Comparação de Modelo de Valoração Monetária de Danos Ambientais

1. DESEMPENHO DE MODELOS DE VALORAÇÃO ECONÔMICA DE DANOS AMBIENTAIS DECORRENTES DA CONTAMINAÇÃO DO SOLO: CATES, VCP, HEA, DEPRN 'U *HRUJHV .DVNDQW]LV 1HWR 1. Introdução A YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GRV UHFXUVRV H GDQRV DPELHQWDLV p XPD DWLYLGDGH FRPSOH[D TXH HQYROYH FRQKHFLPHQWRV multidisciplinares, e requer a SDUWLFLSDomR GH HTXLSHV GH SURÀVVLRQDLV HVSHFLDOL]DGRV $ YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GH UHFXUVRV naturais e impactos pode ser usada nos processos de OLFHQFLDPHQWR DPELHQWDO QD SHUtFLD MXGLFLDO H QD DYDOLDomR LPRELOLiULD YLVDQGR j GHWHUPLQDomR GR YDORU GRV GDQRV TXH SRVVDP DGYLU GDV DWLYLGDGHV GRV HPSUHHQGLPHQWRV RX GRV HYHQWXDLV DFLGHQWDLV DPELHQWDLV (P JHUDO RV PpWRGRV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO VmR XWLOL]DGRV YLVDQGR j HVWLPDWLYD GR YDORU TXH RV LQGLYtGXRV DWULEXHP aos recursos naturais, com base em suas preferências LQGLYLGXDLV 0277$

2. 1R HQWDQWR D YHULÀFDomR GD DÀUPDWLYD GHSHQGH GDV FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV VRFLRHFRQ{PLFDV GR JUXSR HQWUHYLVWDGR $ XWLOL]DomR GHVVD WpFQLFD WHP SRU ÀQDOLGDGH GHWHUPLQDU D GLVSRVLomR D SDJDU RX D UHFHEHU GR LQGLYtGXR UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH SHOD FRQVHUYDomR GR UHFXUVR RX D FRPSHQVDomR SHOD OHVmR SURYRFDGD 'HSHQGHQGR GD PDQHLUD FRPR VH UHDOL]D D FRQVXOWD R UHVXOWDGR SRGH VHU SDUFLDO RX VHMD REWpPVH DSHQDV XPD SDUFHOD GR UHDO YDORU HFRQ{PLFR GRV FRPSRQHQWHV DPELHQWDLV LQYHVWLJDGRV $ H[SUHVVmR PDWHPiWLFD TXH UHSUHVHQWD D GLVSRVLomR D SDJDU RX D UHFHEHU FRPSHQVDomR SHOR GDQR p D HTXDomR

3. $ PHWRGRORJLD 9(5$ 9DORUDomR (FRQ{PLFD GH 5HFXUVRV 1DWXUDLV

4. p UHFRPHQGDGD SHOD $VVRFLDomR GH 1RUPDV 7pFQLFDV GR %UDVLO $%17

5. SDUD H[HFXWDU VHUYLoRV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO WHQGR VLGR SXEOLFDGD QR DQR GH D 1%5

6. 1HVWD QRUPD HQFRQWUDPVH GHVFULWRV RV PpWRGRV GLUHWRV H LQGLUHWRV GH YDORUDomR GH UHFXUVRV DPELHQWDLV GLVSRQtYHLV QD OLWHUDWXUD HVSHFLDOL]DGD WDLV FRPR RV FRQWLQJHQFLDLV FXVWR GH RSRUWXQLGDGH H RXWURV $ H[SUHVVmR 9(5$ SRVVXL D IRUPD 9(5$ 98 9(

7. onde VERA p R YDORU HFRQ{PLFR GR UHFXUVR DPELHQWDO VU UHSUHVHQWD R YDORU GH XVR GLUHWR H LQGLUHWR GR UHFXUVR QDWXUDO H VE p R YDORU GH H[LVWrQFLD GR UHFXUVR QDWXUDO MPMG Jurídico Especial ‡ 31

8. ,QVSHFLRQDQGR D HTXDomR

9. YHULÀFDVH TXH R YDORU GH uso VU FRQWHPSOD GRLV WHUPRV R YDORU GH XVR GLUHWR UHODWLYR DRV ÁX[RV GH PDWpULDVSULPDV FXMRV YDORUHV GH PHUFDGR HVWmR GHÀQLGRV H R YDORU GH XVR LQGLUHWR TXH FRUUHVSRQGH jV IXQo}HV H VHUYLoRV HFRVVLVWrPLFRV SURYLGRV SHORV UHFXUVRV QDWXUDLV j VRFLHGDGH RV TXDLV QmR WrP YDORU HFRQ{PLFR HVWDEHOHFLGR 2 YDORU GH H[LVWrQFLD p DTXHOH TXH independe do uso, presente ou futuro, do recurso natural, UHÁHWLQGR YDORU TXH R PHVPR WHP SRU VL PHVPR D VHUHP REWLGRV QD DYDOLDomR GRV GDQRV SURYHQLHQWHV GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR GH XPD SURSULHGDGH LQGXVWULDO 2 FDVR DQDOLVDGR p R GD HPSUHVD ´5(2%(0 ,QG~VWULD H RPpUFLR GH 7LQWDV H 9HUQL]HV /WGDµ 1R SHUtRGR GH D DSyV D IDOrQFLD GD HPSUHVD GHVFREULXVH TXH HOD KDYLD JHUDGR XP SDVVLYR DPELHQWDO GH W GH UHVtGXRV WHQGR VLGR LQVWDXUDGD XPD $omR LYLO SHOR 0LQLVWpULR 3~EOLFR QD TXDO IRUDP UHVSRQVDELOL]DGDV FHQWR H VHVVHQWD HPSUHVDV TXH GHVWLQDYDP VHXV UHVtGXRV SDUD D 5(2%(0 $SHVDU GD FRQVLVWrQFLD WHyULFD GD PHWRGRORJLD 9(5$ QR SURFHVVR GD YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO YiULRV IDWRUHV SRGHP LQÁXHQFLDU R UHVXOWDGR GD SHVTXLVD WDLV FRPR R QtYHO GH UHQGD H D LQVWUXomR GR HQWUHYLVWDGR 3RU H[HPSOR QD YDORUDomR GR GDQR RULXQGR GR FRUWH LOHJDO GD ÁRUHVWD QDWLYD TXH RFRUUHX QR PXQLFtSLR GH 3DVVRV 0DLD HP 6DQWD DWDULQD GRV HQWUHYLVWDGRV QmR HVWDYDP GLVSRVWRV D SDJDU SHOD FRQVHUYDomR GD ÁRUD DIHWDGD (VVH UHVXOWDGR LQGLFD TXH GRV KDELWDQWHV GH 3DVVRV 0DLD LQGLYtGXRV QmR HVWmR GLVSRVWRV D SDJDU SHOD PDQXWHQomR GD ÁRUHVWD R TXH UHWUDWD R GHVFRQKHFLPHQWR GD SRSXODomR ORFDO D UHVSHLWR GD LPSRUWkQFLD H GR YDORU HFRQ{PLFR GRV UHFXUVRV QDWXUDLV )80$*$//,

