SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 11
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
                                        www.emeraldinsight.com/0888-045X.htm




                                                                                                                      Maximizing an
         Maximizing an economic                                                                                           economic
        recession through strategic                                                                                       recession
        organizational repositioning
                                                                                                                                              13
                                        Adam Murray
    University Libraries, Murray State University, Murray, Kentucky, USA                                                 Received 16 June 2010
                                                                                                                         Accepted 20 July 2010

Abstract
Purpose – The objective of this paper is to demonstrate the possibilities for strategically and
politically repositioning a library, despite economic hardships, for stronger relations with
administration, local government, and user communities.
Design/methodology/approach – The paper presents a case study of Murray State University
Libraries’ efforts to seize the current recession to conduct capital construction planning, donor
development, and political positioning for a new library facility. Additionally, the case study details
some of the activities undertaken during the recession to implement a pay-per-view journal article
process and value-added reference services.
Findings – This case study finds that strategically repositioning a library with administration, local
government, or the user community can be undertaken on either larger or smaller scales, depending on
the particular circumstances in which a library operates.
Originality/value – While the literature is rife with papers urging libraries and librarians to
undertake strategic and political repositioning efforts during economic recessions, this paper provides
a holistic case study of a library successfully doing just that.
Keywords Academic libraries, Public libraries, Information services, Value added,
Organizational planning, Partnership
Paper type Case study




   To be completely subservient to the budget [. . .] has been compared to driving down the road
   by looking at the rear view mirror. It is difficult to make progress and virtually impossible to
   take a new road. Accounting rules and financial methods have their own logic and purpose,
   and innovation is normally welcomed only when cost savings can be realized. Budgets are
   historical, specialized, incremental, non-programmatic, sequential, and repetitive (Marcum,
   2007).


1. Introduction
While the quote above is an excellent way to launch an article on making the best of
difficult economic conditions, perhaps Dickens said it best in his oft-repeated phrase “It
was the best of times; it was the worst of times”. It is certainly no secret that libraries,
along with many other types of institutions, are currently facing difficult budgets, staff                         The Bottom Line: Managing Library
shortages, layoffs, hiring freezes, and reductions in services. At the same time, libraries                                                 Finances
                                                                                                                                  Vol. 24 No. 1, 2011
typically experience surges in use during difficult financial times. These surges serve                                                      pp. 13-23
as an indicator of the possibilities for libraries that arise during a troubled economy.                          q Emerald Group Publishing Limited
                                                                                                                                          0888-045X
Such possibilities include improving the library’s position (politically, financially, and                            DOI 10.1108/08880451111142006
BL     otherwise), building partnerships, and investigating new or altered services to best
24,1   meet user needs. Success is often rewarded with opportunities for more success, and
       while a turbulent economy may prove difficult to navigate, it certainly should not
       hamper the innovations and services that make libraries a critical part of their user
       communities.
           This case study takes just such a perspective. While the literature is full of articles
14     and editorials urging libraries to think strategically and creatively during economic
       downturns, holistic case studies of libraries that are successful do not predominate.
       This case study examines the efforts, initiatives, and services undertaken by the
       Murray State University Libraries during the current economic situation to reposition
       itself politically through capital construction planning, piloting a pay-per-view
       program for journal article acquisition, and implementing value-added reference
       services. Readers should see practical evidence for making the best of the times, in
       spite of the economic climate.

       2. Literature review
       A review of library literature reveals three major trends concerning the economy and
       libraries. Perhaps the most prevalent are editorials on the current state of the economy,
       its impact on libraries, and the opportunities presented during such times. Fialkoff
       (2008, 2010) pointed out the greater need for libraries in times of economic recession, as
       people return to libraries as a source of information, programming, and learning. In
       another editorial, Kenney (2009) discussed the shared impact of economic recessions, as
       cuts in services at some libraries may result in increased demand at others. Arising out
       of this interconnectivity, Kenney urged public advocacy with a single voice and
       message: that of the importance of library services, particularly in times of economic
       instability. Just such unification is examined by Keresztury (2009), who described the
       advocacy planning and efforts put into place by various library agencies and consortia
       in New Jersey as a result of state budget cuts, particularly a task force comprised of
       representatives from the various types of libraries in the state. Marcum (2007)
       discussed the ways in which a politically saavy library director may use political
       capital and the creation of an organizational image of change or value to attract
       additional operating funds from the parent institution. Much like the current article,
       Marcum (2007) suggested that those initiatives that are truly important find funding
       somehow, and that a stance against improving library services because of a lack of
       funding increases is misplaced and unproductive. In another viewpoint article,
       Marcum (2008) pointed out that innovation is central for libraries if they hope to do
       more than simply survive, and that partnerships can help libraries accomplish
       significant projects that otherwise would have been unattainable alone.
           A second trend, moving beyond editorials, describes the impact of the economy on
       libraries through various historical or economic perspectives. Examples of this trend
       include Bullington and Lee (2009), Dougherty (2009), and Stearns (2009). Bullington
       and Lee (2009) described the economic hardships facing educational institutions in
       Wyoming and Colorado, demonstrating that these issues are common across the USA.
       Decreasing state tax revenues, limited access to federal financial stimulus funds, and
       restrictions on tuition increases combine with what Bullington and Lee (2009) describe
       as a “perfect storm” of educational reform requirements arising from the decreasing
educational attainment of younger generations and the impact of technology on               Maximizing an
pedagogy. These challenges lead libraries to strategic collaboration, taking the form of        economic
collective purchasing and reference services.
    From the perspective of transparency, Dougherty (2009) gave an overview of the
                                                                                                recession
many steps taken in libraries, particularly academic libraries, in the face of budget
cuts. These include freezing vacant positions or professional development funding,
closing branches or limiting hours, combining or eliminating service points, and                      15
reducing acquisitions budgets. Depending on the political climate in which the library
operates and the perception of its services, Dougherty recommended transparency and
the solicitation of user feedback when considering the reduction of services that affect
the public.
    Using an economic downturn as a vehicle for change is the subject of Stearns’ (2009)
article on marketing a library during a recession. The article opened with the quote
“never waste a crisis”, and outlined ways in which libraries can use targeted marketing
practices to strengthen existing services, build partnerships, and raise funds for
smaller projects while under tight budget scenarios.
    A final major trend regarding the impact of the current economic downturn on
libraries relates to fundraising, with a particular focus on donor development. DiMattia
(2008) outlined the different fundraising scenarios typical of public, academic, and
school libraries. DiMattia also bulleted the many “What’s in it for me?” questions that
might come up during the process of seeking external support, and how libraries might
prepare for those questions.
    Miller (2010) reported on the Library Journal’s Directors’ Summit, held in November
2009. A central topic of the summit was the state of library budgets in general, and
specifically on fundraising during the economic downturn. Key questions included
whether private funds should be used to “turn on the lights” and other basic services,
and how library budgets can be realigned to support core services so that private funds
may be used for special projects. Whatever the process, Miller (2010) reported that a
theme of the summit was the utilization of fundraising efforts to build long-term
relationships, rather than for just the immediate support of library services.
    Goldberg (2008) described the impact of the economic crisis on the endowments that
support many libraries and library initiatives, ranging from acquisitions budgets to
endowed chair or director positions. Even as interest rates plummet, donors are
proving less likely to give as their ability to fund philanthropic endeavors becomes
more restricted. Despite these overwhelming troubles Goldberg (2008) suggested, like
many others, that the economic downturn gives libraries the perfect opportunity to
cement their importance to the community that turns to them in their need.
    Silverman (2009a, b) highlighted the ways in which inexpensive or free resources
can be used to efficiently and effectively spread information about library initiatives in
order to cultivate donors or as stewardship of existing donors. These include mailings,
the use of social networking tools to virally distribute information, and revisiting the
traditional newsletter. Likewise, using these media to broadcast a message of
desperation in difficult financial times has a tendency to drive away potential donors.
To quote Silverman, “library donors, like sports fans, want to back a winning team”
(Silverman, 2009b). Telling success stories, and showing a responsiveness to user
BL     needs, creates opportunities to match donors’ desire to help with the needs of the
24,1   library.
          Not all articles in this trend deal with donor development; an example of those that
       focus on external funding through grant opportunities is provided by Gerding (2008).
       Gerding (2008) provides definitions of the six primary sources of grants funding
       (federal, state, local, foundation, corporate, professional/trade association), URLs of
16     websites that distribute information about library grant opportunities, and tips for how
       to search for grants. The article concludes with the “eight essential ps” that those
       applying for grant funds should keep in mind during the grant application process.
       These essentials are:
          (1) planning;
          (2) passion;
          (3) persuasion;
          (4) purpose;
          (5) precision;
          (6) partnerships;
          (7) positivity; and
          (8) people.

