message. This is
because magazines  provide:
- A positive content and advertising
experience
- A relevant context that enhances
receptivity to advertising
- A highly trusted environment
With magazines, advertising is not
rejected, it is seen as a positive part of the
experience.
What’s more, this high-quality
attention doesn’t need to be expensive. If
you take price into consideration, you
actually pay less for more attention with
magazines.
27
METHODOLOGY:
ATTENTION PLEASE
THE SURVEY
Stage one of the ‘Attention Please’
project was conducted as a 20 minute
online survey of claimed behaviour in
relation to various media types. The
survey was conducted among 2,000 adults
in the UK.
THE CHANNELS COVERED
The survey covered Magazines,
Newspapers, TV, Radio, OOH, Digital
Display, Social and Cinema.
Due to the number of media channels,
each respondent was allocated up to four
media channels to answer questions
about, based on channel usage.
All channels are analysed based on
users of that channel only.
All channels were set quotas to ensure
a mix of frequency of usage, i.e. a mix of
heavier, medium and lighter users. The
heavy / medium / light levels were set
based on TGI definitions.
If a respondent was assigned a
channel this was labelled as Media Quota
Group for that channel.
WEIGHTING
Data at total sample level was
weighted to be the same broad age, gender
and social grade splits across media quota
groups
SAMPLE SIZES
All media quota groups had some
broad quotas set to aim for 40 percent
light users, 30 percent medium users, and
30 percent heavy users at total level.
Frequency groups below were predomi-
nately put together using TGI definition
where available. Nationally representative
TGI definitions are c. 50 percent light, 30
percent medium and 20 percent heavy,
however our sample were naturally
slightly heavier media consumers due to
the cross channel media requirements.
28
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
820
949
985
983
986
982
983
988
TOTAL
230
266
276
270
271
270
275
271
16-34s
494
573
601
589
596
594
600
592
ABC1s
234
259
191
238
171
166
186
206
HOUSEPERSON
WITH KIDS
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERS
TV
COMMERCIAL RADIO
OOH
DIGITAL DISPLAY
SOCIAL
CINEMA
SAMPLE SIZE
CPT METHODOLOGY
The CPT data was sourced at an All
Adults level through a combination of
WARC 2016 published data and Ebiquity’s
2018 study ‘Re-evaluating Media’ for the
Radiocentre.
WARC CPT data was used for Cinema,
TV, Magazines, Press and Radio while
Ebiquity data was used for Social Media
and Digital Display.
OOH data was taken using a
combination of the data sources and
needed to be adjusted to factor in a 6 sheet
and 48 sheet blended average, paper and
digital.
We then identified three key buying
audiences, 16-34s, ABC1s and Households
with kids. In order to project equivalent
costs for each of these audiences, factors
were applied to the All Adults CPT data.
This was calculated using PHD buying
data for each of the three audiences.
29
NON USER LIGHT MEDIUM HEAVY
MAGAZINES
NEWSPAPERS
TV
COMMERCIAL RADIO
OOH
DIGITAL DISPLAY
SOCIAL
CINEMA
Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic)
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
ONCE A MONTH (WEEKLY)
OR EVERY FEW MONTHS
(MONTHLY)
EVERY OTHER ISSUE
FOR WEEKLY OR
MONTHLY
EVERY ISSUE FOR
WEEKLY OR MONTHLY
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
ONCE A WEEK (DAILY)
OR ONCE A MONTH
(WEEKLY)
EVERY OTHER ISSUE
FOR DAILY OR
WEEKLY
EVERY ISSUE FOR
DAILY OR WEEKLY
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
LESS THAN 20 HOURS
PER WEEK
LESS THAN 5 HOURS
PER WEEK
TRAVEL 0.5-3.5 HOURS
PER WEEK
LESS THAN 5 TIMES
A DAY
LESS THAN TWICE
A YEAR
20-30 HOURS PER WEEK 30+ HOURS PER WEEK
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
5-15 HOURS
PER WEEK
OVER 15 HOURS
PER WEEK
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
TRAVEL 4-8.5
HOURS A WEEK
TRAVEL 9+
HOURS A WEEK
NO QUOTAS SET AS ONLINE PANEL ALL HIGH INTERNET USAGE
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
5 TIMES A DAY
10 TIMES A DAY
OR MORE
NO NON USERS OF
CHANNEL WITHIN
QUOTA GROUP
2-3 TIMES A YEAR
(ONCE EVERY 2-3
MONTHS)
ONCE A MONTH
OR MORE OFTEN
SAMPLE DESIGN
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION
APPENDIX
Magnetic Research
A Matter of Trust (Mediacom)
https://magnetic.media/insight/a-matter-of-trust-insight
Attention Please: The Whitepaper (Bournemouth University)
https://magnetic.media/insight/attention-please
Moments that Matter
https://magnetic.media/insight/moments-that-matter-insight
Home Truths (Emotional Logic)
https://magnetic.media/insight/home-truths-insight
Bridging the long- and short-term divide (Peter Field)
https://magnetic.media/insight/bridging-long-short-term-divide-new-insight
Accelerate (Emotional Logic)
https://magnetic.media/insight/accelerate-automotive-report-magnetic
Why being different still makes a difference (Millward Brown)
https://magnetic.media/insight/why-being-different-still-makes-a-difference-insight
Passion Pound (Enders)
https://magnetic.media/insight/passion-pounds
Metrics that Matter (Carat)
https://magnetic.media/insight/metrics-that-matter-insight
APPENDIX
Other Research
Attention 2.0 (IPSOS Mori and Lumen)
https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf
Re-evaluating media (Radio Centre)
https://www.radiocentre.org/re-evaluating-media/
Magazine Networks Australia
http://www.magazines.org.au/wp-content/uploads/Fiftyfive5-MPA-Passion-Content-Launch-Research-Debrief-final.pdf
Media in Focus (IPA)
https://effworks.co.uk/download-media-in-focus/
News Consumption in the UK (Ofcom)
https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0024/116529/news-consumption-2018.pdf
Trust in news (Kantar)
https://www.tnsglobal.be/fake_news_trust_mainstream_news_brands
THE MA R KETING A GENCY FOR MAGAZINE MEDIA IN THE UK

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.research
Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.researchWhich Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.research
Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.researchMediaSense
 
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014Conversant what's driving_digital_2014
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014Jim Nichols
 
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant Research
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant ResearchWhat's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant Research
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant ResearchConversant, Inc.
 
Marketing_Services_TLP
Marketing_Services_TLPMarketing_Services_TLP
Marketing_Services_TLPMarta Rebelo
 
Understanding what works
Understanding what worksUnderstanding what works
Understanding what worksMSJ14
 
Genesis.milennial.mm model.f
Genesis.milennial.mm model.fGenesis.milennial.mm model.f
Genesis.milennial.mm model.fMichael Wolfe
 
The economist intelligence unit: Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anyway
The economist intelligence unit:  Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anywayThe economist intelligence unit:  Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anyway
The economist intelligence unit: Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anywayAidelisa Gutierrez
 
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORT
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORTChelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORT
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORTCarolina Plexidas
 
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAP
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAPNielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAP
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAPDmytro Lysiuk
 
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care Brand
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care BrandEarned Media Amplification - Personal Care Brand
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care BrandMasood Akhtar
 
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017Phillip Keefe
 
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown Digital
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown DigitalThe Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown Digital
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown DigitalSanoma Belgium
 
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling Innovations in Market Mix Modelling
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling Absolutdata Analytics
 
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)Carolina Feng Chen
 
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement Michael Wolfe
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.research
Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.researchWhich Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.research
Which Way Now? Justin Gibbons, work.research
 
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014Conversant what's driving_digital_2014
Conversant what's driving_digital_2014
 
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant Research
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant ResearchWhat's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant Research
What's Driving Digital Marketing in 2014? Conversant Research
 
Marketing_Services_TLP
Marketing_Services_TLPMarketing_Services_TLP
Marketing_Services_TLP
 
Measuring voc cust exper.gap
Measuring voc cust exper.gapMeasuring voc cust exper.gap
Measuring voc cust exper.gap
 
The Ad Quality Conundrum
The Ad Quality ConundrumThe Ad Quality Conundrum
The Ad Quality Conundrum
 
Understanding what works
Understanding what worksUnderstanding what works
Understanding what works
 
Genesis.milennial.mm model.f
Genesis.milennial.mm model.fGenesis.milennial.mm model.f
Genesis.milennial.mm model.f
 
The economist intelligence unit: Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anyway
The economist intelligence unit:  Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anywayThe economist intelligence unit:  Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anyway
The economist intelligence unit: Voice of the customer, whose job is it, anyway
 