10. 0HWRGRORJLD $ YDORUDomR GD 3UDLD GR DVVLQR ORFDOL]DGD QR 5LR *UDQGH GR 6XO GHVFULWD SRU )LQFR

11. p RXWUR FDVR LQWHUHVVDQWH 1HVVD SHVTXLVD IRUDP HQWUHYLVWDGRV LQGLYtGXRV H FRQIRUPH FLWDGR SHOR DXWRU GRV HQWUHYLVWDGRV DSUHVHQWDUDP UHVSRVWD QHJDWLYD TXDQWR j GLVSRVLomR GH SDJDU SHOD FRQVHUYDomR GD SUDLD GR DVVLQR VLWXDGD QR PXQLFtSLR GH 5LR *UDQGH 56 $SHVDU GR XVR FDGD YH] PDLRU GDV WpFQLFDV GH YDORUDomR ambiental, os modelos matemáticos que se encontram GLVSRQtYHLV QD OLWHUDWXUD VmR OLPLWDGRV 2V PpWRGRV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO WUDGLFLRQDLV VmR FODVVLÀFDGRV FRPR GLUHWRV H LQGLUHWRV 2V PpWRGRV GLUHWRV VmR RV PDLV HPSUHJDGRV PDV IRUQHFHP VRPHQWH XPD SDUWH GR YDORU HFRQ{PLFR GR UHFXUVR RX OHVmR DPELHQWDO HP JHUDO DTXHOD SDUFHOD UHODWLYD j UHFXSHUDomR GR GDQR 2V PpWRGRV LQGLUHWRV GH YDORUDomR QD VXD JUDQGH PDLRULD UHTXHUHP D FROHWD GH GDGRV QR FDPSR YLVDQGR j GHWHUPLQDomR GRV SDUkPHWURV GDV HTXDo}HV HFRQRPpWULFDV 0277$

12. 1R kPELWR GD DFDGHPLD R PpWRGR 9(5$ FXPSUH D ÀQDOLGDGH SDUD D TXDO IRL HODERUDGR PDV QD HVIHUD MXUtGLFD RV UHFXUVRV PRQHWiULRV H SUD]RV GLVSRQtYHLV SDUD UHDOL]DU D YDORUDomR VmR OLPLWDGRV R TXH MXVWLÀFD R PDLRU XVR GRV PpWRGRV GLUHWRV 3DUD FRQWRUQDU D EDUUHLUD RV WpFQLFRV GRV yUJmRV GH FRQWUROH DPELHQWDO H GRV HQWURV GH $SRLR jV 3URPRWRULDV 3~EOLFDV WrP SURSRVWR PpWRGRV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO SDUD DWHQGHU VXDV QHFHVVLGDGHV ,%$0$ *$//, $2

13. (P JHUDO RV PpWRGRV VmR HODERUDGRV FRP EDVH QD H[SHULrQFLD SURÀVVLRQDO GRV WpFQLFRV H GLUHFLRQDGRV D FDVRV HVSHFtÀFRV R TXH VLJQLÀFD TXH QD VXD JUDQGH PDLRULD HVVHV PRGHORV QmR SRGHP VHU HPSUHJDGRV GH PDQHLUD JHQHUDOL]DGD 9LVDQGR FRQWULEXLU SDUD R GHVHQYROYLPHQWR H D GLIXVmR GRV FRQKHFLPHQWRV GD iUHD GD HFRQ{PLFD DPELHQWDO HODERURX VH HVVH HVWXGR 2 REMHWLYR p FRPSDUDU RV UHVXOWDGRV IRUQHFLGRV SRU TXDWUR PRGHORV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO 32 ‡ MPMG Jurídico Especial $ PHWRGRORJLD DGRWDGD LQFOXL WUrV HWDSDV 1D SULPHLUD GHWHUPLQDVH R YDORU ÀQDQFHLUR GRV GDQRV SURYHQLHQWHV GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR WHUUHQR SRU VXEVWkQFLDV Wy[LFDV DSOLFDQGR DV PHWRGRORJLDV VHSDUDGDPHQWH 1D VHJXQGD HWDSD RV YDORUHV PRQHWiULRV GRV GDQRV FDOFXODGRV QD HWDSD DQWHULRU VmR VXEPHWLGRV j DQiOLVH HVWDWtVWLFD YLVDQGR j GHWHUPLQDomR GD PpGLD GR GHVYLR SDGUmR H GDV HVWDWtVWLFDV GH LQWHUHVVH 1D WHUFHLUD HWDSD RV UHVXOWDGRV IRUQHFLGRV SHORV PRGHORV VmR FRPSDUDGRV FRP D PpGLD GR FRQMXQWR GH WRGRV RV UHVXOWDGRV REWLGRV QR HVWXGR $ SDUWLU GD FRPSDUDomR GHWHUPLQDVH D PHWRGRORJLD DGHTXDGD DR FDVR 5(2%(0 $V PHWRGRORJLDV GH YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GH GDQRV DPELHQWDLV FRQVLGHUDGDV VmR $7(6 ² XVWRV $PELHQWDLV 7RWDLV (VSHUDGRV 5,%$6