       A review of relevant professional literature finds the field of librarianship dominated
       by three large trends related to the current economic climate. The first trend is
       comprised of editorial-type articles urging action and unification in the face of budget
       cuts, branch closings, hiring freezes, and layoffs. A second trend describes these
       impacts and library reactions in a more analytical light. The final large trend focuses
       on fundraising, particularly through the cultivation of donors in spite of the economy.
       While articles in each of these trends posit the notion of using an economic downturn to
       a strategic advantage, this review of the literature reveals that there is little reported by
       libraries that do just that. This perceived void in reporting (not necessarily due to a
       lack of action) can be filled by case studies of libraries that have successfully
       repositioned themselves on either a large or small scale.

       3. Case study and background
       This case study is holistic in nature and examines the efforts, large and small,
       undertaken at Murray State University during an economic downturn to reposition
       itself strategically and politically. These efforts include capital construction
       planning/marketing, developing and nurturing partnerships/donors to expand
       services, and the strategic utilization of technology for targeted acquisitions and
       value-added reference services. As was found in the review above, such holistic case
       studies of maximizing economic recessions are rare in the professional literature.
          Murray State University (MSU) is a mid-major regional comprehensive university
       located in Western Kentucky. Enrollment at the university is approximately 10,000
       students. These are mostly traditional residential undergraduates. MSU is, however,
       placing a growing emphasis on recruiting international students and non-traditional
       students through distance education options. Murray State University has received
continual recognition by US News & World Report and Kiplinger’s for the quality and         Maximizing an
affordability of its education. As a regional comprehensive university, it has a focus on       economic
liberal arts education, but also provides degrees in agriculture, nursing,
telecommunications (a noted program of distinction), and is the only university in              recession
the nation to offer both undergraduate and graduate accredited degrees in occupational
safety and health. The University Libraries are comprised of three locations housed
within two buildings. They employ ten faculty and approximately 25 staff. As the                      17
university utilizes “block budgeting” (vacant positions are allowed to stay within the
budget unit, allowing the Dean to determine the use of funds within those vacant lines;
unexpended funds from one fiscal year are allowed to carry forward into the next), the
Dean of University Libraries is afforded the freedom to budget for projects with larger
costs.
    Starting in the 2007-2008 fiscal year, Murray State University was subjected to a
series of budget cuts in state appropriations, accompanied by mid-year rescissions in
previously allocated state funds. Starting with a mid-year rescission in 2007-2008 of
$1.6m, followed by an additional cut of $1.4m, the university’s state appropriations
were reduced by 5.6 percent. This was followed by another mid-year rescission of
roughly 2 percent, or just over $1m. Overall, Murray State University lost just over 7.5
percent of its state appropriations in two years, with the strong probability of
continued cuts in future years. The state of Kentucky operates on a biennial budget
system, and projections for the fiscal years of 2010-2011 and 2011-2012 call for
additional cuts to institutions of higher education, particularly as federal stimulus
funding is exhausted.
    The financial freedom traditionally given to budget units such as the library began
to change in 2007 as the result of the reductions in state appropriations. While not
implementing a hiring freeze, the university became much more selective in which
faculty and professional staff positions to advertise. The university budget was
scrubbed of “low hanging fruit” – budget items that simply did not make sense to
maintain in a faltering economy. Carry-forward funds were held in abeyance in order to
counter mid-year rescissions without damaging core university operations. The
University Libraries’ acquisitions budget was cut by 8.4 percent. Despite these
situations, the University Libraries identified several keys ways to reposition
themselves and their services during the down economy. These steps included
planning efforts for a new library facility, the nurturing of partnerships with
non-library units across campus, and the utilization of technology to bolster
acquisitions flexibility and reference service delivery.

3.1 History of the new library project
In the midst of rescissions and budget reductions, Murray State University began
significant planning work for a new library facility. First mentioned by incoming
President Randy Dunn during his inaugural speech in early 2007, a new library for the
university would be intended to replace the existing building, which was originally a
student center renovated in 1977 to become a library. Starting in October 2008, a task
force of representatives from various academic units, student life offices, student
government/student volunteers, facilities, and development began conceptualizing a
library building with a learning commons at its center. These meetings began with a
BL     very abstract focus, simply observing student behavior in the existing building,
24,1   making observations about the strengths and flaws of the existing facilities, and
       brainstorming services or methods of access. Members of the task force were told to
       “think pie in the sky” while developing notions for services to be included in a learning
       commons. As these services were identified, the author (who served as the chair of the
       task force) contacted units on campus responsible for the services being envisioned in
18     the library to solicit further feedback.
           As the envisioning process became more concrete, the task force decided to conduct
       student surveys and interviews, and to visit facilities similar to what was being
       proposed for Murray State. At this point, it was determined to hire an architectural
       firm to consult on the development of a “conceptual rendering” of the facility. This
       rendering would help determine adjacencies within the building and convey to the
       campus the philosophy underlying a learning commons. Both of these actions required
       funding. The author put together a proposal for site visit locations and worked with the
       Director of Facilities to identify a suitable consultant available on state contract (and
       therefore not requiring a bid process). This proposal was submitted to the President of
       MSU, who after approving, forwarded to the University’s foundation for funding. After
       a short defense of the proposal to the Foundation Director, the actions proposed were
       funded.
           With funding available, the task force completed the site visits with the consultants
       present. These site visits allowed the task force to begin determining a more concrete
       vision for Murray State, identifying which services and facilities should be located near
       each other for the most efficiency. After several debriefing sessions, the architects
       visited Murray for an all-day consultation and information gathering meeting, to which
       all members of the task force, as well as representatives from various campus units,
       were invited. From this meeting, which occurred in May 2009, the architects were able
       to put together a conceptual rendering and preliminary floor plan of a new library
       building.