Predictive analytics
Predictive analyticsPredictive analytics
Predictive analytics
 
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORT
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORTChelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORT
Chelsea-1-2016-MSCSM-MCP REPORT
 
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAP
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAPNielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAP
Nielsen. THE MOBILE ROADMAP
 
ROI Summary
ROI SummaryROI Summary
ROI Summary
 
Alterians
AlteriansAlterians
Alterians
 
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care Brand
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care BrandEarned Media Amplification - Personal Care Brand
Earned Media Amplification - Personal Care Brand
 
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017
Crystal Light PDRF Paper FINAL with cover 02-06-2017
 
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown Digital
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown DigitalThe Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown Digital
The Print Campaign Analysis by Millward Brown Digital
 
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling Innovations in Market Mix Modelling
Innovations in Market Mix Modelling
 
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)
PPT Deck - Stukent Case Study (Global Attribution)
 
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
 

Ähnlich wie Pay attention-final-report.pd

Bridging the long/short term divide
Bridging the long/short term divideBridging the long/short term divide
Bridging the long/short term dividemagazinemediaBE
 
ExactTarget Research - Audience Growth
ExactTarget Research - Audience GrowthExactTarget Research - Audience Growth
ExactTarget Research - Audience GrowthShawn Herring
 
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New Audiences
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New AudiencesUsing Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New Audiences
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New AudiencesContent Marketing Institute
 
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and Online
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and OnlineCome Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and Online
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and OnlineHoward Finberg
 
Nielsen CMO Report-2018
Nielsen CMO Report-2018Nielsen CMO Report-2018
Nielsen CMO Report-2018Mr Nyak
 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes. 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes.  Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes. 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes.  Udit Joshi
 
About PAN
About PANAbout PAN
About PANpancomm
 
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017Samuel Griffin-Flynn
 
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1MTCResearch
 
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015360i
 
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement  Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement Michael Wolfe
 
Predictive scoring essential to your retention strategy webinar slides
Predictive scoring   essential to your retention strategy webinar slidesPredictive scoring   essential to your retention strategy webinar slides
Predictive scoring essential to your retention strategy webinar slidesLouise Byrne
 
Know the value of media report
Know the value of media reportKnow the value of media report
Know the value of media reportIan Adams
 
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...BacsUK
 
2008 Powered Roi Report Final
2008 Powered Roi Report Final2008 Powered Roi Report Final
2008 Powered Roi Report FinalRalph Paglia
 

Ähnlich wie Pay attention-final-report.pd (20)

Bridging the long/short term divide
Bridging the long/short term divideBridging the long/short term divide
Bridging the long/short term divide
 
Media in Focus
Media in FocusMedia in Focus
Media in Focus
 
ExactTarget Research - Audience Growth
ExactTarget Research - Audience GrowthExactTarget Research - Audience Growth
ExactTarget Research - Audience Growth
 
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New Audiences
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New AudiencesUsing Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New Audiences
Using Content Marketing to Generate Demand, Create New Audiences
 
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and Online
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and OnlineCome Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and Online
Come Together: Defining the Complementary Roles of Print and Online
 
Pa685 m7 ppt_alternate
Pa685 m7 ppt_alternatePa685 m7 ppt_alternate
Pa685 m7 ppt_alternate
 
Nielsen CMO Report-2018
Nielsen CMO Report-2018Nielsen CMO Report-2018
Nielsen CMO Report-2018
 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes. 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes.  Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes. 
Studying the Link Between Volume of Media Coverage and Business Outcomes. 
 
About PAN
About PANAbout PAN
About PAN
 
The 2016 State of Social Business
The 2016 State of Social BusinessThe 2016 State of Social Business
The 2016 State of Social Business
 
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017
Salterbaxter Campaignable Reporting 2017
 
Disseration
Disseration Disseration
Disseration
 
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1
Pamro2010 Cecilia Patterson Conference Paper1 Final1
 
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015
Marketing Leadership Playbook 2015
 
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement  Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
Innovations in marketing effectiveness measurement
 
Predictive scoring essential to your retention strategy webinar slides
Predictive scoring   essential to your retention strategy webinar slidesPredictive scoring   essential to your retention strategy webinar slides
Predictive scoring essential to your retention strategy webinar slides
 
Know the value of media report
Know the value of media reportKnow the value of media report
Know the value of media report
 
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...
Current Account Switch Service: Interventions to foster an effective and comp...
 
2008 Powered Roi Report Final
2008 Powered Roi Report Final2008 Powered Roi Report Final
2008 Powered Roi Report Final
 
Measuring Print ROI
Measuring Print ROIMeasuring Print ROI
Measuring Print ROI
 

Mehr von Magazine Media Associatie

Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdf
Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdfMagazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdf
Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdfMagazine Media Associatie
 
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdf
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdfRapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdf
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdfMagazine Media Associatie
 
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdf
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdfrapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdf
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdfMagazine Media Associatie
 
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdf
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdfTrendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdf
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdfMagazine Media Associatie
 
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdf
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdfrapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdf
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdfMagazine Media Associatie
 

Mehr von Magazine Media Associatie (20)

Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdf
Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdfMagazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdf
Magazine Media Associatie Social Media Monitor Q1-24.pdf
 
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdf
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdfRapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdf
Rapportage over gebruik media NMO Mediatrends 2023.pdf
 
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdf
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdfrapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdf
rapportage MMA Social Media Monitor Q4 2023.pdf
 
Social Media Monitor Q3-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q3-23.pdfSocial Media Monitor Q3-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q3-23.pdf
 
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdf
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdfTrendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdf
Trendrapport onderzoek stress en lezen - september 2023.pdf
 
Social Media Monitor Q2-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q2-23.pdfSocial Media Monitor Q2-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q2-23.pdf
 
Social Media Monitor Q1-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q1-23.pdfSocial Media Monitor Q1-23.pdf
Social Media Monitor Q1-23.pdf
 
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q4-22.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q4-22.pdfMMA - Social Media Monitor Q4-22.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q4-22.pdf
 
GfK Trends in digitale media 2022.pdf
GfK Trends in digitale media 2022.pdfGfK Trends in digitale media 2022.pdf
GfK Trends in digitale media 2022.pdf
 
MMA Magazine Media Factbook 2023
MMA Magazine Media Factbook 2023MMA Magazine Media Factbook 2023
MMA Magazine Media Factbook 2023
 
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q3 2022.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q3 2022.pdfMMA - Social Media Monitor Q3 2022.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q3 2022.pdf
 
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q2-22.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q2-22.pdfMMA - Social Media Monitor Q2-22.pdf
MMA - Social Media Monitor Q2-22.pdf
 
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdf
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdfrapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdf
rapportage social media monitor Q1 2022 .pdf
 
Bits en bites magazine media anno 2022
Bits en bites magazine media anno 2022Bits en bites magazine media anno 2022
Bits en bites magazine media anno 2022
 
Mma social media monitor q4 2021
Mma social media monitor q4 2021Mma social media monitor q4 2021
Mma social media monitor q4 2021
 
Gf k trends in digitale media jan 2022
Gf k trends in digitale media jan 2022Gf k trends in digitale media jan 2022
Gf k trends in digitale media jan 2022
 
Bits en bites magazine media 2021 ii
Bits en bites magazine media 2021 iiBits en bites magazine media 2021 ii
Bits en bites magazine media 2021 ii
 
MWG MTalks NMO bijdrage magazinemedia
MWG MTalks NMO bijdrage magazinemediaMWG MTalks NMO bijdrage magazinemedia
MWG MTalks NMO bijdrage magazinemedia
 
200153 mma - social media monitor q3-21
200153   mma - social media monitor q3-21200153   mma - social media monitor q3-21
200153 mma - social media monitor q3-21
 
200141 mma - social media monitor q2-21
200141   mma - social media monitor q2-21200141   mma - social media monitor q2-21
200141 mma - social media monitor q2-21
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxZuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxBigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdf
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdfSchema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdf
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdfLars Albertsson
 
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Call
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip CallDelhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Call
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Callshivangimorya083
 
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFx
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFxEdukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFx
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFxolyaivanovalion
 
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptx
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptxIntroduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptx
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptxfirstjob4
 
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdf
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdfMarket Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdf
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdfRachmat Ramadhan H
 
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptx
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptxBPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptx
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptxMohammedJunaid861692
 
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxCarero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data 2023
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data  2023Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data  2023
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data 2023ymrp368
 
Halmar dropshipping via API with DroFx
Halmar  dropshipping  via API with DroFxHalmar  dropshipping  via API with DroFx
Halmar dropshipping via API with DroFxolyaivanovalion
 
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFx
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFxMidocean dropshipping via API with DroFx
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFxolyaivanovalion
 