14. 93 ² 9DORU GD RPSHQVDomR $PELHQWDO ,%$0$

15. $+( ² $QiOLVH GR +DELWDW (TXLYDOHQWH 12$$

16. H '(351 ² 0RGHOR GR 'HSDUWDPHQWR (VWDGXDO GH 5HFXUVRV 1DWXUDLV GR (VWDGR GH 6mR 3DXOR *$//,

17. 2 LQWHUYDOR GH WHPSR DGRWDGR SDUD DQiOLVH GR YDORU SHFXQLiULR GRV GDQRV p GH GH] DQRV D WD[D GH GHVFRQWR GRV YDORUHV GR GDQR XWLOL]DGD p GH DD WD[D GH PHUFDGR

18. SRGHQGR WDPEpP VHU XWLOL]DGD GHSHQGHQGR GR FDVR D WD[D GH ULVFR GH DD 2VFXVWRVGDUHFXSHUDomRGRVRORFRQWDPLQDGRIRUDPGHÀQLGRV D SDUWLU GD UHDOL]DomR GD SHVTXLVD GH SUHoRV GRV VHUYLoRV GH HQJHQKDULD PmR GH REUD H GRV PDWHULDLV QHFHVViULRV SDUD H[HFXWDU R VHUYLoR 2 YDORU JOREDO GD UHFXSHUDomR GR GDQR VRPD 5 'HVWH WRWDO 5 VmR UHIHUHQWHV DR FXVWR GR WUDQVSRUWH GR VROR FRQWDPLQDGR 5 representam os custos para destinação do solo contaminado DR DWHUUR LQGXVWULDO 5 FRUUHVSRQGHP DR YDORU GD WHUUD GH UHSRVLomR H 5 VmR UHIHUHQWHV j PmR GH REUD 2 QtYHO GD GHVFRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR IRL GHÀQLGR FRP EDVH QRV YDORUHV GH UHIHUrQFLD TXH VH HQFRQWUDP GHVFULWRV QD 5HVROXomR 21$0$ Qž GH GH GH]HPEUR GH %5$6,/

19. $ SURSULHGDGH GD LQYHVWLJDGD 5(2%(0 VLWXDVH QR EDLUUR %DUUR 3UHWR QR PXQLFtSLR GH 6mR -RVp GRV 3LQKDLV 35 FRP XPD iUHD GH P2 H DSUHVHQWD XP YDORU DWXDO QR PHUFDGR VHP D SUHVHQoD GD FRQWDPLQDomR TXH YDULD GH 5 D 5 2 YDORU GH PHUFDGR GR LPyYHO GR %DUUR 3UHWR IRL GHÀQLGR SHVTXLVDQGRVH RV YDORUHV GH VHLV SURSULHGDGHV LQGXVWULDLV VHPHOKDQWHV j FRQWDPLQDGD DSOLFDQGR R PpWRGR FRPSDUDWLYR GLUHWR GHVFULWR QD 1%5 $662,$d®2 %5$6,/(,5$ '( 1250$6 7e1,$6

20. 2 YDORU GH PHUFDGR GR

21. VtWLR GR %DUUR 3UHWR FRP SUHVHQoD GD FRQWDPLQDomR IRL HVWLPDGR HP UHODomR DR PRGHOR SURSRVWR SRU 0D apud +(5%(57

22. 1HVWH HVWXGR D SHUGD GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV FRQWDELOL]DVH GHVGH R DQR GH DWp R DQR GH TXDQGR R QtYHO GRV VHUYLoRV DWLQJH GR Pi[LPR 2 QtYHO GRV VHUYLoRV DQWHULRU DR GDQR IRL GHÀQLGR FRPR GR Pi[LPR SRU VHU D iUHD LQGXVWULDO H Mi VH HQFRQWUDU GHVFDUDFWHUL]DGD $GRWRXVH WDPEpP TXH D YDORUDomR GR GDQR IRL VROLFLWDGD HP H TXH RV SURMHWRV GH descontaminação da propriedade e compensação do dano RULJLQDGR WLYHUDP LQtFLR HP H ÀQDOL]DomR QR DQR GH DVR LQYHVWLJDGR $ FRPSDUDomR GR GHVHPSHQKR GRV PRGHORV GH YDORUDomR GH GDQRV DPELHQWDLV IRL UHDOL]DGD FRP D LQYHVWLJDomR GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR SRU VXEVWkQFLDV Wy[LFDV GH XPD GDV WUrV SURSULHGDGHV GD HPSUHVD 5(2%(0 RQIRUPH GHVFULWR QRV DXWRV GD $omR LYLO Qž 03 GD 9DUD tYHO GD RPDUFD GH 6mR -RVp GRV 3LQKDLV QR GLD GH PDUoR GR DQR GH QD SUHVHQoD GR SURPRWRU GH -XVWLoD H GR 'HOHJDGR GH 3URWHomR GR 0HLR $PELHQWH FRQÀUPRX VH D GHQ~QFLD GRV PRUDGRUHV YL]LQKRV GR HQWRUQR GD IiEULFD GR %DUUR 3UHWR D UHVSHLWR GD H[LVWrQFLD GH UHVtGXRV Wy[LFRV HQWHUUDGRV QD SURSULHGDGH 1D $omR LYLO 3~EOLFD GR 0LQLVWpULR 3~EOLFR IRUDP UHVSRQVDELOL]DGDV as empresas que destinaram resíduos para tratamento na 5(2%(0 Os resíduos na forma líquida, pastosa e sólida foram HQFRQWUDGRV GHQWUR GH WDPERUHV H D JUDQHO D FpX DEHUWR H QD VXD JUDQGH PDLRULD VmR ERUUDV GH WLQWDV FDWDOLVDGRUHV ORGR SURYHQLHQWH GH HVWDo}HV GH WUDWDPHQWR GH HÁXHQWHV GHVFDUWHV GH ODERUDWyULR H RXWURV 2V FRPSRVWRV LGHQWLÀFDGRV QDV DPRVWUDV GR VROR DQDOLVDGDV QR ODERUDWyULR VmR PHWDLV U 3E X R =Q 1L