       3.2 Marketing, faculty response, and board approval
       In September 2009, the MSU Board of Regents met to approve the capital construction
       priorities for the university. Prior to this meeting, the members of the New Library
       Task Force had engaged in a campus-wide marketing campaign to spread information
       about the philosophy and vision of a new library. This marketing push had three main
       objectives: to inform students/faculty of the vision for a new library; to counter
       negative faculty response from a minority within faculty senate; and to bolster support
       for the new library plans leading up to the Board’s vote on its ranking within the
       capital construction priorities. Input from faculty about a new library was gathered
       through a faculty survey conducted by the faculty regent; the survey found a negative
       response to the possibility of a new library was a minority, although a larger
       percentage of faculty expressed ambivalence about the construction of a “book
       warehouse”,
          The marketing campaign put into place by the task force included:
          .
             the production of brochures containing frequently asked questions and the
             results of the student survey;
.
       the creation of a website linked off of the main Murray State website for                    Maximizing an
       distributing information about the task force, including images of the proposed                  economic
       building and photos from site visits;
                                                                                                        recession
   .
       an article on the new library within an MSU alumni/community publication;
   .
       special appearances and reports in local radio and news venues and the campus
       newspaper;
                                                                                                              19
   .
       the distribution of a glossy annual report containing the conceptual renderings;
       and
   .
       hosting faculty events to showcase problems in the existing building.

The FAQ and survey results were distributed across a broad range of campus groups,
including a packet at each place-setting during the faculty and staff luncheons in
August 2009. The annual report highlighting the libraries’ many successes and the
rendering of the proposed building was distributed to the Board of Regents, and
individual conversations took place with several of the regents seeking more
information from the author. Presentations on the philosophy and preliminary floor
plan were made by the author at a campus-wide administrators meeting, student
government meetings, with the heads of the residential colleges, staff congress, faculty
senate, and others. A high-profile campus visit was arranged for the State Librarian
and Commissioner of the Department of Libraries and Archives, including a reception
at the President’s house for strategic leaders on campus who remained on the fence
about the project. A faculty-only “coffee with the President” event was hosted in the
lobby of the existing building to give faculty face-time with the President and to
showcase problems with the facility.
   While each of these events and initiatives took considerable amount of planning and
effort (but not a lot of funding) to make a reality, the pay-off was readily apparent.
Faculty response to a new library changed from “why” to “when”. The minority within
the Faculty Senate reduced their attacks, and the Board of Regents voted the new
library as the campus’s number two capital construction priority.

3.3 Partnerships nurtured
   Done right, however, [fundraising] can do so much more than mitigate current budget woes; it
   can foster the relationships that will anchor the library well into the future (Miller, 2010).
Extending beyond fundraising, times of economic trouble can be used to nurture
partnerships that (re)define library services and the library’s political and social
position on campus or in the community. As units or potential partners struggle to
maintain budgets or services, a library represents a burgeoning place of business,
particularly as library use spikes during economic turbulence. The University
Libraries at Murray State University have done just that over the range of years
starting with 2007.
   The nurturing of partnerships with the MSU Libraries started with MSU’s Center
for Teaching Learning, and Technology (CTLT). This unit, which has a mission
similar to the University Libraries’, hosts a number of events targeted towards faculty,
pedagogy, and the use of technology in the classroom. Starting in 2007, the University
Libraries began partnering with CTLT to co-host these events within the main library.
BL     For CTLT, this partnership brought additional personnel to work the event and a
24,1   larger space in which to operate. For the University Libraries, it associated the
       organization with highly-attended technology and pedagogy expos, bringing faculty
       that never use the library into the building – for the first time in years in many cases. It
       also gives library faculty first pick at presentation slots for library-related services or
       technology, increasing the libraries’ visibility with a segment of the population that
20     may have previously viewed the library as antiquated.
          Beginning in Spring 2008, the author became aware of a series of relocations on
       campus as the result of a push for donor funding of a “trading room” (a classroom
       modeled on stock exchange trading rooms) to be housed in the College of Business. The
       intended location for the trading room meant the relocation of several other services,
       including MSU’s printing and publication service, called Copy Express. Copy Express
       was previously housed in a building far from most of the academic facilities on
       campus, with no easy access to parking. The services offered by Copy Express include
       the preparation and sale of course packs, special printing jobs, passport photos, faxes,
       and various other office services. In preparation for leading the New Library Task
       Force, it became apparent that housing such a service within a new library would be
       ideal. As part of a revitalization of poorly used space within the main library, the
       author determined that the existing building could be renovated to serve the needs of
       Copy Express, thereby building a relationship with a unit intended for the new library
       building. Upon approaching the various individuals associated with cultivating donors
       for the trading room with a possible solution, and upon receiving an expression of
       interest from the manager of Copy Express, planning for the renovation and relocation
       began in the summer of 2009. The author worked as a liaison with Facilities and Copy
       Express to help design the new location and to provide supervision of the construction;
       the cost of the renovation was born by the budget unit responsible for Copy Express
       (not the library). Construction began in late fall of 2009, with Copy Express opening its
       doors in a new location in January 2010. Student and faculty feedback to the move has
       been very positive, with many indicating that it “only made sense” to house Copy
       Express in a heavily visited library building at the center of campus.
          The poorly used space that was renovated to house Copy Express had previously
       been used as storage for the library’s media collection. Before Copy Express could
       move into the main library building, the media collection had to be stored elsewhere.
       The summer before the Copy Express renovation, the library undertook a compact
       shelving renovation on the main floor, making the media collection much more
       accessible to library users. This compact shelving project also freed up a significant
       amount of space on the main floor, opening up the possibility of another partnership
       that had been discussed in association with a new library building – a Writing Center.
       Following the identification of a need for writing assistance in a new facility, the author
       approached the chair of the English Department to determine whether there was an
       interest in collaborating on such an initiative. While the discussion was initially
       oriented at space needs in a new facility, the possibility of a “start-up” writing center in
       the existing building quickly gained momentum. As the author and the chair discussed
       possible sizes, locations, and available services for such a start-up center, it was
       decided to bring a development officer (who happened to serve both the University
       Libraries as well as the College of Humanities and Fine Arts, where the English
Department is housed) into the conversation. The development officer was able to             Maximizing an
quickly match the vision for a writing center with the desires of a potential donor,            economic
bringing in the funding for the renovations, equipment, and staffing necessary for such
a service. As of this writing, an oversight committee comprised of Reference                    recession
Librarians, library staff, English Department faculty, and the development officer is
developing policies for the operation of the Writing Center. Housing such a center
within the library will not only provide students with a valuable service through the                 21
creation of a partnership, it positions the library as a key player in MSU’s Quality
Enhancement Plan (QEP) for the upcoming accreditation by the Southern Association
of Colleges and Schools (SACS) agency, particularly since writing skills was chosen by
a university vote as the focus of ongoing QEP efforts.
   These descriptions of library partnerships in tight economic times are not
exhaustive, nor are partnerships limited to space allocations or uses within an existing
building. For example, the Murray State University Libraries partnered with five other
offices on campus, including the Institute for International Studies and the President’s
Office to acquire a web-based subscription to Rosetta Stone. The University Libraries
have forged or strengthened relations with other units on campus such as Dining
Services and the Honors Program. These partnerships allow for the expansion or
improvement of services, despite rescissions and budget cuts.

