SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 17
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Housing Affordability Primer
Prepared by: Kimberley Crofts z3199999
PLAN7148 – STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING – 2019
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Housing Affordability Primer
This Primer has been prepared for the
incoming Housing Affordability Tsar for
NSW. We welcome this appointment to
address much needed reform.
Housing is a critical component of a
healthy and equal society (Emsley, et
al., 2008). Yet, the affordability of
housing in Sydney has declined sharply
in the past forty to fifty years, hitting
lower income households in middle to
outer-suburbs most acutely (Gleeson,
Low, 2000; Yates and Milligan et al.,
2007).
CONTENTS
Background & context ……………………………………….. 3
Levers for change ………………………………………………… 4
Reduce the upfront cost of land ………………….. 5
Alternative funding & ownership models …... 8
Innovative approaches to building ……………….11
Conclusion ……………………………………………………….... 14
References ………………………...………………………………. 15
2
We recognise the complexity of the situation,
due in part to the involvement of multiple
stakeholders across levels of government, the
private sector, and not-for-profit entities. This
primer seeks to address some of this complexity
and offer suggestions for ways forward. In
particular we focus on three levers:
1. Reducing the upfront cost of land
2. Alternative funding & ownership models
3. Innovative approaches to building.
The three sections of this primer address these
levers, and also give an overview of associated
key issues, best practices, and opportunities.
Whilst we have provided examples from
different Australian and international cities, it is
important to recognise the importance of local
context in the development of affordable
housing, primarily because of the highly variable
nature of policy and housing market
characteristics (Randolph, et al., 2018).
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Background & context
Sydney’s population is estimated to
grow by 1.74 million by 2036, resulting
in a need for an additional 725,000
homes across Sydney (NSW
Department of Planning, 2019).
Without a comprehensive affordable
housing strategy, the pressures of
increasing housing costs currently
experienced by lower income
households across Sydney are unlikely
to ease.
With lack of access to affordable housing
comes housing stress, which is particularly high
in Sydney, with an estimated 57.7 per cent of
lower income renter households in metropolitan
Sydney paying more than 30 per cent of total
household income on housing costs in the
period 2017 to 2018 (ABS, 2019).
Health implications related to housing stress
include a lack of nutrition as low income earners
cut back on essentials such as food, along with
more long-term mental health implications from
continued stress caused by instability in housing
(Singh et al., 2019; Yates, Milligan, 2007).
The location of housing can further embed
disadvantage because of reduced access to
transport and employment (Commonwealth of
Australia, 2014; Dodson, Sipe, 2008; Winter,
2013).
3
There have been multiple and high-profile claims
that housing supply is failing to keep up with
demand, and that this affects affordability
(Daley, et al., 2018; RBA, 2014). In response, the
NSW Premier has identified housing affordability
as one of 12 Premier’s Priorities, primarily
looking at increasing supply through fast
tracking of housing approvals and rezoning,
with aims to complete 61,000 houses by 2021
(NSW Government, 2019).
Research demonstrates, however, that blanket
increases in supply will have only modest
results, suggesting that there are more complex
and nuanced factors at play in the supply of
affordable housing (Ong et al., 2017; Pinnegar,
Randolph, 2012).
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Levers for change
This primer introduces three levers
aimed at reducing the gap between
what people can pay and what the
market or government can build. The
coordinated application of measures in
three related areas should see some
improvements in affordability.
LEVER 1: Reduce the upfront cost of land so
that affordable housing providers do not have to
compete with private developers.
LEVER 2: Provide a spectrum of funding
mechanisms to expand the capacity of a greater
range of low-income households to secure
affordable housing.
LEVER 3:Explore innovative models of building
that reduce upfront costs and help low-income
households enter the housing market.
4
LEVER 2
FUNDING
LEVER 1
LAND
LEVER 3
BUILDING
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Access to cheap land is a major barrier
to the development of affordable
housing (Randolph et al., 2018). In
Sydney, the trend has been for new
affordable housing to be built at a
distance from the city centre and areas
of highest employment as land toward
the centre has become more expensive
(Dodson, Sipe, 2008).
Since 2011, approximately $10 billion of
government-owned property assets
have been sold (Robertson, 2017). This
privatisation of previously public space
is a trend which appears likely to
continue.
KEY ISSUES
Land costs significantly add to long term
project costs for affordable housing
developers. The cost of land is approximately
15% of total housing costs for infill
developments and up to 23 per cent for
greenfield developments (URBIS, 2011). Whilst
this does not represent the most significant cost
for new buildings—construction can be up to 60
per cent—in markets such as Sydney this can be
a significant cost that affordable housing
developers must carry over the term of the
investment.
Attractiveness of short-term commercial
returns. The Coalition Government’s
privatisation agenda means that there is little
exploration of more long-term finance
arrangements that could be as, if not more,
financially beneficial than the cost of land
(Randolph, et al, 2018).
5
Reducing the upfront cost of land
LEVER 1
Whilst we do not begrudge a desire to
finance government services through
these sales, we believe there might be
an opportunity to think more creatively
around the provision, use and valuation
of public land in order to attract the
building of affordable homes where
they are most needed.
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Best practice
Community land Trusts (CLTs)
CLTs have been credited as providing
similar benefits to outright ownership such
as security of tenure (Crabtree et al., 2012;
Pinnegar, et al., 2008). Dedication of public
land to affordable housing has been used
by the cities of Port Phillip and Brisbane to
deliver significant results (Emsley et al.,
2008).
6
Land rent schemes for individuals
As part of the ACT Affordable Housing
Action Plan, households earning less than
$85,000 per annum were offered a
residential block of land to rent from the
government at two per cent of the land
value. This scheme enabled low income
households to reduce the deposit gap and
the overall cost of building a new home
The program aimed at providing for 1,000
households, and has subsequently been
opened up to the community housing
sector (Rowley et al., 2017).
LEVER 1: REDUCING THE UPFRONT COST OF LAND
Moncrieff West in Canberra has properties built as part of
the Land Rent Scheme (Photo: Spacelab)
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Opportunities
Reduce long-term project costs
through land contributions
Lessening the upfront cost of land will
reduce the overall cost of developing
affordable housing. This is because, unlike
for-profit developers who get immediate
return on or before completion, community
housing and affordable housing developers
are often required to spread their debt over
a longer period, meaning they often pay
more interest (Randolph, et al, 2018).
7
Government retains equity
Rather than outright sales of public land,
the government should consider retaining
equity in some developments in exchange
for the contribution of land. This is a more
long-term approach that could see
governments receive greater financial
rewards than one-off, short-term sales.
Treat land as a platform
for social good
This change of framing helps to place
greater importance on the long-term value
of land retention for public good (Parvin,
Reeve, 2019). With this in mind, it is
recommended that in locations where
affordable housing will have the most
impact, the government should reconsider
the need to achieve the ‘highest and best
use’ price for that land.
LEVER 1: REDUCING THE UPFRONT COST OF LAND
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Alternative funding & ownership models
8
LEVER 2
The great Australian dream of home
ownership may not benefit all
households equally, because too often,
low income households are forced to
buy properties of poor quality in
substandard locations (Dodson, Sipe,
2008).
Rather than assuming that people on
low incomes can or will want to own a
property outright, it is worth exploring
spectrums of ownership and equity
across the ‘housing continuum’ that
might provide similar benefits.
The discontinuation of the National Rental
Affordability Scheme (NRAS) has raised fears
of negative outcomes for low-income renters
(Aliento, 2018; Burke, 2018), especially when
compared to recent ABS figures which show