23. %7(; EHQ]HQR WROXHQR HWLOEHQ]HQR H [LOHQR

24. 7+3 WHWUDLGURSLSHULQD

25. +3$ KLGURFDUERQHWRV SROLFtFOLFRV DURPiWLFRV

26. FRPSRVWRV RUJDQRFORUDGRV HWF 0HWRGRORJLDV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO $ YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GRV GDQRV RULJLQDGRV SHOD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR GR VtWLR GR %DUUR 3UHWR IRL UHDOL]DGD XWLOL]DQGR RV PpWRGRV FLWDGRV 1D VHTXrQFLD FDGD XP GRV PpWRGRV VHUi GHVFULWR FRP GHWDOKHV H DSOLFDGR QD YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GRV GDQRV RULXQGRV GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VtWLR LQYHVWLJDGR 4.1. Método dos Custos Ambientais Totais Esperados 2 PpWRGR GRV XVWRV $PELHQWDLV 7RWDLV (VSHUDGRV $7(6

27. IRL SURSRVWR SRU 5LEDV

28. SDUD VLVWHPDV ÁRUHVWDV 2 FRQFHLWR GR $7(6 HVWi DVVRFLDGR j UHQGD SHUSpWXD TXH D VRFLHGDGH HVWDULD GLVSRVWD D UHFHEHU FRPR LQGHQL]DomR SHFXQLiULD RX QmR

29. SHOR GDQR DPELHQWDO (VVH modelo considera dois casos: os custos totais esperados FRP GDQR LQWHUPLWHQWH H RV FXVWRV WRWDLV HVSHUDGRV FRP GDQR LUUHYHUVtYHO (VVH PRGHOR WDPEpP UHODFLRQD RV GDQRV LQGLUHWRV FRP RV GLUHWRV DWUDYpV GH XP IDWRU Fi/d com escala QXPpULFD GH D $ HTXDomR GR $7(6 WHP D IRUPD $7( 9c d ‡ FLG

33. n onde CATE representa os custos ambientais totais HVSHUDGRV Vc p R YDORU GD SURSULHGDGH Cd são os custos da UHFXSHUDomR GD FRQWDPLQDomR Fi/d p R IDWRU TXH UHODFLRQD RV GDQRV GLUHWRV H LQGLUHWRV j p D WD[D GH MXURV H n p R SHUtRGR GH GXUDomR GRV HIHLWRV GRV LPSDFWRV DGYHUVRV 2V SDUkPHWURV GH HQWUDGD GR $7(6 QR FDVR GD contaminação do solo são: Vc 5 Cd 5 Fi/d R GDQR DR VROR DFDUUHWRX D SROXLomR GR OHQoRO IUHiWLFR

34. j DD H n DQRV 6XEVWLWXLQGR HVWHV YDORUHV HP

35. REWpPVH $7( *

37. 0pWRGR $PELHQWDO GR 9DORU GD RPSHQVDomR 2 PpWRGR 9DORU GD RPSHQVDomR $PELHQWDO 93

38. IRL HODERUDGR QR DQR GH SHOR ,QVWLWXWR %UDVLOHLUR GR 0HLR $PELHQWH H GRV 5HFXUVRV 1DWXUDLV 5HQRYiYHLV ,%$0$

39. YLVDQGR j FRPSHQVDomR GH LPSDFWRV QHJDWLYRV DGYLQGRV GDV LQVWDODo}HV GH UDGLRGLIXVmR HP 8QLGDGHV GH RQVHUYDomR $ HTXDomR GR PpWRGR 93 p FRQVWLWXtGD por cinco termos: 93 S1 S2 S3 S ,(

40. onde no presente estudo a soma dos primeiros quatro termos do lado direito da equação representam os custos de recuperação do solo afetado e IE p R LPSDFWR VREUH RV VHUYLoRV HFRVVLVWrPLFRV (QWmR p1 p R FXVWR GH WUDQVSRUWH GR VROR FRQWDPLQDGR p2 p R FXVWR GD GLVSRVLomR GR VROR HP DWHUUR FODVVH ,, p3 p R FXVWR GD WHUUD GH UHFRPSRVLomR p4 p R FXVWR GD PmR GH REUD UHTXHULGD SDUD H[HFXWDU RV VHUYLoRV 2 YDORU PRQHWiULR GRV VHUYLoRV HFRVVLVWrPLFRV IRL GHÀQLGR D SDUWLU GRV YDORUHV UHFRPHQGDGRV SRU RQVWDQ]D