3.4 Value-added services
Thus far, this case study on how one university library system used economic
hardships as an opportunity to reposition itself strategically has focused on large
projects such as capital construction planning, the creation or strengthening of
long-term partnerships, and the cultivation of donors. In this section, the author shifts
direction to focus instead on three value-added services which Murray State University
Libraries put together to enhance service or access, without having to rely on
“permanent” additional funding.
   The first such value-added service is a pay-per-view (user-driven acquisition)
program offered to MSU’s College of Science, Engineering, and Technology.
User-driven acquisition is a topic of much discussion in the realm of serials
acquisition and management, and in order to serve a lack of content created by a large
journal cancellation, the University Libraries diverted a portion of end-of-year
“one-time” money to the creation of an account with Science Direct. This account
allowed the University Libraries to put into place a pay-per-view program to serve the
faculty of the College of Science with instant access to the content of many journals
they otherwise would have to wait on interlibrary loan to provide. The program is
intended to run as a trial for three years, at which point usage will be examined for
further decisions on funding or the extension of the service to other subject areas.
   Two other value-added services relate to Reference and the delivery of
subject-specific research assistance to library users. In collaboration with CTLT, the
libraries obtained a permanent link in each Blackboard course-shell (Blackboard is the
Learning Management System used by Murray State) to a service called “Library on
Bb”. Unlike many library links embedded within Blackboard, this link did not simply
direct students to the library’s website. Instead, students were presented with a subject
index, which allowed them to navigate to in-depth subject guides while remaining
BL     within Blackboard. The university is in the process of aligning all authentication
24,1   systems so that eventually, anyone off campus logged into Blackboard will also
       automatically be logged in to library resources. This simple project has grown into one
       of the University Libraries’ most powerful tools, as subject-specific federated search
       engines were embedded within each subject guide. More recently, LibGuides was
       purchased as a means to transform the subject guide pages from static web pages to a
22     more dynamic model, with control and placement of the content resting with the
       reference librarians.
          Finally, the Murray State University Libraries recently added texting services as a
       method of receiving reference questions from library users. Available through Mosio’s
       “Text-a-Librarian” program for a very modest price, this service does not require the
       University Libraries to maintain a cell phone plan, but instead allows reference
       librarians to send answers to reference questions by computer to library users’ cell
       phones. In place beginning in January 2010, this value-added service has seen steady
       use since its inception. These and other value-added services allow the Murray State
       University Libraries to continually improve the quality or accessibility of services
       without waiting for new funding to do so.

       4. Conclusion
       Difficult economic conditions result in a set of challenges and uncertainties that while
       unfortunate, present libraries with opportunities to re-position themselves strategically
       and politically within their user communities. As this case study demonstrates, such
       efforts can be large or small in nature, depending on the particular circumstances in
       which the library operates. Large capital projects, planning, or donor cultivation do not
       have to be put on hold because of tight financial constraints; in fact, the success
       generated by increased library use during periods of economic recession can help prove
       the need for such large activities. Likewise, value-added services can be investigated
       and implemented without overly straining flat budgets or jeopardizing staff positions.
       As the quote at the beginning of this article indicates, letting the historical budget drive
       current and ongoing initiatives and services ignores the possibilities that turbulent
       financial times present to libraries for reinventing themselves. For the saavy librarian,
       the worst of times can sometimes be transformed into the best of times.

       References
       Bullington, J. and Lee, J. (2009), “Tough economic times call for more library cooperation: report
             on a Wyoming and Colorado Alliance Conference”, Collaborative Librarianship, Vol. 1
             No. 4, pp. 151-5.
       DiMattia, S. (2008), “Getting the money you need: relationships and fundraising”, Online, Vol. 32
             No. 1, pp. 22-6.
       Dougherty, R. (2009), “Prescription for financial recovery”, American Libraries, Vol. 40 No. 6,
             pp. 50-3.
       Fialkoff, F. (2008), “Serving in tough times”, Library Journal, Vol. 133 No. 17, p. 8.
       Fialkoff, F. (2010), “Editorial: Recession-buster”, Library Journal, Vol. 135 No. 1, p. 8.
       Gerding, S. (2008), “Tips and resources for finding grants”, Online, Vol. 32 No. 6, pp. 16-21.
       Goldberg, B. (2008), “Economic uncertainty spreads to library endowments”, American Libraries,
             Vol. 39 No. 10, pp. 20-1.
Kenney, B. (2009), “United we stand”, School Library Journal, Vol. 55 No. 6, p. 11.               Maximizing an
Keresztury, T. (2009), “The library crisis in New Jersey: a statewide strategy for survival”,         economic
       The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 22 No. 4, pp. 101-5.
Marcum, J. (2007), “It’s not the dollars, it’s the politics”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library
                                                                                                      recession
       Finances, Vol. 20 No. 4, pp. 161-4.
Marcum, J. (2008), “Partnering for innovation and sustainability”, The Bottom Line: Managing
       Library Finances, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 82-4.                                                           23
Miller, R. (2010), “Fundraising in the downturn”, Library Journal, Vol. 135, pp. 48-50.
Silverman, E. (2009a), “Staying positive in a down economy”, The Bottom Line: Managing
       Library Finances, Vol. 22 No. 1, pp. 27-9.
Silverman, E. (2009b), “Inviting the donor to give”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library
       Finances, Vol. 22 No. 4, pp. 139-41.
Stearns, E. (2009), “Top ten marketing tips for financial strength and sustainability”, Illinois
       Library Association Reporter, Vol. 27 No. 5, pp. 8-9.

About the author
Adam Murray completed his Master’s in Library and Information Studies from the University of
North Carolina at Greensboro in 2006. At the age of 27, he became Interim Dean of University
Libraries, a position he held for two years before his appointment as Dean in 2010. He has been
recognized by the American Library Association as an Emerging Leader in the class of 2009, a
distinguished alumnus (early career category) of UNCG, and is an alumnus of Vanderbilt
University’s Academic Library Leadership Institute. He is currently pursuing a doctoral degree
in Educational Leadership from Western Kentucky University. Adam Murray can be contacted
at: adam.murray@murraystate.edu




To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com
Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch

11.budget allocation
11.budget allocation11.budget allocation
11.budget allocation
libfsb
 
1.spare parts
1.spare parts1.spare parts
1.spare parts
libfsb
 
3.cruise passengers'
3.cruise passengers'3.cruise passengers'
3.cruise passengers'
libfsb
 
10.paperless society
10.paperless society 10.paperless society
10.paperless society
libfsb
 
8.moving on
8.moving on 8.moving on
8.moving on
libfsb
 
6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of
libfsb
 
5.the management
5.the management5.the management
5.the management
libfsb
 
3.great profits
3.great profits3.great profits
3.great profits
libfsb
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
libfsb
 
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
libfsb
 

Andere mochten auch (10)

11.budget allocation
11.budget allocation11.budget allocation
11.budget allocation
 
1.spare parts
1.spare parts1.spare parts
1.spare parts
 
3.cruise passengers'
3.cruise passengers'3.cruise passengers'
3.cruise passengers'
 
10.paperless society
10.paperless society 10.paperless society
10.paperless society
 
8.moving on
8.moving on 8.moving on
8.moving on
 
6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of
 
5.the management
5.the management5.the management
5.the management
 
3.great profits
3.great profits3.great profits
3.great profits
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
 
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
 

Ähnlich wie 2.maximizing an

1.the recession,
1.the recession,1.the recession,
1.the recession,
libfsb
 
7.internal and
7.internal and7.internal and
7.internal and
libfsb
 
3.the library
3.the library3.the library
3.the library
libfsb
 
1.hedge your
1.hedge your1.hedge your
1.hedge your
libfsb
 
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
AccelerateH2O
 
Snow_Strategic_Planning
Snow_Strategic_PlanningSnow_Strategic_Planning
Snow_Strategic_Planning
Peter NT Snow
 
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
Patrick Lowenthal
 
Pharmacy Essay
Pharmacy EssayPharmacy Essay
Pharmacy Essay
Roberta Zalewski
 
Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
 Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
joney4
 
7.a more
7.a more7.a more
7.a more
libfsb
 
7.a more
7.a more7.a more
7.a more
libfsb
 

Ähnlich wie 2.maximizing an (20)

1.the recession,
1.the recession,1.the recession,
1.the recession,
 
7.internal and
7.internal and7.internal and
7.internal and
 
3.the library
3.the library3.the library
3.the library
 
1.hedge your
1.hedge your1.hedge your
1.hedge your
 
Prospective innovation at ethical banking and finance leaflet
Prospective innovation at ethical banking and finance leafletProspective innovation at ethical banking and finance leaflet
Prospective innovation at ethical banking and finance leaflet
 
Reflections on sustaining Open Educational Resources: an institutional case s...
Reflections on sustaining Open Educational Resources: an institutional case s...Reflections on sustaining Open Educational Resources: an institutional case s...
Reflections on sustaining Open Educational Resources: an institutional case s...
 