that housing costs as a proportion of income
are rising for renters (ABS, 2019).
Inclusionary planning and planning bonuses
provide insufficient affordable housing. In the
UK, inclusionary planning requirements delivered
43 per cent of total affordable housing output
compared to just 1 per cent in Sydney (Emsley
et al., 2008; Gurran et al., 2018; Rowley, 2015).
Shared equity arrangements are highly
dependent on market stability. When markets
slowed in the late 1980s, NSW households with
HomeFund loans found that they owed more
money than their home was worth (Public
Interest Advocacy Centre, 2017). Greater caution
in this state toward shared equity schemes has
been attributed to this (Pinnegar, et al., 2008).
KEY ISSUES
Home ownership has become out of reach for
many. The borrowing capacity of households
has not grown at the same rate as the cost of
housing (Pinnegar et al., 2008; Yates and
Milligan et al., 2007). Structural factors, in
particular, have been linked to the lack of
pathways for lower-income households to home
ownership (Yates and Milligan et al., 2007).
Demand-side incentives affect affordability.
Mechanisms which increase the purchasing
power of first home buyers can drive up the
price of houses unless there is a corresponding
increase in supply (Karp, 2019; Pascoe, 2013;
Pinnegar et al., 2008; Yates, 2017). Moreover,
international research has shown that there has
been little increase in the supply of affordable
housing in countries where individual household
subsidies were the only mechanism applied
(Rowley et al., 2016).
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Best practice
Government retained equity
In Western Australia, the state government
has taken an equity share from a private
developer in return for the contribution of
the land (Randolph, et al, 2018). As the
government is able to draw on the value of
the housing along with onsite asset sales,
the return on this arrangement has far
exceed what they would have received from
the outright sale of the land.
Cooperative housing
This is a popular model in countries which
value collectivisation (Crabtree et al., 2019).
Co-ops account for 10 to 15 per cent of
housing in Sweden, Norway and Germany,
but just 0.05 per cent of the total housing
sector in Australia (SBS, 2013).
9
Nightingale Housing model
The ‘Nightingale Covenant’ caps profits at
15 per cent and is based around the offer of
perpetual affordability. Development costs
are reduced where possible, and ongoing
costs for residents are reduced through
sustainable building design. Nightingale
chooses owners by ballot and gives
preference to key workers and Indigenous
people (Cumming, 2018; Nightingale
Housing, 2018).
LEVER 2: ALTERNATIVE FUNDING AND OWNERSHIP MODELS
Nightingale 1 in Brunswick, Melbourne
(Photo: Nightingale Housing)
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Opportunities
Encourage the Federal Government
to resume the National Rental
Affordability Scheme
Community Housing advocates have called
for its reinstatement as part of a cohesive
affordable housing strategy (Aliento, 2018;
Burke, 2018). If reinstated, it is suggested
that the flat-rate of the subsidy should be
altered to take into account spatial aspects
to affordability, as the funding gap in high
cost locations cannot always be met
through the subsidy (Randolph et al., 2018).
10
Combine shared equity with
reductions in land costs
To reduce the impact of market changes to
the value of homes within shared equity
schemes (such as with HomeFund), the
overall cost of the property should be
lessened, potentially through land rent
schemes as proposed in the previous
section.
Increase levels of cooperative
housing
There is scope for NSW to further promote
the use of cooperative models to provide
affordable housing (Emsley, et al., 2008).
The sector in NSW could be assisted
through scaling back recent changes to the
income and asset tests for residents.
Previously there was an allocation of 35 per
cent of residents who did not have to meet
any eligibility requirements, meaning a
greater diversity of residents and higher
revenues for the co-ops (Crabtree et al.,
2019).
LEVER 2: ALTERNATIVE FUNDING AND OWNERSHIP MODELS
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Innovative approaches to building
11
LEVER 3
There are multiple barriers to people
with low incomes entering the formal
housing market (Gurran et al., 2019).
Although the high cost of purchasing a
home is a major factor, it is also worth
noting that there have been few
changes to the models of affordable
housing supply—including how the
homes themselves are built—especially
in light of dramatic demographic shifts
in Australia’s population (Milligan et al.,
2014). This means that even if there are
sufficient affordable homes, they are
not necessarily meeting the needs of
our current population.
Ongoing costs of maintenance of low-cost
buildings. Residents of housing built at low cost
are often beset with significant costs for
heating, cooling, and maintenance because of
the poor quality of the build (Gibbs, 2017).
Lack of variety in housing types in areas of
most need. The provision of a diverse range of
housing creates affordability for a diverse range
of people (Rowley, Phibbs, 2012). Yet in Sydney,
detached dwellings dominate suburbs of
disadvantage, with apartments tending toward
areas of greater advantage such as the CBD or
along transport nodes (Hulse, et al., 2014).
KEY ISSUES
Informal dwelling construction is on the
increase but doesn’t always comply. According
to Gurran et al., higher levels of informal housing
are being built across Sydney to match the
undersupply of cheaper housing—and lack of
flexibility in building types—yet many of these do
not comply with the planning system and
building codes (Gurran et al., 2019). This raises
issues of safety, health, privacy and general
liveability for occupants.
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Best practice
Direct relationships between
council and home owner
People on low incomes in Almere in the
Netherlands can buy land from the local
council and then choose from a range of
ready-made homes to place on their plot, or
design their own based on some official
design principles. Over 3,000 homes are
planned for this region (Feary, 2015;
NACSBA, 2019).
Greater levels of self-build
The UK Government’s National Planning
Policy Framework stipulates that councils
must provide for the self-build market,
noting that it could be a key in the provision
of affordable housing (Ministry of Housing,
Communities and Local Government,
2019).
12
‘Half a House’ concept
This is a model where homeowners are
provided with the bare basics of a home for
an affordable price, allowing them the
space to expand through self-build as and
when they have the resources to do so
(Turner, 1972). This model was put into play
when affordable ‘half houses’ were sold to
earthquake survivors in Conception, Chile
(Zilliacus, 2016).
Building community capacity
The Lockhart River Aboriginal Shire Council
has used funding from the federal
government's National Partnership
Agreement on Remote Indigenous Housing
(NPARIH) to upskill local people to build
their own houses (Mounter, 2019).
LEVER 2: INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO BUILDING
Vila Verde in Conception Chile – A ‘Half a House’ model.
(Photo: Arch Daily)
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Opportunities
Allow for the building of more
flexible housing
Traditional models of family houses do not
allow the flexibility required of today’s
families. Principles of flexibility could be
engaged to allow for expansion and
contraction over time. We suggest that the
Tsar could assist councils to take a more
proactive stance on the revision of building
codes to allow for greater flexibility.
13
Consider ongoing costs when
measuring affordability
Gibbs suggests that affordability as a
concept needs reframing to include the
ongoing costs paid by households through
their tenure (Gibbs, 2017). This includes
payment for electricity, insurance and
maintenance, a significant cost for some
when buildings are of poor quality. This
would need to work in concert with
measures to alleviate the extra costs
associated with the use of quality materials
and building techniques.
Ensure affordable housing does
not further embed disadvantage
Climate resilience means building homes
which will protect occupants from rising
heat and other effects of climate change.
Sustainable buildings will reduce ongoing
costs to residents (Emsley, et al., 2008).
Reinvigorate self-build traditions
Australia has a long tradition of self-build,
and as late as 2003, NSW offered a
self-build subsidy (Crabtree, 2018). There
may be capacity for the government to
partner with an organisation such as
Habitat for Humanity Australia who offer
reduced rate home loans in return for
‘sweat equity’ during construction (Habitat
for Humanity, 2018).
LEVER 2: INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO BUILDING
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
Conclusion
14
A range of challenges and opportunities
have been introduced here while by no
means comprehensive, should offer a
source of inspiration to the incoming Tsar
as they tackle this crisis in housing