41. 1HVWH FDVR IRUDP FRQVLGHUDGRV RV VHUYLoRV GH UHJXODomR KtGULFD SURWHomR j HURVmR H VXSULPHQWR GH iJXD VXEWHUUkQHD SDUD FRQVXPR WHQGR VLGR DGRWDGRV RV YDORUHV 5 P DQR 5 P DQR 5 P DQR UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH 6RPDQGRVH RV YDORUHV GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV FKHJDVH D 5 Pano H PXOWLSOLFDQGR VH R UHVXOWDGR SHOR YDORU GR WHUUHQR H R LQWHUYDOR GH WHPSR GH DQRV REWpPVH R YDORU IE 5 'HVVD IRUPD R YDORU PRQHWiULR VCP no ano em que IRL VROLFLWDGD D YDORUDomR GR GDQR p 5 5 5 RQWXGR R GDQR DRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV WHYH LQtFLR HP H DWp R DQR GH WDLV VHUYLoRV DLQGD QmR HVWDYDP UHVWLWXtGRV SRUWDQWR GHYH VH FDOFXODU R YDORU SUHVHQWH GRV VHUYLoRV GHVGH R DQR GH DWp R DQR GH TXDQGR WHRULFDPHQWH RV VHUYLoRV HFRVVLVWrPLFRV GHYHUmR DWLQJLU GR QtYHO Pi[LPR FRP D GHVFRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR $GRWDQGRVH D WD[D GH MXURV MPMG Jurídico Especial ‡ 33

42. GH PHUFDGR DWXDO DD

43. REWpPVH R IDWRU GH GHVFRQWR H R YDORU SUHVHQWH GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV DR ORQJR GR SHUtRGR GH D 'H PDQHLUD VHPHOKDQWH FDOFXOD VH R YDORU SUHVHQWH GRV FXVWRV GH UHFXSHUDomR GR VROR XWLOL]DQGR QHVVH FDVR VHLV SHUtRGRV RX VHMD D SDUWLU GR DQR GH TXDQGR VH LQLFLD R SURMHWR DWp R DQR GH TXDQGR VH ÀQDOL]D $ VRPD GRV YDORUHV GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV H FXVWRV GH UHFXSHUDomR GHVFRQWDGRV VmR 5 H 5 UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH 3RUWDQWR R YDORU PRQHWiULR GR GDQR DPELHQWDO REWLGR FRP R 93 p 93 5 5 5 0pWRGR GD $QiOLVH GR +DELWDW (TXLYDOHQWH $ PHWRGRORJLD ´$QiOLVH GR +DELWDW (TXLYDOHQWHµ $+(

44. IRL HODERUDGD SRU SHVTXLVDGRUHV GD 1$7,21$/ 2($1, $1' $70263+(5, $'0,1,675$7,21 12$$

45. (VWH PRGHOR IRUQHFH R WDPDQKR GR SURMHWR GH FRPSHQVDomR GR GDQR DPELHQWDO FRQWDELOL]DQGR RV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV DIHWDGRV H DTXHOHV D VHUHP IRUQHFLGRV SURJUHVVLYDPHQWH FRP D GHVFRQWDPLQDomR GD iUHD H R GHVHQYROYLPHQWR GH XPD QRYD iUHD VLPLODU j GHJUDGDGD 2 PRGHOR $+( LQFOXL WUrV HWDSDV 1D SULPHLUD ID]VH D DYDOLDomR GRV FRPSRQHQWHV DPELHQWDLV LQMXULDGRV QD VHJXQGD HWDSD TXDQWLÀFDVH R GDQR DQDOLVDQGR DV SRVVLELOLGDGHV GRV SURMHWRV GH UHFXSHUDomR H FRPSHQVDomR QD ~OWLPD HWDSD H[HFXWDPVH RV SURMHWRV DFRPSDQKDQGR D HYROXomR GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV 2 WDPDQKR GR habitat D VHU GHVHQYROYLGR QR SURMHWR GH FRPSHQVDomR SRGH VHU FDOFXODGR FRP D HTXDomR

46. FXMR QXPHUDGRU UHSUHVHQWD D TXDQWLGDGH WRWDO GHVFRQWDGD GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV DIHWDGRV H R GHQRPLQDGRU LQGLFD R IRUQHFLPHQWR 3 9j 9p * % W R ǒ * Ej [jt

47. Ej@ / W R ǒ * [p Ep

48. Ej@ t [ƴ [ƴ *j

49. 1D H[SUHVVmR P p R WDPDQKR GR SURMHWR GH FRPSHQVDomR J p R Q~PHUR GH XQLGDGHV GH iUHD DIHWDGDV Vj p R YDORU GRV VHUYLoRV IRUQHFLGR SRU XQLGDGH GH iUHDWHPSR Vp p R YDORU GRV VHUYLoRV IRUQHFLGR SHOD QRYD iUHD xt j p R QtYHO 34 ‡ MPMG Jurídico Especial GRV VHUYLoRV IRUQHFLGRV QD iUHD DIHWDGD QR WHPSR t xt p p R QtYHO GRV VHUYLoRV IRUQHFLGRV SHOD iUHD GH FRPSHQVDomR no tempo t; b j p R YDORU GD OLQKD EDVH GRV VHUYLoRV DQWHV GR GDQR SRU XQLGDGH GH iUHD DIHWDGD bp p R QtYHO LQLFLDO GRV VHUYLoRV IRUQHFLGRV SHOD QRYD iUHD SRU XQLGDGH GH iUHD HVWDEHOHFLGD ǒ p R IDWRU GH GHVFRQWR U