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focusWilliams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
 
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
21st Century Academic Enterprises & Innovation
 
Snow strategic planning
Snow strategic planningSnow strategic planning
Snow strategic planning
 
Snow_Strategic_Planning
Snow_Strategic_PlanningSnow_Strategic_Planning
Snow_Strategic_Planning
 
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
The cyclical rhetoric of educational reform and the rationalization of a fail...
 
BKLA Issues
BKLA IssuesBKLA Issues
BKLA Issues
 
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focusWilliams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
Williams, monica why hbcu presidents need entrepreneurial focus
 
The uk's key information set was it really needed and what was its real purpose
The uk's key information set was it really needed and what was its real purposeThe uk's key information set was it really needed and what was its real purpose
The uk's key information set was it really needed and what was its real purpose
 
Applied Research In Accounting A Commentary
Applied Research In Accounting  A CommentaryApplied Research In Accounting  A Commentary
Applied Research In Accounting A Commentary
 
Pharmacy Essay
Pharmacy EssayPharmacy Essay
Pharmacy Essay
 
Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
 Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
Balancing the Four Es; or Can We Achieve Equity for Socia.docx
 
7.a more
7.a more7.a more
7.a more
 
7.a more
7.a more7.a more
7.a more
 
Thesis-Ch_1-3.pdf
Thesis-Ch_1-3.pdfThesis-Ch_1-3.pdf
Thesis-Ch_1-3.pdf
 

Mehr von libfsb

Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
libfsb
 
Foodbeverage
FoodbeverageFoodbeverage
Foodbeverage
libfsb
 
Food and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operationsFood and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operations
libfsb
 
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operatorsFood safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
libfsb
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
libfsb
 
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.editionIntroduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
libfsb
 
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd editionHotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
libfsb
 
4.the singularity
4.the singularity4.the singularity
4.the singularity
libfsb
 
2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all
libfsb
 
9.greener library
9.greener library9.greener library
9.greener library
libfsb
 
7.let them
7.let them7.let them
7.let them
libfsb
 
6.dealing with
6.dealing with6.dealing with
6.dealing with
libfsb
 
4.making the
4.making the4.making the
4.making the
libfsb
 
2.free electronic
2.free electronic2.free electronic
2.free electronic
libfsb
 
13.roi. measuring
13.roi. measuring13.roi. measuring
13.roi. measuring
libfsb
 
11.the yogi
11.the yogi11.the yogi
11.the yogi
libfsb
 
10.efficiencies and
10.efficiencies and10.efficiencies and
10.efficiencies and
libfsb
 
9.the value
9.the value9.the value
9.the value
libfsb
 
8.e books- little
8.e books- little8.e books- little
8.e books- little
libfsb
 
Ie mba#16
Ie mba#16Ie mba#16
Ie mba#16
libfsb
 

Mehr von libfsb (20)

Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
 
Foodbeverage
FoodbeverageFoodbeverage
Foodbeverage
 
Food and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operationsFood and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operations
 
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operatorsFood safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
 
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.editionIntroduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
 
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd editionHotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
 