affordability. A lack of appetite of
successive governments to consider and
provide affordable housing has contributed
to this crisis, as has the complexity involved
in coordinating responses across levels of
government and with the non-profit and
private sectors on which the responsibility
of provision of most affordable housing has
been placed.
If there were to be one overarching
recommendation it would be for the
creation of a governance framework for
housing affordability—consisting of the the
levers mentioned in this paper— which can
encompass and guide the navigation of this
complex system. As, without sufficient
policy and responsibilities it will be difficult
to achieve the aims of providing affordable
housing to all.
It is worth stressing that societal goals of
greater housing affordability will not be
reached by simple solutions. Different
households experience housing affordability
problems in different ways, so what is
suitable for one household may not be so
for another. Policy responses will therefore
need to be varied, integrated, and
cross-governmental (Yates, Milligan, 2007).
This effort will be worth it, however, as
housing is such a critical component of a
healthy and equal society (Emsley, et al.,
2008). In addition, the government should
benefit from the financial savings from less
spend on other services—such as mental
health—which are related to the housing
stress experienced by many people on low
incomes.
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
References
15
ABS 2019, Housing Occupancy and Costs, Australia, 2007–08 to 2017–18,
Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra.
Aikman, M., Frankel, D. & Wood, S., National dwelling cost study, URBIS, 2011.
Aliento, W. 2018, End of NRAS means even less affordable housing. Available:
https://www.communityhousing.com.au/nras/ [2019, 7 August].
Burke, K. 2018, More Australians at risk of homelessness as National Rental
Affordability Scheme comes to an end. Available:
https://www.domain.com.au/news/nras-782290/
Crabtree, L., Grimstad, S., McNeill, J., Perry, N., & Power, E. (2019). Articulating Value
in Cooperative Housing: International and Methodological Review.
Crabtree, L., Phibbs, P., Milligan, V. & Blunden, H. 2012, "Principles and practices of an
affordable housing Community Land Trust model", Australian Housing and
Urban Research Institute, .
Crabtree, L. 2018, "Self-organised housing in Australia: housing diversity in an age of
market heat", International Journal of Housing Policy, vol. 18, no. 1.
Cumming, A. 2018, Redefining the model: Nightingale. Available:
https://renew.org.au/sanctuary-magazine/multi-residential/refining-the-model/
Daley, J., Coates, B. & Wiltshire, T. 2018, Housing affordability: re-imagining the
Australian dream, Grattan Institute.
Dodson, J. & Sipe, N. 2008, Unsettling suburbia: The new landscape of oil and
mortgage vulnerability in Australian cities, Urban Research Program,
Griffith University.
Emsley, S., Phibbs, P. & Crabtree, L. 2008, Models of sustainable and affordable
housing for local government, Urban Research Centre, Sydney.
Feary, T. 2015, Inside Almere: the Dutch city that's pioneering alternative housing.
Available: https://www.theguardian.com/housing-network/2015/dec/
15/almere-dutch-city-alternative-housing-custom-build [2019, 5 August].
Gibbs, M. 2017, Affordable housing is not just about the purchase price.
Available: https://theconversation.com/affordable-housing-is-not-
just-about-the-purchase-price-7585Gleeson, B. & Low, N.P. 2000, Australian
urban planning, 1st publ. edn, Allen & Unwin, St. Leonards.
Gurran, N., Gilbert, C., Gibb, K., van den Nouwelant, R., James, A. & Phibbs, P. 2018,
"Supporting affordable housing supply: inclusionary planning in new and
renewing communities", AHURI Final Report, no. 297.
Gurran, N., Pill, M., Maalsen, S., Alizadeh, T. & Shrestha, P. 2019, Informal
accommodation and vulnerable households, Sydney Policy Lab, Sydney.
Habitat for Humanity 2018, Habitat for Humanity: What we do. Available:
https://habitat.org.au/what-we-do/australia/nsw/ [2019, 10 August].
Hulse, K., Pawson, H., Reynolds, M.A. & Herath, S. 2014, Disadvantaged places in
urban Australia: analysing socio-economic diversity and housing market
performance, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.
Karp, P. 2019, First homebuyers' scheme: who gets it and will it work?
Available: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/may/13/
first-homebuyers-scheme-who-gets-it-and-will-it-work-explainer [2019, 30 July].
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
References
16
Milligan, V., Pawson, H., Randolph, B. & Yates, J. 2014, City Futures Submission to
the Senate Economics References Committee Inquiry on Affordable Housing,
City Futures Research Centre, UNSW, Sydney.
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government 2019, National Planning
Policy Framework (England), 1st edn, Oxford University Press.
Mounter, B. 2019, Lockhart River locals skill up to build houses and reduce
overcrowding in homes. Available:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-08-05/lockhart-river-builds-houses-red
uces-overcrowding-in-homes/11338282?pfmredir=sm.
NACSBA 2019, The first self build project achieved on a truly large scale. Available:
https://selfbuildportal.org.uk/case-studies/homeruskwartier-district-almere
[2019, 7 August].
Nightingale Housing 2019, Nightingale Housing website. Available:
https://nightingalehousing.org/faq [2019, 9 August].
NSW Department of Planning 2019, Sydney Housing Supply Forecast. Available:
https://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/Research-and-Demography/Sydney-hous
ing-supply-forecast [2019, 29 July].
NSW Government 2019, Key Issues for the 57th Parliament, NSW Parliamentary
Research Service, Sydney.
Ong, R., Dalton, T., Gurran, N., Phelps, C., Rowley, S. & Wood, G. 2017, Housing
supply responsiveness in Australia: distribution, drivers and institutional
settings, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited,
Melbourne.
Parvin, A. & Reeve, A. 2019, Affordable Land, Open Systems Lab. London, UK.
Pascoe, M. 2013, Grants do not help first home buyers. Available:
https://www.smh.com.au/business/grants-do-not-help-first-home-buyers-2013
0327-2gtas.html [2019, 30 July].
Pinnegar, S., Milligan, V., Quintal, D., Randolph, B., Williams, P. & Yates, J. 2008,
Innovative financing for home ownership: the potential for shared equity
initiatives in Australia, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.
Pinnegar, S. & Randolph, B. 2012, "Renewing the West: Prospects for urban
regeneration in Sydney’s western suburbs", City Futures Research Paper No. 13.
Public Interest Advocacy Centre, HomeFund: fair loans. Available:
https://www.piac.asn.au/legal-help/public-interest-cases/homefund-fair-loans/
[2019, 2 August].
Randolph, B., Troy, L., Milligan, V. & van den Nouwelant, R. 2018, Paying for affordable
housing in different market contexts, Australian Housing and Urban Research
Institute.
RBA 2014, Submission to the Inquiry into Affordable Housing. Available:
https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/submissions/housing-and-housing-finan
ce/inquiry-affordable-housing/ [2019, 18 July].
Robertson, G. 2017, Government's privatisation push extends to $9 billion property
sale pipeline. Available: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/
governments-privatisation-push-extends-to-9-billion-property-sale-pipeline-201
70904-gyagew.html [2019, 31 July].
KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2
References
17
Rowley, S. 2015, Increasing land supply isn’t the answer to the affordable housing
problem. Available: https://theconversation.com/increasing-land-supply-
isnt-the-answer-to-the-affordable-housing-problem-50074 [2019, 7 August].
Rowley, S., James, A., Gilbert, C., Gurran, N., Ong, R., Phibbs, P., Rosen, D. &
Whitehead, C. 2016, "Subsidised affordable rental housing: lessons from
Australia and overseas", AHURI Final Report, , no. 267.
Rowley, S., James, A., Phibbs, P., van den Nouwelant, R. & Troy, L. 2017, "Government
led innovations in affordable housing delivery", AHURI Final Report, , no. 289.
Rowley, S. & Phibbs, P. 2012, Delivering diverse and affordable housing on infill
development sites, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.
SBS 2013, Co-op housing: an affordable housing solution?. Available:
https://www.sbs.com.au/news/co-op-housing-an-affordable-housing-solution
[2019, 9 August].
Singh, A., Daniel, L., Baker, E. & Bentley, R. 2019, "Housing Disadvantage and Poor
Mental Health: A Systematic Review", American Journal of Preventive
Medicine, vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 262-272.
Turner, J. 1972, "Housing as a verb" in Freedom to build; dweller control of the
housing process, eds. J. Turner & R. Fichter, Collier Macmillan, New York.
Yates, J. 2017, "Housing Australia" in Housing Australia CEDA, Melbourne.
Yates, J. & Milligan, V. 2007, Housing affordability: a 21st century problem,
Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.
Zilliacus, A. 2016, , Half A House Builds A Whole Community. Available:
https://www.archdaily.com/797779/half-a-house-builds-a-whole-community-
elementals-controversial-social-housing [2019, 18 July].