50. W ² ), onde r p D WD[D GH GHVFRQWR H C o ano que inicia o projeto de FRPSHQVDomR 2EVHUYDVH TXH QHVWH PpWRGR D IXQomR GH UHFXSHUDomR GRV VHUYLoRV p OLQHDU 1R FDVR FRQVLGHUDGR RV SDUkPHWURV GR PRGHOR $+( VmR J P2 r DD bj GR Pi[LPR bp Vj/Vp QtYHO GRV VHUYLoRV DSyV R GDQR VHUYLoRV DSyV D UHFXSHUDomR GR Pi[LPR DQR TXH LQLFLD H WHUPLQD D UHFXSHUDomR ² H UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH 1D WDEHOD HQFRQWUDPVH RV UHVXOWDGRV DSUHVHQWDGRV GR $+( $R REVHUYDU D WDEHOD QRWDVH TXH D SHUGD WRWDO GRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV GHFRUUHQWH GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR QR LQWHUYDOR GH D p HTXLYDOHQWH DRV VHUYLoRV TXH GHULYDP GH XP WHUUHQR LJXDO jTXHOH TXH IRL DIHWDGR GH P2 RP R LQtFLR GD UHFXSHUDomR GR VROR H D H[HFXomR GR SURMHWR GH FRPSHQVDomR VHUmR IRUQHFLGRV VHUYLoRV DPELHQWDLV HTXLYDOHQWHV jTXHOHV RULXQGRV GH P2 GH XPD iUHD GD PHVPD QDWXUH]D TXH j GDTXHOD FRQWDPLQDGD SRU UHVtGXRV Wy[LFRV HQWHUUDGRV QR VROR 2V UHVXOWDGRV GD WDEHOD LQGLFDP TXH RV VHUYLoRV descontados que serão fornecidos por unidade de área HTXLYDOHP D P2 $VVLP D GLPHQVmR GD iUHD GR SURMHWR GH FRPSHQVDomR D VHU GHVHQYROYLGR SHOR UHVSRQViYHO TXH SURYRFRX R GDQR p P2 3 [ ) P2 2 YDORU GH PHUFDGR PpGLR GR WHUUHQR GH P2 sem D FRQWDPLQDomR p 5 RX VHMD 5 P2, e, SRUWDQWR R YDORU PRQHWiULR GR GDQR DPELHQWDO GHFRUUHQWH GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR p 9DORU GR GDQR $+(

51. 5 P2 [ P2 5

52. 7DEHOD 5HVXOWDGRV IRUQHFLGRV SHOR PpWRGR GD $QiOLVH GR +DELWDW (TXLYDOHQWH $+(

53. Perda de serviços ambientais Fornecimento de serviços Ano QtYHO bruta desconto descontada QtYHO bruto descontado 1,33 1,21 Serviços ambientais permanentes --- --- --- Somatório dos serviços ambientais --- --- 0pWRGR '(351 $ PHWRGRORJLD '(351 IRL GHVHQYROYLGD SHOR 'HSDUWDPHQWR (VWDGXDO GH 3URWHomR GH 5HFXUVRV 1DWXUDLV GR (VWDGR GH 6mR 3DXOR *$//,

54. 3DUD HVWLPDU R YDORU PRQHWiULR GR GDQR XWLOL]DPVH GXDV WDEHODV 1D SULPHLUD WDEHOD HVWmR GHVFULWRV RV FULWpULRV GH DYDOLDomR GRV DJUDYRV decorrentes dos impactos, dos componentes ambientais, GHYHQGR VHU VRPDGRV SDUD REWHU R IDWRU GH PXOWLSOLFDomR R TXDO VH HQFRQWUD LQGLFDGR QD VHJXQGD WDEHOD (P VHJXLGD FDOFXODVH R YDORU GH H[SORUDomR RX GH UHFXSHUDomR GR habitat injuriado, sendo, então, multiplicado pelo citado IDWRU SDUD GHWHUPLQDU R YDORU PRQHWiULR GR GDQR 3DUD R FDVR DQDOLVDGR RV FULWpULRV GH DYDOLDomR GRV DJUDYRV VmR WR[LFLGDGH FRPSURYDGD

55. DOWHUDomR GR IUHiWLFR FRPSURYDGR

56. DVVRUHDPHQWR GH FRUSR KtGULFR EDL[D LQWHQVLGDGH

57. PRUWH RX GDQR j IDXQD VXSRVWR

58. PRUWH RX GDQR j ÁRUD FRPSURYDGR

59. PXGDQoD GR XVR GR VROR PDLV GH XPD FODVVH

60. GDQRV DR UHOHYR SUHYLVmR GH UHHTXLOtEULR PpGLR SUD]R

61. 6RPDQGR RV YDORUHV GRV FULWpULRV H XWLOL]DQGR D VHJXQGD WDEHOD UHVXOWD R IDWRU GH PXOWLSOLFDomR 'HVVH PRGR R SURGXWR GR IDWRU H dos custos de recuperação da propriedade contaminada IRUQHFH R YDORU GR GDQR DPELHQWDO '(351 IDWRU GH PXOWLSOLFDomR [ FXVWRV GH UHFXSHUDomR [ 5 5 $QiOLVH GRV UHVXOWDGRV 2V YDORUHV PRQHWiULRV GR GDQR DPELHQWDO GD SURSULHGDGH GR %DUUR 3UHWR FRQWDPLQDGD IRUQHFLGRV SHORV PRGHORV GH YDORUDomR H DV HVWDWtVWLFDV GRV UHVXOWDGRV VH HQFRQWUDP LQGLFDGRV QD WDEHOD MPMG Jurídico Especial ‡ 35

62. 7DEHOD (VWDWtVWLFD GRV UHVXOWDGRV IRUQHFLGRV SHORV PRGHORV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO Modelo Dano (R$) Desvio absoluto (R$) Desvio relativo (%) CATE VCP HEA DEPRN 0pGLD --- --- 'HVYLR SDGUmR /

