Journal article submission and review process

1. Journal Article Submission
and Review Process
Prof. Dr. Khalid Mahmood
Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences
University of the Punjab

2. Manuscript submission
 Guidelines for authors
 Process of submission
 Acknowledgement by editor

3. Review
process

4. Process of review
 First scanning by editor
 Selection of reviewers
 Double blind review
 Time for review
 Decision of reviewers
 Communication of decision to author
 Acceptance, Rejection or Revision
 Submission and review of revised version
 Final decision

5. Criteria for judging a paper
 Does the article add to what is already known?
 Is the article demonstrably related to what has been
previously written?
 Are the arguments employed valid in terms of the body of
knowledge?
 Is the article easy to read?
 Do the arguments flow logically?
 Are the conclusions strong?

6. Review
pro forma

7. Best of luck for your publishing career
You may also watch my videos at
Khalidmahmood.pk
Libraryinf.com