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Primer on affordable housing

Housing Value.docx
Housing Value.docxHousing Value.docx
Housing Value.docx
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghanaA model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
Alexander Decker
 
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghanaA model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
Alexander Decker
 

Ähnlich wie Primer on affordable housing (20)

Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptxAffordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
 
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI)
 
Housing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeriaHousing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeria
 
HOUSING ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING.pptx
HOUSING ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING.pptxHOUSING ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING.pptx
HOUSING ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING.pptx
 
Paul Cheshire slides | Wolfson Economics Prize 2014 conference
Paul Cheshire slides | Wolfson Economics Prize 2014 conferencePaul Cheshire slides | Wolfson Economics Prize 2014 conference
Paul Cheshire slides | Wolfson Economics Prize 2014 conference
 
Housing Value.docx
Housing Value.docxHousing Value.docx
Housing Value.docx
 
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDYNational Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
 
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housingStanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
 
03 Larkham Morton
03 Larkham Morton03 Larkham Morton
03 Larkham Morton
 
Affordable Self Sustaining Housing In Developing Countries Of Composite Clima...
Affordable Self Sustaining Housing In Developing Countries Of Composite Clima...Affordable Self Sustaining Housing In Developing Countries Of Composite Clima...
Affordable Self Sustaining Housing In Developing Countries Of Composite Clima...
 
Research report on phil. housing finance sector of Philippines
Research report on phil. housing finance sector of PhilippinesResearch report on phil. housing finance sector of Philippines
Research report on phil. housing finance sector of Philippines
 
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
 
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
 
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghanaA model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
 
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghanaA model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
A model for reactivating abandoned public housing projects in ghana
 
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housingChandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
 
Public Private Partnership in Affordable Housing
Public Private Partnership in Affordable HousingPublic Private Partnership in Affordable Housing
Public Private Partnership in Affordable Housing
 
Introductio1.docx
Introductio1.docxIntroductio1.docx
Introductio1.docx
 
Home matters nrv home_report_opt
Home matters nrv home_report_optHome matters nrv home_report_opt
Home matters nrv home_report_opt
 
Affordable Housing, Slum Redevelopment In Cities of India
Affordable Housing, Slum Redevelopment In Cities of IndiaAffordable Housing, Slum Redevelopment In Cities of India
Affordable Housing, Slum Redevelopment In Cities of India
 

Mehr von Kimberley Crofts

Mehr von Kimberley Crofts (9)

Nena Research Jam 2021
Nena Research Jam 2021Nena Research Jam 2021
Nena Research Jam 2021
 
Hunter valley organisations
Hunter valley organisationsHunter valley organisations
Hunter valley organisations
 
Sustainable institutes map v1
Sustainable institutes map v1Sustainable institutes map v1
Sustainable institutes map v1
 
The Resilient River
The Resilient RiverThe Resilient River
The Resilient River
 
Rydalmere masterplan
Rydalmere masterplanRydalmere masterplan
Rydalmere masterplan
 
Presentation to the Greater Sydney Commission
Presentation to the Greater Sydney CommissionPresentation to the Greater Sydney Commission
Presentation to the Greater Sydney Commission
 
Auditing the interchange
Auditing the interchangeAuditing the interchange
Auditing the interchange
 
Improving transport in eastern sydney
Improving transport in eastern sydneyImproving transport in eastern sydney
Improving transport in eastern sydney
 
Mapping access
Mapping accessMapping access
Mapping access
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dehradun🔝 Escor...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dehradun🔝   Escor...➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dehradun🔝   Escor...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dehradun🔝 Escor...
amitlee9823
 
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
amitlee9823
 
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
amitlee9823
 
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
instagramfab782445
 
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
amitlee9823
 
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
amitlee9823
 
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
nirzagarg
 
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dharamshala🔝 ...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dharamshala🔝  ...➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dharamshala🔝  ...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dharamshala🔝 ...
amitlee9823
 
How to Build a Simple Shopify Website
How to Build a Simple Shopify WebsiteHow to Build a Simple Shopify Website
How to Build a Simple Shopify Website
mark11275
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Pooja 9892124323, Call girls Services and Mumbai Escort Service Near Hotel Gi...
Pooja 9892124323, Call girls Services and Mumbai Escort Service Near Hotel Gi...Pooja 9892124323, Call girls Services and Mumbai Escort Service Near Hotel Gi...
Pooja 9892124323, Call girls Services and Mumbai Escort Service Near Hotel Gi...
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Meerut Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Meerut Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Meerut Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Meerut Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dehradun🔝 Escor...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dehradun🔝   Escor...➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dehradun🔝   Escor...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dehradun Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dehradun🔝 Escor...
 
Gamestore case study UI UX by Amgad Ibrahim
Gamestore case study UI UX by Amgad IbrahimGamestore case study UI UX by Amgad Ibrahim
Gamestore case study UI UX by Amgad Ibrahim
 
VIP Model Call Girls Kalyani Nagar ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From ...
VIP Model Call Girls Kalyani Nagar ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From ...VIP Model Call Girls Kalyani Nagar ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From ...
VIP Model Call Girls Kalyani Nagar ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From ...
 
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
Whitefield Call Girls Service: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Ba...
 
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Nagavara ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
 
Just Call Vip call girls Nagpur Escorts ☎️8617370543 Starting From 5K to 25K ...
Just Call Vip call girls Nagpur Escorts ☎️8617370543 Starting From 5K to 25K ...Just Call Vip call girls Nagpur Escorts ☎️8617370543 Starting From 5K to 25K ...
Just Call Vip call girls Nagpur Escorts ☎️8617370543 Starting From 5K to 25K ...
 
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
Abortion pill for sale in Muscat (+918761049707)) Get Cytotec Cash on deliver...
 
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
Escorts Service Basapura ☎ 7737669865☎ Book Your One night Stand (Bangalore)
 
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Brookefield Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
 
Hingoli ❤CALL GIRL 8617370543 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Hingoli ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
Hingoli ❤CALL GIRL 8617370543 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Hingoli ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRLHingoli ❤CALL GIRL 8617370543 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Hingoli ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
Hingoli ❤CALL GIRL 8617370543 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Hingoli ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
 
call girls in Vasundhra (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
call girls in Vasundhra (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...call girls in Vasundhra (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
call girls in Vasundhra (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
 
call girls in Kaushambi (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
call girls in Kaushambi (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...call girls in Kaushambi (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
call girls in Kaushambi (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝...
 
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
Nisha Yadav Escorts Service Ernakulam ❣️ 7014168258 ❣️ High Cost Unlimited Ha...
 
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dharamshala🔝 ...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dharamshala🔝  ...➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men  🔝dharamshala🔝  ...
➥🔝 7737669865 🔝▻ dharamshala Call-girls in Women Seeking Men 🔝dharamshala🔝 ...
 
How to Build a Simple Shopify Website
How to Build a Simple Shopify WebsiteHow to Build a Simple Shopify Website
How to Build a Simple Shopify Website
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Call Girl Baran is experienced
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Call Girl Baran is experiencedWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Call Girl Baran is experienced
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Call Girl Baran is experienced
 
Sector 104, Noida Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
Sector 104, Noida Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verifiedSector 104, Noida Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
Sector 104, Noida Call girls :8448380779 Model Escorts | 100% verified
 

Primer on affordable housing

  • 1. Housing Affordability Primer Prepared by: Kimberley Crofts z3199999 PLAN7148 – STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING – 2019
  • 2. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Housing Affordability Primer This Primer has been prepared for the incoming Housing Affordability Tsar for NSW. We welcome this appointment to address much needed reform. Housing is a critical component of a healthy and equal society (Emsley, et al., 2008). Yet, the affordability of housing in Sydney has declined sharply in the past forty to fifty years, hitting lower income households in middle to outer-suburbs most acutely (Gleeson, Low, 2000; Yates and Milligan et al., 2007). CONTENTS Background & context ……………………………………….. 3 Levers for change ………………………………………………… 4 Reduce the upfront cost of land ………………….. 5 Alternative funding & ownership models …... 8 Innovative approaches to building ……………….11 Conclusion ……………………………………………………….... 14 References ………………………...………………………………. 15 2 We recognise the complexity of the situation, due in part to the involvement of multiple stakeholders across levels of government, the private sector, and not-for-profit entities. This primer seeks to address some of this complexity and offer suggestions for ways forward. In particular we focus on three levers: 1. Reducing the upfront cost of land 2. Alternative funding & ownership models 3. Innovative approaches to building. The three sections of this primer address these levers, and also give an overview of associated key issues, best practices, and opportunities. Whilst we have provided examples from different Australian and international cities, it is important to recognise the importance of local context in the development of affordable housing, primarily because of the highly variable nature of policy and housing market characteristics (Randolph, et al., 2018).
  • 3. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Background & context Sydney’s population is estimated to grow by 1.74 million by 2036, resulting in a need for an additional 725,000 homes across Sydney (NSW Department of Planning, 2019). Without a comprehensive affordable housing strategy, the pressures of increasing housing costs currently experienced by lower income households across Sydney are unlikely to ease. With lack of access to affordable housing comes housing stress, which is particularly high in Sydney, with an estimated 57.7 per cent of lower income renter households in metropolitan Sydney paying more than 30 per cent of total household income on housing costs in the period 2017 to 2018 (ABS, 2019). Health implications related to housing stress include a lack of nutrition as low income earners cut back on essentials such as food, along with more long-term mental health implications from continued stress caused by instability in housing (Singh et al., 2019; Yates, Milligan, 2007). The location of housing can further embed disadvantage because of reduced access to transport and employment (Commonwealth of Australia, 2014; Dodson, Sipe, 2008; Winter, 2013). 3 There have been multiple and high-profile claims that housing supply is failing to keep up with demand, and that this affects affordability (Daley, et al., 2018; RBA, 2014). In response, the NSW Premier has identified housing affordability as one of 12 Premier’s Priorities, primarily looking at increasing supply through fast tracking of housing approvals and rezoning, with aims to complete 61,000 houses by 2021 (NSW Government, 2019). Research demonstrates, however, that blanket increases in supply will have only modest results, suggesting that there are more complex and nuanced factors at play in the supply of affordable housing (Ong et al., 2017; Pinnegar, Randolph, 2012).
  • 4. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Levers for change This primer introduces three levers aimed at reducing the gap between what people can pay and what the market or government can build. The coordinated application of measures in three related areas should see some improvements in affordability. LEVER 1: Reduce the upfront cost of land so that affordable housing providers do not have to compete with private developers. LEVER 2: Provide a spectrum of funding mechanisms to expand the capacity of a greater range of low-income households to secure affordable housing. LEVER 3:Explore innovative models of building that reduce upfront costs and help low-income households enter the housing market. 4 LEVER 2 FUNDING LEVER 1 LAND LEVER 3 BUILDING
  • 5. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Access to cheap land is a major barrier to the development of affordable housing (Randolph et al., 2018). In Sydney, the trend has been for new affordable housing to be built at a distance from the city centre and areas of highest employment as land toward the centre has become more expensive (Dodson, Sipe, 2008). Since 2011, approximately $10 billion of government-owned property assets have been sold (Robertson, 2017). This privatisation of previously public space is a trend which appears likely to continue. KEY ISSUES Land costs significantly add to long term project costs for affordable housing developers. The cost of land is approximately 15% of total housing costs for infill developments and up to 23 per cent for greenfield developments (URBIS, 2011). Whilst this does not represent the most significant cost for new buildings—construction can be up to 60 per cent—in markets such as Sydney this can be a significant cost that affordable housing developers must carry over the term of the investment. Attractiveness of short-term commercial returns. The Coalition Government’s privatisation agenda means that there is little exploration of more long-term finance arrangements that could be as, if not more, financially beneficial than the cost of land (Randolph, et al, 2018). 5 Reducing the upfront cost of land LEVER 1 Whilst we do not begrudge a desire to finance government services through these sales, we believe there might be an opportunity to think more creatively around the provision, use and valuation of public land in order to attract the building of affordable homes where they are most needed.
  • 6. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Best practice Community land Trusts (CLTs) CLTs have been credited as providing similar benefits to outright ownership such as security of tenure (Crabtree et al., 2012; Pinnegar, et al., 2008). Dedication of public land to affordable housing has been used by the cities of Port Phillip and Brisbane to deliver significant results (Emsley et al., 2008). 6 Land rent schemes for individuals As part of the ACT Affordable Housing Action Plan, households earning less than $85,000 per annum were offered a residential block of land to rent from the government at two per cent of the land value. This scheme enabled low income households to reduce the deposit gap and the overall cost of building a new home The program aimed at providing for 1,000 households, and has subsequently been opened up to the community housing sector (Rowley et al., 2017). LEVER 1: REDUCING THE UPFRONT COST OF LAND Moncrieff West in Canberra has properties built as part of the Land Rent Scheme (Photo: Spacelab)
  • 7. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Opportunities Reduce long-term project costs through land contributions Lessening the upfront cost of land will reduce the overall cost of developing affordable housing. This is because, unlike for-profit developers who get immediate return on or before completion, community housing and affordable housing developers are often required to spread their debt over a longer period, meaning they often pay more interest (Randolph, et al, 2018). 7 Government retains equity Rather than outright sales of public land, the government should consider retaining equity in some developments in exchange for the contribution of land. This is a more long-term approach that could see governments receive greater financial rewards than one-off, short-term sales. Treat land as a platform for social good This change of framing helps to place greater importance on the long-term value of land retention for public good (Parvin, Reeve, 2019). With this in mind, it is recommended that in locations where affordable housing will have the most impact, the government should reconsider the need to achieve the ‘highest and best use’ price for that land. LEVER 1: REDUCING THE UPFRONT COST OF LAND
  • 8. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Alternative funding & ownership models 8 LEVER 2 The great Australian dream of home ownership may not benefit all households equally, because too often, low income households are forced to buy properties of poor quality in substandard locations (Dodson, Sipe, 2008). Rather than assuming that people on low incomes can or will want to own a property outright, it is worth exploring spectrums of ownership and equity across the ‘housing continuum’ that might provide similar benefits. The discontinuation of the National Rental Affordability Scheme (NRAS) has raised fears of negative outcomes for low-income renters (Aliento, 2018; Burke, 2018), especially when compared to recent ABS figures which show that housing costs as a proportion of income are rising for renters (ABS, 2019). Inclusionary planning and planning bonuses provide insufficient affordable housing. In the UK, inclusionary planning requirements delivered 43 per cent of total affordable housing output compared to just 1 per cent in Sydney (Emsley et al., 2008; Gurran et al., 2018; Rowley, 2015). Shared equity arrangements are highly dependent on market stability. When markets slowed in the late 1980s, NSW households with HomeFund loans found that they owed more money than their home was worth (Public Interest Advocacy Centre, 2017). Greater caution in this state toward shared equity schemes has been attributed to this (Pinnegar, et al., 2008). KEY ISSUES Home ownership has become out of reach for many. The borrowing capacity of households has not grown at the same rate as the cost of housing (Pinnegar et al., 2008; Yates and Milligan et al., 2007). Structural factors, in particular, have been linked to the lack of pathways for lower-income households to home ownership (Yates and Milligan et al., 2007). Demand-side incentives affect affordability. Mechanisms which increase the purchasing power of first home buyers can drive up the price of houses unless there is a corresponding increase in supply (Karp, 2019; Pascoe, 2013; Pinnegar et al., 2008; Yates, 2017). Moreover, international research has shown that there has been little increase in the supply of affordable housing in countries where individual household subsidies were the only mechanism applied (Rowley et al., 2016).
  • 9. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Best practice Government retained equity In Western Australia, the state government has taken an equity share from a private developer in return for the contribution of the land (Randolph, et al, 2018). As the government is able to draw on the value of the housing along with onsite asset sales, the return on this arrangement has far exceed what they would have received from the outright sale of the land. Cooperative housing This is a popular model in countries which value collectivisation (Crabtree et al., 2019). Co-ops account for 10 to 15 per cent of housing in Sweden, Norway and Germany, but just 0.05 per cent of the total housing sector in Australia (SBS, 2013). 9 Nightingale Housing model The ‘Nightingale Covenant’ caps profits at 15 per cent and is based around the offer of perpetual affordability. Development costs are reduced where possible, and ongoing costs for residents are reduced through sustainable building design. Nightingale chooses owners by ballot and gives preference to key workers and Indigenous people (Cumming, 2018; Nightingale Housing, 2018). LEVER 2: ALTERNATIVE FUNDING AND OWNERSHIP MODELS Nightingale 1 in Brunswick, Melbourne (Photo: Nightingale Housing)
  • 10. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Opportunities Encourage the Federal Government to resume the National Rental Affordability Scheme Community Housing advocates have called for its reinstatement as part of a cohesive affordable housing strategy (Aliento, 2018; Burke, 2018). If reinstated, it is suggested that the flat-rate of the subsidy should be altered to take into account spatial aspects to affordability, as the funding gap in high cost locations cannot always be met through the subsidy (Randolph et al., 2018). 10 Combine shared equity with reductions in land costs To reduce the impact of market changes to the value of homes within shared equity schemes (such as with HomeFund), the overall cost of the property should be lessened, potentially through land rent schemes as proposed in the previous section. Increase levels of cooperative housing There is scope for NSW to further promote the use of cooperative models to provide affordable housing (Emsley, et al., 2008). The sector in NSW could be assisted through scaling back recent changes to the income and asset tests for residents. Previously there was an allocation of 35 per cent of residents who did not have to meet any eligibility requirements, meaning a greater diversity of residents and higher revenues for the co-ops (Crabtree et al., 2019). LEVER 2: ALTERNATIVE FUNDING AND OWNERSHIP MODELS
  • 11. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Innovative approaches to building 11 LEVER 3 There are multiple barriers to people with low incomes entering the formal housing market (Gurran et al., 2019). Although the high cost of purchasing a home is a major factor, it is also worth noting that there have been few changes to the models of affordable housing supply—including how the homes themselves are built—especially in light of dramatic demographic shifts in Australia’s population (Milligan et al., 2014). This means that even if there are sufficient affordable homes, they are not necessarily meeting the needs of our current population. Ongoing costs of maintenance of low-cost buildings. Residents of housing built at low cost are often beset with significant costs for heating, cooling, and maintenance because of the poor quality of the build (Gibbs, 2017). Lack of variety in housing types in areas of most need. The provision of a diverse range of housing creates affordability for a diverse range of people (Rowley, Phibbs, 2012). Yet in Sydney, detached dwellings dominate suburbs of disadvantage, with apartments tending toward areas of greater advantage such as the CBD or along transport nodes (Hulse, et al., 2014). KEY ISSUES Informal dwelling construction is on the increase but doesn’t always comply. According to Gurran et al., higher levels of informal housing are being built across Sydney to match the undersupply of cheaper housing—and lack of flexibility in building types—yet many of these do not comply with the planning system and building codes (Gurran et al., 2019). This raises issues of safety, health, privacy and general liveability for occupants.
  • 12. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Best practice Direct relationships between council and home owner People on low incomes in Almere in the Netherlands can buy land from the local council and then choose from a range of ready-made homes to place on their plot, or design their own based on some official design principles. Over 3,000 homes are planned for this region (Feary, 2015; NACSBA, 2019). Greater levels of self-build The UK Government’s National Planning Policy Framework stipulates that councils must provide for the self-build market, noting that it could be a key in the provision of affordable housing (Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, 2019). 12 ‘Half a House’ concept This is a model where homeowners are provided with the bare basics of a home for an affordable price, allowing them the space to expand through self-build as and when they have the resources to do so (Turner, 1972). This model was put into play when affordable ‘half houses’ were sold to earthquake survivors in Conception, Chile (Zilliacus, 2016). Building community capacity The Lockhart River Aboriginal Shire Council has used funding from the federal government's National Partnership Agreement on Remote Indigenous Housing (NPARIH) to upskill local people to build their own houses (Mounter, 2019). LEVER 2: INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO BUILDING Vila Verde in Conception Chile – A ‘Half a House’ model. (Photo: Arch Daily)
  • 13. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Opportunities Allow for the building of more flexible housing Traditional models of family houses do not allow the flexibility required of today’s families. Principles of flexibility could be engaged to allow for expansion and contraction over time. We suggest that the Tsar could assist councils to take a more proactive stance on the revision of building codes to allow for greater flexibility. 13 Consider ongoing costs when measuring affordability Gibbs suggests that affordability as a concept needs reframing to include the ongoing costs paid by households through their tenure (Gibbs, 2017). This includes payment for electricity, insurance and maintenance, a significant cost for some when buildings are of poor quality. This would need to work in concert with measures to alleviate the extra costs associated with the use of quality materials and building techniques. Ensure affordable housing does not further embed disadvantage Climate resilience means building homes which will protect occupants from rising heat and other effects of climate change. Sustainable buildings will reduce ongoing costs to residents (Emsley, et al., 2008). Reinvigorate self-build traditions Australia has a long tradition of self-build, and as late as 2003, NSW offered a self-build subsidy (Crabtree, 2018). There may be capacity for the government to partner with an organisation such as Habitat for Humanity Australia who offer reduced rate home loans in return for ‘sweat equity’ during construction (Habitat for Humanity, 2018). LEVER 2: INNOVATIVE APPROACHES TO BUILDING
  • 14. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 Conclusion 14 A range of challenges and opportunities have been introduced here while by no means comprehensive, should offer a source of inspiration to the incoming Tsar as they tackle this crisis in housing affordability. A lack of appetite of successive governments to consider and provide affordable housing has contributed to this crisis, as has the complexity involved in coordinating responses across levels of government and with the non-profit and private sectors on which the responsibility of provision of most affordable housing has been placed. If there were to be one overarching recommendation it would be for the creation of a governance framework for housing affordability—consisting of the the levers mentioned in this paper— which can encompass and guide the navigation of this complex system. As, without sufficient policy and responsibilities it will be difficult to achieve the aims of providing affordable housing to all. It is worth stressing that societal goals of greater housing affordability will not be reached by simple solutions. Different households experience housing affordability problems in different ways, so what is suitable for one household may not be so for another. Policy responses will therefore need to be varied, integrated, and cross-governmental (Yates, Milligan, 2007). This effort will be worth it, however, as housing is such a critical component of a healthy and equal society (Emsley, et al., 2008). In addition, the government should benefit from the financial savings from less spend on other services—such as mental health—which are related to the housing stress experienced by many people on low incomes.
  • 15. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 References 15 ABS 2019, Housing Occupancy and Costs, Australia, 2007–08 to 2017–18, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra. Aikman, M., Frankel, D. & Wood, S., National dwelling cost study, URBIS, 2011. Aliento, W. 2018, End of NRAS means even less affordable housing. Available: https://www.communityhousing.com.au/nras/ [2019, 7 August]. Burke, K. 2018, More Australians at risk of homelessness as National Rental Affordability Scheme comes to an end. Available: https://www.domain.com.au/news/nras-782290/ Crabtree, L., Grimstad, S., McNeill, J., Perry, N., & Power, E. (2019). Articulating Value in Cooperative Housing: International and Methodological Review. Crabtree, L., Phibbs, P., Milligan, V. & Blunden, H. 2012, "Principles and practices of an affordable housing Community Land Trust model", Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute, . Crabtree, L. 2018, "Self-organised housing in Australia: housing diversity in an age of market heat", International Journal of Housing Policy, vol. 18, no. 1. Cumming, A. 2018, Redefining the model: Nightingale. Available: https://renew.org.au/sanctuary-magazine/multi-residential/refining-the-model/ Daley, J., Coates, B. & Wiltshire, T. 2018, Housing affordability: re-imagining the Australian dream, Grattan Institute. Dodson, J. & Sipe, N. 2008, Unsettling suburbia: The new landscape of oil and mortgage vulnerability in Australian cities, Urban Research Program, Griffith University. Emsley, S., Phibbs, P. & Crabtree, L. 2008, Models of sustainable and affordable housing for local government, Urban Research Centre, Sydney. Feary, T. 2015, Inside Almere: the Dutch city that's pioneering alternative housing. Available: https://www.theguardian.com/housing-network/2015/dec/ 15/almere-dutch-city-alternative-housing-custom-build [2019, 5 August]. Gibbs, M. 2017, Affordable housing is not just about the purchase price. Available: https://theconversation.com/affordable-housing-is-not- just-about-the-purchase-price-7585Gleeson, B. & Low, N.P. 2000, Australian urban planning, 1st publ. edn, Allen & Unwin, St. Leonards. Gurran, N., Gilbert, C., Gibb, K., van den Nouwelant, R., James, A. & Phibbs, P. 2018, "Supporting affordable housing supply: inclusionary planning in new and renewing communities", AHURI Final Report, no. 297. Gurran, N., Pill, M., Maalsen, S., Alizadeh, T. & Shrestha, P. 2019, Informal accommodation and vulnerable households, Sydney Policy Lab, Sydney. Habitat for Humanity 2018, Habitat for Humanity: What we do. Available: https://habitat.org.au/what-we-do/australia/nsw/ [2019, 10 August]. Hulse, K., Pawson, H., Reynolds, M.A. & Herath, S. 2014, Disadvantaged places in urban Australia: analysing socio-economic diversity and housing market performance, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. Karp, P. 2019, First homebuyers' scheme: who gets it and will it work? Available: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/may/13/ first-homebuyers-scheme-who-gets-it-and-will-it-work-explainer [2019, 30 July].
  • 16. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 References 16 Milligan, V., Pawson, H., Randolph, B. & Yates, J. 2014, City Futures Submission to the Senate Economics References Committee Inquiry on Affordable Housing, City Futures Research Centre, UNSW, Sydney. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government 2019, National Planning Policy Framework (England), 1st edn, Oxford University Press. Mounter, B. 2019, Lockhart River locals skill up to build houses and reduce overcrowding in homes. Available: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-08-05/lockhart-river-builds-houses-red uces-overcrowding-in-homes/11338282?pfmredir=sm. NACSBA 2019, The first self build project achieved on a truly large scale. Available: https://selfbuildportal.org.uk/case-studies/homeruskwartier-district-almere [2019, 7 August]. Nightingale Housing 2019, Nightingale Housing website. Available: https://nightingalehousing.org/faq [2019, 9 August]. NSW Department of Planning 2019, Sydney Housing Supply Forecast. Available: https://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/Research-and-Demography/Sydney-hous ing-supply-forecast [2019, 29 July]. NSW Government 2019, Key Issues for the 57th Parliament, NSW Parliamentary Research Service, Sydney. Ong, R., Dalton, T., Gurran, N., Phelps, C., Rowley, S. & Wood, G. 2017, Housing supply responsiveness in Australia: distribution, drivers and institutional settings, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute Limited, Melbourne. Parvin, A. & Reeve, A. 2019, Affordable Land, Open Systems Lab. London, UK. Pascoe, M. 2013, Grants do not help first home buyers. Available: https://www.smh.com.au/business/grants-do-not-help-first-home-buyers-2013 0327-2gtas.html [2019, 30 July]. Pinnegar, S., Milligan, V., Quintal, D., Randolph, B., Williams, P. & Yates, J. 2008, Innovative financing for home ownership: the potential for shared equity initiatives in Australia, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. Pinnegar, S. & Randolph, B. 2012, "Renewing the West: Prospects for urban regeneration in Sydney’s western suburbs", City Futures Research Paper No. 13. Public Interest Advocacy Centre, HomeFund: fair loans. Available: https://www.piac.asn.au/legal-help/public-interest-cases/homefund-fair-loans/ [2019, 2 August]. Randolph, B., Troy, L., Milligan, V. & van den Nouwelant, R. 2018, Paying for affordable housing in different market contexts, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. RBA 2014, Submission to the Inquiry into Affordable Housing. Available: https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/submissions/housing-and-housing-finan ce/inquiry-affordable-housing/ [2019, 18 July]. Robertson, G. 2017, Government's privatisation push extends to $9 billion property sale pipeline. Available: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/ governments-privatisation-push-extends-to-9-billion-property-sale-pipeline-201 70904-gyagew.html [2019, 31 July].
  • 17. KIMBERLEY CROFTS – Z3199999 – UNSW STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING ASSIGNMENT 2 References 17 Rowley, S. 2015, Increasing land supply isn’t the answer to the affordable housing problem. Available: https://theconversation.com/increasing-land-supply- isnt-the-answer-to-the-affordable-housing-problem-50074 [2019, 7 August]. Rowley, S., James, A., Gilbert, C., Gurran, N., Ong, R., Phibbs, P., Rosen, D. & Whitehead, C. 2016, "Subsidised affordable rental housing: lessons from Australia and overseas", AHURI Final Report, , no. 267. Rowley, S., James, A., Phibbs, P., van den Nouwelant, R. & Troy, L. 2017, "Government led innovations in affordable housing delivery", AHURI Final Report, , no. 289. Rowley, S. & Phibbs, P. 2012, Delivering diverse and affordable housing on infill development sites, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. SBS 2013, Co-op housing: an affordable housing solution?. Available: https://www.sbs.com.au/news/co-op-housing-an-affordable-housing-solution [2019, 9 August]. Singh, A., Daniel, L., Baker, E. & Bentley, R. 2019, "Housing Disadvantage and Poor Mental Health: A Systematic Review", American Journal of Preventive Medicine, vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 262-272. Turner, J. 1972, "Housing as a verb" in Freedom to build; dweller control of the housing process, eds. J. Turner & R. Fichter, Collier Macmillan, New York. Yates, J. 2017, "Housing Australia" in Housing Australia CEDA, Melbourne. Yates, J. & Milligan, V. 2007, Housing affordability: a 21st century problem, Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute. Zilliacus, A. 2016, , Half A House Builds A Whole Community. Available: https://www.archdaily.com/797779/half-a-house-builds-a-whole-community- elementals-controversial-social-housing [2019, 18 July].