63. RH¿FLHQWH 6NHZQHVV 9DULkQFLD ( /

64. (UUR SDGUmR RH¿FLHQWH GH .XUWRVLV 9 /HJHQGD / ² OLPLWH GH FRQÀDQoD 9 ² FRHÀFLHQWH GH YDULDomR 2EVHUYDQGR D WDEHOD YHULÀFDVH TXH D PpGLD GRV YDORUHV GR GDQR p 5 SRGHQGR YDULDU “ 5 2V GDGRV GD WDEHOD LQGLFDP TXH R $7(6 p R PRGHOR TXH DSUHVHQWD R PHQRU GHVYLR HP UHODomR j PpGLD GHSRLV p R +($ R '(351 H R 93 2EVHUYDVH TXH WRGRV RV GHVYLRV VmR PHQRUHV TXH VLJQLÀFDQGR TXH RV UHVXOWDGRV VmR VDWLVIDWyULRV 2V GDGRV GD WDEHOD LQGLFDP TXH WRGRV RV YDORUHV GR GDQR FDOFXODGRV VH HQFRQWUDP QR LQWHUYDOR GH FRQÀDQoD HVWDWtVWLFD

65. 2V FRHÀFLHQWHV GH 6NHZQHVV H .XUWRVLV VXJHUHP TXH RV GDGRV QmR DMXVWDP D IXQomR QRUPDO GH GLVWULEXLomR GH IUHTXrQFLDV VLJQLÀFDQGR TXH GHYHP VHU WUDQVIRUPDGRV SDUD DWHQGHU RXWUD FXUYD GH GLVWULEXLomR FRPR SRU H[HPSOR D ORJQRUPDO (P QRYH DQRV GHSRLV GD GHVFREHUWD GR SDVVLYR GD 5(2%(0 D -XVWLoD GD RPDUFD GH 6mR -RVp GRV 3LQKDLV FRQGHQRX HPSUHVDV D UHFXSHUDUHP DV iUHDV DIHWDGDV H D SDJDUHP VDQo}HV TXH YDULDP GH 5 PLO D 5 PLO GHSHQGHQGR GR Q~PHUR GH WDPERUHV SHUWHQFHQWHV jV HPSUHVDV HQFRQWUDGRV QD 5(2%(0 2V GDGRV GD WDEHOD LQGLFDP TXH j PHGLGD TXH DXPHQWD D TXDQWLGDGH GH UHVtGXRV D VDQomR SHFXQLiULD GLPLQXL 3RU H[HPSOR D HPSUHVD UHVSRQViYHO SRU WRQpLV FRQWHQGR W GH UHVtGXRV LUi SDJDU 5 TXH UHSUHVHQWD 5 W GH UHVtGXRV HQTXDQWR D HPSUHVD TXH HQYLRX WRQpLV FRP W GH UHVtGXRV SDUD D 5(2%(0 LUi SDJDU 5 RX VHMD 5 W GH UHVtGXRV 7DEHOD 7RQpLV PDVVD GH UHVtGXRV H VDQo}HV D SDJDU SHODV HPSUHVDV UHVSRQViYHLV SHOR GDQR Empresa Tonéis Resíduos (t) A % C D Sanção 9DORUWRQHO 9DORUW GH UHVtGXR 5 5 5 32 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 RQVLGHUDo}HV ÀQDLV 2 YDORU PRQHWiULR GR GDQR GHFRUUHQWH GD FRQWDPLQDomR GR VROR GR LPyYHO GD 5(2%(0 VLWXDGR QR EDLUUR %DUUR GR 3UHWR IRL HVWLPDGR XVDQGRVH TXDWUR PHWRGRORJLDV GH YDORUDomR DPELHQWDO 2V UHVXOWDGRV REWLGRV LQGLFDP TXH R YDORU PpGLR GR GDQR p 5 “ 5 Comparando esse resultado com aqueles obtidos dos PRGHORV GH YDORUDomR SDUD R FDVR DQDOLVDGR FRQFOXLVH TXH R $7(6 p R TXH DSUHVHQWD R PHOKRU GHVHPSHQKR SRUTXH GR YDORU GR GDQR TXH IRUQHFH UHVXOWD R PHQRU GHVYLR HP UHODomR j PpGLD GR FRQMXQWR GH WRGRV RV UHVXOWDGRV REWLGRV QR WUDEDOKR A partir da análise das sanções pecuniárias aplicadas jV HPSUHVDV UHVSRQViYHLV SHORV UHVtGXRV HQFRQWUDGRV QD 5(2%(0 SRGHVH FRQFOXLU TXH D GLVWULEXLomR GR {QXV SHOR GDQR DPELHQWDO RULJLQDGR QmR DSUHVHQWD 36 ‡ MPMG Jurídico Especial SURSRUFLRQDOLGDGH RPSDUDQGR RV WHRUHV GRV SURGXWRV LGHQWLÀFDGRV QDV DPRVWUDV GR VROR FRP RV YDORUHV GH UHIHUrQFLD GD 5HVROXomR 21$0$ Qž FRQFOXLVH TXH R VROR GD SURSULHGDGH GR %DUUR 3UHWR HVWi FRQWDPLQDGR FRP PHWDLV SHVDGRV $ SDUWLU GRV IDWRV DSUHVHQWDGRV SRGHVH DÀUPDU TXH D VLVWHPiWLFD LQRYDGRUD GHVFULWD QHVWH HVWXGR DXPHQWD D TXDOLGDGH GRV UHVXOWDGRV GD YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GR GDQR DPELHQWDO 2 HPSUHJR GH GRLV RX PDLV PpWRGRV SDUD DYDOLDU GHWHUPLQDGR FDVR DXPHQWD D FRQÀDELOLGDGH GR UHVXOWDGR ÀQDO H GHVVH PRGR IDFLOLWD D WRPDGD GD GHFLVmR WpFQLFD H OHJDO TXDQWR DR YDORU GR GDQR RULXQGR GR FDVR LQYHVWLJDGR $VVLP FRQFOXLVH TXH D VLVWHPiWLFD GHVFULWD QHVVH HVWXGR FRQWULEXL SDUD R DYDQoR GRV FRQKHFLPHQWRV GD iUHD GD HFRQ{PLFD DPELHQWDO VLJQLÀFDQGR TXH R WUDEDOKR DWLQJLX R REMHWLYR DOPHMDGR