4.the singularity
4.the singularity4.the singularity
4.the singularity
 
2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all
 
9.greener library
9.greener library9.greener library
9.greener library
 
7.let them
7.let them7.let them
7.let them
 
6.dealing with
6.dealing with6.dealing with
6.dealing with
 
4.making the
4.making the4.making the
4.making the
 
2.free electronic
2.free electronic2.free electronic
2.free electronic
 
13.roi. measuring
13.roi. measuring13.roi. measuring
13.roi. measuring
 
11.the yogi
11.the yogi11.the yogi
11.the yogi
 
10.efficiencies and
10.efficiencies and10.efficiencies and
10.efficiencies and
 
9.the value
9.the value9.the value
9.the value
 
8.e books- little
8.e books- little8.e books- little
8.e books- little
 
Ie mba#16
Ie mba#16Ie mba#16
Ie mba#16
 

2.maximizing an

  • 1. The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0888-045X.htm Maximizing an Maximizing an economic economic recession through strategic recession organizational repositioning 13 Adam Murray University Libraries, Murray State University, Murray, Kentucky, USA Received 16 June 2010 Accepted 20 July 2010 Abstract Purpose – The objective of this paper is to demonstrate the possibilities for strategically and politically repositioning a library, despite economic hardships, for stronger relations with administration, local government, and user communities. Design/methodology/approach – The paper presents a case study of Murray State University Libraries’ efforts to seize the current recession to conduct capital construction planning, donor development, and political positioning for a new library facility. Additionally, the case study details some of the activities undertaken during the recession to implement a pay-per-view journal article process and value-added reference services. Findings – This case study finds that strategically repositioning a library with administration, local government, or the user community can be undertaken on either larger or smaller scales, depending on the particular circumstances in which a library operates. Originality/value – While the literature is rife with papers urging libraries and librarians to undertake strategic and political repositioning efforts during economic recessions, this paper provides a holistic case study of a library successfully doing just that. Keywords Academic libraries, Public libraries, Information services, Value added, Organizational planning, Partnership Paper type Case study To be completely subservient to the budget [. . .] has been compared to driving down the road by looking at the rear view mirror. It is difficult to make progress and virtually impossible to take a new road. Accounting rules and financial methods have their own logic and purpose, and innovation is normally welcomed only when cost savings can be realized. Budgets are historical, specialized, incremental, non-programmatic, sequential, and repetitive (Marcum, 2007). 1. Introduction While the quote above is an excellent way to launch an article on making the best of difficult economic conditions, perhaps Dickens said it best in his oft-repeated phrase “It was the best of times; it was the worst of times”. It is certainly no secret that libraries, along with many other types of institutions, are currently facing difficult budgets, staff The Bottom Line: Managing Library shortages, layoffs, hiring freezes, and reductions in services. At the same time, libraries Finances Vol. 24 No. 1, 2011 typically experience surges in use during difficult financial times. These surges serve pp. 13-23 as an indicator of the possibilities for libraries that arise during a troubled economy. q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0888-045X Such possibilities include improving the library’s position (politically, financially, and DOI 10.1108/08880451111142006
  • 2. BL otherwise), building partnerships, and investigating new or altered services to best 24,1 meet user needs. Success is often rewarded with opportunities for more success, and while a turbulent economy may prove difficult to navigate, it certainly should not hamper the innovations and services that make libraries a critical part of their user communities. This case study takes just such a perspective. While the literature is full of articles 14 and editorials urging libraries to think strategically and creatively during economic downturns, holistic case studies of libraries that are successful do not predominate. This case study examines the efforts, initiatives, and services undertaken by the Murray State University Libraries during the current economic situation to reposition itself politically through capital construction planning, piloting a pay-per-view program for journal article acquisition, and implementing value-added reference services. Readers should see practical evidence for making the best of the times, in spite of the economic climate. 2. Literature review A review of library literature reveals three major trends concerning the economy and libraries. Perhaps the most prevalent are editorials on the current state of the economy, its impact on libraries, and the opportunities presented during such times. Fialkoff (2008, 2010) pointed out the greater need for libraries in times of economic recession, as people return to libraries as a source of information, programming, and learning. In another editorial, Kenney (2009) discussed the shared impact of economic recessions, as cuts in services at some libraries may result in increased demand at others. Arising out of this interconnectivity, Kenney urged public advocacy with a single voice and message: that of the importance of library services, particularly in times of economic instability. Just such unification is examined by Keresztury (2009), who described the advocacy planning and efforts put into place by various library agencies and consortia in New Jersey as a result of state budget cuts, particularly a task force comprised of representatives from the various types of libraries in the state. Marcum (2007) discussed the ways in which a politically saavy library director may use political capital and the creation of an organizational image of change or value to attract additional operating funds from the parent institution. Much like the current article, Marcum (2007) suggested that those initiatives that are truly important find funding somehow, and that a stance against improving library services because of a lack of funding increases is misplaced and unproductive. In another viewpoint article, Marcum (2008) pointed out that innovation is central for libraries if they hope to do more than simply survive, and that partnerships can help libraries accomplish significant projects that otherwise would have been unattainable alone. A second trend, moving beyond editorials, describes the impact of the economy on libraries through various historical or economic perspectives. Examples of this trend include Bullington and Lee (2009), Dougherty (2009), and Stearns (2009). Bullington and Lee (2009) described the economic hardships facing educational institutions in Wyoming and Colorado, demonstrating that these issues are common across the USA. Decreasing state tax revenues, limited access to federal financial stimulus funds, and restrictions on tuition increases combine with what Bullington and Lee (2009) describe as a “perfect storm” of educational reform requirements arising from the decreasing
  • 3. educational attainment of younger generations and the impact of technology on Maximizing an pedagogy. These challenges lead libraries to strategic collaboration, taking the form of economic collective purchasing and reference services. From the perspective of transparency, Dougherty (2009) gave an overview of the recession many steps taken in libraries, particularly academic libraries, in the face of budget cuts. These include freezing vacant positions or professional development funding, closing branches or limiting hours, combining or eliminating service points, and 15 reducing acquisitions budgets. Depending on the political climate in which the library operates and the perception of its services, Dougherty recommended transparency and the solicitation of user feedback when considering the reduction of services that affect the public. Using an economic downturn as a vehicle for change is the subject of Stearns’ (2009) article on marketing a library during a recession. The article opened with the quote “never waste a crisis”, and outlined ways in which libraries can use targeted marketing practices to strengthen existing services, build partnerships, and raise funds for smaller projects while under tight budget scenarios. A final major trend regarding the impact of the current economic downturn on libraries relates to fundraising, with a particular focus on donor development. DiMattia (2008) outlined the different fundraising scenarios typical of public, academic, and school libraries. DiMattia also bulleted the many “What’s in it for me?” questions that might come up during the process of seeking external support, and how libraries might prepare for those questions. Miller (2010) reported on the Library Journal’s Directors’ Summit, held in November 2009. A central topic of the summit was the state of library budgets in general, and specifically on fundraising during the economic downturn. Key questions included whether private funds should be used to “turn on the lights” and other basic services, and how library budgets can be realigned to support core services so that private funds may be used for special projects. Whatever the process, Miller (2010) reported that a theme of the summit was the utilization of fundraising efforts to build long-term relationships, rather than for just the immediate support of library services. Goldberg (2008) described the impact of the economic crisis on the endowments that support many libraries and library initiatives, ranging from acquisitions budgets to endowed chair or director positions. Even as interest rates plummet, donors are proving less likely to give as their ability to fund philanthropic endeavors becomes more restricted. Despite these overwhelming troubles Goldberg (2008) suggested, like many others, that the economic downturn gives libraries the perfect opportunity to cement their importance to the community that turns to them in their need. Silverman (2009a, b) highlighted the ways in which inexpensive or free resources can be used to efficiently and effectively spread information about library initiatives in order to cultivate donors or as stewardship of existing donors. These include mailings, the use of social networking tools to virally distribute information, and revisiting the traditional newsletter. Likewise, using these media to broadcast a message of desperation in difficult financial times has a tendency to drive away potential donors. To quote Silverman, “library donors, like sports fans, want to back a winning team” (Silverman, 2009b). Telling success stories, and showing a responsiveness to user