{Pooja: 9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...
{Pooja:  9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...{Pooja:  9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...
{Pooja: 9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...Pooja Nehwal
 
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptxAnupama Kate
 
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxBabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxSmarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxolyaivanovalion
 
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Callshivangimorya083
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxZuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Zuja dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxBigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BigBuy dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdf
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdfSchema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdf
Schema on read is obsolete. Welcome metaprogramming..pdf
 
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Call
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip CallDelhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Call
Delhi Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199171 ☎✔👌✔ Whatsapp Hard And Sexy Vip Call
 
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFx
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFxEdukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFx
Edukaciniai dropshipping via API with DroFx
 
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PARI) Call Girls Wanowrie ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
Sampling (random) method and Non random.ppt
Sampling (random) method and Non random.pptSampling (random) method and Non random.ppt
Sampling (random) method and Non random.ppt
 
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptx
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptxIntroduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptx
Introduction-to-Machine-Learning (1).pptx
 
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdf
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdfMarket Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdf
Market Analysis in the 5 Largest Economic Countries in Southeast Asia.pdf
 
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
ALSO dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptx
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptxBPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptx
BPAC WITH UFSBI GENERAL PRESENTATION 18_05_2017-1.pptx
 
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxCarero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Carero dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data 2023
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data  2023Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data  2023
Data-Analysis for Chicago Crime Data 2023
 
Halmar dropshipping via API with DroFx
Halmar  dropshipping  via API with DroFxHalmar  dropshipping  via API with DroFx
Halmar dropshipping via API with DroFx
 
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFx
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFxMidocean dropshipping via API with DroFx
Midocean dropshipping via API with DroFx
 
{Pooja: 9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...
{Pooja:  9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...{Pooja:  9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...
{Pooja: 9892124323 } Call Girl in Mumbai | Jas Kaur Rate 4500 Free Hotel Del...
 
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx
100-Concepts-of-AI by Anupama Kate .pptx
 
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxBabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
BabyOno dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptxSmarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
Smarteg dropshipping via API with DroFx.pptx
 
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call
꧁❤ Greater Noida Call Girls Delhi ❤꧂ 9711199171 ☎️ Hard And Sexy Vip Call
 