66. 5HIHUrQFLDV ELEOLRJUiÀFDV $662,$d®2 %5$6,/(,5$ '( 1250$6 7e1,$6 1%5 DYDOLDomR GH EHQV LPyYHLV XUEDQRV S MXQ *$//, ) 9DORUDomR GH GDQRV DPELHQWDLV VXEVtGLR SDUD DomR FLYLO 6pULH 'LYXOJDomR H ,QIRUPDomR RPSDQKLD (QHUJpWLFD GH 6mR 3DXOR (63 6mR 3DXOR $662,$d®2 %5$6,/(,5$ '( 1250$6 7e1,$6 1%5 recursos naturais e ambientais S MXQ +(5%(57 % 3 (VWXGR GD YDORUDomR PRQHWiULD GH SURSULHGDGHV contaminadas em ambiente urbano PDU 'LVVHUWDomR 0HVWUDGR (1752 '( $32,2 23(5$,21$/ '$6 35202725,$6 '( -867,d$ '( '()(6$ '2 0(,2 $0%,(17( 3$75,0Ñ1,2 3URÀVVLRQDOL]DQWH 0HLR $PELHQWH 8UEDQR H ,QGXVWULDO

67. ² 8QLYHUVLGDGH )HGHUDO GR 3DUDQi XULWLED 8/785$/ 85%$1,602 +$%,7$d®2 $2

68. Parecer de TXDQWLÀFDomR GR GDQR DPELHQWDO %HOR +RUL]RQWH 0* IHY ,%$0$ 3HL[RWR : * 0RGHOR GH YDORUDomR HFRQ{PLFD GRV LPSDFWRV 216(/+2 1$,21$/ '2 0(,2 $0%,(17( 0LQLVWpULR GR 0HLR ambientais em unidades de conservação. ,QVWLWXWR %UDVLOHLUR GR 0HLR $PELHQWH H GH 5HFXUVRV 5HQRYiYHLV ² %UDVtOLD ') $PELHQWH 5HVROXomR 21$0$ Qž GH GH GH]HPEUR GH 'LVS}H VREUH FULWpULRV H YDORUHV RULHQWDGRUHV GH TXDOLGDGH GR VROR 0277$ 5 6 Estimativa do custo econômico do desmatamento na TXDQWR j SUHVHQoD GH VXEVWkQFLDV TXtPLFDV H HVWDEHOHFH GLUHWUL]HV SDUD R JHUHQFLDPHQWR DPELHQWDO GH iUHDV FRQWDPLQDGDV SRU HVVDV VXEVWkQFLDV Amazônia ,QVWLWXWR GH 3HVTXLVD (FRQ{PLFD $SOLFDGD ² ,3($ 0LQLVWpULR GR 3ODQHMDPHQWR 2UoDPHQWR H *HVWmR 5LR GH -DQHLUR HP GHFRUUrQFLD GH DWLYLGDGHV DQWUySLFDV %UDVtOLD ') GH] 1$7,21$/ 2($1, $1' $70263+(5, $'0,1,675$7,21 267$1=$ 5 et al 7KH YDOXH RI WKH ZRUOGV HFRVVWHP VHUYLFHV DQG QDWXUDO FDSLWDO 1DWXUH Y PDLR 12$$

69. +DELWDW (TXLYDOHQF $QDOVLV DQ RYHUYLHZ 'DPDJH $VVHVVPHQW DQG 5HVWRUDWLRQ 3URJUDP 86$ :DVKLQJWRQ ' ),12 0 9 $ 9DORUDomR DPELHQWDO XPD HVWLPDWLYD GR YDORU GH XVR H GR YDORU GH RSomR SDUD R OLWRUDO GR 5LR *UDQGH GR 6XO $QDLV GR ,, (QFRQWUR GH (FRQRPLD (FROyJLFD 6mR 3DXOR 5,%$6 / 0HWRGRORJLD YDORUDomR GH GDQRV DPELHQWDLV ² FDVR ÁRUHVWDO 7HVH 'RXWRUDGR

70. ² (VFROD 3ROLWpFQLFD GD 8QLYHUVLGDGH GH 6mR 3DXOR 863 6mR 3DXOR )80$*$//, 5 / et al. $YDOLDomR HFRQ{PLFD GR GHVPDWDPHQWR GH iUHD GH ÁRUHVWD RPEUyÀOD PLVWD 'LVSRQtYHO HP KWWSFODXGLR MDFRVNLJRRJOHSDJHVFRPGHVPDWDPHQWRSGI! $FHVVR HP DEU MPMG Jurídico Especial ‡ 37

Comparação de Modelo de Valoração Monetária de Danos Ambientais

Empfohlen

Empfohlen

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Was ist angesagt? (18)

Ähnlich wie Comparação de Modelo de Valoração Monetária de Danos Ambientais

Ähnlich wie Comparação de Modelo de Valoração Monetária de Danos Ambientais (20)

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Comparação de Modelo de Valoração Monetária de Danos Ambientais