  • 4. BL needs, creates opportunities to match donors’ desire to help with the needs of the 24,1 library. Not all articles in this trend deal with donor development; an example of those that focus on external funding through grant opportunities is provided by Gerding (2008). Gerding (2008) provides definitions of the six primary sources of grants funding (federal, state, local, foundation, corporate, professional/trade association), URLs of 16 websites that distribute information about library grant opportunities, and tips for how to search for grants. The article concludes with the “eight essential ps” that those applying for grant funds should keep in mind during the grant application process. These essentials are: (1) planning; (2) passion; (3) persuasion; (4) purpose; (5) precision; (6) partnerships; (7) positivity; and (8) people. A review of relevant professional literature finds the field of librarianship dominated by three large trends related to the current economic climate. The first trend is comprised of editorial-type articles urging action and unification in the face of budget cuts, branch closings, hiring freezes, and layoffs. A second trend describes these impacts and library reactions in a more analytical light. The final large trend focuses on fundraising, particularly through the cultivation of donors in spite of the economy. While articles in each of these trends posit the notion of using an economic downturn to a strategic advantage, this review of the literature reveals that there is little reported by libraries that do just that. This perceived void in reporting (not necessarily due to a lack of action) can be filled by case studies of libraries that have successfully repositioned themselves on either a large or small scale. 3. Case study and background This case study is holistic in nature and examines the efforts, large and small, undertaken at Murray State University during an economic downturn to reposition itself strategically and politically. These efforts include capital construction planning/marketing, developing and nurturing partnerships/donors to expand services, and the strategic utilization of technology for targeted acquisitions and value-added reference services. As was found in the review above, such holistic case studies of maximizing economic recessions are rare in the professional literature. Murray State University (MSU) is a mid-major regional comprehensive university located in Western Kentucky. Enrollment at the university is approximately 10,000 students. These are mostly traditional residential undergraduates. MSU is, however, placing a growing emphasis on recruiting international students and non-traditional students through distance education options. Murray State University has received
  • 5. continual recognition by US News & World Report and Kiplinger’s for the quality and Maximizing an affordability of its education. As a regional comprehensive university, it has a focus on economic liberal arts education, but also provides degrees in agriculture, nursing, telecommunications (a noted program of distinction), and is the only university in recession the nation to offer both undergraduate and graduate accredited degrees in occupational safety and health. The University Libraries are comprised of three locations housed within two buildings. They employ ten faculty and approximately 25 staff. As the 17 university utilizes “block budgeting” (vacant positions are allowed to stay within the budget unit, allowing the Dean to determine the use of funds within those vacant lines; unexpended funds from one fiscal year are allowed to carry forward into the next), the Dean of University Libraries is afforded the freedom to budget for projects with larger costs. Starting in the 2007-2008 fiscal year, Murray State University was subjected to a series of budget cuts in state appropriations, accompanied by mid-year rescissions in previously allocated state funds. Starting with a mid-year rescission in 2007-2008 of $1.6m, followed by an additional cut of $1.4m, the university’s state appropriations were reduced by 5.6 percent. This was followed by another mid-year rescission of roughly 2 percent, or just over $1m. Overall, Murray State University lost just over 7.5 percent of its state appropriations in two years, with the strong probability of continued cuts in future years. The state of Kentucky operates on a biennial budget system, and projections for the fiscal years of 2010-2011 and 2011-2012 call for additional cuts to institutions of higher education, particularly as federal stimulus funding is exhausted. The financial freedom traditionally given to budget units such as the library began to change in 2007 as the result of the reductions in state appropriations. While not implementing a hiring freeze, the university became much more selective in which faculty and professional staff positions to advertise. The university budget was scrubbed of “low hanging fruit” – budget items that simply did not make sense to maintain in a faltering economy. Carry-forward funds were held in abeyance in order to counter mid-year rescissions without damaging core university operations. The University Libraries’ acquisitions budget was cut by 8.4 percent. Despite these situations, the University Libraries identified several keys ways to reposition themselves and their services during the down economy. These steps included planning efforts for a new library facility, the nurturing of partnerships with non-library units across campus, and the utilization of technology to bolster acquisitions flexibility and reference service delivery. 3.1 History of the new library project In the midst of rescissions and budget reductions, Murray State University began significant planning work for a new library facility. First mentioned by incoming President Randy Dunn during his inaugural speech in early 2007, a new library for the university would be intended to replace the existing building, which was originally a student center renovated in 1977 to become a library. Starting in October 2008, a task force of representatives from various academic units, student life offices, student government/student volunteers, facilities, and development began conceptualizing a library building with a learning commons at its center. These meetings began with a
  • 6. BL very abstract focus, simply observing student behavior in the existing building, 24,1 making observations about the strengths and flaws of the existing facilities, and brainstorming services or methods of access. Members of the task force were told to “think pie in the sky” while developing notions for services to be included in a learning commons. As these services were identified, the author (who served as the chair of the task force) contacted units on campus responsible for the services being envisioned in 18 the library to solicit further feedback. As the envisioning process became more concrete, the task force decided to conduct student surveys and interviews, and to visit facilities similar to what was being proposed for Murray State. At this point, it was determined to hire an architectural firm to consult on the development of a “conceptual rendering” of the facility. This rendering would help determine adjacencies within the building and convey to the campus the philosophy underlying a learning commons. Both of these actions required funding. The author put together a proposal for site visit locations and worked with the Director of Facilities to identify a suitable consultant available on state contract (and therefore not requiring a bid process). This proposal was submitted to the President of MSU, who after approving, forwarded to the University’s foundation for funding. After a short defense of the proposal to the Foundation Director, the actions proposed were funded. With funding available, the task force completed the site visits with the consultants present. These site visits allowed the task force to begin determining a more concrete vision for Murray State, identifying which services and facilities should be located near each other for the most efficiency. After several debriefing sessions, the architects visited Murray for an all-day consultation and information gathering meeting, to which all members of the task force, as well as representatives from various campus units, were invited. From this meeting, which occurred in May 2009, the architects were able to put together a conceptual rendering and preliminary floor plan of a new library building. 3.2 Marketing, faculty response, and board approval In September 2009, the MSU Board of Regents met to approve the capital construction priorities for the university. Prior to this meeting, the members of the New Library Task Force had engaged in a campus-wide marketing campaign to spread information about the philosophy and vision of a new library. This marketing push had three main objectives: to inform students/faculty of the vision for a new library; to counter negative faculty response from a minority within faculty senate; and to bolster support for the new library plans leading up to the Board’s vote on its ranking within the capital construction priorities. Input from faculty about a new library was gathered through a faculty survey conducted by the faculty regent; the survey found a negative response to the possibility of a new library was a minority, although a larger percentage of faculty expressed ambivalence about the construction of a “book warehouse”, The marketing campaign put into place by the task force included: . the production of brochures containing frequently asked questions and the results of the student survey;
  • 7. . the creation of a website linked off of the main Murray State website for Maximizing an distributing information about the task force, including images of the proposed economic building and photos from site visits; recession . an article on the new library within an MSU alumni/community publication; . special appearances and reports in local radio and news venues and the campus newspaper; 19 . the distribution of a glossy annual report containing the conceptual renderings; and . hosting faculty events to showcase problems in the existing building. The FAQ and survey results were distributed across a broad range of campus groups, including a packet at each place-setting during the faculty and staff luncheons in August 2009. The annual report highlighting the libraries’ many successes and the rendering of the proposed building was distributed to the Board of Regents, and individual conversations took place with several of the regents seeking more information from the author. Presentations on the philosophy and preliminary floor plan were made by the author at a campus-wide administrators meeting, student government meetings, with the heads of the residential colleges, staff congress, faculty senate, and others. A high-profile campus visit was arranged for the State Librarian and Commissioner of the Department of Libraries and Archives, including a reception at the President’s house for strategic leaders on campus who remained on the fence about the project. A faculty-only “coffee with the President” event was hosted in the lobby of the existing building to give faculty face-time with the President and to showcase problems with the facility. While each of these events and initiatives took considerable amount of planning and effort (but not a lot of funding) to make a reality, the pay-off was readily apparent. Faculty response to a new library changed from “why” to “when”. The minority within the Faculty Senate reduced their attacks, and the Board of Regents voted the new library as the campus’s number two capital construction priority. 3.3 Partnerships nurtured Done right, however, [fundraising] can do so much more than mitigate current budget woes; it can foster the relationships that will anchor the library well into the future (Miller, 2010). Extending beyond fundraising, times of economic trouble can be used to nurture partnerships that (re)define library services and the library’s political and social position on campus or in the community. As units or potential partners struggle to maintain budgets or services, a library represents a burgeoning place of business, particularly as library use spikes during economic turbulence. The University Libraries at Murray State University have done just that over the range of years starting with 2007. The nurturing of partnerships with the MSU Libraries started with MSU’s Center for Teaching Learning, and Technology (CTLT). This unit, which has a mission similar to the University Libraries’, hosts a number of events targeted towards faculty, pedagogy, and the use of technology in the classroom. Starting in 2007, the University Libraries began partnering with CTLT to co-host these events within the main library.