Pay attention-final-report.pd

  • 1.
  • 2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CHAPTER 1: MAGAZINES WORK CHAPTER 2: ATTENTION MATTERS CHAPTER 3: QUALITY ATTENTION AND MAGAZINES CHAPTER 4: WHAT’S AT THE CENTRE OF ATTENTION? CHAPTER 5: PAY LESS FOR MORE ATTENTION CONCLUSION METHODOLOGY 2 3 8 13 18 25 27 28 CONTENTS
  • 3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The effectiveness of magazines is much underestimated, as a recent report from the Radio Centre ‘Re-evaluating media’ underlined. An aggregate of all the media scores in this study shows that the gap between evidence and perception is the starkest for magazines. Narrowing this perception gap is an important challenge facing the magazine industry. Our own effectiveness work has demonstrated the power of magazines when it comes to long and short term effects including brand equity, customer acquisition and activation. We are keen to tackle this perception challenge. This report serves to answer the question ‘why should advertisers and agencies invest in magazines?’ In today’s media landscape attention is hugely important. Attention to advertising matters more than it ever has. There are more times and places where we can capture the consumer‘s attention, yet numerous studies show attention to advertising is declining. Why? Because attention is a finite resource and we are in danger of over exploiting it. When it comes to attention to advertising, it seems the more attention we try to squeeze out of consumers, the more they find ways to defend against it. Digital detox, banner blindness and adblocking are all symptoms of an advertising ecosystem that is overloaded. In our rush to embrace all the new ways we can reach the consumer, to continually mine and measure this using the new tools of digitalisation and data, we have focused too heavily on eyeballs. Not all reach is equal, and now is the time to consider quality attention. Quality attention matters. The neuroscience evidence shows that advertising that is encoded into memory is a predictor of future behavior.  We need to start to prioritise environments where ad avoidance is low. These spaces where advertising is welcome provide a under-appreciated value. Magazines provide high quality attention that is immersive and focused, more importantly attention to its advertising is one of the highest. This is because they provide a positive content and advertising experience, a relevant context that enhances receptivity to advertising and a highly trusted environ- ment. With magazines, advertising is not rejected, but seen as a positive part of the experience. What’s more, this high-quality attention doesn’t need to be expensive. Analysis of CPTs for commonly planned and bought audiences shows that magazines are exceptional value. A BRIEF NOTE ON REPORT SCOPE Measuring attention is complex; no single study will be able to provide us with the full picture and our whitepaper in collaboration with Bournemouth university made this apparent. This report is the start of a journey, from which we hope some interesting debate will emerge. We are committed to building our understanding of attention and the unique role that magazine media plays for advertisers. This report includes evidence for magazines in print and online, although it is unashamedly print focused. When it comes to attention, it is magazine print environments that deliver the most focused type of attention. This is not to dismiss the role of online or indeed any other channel. All channels have their own unique part to play and this report simply serves to underline the modern role of magazines. Throughout the report we will clearly indicate if we are referring to magazines in print or online. 2
  • 4. MAGAZINES WORK THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MAGAZINES IS MUCH UNDERESTIMATED CHAPTER 1 Being able to prove the effectiveness of your marketing has always been critical and in the current climate of uncertainty, arguably it’s more important than ever. Fuelled by the proliferation of data and a culture of justification, as an industry we have built up an enviable body of effectiveness work in the UK. Every channel has its own effectiveness evidence and magazines are no exception. A deeper dive into this evidence will also reveal against which objectives different channels excel. This detail is where a lot of the most useful information is, because effective campaigns require a mix of media and figuring out the role for each channel is a critical question. This is where the bulk of this paper focuses. But before we get into that, it’s worth briefly reviewing the effectiveness evidence available for magazines. In ‘Re-evaluating Media’ from the Radio Centre we find that Magazines and Newspapers are joint third after TV and Radio when it comes to generating ROI. This is significant because in a survey of advertisers and agencies, for the same study, magazines were placed ninth in terms of their perceived ability to deliver ROI. 3 Source: ‘Re-evaluating media, 2017 (Radiocentre/ Ebiquity) 1 2 3= 3= 5 6 7 8 9 10 WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS TV RADIO NEWSPAPERS MAGAZINES ONLINE VIDEO DIRECT MAIL SOCIAL MEDIA (PAID) ONLINE DISPLAY OUT OF HOME CINEMA 1 2= 2= 2= 5 6 7 8 9 10 WHAT ADVERTISERS & AGENCIES THINK TV RADIO SOCIAL MEDIA (PAID) ONLINE VIDEO DIRECT MAIL OUT OF HOME ONLINE DISPLAY NEWSPAPERS MAGAZINES CINEMA INCREASES IN ROI
  • 5. ‘ALL TYPES OF PRESS APPEAR TO BE EFFECTIVE, BUT CONSUMER MAGAZINES SEEM TO PRODUCE SURPRISINGLY BIG EFFECTS, GIVEN THEIR SHARE OF THE BUDGET’ 4 Source: ‘Media in Focus’, 2017 (IPA) At Magnetic, we know that the ability of magazine to deliver against advertiser objectives is much underestimated. One of the challenges is that magazine closures and circulation figures are often used as shortcuts to aid decision making about magazine spend. The reality is that the decline of magazines is much overstated. If you look at ABCs for example, you can see that magazine circulation has stabilised in recent years. However, the ad spend decline is much steeper. Furthermore, the closing of titles commands understandable headlines but the opening of titles and launch of new initiatives less so. The publishing industry is in the midst of large-scale change, constantly moving resources to more relevant areas of the business, including digital, events and licensing. Whilst all this is happening, a report by the IPA - ‘Media in Focus’, shows that magazines have become more effective over the last ten years. They show surprisingly big results when considering the average share of budget they attract. Magnetic have carried out a number of effectiveness studies covering a range of topics including long- and short-term effectiveness, brand metrics and ROI, as well as addressing the effectiveness of magazines in print and online. For a detailed understanding of these areas please see the individual reports cited in the appendix. Source: ‘Media in Focus’, 2017 (IPA) 0 2,000,000 4,000,000 6,000,000 8,000,000 10,000,000 12,000,000 14,000,000 16,000,000 18,000,000 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 6.0% 7.0% 8.0% 2010 2017201620152014201320122011 CIRCULATION MAGAZINES £ACTIVELY PURCHASED 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 NO PRESS CONSUMER MAGS NEWSPAPERS INSERTS BUSINESS MAGS AVERAGENUMBEROFVERYLARGEBUSINESSEFFECTS 1.1 1.9 1.5 1.4 1.25 CIRCULATION(ABCs) ACTIVELYPURCHASED(ABCs)
  • 6. MAGAZINES FACILITATE BRAND DISCOVERY AND DRIVE CUSTOMER ACQUISITION 5 We know from the expert analysis of Les Binet and Peter Field, in collaboration with the IPA, that it’s not enough to look at brand or activation effects in isolation. In fact, brand building and activation have a symbiotic relationship. Fail to invest sufficiently in brand building and, not only will you fail to build brand equity but, you will also get a poor response to any activation work. Spend too little on activation and you may build strong brands, but you will struggle to convert that into results. Our own study with Peter Field (’Bridging the Long- and Short-term Divide’) found that magazines were strong at driving the following long-term effects; sale gain, market share gain and customer acquisition gain. In particular, campaigns that included magazines showed an astounding 161 percent higher level of customer acquisition gain relative to campaigns that didn’t include magazine media. This is a significant finding in today’s media environment where digital is often viewed as reigning supreme at delivering new customers, due to an ability to target tightly defined audiences. This evidence suggests that the context offered by magazine media, which better facilitates brand discovery, offers an alternative to the precision point targeting and optimisation of a purely digital driven customer acquisition strategy. PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic) 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% SALES GAIN 23% UPLIFT MARKET SHARE GAIN 74% UPLIFT CUSTOMER ACQUISITION GAIN 161% UPLIFT %REPORTINGVERYLARGEBUSINESSEFFECTS NON-USERS OF MAGAZINES USERS OF MAGAZINES
  • 7. MAGAZINES DELIVER ACTIVATION EFFECTS 6 In our report ‘Bridging the Long- and Short-term Divide’, we were able to prove for the first time that, not only do magazines deliver long term brand value, they also deliver significant activation effects. Using magazines in the mix, results in a 30 percent uplift in activation effects. This includes short-term direct response metrics such as trial, web visits, search and click throughs. We attribute the success in activation performance to the diversification of magazine media across digital channels. Other studies such as ‘Profit Ability’ by Thinkbox, show that print is second only to TV in terms of delivering both long- and short-term effects, so it’s clear that physical magazines have a strong role to play in the media mix, but what about magazines online? ACTIVATION EFFECTS UPLIFT FROM MAGAZINE USAGE PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic) 44% 33% 22% 11% 0% NON-USERS OF MAGAZINES 34% USERS OF MAGAZINES 44% %REPORTINGVERYLARGEACTIVATIONEFFECTS 30% UPLIFT
  • 8. QUALITY ENVIRONMENTS ONLINE DELIVER STRONGER EFFECTS 7 We have looked at the performance of magazines online in a number of our studies. With ‘Metrics That Matter’ we found that, compared to other digital environments, magazines online delivered a stronger brand impact. With campaigns that used online magazine environments seeing a 41 percent improvement in KPIs compared to campaigns that used other online environments. The reality is, the best approach is to use a range of online environments including quality publishing sites such as magazines. In our study ‘Bridging the Long- and Short-term Divide’ we compared campaigns that used magazines against those that didn’t. We found that, if a client was using online rich media, and they combined this with magazines, they saw a 44 percent uplift in very large business effects, compared to campaigns that didn’t use magazines at all. We will continue to build and update our effectiveness evidence; however, alongside this we believe it is also important to explore why magazines work, the rest of the report focuses here. MAGAZINE MULTIPLIER EFFECTS WITH ONLINE VIDEO Source: ‘Bridging the Long/Short Term Divide: The role of magazine brands in the digital era’, 2017 (Peter Field/Magnetic) PRINT & DIGITAL MAGAZINE DATA 1.8 1.4 0.9 0.5 0 O/L VIDEO WITHOUT MAGAZINES 1.3 O/L VIDEO WITH MAGAZINES 1.8 %REPORTINGVERYLARGEACTIVATIONEFFECTS 44% UPLIFT Source: ‘Metrics That Matter’, 2016 (Magnetic) 0.12 0.09 0.06 0.03 0 OTHER DIGITAL ENVIRONMENTS MAGAZINE BRANDS ONLINE AVERAGEMEDIAKPICONTRIBUTION 41% UPLIFT
  • 9. ATTENTION MATTERS ATTENTION TO ADVERTISING IS DECLINING CHAPTER 2 The proliferation of media, especially always on mobile technology, means there are more times and places where we can capture consumers’ attention. To put these changes into a real-world context, it’s worth knowing that android sends out 11 billion notifications per day, and on average, consumers check their phone 150 times per day for short bursts of 30 seconds. This should mean our job is getting easier. But all the signs are that attention to advertising is in decline. A recent report from Teixeira shows a steep decline in the number of adverts viewed. In the online environment viewability is widely acknowledged as a significant challenge, and a viewable advert doesn’t necessarily mean the consumer has paid attention to the advert. Furthermore, the rise of adblocking software means that all these opportunities that are being opened up to reach the consumer are compromised. TGI data tells a similar story about attitudes to advertising, with 51 percent of consumers agreeing that they feel bombarded by advertising, this up from 45 percent in 2015. Recently, a study from the Advertising Association think tank Credos, showed that public favourability towards advertising hit a record low of 25 percent in December 2018. According to Credos, shis was the latest measure in a "long-term decline" in trust in advertising. There is an inherent contradiction in attention. As Herb Simon explains, there is an inverse relationship between the availability of information and attention. Increased information results in a scarcity of attention. This means that attention has become a precious commodity in our content rich world. 8 Source: ‘Attention Please the White Paper, 2018 (Bournemouth University) Source: ‘Attention 2.0’, 2018 (Lumen, Ipsos MORI) Source: TGI, 2018 ‘WHAT INFORMATION CONSUMES IS RATHER OBVIOUS: IT CONSUMES THE ATTENTION OF ITS RECIPIENTS. HENCE A WEALTH OF INFORMATION CREATES A POVERTY OF ATTENTION, AND A NEED TO ALLOCATE THAT ATTENTION EFFICIENTLY AMONG THE OVERABUNDANCE OF INFORMATION SOURCES THAT MIGHT CONSUME IT.’ HERBERT A SIMON CONSUMERS CHECK THEIR PHONE 150 TIMES/DAY FOR SHORT BURSTS OF 30 SECONDS ANDROID SENDS OUT 11 BILLION NOTIFICATIONS PER DAY OF ONLINE USERS IN BRITAIN CLAIM TO USE AN AD BLOCKER OF CONSUMERS FEEL BOMBARDED BY ADVERTISING 51%47%
  • 10. THE MEDIA INDUSTRY IS FOCUSED ON REACH AND INTERRUPTIVE ATTENTION 9 The digitalisation of content and distribution has made attention cheaper and easier to capture, and the abundance of data has enabled optimisation. This has resulted in a reach led approach to attention, focused on interruptive strategies, grabbing attention and maximising eyeballs. The reality is however, that attention is a finite resource. Put simply there are only so many hours in the day. Attention strategies that are based on the premise of interruption, capitalising on low quality attention and maximising reach could prove problematic for the long-term health of advertising. Attempting to squeeze more and more attention out of increasingly distracted consumers risks undermining our overall capacity for attention to advertising. Communication strategists such as Oliver Feldwick* and Faris Yakob* have questioned the sustainability of an attention-grabbing approach. So how do we achieve a more sustainable approach? ACHIEVING A SUSTAINABLE APPROACH TO ATTENTION The starting point is an appreciation that not all attention is equal, and that we need to place greater emphasis on quality attention. Quality attention is not just clicks, it can’t be measured in eyeballs alone, it’s about time well spent, it’s about focused and immersive attention. Yacob asks us to consider a spectrum of attention, to acknowledge for example that the requisite two seconds online hoping to attract a thumb is very different to watching a 30 second commercial in a darkened movie theatre*. So instead of grabbing attention, we need to think about cultivating attention over the long term; this is a more sustainable approach. This means prioritising an approach that values meaningful media experiences, where advertising isn’t interruptive and ad avoidance is low. *Sources: https://medium.com/@oliverfeldwick/fixing-the-distraction-economy-60525d68b02 | https://medium.com/@faris/ how-to-balance-your-media-plans-8f24858985953 HOW TO MEASURE ATTENTION? The challenge, as always, comes back to measurement. Whilst it’s relatively straightforward to make an intellectual argument for quality attention, advertisers will inevitably want to be able to quantify ‘quality attention’. The difficulty here is that with a mix of complex and subtly different metrics, it is incredibly hard to compare attention across different platforms. Time spent is one of the standard ways to measure attention, unfortunately it’s not as simple as that. A recent report from Ipsos MORI and Lumen** acknowledges that, even in the online environment where dwell time is a standard metric, this doesn’t provide the full picture. Analysis of creative performance of digital ads found that a well created digital advert can deliver recognition at a glance and aid brand impact. When a weaker ad might not perform even with a longer dwell time. In our ‘Attention Please’ whitepaper in collaboration with Bournemouth University, we outlined the need to consider intensity of attention; this refers to a more qualitative understanding of attention. **https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf
  • 11. THERE ARE DIFFERENT TYPES OF ATTENTION 10 Source: Attention Please: the White Paper, 2018  (Bournemouth University) With this in mind, Bournemouth University developed a framework for understanding attention, which acknowl- edges there are different types. Informed by a variety of theories, they assert that attention sits on a spectrum from top down, which is conscious and immersive, to bottom up, which is unconscious and fast. Alongside this we also need to consider how people process information. Information can be processed cognitively, i.e. analytically based on supporting arguments, often text based or lists of attributes or features. Or they can be processed emotionally based on value expressive goals linked to self identity. Typically these are more reliant on imagery and seek to meets moods, desires and feelings. Bottom up: system 1- intuitive, automatic, effortless, associated, fast, unconscious, often occurs when multi-tasking, stimulus driven Top Down: system 2- controlled, effortful, deductive, slow, self-aware, usually solo focused attention, goal driven Emotion processing: feeling-based processes, aroused by value expressive goals Cognitive processing: information is processed rationally, aroused by utilitarian goals ATTENTION ATTENTION ATTENTION ATTENTION COGNITIVE (THINKING / WORDS) EMOTIONAL (FEELING / VISUAL) TOP DOWN (SLOW) BOTTOM UP (FAST)
  • 12. 11 Source: PHD Source: PHD It can be argued that different objectives and sectors are better suited to different types of attention, so it’s important to consider this when planning a campaign. A useful way to think about this is the idea that attention has different modes: studying, soaking up, skimming and scanning. You might select one of these on the basis of the creative you are working with, the message that you are trying to communicate or the behaviour you are trying to change. Advertisers can use any or all of these modes depending on their objectives. For example, the above Smart Energy campaign used all four modes deploying cinema and advertorials in magazines for top down immersive attention and display advertising and video online to achieve bottom up interruptive attention. Media channels don’t naturally sit in one mode or another; many straddle a number of modes depending on how the channel is deployed and the creative treatment. A magazine for example, can be studied, soaked up or skimmed depending on the title, whether the consumer is reading in print on, social or online, and the creative approach taken with the commercial message. For example, a display advert, a partnership strategy, a home page take-over or an online influencer campaign. From this framework, the important take out is to work with the type of attention that your brand objectives, creative and media channels are best suited to. This is the best way to achieve a higher quality of attention. STUDYING SKIMMING SOAKING UP SCANNING COGNITIVE EMOTIONAL TOP DOWN BOTTOM UP COGNITIVE EMOTIONAL TOP DOWN BOTTOM UP Magazines Outdoor TV Cinema
  • 13. QUALITY ATTENTION DRIVES ACTIONS 12 Measuring attention is undeniably a challenge. A single metric is unlikely to fully account for the different types of attention and all the variety of factors that influence it. In our ‘Attention Please’ whitepaper Bournemouth university highlighted five contextual factors that need to be considered when measuring attention. a) Advertising goals: Purpose of the advertisement (desired outcome, remind, inform, change attitude, build brand etc). b) Personal goals: Utilitarian or value expressive (and specific nature of those goals). c) Media moment: how the media is being experienced (escapism, diversion, killing time). d) Media brand/channel relationship: Consumers’ relationship with particular media brands (pleasure, purpose, trust, relevance, credibility, personal connection, emotion, control, personal choice, loyalty). e) Advertising relationship: Consumers’ relationship with an advertisement (part of experience, relevance, distracting, annoying etc). So is all this complexity worth our attention because ultimately the measure of success in advertising comes back to proving effective outcomes. For attention to be taken seriously as a topic, there needs to be a link between attention and important KPIs, such as purchase and consideration. Neuroscience provides some compel- ling insight into this question. In this field, attention is referred to as memory encoding, and memory encoding is seen to be a crucial metric.  The science shows that if something isn’t stored into memory, no matter how much we enjoy it at the time, it can’t possibly affect our future behaviour – if it’s not stored away into memory, it’s simply not there in our heads. The significance of memory goes even deeper than this, because our brains are very selective about what is stored away, and we tend to encode things for which the brain has already identified a use.   Therefore if something is encoded into memory, this is both an enabler and predictor of likely future behaviour. In neuroscience, we find that attention really matters because the ultimate goal of any campaign is always to create some kind of behaviour change.
  • 14. SOLO FOCUS = % NOT DOING ANYTHING ELSE AT THE TIME Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 90% 68% 45% 23% 0% 58% MAGAZINES 60% NEWSPAPERS 30% TV 11% COMMERCIAL RADIO 20% OOH 52% DIGITAL DISPLAY (WEBSITES) 35% SOCIAL 87% CINEMA QUALITY ATTENTION & MAGAZINES ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES IS WELCOMED NOT AVOIDED CHAPTER 3 From our Attention framework we know that understanding the media moment is a key component to attention. So we decided to ask consumers about their media consumption behaviour. We chose a claimed survey rather than monitoring or observing actual behaviour because we were keen to understand why people were attending to something.  Measuring behaviour in situ has become more popular due to the availability of eye tracking technology. However, we are fascinated not just by eyeballs and where they are looking and for how long, but also more detailed questions about what is going on inside people’s brains and what is driving their behaviour. In our consumer data we noticed that targeted media such as magazines, newspapers and cinema generally tend to command the most focused top down attention. Consumers are more likely to state that they are doing other things while consuming broadcast media. Divided attention is inherently more competitive, advertising has to work harder to compete with the alternative and is more reliant on bottom up attention. What magazines, newspapers and cinema have in common is that they are self-selecting and in most cases, paid for, their content is often oriented to areas of special interest to the consumer. This goes some way to explain why they are commanding a different type of attention. 13
  • 15. Although we were interested in the media moment, the relationship consumers have with advertising in different media channels was the area we were most keen to explore, so we asked a number of questions on this topic area. It’s here that we found some strong results for magazines;  57 percent of consumers stated that magazine advertising is part of the experience, the highest score for any channel. Consumers tend to experience magazine advertising more positively than advertising in other channels. They are much less likely to think the adverts are annoying or feel bombarded by them.   This is because magazine advertising is less interruptive, not disrupting the core reason that consumers are engaging, which is to consume the content. In the magazine environment there are lots of opportunities for advertiser objectives and consumer interests to collide, which is probably why magazine advertising is the most welcomed type of advertising. 14 ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES IS WELCOMED NOT REJECTED Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 90% 68% 45% 23% 0% 82% MAGAZINES 75% NEWSPAPERS 42% TV 58% COMMERCIAL RADIO 58% DIGITAL DISPLAY 53% SOCIAL 70% CINEMA ‘IF THIS MEDIA DIDN’T HAVE ANY ADVERTISING, IT WOULD BE A LOT BETTER’ NET DISAGREE WITH MAGAZINES ADVERTISING IS PART OF THE EXPERIENCE ‘THE ADVERTS ARE A PART OF THE EXPERIENCE’ NET AGREE Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% 57% MAGAZINES 47% NEWSPAPERS 44% TV 47% COMMERCIAL RADIO 27% DIGITAL DISPLAY 27% SOCIAL 55% CINEMA Calculated using the average of the following statements: The adverts are annoying / I feel bombarded by the advertising in this media NET AGREE (SEE STATEMENTS BELOW) Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 35% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 14% MAGAZINES 15% NEWSPAPERS 31% TV 28% COMMERCIAL RADIO 12% OOH 33% DIGITAL DISPLAY 32% SOCIAL 16% CINEMA MAGAZINE ADVERTISING DOESN’T ATTRACT NEGATIVE PERCEPTIONS
  • 16. MAGAZINES BENEFIT FROM CONTEXTUAL RELEVANCY 15 Consumers also find magazine advertising to be more relevant than advertising in other channels; which again explains why it’s welcomed and people pay more attention to it. Relevancy and attention are closely linked. In another study, ‘Home Truths’ focused on home furnishing and electron- ics advertisers, we found that relevantly placed adverts achieved more attention. Note the higher scores on the relevantly placed ads above and left. This study used an eye tracking approach and uncovered some interesting behaviour. We found that for contextually relevant ads respondents were continually switching their gaze from left to right and swapping their attention between advertising and editorial. Adverts placed in these environments experience on average eight times the number of double takes. Demonstrating the impact of advertising and editorial working together in perfect synergy. Our motors study ‘Accelerate’ used the same approach and reached similar conclusions for car advertisers. We believe these types of results are likely to be mirrored in other high value, high interest sectors. https://magnetic.media/in- sight/home-truths-tv-audio https://magnetic.media/in- sight/home-truths-connected-technology https://magnetic.media/insight/acceler- ate-automotive-report-magnetic 50% 38% 25% 13% 0% 43% MAGAZINES 34% NEWSPAPERS 24% TV 23% COMMERCIAL RADIO 14% OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY 24% 27% SOCIAL 31% CINEMA Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) MAGAZINE ADS PERFORM BEST ON AD RELEVANCY RELEVANCY Thinking about each of the statements below, please select the media channels which you believe apply to each statement. On a scale of 1-5, how much do you agree with the following - ‘The adverts are relevant to me’. Base: All adults within each media quota group for each channel. ADVERTISING PLACED IN A RELEVANT CONTEXT ACHIEVES A GREATER SHARE OF ATTENTION Source: ‘Home Truths’, 2018 (Magnetic) 44% 56% 22% 78% 76% 24% 49% 51%
  • 17. CAN MAGAZINES ONLINE DELIVER QUALITY ATTENTION? 16 So far, we have focused predominantly on attention in print environments. We believe it’s important to start here, to re-state the role of printed magazines where the case for quality attention is strongest. However, there is already evidence to suggest that magazine online environment achieve a quality of attention that is better than the digital average. Lumen, a research agency focused on eye tracking, online measurement and attention have a great deal of evidence about publisher environments which supports the idea that premium editorial environments deliver a higher quality of attention. Work they conducted for us found that advertising on motors magazine sites can result in an eight per cent uplift in likelihood to see the advert. Furthermore, a digital analytics company (Moat) conducted some analysis for us as part of our ‘Metrics That Matter’ study. They compared a selection of magazine sites to the norms for all Moat subscribers. They found that the interaction rate was more than 18 percent higher for magazine brands online when compared with other digital environments, and that interaction time was 30 percent higher. Source: Lumen LIKELIHOOD TO SEE AD DWELL TIME WITH ADS 100% 0% 1.6 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 20% 40% 60% 80% CAR MAGAZINES OTHER SITES OTHER SITES 59% 68% 0.8 1.5 CAR MAGAZINES
  • 18. PLACING YOUR CREATIVE IN AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE CONSUMERS PAY MORE ATTENTION MAKES YOUR INVESTMENT WORK HARD FOR YOU Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 69% 59% 52% 61% 33% 54% 37% 40% 35% 29% 21% 17% 15% 15% ATTENTION TO CHANNEL ATTENTION TO ADS IN CHANNEL CINEMA MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS TV COMMERCIAL RADIO DIGITAL DISPLAY SOCIAL CREATIVE HAS A ROLE TO PLAY MAKE YOUR CREATIVE WORK HARDER WITH MAGAZINES 17 We agree that creative is an important element to consider if your ambition is to cultivate high quality attention. Good creative, however, can be a costly investment. So it’s good to know that placing your creative in an environment where consumers are more likely to pay attention, certainly ensures that investment works hard for you. Which is why we found it particularly interesting that magazines were the media where claimed attention to content and attention to advertising were both high and closely matched. From this you can see that magazines successfully convert attention to their channel into attention to advertising. Our attention framework also acknowledges that advertising goals are a crucial part of attention and that creative has a role to play. We know from the IPA’s strong body of work on effectiveness that creativity is a powerful force. This is also further supported by the brilliant work of System 1*  whose long-term analysis of creative and what drives effectiveness reveals three important creative principles; fame, feeling and fluency.   More recently, work conducted by Lumen and Ipsos MORI has uncovered how creative can impact on attention in the online environment. Here they find that many of the established principles hold true. Their report Attention 2**, underlines the importance of distinctive brand assets, strong visuals and a simple message; which they find are more likely to get the audience's attention and more importantly drive brand recall or recognition. To fully understand how to cultivate attention, we need to explore how media environment and creative interact and are best deployed to achieve quality attention. This is one of the areas we plan to explore further in the next phase of ‘Pay Attention’. Sources: *https://www.system1research.com/blog/fame-feeling-and-fluency-the-only-brand-metrics-you-will-ever-need **https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf
  • 19. 92% DIGITAL Source: PAMCo Oct 2017–Sep 2018 MAGAZINES ARE TIME WELL SPENT 89% PRINT MAGAZINES – A POSITIVE EXPERIENCE Immersion and undivided attention on one thing for a sustained period makes our brains calmer and less anxious. It’s why reading books helps us sleep. It’s why reading magazines make us smile. Evidence of a link between magazine reading and a positive effect on wellbeing comes from two separate studies. ‘Moments That Matter’ uncovered a 6 percent uplift in subjective wellbeing; a metric developed by world renown happiness expert Professor Paul Dolan. A study from Hearst, ‘The Power of Positivity’, has also revealed that magazines alongside cinema, music streaming and a selection of your favourite tv shows on demand make people feel more positive than other media experience. This group of media experi- ences really excels at harnessing positivity. It is significant at a time when the debate about the impact of digital content on our happiness still rages, especially with regards to social media. The debate tends to focus on the nature of the content and the impact on our wellbeing of constantly switching tasks. Furthermore; the Hearst study made a link between the ability of magazines to make readers happy and advertising effectiveness. The study found that 26 percent of magazine consumers went on to buy a product they had seen advertised, versus 11 percent for non-magazine readers. Although this is predominantly a print led argument, PAMCo, the audience measurement currency for the industry, finds that 92 percent of readers agree magazine content online is also time well spent. WHAT’S AT THE CENTRE OF ATTENTION? MAGAZINES CULTIVATE ATTENTION THROUGH THE RELATIONSHIP THEY HAVE WITH THEIR READERS CHAPTER 4 The case for magazines as a quality attention environment is strong, but what is it about magazines that enable them to successfully deliver this for advertisers? A closer look at the relationship they have with their readers and the nature of magazine content starts to reveal what is at the centre of this attention. Three underlying qualities explain our hypothesis. Magazines offer advertisers quality attention because they are - Positive - Relevant - Trusted 18
  • 20. 19 This speaks for the nature of the content playing a key role rather than just the channel. When readers are immersed in quality content, whether that be in print or online, they are less inclined to switch away and get distracted. They see reading magazines as time well spent, time when they want to keep their attention focused. The fact that reading a magazine is experienced positively by the consumer and is considered time well spent provides benefits for advertisers too. As we have shown in ‘Attention Please’, this benefit translates to the way advertising is experienced in magazines. Magazines are the highest scoring channel when it comes to positive attitudes towards advertising and the lowest scoring channel when it comes to negative attitudes to advertising. The attention that magazines cultivate is highly positive and valued by the consumer and this provides a high quality environment for advertisers. CONSUMERS HAVE POSITIVE PERCEPTIONS OF ADVERTISING IN MAGAZINES Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 30% 23% 15% 8% 0% 30% MAGAZINES 21% NEWSPAPERS 15% TV 13% COMMERCIAL RADIO 9% OOH 14% DIGITAL DISPLAY 15% SOCIAL 20% CINEMA Calculated using the average of the following statements: ‘The adverts are relevant to me’ / ‘I love the range of advertising this media gives me’ / ‘The adverts feature brands I like’
  • 21. MAGAZINES - A RELEVANT CONTEXT 20 We know that brand relevancy is an important KPI from our ‘Metrics That Matter’ study. According to the analysis conducted, relevancy is an interesting brand perception as it has the biggest impact on brand KPIs, but is the hardest for media to move. This study found that magazines were the number one channel at driving brand relevancy, a distinctiveness or level of differentiation that is more targeted. Magazine content is largely aimed at to consumer interests, be that fashion or football, television or travel, so relevancy is at the core of magazines. A recent report from Enders Analysis underlined the value of being present in these passion orientated environments and the value of the ‘passion pound’. It found that people are spending more money on passions. The report charts the rise of the passion pound. It identifies a rising ‘Identity Economy’, where identity categories made up 52 percent of discretionary household spending last year, and captured 79 percent of the growth in spend in the last five years. Source: ‘Metrics That Matter’, 2016 (Magnetic) 10% 8% 5% 3% 0% RELEVANCE QUALITY PRESENCE INNOVATION VALUEFORMONEY TASTE EMOTION TRUST QUALITY(PERFORMANCE) KNOWLEDGE RANGE PERSONALITY PRESENCE(PACKAGING) HERITAGE TRUST(RELIABLE) EXPERT HEALTH REPUTATION EASYTOUSE CONVENIENCE CUSTOMERUNDERSTANDING CUSTOMERSERVICE MODERN LEADER INTEGRITY STYLISH CUSTOMERCARE ACCEPTABILITY DIFFERENCE APPEAL CULTURE(TRADTION) PRESTIGE(LUXURY) NOSTALGIA FAMILY SUITABILITY(VERSATILITY) STANDSOUT CULTURE BONDING ASSOCIATION POPULAR OFFERS KIDREQUEST PRESTIGE(PREMIUM) SPEED/TIME GUIDANCE SUITABILITY(OCCASION) FAMILY(CHILDREN) TEXTURE PRESTIGE FAMILY(FRIENDS) EVALUATION OF ICE DATABASE MADE UP OF 65 STUDIES FROM 2010-2015 AVERAGEMEDIAKPICONTRIBUTION GROWTH OF THE PASSION POUND Source: ‘Passion Pays’, 2018 (Enders/Magnetic) £THE IDENTITY ECONOMY ACCOUNTS FOR 52% OF HOUSEHOLD SPENDING… …AND 79% OF GROWTH IN SPEND IN THE LAST 5 YEARS RELEVANCE AN IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTOR TO BRAND KPIs % CONTRIBUTION TO BRAND KPIs
  • 22. 21 Source: PAMCo, Oct17-Sep18 Source: ‘Passion Pound’, 2018 (Enders/ Magnetic) Magazine content speaks to these passions, covering subject matter as diverse as fashion, food and film, music, motoring and make-up, subject matter that really matters to their audiences.   PAMCo tells us that readers feel a close connection to magazine content, 72 percent of readers in both print and online agree. The Enders report makes a connection between the economic opportunity of the passion pound and a missed marketing opportunity.  In ‘Identity Economy’ categories, ad spend grew spend just 1.7 percent in two years, much lower than overall ad growth of 12 percent. This discrepancy can be explained by the ongoing shift to online performance channels like search and in-feed social media advertising. The report calls for more investment in emotionally and culturally relevant media, such as magazines, citing academic research that suggests media environments that make our identity more salient have a positive impact on decision making. It calls for less reliance of hyper-targeted behavioural-led strategies which may reach the right people with the right message but ignore context. The report underlines that consumers can be more receptive to messages based on how salient their identity as a consumer of the category is at the time. READERS FEEL A CLOSE CONNECTION TO MAGAZINES 72%72% THE MISSED OPPORTUNITY OF THE PASSION POUND GROWTH IN ADVERTISING SPEND GROWTH IN CONSUMER SPEND 10% -11% 10% 6% 10% 24% 24% -1% -2% -14% -18% -5% 7% -24% 14% 10% 2% 9% 18% 17% 31% -15% 11% 24% 8% 11% 28% 10% 10% 0% 10% 10% 10% 10% FASHION HOME & DIY TRAVEL CARS HOBBIES CHARITIES COMPUTERS & GAMING FITNESS & SPORTS FOOD (EATING OUT) ARTS MUSIC (AUDIO EQUIPMENT) GARDENING PETS
  • 23. 22 Magazines cover subjects that really matter to their audience and this passion-driven consumption provides a highly attentive audience. What’s more, this audience is more receptive to commercial messages. As we have seen in ‘Attention Please’, magazine advertising is the highest scoring channel when it comes to advertising being seen as relevant. These strong results are underpinned by the opportunity that magazines offer, a high degree of contextual relevance. Using the contextual impact of magazines doesn’t have to be limited to passion areas, as the award-winning case study from Smart Energy proves. With a clever content strategy, even a subject as low involvement as your energy provider can be made relevant by connecting to areas of consumer interest. https://magnetic.media/magnetic-case-stu dies/smart-energy-persuade-67-of-young- people-to-install-a-smart-meter-with-fully -integrated-campaign Magazine brands are experts in content that matters to consumers, and they can put brands in front of people who care about these subject matters. This speaks volumes when it comes to commanding attention. EVEN IF YOU REACH THE RIGHT PEOPLE WITH THE RIGHT MESSAGE, THEY CAN BE MORE OR LESS RECEPTIVE TO IT BASED ON HOW SALIENT THE RIGHT PARTS OF THEIR IDENTITY ARE AT THE TIME – A FACTOR AFFECTED BY MEDIA CONTEXT. Source: ‘Passion Pound’, 2018 (Enders/ Magnetic)
  • 24. MAGAZINES - A TRUSTED RELATIONSHIP 23 The relationship that magazines have with their readers is based on trust. This is backed up by a number of studies from outside the publishing sector, including surveys from Kantar and Ofcomm. These studies both agree that magazines are the most trusted source for news. Our own study ‘A Matter of Trust’, also found that magazines were more trusted than social media for content on fashion, beauty, home, motors and entertainment, as well as news. PAMCo also backs this up with figures showing that magazines achieve high levels of trust across a range of content areas and an average trust score of 82 percent in print and 84 percent online. MAGAZINES ARE TRUSTED ACROSS A RANGE OF SECTORS IN PRINT & ONLINE Source: PAMCo Oct 2017–Sep 2018 Source: ‘News Consumption in the UK’, 2018 (Ofcom) / ‘Trust in News’, 2018 (Kantar) OF MAGAZINE READERS SAY THAT THEY TRUST WHAT THEY READ IN MAGAZINES 80% OF PEOPLE SAY THAT MAGAZINES ARE THEIR MOST TRUSTED SOURCE FOR NEWS 72% 100% 75% 50% 25% 0% ALL MAGAZINES 84% FOOD MAGAZINES 92% MOTORS MAGAZINES 89% HOMES MAGAZINES 89% 82% 91% 86% 87% PRINT DIGITAL
  • 25. Source: ‘Passion Content Launch’, 2016 (Magazine Publishers of Australia, Fiftyfive5) 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% MAGAZINES (PRINT) MAGAZINES (ONLINE) BLOGS INTERNET RADIO (ONLINE) NEWSPAPER (PRINT) TV (LIVE) TV (ONLINE) SOCIAL MEDIA NEWSPAPERS (ONLINE) RADIO (LIVE) OOH ‘MAKES ME MORE CONFIDENT ABOUT BUYING PRODUCTS FEATURED OR ADVERTISED HERE’ 56% 55% 53% 50% 39% 38% 33% 30% 23% 31% 26% 12% 24 Source: ‘A Matter of Trust’, 2017 (Magnetic/ MediaCom) Editorial standards and expert journalism is at the heart of these results. We know from our ‘Matter of Trust’ study that it’s relevancy, reliability and expertise that underpins the trusted status of magazines. Magazine brands are experts in curating high quality content for their readers. They are a trusted authority for many consumers when it comes to areas close to their hearts. The trusted environment of magazines delivers quality attention and there is a rub effect for advertisers. ‘Matter of Trust’ also found that brands who invested in magazine advertising saw significant uplifts in brand attributes connected to trust. This is backed up by a study from Magazine Networks Australia which finds that magazines are the best channel to build confidence in products. In fact, they are 77 percent more critical to building product confidence compared to social media. Magazines are highly trusted brands in themselves and the confidence consumers have in their content and editorial enables advertisers to build confidence in their brands too. THE DRIVERS OF TRUST IN MEDIA BRANDS TRUST TRANSLATES INTO BRAND CONFIDENCE 31% RELEVANCY & MEANING 9% TRANSPARENCY 8% VIEWPOINT DIVERSITY 5% REPUTATION & FAME 27% RELIABILITY & ETHICS 20% EXPERTISE & OBJECTIVITY
  • 26. You might expect quality attention to come at a premium. You only need to look at average planning costs* to see this is not the case. We have gathered some planning costs from a number of sources, including publicly available data from Ebiquity and WARC. In partnership with PHD, we applied a factoring so to get to audience costs that better reflect the most commonly planned and bought demographics, rather than relying on ‘all adults’ figures, Of course, these are still average costs. Buyers will deal with different costs depending on programmes, titles and packages. In addition, costs will vary to some extent by agency group. However, the shape of the costs on average will remain broadly the same. What you will notice here is that magazines consistently feature in middle of this range. If you consider that magazine attention is high, it starts to reveal the exceptional value that magazines offer. PAY LESS FOR MORE ATTENTION QUALITY ATTENTION DOESN’T HAVE TO BE EXPENSIVE CHAPTER 5 25 *CPT data is taken from a combination of Warc data and Ebiquity data published in the ‘Re-evaluating Media’ report. These provide adult cost per thousands. We then used PHD audience CPT data to apply a factoring to create costs for 16-34s, HH+CH and ABC1s. See Methodology section for more detailed explanation. £45.00 £0.00 £5.00 £10.00 £15.00 £20.00 £25.00 £30.00 £35.00 £40.00 SOCIAL DIGITAL DISPLAY RADIO OOH MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS CINEMATV 16-34 £50.00 £45.00 £0.00 £5.00 £10.00 £15.00 £20.00 £25.00 £30.00 £35.00 £40.00 RADIO SOCIAL NEWSPAPERS MAGAZINES OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY CINEMATV ABC1 Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) £60.00 £0.00 £10.00 £20.00 £30.00 £40.00 £50.00 SOCIAL RADIO DIGITAL DISPLAY MAGAZINES OOH NEWSPAPERS CINEMATV HH KIDS CPT(£)CPT(£)CPT(£)
  • 27. MAGAZINES PROVIDE HIGH QUALITY ATTENTION AT EXCEPTIONAL VALUE 26 This becomes even clearer when you plot attention to advertising and media cost in combination. It shows that what magazines deliver is high quality attention at exceptional value. High quality attention doesn’t have to be expensive. With magazines you pay less for more attention. Magazines have one of the highest levels of attention to advertising, second only to cinema, but are more competitive on cost. If you consider the high attention channels, magazines have the lowest cost of all of these for two of the three key buying audiences. We looked at how Attention vs CPT analysis changed for 16-34s, HH+CH and ABC1s; which account for the majority of the ad spend in the UK market place. Magazines come out the most favourably for 16-34s and HH+CH, with Newspapers being the most competitive high attention channel for ABC1s. *CPT data is taken from a combination of Warc data and Ebiquity data published in Re-evaluating media report. These provide adult cost per thousands. We then used PHD audience CPT data to apply a factoring to create costs for 16-34’s, HH+CH and ABC1’s. See Methodology section for more detailed explanation. Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) ATTENTION TO ADS: 16–34s ATTENTION & CPT ATTENTION TO ADS: ABC1s ATTENTION & CPT ATTENTION TO ADS: HHKIDS ATTENTION & CPT 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% £50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00 MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS TV RADIODISPLAY SOCIAL OOH CINEMA 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERSTV RADIO DISPLAY SOCIAL OOH CINEMA £50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00 60% 45% 30% 15% 0% MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS TV RADIO DISPLAY SOCIAL OOH CINEMA £50.00 £37.50 £25.00 £12.50 £0.00
  • 28. CONCLUSION Magazines are an under-rated media channel when it comes to effectiveness. There is a big gap between the evidence and perceptions of effectiveness. Given declining trust and openness to advertising, attention to advertising is an increasingly important area to consider when planning campaigns. Attention comes in many forms, but the type of attention that magazines offer warrants more serious consideration. Magazines offer advertisers a high attention environment, which translates into high attention to the message. This is because magazines  provide: - A positive content and advertising experience - A relevant context that enhances receptivity to advertising - A highly trusted environment With magazines, advertising is not rejected, it is seen as a positive part of the experience. What’s more, this high-quality attention doesn’t need to be expensive. If you take price into consideration, you actually pay less for more attention with magazines. 27
  • 29. METHODOLOGY: ATTENTION PLEASE THE SURVEY Stage one of the ‘Attention Please’ project was conducted as a 20 minute online survey of claimed behaviour in relation to various media types. The survey was conducted among 2,000 adults in the UK. THE CHANNELS COVERED The survey covered Magazines, Newspapers, TV, Radio, OOH, Digital Display, Social and Cinema. Due to the number of media channels, each respondent was allocated up to four media channels to answer questions about, based on channel usage. All channels are analysed based on users of that channel only. All channels were set quotas to ensure a mix of frequency of usage, i.e. a mix of heavier, medium and lighter users. The heavy / medium / light levels were set based on TGI definitions. If a respondent was assigned a channel this was labelled as Media Quota Group for that channel. WEIGHTING Data at total sample level was weighted to be the same broad age, gender and social grade splits across media quota groups SAMPLE SIZES All media quota groups had some broad quotas set to aim for 40 percent light users, 30 percent medium users, and 30 percent heavy users at total level. Frequency groups below were predomi- nately put together using TGI definition where available. Nationally representative TGI definitions are c. 50 percent light, 30 percent medium and 20 percent heavy, however our sample were naturally slightly heavier media consumers due to the cross channel media requirements. 28 Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) 820 949 985 983 986 982 983 988 TOTAL 230 266 276 270 271 270 275 271 16-34s 494 573 601 589 596 594 600 592 ABC1s 234 259 191 238 171 166 186 206 HOUSEPERSON WITH KIDS MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS TV COMMERCIAL RADIO OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY SOCIAL CINEMA SAMPLE SIZE
  • 30. CPT METHODOLOGY The CPT data was sourced at an All Adults level through a combination of WARC 2016 published data and Ebiquity’s 2018 study ‘Re-evaluating Media’ for the Radiocentre. WARC CPT data was used for Cinema, TV, Magazines, Press and Radio while Ebiquity data was used for Social Media and Digital Display. OOH data was taken using a combination of the data sources and needed to be adjusted to factor in a 6 sheet and 48 sheet blended average, paper and digital. We then identified three key buying audiences, 16-34s, ABC1s and Households with kids. In order to project equivalent costs for each of these audiences, factors were applied to the All Adults CPT data. This was calculated using PHD buying data for each of the three audiences. 29 NON USER LIGHT MEDIUM HEAVY MAGAZINES NEWSPAPERS TV COMMERCIAL RADIO OOH DIGITAL DISPLAY SOCIAL CINEMA Source: ‘Attention Please’, 2018 (Magnetic) NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP ONCE A MONTH (WEEKLY) OR EVERY FEW MONTHS (MONTHLY) EVERY OTHER ISSUE FOR WEEKLY OR MONTHLY EVERY ISSUE FOR WEEKLY OR MONTHLY NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP ONCE A WEEK (DAILY) OR ONCE A MONTH (WEEKLY) EVERY OTHER ISSUE FOR DAILY OR WEEKLY EVERY ISSUE FOR DAILY OR WEEKLY NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP LESS THAN 20 HOURS PER WEEK LESS THAN 5 HOURS PER WEEK TRAVEL 0.5-3.5 HOURS PER WEEK LESS THAN 5 TIMES A DAY LESS THAN TWICE A YEAR 20-30 HOURS PER WEEK 30+ HOURS PER WEEK NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP 5-15 HOURS PER WEEK OVER 15 HOURS PER WEEK NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP TRAVEL 4-8.5 HOURS A WEEK TRAVEL 9+ HOURS A WEEK NO QUOTAS SET AS ONLINE PANEL ALL HIGH INTERNET USAGE NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP 5 TIMES A DAY 10 TIMES A DAY OR MORE NO NON USERS OF CHANNEL WITHIN QUOTA GROUP 2-3 TIMES A YEAR (ONCE EVERY 2-3 MONTHS) ONCE A MONTH OR MORE OFTEN SAMPLE DESIGN
  • 31. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION
  • 32. APPENDIX Magnetic Research A Matter of Trust (Mediacom) https://magnetic.media/insight/a-matter-of-trust-insight Attention Please: The Whitepaper (Bournemouth University) https://magnetic.media/insight/attention-please Moments that Matter https://magnetic.media/insight/moments-that-matter-insight Home Truths (Emotional Logic) https://magnetic.media/insight/home-truths-insight Bridging the long- and short-term divide (Peter Field) https://magnetic.media/insight/bridging-long-short-term-divide-new-insight Accelerate (Emotional Logic) https://magnetic.media/insight/accelerate-automotive-report-magnetic Why being different still makes a difference (Millward Brown) https://magnetic.media/insight/why-being-different-still-makes-a-difference-insight Passion Pound (Enders) https://magnetic.media/insight/passion-pounds Metrics that Matter (Carat) https://magnetic.media/insight/metrics-that-matter-insight
  • 33. APPENDIX Other Research Attention 2.0 (IPSOS Mori and Lumen) https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-06/ipsos_morilumen_attention_2.0_tp_may_18.pdf Re-evaluating media (Radio Centre) https://www.radiocentre.org/re-evaluating-media/ Magazine Networks Australia http://www.magazines.org.au/wp-content/uploads/Fiftyfive5-MPA-Passion-Content-Launch-Research-Debrief-final.pdf Media in Focus (IPA) https://effworks.co.uk/download-media-in-focus/ News Consumption in the UK (Ofcom) https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0024/116529/news-consumption-2018.pdf Trust in news (Kantar) https://www.tnsglobal.be/fake_news_trust_mainstream_news_brands
  • 34. THE MA R KETING A GENCY FOR MAGAZINE MEDIA IN THE UK