This document summarizes a presentation on recent patent law updates and trends for medical device companies. It discusses Inter Partes Review (IPR) proceedings, including what they are, filing trends, and changes under the new Director of the Patent Office. It also summarizes a Supreme Court case regarding the eligibility of temperature measurement patents and trends of decreased district court litigation due to IPRs. Finally, it discusses the importance of intellectual property for medical device companies and strategies for building a strong patent portfolio.
8. SECURITY GUARD CREED, CODE OF CONDUCT, COPE.pptx
Patent Law Update for Medical Device Companies 2018
1. Patent Law Update for Medical
Device Companies 2018
Paul Conover, Irfan Lateef, &
Curtis Huffmire
MedTech Strategist Innovation Summit
November 28, 2018 / 11:45 AM
36. Orange County San Diego San FranciscoLos Angeles Seattle Washington DCNew York
Paul.Conover@knobbe.com
Irfan.Lateef@knobbe.com
Curtis.Huffmire@knobbe.com
Thank you!
Hinweis der Redaktion
Right to exclude or prevent someone from doing something
Government registration – Enforce it in court
Intellectual Property Tools:
Copyrights: protect content and expression
Trademarks: enhance marketing strategies
Trade Secrets: keep proprietary info confidential
Patents: obtain exclusivity in your market niche
Utility: functionality
Design: appearance
TM is any symbol capable of identifying and distinguishing its owner’s products from those of others…
Fanciful marks
A fanciful / inherently distinctive trademark is prima facie registrable, and comprises an entirely invented or "fanciful" sign. For example, "Kodak" had no meaning before it was adopted and used as a trademark in relation to goods, whether photographic goods or otherwise. Invented marks are neologisms which will not previously have been found in any dictionary.
Arbitrary marks
An arbitrary trademark is usually a common word which is used in a meaningless context (e.g. "Apple" for computers). Such marks consist of words or images which have some dictionary meaning before being adopted as trademarks, but which are used in connection with products or services unrelated to that dictionary meaning. Arbitrary marks are also immediately eligible for registration. Salty would be an arbitrary mark if it used in connection with e.g. telephones such as in Salty Telephones, as the term "salt" has no particular connection with such products.
Suggestive marks
A suggestive trademark tends to indicate the nature, quality, or a characteristic of the products or services in relation to which it is used, but does not describe this characteristic, and requires imagination on the part of the consumer to identify the characteristic. Suggestive marks invoke the consumer’s perceptive imagination. An example of a suggestive mark is Blu-ray, a new technology of high-capacity data storage.
Descriptive marks
A descriptive mark is a term with a dictionary meaning which is used in connection with products or services directly related to that meaning. An example might be Salty used in connection with saltine crackers or anchovies. Such terms are not registrable unless it can be shown that distinctive character has been established in the term through extensive use in the marketplace (see further below). Lektronic was famously refused protection by the USPTO on ground of being descriptive for electronic goods.
Generic terms
"Generic term" redirects here. For other uses, see Generic term (disambiguation).
A generic term is the common name for the products or services in connection with which it is used, such as "salt" when used in connection with sodium chloride. A generic term is not capable of serving the essential trademark function of distinguishing the products or services of a business from the products or services of other businesses, and therefore cannot be afforded any legal protection. This is because there has to be some term which may generally be used by anyone—including other manufacturers—to refer to a product without using some organization's proprietary trademark. Marks which become generic after losing distinctive character are known as genericized trademarks.
Search existing marks before you invest in branding and marketing
Evaluate potential for TM registration and infringement
Preferably select strong marks that are arbitrary or fanciful
Not weak marks that are descriptive or generic to product or service
To get a trademark:
For TM – Start marking sold goods with the MARKTM – common law
For ® – Register with USPTO
Properly display trademarks in marketing and police infringement
Identify – What trade secrets do you have?
Classify – Have systems in place to organize secret information.
Protect – Take reasonable measures to maintain the secrecy.
Valuate – How much are your trade secrets worth?
Do you have good patents?
Do you have issued patents?
Do you have comprehensive specifications, with lots of alternatives?
Are the claims too broad? Too narrow? Do they cover your product? Do they cover your competitors?
Were they filed on time? File early!
When will they expire?
What countries do you have covered?