  • 8. BL For CTLT, this partnership brought additional personnel to work the event and a 24,1 larger space in which to operate. For the University Libraries, it associated the organization with highly-attended technology and pedagogy expos, bringing faculty that never use the library into the building – for the first time in years in many cases. It also gives library faculty first pick at presentation slots for library-related services or technology, increasing the libraries’ visibility with a segment of the population that 20 may have previously viewed the library as antiquated. Beginning in Spring 2008, the author became aware of a series of relocations on campus as the result of a push for donor funding of a “trading room” (a classroom modeled on stock exchange trading rooms) to be housed in the College of Business. The intended location for the trading room meant the relocation of several other services, including MSU’s printing and publication service, called Copy Express. Copy Express was previously housed in a building far from most of the academic facilities on campus, with no easy access to parking. The services offered by Copy Express include the preparation and sale of course packs, special printing jobs, passport photos, faxes, and various other office services. In preparation for leading the New Library Task Force, it became apparent that housing such a service within a new library would be ideal. As part of a revitalization of poorly used space within the main library, the author determined that the existing building could be renovated to serve the needs of Copy Express, thereby building a relationship with a unit intended for the new library building. Upon approaching the various individuals associated with cultivating donors for the trading room with a possible solution, and upon receiving an expression of interest from the manager of Copy Express, planning for the renovation and relocation began in the summer of 2009. The author worked as a liaison with Facilities and Copy Express to help design the new location and to provide supervision of the construction; the cost of the renovation was born by the budget unit responsible for Copy Express (not the library). Construction began in late fall of 2009, with Copy Express opening its doors in a new location in January 2010. Student and faculty feedback to the move has been very positive, with many indicating that it “only made sense” to house Copy Express in a heavily visited library building at the center of campus. The poorly used space that was renovated to house Copy Express had previously been used as storage for the library’s media collection. Before Copy Express could move into the main library building, the media collection had to be stored elsewhere. The summer before the Copy Express renovation, the library undertook a compact shelving renovation on the main floor, making the media collection much more accessible to library users. This compact shelving project also freed up a significant amount of space on the main floor, opening up the possibility of another partnership that had been discussed in association with a new library building – a Writing Center. Following the identification of a need for writing assistance in a new facility, the author approached the chair of the English Department to determine whether there was an interest in collaborating on such an initiative. While the discussion was initially oriented at space needs in a new facility, the possibility of a “start-up” writing center in the existing building quickly gained momentum. As the author and the chair discussed possible sizes, locations, and available services for such a start-up center, it was decided to bring a development officer (who happened to serve both the University Libraries as well as the College of Humanities and Fine Arts, where the English
  • 9. Department is housed) into the conversation. The development officer was able to Maximizing an quickly match the vision for a writing center with the desires of a potential donor, economic bringing in the funding for the renovations, equipment, and staffing necessary for such a service. As of this writing, an oversight committee comprised of Reference recession Librarians, library staff, English Department faculty, and the development officer is developing policies for the operation of the Writing Center. Housing such a center within the library will not only provide students with a valuable service through the 21 creation of a partnership, it positions the library as a key player in MSU’s Quality Enhancement Plan (QEP) for the upcoming accreditation by the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools (SACS) agency, particularly since writing skills was chosen by a university vote as the focus of ongoing QEP efforts. These descriptions of library partnerships in tight economic times are not exhaustive, nor are partnerships limited to space allocations or uses within an existing building. For example, the Murray State University Libraries partnered with five other offices on campus, including the Institute for International Studies and the President’s Office to acquire a web-based subscription to Rosetta Stone. The University Libraries have forged or strengthened relations with other units on campus such as Dining Services and the Honors Program. These partnerships allow for the expansion or improvement of services, despite rescissions and budget cuts. 3.4 Value-added services Thus far, this case study on how one university library system used economic hardships as an opportunity to reposition itself strategically has focused on large projects such as capital construction planning, the creation or strengthening of long-term partnerships, and the cultivation of donors. In this section, the author shifts direction to focus instead on three value-added services which Murray State University Libraries put together to enhance service or access, without having to rely on “permanent” additional funding. The first such value-added service is a pay-per-view (user-driven acquisition) program offered to MSU’s College of Science, Engineering, and Technology. User-driven acquisition is a topic of much discussion in the realm of serials acquisition and management, and in order to serve a lack of content created by a large journal cancellation, the University Libraries diverted a portion of end-of-year “one-time” money to the creation of an account with Science Direct. This account allowed the University Libraries to put into place a pay-per-view program to serve the faculty of the College of Science with instant access to the content of many journals they otherwise would have to wait on interlibrary loan to provide. The program is intended to run as a trial for three years, at which point usage will be examined for further decisions on funding or the extension of the service to other subject areas. Two other value-added services relate to Reference and the delivery of subject-specific research assistance to library users. In collaboration with CTLT, the libraries obtained a permanent link in each Blackboard course-shell (Blackboard is the Learning Management System used by Murray State) to a service called “Library on Bb”. Unlike many library links embedded within Blackboard, this link did not simply direct students to the library’s website. Instead, students were presented with a subject index, which allowed them to navigate to in-depth subject guides while remaining
  • 10. BL within Blackboard. The university is in the process of aligning all authentication 24,1 systems so that eventually, anyone off campus logged into Blackboard will also automatically be logged in to library resources. This simple project has grown into one of the University Libraries’ most powerful tools, as subject-specific federated search engines were embedded within each subject guide. More recently, LibGuides was purchased as a means to transform the subject guide pages from static web pages to a 22 more dynamic model, with control and placement of the content resting with the reference librarians. Finally, the Murray State University Libraries recently added texting services as a method of receiving reference questions from library users. Available through Mosio’s “Text-a-Librarian” program for a very modest price, this service does not require the University Libraries to maintain a cell phone plan, but instead allows reference librarians to send answers to reference questions by computer to library users’ cell phones. In place beginning in January 2010, this value-added service has seen steady use since its inception. These and other value-added services allow the Murray State University Libraries to continually improve the quality or accessibility of services without waiting for new funding to do so. 4. Conclusion Difficult economic conditions result in a set of challenges and uncertainties that while unfortunate, present libraries with opportunities to re-position themselves strategically and politically within their user communities. As this case study demonstrates, such efforts can be large or small in nature, depending on the particular circumstances in which the library operates. Large capital projects, planning, or donor cultivation do not have to be put on hold because of tight financial constraints; in fact, the success generated by increased library use during periods of economic recession can help prove the need for such large activities. Likewise, value-added services can be investigated and implemented without overly straining flat budgets or jeopardizing staff positions. As the quote at the beginning of this article indicates, letting the historical budget drive current and ongoing initiatives and services ignores the possibilities that turbulent financial times present to libraries for reinventing themselves. For the saavy librarian, the worst of times can sometimes be transformed into the best of times. References Bullington, J. and Lee, J. (2009), “Tough economic times call for more library cooperation: report on a Wyoming and Colorado Alliance Conference”, Collaborative Librarianship, Vol. 1 No. 4, pp. 151-5. DiMattia, S. (2008), “Getting the money you need: relationships and fundraising”, Online, Vol. 32 No. 1, pp. 22-6. Dougherty, R. (2009), “Prescription for financial recovery”, American Libraries, Vol. 40 No. 6, pp. 50-3. Fialkoff, F. (2008), “Serving in tough times”, Library Journal, Vol. 133 No. 17, p. 8. Fialkoff, F. (2010), “Editorial: Recession-buster”, Library Journal, Vol. 135 No. 1, p. 8. Gerding, S. (2008), “Tips and resources for finding grants”, Online, Vol. 32 No. 6, pp. 16-21. Goldberg, B. (2008), “Economic uncertainty spreads to library endowments”, American Libraries, Vol. 39 No. 10, pp. 20-1.
  • 11. Kenney, B. (2009), “United we stand”, School Library Journal, Vol. 55 No. 6, p. 11. Maximizing an Keresztury, T. (2009), “The library crisis in New Jersey: a statewide strategy for survival”, economic The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 22 No. 4, pp. 101-5. Marcum, J. (2007), “It’s not the dollars, it’s the politics”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library recession Finances, Vol. 20 No. 4, pp. 161-4. Marcum, J. (2008), “Partnering for innovation and sustainability”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 82-4. 23 Miller, R. (2010), “Fundraising in the downturn”, Library Journal, Vol. 135, pp. 48-50. Silverman, E. (2009a), “Staying positive in a down economy”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 22 No. 1, pp. 27-9. Silverman, E. (2009b), “Inviting the donor to give”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 22 No. 4, pp. 139-41. Stearns, E. (2009), “Top ten marketing tips for financial strength and sustainability”, Illinois Library Association Reporter, Vol. 27 No. 5, pp. 8-9. About the author Adam Murray completed his Master’s in Library and Information Studies from the University of North Carolina at Greensboro in 2006. At the age of 27, he became Interim Dean of University Libraries, a position he held for two years before his appointment as Dean in 2010. He has been recognized by the American Library Association as an Emerging Leader in the class of 2009, a distinguished alumnus (early career category) of UNCG, and is an alumnus of Vanderbilt University’s Academic Library Leadership Institute. He is currently pursuing a doctoral degree in Educational Leadership from Western Kentucky University. Adam Murray can be contacted at: adam.murray@murraystate.edu To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints